Aero 2010

H
Aero Project 2010
    Design a FAI World Record Setting Electric Powered Radio
                   Controlled Model Airplane



      •Project design requirements, objectives and criteria
      •FAI Requirements and criteria
      •Physics of challenge
      •Design approaches ~ airplane
      •Design approaches ~ propulsion
      •Design trade studies
      •Program Schedule




Current Record; 12 h 36 min 46 sec
Date of flight: 30/07/2008
Project design requirements, objectives and criteria
•   Set World Endurance Record
     –    Recognized by FAI
     –    Just/vastly exceeding current record
•   Other Objectives and Criteria
     –    Use commercial parts;
            • Motors
            • Batteries
            • Propellers
            • Flight controls etc.
     –    Transportable in?
     –    Weather conditions
     –    Location of attempt
     –    Level of autonomy / telemetry
     –    Ease of construction / skill / tools / materials
     –    Durability;
            • Number of flights anticipated
            • Number of attempts (set up and tear down)
     –    Cost
     –    Schedule
     –    ?
Physics of Problem




  Speed   Lift




Thrust                                Drag


           Weight
Physics of Flight
             Induced Drag Di


             Lift L




                                                                                         • Other Vorticity
                                                         Profile Drag = ½ ρ . V2 Sw. CDO
Lift, L = ½ ρ. V2 S. CL. e                               Drag D = Profile Drag + Induced Drag

Ideal Power Required                        L/D
   HP = T x V / 550                                      Flight Speed V plus induced speed vi

                                                                                            Flight Speed V plus induced speed 2vi

                                                      Flight                                                      Fuel
                                                      Speed V
                                                                                                 Horse
                                                                                                                         Weight
                                                           Thrust                                Power
                                                                                                                         of fuel
                                                                 .
                                                  Mass Flow Rate m
                                                                       Propeller               Weight of
                                                                      Disk area A             engine and
                                                                     Efficiency ηp             propeller
       Weight = Structure, controls + L/G
                  Propulsion                                                         .
                                                                     Thrust T = m . 2 vi
                  Fixed Useful Load
                  Fuel                                          Power Required = T . (V+ vi)
                  Payload                                                        550 . ηp
Flight Conditions for Maximum Endurance and Maximum Range
                           at Fixed Weight




                                    ED
                                 UIR
                                R EQ
                                ER
                  MINIMUM




                             POW
                   POWER,
                  MAXIMUM
 Power           ENDURANCE
Required


 Drag




        0
            0
Gliding Flight                   Lift




              Speed


   Rate
Of Descent                               Drag



                is D/L
    Glide Slope




                         Weight
Aerodynamic Trades
Reynolds Number Issues
   with Aspect Ratio
The Endurance Potential for Electric Airplane
Lift, L = ½ ρ. V2 S. CL. e = W

V= √ {W /(½ ρ. S. CL. e)} = K. √ {W/S}

For a given airplane size and aerodynamics;

V = K1 . √W
                                                                      For fixed airplane aerodynamics
V = K1 . √{We + Wb}                                                   the L/D at Vbe is aproximately constant
                                                                      with variation in gross weight*
Power = V . Drag/550 = V . (W/L/D)/550

Drag = W/(L/D) = K. W = K2 . {We + Wb}

So Power = K3 . {We + Wb}1.5

Endurance = K4. {Wb . Kb}/Power                                          Endurance Potential with Battery Fraction

                                                          1.000
Endurance = K5. Wb / {We + Wb}1.5
                                                          0.800
                                              Endurance




Max endurance occurs with Wb = 2 x We                     0.600

                                                          0.400

But What should the size                                  0.200

and weight be?                                            0.000
                                                                  0       0.5            1             1.5           2   2.5
                                                                                    Battery Weight/Weight Empty
Model Design Parameters
                                               FAI REQUIREMENTS
•Wing Area
•Wing Aspect Ratio                             •Max weight 5Kg
•Wing airfoil (flaps?)                         •Max wing + tail surface
•Tail volume                                    area 1.5 sq M
•Control surfaces
•Empty Weight (All Up Weight less Batteries)
•Motor/gearbox/propeller


