Will Hopkins
NH Peace Action
Democratic process installed in 1964, a Marxist faction, the Peoples Democratic
Party of Afghanistan (PDPA) was founded in...
 Soviet forces withdrew in 1989, leaving behind
a great amount of military equipment for use
by PDPA.
 PDPA and Mujahede...
 Civil war between different factions of the
Mujahedeen essentially broke out in 1992, with
the Taliban taking control in...
 In the years leading up to September 11, 2001,
the Al-Queda network, an international group
with anti-western aims condu...
 Osama Bin Laden openly supported the
Taliban regime, and was thought by some in
the intelligence community to be hiding ...
 Unical (Union Oil/Chevron) was engaged in
negotiations with Afghanistan to build a
pipeline across Afghanistan opening u...
 Afghanistan holds some of the worlds largest
reserves of copper, bauxite, aluminum, iron,
cobalt, gold, and lithium. In ...
 Bombing began in 1998.
 With the breakdown of diplomatic relations,
the US began planning a small scale invasion,
India...
 Caspian Pipeline is still not open.
 Minerals are not being harvested by US Interests.
 We still have a strategic inte...
 The counter insurgency manual was published
in 2006 and was written under the supervision
of Army Lt. Gen. David Petreau...
 “People who have been maltreated or have had
close friends or relatives killed by the
government, particularly by its se...
 “Twenty counterinsurgents per 1000 residents
is often considered the minimum troop density
required for effective COIN o...
 “Insurgencies are protracted by nature. Thus,
COIN operations always demand considerable
expenditures of time and resour...
 Cost to put one soldier in Afghanistan for one
year= $1,000,000-$1,200,000,00.
 Minimum number of troops required to
co...
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
80000
90000
100000
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Average US Tro...
 There were four high-ranking Generals who
publically took positions on the best strategy in
Afghanistan in the fall of 2...
 President Obama opted to compromise
between the two plans, and institute a slight
surge to roughly 102,000 troops (+33,0...
 Full COIN
 Afghanistan Study Group
 Hayden/Bennis
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
Has the us war in afghanistan made us
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Has the us war in afghanistan made us

880 views

Published on

Published in: News & Politics
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
880
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
20
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Has the us war in afghanistan made us

