If bell hook made an LMS: Grades, Radical Openness, and Domain of One's Own

Jesse Stommel
Jesse StommelPedagogue / Open Educator / Public Digital Humanist
If bell hooks made an LMS
Grades, Radical Openness, and Domain of One's Own
Jesse Stommel
@Jessifer
Radical openness isn't a bureaucratic gesture. It has to be
rooted in a willingness to sit with discomfort. The learning
management system is not a space built for discomfort.
Radical openness in education means recognizing the ways in
which the work of teaching is a kind of activism. The learning
management system is not a space built for activism.
Radical openness demands the classroom be a space for
relationships and dialogue. The LMS is designed to make
grading students convenient for teachers—and designed to
facilitate the systematic observation (and scoring) of teachers
by administrators. These are not dialogues.
“Ceding authority is an active endeavor. Dichotomies of
leaders and learners, teachers and students, are only helpful
when they facilitate rather than frustrate dialogue, and when
we acknowledge these roles are permeable, transparent, and
flexible.”
~ Sean Michael Morris and Jesse Stommel, “If Freire Made a MOOC”
For the same reason that we shouldn't presume to (even
imaginatively) build the LMS for bell hooks, we should have
never built these systems for students. We shouldn't pre-
determine the shape of a student's learning environment
before that student even arrives upon the scene.
bell hooks writes in Teaching to Transgress about her
experience in graduate school, “nonconformity on our part
was viewed with suspicion, as empty gestures of defiance
aimed at masking inferiority or substandard work.”
The learning management system is a red herring, a symptom
of a much larger beast that has its teeth on education: the rude
quantification of learning, the reduction of teaching to widgets
and students to data points.
Most teaching practice is unexamined, because teachers in
higher education are rarely asked to think critically about
pedagogy. They structure learning as though students are
interchangeable. They expect content mastery. They demand
compliance with course policies. They wield expertise like a
weapon. They grade.
We can't expect that just building new systems will magically
change our teaching practices.
“My commitment to engaged pedagogy is an expression of
political activism. Given that our educational institutions are so
deeply invested in a banking system, teachers are more
rewarded when we do not teach against the grain. The choice
to work against the grain, to challenge the status quo, often
has negative consequences.”
~ bell hooks, Teaching to Transgress
Even a system that invites subversiveness, like Domain of
One's Own, can't single-handedly dismantle the
institutionalized hierarchies of education.
“Until students see this domain as a space that rewards rigor
and experimentation, it will not promote student agency …
The domains project isn’t revolutionary to the traditional
classroom, but it is revolutionary to a classroom reimagined
around public scholarship, student agency and
experimentation.”
~ Andrew Rikard, “Do I Own My Domain if You Grade it?”
When students take learning into their own hands, they have
no use for learning management systems.
bell hooks means something very specific when she talks of
Radical Openness, and so far the Open Education movement
has failed to tread that particular water. Domain of One's Own
has flirted at the edge of Critical Pedagogy, but giving out free
Domains isn't exactly the revolution Paulo Freire, bell hooks, or
Virginia Woolf had in mind. It's a start.
“Spaces can be real and imagined. Spaces can tell stories and
unfold histories. Spaces can be interrupted, appropriated, and
transformed through artistic and literary practice.”
~ bell hooks, “Choosing the Margin as a Space of Radical Openness”
What if dialogue were the stuff of open learning and not
content?
hooks continues, “for me this place of radical openness is a
margin—a profound edge. Locating oneself there is difficult
yet necessary. It is not a 'safe' place. One is always at risk. One
needs a community of resistance.” For hooks, the risks we take
are personal, professional, political. When she says that
“radical openness is a margin,” she suggests it is a place of
uncertainty, a place of friction, a place of critical thinking.
“We act—at our peril—as if 'open' is politically neutral, let
alone politically good or progressive. Indeed, we sometimes
use the word to stand in place of a politics of participatory
democracy.”
~ Audrey Watters, “From ‘Open’ to Justice”
With a project like Domain of One's Own, supporting student
agency means advocating for students as they make choices
about their own work—the what, when, and also whether. As
Debra Schleef writes in “Who's Afraid of Domain of One's
Own,” this means, “a choice to keep one’s domain, to change
it significantly, or not to use it at all.”
Grades are the biggest thorn in the side of Domain of One's
Own—and the biggest barrier to realizing its radical potential.
“Grading [undermines] the climate for teaching and learning.
Once we start grading their work, students are tempted to
study or work for the grade rather than for learning.”
~ Peter Elbow
Ranking. Norming. Objectivity. Uniformity. Measurement.
Outcomes. Quality. Data. Performance. Metrics. Scores.
Excellence. Mastery.
The problem is not just the fact of grades but the fetishization
of them.
“Let your life be a counter-friction to stop the machine.” And
then, “if it is of such a nature that it requires you to be the
agent of injustice to another, then I say, break the law.”
~ Henry David Thoreau, “Civil Disobedience”
Usually when I talk of grading, I do so with a caveat, and I point
toward approaches that offer a middle ground. But I want to
argue here that there really is no middle ground with Domain
of One's Own. Put simply, no, you don't own your domain if I
grade it.
Grading a student domain, by any of our conventional
academic metrics, undermines the work:
• Grades are not good incentive.
• Grades are not good feedback.
• Grades are not good markers of learning.
• Grades don't reflect the idiosyncratic, subjective, often emotional
character of learning.
• Grades encourage competitiveness over collaboration.
• Grades aren't fair. They will never be fair.
All of this demands exactly two pedagogical approaches, and
these are what I see at the heart of Domain of One's Own:
1. Start by trusting students.
2. Realize "fairness" is not a good excuse for a lack of empathy.
“There is still so much work to do.”
~ Martha Burtis, “Messy and Chaotic Learning”
1 of 30

