40% of females say they have sent pictures as a joke
52% of teenage girls say they've sent pictures to their boyfriend as a gift </li></ul>
Sexting Laws It is illegal for anyone to knowingly allure or advocate a minor to send a nude or semi-nude photograph of themselves. It is also illegal for anyone to have possession of photographs of minors displaying breasts, buttocks, genitals or minors engaged in sexual acts. Anything that is considered “harmful” to a minor is illegal.
Currently in Ohio, sexting is considered to be a felony. State legislators are considering legislation to minimize sexting charges from a lifetime listing on a sex-offender registry, to a first degree misdemeanor. Legislation passed by Ohio and Vermont would remove serious legal consequences for teenagers that are involved with sexting. The bill would exempt prosecution for 13-18 year olds that willingly send or receive sext messages.
-Girls are only slightly more likely than boys to send nude photographs, but much more likely to suffer from the emotional effects if the images are spread. -Some of the emotional effects include name calling from peers, humiliation, and verbal harassment, which can lead to depression, dropping out of school, cutting, and possibly suicide. -In many cases, adults, parents, and school administrators do not step in, and instead punish the student who was involved in the sexting, which can increase the emotional effects already caused by it. Emotional Effects
Hope Witsell, a 13 year old girl from Beth Shields Middle School in Hillsborough, Florida, hung herself after nude pictures of her were distributed. Toward the end of the school year, Hope sent a nude picture of herself to a boy that she liked and another girl found it on the boy's phone and forwarded it to other students. The picture eventually began circulating around Beth Shields Middle School and surrounding middle and high schools in the area. Hope suffered from humiliation and verbal harassment at school and began cutting herself. Her depression and embarrassment eventually led her to hang herself in her bedroom. Her suicide is the second in the nation associated with sexting. Hope Witsell
Jesse Logan, an 18 year old girl from Cincinnati, Ohio, hung herself after she sent nude photos to her boyfriend. After they broke up, he sent them to other girls at her high school and they began circulating around the school. She suffered from humiliation and was tortured by the other students at her school, and eventually began skipping school so that she wouldn't have to deal with it. She was punished for skipping school, and her depression caused her to hang herself in her bedroom. Jesse Logan was the first case in the nation of suicide caused by sexting. Jesse Logan
What to do? Sexting is a new spin on an old problem. The solutions offered under current laws are extreme and can have life long consequences. Technology has amplified this age old problem with teenagers and now there is more potential to abuse than ever before. Cell Phones and the Internet have facilitated the spreading of information. This advance has had both positive and negative affect on our lives. It has made certain facet easier but exposed us to unforeseen dangers and abuse. The current rules and regulations do not address this age old problem among teenagers. Something must be done to stop and/or limit the harm that sexting can cause.
Option 1: Parents who are suspicious or certain their child is sexting could block the feature through their cell phone provider. Cell phone providers allow you to block picture messaging without blocking text messaging.
Option 1: Parents Restrict Feature to Protect Children Pros Children unable to be access to any inappropriate pictures. Reduces cost of phone bill, smaller data plan from the majority of providers. Cons By removing the option the children lack the opportunity to learn to be responsible. Instead of being able to make the right choice through understanding the consequences of their actions children would be denied the choice and thus the opportunity to learn. The child could feel incompetent or inferior to their peers with the ability to send picture messages. Taken to an extreme, the child could feel not loved or trusted by the parent because of the lack of this privilege. Obviously, Children would not be able to receive any pictures. The common practice coupling of picture messaging and data plan by cellphone providers could render the more advanced features of the cellphone or smartphone inert.
Option 2: Students could learn about the consequences in schools as part of a Sex Education course. Research suggests students informed about consequences are less likely to take part in sexting.
Option 2: Sex Education in School for Students Pros Student will understand the consequences they will receive if caught sexting. Sext education, like sex education, would be a casual discussion lead by trained professionals to share information and tell reported stories of instances where sexting was dangerous. Cons Many schools may feel it is not their responsibility to educate students about technology not permitted in the school. Teens could use the information discussed to their advantage, making it easier to get around the laws.
Option 3: The government could pass laws making sexting a first degree misdemeanor, also establishing a federal standard. This would alert children to the consequences of their actions without having to experience lifelong consequences.
Option 3: Sexting Delegated to 1 st Degree Misdemeanor Rather Than Felony Pros No life long consequences with a 1 st degree misdemeanor, the offense of sexing is not significant enough to merit a felony. (the felony charge comes from it being labeled child pornography) Offenders still have some legal consequences. 1 st degree misdemeanor still send the message that sexting is illegal. But the majority of consequences to the individual would be the social consequences not legal ones. Offenders would not have to register as sex offenders. As the law stands, it could stop individuals from getting a job or college scholarships even years later because a felony stays on the individual's record. Cons Provides a potential loophole for child pornography. Some may argue a 1 st degree misdemeanor is not strong enough a consequence to send a message to potential offenders.
A composite. For younger children, the picture messaging feature should be disabled by parents. The age where children should be allowed to send picture messaging would be the parents discretion. We would suggest around the age of 15 or late middle school/early high school. At this age, education about both the social and legal consequences of sexting would be crucial. It is Informing teens that they need to use this privilege responsible and realize that once a picture is posted online or sent out it is hard to impossible to retract. Another important facet of our solution would be changing sexting laws. Provided that there is not enough material to justify child pornography or trafficking of child pornography and if the offender is a minor and/or has a relationship with the person in the photo the legal consequence should be a 1 st degree misdemeanor. This change still protects children form child pornography but does not cause lifelong consequences for offending minors. This composite solution is not a final solution and amendments and adjustments are encouraged. Ideal Solution
Bibliography Ben. (2009, April 1). Sexting, Harassment, Bullying and Suicide: Is the Solution More Laws? Bullies Be Gone. Retrieved February 25, 2010 from http://www.bulliesbegoneblog.com/2009/04/01/sexting-harassment-bullying-and-suicide-is-the-solution-more-laws/ Celizic, M. (2009, March 6). Her Teen commited suicide over sexting. msnbc Today , Retrieved from http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/29546030/ Davis, S. (2009, January 17). Kid face porn charges over 'sexting.' Ninemsn. Retrieved from http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=719928 Guilfoil, J. (2009, March 12). Sudbury launches probe of sexting. Boston Globe. Retrieved from http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2010/03/12/sudbury_launches_probe_of_sexting Hallenbeck, T. (2009, April 17). 'Sexting' Solution? Burlington FreePress. Retrieved March 2, 2010 from http://www.burlingtonfreepress.com/blog/politics/2009/04/sexting-solution.html
Bibliography Sex a nd Tech: Results from a Survey of Teens and Young Adults. (2008). Retrieved March 3, 2010, from The National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy: http://www.thenationalcampaign.org/search/? Russ, D. (2009, March 9). Ohio to address sexting laws. WKYC , Retrieved from http://www.wkyc.com/news/local/news_article.aspx?storyid=111478&catid=3 Martin, W. (2009). The Real scandal of sexting. Psychology Today , Retrieved from http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/stepmonster/200912/the-real-scandal-sexting Celizic, M. (2009, March 6). Her Teen commited suicide over sexting. msnbc Today , Retrieved from http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/29546030/ Meacham, A. (2009, November 29). Sexting-related bullying cited in hillsborough teen's suicide. Tampa Bay , Retrieved from http://www.tampabay.com/news/humaninterest/article1054895.ece