•Maximum speed
•Maneuver envelope
•Drag enhancement / rate of descent
•Maneuver capability
•Maximum rate of climb
•Minimum rate of climb
•Visible altitude


•Transport dimensions
•Wing construction
•Tail construction
•Fuselage construction
Size and Weight Factors

Aerodynamics (Reynolds Number) Size            Weight (speed)

Wing Loading (power required)

Structural weight ~ Size

Wing aspect ratio ~ aerodynamics        ~ Structural weight

Weather ~ wind capability ? aspect ratio (structure)

Transportability ?

Visibility in thermals ~ size   aspect ratio

Possible answer;
Max size max weight A/R 10;
Wing span 145 in mean chord 14.5 in, w/s 12 oz/sq ft.
Empty weight 58 oz Battery weight 117 oz
L/D max ~ 17
Approximate Performance for Guessed Design Solution
                                                                        Power Required at 70% overall propulsive efficiency
  Possible answer;
  •Max size max weight A/R 10;                                160
  •Wing span 145 in                                           140
  •Mean chord 14.5 in,
                                                              120
  •w/s 12 oz/sq ft.




                                              Power ~ watts
  •Empty weight 58 oz                                         100

  •Battery weight 117 oz                                      80
  •L/D max ~ 17                                               60
                                                              40
                                                              20

Cruise power required ~ 35 watts                               0
                                                                    0       10          20          30          40            50   60
                                                                                               Speed ~ fps
Battery energy using current LiPo
technology at ~ 4.5 watt hours / oz and 116
ounces weight; 520 W hrs.

Approximate endurance ~ 15 hours vice
current record of 12 h 36 min
                                                                           Design Space for optimization
                                                                           •Improved L/D
                                                                           •Improved propulsive efficiency
                                                                           •Reduced wing loading
                                                                           •Increased battery specific energy
Design Space Possible Solutions ~ L/D and W/S
                                                             30
                                                                                      Baseline Guessed Answer




                              Minimu Power Required @ 100%
                                                             25

                                                                                                                          L/D
                                                             20
                                                                                                                                15




                                        efficiency
                                                                                                                                20
                                                             15
                                                                                                                                25
                                                                                                                                30
                                                             10


                                                             5


                                                             0
                                                                  6    7          8          9       10         11   12
                                                                               Wing Loading ~ oz/sq ft.


                                               Airspeed at CL and Wing Loading at CL = 1.0

                 35

                 30

                 25
Airspeed ~ fps




                 20

                 15

                 10

                 5

                 0
                      4       5                                   6    7          8          9       10         11   12
                                                                      Wing Loading ~ oz / sq ft
Comprehensive Performance Math Model
Math Model Validation ~ Motocalc



                                                  Big Stardust / Aveox

                  450.0

                  400.0
                                            Initial Climb to 400 meters (1320 ft or 1/4 mile) in 64 seconds
                  350.0

                  300.0
                                                    Descent from 400 meters 600 seconds (ten minutes)
Altitude Meters




                  250.0
                                                              Second Climb to ensure sufficient battery energy
                                                              for the SAM 90 seconds climb
                  200.0

                  150.0

                  100.0

                   50.0
                                                                     Dive down to end flight
                    0.0
                          0.0   100.0   200.0       300.0        400.0         500.0           600.0      700.0   800.0
                                                            Time seconds
Weight and Balance
     Model                     108 inch Stardust Special Texaco
                                                                                             CG inches            7.31
     Chord                                  11.3                                * from LE      CG %               0.65
     Target CG Location                    7.375                                               Weight             63.2
                                                                                            Wing Loading           7.9
                                                                                            Weight at 8 oz        63.9

                                                               Weight           Location*      Moment                                          Comments
Airframe                                                                                                                                       From LMR
      Fuselage (aveox) pushrods servos                           22               5.5          121.00
      less motor @ 13.5                                         -13.5               0
      Fairings                                                    4                 7
      Wing                                                       15                 4           60.00
      Empenage                                                    3                41          123.00
      L/G                                                         3               2.25          6.75
                               Structure                                                        0.00
                               W heels                                                          0.00
                                                   Airframe Sub total.   33.5
Propulsion Texaco                                                                               0.00
     Motor/ Gearboxes                                             4                -2           -8.00                          Hacker B20-36 with 4.4:1 and 2:1 in series
     Nose Weight                                                 3.5               7            24.50
     Prop                                                         2                -3           -6.00                          Aeronaut 20 x 11
     Spinner                                                                       1            -5.00
     Motor mount                                                                                0.00
                                                                                                             Allowable         14 cells 1500 AUL cells in 2 x 7
     Power Battery                                              15                 7           105.00        Batt W t.   15.80 parallel.
     Propulsion wiring                                           1                 -1           -1.00
     ESC                                                         0                 0            0.00
                                                                 0                 -2           0.00
                                                   Propulsion Sub total. 25.5
Systems                                                                                         0.00                                           From LMR
     Radio Rx                                                    4.2               10           42.00                          FMA M5
                                                                                                0.00                           2 cell LiPoly
                                                                                                0.00
                                                                                                0.00
                                                                                                0.00
                                                                                                0.00                           2 x HS 85?
                                                                                                0.00
                               Servo Mounting                                                   0.00
                                                                                                0.00

                                                   Systems Sub total.    4.2
Ballast                                                          0                 0            0.00
                                                   Total Weight 63.2     63.2                  462.25

                                                                                             CG inches            7.31
                                                                                               CG %               0.65
Weight Trends

1000

Wing Weight ~ grams

                      Two-Piece Wing Trend

                        y = 0.013x1.5011


100
                                                   ``````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````




                                      One-Piece Wing Trend
                                                                       y = 0.0076x1.5482




         10
           100                                     1000                                               10000
                           Wing Area ~ sq inches
Wing Design and Optimization

Design Space

•Aspect Ratio
•Airfoil
•Maneuver envelope
     •Strength
     •Flutter
     •Control authority
•Flutter
•Flight modes
     •Climb
     •Cruise
     •Dive out of thermals
•Construction and materials
     •Experience
     •Tooling
•Transportation
Advanced Wing Design
                                                         The Swiss solar powered aircraft
                                                       'Solar Impulse' (HB-SIA prototype)
                                                        flies for the first time with test pilot
                                                         Markus Scherdel on board at the
                                                              military airport in Payerne,
                                                         Switzerland, Wednesday, April 7,
                                                            2010. The prototype with the
                                                       wingspan of a Boeing 747 and the
                                                         weight of a small car started to a
                                                          two-hour test flight to examine if
                                                            the plane can keep a straight
                                                                       trajectory.




Minimize wing bending moments by distributing propulsion and batteries span-wise
Build and Fly




See how it is done; www.dhaerotech.com/giantblog.htm
1 of 20

Recommended

Fokker100Fokker100
Fokker100Shashank Dathatreya
3.5K views63 slides
5. climb5. climb
5. climbchococrispis37
4.5K views21 slides
8. descent8. descent
8. descentchococrispis37
1.2K views12 slides
7. cruise ii7. cruise ii
7. cruise iichococrispis37
4.6K views26 slides
4. initial climb4. initial climb
4. initial climbchococrispis37
9.9K views26 slides