Recommended

Queering Open Pedagogy by
Queering Open PedagogyQueering Open Pedagogy
Queering Open PedagogyJesse Stommel
5K views40 slides
Open Pedagogy: Building Compassionate Spaces for Online Learning by
Open Pedagogy: Building Compassionate Spaces for Online LearningOpen Pedagogy: Building Compassionate Spaces for Online Learning
Open Pedagogy: Building Compassionate Spaces for Online LearningJesse Stommel
7.2K views42 slides
If bell hooks Made a Learning Management System by
If bell hooks Made a Learning Management SystemIf bell hooks Made a Learning Management System
If bell hooks Made a Learning Management SystemSean Michael Morris
2.6K views22 slides
Why I Don't Grade by
Why I Don't GradeWhy I Don't Grade
Why I Don't GradeJesse Stommel
39K views50 slides
12 steps for Designing an Assignment with Emergent Outcomes by
12 steps for Designing an Assignment with Emergent Outcomes12 steps for Designing an Assignment with Emergent Outcomes
12 steps for Designing an Assignment with Emergent OutcomesJesse Stommel
58.6K views31 slides
Critical Digital Pedagogy by
Critical Digital PedagogyCritical Digital Pedagogy
Critical Digital PedagogyJesse Stommel
44.1K views29 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Radical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy by
Radical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital PedagogyRadical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy
Radical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital PedagogyJesse Stommel
516 views38 slides
If Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital Pedagogy by
If Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital PedagogyIf Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital Pedagogy
If Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital PedagogyJesse Stommel
27K views31 slides
Centering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher Education by
Centering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher EducationCentering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher Education
Centering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher EducationJesse Stommel
5.7K views53 slides
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy by
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital PedagogyAgainst Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital PedagogyJesse Stommel
3.7K views48 slides
Against Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of Education by
Against Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of EducationAgainst Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of Education
Against Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of EducationJesse Stommel
4.6K views44 slides
An Urgency of Teachers by
An Urgency of TeachersAn Urgency of Teachers
An Urgency of TeachersJesse Stommel
1.3K views40 slides

What's hot(20)

