Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Critical Thinking Unit 2 Guantanamo


Published on

Part of a set of free teaching resources called "Encouraging Critical Thinking Online" by Meriel Patrick of Oxford University, written for the Intute Virtual Training Suite <http: />

Published in: Education, Technology
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Critical Thinking Unit 2 Guantanamo

  1. 1. Encouraging Critical Thinking Online Unit 2 Gauging and Examining Popular Opinion Guantanamo Bay
  2. 2. Guantanamo Bay - Overview • A US detention camp in Cuba • Established to hold suspected terrorists captured in Afghanistan • The Bush administration classed detainees as ‘enemy combatants’, and argued this legitimated holding them without charge or trial
  3. 3. Guantanamo Bay • Find and browse websites that address this issue • Note the range of views you encounter, and the key site(s) for each view • Note how prevalent each view is
  4. 4. Guantanamo Bay - Key Views • The camp should never have existed, and must be closed at once • Closing the camp is desirable, but impractical at present • The camp should be kept open: it serves a useful purpose by containing dangerous men
  5. 5. Guantanamo Bay - Key Sites • International criticism of the camp has been widespread, and allegations of human rights abuses and torture have abounded • The Guardian’s Guantanamo Bay section and a 2006 report from BBC News give an overview
  6. 6. Guantanamo Bay - Key Sites • In January 2009, President Obama signed an order for the camp to be closed within a year • However, the question of what to do with the detainees remains – This Time article outlines some of the difficulties that must be faced
  7. 7. Guantanamo Bay - Key Sites • In May 2009, the US Senate voted to block the transfer of detainees to the US, and denied funding to close the camp • In a June 2009 Gallup poll, a majority of Americans opposed closure and transfer of detainees to the US
  8. 8. Guantanamo Bay - Key Sites • Many older pieces remain online, reflecting different stages in the Guantanamo Bay debate: – USCHO discussion board thread from 2005 – Comments on a US News article from 2008
  9. 9. Guantanamo Bay - Key Sites • Blogs and opinion pieces give a range of views: – Daily Aztec article (anti-closure) – Say Anything blog post (anti-closure?) – Ethical Musings blog post (pro- closure) – Guardian editorial (pro-closure)
  10. 10. Guantanamo Bay – Discussion Questions • Which views are most widespread? – How significant is this? • Are there any discernable patterns in who holds each view? – Among experts and lay people? – In the UK and elsewhere in the world? – Among religious and secular groups?
  11. 11. Guantanamo Bay – Discussion Questions • How representative do you think the views you encountered are of wider society? – What might make people more or less likely to express their views publicly? – What might make them more or less likely to do so online?
  12. 12. Guantanamo Bay – Examining the Sites • Look at some of the websites again, and consider: – How various views are expressed – What techniques sites use to promote their views – What you find persuasive – and why
  13. 13. Guantanamo Bay – Discussion Questions • What techniques are used to promote each view? – Are arguments given? Do they work? – Is evidence presented? Is it convincing? – Are appeals to emotion or shock tactics used? Are these effective?
  14. 14. Guantanamo Bay – Discussion Questions • Do any of the sites examined feature: – Evidence of bias or prejudice? – Ad hominem arguments? – Sweeping generalisations about opponents or opposing views? – Statements you know to be false? • How does this affect your reaction?
  15. 15. Guantanamo Bay – Discussion Questions • What do you personally find persuasive? Why is this? • Was there anything you found off- putting, or that had the opposite effect from that intended by the author? • Did anything cause you to question views you’d held previously?
  16. 16. This slideshow is part of Encouraging Critical Thinking Online, a set of free teaching resources designed to develop students’ analytic abilities, using the Web as source material. For the full set, please visit Intute Training: