2. Lesson of Keywords Paper needs a centre of gravity There needs to be a well-defined argument—what are you positing and demonstrating? Strong presence of an author Dialogue with other sources—quote sparingly by paraphrase and attribute more Use correct style conventions Read aloud and proofread
3. Creative Analytical Processes Substantive Contribution: Does this piece contribute to our understanding of phenomenon? Aesthetic Merit: Does this piece demonstrate the aesthetic qualities of the form? Is there interpretative space for the reader? Reflexivity: Is the author’s subjectivity both producer and product of the text? Is there a level of self-awareness? Impact: Does the piece impact the reader emotionally and intellectually?
4. Dimensions of the Presentation Give colleagues a sense of the central arguments of the book Relate the theoretical ideas to your own work and obsessions Engage your colleagues in the ideas