Radical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy by Jesse Stommel
Radical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital PedagogyRadical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy
Radical Openness: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel516 views
If Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital Pedagogy by Jesse Stommel
If Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital PedagogyIf Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital Pedagogy
If Freire Made a MOOC: Open Education and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel27K views
Centering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher Education by Jesse Stommel
Centering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher EducationCentering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher Education
Centering Teaching: the Human Work of Higher Education
Jesse Stommel5.7K views
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy by Jesse Stommel
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital PedagogyAgainst Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Against Scaffolding: Radical Openness and Critical Digital Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel3.7K views
Against Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of Education by Jesse Stommel
Against Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of EducationAgainst Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of Education
Against Counteranthropomorphism: The Human Future of Education
Jesse Stommel4.6K views
An Urgency of Teachers by Jesse Stommel
An Urgency of TeachersAn Urgency of Teachers
An Urgency of Teachers
Jesse Stommel1.3K views
Digital Pedagogy is about Breaking Stuff: Toward a Critical Digital Humanitie... by Jesse Stommel
Digital Pedagogy is about Breaking Stuff: Toward a Critical Digital Humanitie...Digital Pedagogy is about Breaking Stuff: Toward a Critical Digital Humanitie...
Digital Pedagogy is about Breaking Stuff: Toward a Critical Digital Humanitie...
Jesse Stommel38.1K views
An Urgency of Teachers: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy by Jesse Stommel
An Urgency of Teachers: the Work of Critical Digital PedagogyAn Urgency of Teachers: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy
An Urgency of Teachers: the Work of Critical Digital Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel1.1K views
Critical Pedagogy, Civil Disobedience, and Edtech by Jesse Stommel
Critical Pedagogy, Civil Disobedience, and EdtechCritical Pedagogy, Civil Disobedience, and Edtech
Critical Pedagogy, Civil Disobedience, and Edtech
Jesse Stommel5.5K views
Critical digital pedagogy after covid 19 - reflections on teaching thtrough t... by Sean Michael Morris
Critical digital pedagogy after covid 19 - reflections on teaching thtrough t...Critical digital pedagogy after covid 19 - reflections on teaching thtrough t...
Critical digital pedagogy after covid 19 - reflections on teaching thtrough t...
Learning is Not a Mechanism: Assessment, Student Agency, and Digital Spaces by Jesse Stommel
Learning is Not a Mechanism: Assessment, Student Agency, and Digital SpacesLearning is Not a Mechanism: Assessment, Student Agency, and Digital Spaces
Learning is Not a Mechanism: Assessment, Student Agency, and Digital Spaces
Jesse Stommel22.2K views
Graduate Training in 21st Century Pedagogy by Jesse Stommel
Graduate Training in 21st Century PedagogyGraduate Training in 21st Century Pedagogy
Graduate Training in 21st Century Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel11.4K views
Rewriting the syllabus: Examining New Hybrid and Online Pedagogies by Jesse Stommel
Rewriting the syllabus: Examining New Hybrid and Online PedagogiesRewriting the syllabus: Examining New Hybrid and Online Pedagogies
Rewriting the syllabus: Examining New Hybrid and Online Pedagogies
Jesse Stommel24.7K views
Building an Inclusive Campus by Jesse Stommel
Building an Inclusive CampusBuilding an Inclusive Campus
Building an Inclusive Campus
Jesse Stommel2.5K views
Big Ideas in Digital Pedagogy by Rebecca Davis
Big Ideas in Digital PedagogyBig Ideas in Digital Pedagogy
Big Ideas in Digital Pedagogy
Rebecca Davis1.8K views
Introduction to Digital Pedagogy by Jesse Stommel
Introduction to Digital PedagogyIntroduction to Digital Pedagogy
Introduction to Digital Pedagogy
Jesse Stommel3.1K views

Similar to If bell hook made an LMS: Grades, Radical Openness, and Domain of One's Own

Leibowitz being and becoming a good university teacher by
Leibowitz being and becoming a good university teacherLeibowitz being and becoming a good university teacher
Leibowitz being and becoming a good university teacherBrenda Leibowitz
1.3K views25 slides
Ethical Online Learning by
Ethical Online LearningEthical Online Learning
Ethical Online LearningJesse Stommel
2.7K views43 slides
Examples Of Critical Pedagogy by
Examples Of Critical PedagogyExamples Of Critical Pedagogy
Examples Of Critical PedagogyCindy Ashworth
7 views40 slides
Teaching Philosophy by
Teaching PhilosophyTeaching Philosophy
Teaching PhilosophyDaniel Theisen
296 views6 slides
Critically reflective teaching by
Critically reflective teachingCritically reflective teaching
Critically reflective teachingThe Art of Learning
3.6K views20 slides
Final Research Paper! by
Final Research Paper!Final Research Paper!
Final Research Paper!Joseph Pugh
156 views10 slides

Similar to If bell hook made an LMS: Grades, Radical Openness, and Domain of One's Own(20)

