F5와 벤더의 제품 성능 비교 자료

1. 경쟁사 비교 :성능
목차

2. BIG-IP 2000s 비교
F5 BIG-IP
2000s
Citrix NetScaler
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
MPX-5550 Cisco 4710-0.5G A10 AX1000
10 GigE Ports (Max) 2 0 0 0
L7 RPS 212,000 175,000 39,000 275,000*
L4 CPS 75,000 N/A 120,000 153,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 5 0.5 0.5 4
SSL TPS (2K key) 2,000 1,500 1,000 1,100
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 4 0.5 0.5 1.2
Compression (Gbps) 2.5 (S/W) 0.5 (SW) 0.5 (SW) N/A
Dual PS and DC option Yes No No No
Power Consumption (typical) Watt
74 300 N/A 155
s
*Overstated (no L7 inspection)
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

3. BIG-IP 2200s 비교
F5 BIG-IP
2200s
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-8200
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
Radware Alteon 52
24 (1 Gbps lic.) Cisco 4710-1G A10 AX1030
10 GigE Ports (Max) 2 2 2 0 0
L7 RPS 425,000 350,000 75,000 39,000 237,000
L4 CPS 150,000 N/A 60,000 120,000 491,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 5 2 1 1 7.5
SSL TPS (2K key) 4,000 2,800 400 1,000 1,100
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 4 2 N/A 1 N/A
Compression (Gbps) 4 (HW) 1.1 (SW) 1 (SW) 1 (SW) N/A
Dual PS and DC option Yes Yes Yes No No
Power Consumption (typical
74 450 N/A N/A 155
) in Watts
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

4. BIG-IP 5000s 비교
F5 BIG-IP
5000s
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-8600
Radware Alteon
5224 – 4Gb
A10
AX 3030
10 GigE Ports (Max) 8 2 2 2
L7 RPS 750,000 800,0001 75,000 800,000
L4 CPS 350,000 N/A 120,000 580,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 15/30 6 4 27
SSL TPS (2K key) 10,000 8,500 400 2,700
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 12 5.5 N/A N/A
Compression (Gbps) 6 (S/W) 3.5 (S/W) 3.2 (S/W)3 N/A (S/W)
Hardware SYN Cookies Yes (20M sps) No No No
L4 Offload Yes No No No
Dual PS and DC option Yes Yes Yes Yes
Power Consumption (typical) Watt
165 450 210 188
s
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
1Overstated (no L7 inspection)
2 Based on F5 2013 ADC Performance Report
3 Additional costs to get maximum performanc
e
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

5. BIG-IP 5200v 비교
F5 BIG-IP
5200v
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-11500
Radware Alteon
5224 – 8Gb
A10
AX 3200-12
10 GigE Ports (Max) 8 4 2 4
L7 RPS 1,500,000 1,200,0001 145,0002 800,000
L4 CPS 700,000 370,0002 484,0002 1,100,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 15/30 8 8 19.5
SSL TPS (2K key) 21,000 15,000 400 2700
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 12 6 N/A N/A
Compression (Gbps) 12 (H/W) 3.5 (S/W) 3.2 (S/W)3 N/A (S/W)
Hardware SYN Cookies Yes (40M sps) No No Yes
L4 Offload Yes No No Yes
Dual PS and DC option Yes Yes Yes Yes
Power Consumption (typical) Watt
165 650 210 313
s
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
1Overstated (no L7 inspection)
2 Based on F5 2013 ADC Performance Report
3 Additional costs to get maximum performanc
e
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

6. BIG-IP 7000s 비교
F5 BIG-IP
7000s
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-11500
Radware Alteon
5224XL – 4Gb
A10
AX 3200-12
List Price $55,995 $55,000 $56,000 $55,000
10 GigE Ports (Max) 8 4 2 4
L7 RPS 800,000 1,200,0001 75,0002 800,000
L4 CPS 390,000 N/A 484,0002 1,100,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 20/40 8 4 19.5
SSL TPS (2K key) 15,000 15,000 11,0003 24,0003
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 18 6 4 N/A
Compression (Gbps) 9 (S/W) 3.5 (S/W) 3.2 (S/W)3 N/A (S/W)
Hardware SYN Cookies Yes (20M sps) No No Yes
L4 Offload Yes No No Yes
Dual PS and DC option Yes Yes Yes Yes
Power Consumption (typical) Watt
200 650 210 313
s
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
1Overstated (no L7 inspection)
2 Based on F5 2013 ADC Performance Report
3 Additional costs to get maximum performanc
e
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

