Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend                   Model Based        Model Averaging      Applicat...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling                    Testing for Trend        Model Based                            Mod...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling    Testing for Trend   Model Based          Model Averaging   Application   Discussion...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling                                  Testing for Trend                         Model Based...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based            Model Averaging     Application   Discuss...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion    Refe...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend          Model Based      Model Averaging   Application   Discussi...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling                  Testing for Trend                    Model Based                     ...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling                                           Testing for Trend        Model Based        ...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging    Application   Discussion   Refe...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling                  Testing for Trend   Model Based      Model Averaging        Applicati...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling               Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discus...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling                 Testing for Trend   Model Based    Model Averaging   Application   Dis...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Introduction   Testing and Modeling   Testing for Trend   Model Based   Model Averaging   Application   Discussion   Refer...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Dose-Response Modeling of Gene Expression Data in pre-clinical Microarray Experiments

1,135 views

Published on

Dose-Response Modeling of Gene Expression Data in pre-clinical Microarray Experiments. "Dose-Response Modeling of Gene Expression Data in pre-clinical Microarray Experiments".
Presented in Workshop on Multiplicity and Microarray Analysis, Hasselt University, Diepenbeek Belgium on February 19, 2010

Published in: Education
  • Be the first to comment

Dose-Response Modeling of Gene Expression Data in pre-clinical Microarray Experiments

  1. 1. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion References Dose-Response Modeling of Gene Expression Data in pre-clinical Microarray Experiments Setia Pramana Workshop on Multiplicity and Microarray Analysis Diepenbeek, 19 February 2010
  2. 2. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesOutline Introduction Dose-response Studies Dose-response in Microarray Experiments Modeling Dose-response study in Microarray setting Dose-response Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Antipsychotic Study Results Discussion
  3. 3. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDose-response studies The fundamental study in drug developments. Too high dose can result in an unacceptable toxicity profile. Too low dose decreases the chance of it showing effectiveness. Main aim: find dose or range of dose that is: efficacious (for improving or curing the intended disease condition) safe (with acceptable risk of adverse effects)
  4. 4. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDose-response studies Dose-response study investigates the dependence of the response on doses. Is there any dose-response relationship? What doses exhibit a response different from the control? What is the shape of the relationship? Estimates the target dose: minimum effective dose (MED), maximally tolerated dose (MTD) or half maximal effective concentration/dose (EC50), Ruberg,1995.
  5. 5. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDose-response in Microarray Experiments This research focuses on a dose-response study within a microarray setting. Monitoring of gene expression with respect to increasing dose of a compound. 10 9 gene expression 8 7 6 0 0.01 0.04 0.16 0.63 2.5 dose No prior info about the dose-response shape. Genes have different shapes. Many ”noisy” genes hence need for initial filtering.
  6. 6. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesSteps Remove genes that do not show a monotone trend, using the monotonic trend test statistics, i.e., Likelihood Ratio 2 Test (E01 ). Fit several dose-response models in genes with a monotone trend. Estimate the target dose, e.g., EC50 . Apply model averaging.
  7. 7. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesTesting for Trend Dose-response relationship Gene a: increasing monotonic trend Gene b: decreasing monotonic trend 4 5 + * + + 4 3 * gene expression gene expression * * 3 + 2 2 + 1 + * * + * 1 + * 0 0 −1 0 1 10 100 0 1 10 100 dose dose Gene c: non−monotonic trend Gene d: no dose−response relationship + 3 + 1.5 gene expression gene expression + 2 + + + 0.5 + 1 + −0.5 0 0 1 10 100 0 1 10 100 dose dose
  8. 8. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesTesting for Monotonic Trend For gene i (i = 1, · · · , m) with K doses (j = 0, · · · , K ) H0 : µ(d0 ) = µ(d1 ) = · · · = µ(dK ) Up H1 : µ(d0 ) ≤ µ(d1 ) ≤ · · · ≤ µ(dK ) or Down : µ(d ) ≥ µ(d ) ≥ · · · ≥ µ(d ) H1 0 1 K with at least one inequality.
  9. 9. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesTest Statistics for Trend Test Test statistic Formula ˆ 2 ij (yij −µ) − ˆ⋆ 2 ij (yij −µi ) Likelihood Ratio ¯2 E01 = 2 ij (yij −µ) ˆ Test (LRT) K ni Williams t = (ˆ⋆ − y0 )/ µK ¯ 2× i=0 (y − µi )2 /(ni (n − K )) j=1 ij ˆ K ni Marcus t = (ˆ⋆ − µ⋆ )/ µK ˆ0 2× i=0 (y − µi )2 /(ni (n − K )) j=1 ij ˆ K ni M M = (ˆ⋆ − µ⋆ )/ µK ˆ0 i=0 (y − µ⋆ )2 /(n − K ) j=1 ij ˆi K ni Modified M (M’) M ′ = (ˆ⋆ − µ⋆ ) µK ˆ0 i=0 (y − µ⋆ )2 /(n − I) j=1 ij ˆi More detail see Lin et.al 2007. ¯ In this case the LRT E 2 is used. 01
  10. 10. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesModel Based Assumes a functional relationship between the response and the dose, taken as a quantitative factor, according to a pre-specified parametric model. Provides flexibility in investigating the effect of doses not used in the actual study Its result validity depends on the correct choice of the dose response model, which is a priori unknown.
  11. 11. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDose-response Models Model Name Function Linear f (x) = E0 + δx Linear Log-dose f (x) = E0 + βlog(x + c) Exponential f (x) = E0 + E1 (ex /ϑ − 1) Emax −E0 Four parameter logistic f (x) = E0 + 1+exp[(EC −x )/φ] 50 Emax −E0 Five parameter logistic f (x) = E0 + (1+exp[(EC50 −x )/φ])γ x ×(EMax −E0 ) Hyperbolic Emax f (x) = E0 + x +EC50 x N ×(EMax −E0 ) Sigmoidal Emax f (x) = E0 + N x N +EC50 Gompertz f (x) = E0 + (EMax − E0 )e−exp(ϕ(EC50 −x )) Weibull 1 f (x) = E0 + (Emax − E0 )e−exp(b(log(x )−log(EC50))) Weibull 2 f (x) = E0 + (Emax − E0 )(1 − e−exp(b(log(x )−log(EC50))) )
  12. 12. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDose-response Profiles Dose-response profiles for each model 10 Linear Linear Log−dose 3P Exponential 4P Logistic 5P Logistic 10 10 10 10 8 8 8 8 8 gene expression gene expression gene expression gene expression gene expression 6 6 6 6 6 4 4 4 4 4 2 2 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 dose dose dose dose dose Hyperbolic E−max Sigmoid E−max 4P Gompertz Weibull 1 Weibull 2 10 10 10 10 10 8 8 8 8 8 gene expression gene expression gene expression gene expression gene expression 6 6 6 6 6 4 4 4 4 4 2 2 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 0.0 1.5 3.0 dose dose dose dose dose
  13. 13. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesTarget Dose: EC50 The EC50 : dose/concentration which induces a response halfway between the baseline and maximum. E0 + Emax YEC50 = E0 + (1) 2 E0 E max Slope (N) Emax E0 IC50 D ose
  14. 14. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesModel Averaging Combines results from different models. Account for model uncertainty. All fits are taken into consideration. Poor fits receive a small weights. Let θ be a quantity in which we are interested in and we can estimate θ from R models, the model averaged θ is defined as: R ˆ θ= ωi θi , i where θi is the value of θ from model i and ωi the data-driven weights that sum to one assigned to model i.
