SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 61
Networked Authoritarianism in Azerbaijan: How the Azerbaijani
government uses the Internet to deter dissent
Katy Pearce
Assistant Professor, Department of Communication,
University of Washington
@katypearce
1
2
3
4
5
INTRODUCTION
THE PLAYERS
OPPOSITION INTERNET EFFORTS
GOVERNMENT INTERNET ACTIVITIES
WHAT’S THE ROI?
Outline
INTRODUCTION
01
• Azerbaijan has a unique way of managing the
Internet, by leaving the Internet “open”…
• It can claim that there is freedom of expression
• It can monitor citizens
• It can use the Internet/social media as another
information dissemination medium
• This is unique, but could be emulated elsewhere
• An opportunity to study mechanisms of control and
dissent in the digital era
SO WHAT? (a preview)
• 9 million people
• Majority Shia Muslim
• 99% literacy
• Per capita GDP USD 10,000
• Oil wealth
AZERBAIJAN
AUTHORITARIANISM IN AZERBAIJAN
- Father and son
presidential legacy
- Suppression of civil
liberties
- Little freedom of
expression
- Pervasive bitterness
- Apathy and fear
- Self-censorship
Azerbaijan is a
petro-state whose
oil revenues have
allowed the regime
to preempt any
opposition.
• World has changed.
• Performance of democratic attitudes.
AUTHORITARIANISM AIN’T
WHAT IT USED TO BE
THUS AZERBAIJAN CARES ABOUT ITS
GLOBAL IMAGE (A LITTLE)
Why?
Because Azerbaijan wants
to be seen (by internal
audience) as important
and powerful.
LOREM IPSUM
DOLOR SIT AMET EL
QUASI IPSA OMNIS
ISTEDOLOR SIT
AMET EL QUASI
IPSA OMNIS ISTE
THE INTERNET IS THE ONLY SPACE FOR FREE EXPRESSION IN AZERBAIJAN
BUT
Not many Azerbaijanis are
online
6%
14%
22%
33%
4% 4%
7%
11%
9%
12%
20%
24%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
2009 2010 2011 2012
Daily Internet users (%) (CB)
Armenia Azerbaijan Georgia
19%
31%
38%
52%
19% 20%
26% 27%
25%
29%
37%
43%
0%
20%
40%
60%
2009 2010 2011 2012
Ever use the Internet (%) (CB)
Armenia Azerbaijan Georgia
Azerbaijan can easily lie
about Internet penetration
rates.
Moreover
WHAT ARE
AZERBAIJANIS
DOING ONLINE?
15%
8%
13%
10%
4%
6%
Searching for information
Facebook (raw number = 941,554 adults)
Email
Music / videos
News
Skype
3%
Games
Caucasus Barometer, 2012
THE PLAYERS
02
Some of those 11%-27% of Azerbaijanis are up for grabs.
And as more Azerbaijanis get online, they will be up for
grabs as well.
The Government
President
169,959
Policy decisions
PR social media
team
First Lady
66,639 + 14,293
Daughters
123,000 + 2422
Pro-government youth
5,113 personality / 28,365 group
More distant dirty
workers
5 million AZN = $6.37 million
Why?
Facebook likes, late April 2013
The Opposition
Collective and Connective Action
Networks
ConnectiveAction
• Self organizing networks
• Little or no organizational
coordination of action
• Large scale personal access to
multi-layered social
technologies
• Personal expression shared
over social networks
ConnectiveAction
• Organizationally enabled
networks
• Loose organizational
coordination of action
• Some organizational
moderation of personal
expression through social
networks
• Organizations in the
background, loosely linked
networks
CollectiveAction
• Organizationally brokered
networks
• Organizations in the
foreground
• Social technologies used by
organizations to manage
participation and coordinate
goals
(Bennett & Segerberg, 2012)
Collective and Connective Action
Networks in Azerbaijan
ConnectiveAction
• Self organizing networks
• Outside of the formal
opposition party system
• Strong personalities
• Reputation built &solidified
online
• Strategic use of social media
• Strongest social media
influence
• Some openly critique
opposition
ConnectiveAction
• Organizationally enabled
networks
• Individuals affiliated with
looser organizations
• Less social media influence
than self organizing, although
still large numbers of
followers and friends
CollectiveAction
• Organizationally brokered
networks
• Traditional opposition parties
use social media to some
degree
• Best known personalities do
have many
followers/friends/likes, but
such little content, very little
influence
1649 5420 6249 7577 8000 9139
11353 12524 13679
16821 18000
22927
70000
78293
E D C F G I B K L J G A N O
Facebook Audience Size (Late April 2013)
Opposition
leader
Opposition
leader
Notable
foreign
audienceNotable
foreign
audience
Primarily
youth
audience
8307
Self organizing networks
Organizationally enabled
networks
Organizationally brokered
networks
58024
Takeaways
• Government is a hierarchical structure
• Many followers, but entirely for information
dissemination, little interactivity
• Opposition networks exist in 3 forms
• Traditional collective action
• Use social media for information dissemination
• Organizational enabled networks
• Personality-driven, but within loose affiliations with
organizations
• Social media reach weaker than other types
• Connective action networks
• Independent from organizations
