SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 32
Regulation by proxy Limiting the Open Society
Is anyone listening… Why free speech?
Truth (Mill)Tolerance (Bollinger)Democracy (art xix) Would any politician be against it…
Highpoint 1948
History…
Almost 300 years ago The state as threat, discussion was on imprimatur
Revolution & rights
Media centralization
In the hands of a small clique Means of production
speakers corner
Enter the net :)
Freedom as side effect
Freedom by agreement (of a homogeneous group) Open end-to-end Packet switching  “liberal” ideology
A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace Governments of the Industrial World, you wearygiants of flesh and steel, I come from Cyberspace, the new home of Mind. On behalf of the future, I ask you of the past to leaveusalone. You are not welcomeamongus. You have no sovereigntywherewegather. Barlowe, 1996
Freedom as bi-product
There is one and only one social responsibility of business—to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits… Milton Friedman
censorship
Circus dogs jump when the trainer cracks his whip, but the really well-trained dog is the one that turns his somersault when there is no whip.
Lone voices in the crowd/cloud
Inadvertent censorship affordances
german engineer problem
Chilling effects
Evil euLa Thought control?
When states wash their hands… Regulation by proxy
What can be done?
What its there for! Remember…
If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.
What I want… Freedom of speech on the platforms of others Return of the state  End of regulation by proxy
It’s the hypocrisy  that I find insulting or remove free speech as a human right…
Thank you.
Information ,[object Object]

More Related Content

Similar to Limiting the Open Society

Identity, expression & reputation
Identity, expression & reputationIdentity, expression & reputation
Identity, expression & reputationMathias Klang
 
Regulating the Network
Regulating the NetworkRegulating the Network
Regulating the NetworkMathias Klang
 
Digital Presence, Expression & Reputation
Digital Presence, Expression & ReputationDigital Presence, Expression & Reputation
Digital Presence, Expression & ReputationMathias Klang
 
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things togetherPublic/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things togetherMathias Klang
 
Debating the networked society: technical roots of social change
Debating the networked society: technical roots of social changeDebating the networked society: technical roots of social change
Debating the networked society: technical roots of social changeMathias Klang
 
Government & Social Media
Government & Social MediaGovernment & Social Media
Government & Social MediaMathias Klang
 
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human RightsFailure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human RightsMathias Klang
 
Pedagogical Challenges of Social Media
Pedagogical Challenges of Social MediaPedagogical Challenges of Social Media
Pedagogical Challenges of Social MediaMathias Klang
 
082710 gov team political philosophy 50m
082710 gov team political philosophy    50m082710 gov team political philosophy    50m
082710 gov team political philosophy 50mMonta Vista High School
 
Old Rules - New Media: application & interpretation
Old Rules - New Media: application & interpretationOld Rules - New Media: application & interpretation
Old Rules - New Media: application & interpretationMathias Klang
 
Information politics
Information politicsInformation politics
Information politicsMathias Klang
 
082710 gov team political philosophy 50m
082710 gov team political philosophy    50m082710 gov team political philosophy    50m
082710 gov team political philosophy 50mMonta Vista High School
 
Regulatory Theory in Social Media Society
Regulatory Theory in Social Media SocietyRegulatory Theory in Social Media Society
Regulatory Theory in Social Media SocietyMathias Klang
 
Information frihet & kontroll
Information frihet & kontrollInformation frihet & kontroll
Information frihet & kontrollMathias Klang
 
Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...
Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...
Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...Kaido Kikkas
 
LECTURE 11 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 11 - CybercultureLECTURE 11 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 11 - CybercultureKim Flintoff
 
Law, Ethics & Information Systems
Law, Ethics  & Information SystemsLaw, Ethics  & Information Systems
Law, Ethics & Information SystemsMathias Klang
 
Law and Disorder in New & Social Media
Law and Disorder in New & Social MediaLaw and Disorder in New & Social Media
Law and Disorder in New & Social MediaMathias Klang
 

Similar to Limiting the Open Society (20)

Identity, expression & reputation
Identity, expression & reputationIdentity, expression & reputation
Identity, expression & reputation
 
Regulating the Network
Regulating the NetworkRegulating the Network
Regulating the Network
 
Digital Presence, Expression & Reputation
Digital Presence, Expression & ReputationDigital Presence, Expression & Reputation
Digital Presence, Expression & Reputation
 
Klang PSU
Klang PSUKlang PSU
Klang PSU
 
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things togetherPublic/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
Public/Private Spaces: Pulling things together
 
Debating the networked society: technical roots of social change
Debating the networked society: technical roots of social changeDebating the networked society: technical roots of social change
Debating the networked society: technical roots of social change
 
Government & Social Media
Government & Social MediaGovernment & Social Media
Government & Social Media
 
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human RightsFailure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
Failure of Law - Social Media & Human Rights
 
Pedagogical Challenges of Social Media
Pedagogical Challenges of Social MediaPedagogical Challenges of Social Media
Pedagogical Challenges of Social Media
 
082710 gov team political philosophy 50m
082710 gov team political philosophy    50m082710 gov team political philosophy    50m
082710 gov team political philosophy 50m
 
Old Rules - New Media: application & interpretation
Old Rules - New Media: application & interpretationOld Rules - New Media: application & interpretation
Old Rules - New Media: application & interpretation
 
Information politics
Information politicsInformation politics
Information politics
 
082710 gov team political philosophy 50m
082710 gov team political philosophy    50m082710 gov team political philosophy    50m
082710 gov team political philosophy 50m
 
Regulatory Theory in Social Media Society
Regulatory Theory in Social Media SocietyRegulatory Theory in Social Media Society
Regulatory Theory in Social Media Society
 
8 Slides
8  Slides8  Slides
8 Slides
 
Information frihet & kontroll
Information frihet & kontrollInformation frihet & kontroll
Information frihet & kontroll
 
Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...
Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...
Of Hobbits, Amish, Hackers and Technology (or, is technology for humans or vi...
 