More Related Content

Recently uploaded(20)

evidence .pptxevidence .pptx
evidence .pptx
npgkddpbpd9 views
My Creative Resume DIAPOS.pptxMy Creative Resume DIAPOS.pptx
My Creative Resume DIAPOS.pptx
BrayanQuispe239 views
StratPlanning Manual 220713.pdfStratPlanning Manual 220713.pdf
StratPlanning Manual 220713.pdf
Lakewalk Media12 views
Anti -Parkinsonian Drugs-Medicinal ChemistryAnti -Parkinsonian Drugs-Medicinal Chemistry
Anti -Parkinsonian Drugs-Medicinal Chemistry
NarminHamaaminHussen9 views
Anti-Cancer Drugs-Medicinal ChemistryAnti-Cancer Drugs-Medicinal Chemistry
Anti-Cancer Drugs-Medicinal Chemistry
NarminHamaaminHussen7 views
Figma Prototype A to Z.pdfFigma Prototype A to Z.pdf
Figma Prototype A to Z.pdf
Atiqur Rahaman15 views
Big Deal Curmel Moton ShirtBig Deal Curmel Moton Shirt
Big Deal Curmel Moton Shirt
brandshop18 views
Task 3.pptxTask 3.pptx
Task 3.pptx
ZaraCooper217 views
Here_Process bookHere_Process book
Here_Process book
nykimstudio15 views
TISFLEET WEB DESIGN PROJECTTISFLEET WEB DESIGN PROJECT
TISFLEET WEB DESIGN PROJECT
Rabius Sany38 views
3 Dark Design Templates3 Dark Design Templates
3 Dark Design Templates
Pixeldarts14 views
Nomor Meja RUANG-4.docNomor Meja RUANG-4.doc
Nomor Meja RUANG-4.doc
ssuserc40b916 views
UX Camp Nov 2023_upload.pptxUX Camp Nov 2023_upload.pptx
UX Camp Nov 2023_upload.pptx
Amir Ansari49 views
Benzodiazepines--Medicinal ChemistryBenzodiazepines--Medicinal Chemistry
Benzodiazepines--Medicinal Chemistry
NarminHamaaminHussen6 views
polarispolaris
polaris
scribddarkened352233 views
SS25 Fashion Key Items trend bookSS25 Fashion Key Items trend book
SS25 Fashion Key Items trend book
Peclers Paris80 views
Task 3 copy.pptxTask 3 copy.pptx
Task 3 copy.pptx
ZaraCooper216 views
Doing Footwear - Footwear FactoryDoing Footwear - Footwear Factory
Doing Footwear - Footwear Factory
Doing Footwear8 views

Featured(20)

How to have difficult conversations How to have difficult conversations
How to have difficult conversations
Rajiv Jayarajah, MAppComm, ACC3.9K views
Introduction to Data ScienceIntroduction to Data Science
Introduction to Data Science
Christy Abraham Joy82.1K views
ChatGPT webinar slidesChatGPT webinar slides
ChatGPT webinar slides
Alireza Esmikhani30.2K views
More than Just Lines on a Map: Best Practices for U.S Bike RoutesMore than Just Lines on a Map: Best Practices for U.S Bike Routes
More than Just Lines on a Map: Best Practices for U.S Bike Routes
Project for Public Spaces & National Center for Biking and Walking6.9K views
Barbie - Brand Strategy PresentationBarbie - Brand Strategy Presentation
Barbie - Brand Strategy Presentation
Erica Santiago25.1K views
9 Tips for a Work-free Vacation9 Tips for a Work-free Vacation
9 Tips for a Work-free Vacation
Weekdone.com7.1K views
I Rock Therefore I Am. 20 Legendary Quotes from PrinceI Rock Therefore I Am. 20 Legendary Quotes from Prince
I Rock Therefore I Am. 20 Legendary Quotes from Prince
Empowered Presentations142.8K views
How to Map Your FutureHow to Map Your Future
How to Map Your Future
SlideShop.com275.1K views