  1. 1. Will Hopkins NH Peace Action
  2. 2. Democratic process installed in 1964, a Marxist faction, the Peoples Democratic Party of Afghanistan (PDPA) was founded in 1965 and continued to grow and gain in power through to 1978. In 1978, a prominent PDPA member (Akbar Khyber) was killed, PDPA leaders publically accused the government of being responsible. Protests surrounding the dubious conditions of Khyber’s death led to the arrests of the majority of PDPA leaders. Military factions loyal to the PDPA staged a coup in April of 1978 and PDPA took control of the country. As the PDPA attempted to instill state atheism and equal rights for women, religious Afghans began to rebel, with arming, funding, and training provided by the United States whose chief concern at the time was preventing the spread of communism. These forces became known as the Mujahedeen. To attempt to quell the rebellion, PDPA officials requested soviet military re-enforcement. US support of the Mujahedeen skyrocketed and the proxy war against the Soviet Union was engaged.
  3. 3.  Soviet forces withdrew in 1989, leaving behind a great amount of military equipment for use by PDPA.  PDPA and Mujahedeen engaged in civil war from 1989 to 1992, while the US, Saudi Arabia, and Pakistan continued to fund Mujahedeen.  In 1992 with the Soviet Union dissolved a well funded and armed Mujahedeen finally toppled the PDPA, Islamic State of Afghanistan is born.
  4. 4.  Civil war between different factions of the Mujahedeen essentially broke out in 1992, with the Taliban taking control in 1996, but regional violence has continued unabated to the present.
  5. 5.  In the years leading up to September 11, 2001, the Al-Queda network, an international group with anti-western aims conducted training and recruitment all over the middle east. Very few local governments attempted to curb this in any way. The US attacked training camps in Sudan, Somalia, Lebanon, Jordan, and Afghanistan. Al-Queda, a Wahabi group, is strongest and recruits most of it’s members in Saudi Arabia which is also the hub of Wahabism.
  6. 6.  Osama Bin Laden openly supported the Taliban regime, and was thought by some in the intelligence community to be hiding in Afghanistan after 9-11. Seeking Osama Bin Laden to hold him accountable for the 9-11 attacks may have legitimately been a part of the reason we invaded.  However, the Taliban agreed to cooperate and turn over Bin Laden to the US if the US would provide evidence that he was indeed responsible for the attacks.
  7. 7.  Unical (Union Oil/Chevron) was engaged in negotiations with Afghanistan to build a pipeline across Afghanistan opening up 4.7% of the worlds natural gas reserves. Caspian natural gas reserves currently flow at about 4 trillion cubic feet per year. Negotiations broke down in August of 1998. The US had reasonable diplomatic relations with the Taliban up to this point. Bombing campaign began within days.
  8. 8.  Afghanistan holds some of the worlds largest reserves of copper, bauxite, aluminum, iron, cobalt, gold, and lithium. In July the Pentagon announced that a US Geological survey estimated the reserves’ net worth at over 1.4 Trillion dollars.
  9. 9.  Bombing began in 1998.  With the breakdown of diplomatic relations, the US began planning a small scale invasion, India and England both committed troops to a US invasion during the summer BEFORE 9-11. Realistically isn’t the bulk of our invasion a retaliation for 9-11?
  10. 10.  Caspian Pipeline is still not open.  Minerals are not being harvested by US Interests.  We still have a strategic interest in that part of the world.  Taliban have popular support and resources to retake country without our presence.
  11. 11.  The counter insurgency manual was published in 2006 and was written under the supervision of Army Lt. Gen. David Petreaus and Marine Lt. Gen. James Amos.  “Defeating such enemies requires a global, strategic response—one that addresses the array of linked resources and conflicts that sustain these movements while tactically addressing the local grievances that feed them.” Counter Insurgency Manual 1-23 on Al- Queda
  12. 12.  “People who have been maltreated or have had close friends or relatives killed by the government, particularly by its security forces, may strike back at their attackers. Security force abuses and the social upheaval caused by collateral damage from combat can be major escalating factors for insurgencies.” Counter Insurgency Manual 1-45  “An operation that kills five insurgents is counterproductive if collateral damage leads to the recruitment of fifty more insurgents.” 1-141
  13. 13.  “Twenty counterinsurgents per 1000 residents is often considered the minimum troop density required for effective COIN operations” Counter Insurgency Manual 1-67  Population of Afghanistan as of 2010: 28,395,716 CIA World Factbook.  Minimum troop density required for effective COIN operations in Afghanistan: 567,914 combat troops.  Post-surge troop density: 102,000, or roughly 18% of minimum for COIN.
  14. 14.  “Insurgencies are protracted by nature. Thus, COIN operations always demand considerable expenditures of time and resources.” Counter Insurgency Manual 1-134  “Historically, Counter-Insurgency Ops have gone nine or ten years.” –General David Petraeus on Fox News
  15. 15.  Cost to put one soldier in Afghanistan for one year= $1,000,000-$1,200,000,00.  Minimum number of troops required to conduct a counter-insurgency campaign in Afghanistan= 567,914.  Amount of time required 9-10 years.  Total “direct” costs= $5,111,226,000,000.00- $6,814,968,000,000.00
  16. 16. 0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 90000 100000 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Average US Troop Level Coalition Troop Casualties*100
  17. 17.  There were four high-ranking Generals who publically took positions on the best strategy in Afghanistan in the fall of 2009 as President Obama weighed his options.  McChrystal and Petreaus each favored increasing to troop levels more conducive to a counter- insurgency campaign (60-80,000 additional troops to begin) and continuing operations indefinitely.  McCaffery and Eikenberry each leaked or released statements suggesting that without reliable partners in government in Afghanistan, or the resources to successfully conduct a counter- insurgency campaign, the United States and coalition forces should begin withdrawal.
  18. 18.  President Obama opted to compromise between the two plans, and institute a slight surge to roughly 102,000 troops (+33,000); but to begin withdrawal with no firm timeline dependant on “conditions on the ground” beginning in July of 2011.  This compromise between beginning a counter- insurgency campaign, and beginning a withdrawal has thus far been disastrous and has led to substantial increases in civilian casualties, US and coalition casualties, and substantially bolstered the popularity and influence of the Taliban.
  19. 19.  Full COIN  Afghanistan Study Group  Hayden/Bennis

×