• Social media is the organizing medium
• Substantial audience
OPPOSITION INTERNET EFFORTS
03
11/11/2012 5/1/2013
Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13
Jan-13
LARGEUNSANCTIONED PROTEST
Feb-13
LARGEUNSANCTIONED PROTEST
Mar-13
OPPOSITIONYOUTH DETAINED
Mar-13
MOREOPPOSITION YOUTH DETAINED
Jan-13
FINES IN EFFECT
Jan-13
RIOTS
Feb-13
PROTEST
Feb-13
FUNDRAISING
Mar-13
LARGEUNSANCTIONED PROTEST
Nov-12
GULARGATE
Mar-13
ATTACKS ONINGOS & OSCE
Mar-13
MOREOPPOSITION YOUTH DETAINED
Apr-13
MOREOPPOSITION YOUTH DETAINED
Apr-13
OPPOSITIONYOUTH DETAINE
Feb-13
FUNDRAISING LAW
Apr-13
AFU TROUBLES
Connective Action - Self Organizing
Real
10,500 AZN
US$13,000
GOVERNMENT INTERNET
ACTIVITIES04
This is a “middle path” between open access
and censorship.
The Azerbaijani government claims that "there
is Internet freedom in Azerbaijan“ because
there is no filtering.
By electing to define Internet freedom in the
strictest sense of the word, the government
uses a semantic shift to deflect criticism.
Azerbaijan has a unique approach to
Internet regulation
AZERBAIJAN AND
INTERNET REGULATION
CONTENT CONTROLS THAT REDUCE “INTERNET FREEDOM”
Internet filtering
Policing cyber cafes
FIRST GENERATION SECOND GENERATION THIRD GENERATION
Legal information control and
illegal content, defamation
laws
Information removal requests
Shutdowns
Network attacks
Surveillance
State-sponsored information
campaigns
Trolling*
Cult of personality*
Direct action
Deibert & Rohozinski, 2010; * Pearce, 2013
FIRST GENERATION
Pornography is filtered
Occasionally during elections there is greater filtering
Recent blocking efforts and threats of blocking
But there are no administrative or court decisions
ordering blocking
In an informal test of cafes, we found no filtering
NOT EXTENSIVE BUT…
Internet filtering
Policing cyber cafes
SECOND GENERATION
Offline laws apply to the online space – including defamation
Publicizing opinions that instigate extremism or have
“harmful content” is illegal
Officials have claimed that spreading misinformation is a
cybercrime and noted Skype and Wikipedia as threats to
national security
Wide scope of circumstances where ISPs can cut off Internet
services
Legal information control
and illegal
content, defamation laws
Information removal
requests
Shutdowns
Network attacks
THIRD GENERATION
THE MOST COMMON FORM IN
AZERBAIJAN
Surveillance
State-sponsored information
campaigns
Trolling
Online cult of personality
Direct action
Real
• Activists report having printed Facebook private
messaging transcripts handed to them while in
police custody
• Logins from multiple IP addresses in Facebook and
Gmail
• Arrests
• Evidence of working with known surveillance firms
Imagined
• Reality does not matter when many believe that the
government is watching
SURVEILLANCE
Real and imagined
• Azerbaijani government-controlled media
links social media use with
• Mental illness
• Family tragedies
• Criminal incidents
• Sex trafficking
• Pedophilia
• Pro-government youth encouraged to
become active on social networking sites
• Instructed to expose traitors
INFORMATION
CAMPAIGNS
State-sponsored
TROLLING
Memes
TROLLING
Twitter shenanigans
TROLLING
Kompromat
CULT OF
PERSONALITY
Online
CULT OF
PERSONALITY
Online
DIRECT ACTION
Online behaviors have offline
consequences
FIRST GENERATION
DIRECT ACTION
Online behaviors have offline
consequences
2013
WHAT’S THE ROI?
05
IS THIS WORKING FOR THE
GOVERNMENT?
YES
Many people are afraid to express themselves
The outspoken online are the already outspoken offline and are willing to
take risks
Social media provide an excellent way to monitor behavior
The pro-government social media world is expanding
There are few successful critiques
What happens on Facebook used to stay on Facebook
When things aren’t working, make new policies
IS THIS WORKING FOR THE
GOVERNMENT?
NO
Opposition audience
Network structures are advantageous
Some opposition have access to foreigners and gaining attention
Lack of sustainability
BUT THE GOVERNMENT IS
WINNING… FOR NOW.
By focusing on “the good life” and punishing dissent in a variety of
ways, the government is solidifying its position.
But is this worth the cost?
The opposition on the other hand, has a network structure that is
resilient and efficient.
Some of the opposition responds to attacks in innovative ways.
THANK YOU
FOR YOUR
TIME
Extra Slides
A
OppositionParty1
22,927likes
B
OppositionParty 2
11,353followers/
friends
Various
Youth activist org 1
K
12,524followers/
friends
J
16,821likes
F
Organization 2
7577 followers/
friends
D
Affiliated withOP2
5420 followers/
friends
L
13,679followers/
friends
H
8000 followers/
friends
C
Organization 1
6249 followers/
friends
M
?
I
9139 friends/
followers
G
18,000followers/
friends
N
78,293followers/
friends
O
~70,000 followers/
friends
E
Youth activist org 1
1649 followers
Connective Action – Organizationally
Enabled Networks
Collective Action
Uwtalk