Leibowitz being and becoming a good university teacher by Brenda Leibowitz
Leibowitz being and becoming a good university teacherLeibowitz being and becoming a good university teacher
Leibowitz being and becoming a good university teacher
Brenda Leibowitz1.3K views
Ethical Online Learning by Jesse Stommel
Ethical Online LearningEthical Online Learning
Ethical Online Learning
Jesse Stommel2.7K views
Final Research Paper! by Joseph Pugh
Final Research Paper!Final Research Paper!
Final Research Paper!
Joseph Pugh156 views
Multicultural Teaching and Learning as Everyone's Every Day Work by Ilene Dawn Alexander
Multicultural Teaching and Learning as Everyone's Every Day WorkMulticultural Teaching and Learning as Everyone's Every Day Work
Multicultural Teaching and Learning as Everyone's Every Day Work
Essay About My Philosophy Of Classroom Management by Amanda Gray
Essay About My Philosophy Of Classroom ManagementEssay About My Philosophy Of Classroom Management
Essay About My Philosophy Of Classroom Management
Amanda Gray4 views
Critical instructional design and Open Education by Sean Michael Morris
Critical instructional design and Open EducationCritical instructional design and Open Education
Critical instructional design and Open Education
Educational Philosophy Reflection by Sherry Bailey
Educational Philosophy ReflectionEducational Philosophy Reflection
Educational Philosophy Reflection
Sherry Bailey3 views
Teaching Strategies - The Secrets by rccartips
Teaching Strategies - The SecretsTeaching Strategies - The Secrets
Teaching Strategies - The Secrets
rccartips636 views
Myths and promises of blended learning by Martin Oliver
Myths and promises of blended learningMyths and promises of blended learning
Myths and promises of blended learning
Martin Oliver560 views
Luis Valentino on Scholarship Leadership Agency by JimmyGFlores
Luis Valentino on Scholarship Leadership AgencyLuis Valentino on Scholarship Leadership Agency
Luis Valentino on Scholarship Leadership Agency
JimmyGFlores39 views
Buffy hamilton project 1 read 8100 by Buffy Hamilton
Buffy hamilton project 1 read 8100Buffy hamilton project 1 read 8100
Buffy hamilton project 1 read 8100
Buffy Hamilton332 views
Low Impact Educational Practices by Peter Felten
Low Impact Educational PracticesLow Impact Educational Practices
Low Impact Educational Practices
Peter Felten601 views

More from Jesse Stommel

Designing for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online Learning by
Designing for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online LearningDesigning for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online Learning
Designing for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online LearningJesse Stommel
737 views29 slides
Virtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging Online by
Virtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging OnlineVirtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging Online
Virtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging OnlineJesse Stommel
248 views47 slides
Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an... by
Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an...Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an...
Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an...Jesse Stommel
9.6K views39 slides
Stand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital Humanities by
Stand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital HumanitiesStand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital Humanities
Stand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital HumanitiesJesse Stommel
4.1K views29 slides
New-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanities by
New-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanitiesNew-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanities
New-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanitiesJesse Stommel
13.1K views32 slides
Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T... by
Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T...Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T...
Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T...Jesse Stommel
4.4K views25 slides

More from Jesse Stommel(7)

Designing for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online Learning by Jesse Stommel
Designing for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online LearningDesigning for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online Learning
Designing for Care: Inclusive Pedagogies for Online Learning
Jesse Stommel737 views
Virtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging Online by Jesse Stommel
Virtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging OnlineVirtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging Online
Virtual Learning Communities: 6 Theses for Creating a Sense of Belonging Online
Jesse Stommel248 views
Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an... by Jesse Stommel
Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an...Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an...
Digital Humanities and the Future of Scholarship: Exclusivity, Disruption, an...
Jesse Stommel9.6K views
Stand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital Humanities by Jesse Stommel
Stand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital HumanitiesStand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital Humanities
Stand and Unfold Yourself: MOOCs, Networked Learning, and the Digital Humanities
Jesse Stommel4.1K views
New-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanities by Jesse Stommel
New-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanitiesNew-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanities
New-form Scholarship and the Public digital humanities
Jesse Stommel13.1K views
Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T... by Jesse Stommel
Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T...Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T...
Massive Learning, Massive Play: Constructing Identity and Community through T...
Jesse Stommel4.4K views
Zombie Pedagogies: Embodied Learning in the Digital Age by Jesse Stommel
Zombie Pedagogies: Embodied Learning in the Digital AgeZombie Pedagogies: Embodied Learning in the Digital Age
Zombie Pedagogies: Embodied Learning in the Digital Age
Jesse Stommel31K views

