What is Liability Driven Investing?<br />Presented by:<br />Brent Burns<br />
Liability-driven investing (LDI) is an investment strategy of a company or individual based on the cash flows needed to fu...
Decline in Traditional PensionsFortune 100 Companies 1985-2010<br />
Behavioral Finance Meets Asset Allocation<br />
Clients with multiple goals and varying timelines have trouble relating to stocks, bonds and cash are blended into a singl...
Client Needs<br />Liquidity for current expenses<br />Predictable near-term cash flows to cover near-term expenses (usuall...
Total Return Asset Allocation<br />Long-Term Growth<br />Cash Flow Needs<br />Bonds<br />Stocks<br />Cash<br />
Splitting assets into multiple sub-portfolios helps clients better understand and stick to an allocation strategy. Bonds a...
Total Portfolio<br />Split into sub-portfolios to serve different purposes<br />Bonds<br />Stocks<br />Total<br />Return<b...
Asset Allocation and Time HorizonUsing Asset Classes That Fit How Clients Think About Their Money<br />Stocks<br />Bonds<b...
How Often Bonds Beat Stocks<br />S&P 500 and Intermediate Treasury Bond Index 1927-2009 <br />
Worst and Average Spread<br />S&P 500 and Intermediate Treasury Bond Index 1927-2009 <br />
Using Individual Bonds to Build Income-Matching LDI Portfolios<br />
Immunization Definition<br />“When a bond portfolio is immunized, the investor receives a specific rate of return over a g...
Income-Matching “Paycheck” Portfolios<br />Immediate – Cash flows begin now<br />Deferred – Cash flows begin when the clie...
Building an Income-Matching Portfolio<br />Engineered to match a specific cash flow stream<br />Example:<br />$100,000 per...
The following example show a target cash flow stream, which comes from the client’s financial plan, that is closely matche...
Timing Cash Flows<br />Bond quotes 10/20/2010<br />
The Advantage of a Deferred Portfolio<br />Cost = $763,530 <br />Duration = 6.2 Years<br />IRR = 2.64%<br />
Immediate Portfolio Metrics<br />Cost = $809,589 <br />Duration = 4.1 Years<br />IRR = 2.46%<br />Bond quotes 10/20/2010<b...
Leveraging the Yield Curve<br />
Optimization Process<br />
Mathematical Programming<br />
Tale of Two Allocations<br />Total Return<br />LDI<br />
Double Duty From Bonds<br />Standard Benefits<br />Beta exposure to fixed income<br />Diversification<br />Dampen volatili...
“Flexible” rolling horizons<br />Using time to ride out bad markets<br />Taking more off the table when markets have been ...
Why Individual Bonds?<br />
Individual Bonds<br />Vs.<br />Bond Funds <br />
Legal Obligation<br />Vs.<br />Mutual Fund <br />
Decomposing Bond Fund Total Return<br />Income Return<br />Income return represents the sum of portfolio’s coupon payments...
Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
In periods of falling interest rates, bond funds and individual bonds behave similarly.  Both approaches invest for total ...
Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
30 years of falling interest rates has led to an unprecedented bull market for bonds.<br />
30 Years of Tailwinds<br />Total Return  11.3%<br />Source: United States Treasury 10-year constant maturity yield 1962-20...
97%<br />of taxable bond funds were started after 1981.  Sustained rising interest rates will be new territory for most po...
“People have unrealistic expectations of what a portfolio manager can do in a rising-rate environment.” <br />Jim Jessee, ...
Unprecedented bond fund flows will likely put added pressureon the bond market as rising rates cause losses and investors ...
Bond Fund Flows<br />
Like periods of falling interest rates, bond funds and individual bonds behave similarly in periods of flat interest rates...
Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
There is plenty of historical precedent for sustained periods of flat interest rates following economic turmoil.  Rates st...
Historical Interest Rates Average Yield 1800-2010<br />Long Depression	<br />Great Depression	<br />Source: United States ...