More Related Content

What's hot

Social Good: Social Media beyond politics
Social Good: Social Media beyond politicsSocial Good: Social Media beyond politics
Social Good: Social Media beyond politicsVernon Joseph Go
 
Hum 140: Social Media: Privacy
Hum 140: Social Media: PrivacyHum 140: Social Media: Privacy
Hum 140: Social Media: PrivacyRay Brannon
 
Social media and Missing workshop
Social media and Missing workshopSocial media and Missing workshop
Social media and Missing workshopRay Brannon
 
CSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education Campaign
CSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education CampaignCSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education Campaign
CSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education CampaignKimberly Gonzalez
 
What social media is doing to the world
What social media is doing to the worldWhat social media is doing to the world
What social media is doing to the worldJulieCarn
 
Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?
Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?
Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?Bernard Marr
 
Protection of children over the internet
Protection of children over the internetProtection of children over the internet
Protection of children over the internetCiaran Moran
 
Privately Obscure
Privately ObscurePrivately Obscure
Privately Obscurelisafilipek
 
Youth Internet Safety
Youth Internet SafetyYouth Internet Safety
Youth Internet SafetyEric Cedo
 
CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...
CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...
CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...CILIP
 
Social media and the future of e-discovery
Social media and the future of e-discoverySocial media and the future of e-discovery
Social media and the future of e-discoveryLogikcull.com
 
Fotn 2013 summary of findings
Fotn 2013 summary of findingsFotn 2013 summary of findings
Fotn 2013 summary of findingsChafik YAHOU
 
Communicating across the Digital Divide
Communicating across the Digital DivideCommunicating across the Digital Divide
Communicating across the Digital DivideLloyd Brown
 
Children as target of cyber crimes
Children as target of cyber crimesChildren as target of cyber crimes
Children as target of cyber crimesNilendra Kumar
 
Young Adults And On Line Privacy
Young Adults And On Line PrivacyYoung Adults And On Line Privacy
Young Adults And On Line PrivacyRecrue
 
Pr cyberbullying campaign powerpoint
Pr cyberbullying campaign powerpointPr cyberbullying campaign powerpoint
Pr cyberbullying campaign powerpointhmorrell1
 
So-Sial Networking
So-Sial NetworkingSo-Sial Networking
So-Sial NetworkingAlanGun Alan
 
Internet censorship power point
Internet censorship power pointInternet censorship power point
Internet censorship power pointJonathan Milner
 

What's hot (20)

Social Good: Social Media beyond politics
Social Good: Social Media beyond politicsSocial Good: Social Media beyond politics
Social Good: Social Media beyond politics
 
Hum 140: Social Media: Privacy
Hum 140: Social Media: PrivacyHum 140: Social Media: Privacy
Hum 140: Social Media: Privacy
 
Social media and Missing workshop
Social media and Missing workshopSocial media and Missing workshop
Social media and Missing workshop
 
CSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education Campaign
CSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education CampaignCSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education Campaign
CSUN - Youth Driven Information Privacy Education Campaign
 
What social media is doing to the world
What social media is doing to the worldWhat social media is doing to the world
What social media is doing to the world
 
Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?
Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?
Can Artificial Intelligence Predict The Spread Of Online Hate Speech?
 
Protection of children over the internet
Protection of children over the internetProtection of children over the internet
Protection of children over the internet
 
Social media and Politics 101
Social media and Politics 101Social media and Politics 101
Social media and Politics 101
 
Ethics and Big Data
Ethics and Big Data Ethics and Big Data
Ethics and Big Data
 
Privately Obscure
Privately ObscurePrivately Obscure
Privately Obscure
 
Youth Internet Safety
Youth Internet SafetyYouth Internet Safety
Youth Internet Safety
 
CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...
CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...
CILIP Conference - Promoting digital literacy and digital well-being for chil...
 
Social media and the future of e-discovery
Social media and the future of e-discoverySocial media and the future of e-discovery
Social media and the future of e-discovery
 
Fotn 2013 summary of findings
Fotn 2013 summary of findingsFotn 2013 summary of findings
Fotn 2013 summary of findings
 
Communicating across the Digital Divide
Communicating across the Digital DivideCommunicating across the Digital Divide
Communicating across the Digital Divide
 
Children as target of cyber crimes
Children as target of cyber crimesChildren as target of cyber crimes
Children as target of cyber crimes
 
Young Adults And On Line Privacy
Young Adults And On Line PrivacyYoung Adults And On Line Privacy
Young Adults And On Line Privacy
 
Pr cyberbullying campaign powerpoint
Pr cyberbullying campaign powerpointPr cyberbullying campaign powerpoint
Pr cyberbullying campaign powerpoint
 
So-Sial Networking
So-Sial NetworkingSo-Sial Networking
So-Sial Networking
 
Internet censorship power point
Internet censorship power pointInternet censorship power point
Internet censorship power point
 

Similar to Uwtalk

Effects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youthEffects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youthAlankarSharma13
 
Effects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youthEffects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youthVikas Gupta
 
Online Trends and Diversity
Online Trends and DiversityOnline Trends and Diversity
Online Trends and DiversityAnne Adrian
 
Social Networking: Use & Impact
Social Networking: Use & ImpactSocial Networking: Use & Impact
Social Networking: Use & ImpactGaurav Wadhwa
 
Impact of social networking sites on youth
Impact of social networking sites on youthImpact of social networking sites on youth
Impact of social networking sites on youthsobic1234
 
Ethics & Technology :Facebook
Ethics & Technology :FacebookEthics & Technology :Facebook
Ethics & Technology :Facebookrahul8793
 
SPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docx
SPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docxSPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docx
SPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docxwilliame8
 
Communicating with social media to make corruption obsolete
Communicating with social media to make corruption obsoleteCommunicating with social media to make corruption obsolete
Communicating with social media to make corruption obsoleteBob Pickard
 
Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...
Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...
Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...LorieLynDeGuzmanSalv
 
Big data and the sharing economy
Big data and the sharing economyBig data and the sharing economy
Big data and the sharing economySoraj Hongladarom
 
Minnesota Planned Giving Council
Minnesota Planned Giving CouncilMinnesota Planned Giving Council
Minnesota Planned Giving Counciljmstremcha
 
9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx
9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx
9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptxBenjieBarlaan
 
