Great Debate 4 - Sherlock Holmes Pastiche Books

2,260 views

Published on

Author Luke Kuhns reviews the current state of Sherlock Holmes pastiche books.

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
2,260
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1,596
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Great Debate 4 - Sherlock Holmes Pastiche Books

  1. 1. www.facebook.com/saveundershawPastiche
  2. 2. www.facebook.com/saveundershawShort StoriesPositivesNegatives
  3. 3. www.facebook.com/saveundershawNovels/NovellasPositivesNegatives
  4. 4. www.facebook.com/saveundershawPositivesNew ReadershipDeepens the world created by DoyleFurthers the Holmes/Watson partnershipNegativeSome Poorly written - Not Emulating the VoiceSome Badly researhed - Historical and Canonical Errors
  5. 5. www.facebook.com/saveundershawCrossover & FantasyPositivesNegatives
  6. 6. www.facebook.com/saveundershawPositivesTwists on History/Classic LiteratureFreer Writing StyleNegativesStories Can Be Redundant - too many ofthe same thingSome lack of OriginalityGive Me Doyle or Give Me Death
  7. 7. www.facebook.com/saveundershawSemi-TraditionalPositivesNegatives
  8. 8. www.facebook.com/saveundershawPositivesDeveloping Minor CharactersNegativesOutside the Box
  9. 9. www.facebook.com/saveundershawGraphic Novels
  10. 10. www.facebook.com/saveundershawPositivesGood DesignsCombination of Written work/Visual AidNon-verbal Elements Better RelatedCaptures A Market that Novels May NotNegativesBad DesignUnfamiliar FormatNiche Within Niche

×