Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Results from the evaluation study of the Finnish Basic Income Experiment 2017-2018

Minna Ylikännö: Results from the evaluation study of the Finnish Basic Income Experiment 2017-2018.

  • Be the first to comment

Results from the evaluation study of the Finnish Basic Income Experiment 2017-2018

  1. 1. Results from the evaluation study of the Finnish Basic Income Experiment 2017-2018 6th May 2020 O. Kangas, M. Simanainen, S. Jauhiainen, M. Ylikännö (ed.)
  2. 2. Basic Income Experiment 2017-2018 • A nation-wide obligatory basic income experiment, based on a law on UBI experiment, was conducted in Finland in years 2017– 2018 • The interest was in the impact of a basic income on the participants’ employment status, income, use of social benefits and subjective well-being • In the experiment, 2,000 randomly selected unemployed job seekers between 25 and 58 years of age received a monthly payment of €560, unconditionally and without means testing
  3. 3. Scientific evaluation of the experiment • To study the effects of basic income, the treatment group of 2,000 individuals is compared against a control group comprised of 173,000 • Several subprojects evaluate the experiment from different perspectives with a rich set of data sources. • Also, the media coverage of the basic income experiment was studied as well as public opinion of UBI after the experiment 26.5.20203
  4. 4. Employment • From November 2017 to October 2018 employment increased on average six days more in the treatment group than in the control group - more positive employment effects among families with children, and among those whose mother tongue is other than Finnish, Swedish or Same • In January 2018, an activation model was implemented as part of public UB system • The employment effects for the second year of the experiment were a joint effect of the basic income experiment and the activation model 26.5.20204 For more information, please contact: kari.hamalainen@vatt.fi
  5. 5. Subjective wellbeing • The phone survey was targeted at the 2,000 recipients of a basic income and at a sample of 5,000 persons in the control group, and it was conducted in October–December 2018 • The response rate was low, 31% in the treatment group and 20% in the control group – this is not exceptional today in survey studies • The survey results showed significant differences between the groups on key indicators representing different aspects of subjective well-being - basic income recipients assessed their well-being more positively than respondents in the control group 26.5.20205
  6. 6. Subjective wellbeing • Higher generalized and institutional trust, as well as confidence in the future and self-confidence among UBI recipients - also, less stress and symptoms of depression and better cognitive functioning than the control group • Financial well-being of UBI recipients was better • UBI recipients experienced less bureaucracy • Different aspects of wellbeing were scrutinized in different subprojects – however they are clearly intertwined 26.5.20206 For more information, please contact: signe.jauhiainen@kela.fi
  7. 7. Life on basic income expresses great diversity • The subproject is based on interviews with 81 basic income recipients • Some interviewees portrayed basic income as having affected their labour market behaviour largely, while others described it as having had only marginal effects • These reflections were related to the recipients’ diverse premises for employment and life in general 26.5.20207 For more information, please contact: helena.blomberg@helsinki.fi
  8. 8. Life on basic income expresses great diversity • For some interviewees, the experiment provided a larger variety of legitimate modes of participation outside of paid labour • For some interviewees, the experiment created mental pressure to gain employment, which led to coping difficulties • Strengthened autonomy through enhanced possibilities of long- term financial planning, lessened stress related to bureaucracy and activation demands, and improved possibilities of doing meaningful things were reported regardless of changes in employment 26.5.2020 Yksikkö/Projekti/Esittäjä | Esityksen otsikko8
  9. 9. Media coverage and public opinion • Finnish Basic Income Experiment was largely covered in the media, and especially in the international media – expresses and impacts public opinion on UBI • In the evaluation study, attitudes towards basic income after the experiment were measured with a phone survey • In the survey, 46% of the respondents agreed or somewhat agreed with the statement that a basic income should be introduced as a permanent part of the Finnish social security system 26.5.20209 For more information, please contact: katja.makkyla@kela.fi (media analysis) or olli.kangas@utu.fi (UBI support)
  10. 10. Summary • Positive effects of UBI were observed more often than negative ones • The heterogenity of the treatment group becomes most visible in the interview study • Results are in accordance with results from other earlier experiments implemented in other countries (e.g. Canada, US, Netherlands) – greater effect on wellbeing than employment • As regards employment, financial support system plays a central role, but alone it is not sufficient to significantly promote either labour supply or demand 26.5.202010
  11. 11. Thank you! olli.kangas@utu.fi miska.simanainen.kela.fi signe.jauhiainen@kela.fi minna.ylikanno@kela.fi

    Be the first to comment

    Login to see the comments

  • luizhenriquemuseuandrade

    Jun. 11, 2020

Minna Ylikännö: Results from the evaluation study of the Finnish Basic Income Experiment 2017-2018.

Views

Total views

1,517

On Slideshare

0

From embeds

0

Number of embeds

49

Actions

Downloads

24

Shares

0

Comments

0

Likes

1

×