Social media and illiteracy (PPT)
Social media and illiteracy (PPT)Social media and illiteracy (PPT)
Social media and illiteracy (PPT)abdulwasay733255
 
Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship
Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship
Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship Catherine Hainstock
 
9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchange9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchangeleejhayacosido
 
9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchange9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchangeJhouBautista
 

Similar to Uwtalk (20)

Effects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youthEffects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youth
 
The facebook journey … 14% finished
The facebook journey … 14% finishedThe facebook journey … 14% finished
The facebook journey … 14% finished
 
Effects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youthEffects of social media on youth
Effects of social media on youth
 
Online Trends and Diversity
Online Trends and DiversityOnline Trends and Diversity
Online Trends and Diversity
 
Social Networking: Use & Impact
Social Networking: Use & ImpactSocial Networking: Use & Impact
Social Networking: Use & Impact
 
Apps and Young Users.pptx
Apps and Young Users.pptxApps and Young Users.pptx
Apps and Young Users.pptx
 
Facebook
FacebookFacebook
Facebook
 
Impact of social networking sites on youth
Impact of social networking sites on youthImpact of social networking sites on youth
Impact of social networking sites on youth
 
Ethics & Technology :Facebook
Ethics & Technology :FacebookEthics & Technology :Facebook
Ethics & Technology :Facebook
 
SPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docx
SPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docxSPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docx
SPECIAL REPORT ONDigital Literacy for Women & Girls.docx
 
Communicating with social media to make corruption obsolete
Communicating with social media to make corruption obsoleteCommunicating with social media to make corruption obsolete
Communicating with social media to make corruption obsolete
 
Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...
Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...
Week 1. Opportunities, Challenges and Power of Media and Information [Autosav...
 
Big data and the sharing economy
Big data and the sharing economyBig data and the sharing economy
Big data and the sharing economy
 
Social Media & Young Adults
Social Media & Young AdultsSocial Media & Young Adults
Social Media & Young Adults
 
Minnesota Planned Giving Council
Minnesota Planned Giving CouncilMinnesota Planned Giving Council
Minnesota Planned Giving Council
 
9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx
9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx
9-ictasplatformforchange-180206004734(1).pptx
 
Social media and illiteracy (PPT)
Social media and illiteracy (PPT)Social media and illiteracy (PPT)
Social media and illiteracy (PPT)
 
Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship
Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship
Turning the Corner: From Cybersafety to Digital Citizenship
 
9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchange9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchange
 
9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchange9 ictasplatformforchange
9 ictasplatformforchange
 

More from Katy Pearce

Socinfo - teaching social network analysis
Socinfo - teaching social network analysisSocinfo - teaching social network analysis
Socinfo - teaching social network analysisKaty Pearce
 
Pearce - LOLs of Nations
Pearce - LOLs of NationsPearce - LOLs of Nations
Pearce - LOLs of NationsKaty Pearce
 
Azerbaijanicts2013
Azerbaijanicts2013Azerbaijanicts2013
Azerbaijanicts2013Katy Pearce
 
Attitudes toward elections in georgia
Attitudes toward elections in georgiaAttitudes toward elections in georgia
Attitudes toward elections in georgiaKaty Pearce
 
Caucasus ict trends
Caucasus ict trendsCaucasus ict trends
Caucasus ict trendsKaty Pearce
 
Katy Pearce #ttw12
Katy Pearce #ttw12Katy Pearce #ttw12
Katy Pearce #ttw12Katy Pearce
 
Armenia ict adoption ii
Armenia ict adoption iiArmenia ict adoption ii
Armenia ict adoption iiKaty Pearce
 
Facebookodnoklassniki
FacebookodnoklassnikiFacebookodnoklassniki
FacebookodnoklassnikiKaty Pearce
 

More from Katy Pearce (20)

Socinfo - teaching social network analysis
Socinfo - teaching social network analysisSocinfo - teaching social network analysis
Socinfo - teaching social network analysis
 
Pdfmemes
PdfmemesPdfmemes
Pdfmemes
 
Ica cs spanelv2
Ica cs spanelv2Ica cs spanelv2
Ica cs spanelv2
 
Pearce - LOLs of Nations
Pearce - LOLs of NationsPearce - LOLs of Nations
Pearce - LOLs of Nations
 
Change
ChangeChange
Change
 
Pennv3
Pennv3Pennv3
Pennv3
 
Azerbaijanicts2013
Azerbaijanicts2013Azerbaijanicts2013
Azerbaijanicts2013
 
Attitudes toward elections in georgia
Attitudes toward elections in georgiaAttitudes toward elections in georgia
Attitudes toward elections in georgia
 
Mobile
MobileMobile
Mobile
 
Caucasus ict trends
Caucasus ict trendsCaucasus ict trends
Caucasus ict trends
 
Icakzkgtj
IcakzkgtjIcakzkgtj
Icakzkgtj
 
Azerbaijanicts
AzerbaijanictsAzerbaijanicts
Azerbaijanicts
 
Mobilepreconf
MobilepreconfMobilepreconf
Mobilepreconf
 
Katy Pearce #ttw12
Katy Pearce #ttw12Katy Pearce #ttw12
Katy Pearce #ttw12
 
Armenia ict adoption ii
Armenia ict adoption iiArmenia ict adoption ii
Armenia ict adoption ii
 
Georgian women
Georgian womenGeorgian women
Georgian women
 
Facebookodnoklassniki
FacebookodnoklassnikiFacebookodnoklassniki
Facebookodnoklassniki
 
Gettingajob
GettingajobGettingajob
Gettingajob
 
English
EnglishEnglish
English
 
Incomesources
IncomesourcesIncomesources
Incomesources
 

Recently uploaded

Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...
Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...
Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...Lviv Startup Club
 
Excvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers referenceExcvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers referencessuser2c065e
 
How to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your Business
How to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your BusinessHow to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your Business
How to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your BusinessHelp Desk Migration
 
Types of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdf
Types of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdfTypes of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdf
Types of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdfASGITConsulting
 
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic ExperiencesUnveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic ExperiencesDoe Paoro
 
Interoperability and ecosystems: Assembling the industrial metaverse
Interoperability and ecosystems:  Assembling the industrial metaverseInteroperability and ecosystems:  Assembling the industrial metaverse
Interoperability and ecosystems: Assembling the industrial metaverseSiemens
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxRakhi Bazaar
 
Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...
Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...
Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...Aggregage
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersPeter Horsten
 
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon HarmerDriving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon HarmerAggregage
 
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataNAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataExhibitors Data
 
Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...
Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...
Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...ssuserf63bd7
 
digital marketing , introduction of digital marketing
digital marketing , introduction of digital marketingdigital marketing , introduction of digital marketing
digital marketing , introduction of digital marketingrajputmeenakshi733
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Jiastral oracle
 
Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)
Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)
Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)Lviv Startup Club
 
Exploring Elite Translation Services in Your Vicinity
Exploring Elite Translation Services in Your VicinityExploring Elite Translation Services in Your Vicinity
Exploring Elite Translation Services in Your VicinityThe Spanish Group
 
Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...
Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...
Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...PRnews2
 
Data Analytics Strategy Toolkit and Templates
Data Analytics Strategy Toolkit and TemplatesData Analytics Strategy Toolkit and Templates
Data Analytics Strategy Toolkit and TemplatesAurelien Domont, MBA
 
5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf
5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf
5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdfSherl Simon
 
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptxImplementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptxRich Reba
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...
Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...
Andrii Rodionov: What can go wrong in a distributed system – experience from ...
 
Excvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers referenceExcvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers reference
 
How to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your Business
How to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your BusinessHow to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your Business
How to Conduct a Service Gap Analysis for Your Business
 
Types of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdf
Types of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdfTypes of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdf
Types of Cyberattacks - ASG I.T. Consulting.pdf
 
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic ExperiencesUnveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
Unveiling the Soundscape Music for Psychedelic Experiences
 
Interoperability and ecosystems: Assembling the industrial metaverse
Interoperability and ecosystems:  Assembling the industrial metaverseInteroperability and ecosystems:  Assembling the industrial metaverse
Interoperability and ecosystems: Assembling the industrial metaverse
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
 
Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...
Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...
Strategic Project Finance Essentials: A Project Manager’s Guide to Financial ...
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
 
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon HarmerDriving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
Driving Business Impact for PMs with Jon Harmer
 
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataNAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
 
Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...
Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...
Intermediate Accounting, Volume 2, 13th Canadian Edition by Donald E. Kieso t...
 
digital marketing , introduction of digital marketing
digital marketing , introduction of digital marketingdigital marketing , introduction of digital marketing
digital marketing , introduction of digital marketing
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
 
Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)
Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)
Roman Kyslyi: Використання та побудова LLM агентів (UA)
 
Exploring Elite Translation Services in Your Vicinity
Exploring Elite Translation Services in Your VicinityExploring Elite Translation Services in Your Vicinity
Exploring Elite Translation Services in Your Vicinity
 
Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...
Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...
Introducing the AI ShillText Generator A New Era for Cryptocurrency Marketing...
 
Data Analytics Strategy Toolkit and Templates
Data Analytics Strategy Toolkit and TemplatesData Analytics Strategy Toolkit and Templates
Data Analytics Strategy Toolkit and Templates
 
5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf
5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf
5-Step Framework to Convert Any Business into a Wealth Generation Machine.pdf
 
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptxImplementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
 