Japanese Interest Rates Since 1985<br />
The big advantage of individual bonds over bond funds becomes clear when rates rise.  Because bond funds turnover the bond...
Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
Volatility of Bond Funds Revealed<br />5-year Treas.<br />Source: BondDesk, 2009.  Data: CRSP Survivor-Bias-Free US Mutual...
Catch-22 for Bond Fund Investors<br />
Keep Duration Short and Rates Stay Flat (Japan)<br />The opportunity cost of staying short can be significant over time.  ...
Japanese Interest Rates Since 1985<br />
Extend Duration and Rates Rise<br />If rates rise and you are not immunized then losses are a function of duration and yie...
Headwind of Rising Rates<br />Total Return  2.2%<br />Average Coupon 5.6%<br />Source: United States Treasury 10-year cons...
Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
Managing the Shortfall<br />
The following example shows the impact of changing interest rates on an $800,000 investment in both a bond funds and an in...
An income-matching portfolio, shown as the red line, a has known worst case scenario of its yield to maturity and is alway...
Under the same withdrawal scenarios, an income matching portfolio will deliver target cash flows even when rising rates ca...
Other Income Strategies<br />Annuities<br />Dividend paying stocks<br />Real Estate/REITs<br />
Annuities tend to be expensive and inflexible, but until now were one of the few investment products designed specifically...
In the following example, equal amounts are invested in a 10-year income-matching portfolio and a 10-year period certain a...
Income-Matching Portfolios Vs. Annuities<br />Initial investment = $983,000<br />Income-Matching<br />total cash flows <br...
Based on the Treasury yield curve and standard mortality tables, annuitants can expect to only receive <br />81%-85% <br /...
Challenges for Annuities<br />Passing assets on to heirs<br />Managing inflation<br />Flexibility<br />Expenses, commissio...
Other Income Strategies<br />Annuities<br />Dividend paying stocks<br />Real Estate/REITs<br />
Dividend portfolios, the best of both worlds? <br />Income<br />Growth<br />
Not when dividends are spent instead of reinvested.  Jeremy Siegel showed that when investors spent the dividends growth o...
Investors who relied on dividends for income had to take a big pay cut when payments from companies in the S&P 500 dropped...
Other Income Strategies<br />Annuities<br />Dividend paying stocks<br />Real Estate/REITs<br />
70%<br />of REITs followed by Morningstar cut or suspended their dividends in 2009.  Not a reliable paycheck either.<br />...
Key Points<br />LDI ties portfolio construction to financial planning<br />Bond funds face a real challenge in a rising ra...
Disclosures<br />Past performance may not be indicative of future results. Therefore, no current or prospective client sho...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

What is Liability Driven Investing - FPA NY 2011

1,844 views

Published on

Presentation slides delivered at the FPA NY Forum in April 2011.