LECTURE 11 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 11 - CybercultureLECTURE 11 - Cyberculture
LECTURE 11 - Cyberculture
 
Law, Ethics & Information Systems
Law, Ethics  & Information SystemsLaw, Ethics  & Information Systems
Law, Ethics & Information Systems
 
Law and Disorder in New & Social Media
Law and Disorder in New & Social MediaLaw and Disorder in New & Social Media
Law and Disorder in New & Social Media
 

More from Mathias Klang

Surveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the SimulacrumSurveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the SimulacrumMathias Klang
 
Web of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie CultureWeb of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie CultureMathias Klang
 
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?Mathias Klang
 
Sharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfiesSharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfiesMathias Klang
 
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts Mathias Klang
 
Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about. Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about. Mathias Klang
 
Civil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & TechnologyCivil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & TechnologyMathias Klang
 
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces Mathias Klang
 
Digital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net NeutralityDigital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net NeutralityMathias Klang
 
Design and Access to the city
Design and Access to the cityDesign and Access to the city
Design and Access to the cityMathias Klang
 
Cities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & DesignCities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & DesignMathias Klang
 
Technologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desireTechnologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desireMathias Klang
 
Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371Mathias Klang
 
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & communityPlatforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & communityMathias Klang
 
Is that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriersIs that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriersMathias Klang
 
Nobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagement
Nobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagementNobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagement
Nobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagementMathias Klang
 
eBook piracy - Waiting for a napster moment
eBook piracy - Waiting for anapster momenteBook piracy - Waiting for anapster moment
eBook piracy - Waiting for a napster momentMathias Klang
 

More from Mathias Klang (20)

Surveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the SimulacrumSurveillance in the Simulacrum
Surveillance in the Simulacrum
 
Web of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie CultureWeb of Introverts and Selfie Culture
Web of Introverts and Selfie Culture
 
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
Screens & Maps: Is seeing believing?
 
Sharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfiesSharing, oversharing and selfies
Sharing, oversharing and selfies
 
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
Copyright & Licensing: The progress of science & useful arts
 
FOSS & Society
FOSS & SocietyFOSS & Society
FOSS & Society
 
Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about. Academic Writing: Things to think about.
Academic Writing: Things to think about.
 
Civil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & TechnologyCivil Disobedience & Technology
Civil Disobedience & Technology
 
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
Regulating Online Public/Private Spaces
 
Digital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net NeutralityDigital Divides and Net Neutrality
Digital Divides and Net Neutrality
 
Design and Access to the city
Design and Access to the cityDesign and Access to the city
Design and Access to the city
 
Cities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & DesignCities, Suburbs & Design
Cities, Suburbs & Design
 
Control by design
Control by designControl by design
Control by design
 
Technologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desireTechnologies of control & desire
Technologies of control & desire
 
Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371Introduction to Civic Media com371
Introduction to Civic Media com371
 
Image by Wikipedia?
Image by Wikipedia?Image by Wikipedia?
Image by Wikipedia?
 
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & communityPlatforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
Platforms of Restraint: News aggregators, open webs & community
 
Is that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriersIs that your book? On content & carriers
Is that your book? On content & carriers
 
Nobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagement
Nobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagementNobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagement
Nobody cites your work: copyright licensing and public engagement
 
eBook piracy - Waiting for a napster moment
eBook piracy - Waiting for anapster momenteBook piracy - Waiting for anapster moment
eBook piracy - Waiting for a napster moment
 

Limiting the Open Society

Editor's Notes

  1. Shut Happens from alancleaver_2000 cc byWith social media quickly becoming the communications tool of choice many have hailed this as an introduction to an open transparent society. But how open is this open society? Is this new stage in the information society really open or is this an illusion brought about by popular technology? This talk looks at the weaknesses and control mechanisms built into the technology and the different regulations and policies implemented to control our communications.
  2. Sound of silence by Daniel Gasienica cc by ncnd
  3. Statue Park by Bill McIntyre cc by ncsa
  4. Superman in North Dakota from Fonzie's cousin cc by ncsa
  5. Trooping in the rain from Stéfan cc by csa
  6. whirling dervish by Mr. Wright cc by ncsa
  7. scream and shout from mdanys cc by
  8. pep sala-el quesenties per nadal from visualpanic cc by
  9. Speakers' Corner from duncan cc by nc
  10. I'm working.(1) by purprin cc by ncsa
  11. Came hameháááá! from R'eyes cc by
  12. Brown Bagged Goof from privatenobby cc by ncsa
  13. 12-06 by Daniel_1977 cc by ncsa
  14. Fancy Glasses by RobertFrancis cc by ncsa.jpgCapitalism and Freedom 1962
  15. Orwell "As I Please," Tribune (7 July 1944)
  16. Radiohead Crowd from Samuel Stroube cc by ncsa
  17. image (c) Yumiko Hayakawa essay Public Benches Turn ‘Anti-Homeless’
  18. Untitled from Kennedy Garrett cc by
  19. I just couldn’t live with myself... from Eric "Claptøn" Nelsøn cc by ncsa
  20. goldfish from a_trotskyite cc by ncsa
  21. Day 175- Out o7 Order from theogeo cc by
  22. Eskatol (8 of 12) from SynneTonidas cc by ncsaOrwell in Preface to Animal Farm
  23. Heroes from Gastev cc by
  24. Eyes ! (Youth from Antikythera!) by agelakis cc by nc sa