Uwtalk

  • 1. Networked Authoritarianism in Azerbaijan: How the Azerbaijani government uses the Internet to deter dissent Katy Pearce Assistant Professor, Department of Communication, University of Washington @katypearce
  • 2. 1 2 3 4 5 INTRODUCTION THE PLAYERS OPPOSITION INTERNET EFFORTS GOVERNMENT INTERNET ACTIVITIES WHAT’S THE ROI? Outline
  • 4. • Azerbaijan has a unique way of managing the Internet, by leaving the Internet “open”… • It can claim that there is freedom of expression • It can monitor citizens • It can use the Internet/social media as another information dissemination medium • This is unique, but could be emulated elsewhere • An opportunity to study mechanisms of control and dissent in the digital era SO WHAT? (a preview)
  • 5. • 9 million people • Majority Shia Muslim • 99% literacy • Per capita GDP USD 10,000 • Oil wealth AZERBAIJAN
  • 6. AUTHORITARIANISM IN AZERBAIJAN - Father and son presidential legacy - Suppression of civil liberties - Little freedom of expression - Pervasive bitterness - Apathy and fear - Self-censorship Azerbaijan is a petro-state whose oil revenues have allowed the regime to preempt any opposition.
  • 7. • World has changed. • Performance of democratic attitudes. AUTHORITARIANISM AIN’T WHAT IT USED TO BE
  • 8. THUS AZERBAIJAN CARES ABOUT ITS GLOBAL IMAGE (A LITTLE) Why? Because Azerbaijan wants to be seen (by internal audience) as important and powerful. LOREM IPSUM DOLOR SIT AMET EL QUASI IPSA OMNIS ISTEDOLOR SIT AMET EL QUASI IPSA OMNIS ISTE
  • 9. THE INTERNET IS THE ONLY SPACE FOR FREE EXPRESSION IN AZERBAIJAN
  • 10. BUT Not many Azerbaijanis are online 6% 14% 22% 33% 4% 4% 7% 11% 9% 12% 20% 24% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 2009 2010 2011 2012 Daily Internet users (%) (CB) Armenia Azerbaijan Georgia 19% 31% 38% 52% 19% 20% 26% 27% 25% 29% 37% 43% 0% 20% 40% 60% 2009 2010 2011 2012 Ever use the Internet (%) (CB) Armenia Azerbaijan Georgia
  • 11. Azerbaijan can easily lie about Internet penetration rates. Moreover
  • 12. WHAT ARE AZERBAIJANIS DOING ONLINE? 15% 8% 13% 10% 4% 6% Searching for information Facebook (raw number = 941,554 adults) Email Music / videos News Skype 3% Games Caucasus Barometer, 2012
  • 14. Some of those 11%-27% of Azerbaijanis are up for grabs. And as more Azerbaijanis get online, they will be up for grabs as well.
  • 15.
  • 17. President 169,959 Policy decisions PR social media team First Lady 66,639 + 14,293 Daughters 123,000 + 2422 Pro-government youth 5,113 personality / 28,365 group More distant dirty workers 5 million AZN = $6.37 million Why? Facebook likes, late April 2013
  • 19. Collective and Connective Action Networks ConnectiveAction • Self organizing networks • Little or no organizational coordination of action • Large scale personal access to multi-layered social technologies • Personal expression shared over social networks ConnectiveAction • Organizationally enabled networks • Loose organizational coordination of action • Some organizational moderation of personal expression through social networks • Organizations in the background, loosely linked networks CollectiveAction • Organizationally brokered networks • Organizations in the foreground • Social technologies used by organizations to manage participation and coordinate goals (Bennett & Segerberg, 2012)
  • 20. Collective and Connective Action Networks in Azerbaijan ConnectiveAction • Self organizing networks • Outside of the formal opposition party system • Strong personalities • Reputation built &solidified online • Strategic use of social media • Strongest social media influence • Some openly critique opposition ConnectiveAction • Organizationally enabled networks • Individuals affiliated with looser organizations • Less social media influence than self organizing, although still large numbers of followers and friends CollectiveAction • Organizationally brokered networks • Traditional opposition parties use social media to some degree • Best known personalities do have many followers/friends/likes, but such little content, very little influence
  • 21. 1649 5420 6249 7577 8000 9139 11353 12524 13679 16821 18000 22927 70000 78293 E D C F G I B K L J G A N O Facebook Audience Size (Late April 2013) Opposition leader Opposition leader Notable foreign audienceNotable foreign audience Primarily youth audience 8307 Self organizing networks Organizationally enabled networks Organizationally brokered networks 58024
  • 22. Takeaways • Government is a hierarchical structure • Many followers, but entirely for information dissemination, little interactivity • Opposition networks exist in 3 forms • Traditional collective action • Use social media for information dissemination • Organizational enabled networks • Personality-driven, but within loose affiliations with organizations • Social media reach weaker than other types • Connective action networks • Independent from organizations • Social media is the organizing medium • Substantial audience