7. BIG-IP 7200v 비교
F5 BIG-IP
7200v
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-13500
Radware Alteon
5224 XL – 12Gb
A10
AX 3000-11
10 GigE Ports (Max) 8 4 2 4
L7 RPS 1,600,000 1,600,0001 290,0002 1,400,0001
L4 CPS 775,000 N/A 484,0002 850,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 20/40 12 12 30
SSL TPS (2K key) 25,000 19,000 11,0003 24,0003
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 18 6.5 4 N/A
Compression (Gbps) 18 (H/W) 4.5 (S/W) 3.2 (S/W)3 N/A (S/W)
Hardware SYN Cookies Yes (40M sps) No No No
L4 Offload Yes No No No
Dual PS and DC option Yes Yes Yes Yes
Power Consumption (typical) Watt
200 650 210 315
s
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
1Overstated (no L7 inspection)
2 Based on F5 2013 ADC Performance Report
3 Additional costs to get maximum performanc
e
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

8. BIG-IP 10000s 비교
F5 BIG-IP
10000s
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-13500
Radware Alteon 52
24XL (14Gbps)
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
A10
AX3000-11
40 GigE Ports (Max) 2 0 0 0
L7 RPS 1,000,000 1,600,0001 290,0002 1,400,0001
L4 CPS 500,000 N/A 480,000 850,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 40/80 12 14 30
SSL TPS (2K key) 21,000 19,000 11,0003 24,0003
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 22 6.5 4.1 N/A
Compression (Gbps) 12 (SW) 4.5 (SW) 3.2 (SW) N/A
Hardware SYN Cookies Yes (40M sps) No N/A No
L4 Offload Yes No No No
Power Consumption (typical) Watt
320 650 210 315
s
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta
1Overstated (no L7 inspection)
2 Based on F5 2013 ADC Performance Report
3 Additional costs to get maximum performanc
e

9. BIG-IP 10200v 비교
F5 BIG-IP
10200v
Citrix NetScaler
MPX-14500
N/A = Data not available
N/S = Feature not supported
Radware Alteon 541
2XL (20Gbps lic.) Cisco ACE30-16G A10 AX3400
40 GigE Ports (Max) 2 0 0
0 (Option thru route
r chassis)
0
L7 RPS 2,000,,000 1,800,000 700,000 200,000 2,000,000
L4 CPS 1,000,000 N/A 340,000 500,000 2,500,000
L7/L4 Tput (Gbps) 40/80 18 20 16 25/38
SSL TPS (2K key) 42,000 23,000 41,000 6,000 24,000
SSL Bulk (Gbps) 22 7 N/A 6 N/A
Compression (Gbps) 24 (HW) 4.5 (SW) 1.5 (SW) 6 (SW) N/A
Hardware SYN Cookies Yes (80M sps) No N/A N/A Yes
L4 Offload Yes No N/A N/A Yes
Power Consumption (typical
320 650 N/A N/A 338
) in Watts
Note: Specs in orange color indicated derived or non-public da
ta

10. 성능 테스트 결과 : L4
L4 CPS L4 Throughput

11. 성능 테스트 결과 : L4
L4 CPS + L4 Throughput

12. 성능 테스트 결과 : L7
L7 RPS L7 Throughput

13. 성능 테스트 결과 : L7
L7 RPS + L7 Throughput

14. 성능 테스트 결과 : SSL
SSL TPS SSL Throughput

15. 성능 테스트 결과 : SSL
SSL TPS + SSL Throughput

16. 성능 테스트 결과 : L7 추가기능 Enable
L7 기능(Persist HTTP Cookie) 사용시 RPS L7기능 (HTTP Compression) 사용시 Throughput