  15. 15. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesModel Averaging Model averaging uses all (or most) of the candidate models whereas model selection selects the best model (the model with the highest value of ωi ). Akaike’s weights: exp(− 1 ∆AICi ) 2 ωi (AIC) = R 1 (2) i=1 exp(− 2 ∆AICi ) where ∆AICi = AICi − AICmin
  16. 16. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesModel Averaged EC50 The model-averaged EC50 is defined as: R EC 50 = ωi (AIC)EC 50,i , (3) i=1 where ωi : the Akaike’s weight and EC50,i : the EC50 of model i. The estimator for variance of EC 50 is defined as: R 2 var (EC 50 ) = ωi (AIC) var (EC50,i |Mi ) + (EC50,i − EC 50 )2 , i=1 (4) where var (EC50,i |Mi ) is the variance of EC50 in model i.
  17. 17. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesAntipsychotic Study Case study: a study focuses on an antipsychotic compound. 6 dose levels with 4-5 samples at each dose level. Each array consists of 11,565 genes. 10 9 gene expression 8 7 6 0 0.01 0.04 0.16 0.63 2.5 dose
  18. 18. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults 250 genes have a significant monotonic trend (FDR=0.05) using E 2 test statistic with 1000 permutations. Data and isotonic trend of four best genes 1 2 11 + * + * + + * * 10 gene expression gene expression + * + * 10 9 + * + * 8 9 + + 7 * * + * 8 + * 6 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 dose dose 3 4 9.0 + * + + * + + * * * 12 + * gene expression gene expression + * 8.0 + 11 * + * 10 7.0 + * + * 9 + * 6.0 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 dose dose
  19. 19. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults Data and isotonic trend of four other genes 6.7 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 + * gene expression gene expression 6.5 + * + * + 6.3 * + * + + *+ + * * *+ +* + 6.1 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 dose dose 13.35 13.10 gene expression gene expression + + + ++ ** * +* * + * + 13.25 + * 13.00 + * + * + * 13.15 12.90 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 dose dose
  20. 20. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults Number of models that converged and number of times as the best model: Model Number of models Number selected as converge the best model Linear 250 18 Linear log-dose 250 31 Three parm exponential 45 15 Four parm logistic 199 4 Five parm logistic 135 0 Sigmoidal Emax 25 1 Hyperbolic Emax 250 153 Four parm Gompertz 8 0 Weibull 1 213 22 Weibull 2 213 6
  21. 21. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults Data and fitted value for the best gene 10 9 gene expression linear Linear Logdose 8 Hyperbolic Emax Weibull 1 Weibull 2 Averaged Model 7 6 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 dose
  22. 22. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults AIC, EC50 , and Akaike’s weight for the best gene Model AIC EC50 Weight Linear 93.062 1.250 1.027e-14 Linear log-dose 93.062 0.871 1.212e-13 Hyperbolic Emax 29.656 0.039 0.603 Weibull 1 31.709 1.023 0.216 Weibull 2 32.064 1.061 0.181 Model Average - 0.436 -
  23. 23. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults Plot of Confidence Interval of EC50 MAIC50 weibull2 weibull1 Models hipEmax LinLog Lin −0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 EC50
  24. 24. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults Data and fitted value for Gene 2 11.9 Linear Linear Logdose 4 parm Logistic 11.8 5 parm Logistic Hyperbolic Emax Weibull 1 Weibull 2 Averaged Model 11.7 gene expression 11.6 11.5 11.4 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 dose
  25. 25. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesResults AIC, EC50 , and Akaike’s weight for Gene 2 Model AIC EC50 Weight Linear -35.03 1.25 0.021 Linear log-dose -37.06 0.871 0.056 Four parameter logistic -39.61 0.073 0.204 Five parameter logistic -37.81 0.373 0.083 Hyperbolic Emax -39.67 0.095 0.211 Weibull 1 -39.91 1.240 0.236 Weibull 2 -39.44 1.141 0.187 Model Average - 0.706 -
  26. 26. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDiscussion In dose-response modeling in a microarray setting, fitting directly the proposed models to all genes (which can be tens thousands) can create problems, such as complexity and time consumption. We propose a three steps approach: Select the genes with a monotone trend using the LRT (E 2 ) test statistic. Fit the selected genes with the candidate models to estimate the target dose. Average the target dose from the candidate models. Testing for trend Assumes no specific dose-response relationship shape. Filters genes with a non monotonic trend
  27. 27. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesDiscussion Model-based approach: Assumes a functional relationship. Provides flexibility. Model averaging: Accounts for uncertainty. Takes in to account all the proposed models. Genes then can be ranked based on the Model Averaged EC50 Software: IsoGene and IsoGeneGUI packages for testing for trend.
  28. 28. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion ReferencesSelected References Barlow, R.E., Bartholomew, D.J., Bremner, M.J. and Brunk, H.D. (1972) Statistical Inference Under Order Restriction, New York: Wiley. Benjamini, Y. and Hochberg, Y. (1995) Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing, J. R. Statist. Soc. B, 57, 289-300. Lin, Dan, Shkedy, Ziv, Yekutieli, Dani, Burzykowski, Tomasz, ¨ Gohlmann, Hinrich, De Bondt, An, Perera, Tim, Geerts, Tamara and Bijnens, Luc.(2007) Testing for Trends in Dose-Response Microarray Experiments: A Comparison of Several Testing Procedures, Multiplicity and Resampling-Based Inference, Statistical Applications in Genetics and Molecular Biology: Vol. 6 : Iss. 1, Article 26. Pinheiro, J.C. and Bates, D.M. (2000) Mixed Effects Models in S and S-Plus. Springer-Verlag, New York.
  29. 29. Introduction Testing and Modeling Testing for Trend Model Based Model Averaging Application Discussion References Thank You for Your Attention

×