Aero 2010

  • 1. Aero Project 2010 Design a FAI World Record Setting Electric Powered Radio Controlled Model Airplane •Project design requirements, objectives and criteria •FAI Requirements and criteria •Physics of challenge •Design approaches ~ airplane •Design approaches ~ propulsion •Design trade studies •Program Schedule Current Record; 12 h 36 min 46 sec Date of flight: 30/07/2008
  • 2. Project design requirements, objectives and criteria • Set World Endurance Record – Recognized by FAI – Just/vastly exceeding current record • Other Objectives and Criteria – Use commercial parts; • Motors • Batteries • Propellers • Flight controls etc. – Transportable in? – Weather conditions – Location of attempt – Level of autonomy / telemetry – Ease of construction / skill / tools / materials – Durability; • Number of flights anticipated • Number of attempts (set up and tear down) – Cost – Schedule – ?
  • 3. Physics of Problem Speed Lift Thrust Drag Weight
  • 4. Physics of Flight Induced Drag Di Lift L • Other Vorticity Profile Drag = ½ ρ . V2 Sw. CDO Lift, L = ½ ρ. V2 S. CL. e Drag D = Profile Drag + Induced Drag Ideal Power Required L/D HP = T x V / 550 Flight Speed V plus induced speed vi Flight Speed V plus induced speed 2vi Flight Fuel Speed V Horse Weight Thrust Power of fuel . Mass Flow Rate m Propeller Weight of Disk area A engine and Efficiency ηp propeller Weight = Structure, controls + L/G Propulsion . Thrust T = m . 2 vi Fixed Useful Load Fuel Power Required = T . (V+ vi) Payload 550 . ηp
  • 5. Flight Conditions for Maximum Endurance and Maximum Range at Fixed Weight ED UIR R EQ ER MINIMUM POW POWER, MAXIMUM Power ENDURANCE Required Drag 0 0
  • 6. Gliding Flight Lift Speed Rate Of Descent Drag is D/L Glide Slope Weight
  • 8. Reynolds Number Issues with Aspect Ratio
  • 9. The Endurance Potential for Electric Airplane Lift, L = ½ ρ. V2 S. CL. e = W V= √ {W /(½ ρ. S. CL. e)} = K. √ {W/S} For a given airplane size and aerodynamics; V = K1 . √W For fixed airplane aerodynamics V = K1 . √{We + Wb} the L/D at Vbe is aproximately constant with variation in gross weight* Power = V . Drag/550 = V . (W/L/D)/550 Drag = W/(L/D) = K. W = K2 . {We + Wb} So Power = K3 . {We + Wb}1.5 Endurance = K4. {Wb . Kb}/Power Endurance Potential with Battery Fraction 1.000 Endurance = K5. Wb / {We + Wb}1.5 0.800 Endurance Max endurance occurs with Wb = 2 x We 0.600 0.400 But What should the size 0.200 and weight be? 0.000 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 Battery Weight/Weight Empty
  • 10. Model Design Parameters FAI REQUIREMENTS •Wing Area •Wing Aspect Ratio •Max weight 5Kg •Wing airfoil (flaps?) •Max wing + tail surface •Tail volume area 1.5 sq M •Control surfaces •Empty Weight (All Up Weight less Batteries) •Motor/gearbox/propeller •Maximum speed •Maneuver envelope •Drag enhancement / rate of descent •Maneuver capability •Maximum rate of climb •Minimum rate of climb •Visible altitude •Transport dimensions •Wing construction •Tail construction •Fuselage construction
  • 11. Size and Weight Factors Aerodynamics (Reynolds Number) Size Weight (speed) Wing Loading (power required) Structural weight ~ Size Wing aspect ratio ~ aerodynamics ~ Structural weight Weather ~ wind capability ? aspect ratio (structure) Transportability ? Visibility in thermals ~ size aspect ratio Possible answer; Max size max weight A/R 10; Wing span 145 in mean chord 14.5 in, w/s 12 oz/sq ft. Empty weight 58 oz Battery weight 117 oz L/D max ~ 17