  • 24. 11/11/2012 5/1/2013 Dec-12 Jan-13 Feb-13 Mar-13 Apr-13 Jan-13 LARGEUNSANCTIONED PROTEST Feb-13 LARGEUNSANCTIONED PROTEST Mar-13 OPPOSITIONYOUTH DETAINED Mar-13 MOREOPPOSITION YOUTH DETAINED Jan-13 FINES IN EFFECT Jan-13 RIOTS Feb-13 PROTEST Feb-13 FUNDRAISING Mar-13 LARGEUNSANCTIONED PROTEST Nov-12 GULARGATE Mar-13 ATTACKS ONINGOS & OSCE Mar-13 MOREOPPOSITION YOUTH DETAINED Apr-13 MOREOPPOSITION YOUTH DETAINED Apr-13 OPPOSITIONYOUTH DETAINE Feb-13 FUNDRAISING LAW Apr-13 AFU TROUBLES
  • 25. Connective Action - Self Organizing
  • 26. Real
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 32. This is a “middle path” between open access and censorship. The Azerbaijani government claims that "there is Internet freedom in Azerbaijan“ because there is no filtering. By electing to define Internet freedom in the strictest sense of the word, the government uses a semantic shift to deflect criticism. Azerbaijan has a unique approach to Internet regulation AZERBAIJAN AND INTERNET REGULATION
  • 33. CONTENT CONTROLS THAT REDUCE “INTERNET FREEDOM” Internet filtering Policing cyber cafes FIRST GENERATION SECOND GENERATION THIRD GENERATION Legal information control and illegal content, defamation laws Information removal requests Shutdowns Network attacks Surveillance State-sponsored information campaigns Trolling* Cult of personality* Direct action Deibert & Rohozinski, 2010; * Pearce, 2013
  • 34. FIRST GENERATION Pornography is filtered Occasionally during elections there is greater filtering Recent blocking efforts and threats of blocking But there are no administrative or court decisions ordering blocking In an informal test of cafes, we found no filtering NOT EXTENSIVE BUT… Internet filtering Policing cyber cafes
  • 35. SECOND GENERATION Offline laws apply to the online space – including defamation Publicizing opinions that instigate extremism or have “harmful content” is illegal Officials have claimed that spreading misinformation is a cybercrime and noted Skype and Wikipedia as threats to national security Wide scope of circumstances where ISPs can cut off Internet services Legal information control and illegal content, defamation laws Information removal requests Shutdowns Network attacks
  • 36.
  • 37. THIRD GENERATION THE MOST COMMON FORM IN AZERBAIJAN Surveillance State-sponsored information campaigns Trolling Online cult of personality Direct action
  • 38. Real • Activists report having printed Facebook private messaging transcripts handed to them while in police custody • Logins from multiple IP addresses in Facebook and Gmail • Arrests • Evidence of working with known surveillance firms Imagined • Reality does not matter when many believe that the government is watching SURVEILLANCE Real and imagined
  • 39. • Azerbaijani government-controlled media links social media use with • Mental illness • Family tragedies • Criminal incidents • Sex trafficking • Pedophilia • Pro-government youth encouraged to become active on social networking sites • Instructed to expose traitors INFORMATION CAMPAIGNS State-sponsored
  • 45.
  • 46. DIRECT ACTION Online behaviors have offline consequences FIRST GENERATION
  • 47. DIRECT ACTION Online behaviors have offline consequences 2013
  • 49. IS THIS WORKING FOR THE GOVERNMENT? YES Many people are afraid to express themselves The outspoken online are the already outspoken offline and are willing to take risks Social media provide an excellent way to monitor behavior The pro-government social media world is expanding There are few successful critiques What happens on Facebook used to stay on Facebook When things aren’t working, make new policies
  • 50. IS THIS WORKING FOR THE GOVERNMENT? NO Opposition audience Network structures are advantageous Some opposition have access to foreigners and gaining attention Lack of sustainability
  • 51. BUT THE GOVERNMENT IS WINNING… FOR NOW. By focusing on “the good life” and punishing dissent in a variety of ways, the government is solidifying its position. But is this worth the cost? The opposition on the other hand, has a network structure that is resilient and efficient. Some of the opposition responds to attacks in innovative ways.
  • 54. A OppositionParty1 22,927likes B OppositionParty 2 11,353followers/ friends Various Youth activist org 1 K 12,524followers/ friends J 16,821likes F Organization 2 7577 followers/ friends D Affiliated withOP2 5420 followers/ friends L 13,679followers/ friends H 8000 followers/ friends C Organization 1 6249 followers/ friends M ? I 9139 friends/ followers G 18,000followers/ friends N 78,293followers/ friends O ~70,000 followers/ friends E Youth activist org 1 1649 followers
  • 55. Connective Action – Organizationally Enabled Networks
  • 56.
  • 57.
  • 58.
  • 59.