Published in: Economy & Finance, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
1,844
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
489
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
33
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • BB
  • SH
  • What is Liability Driven Investing - FPA NY 2011

    1. 1. What is Liability Driven Investing?<br />Presented by:<br />Brent Burns<br />
    2. 2. Liability-driven investing (LDI) is an investment strategy of a company or individual based on the cash flows needed to fund future liabilities<br />Source: Wikipedia<br />
    3. 3. Decline in Traditional PensionsFortune 100 Companies 1985-2010<br />
    4. 4. Behavioral Finance Meets Asset Allocation<br />
    5. 5. Clients with multiple goals and varying timelines have trouble relating to stocks, bonds and cash are blended into a single portfolio. People tend to use mental accounts to manage various goals in their head. A pure Total Return approach creates a single portfolio that isn’t intuitively linked to the underlying goals.<br />
    6. 6. Client Needs<br />Liquidity for current expenses<br />Predictable near-term cash flows to cover near-term expenses (usually 8-10 years for those in retirement)<br />Long-term growth to ensure sufficient growth to cover future needs<br />
    7. 7. Total Return Asset Allocation<br />Long-Term Growth<br />Cash Flow Needs<br />Bonds<br />Stocks<br />Cash<br />
    8. 8. Splitting assets into multiple sub-portfolios helps clients better understand and stick to an allocation strategy. Bonds are specifically allocated to predictable current or future income (LDI). Equities are dedicated to long term growth, but are given time to ride through bad markets (long-term total return). Each asset class is dedicated to the function it best serves.<br />
    9. 9. Total Portfolio<br />Split into sub-portfolios to serve different purposes<br />Bonds<br />Stocks<br />Total<br />Return<br />Liability Driven Investing<br />
    10. 10. Asset Allocation and Time HorizonUsing Asset Classes That Fit How Clients Think About Their Money<br />Stocks<br />Bonds<br />Cash<br />8 Years – Prefers predictable bonds <br />Today -<br />Prefers liquidity of money market<br />9 Years – Prefers higher return prospects of stocks<br />Next Year – Prefers predictable bonds <br />7 Years – Prefers predictable bonds <br />Time<br />
    11. 11. How Often Bonds Beat Stocks<br />S&P 500 and Intermediate Treasury Bond Index 1927-2009 <br />
    12. 12. Worst and Average Spread<br />S&P 500 and Intermediate Treasury Bond Index 1927-2009 <br />
    13. 13. Using Individual Bonds to Build Income-Matching LDI Portfolios<br />
    14. 14. Immunization Definition<br />“When a bond portfolio is immunized, the investor receives a specific rate of return over a given time period regardless of what happens to interest rates during that time.”<br />Morningstar Bond Course 104<br />
    15. 15. Income-Matching “Paycheck” Portfolios<br />Immediate – Cash flows begin now<br />Deferred – Cash flows begin when the client retires<br />
    16. 16. Building an Income-Matching Portfolio<br />Engineered to match a specific cash flow stream<br />Example:<br />$100,000 per year starting in 2 years<br />3% inflation adjustment<br />8 year time horizon<br />
    17. 17. The following example show a target cash flow stream, which comes from the client’s financial plan, that is closely matched by the actual portfolio cash flows. Cash flows come from coupon payments generated by all the bonds and redemptions for each year. <br />
    18. 18. Timing Cash Flows<br />Bond quotes 10/20/2010<br />
    19. 19. The Advantage of a Deferred Portfolio<br />Cost = $763,530 <br />Duration = 6.2 Years<br />IRR = 2.64%<br />
    20. 20. Immediate Portfolio Metrics<br />Cost = $809,589 <br />Duration = 4.1 Years<br />IRR = 2.46%<br />Bond quotes 10/20/2010<br />
    21. 21. Leveraging the Yield Curve<br />
    22. 22. Optimization Process<br />
    23. 23. Mathematical Programming<br />
    24. 24. Tale of Two Allocations<br />Total Return<br />LDI<br />
    25. 25. Double Duty From Bonds<br />Standard Benefits<br />Beta exposure to fixed income<br />Diversification<br />Dampen volatility<br />Unique LDI Benefits<br />Predictable cash flows<br />Immunization from rising interest rates<br />8<br />Years of Income<br />
    26. 26. “Flexible” rolling horizons<br />Using time to ride out bad markets<br />Taking more off the table when markets have been good<br />Do Not Roll . . .<br />Years<br />
    27. 27. Why Individual Bonds?<br />
    28. 28. Individual Bonds<br />Vs.<br />Bond Funds <br />
    29. 29. Legal Obligation<br />Vs.<br />Mutual Fund <br />