Recently uploaded

UNIDAD 3 6º C.MEDIO.pptx by
UNIDAD 3 6º C.MEDIO.pptxUNIDAD 3 6º C.MEDIO.pptx
UNIDAD 3 6º C.MEDIO.pptxMarcosRodriguezUcedo
145 views32 slides
StudioX.pptx by
StudioX.pptxStudioX.pptx
StudioX.pptxNikhileshSathyavarap
89 views18 slides
Education of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptx by
Education of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptxEducation of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptx
Education of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptxGarimaBhati5
40 views36 slides
Narration lesson plan by
Narration lesson planNarration lesson plan
Narration lesson planTARIQ KHAN
69 views11 slides
ANGULARJS.pdf by
ANGULARJS.pdfANGULARJS.pdf
ANGULARJS.pdfArthyR3
49 views10 slides
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptx by
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptxCreate a Structure in VBNet.pptx
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptxBreach_P
82 views8 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Education of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptx by GarimaBhati5
Education of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptxEducation of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptx
Education of marginalized and socially disadvantages segments.pptx
GarimaBhati540 views
Narration lesson plan by TARIQ KHAN
Narration lesson planNarration lesson plan
Narration lesson plan
TARIQ KHAN69 views
ANGULARJS.pdf by ArthyR3
ANGULARJS.pdfANGULARJS.pdf
ANGULARJS.pdf
ArthyR349 views
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptx by Breach_P
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptxCreate a Structure in VBNet.pptx
Create a Structure in VBNet.pptx
Breach_P82 views
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau by DivyaSheta
The Accursed House  by Émile GaboriauThe Accursed House  by Émile Gaboriau
The Accursed House by Émile Gaboriau
DivyaSheta246 views
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx by mary850239
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx
11.28.23 Social Capital and Social Exclusion.pptx
mary850239409 views
Creative Restart 2023: Atila Martins - Craft: A Necessity, Not a Choice by Taste
Creative Restart 2023: Atila Martins - Craft: A Necessity, Not a ChoiceCreative Restart 2023: Atila Martins - Craft: A Necessity, Not a Choice
Creative Restart 2023: Atila Martins - Craft: A Necessity, Not a Choice
Taste41 views
Payment Integration using Braintree Connector | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #37 by MysoreMuleSoftMeetup
Payment Integration using Braintree Connector | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #37Payment Integration using Braintree Connector | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #37
Payment Integration using Braintree Connector | MuleSoft Mysore Meetup #37
Retail Store Scavenger Hunt.pptx by jmurphy154
Retail Store Scavenger Hunt.pptxRetail Store Scavenger Hunt.pptx
Retail Store Scavenger Hunt.pptx
jmurphy15452 views
INT-244 Topic 6b Confucianism by S Meyer
INT-244 Topic 6b ConfucianismINT-244 Topic 6b Confucianism
INT-244 Topic 6b Confucianism
S Meyer44 views
Guess Papers ADC 1, Karachi University by Khalid Aziz
Guess Papers ADC 1, Karachi UniversityGuess Papers ADC 1, Karachi University
Guess Papers ADC 1, Karachi University
Khalid Aziz83 views
11.30.23A Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx by mary850239
11.30.23A Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx11.30.23A Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
11.30.23A Poverty and Inequality in America.pptx
mary85023986 views