  • 12. Approximate Performance for Guessed Design Solution Power Required at 70% overall propulsive efficiency Possible answer; •Max size max weight A/R 10; 160 •Wing span 145 in 140 •Mean chord 14.5 in, 120 •w/s 12 oz/sq ft. Power ~ watts •Empty weight 58 oz 100 •Battery weight 117 oz 80 •L/D max ~ 17 60 40 20 Cruise power required ~ 35 watts 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Speed ~ fps Battery energy using current LiPo technology at ~ 4.5 watt hours / oz and 116 ounces weight; 520 W hrs. Approximate endurance ~ 15 hours vice current record of 12 h 36 min Design Space for optimization •Improved L/D •Improved propulsive efficiency •Reduced wing loading •Increased battery specific energy
  • 13. Design Space Possible Solutions ~ L/D and W/S 30 Baseline Guessed Answer Minimu Power Required @ 100% 25 L/D 20 15 efficiency 20 15 25 30 10 5 0 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Wing Loading ~ oz/sq ft. Airspeed at CL and Wing Loading at CL = 1.0 35 30 25 Airspeed ~ fps 20 15 10 5 0 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Wing Loading ~ oz / sq ft
  • 15. Math Model Validation ~ Motocalc Big Stardust / Aveox 450.0 400.0 Initial Climb to 400 meters (1320 ft or 1/4 mile) in 64 seconds 350.0 300.0 Descent from 400 meters 600 seconds (ten minutes) Altitude Meters 250.0 Second Climb to ensure sufficient battery energy for the SAM 90 seconds climb 200.0 150.0 100.0 50.0 Dive down to end flight 0.0 0.0 100.0 200.0 300.0 400.0 500.0 600.0 700.0 800.0 Time seconds
  • 16. Weight and Balance Model 108 inch Stardust Special Texaco CG inches 7.31 Chord 11.3 * from LE CG % 0.65 Target CG Location 7.375 Weight 63.2 Wing Loading 7.9 Weight at 8 oz 63.9 Weight Location* Moment Comments Airframe From LMR Fuselage (aveox) pushrods servos 22 5.5 121.00 less motor @ 13.5 -13.5 0 Fairings 4 7 Wing 15 4 60.00 Empenage 3 41 123.00 L/G 3 2.25 6.75 Structure 0.00 W heels 0.00 Airframe Sub total. 33.5 Propulsion Texaco 0.00 Motor/ Gearboxes 4 -2 -8.00 Hacker B20-36 with 4.4:1 and 2:1 in series Nose Weight 3.5 7 24.50 Prop 2 -3 -6.00 Aeronaut 20 x 11 Spinner 1 -5.00 Motor mount 0.00 Allowable 14 cells 1500 AUL cells in 2 x 7 Power Battery 15 7 105.00 Batt W t. 15.80 parallel. Propulsion wiring 1 -1 -1.00 ESC 0 0 0.00 0 -2 0.00 Propulsion Sub total. 25.5 Systems 0.00 From LMR Radio Rx 4.2 10 42.00 FMA M5 0.00 2 cell LiPoly 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2 x HS 85? 0.00 Servo Mounting 0.00 0.00 Systems Sub total. 4.2 Ballast 0 0 0.00 Total Weight 63.2 63.2 462.25 CG inches 7.31 CG % 0.65
  • 17. Weight Trends 1000 Wing Weight ~ grams Two-Piece Wing Trend y = 0.013x1.5011 100 `````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````` One-Piece Wing Trend y = 0.0076x1.5482 10 100 1000 10000 Wing Area ~ sq inches
  • 18. Wing Design and Optimization Design Space •Aspect Ratio •Airfoil •Maneuver envelope •Strength •Flutter •Control authority •Flutter •Flight modes •Climb •Cruise •Dive out of thermals •Construction and materials •Experience •Tooling •Transportation
  • 19. Advanced Wing Design The Swiss solar powered aircraft 'Solar Impulse' (HB-SIA prototype) flies for the first time with test pilot Markus Scherdel on board at the military airport in Payerne, Switzerland, Wednesday, April 7, 2010. The prototype with the wingspan of a Boeing 747 and the weight of a small car started to a two-hour test flight to examine if the plane can keep a straight trajectory. Minimize wing bending moments by distributing propulsion and batteries span-wise
  • 20. Build and Fly See how it is done; www.dhaerotech.com/giantblog.htm