    30. 30. Decomposing Bond Fund Total Return<br />Income Return<br />Income return represents the sum of portfolio’s coupon payments<br />Income is never negative<br />Price Return<br />Bond prices are inversely related to interest rates<br />Bond prices fall as rates rise<br />
    31. 31. Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
    32. 32. In periods of falling interest rates, bond funds and individual bonds behave similarly. Both approaches invest for total return, which is greater than the stated YTM on the underlying bonds<br />
    33. 33. Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
    34. 34. 30 years of falling interest rates has led to an unprecedented bull market for bonds.<br />
    35. 35. 30 Years of Tailwinds<br />Total Return 11.3%<br />Source: United States Treasury 10-year constant maturity yield 1962-2009, Global Financial Data 1800-1962. 5-year rolling average<br />
    36. 36. 97%<br />of taxable bond funds were started after 1981. Sustained rising interest rates will be new territory for most portfolio managers.<br />
    37. 37. “People have unrealistic expectations of what a portfolio manager can do in a rising-rate environment.” <br />Jim Jessee, president of MFS Fund Distributors Inc. Investment News mutual fund round table in New York on Feb. 9, 2010<br />
    38. 38. Unprecedented bond fund flows will likely put added pressureon the bond market as rising rates cause losses and investors exit their bond funds.<br />
    39. 39. Bond Fund Flows<br />
    40. 40. Like periods of falling interest rates, bond funds and individual bonds behave similarly in periods of flat interest rates. Bond values stay at par, meaning that coupon interest is the primary source of returns.<br />
    41. 41. Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
    42. 42. There is plenty of historical precedent for sustained periods of flat interest rates following economic turmoil. Rates stayed low and flat for many years following the Long Depression in 1879 and again after the Great Depression. Japan has had more than a decade of low rates.<br />
    43. 43. Historical Interest Rates Average Yield 1800-2010<br />Long Depression <br />Great Depression <br />Source: United States Treasury 10-year constant maturity yield 1962-2009, Global Financial Data 1800-1962. 5-year rolling average<br />
    44. 44. Japanese Interest Rates Since 1985<br />
    45. 45. The big advantage of individual bonds over bond funds becomes clear when rates rise. Because bond funds turnover the bonds in their portfolios, they have<br />
    46. 46. Impact of Interest Rates on Total Return<br />
    47. 47. Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
    48. 48. Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
    49. 49. Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
    50. 50. Volatility of Bond Funds Revealed<br />5-year Treas.<br />Source: BondDesk, 2009. Data: CRSP Survivor-Bias-Free US Mutual Fund Database; Classes: Intermediate Treasury and Short-Intermediate Treasury.<br />
    51. 51. Catch-22 for Bond Fund Investors<br />
    52. 52. Keep Duration Short and Rates Stay Flat (Japan)<br />The opportunity cost of staying short can be significant over time. You need to take on duration to pickup any yield in this kind of environment.<br />
    53. 53. Japanese Interest Rates Since 1985<br />
    54. 54. Extend Duration and Rates Rise<br />If rates rise and you are not immunized then losses are a function of duration and yield on the portfolio. Bond funds will suffer a price loss of roughly their duration for each 1% rise in yield, offset by the coupon interest.<br />Duration ≈ 5 years<br />Estimated loss ≈ -2%<br />
    55. 55. Headwind of Rising Rates<br />Total Return 2.2%<br />Average Coupon 5.6%<br />Source: United States Treasury 10-year constant maturity yield 1962-2009, Global Financial Data 1800-1962. 5-year rolling average<br />
    56. 56. Rising Rates 1950-1981<br />
    57. 57. Managing the Shortfall<br />
    58. 58. The following example shows the impact of changing interest rates on an $800,000 investment in both a bond funds and an income-matching portfolio designed to generate $100,000 per year plus 3% inflation over 8 years. Estimated bond fund shortfall, shown by the white line, are for a fund with a duration of 5 years and an SEC 30-day yield of 3%. When interest rates rise, the portfolio is exhausted early.<br />
    59. 59.
    60. 60. An income-matching portfolio, shown as the red line, a has known worst case scenario of its yield to maturity and is always positive. Immunized from interest rate risk, the target cash flows are delivered regardless of loss in value of the bonds, because the return of principal and coupon payments are not affected by changes in price. If rates fall, gains can be harvested, however.<br />
    61. 61.