Editor's Notes

  1. 01 INTRODUCTION Background on Azerbaijan Internet in Azerbaijan02 THE PLAYERS Government Opposition Network structures03 OPPOSITION INTERNET EFFORTS04 GOVERNMENT INTERNET ACTIVITIES05 WHAT’S THE ROI?
  2. Authoritarianism is both a set of governing practices and an ideological construct. In the political sense, authoritarianism is a form of government in which state authority rests exclusively with sanctioned members of the state. Non-government actors are expressly excluded from governing processes, and citizens are not guaranteed political pluralism, civil liberties, or government accountability (Vaillant 2012). Operationally, authoritarianism entails low levels of political pluralism and high levels of political apathy and perceived political powerlessness (Linz 2000). Force, censorship, fear (Vaillant 2012), distrust of other citizens, denial of resources to opposition, harassment of troublemakers, media control, state dependence for employment, and suppression of autonomous organizing (Radnitz 2010) are common techniques to enforce an exclusive claim to power.As one of the most repressive of the post-Soviet states (Freedom House 2012), Azerbaijan exemplifies the extensive level of social control that post-Soviet authoritarian governments exercise over their peoples. Azerbaijan is a petro-state whose oil revenues have allowed the regime to preempt any opposition (Guliyev 2009). Azerbaijan has been politically dominated by a father and son since 1993. The son and current president, IlhamAliev, has suppressed opposition groups, violating basic rights and civil liberties and moved the country towards "full-fledged authoritarianism" (FrichovaGrono 2011). This rule has created a “pervasive bitterness and growing sense of deprivation” (Rasizade, 2003, p. 127), a general sense of apathy and fear (Abbasov 2010), and a lack of trust in others (Gahramanova 2009). As such, Azerbaijani society is fearful and self-censoring (Gahramanova 2009; Kazimova 2011).
  3. 1.There is no more soviet sponsorshipDemocracy promotion is an industryInternet and technology has arrived2. don’t openly steal the election, pepper the speech with democracy slogans
  4. Make an argument that not EVERYONE is on Facebook
  5. Selling moral upper hand versus glamour and the good life
  6. Traditional hierarchy in the government side of things – pretty much this is top downYou can see that there are a lot of followers, if there are only 941,554 Azerbaijani adults on Facebook, these are pretty solid numbers of followersBut the government is investing a TON into social media – why?This is a very important question… the 5 million manat question, if I may. - The government obviously has the upper hand – it controls all the mainstream media, it controls the legal system… so let’s come back to this question.
  7. The opposition is, unsurprisingly a little more complicated….I want to present a framework of different ways that opposition members organize themselves – both online and offline
  8. Organizationally brokered networks Strong organizational coordination of action Social technologies used by organizations to manage participation and coordinate goals Communication context centers on collective action frames Organizational management of social networks – more emphasis on interpersonal networks to build relationships for collective action Organizations in the foreground Organizationally enabled networks Loose organizational coordination of action Organizations provide social technology outlays Communication content centers on organizationally generated inclusive personal action frames Some organizational moderation of personal expression through social networks Organizations in the background, loosely linked networksSelf organizing networks Little or no organizational coordination of action Large scale personal access to multi-layered social technologies Communication content centers on emergent inclusive personal action frames Personal expression shared over social networks Collectivities often shun formal organizations
  9. In Azerbaijan, these are individuals that are outside of the formal opposition party system.Strong personalities, built reputation on personal identity.Reputation built primarily and certainly solidified online.Strategic use of social media for both domestic and foreign audiences. Have the strongest social media influence of anyone in Azerbaijan.Some openly critique the opposition parties. Some ignore the opposition parties.A generational difference, but not huge.Emin, Khadija, Habib, Baxtiyar, MehmanIn Azerbaijan, these are loose organizations and sometimes individuals (often representing these loose organizations) that fit into the second kind of connective action type where is there a closer link with an organization. This type does not have the same social media influence as the previous type. While still having large numbers of followers and friends, perhaps because information also spreads through organizational channels, or possibly because of the sense of needing to represent the organization, these individuals are not as important to the overall network.There are also traditional opposition party organizations that use social media to some degree. The best known individuals do have a lot of followers/friends/likes, but there is such infrequent interactivity and the statements made are so guarded that these individuals have little influence.
  10. The opposition leaders have a social media presence, but it isn’t very interactive and is very formal. They seldom share material from others and stick to the party line.941,554 Azerbaijani adults on Facebook
  11. And these network forms are part of what is so threatening to the governmentNot only do they have a large audience, but the efficiency at which they share information and collectively organize is amazing, thus this threatening to the governmentSo let’s look at some examples of what the opposition is doing
  12. I’m not going to bog anyone down with this, but needless to say it has been a very busy year in Azerbaijan leading up to the October election
  13. Let’s start with the independent networks – this is the most interesting, I think.
  14. NerminRehimli, one of the organisers of the campaign, the sum of 10,500 manats needed to cover all the fines was collected within five days.“The amount of money raised in such a short period of time and the demonstration of support by a wide variety of Azerbaijanis was significant,” Pearce said. “More than 2,000 people donated during the campaign, the majority of them Facebook and Twitter users. The purpose of the campaign was to continue the solidarity demonstrated at the January 12 protest action over conscript deaths.”In what looked like a response to the “five qepik” campaign, the government amended the civil offence code in early February to stipulate fines of 250 to 500 manats for anyone who donates money to political parties, civil society groups and international non-governmental organisations. The fines are higher for state employees, and there are separate penalties for organisations that accept the money.$13k US
  15. How much money raised?
  16. http://azerireport.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2095
  17. the Azerbaijani government monitors its citizens’ use of social media. Azerbaijanis believe that their government is watching ‘‘everyone’’ on social media. In addition, there is evidence for this: users have had their Facebook accounts as well as Yahoo! and Gmail e-mail accounts compromised. This causes self-censorship amongst those that do use social media while discouraging those too fearful to engage.
  18. EminMilli and Adnan HajizadaBakhtiyarHajiyev Khadija IsmayilDirect actionThird, the government arrests online activists. In early September 2009, Adnan Hajizada and EminMilli,two young Baku foreign-educated elites, employees of international organizations and youth activists,produced a YouTube video163 parodying the government for spending hundreds of thousands of dollarsto import donkeys from Germany. In the video, a group of solemn journalists interview a donkey(Hajizada in costume) and note that this donkey would be afforded more civil liberties than Azerbaijanicitizens, ‘‘There will be someone to protect donkey rights,’’ the video concludes, ‘‘but what of humanrights?’’ Two weeks later, Hajizada and Milli were having dinner with friends when they were attacked bytwo unknown men. They went to the police, assuming that the incident would be investigated. Instead,they were arrested for “hooliganism” and sentenced to 30 and 24 months imprisonment, respectively, onNovember 11, 2009. Appeals by human rights groups and foreign governments in late 2009 and throughmost of 2010 were denied. After intense international pressure, the two were released in November2010.Also, on the very day the “Arab Spring” began in late January 2011, state officials arrested formerparliamentary candidate and online activist BaxtiyarHajiyev, who remains in jail at the time of writing.Two other online youth activists, JabbarSalavan and DeyanatBabayev, were arrested in February andMarch 2011, respectively. Salavan was released on 26 December 2011 and Babayev confirmed to theauthor in December 2011 that he was released although there was no press coverage164.While the earlier cases had no mainstream media coverage, the 2011 cases have, which furtherdemonizes social media to the Azerbaijani public.On 4 March 2011, Hajiyev was questioned by police about Facebook activity related to an upcoming anti-government protest, scheduled for 11 March.[4] Later in the day, he was arrested on charges of having disobeyed a police order not to leave the city of Ganja while charges that he had evaded military service were being investigated.[4] On 7 March, Hajiyev passed his lawyer, ElchinNamazov, a letter stating that he had been beaten, tortured, and threatened with sexual abuse while in custody.[5] When Namazov visited Hajiyev on 7 May, the lawyer saw "an open wound on Hajiyev's neck, bruises on his eyes, and a hematoma on the left side of his nose".[3]Namazov filed a complaint with Ganja's prosecutor's office, but authorities reportedly failed to investigate Hajivev's claims of abuse.[3]On 18 May, the Nizami District Court of Ganja sentenced Hajiyev to two years' imprisonment.[3] The Supreme Court of Azerbaijan upheld the sentence on 6 December 2011.[6] A government official reported to the court that Hajiyev had been given a negative assessment by prison staff, indicating that he was unrepentant.[7]Hajiyev was released early by the Supreme Court of Azerbaijan for good behavior on 4 June 2012.[8] The announcement came days before a visit by U.S. Secretary of StateHillary Clinton.[9]
  19. NEED TEXT FOR NIDA KIDS
  20. Attention to these names…