Chapter 11


Published on

Published in: Education
  • Be the first to comment

Chapter 11

  1. 1. Chapter 11Qualitative Research Design<br />Bart Miller<br />EDUC 519<br />
  2. 2. Presentation Guideline<br />Qualitative Research* Characteristics* Types* Methods* Research Problems* Credibility<br />
  3. 3. Characteristics of Qualitative Research<br /><ul><li> Occurs naturally – field research
  4. 4. Data collected directly from the source.
  5. 5. Rich descriptions & details in recording.
  6. 6. Process orientation - Focus on “HOW” and “WHY”.
  7. 7. Data gathered first, then synthesized to form generalizations.
  8. 8. Focus on participants’ perspectives and understanding.
  9. 9. Research design evolves and changes throughout the study.</li></li></ul><li>Question #1<br />Name the four types of qualitative research and give an example of each in an educational research context.<br />
  10. 10. Types of Qualitative Research<br /><ul><li> Ethnographic Studies
  11. 11. Case Studies
  12. 12. Phenomenological Studies
  13. 13. Grounded Theory Studies</li></li></ul><li>Ethnographic Studies<br />In-depth descriptions and interpretations of cultural patterns and meanings within a culture or social group. Researchers observe a culture for an extended period of time, interacting with and interviewing members of the culture, gaining knowledge through the analysis of documents and artifacts.<br />Identifying and Entering the Research Site<br /><ul><li> Gaining Permission & Establishing Rapport</li></ul>Selecting Participants<br />Data Collection<br /> - Observations<br /> - Interviews – Types<br /> - Document Analysis<br />Data Analysis<br /> - Emic<br /> - Etic<br /> - Codes<br />
  14. 14. Ethnographic Studies<br />Examples: <br /> Mary - a study of new mathematics teachers' attitudes of using manipulatives.<br />Ham - comparison of children from three different cultures attending kindergarten.<br />
  15. 15. Case Studies<br />An in-depth investigation of one entity, which is carefully defined and characterized by time and place. <br />Types of Case Studies<br /> - Historical Organizational, Observational, Life History, Situation analysis, Multicase, Multisite<br />Research Problem Statement<br />Entering the Site & Selecting Participants<br />Data Collection<br /> - Observations<br /> - Interviews – Types<br /> - Document Analysis<br />Data Analysis<br /> - Transcripts and field notes need to be coded, organized, summarized, etc.<br /> - Similar to ethnographic studies<br />
  16. 16. Case Studies<br />Examples: <br /> Mary - a with-in study of a instructional strategy at a single school<br />Ham - study of a situation analysis on how peer pressure effects the choices that kids make.<br />
  17. 17. Phenomenological Studies<br />To describe and interpret the experiences of participants in order to understand the essence of the experience as perceived by the participants.<br />Focuses on the consciousness of human experiences.<br />Examples: <br /> Mary - a study of the relationship between peer tutors and tutoree<br />Ham - on the influence of television on student study habits.<br />
  18. 18. Grounded Theory Studies<br />The intent of a grounded theory study is to discover or generate a theory.<br />Data Collection:<br /> - Interviews<br />Data Analysis:<br /> - Coding to constantly compare findings to themes<br />Reporting of Results:<br /> - As a set of propositions, hypotheses, or theories <br />Examples: <br />Mary -a study of the effect of discipline during elementary school on the later adolescent success<br />Ham - collecting field data on how does exercise influence students grades, how does healthy food assist kids grades, how does outdoor play effect students grades.<br />
  19. 19. Activity: Types of Qualitative Research <br />Name the type of qualitative research for each example:<br /><ul><li> An investigation of 15 students’ perspectives on their experience in the high school band.
  20. 20. A with-in study of how a specific scheduling system works at a single school district.
  21. 21. Data collected to find out how elementary student’s involvement in physical education programs effect their overall school grades.
  22. 22. An in-depth study of Native American school children on the reservation.</li></li></ul><li>Credibility of Qualitative Research<br /><ul><li> Triangulation
  23. 23. Reliability
  24. 24. Internal Validity
  25. 25. External Validity</li></li></ul><li>Question # 2<br />Why is it important for researchers to use multiple methods of data collection?<br />Mary – It is important to yield richness of understanding the phenomenon being studied. In addition, interviews and document analysis could help to verify observations and explain a participant's point of view. <br />Ham - Using multiple methods enhance the credibility of results. Since, researchers judge credibility of results from a holistic perspective. If you are using different methods but get the same results the validity of the research is verified. <br />