    62. 62. Under the same withdrawal scenarios, an income matching portfolio will deliver target cash flows even when rising rates cause the underlying value of the bonds to fall. Bond funds, on the other hand, lose money, leading to a funding shortfall. The portfolio suffers the worst case of reverse dollar cost averaging and cannot sustain withdrawals from a declining asset base. <br />
    63. 63.
    64. 64. Other Income Strategies<br />Annuities<br />Dividend paying stocks<br />Real Estate/REITs<br />
    65. 65. Annuities tend to be expensive and inflexible, but until now were one of the few investment products designed specifically to generate predictable income. <br />
    66. 66. In the following example, equal amounts are invested in a 10-year income-matching portfolio and a 10-year period certain annuity. The income-matching portfolio generates more income.<br />
    67. 67. Income-Matching Portfolios Vs. Annuities<br />Initial investment = $983,000<br />Income-Matching<br />total cash flows <br />= $1,162,423<br />Annuity <br />total cash flows <br />= $1,104,600<br />Income-Matching advantage = $57,823 <br />Annuity quote from www.immediateannuities.com 4/21/2011; Price quotes for CDs and agency bonds used to build LDI portfolio 4/21/2011.<br />
    68. 68. Based on the Treasury yield curve and standard mortality tables, annuitants can expect to only receive <br />81%-85% <br />of their premium in return.<br />Annuities for an Ageing World, Olivia S. Mitchell and David McCarthy, June 9, 2002<br />
    69. 69. Challenges for Annuities<br />Passing assets on to heirs<br />Managing inflation<br />Flexibility<br />Expenses, commissions, and fees<br />Counterparty risk<br />
    70. 70. Other Income Strategies<br />Annuities<br />Dividend paying stocks<br />Real Estate/REITs<br />
    71. 71. Dividend portfolios, the best of both worlds? <br />Income<br />Growth<br />
    72. 72. Not when dividends are spent instead of reinvested. Jeremy Siegel showed that when investors spent the dividends growth on the remaining portfolio trailed the S&P 500 by 3.5% compounded from 1964 to 2005.1<br />Unique Risk and Return Characteristics of Dividend-Weighted Stock Indexes; Siegel, Jeremy, et al; 2006<br />
    73. 73. Investors who relied on dividends for income had to take a big pay cut when payments from companies in the S&P 500 dropped by…January 2008 to January 2009<br />23.9%<br />Standard and Poors S&P 500 Market Attributes Snapshot, January 2009<br />
    74. 74. Other Income Strategies<br />Annuities<br />Dividend paying stocks<br />Real Estate/REITs<br />
    75. 75. 70%<br />of REITs followed by Morningstar cut or suspended their dividends in 2009. Not a reliable paycheck either.<br />Morningstar Industry Report 2010<br />
    76. 76. Key Points<br />LDI ties portfolio construction to financial planning<br />Bond funds face a real challenge in a rising rate environment<br />Income-matching can bring more predictability and transparency to the retirement income problem<br />
    77. 77. Disclosures<br />Past performance may not be indicative of future results. Therefore, no current or prospective client should assume that future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy (including the investments and/or investment strategies recommended or undertaken by Asset Dedication) made reference to directly or indirectly by Asset Dedication in their literature or otherwise will be profitable or equal the corresponding indicated performance level(s). Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that any specific investment will either be suitable or profitable for a client or prospective client’s investment portfolio. Historical performance results for investment indices and/or categories generally do not reflect the deduction of transaction and/or custodial charges, the deduction of an investment management fee, nor the impact of taxes, the incurrence of which would have the effect of decreasing historical performance results.<br />Please remember that different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and there can be no assurance that the future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy (including those undertaken or recommended by Asset Dedication), will be profitable or equal any historical performance level(s).<br />

    ×