If bell hook made an LMS: Grades, Radical Openness, and Domain of One's Own

  • 1. If bell hooks made an LMS Grades, Radical Openness, and Domain of One's Own
  • 3. Radical openness isn't a bureaucratic gesture. It has to be rooted in a willingness to sit with discomfort. The learning management system is not a space built for discomfort.
  • 4. Radical openness in education means recognizing the ways in which the work of teaching is a kind of activism. The learning management system is not a space built for activism.
  • 5. Radical openness demands the classroom be a space for relationships and dialogue. The LMS is designed to make grading students convenient for teachers—and designed to facilitate the systematic observation (and scoring) of teachers by administrators. These are not dialogues.
  • 6. “Ceding authority is an active endeavor. Dichotomies of leaders and learners, teachers and students, are only helpful when they facilitate rather than frustrate dialogue, and when we acknowledge these roles are permeable, transparent, and flexible.” ~ Sean Michael Morris and Jesse Stommel, “If Freire Made a MOOC”
  • 7. For the same reason that we shouldn't presume to (even imaginatively) build the LMS for bell hooks, we should have never built these systems for students. We shouldn't pre- determine the shape of a student's learning environment before that student even arrives upon the scene.
  • 8. bell hooks writes in Teaching to Transgress about her experience in graduate school, “nonconformity on our part was viewed with suspicion, as empty gestures of defiance aimed at masking inferiority or substandard work.”
  • 9. The learning management system is a red herring, a symptom of a much larger beast that has its teeth on education: the rude quantification of learning, the reduction of teaching to widgets and students to data points.
  • 10. Most teaching practice is unexamined, because teachers in higher education are rarely asked to think critically about pedagogy. They structure learning as though students are interchangeable. They expect content mastery. They demand compliance with course policies. They wield expertise like a weapon. They grade.
  • 11. We can't expect that just building new systems will magically change our teaching practices.
  • 12. “My commitment to engaged pedagogy is an expression of political activism. Given that our educational institutions are so deeply invested in a banking system, teachers are more rewarded when we do not teach against the grain. The choice to work against the grain, to challenge the status quo, often has negative consequences.” ~ bell hooks, Teaching to Transgress
  • 13. Even a system that invites subversiveness, like Domain of One's Own, can't single-handedly dismantle the institutionalized hierarchies of education.
  • 14. “Until students see this domain as a space that rewards rigor and experimentation, it will not promote student agency … The domains project isn’t revolutionary to the traditional classroom, but it is revolutionary to a classroom reimagined around public scholarship, student agency and experimentation.” ~ Andrew Rikard, “Do I Own My Domain if You Grade it?”
  • 15. When students take learning into their own hands, they have no use for learning management systems.
  • 16. bell hooks means something very specific when she talks of Radical Openness, and so far the Open Education movement has failed to tread that particular water. Domain of One's Own has flirted at the edge of Critical Pedagogy, but giving out free Domains isn't exactly the revolution Paulo Freire, bell hooks, or Virginia Woolf had in mind. It's a start.
  • 17. “Spaces can be real and imagined. Spaces can tell stories and unfold histories. Spaces can be interrupted, appropriated, and transformed through artistic and literary practice.” ~ bell hooks, “Choosing the Margin as a Space of Radical Openness”
  • 18. What if dialogue were the stuff of open learning and not content?
  • 19. hooks continues, “for me this place of radical openness is a margin—a profound edge. Locating oneself there is difficult yet necessary. It is not a 'safe' place. One is always at risk. One needs a community of resistance.” For hooks, the risks we take are personal, professional, political. When she says that “radical openness is a margin,” she suggests it is a place of uncertainty, a place of friction, a place of critical thinking.
  • 20. “We act—at our peril—as if 'open' is politically neutral, let alone politically good or progressive. Indeed, we sometimes use the word to stand in place of a politics of participatory democracy.” ~ Audrey Watters, “From ‘Open’ to Justice”
  • 21. With a project like Domain of One's Own, supporting student agency means advocating for students as they make choices about their own work—the what, when, and also whether. As Debra Schleef writes in “Who's Afraid of Domain of One's Own,” this means, “a choice to keep one’s domain, to change it significantly, or not to use it at all.”
  • 22. Grades are the biggest thorn in the side of Domain of One's Own—and the biggest barrier to realizing its radical potential.
  • 23. “Grading [undermines] the climate for teaching and learning. Once we start grading their work, students are tempted to study or work for the grade rather than for learning.” ~ Peter Elbow
  • 24. Ranking. Norming. Objectivity. Uniformity. Measurement. Outcomes. Quality. Data. Performance. Metrics. Scores. Excellence. Mastery.
  • 25. The problem is not just the fact of grades but the fetishization of them.
  • 26. “Let your life be a counter-friction to stop the machine.” And then, “if it is of such a nature that it requires you to be the agent of injustice to another, then I say, break the law.” ~ Henry David Thoreau, “Civil Disobedience”
  • 27. Usually when I talk of grading, I do so with a caveat, and I point toward approaches that offer a middle ground. But I want to argue here that there really is no middle ground with Domain of One's Own. Put simply, no, you don't own your domain if I grade it.
  • 28. Grading a student domain, by any of our conventional academic metrics, undermines the work: • Grades are not good incentive. • Grades are not good feedback. • Grades are not good markers of learning. • Grades don't reflect the idiosyncratic, subjective, often emotional character of learning. • Grades encourage competitiveness over collaboration. • Grades aren't fair. They will never be fair.
  • 29. All of this demands exactly two pedagogical approaches, and these are what I see at the heart of Domain of One's Own: 1. Start by trusting students. 2. Realize "fairness" is not a good excuse for a lack of empathy.
  • 30. “There is still so much work to do.” ~ Martha Burtis, “Messy and Chaotic Learning”