Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

The future for the voluntary and community sector


Published on

Presentation by Cathy Pharoah to the Southwark Forum on 23rd June 2011

Published in: Health & Medicine
  • Be the first to comment

The future for the voluntary and community sector

  1. 1. Future for the voluntary and communitysector –funding trends, challenges, opportunities Cathy Pharoah, Co-Director, ESRC CGAP
  2. 2. At threshold of change in sector environment –economic, political, socialEconomic uncertainty/ weak growthCuts in public expenditureFalls in consumer spendingNew focus on the role of the individual/ community –steppingin to provide public goods where governments failLocalism
  3. 3. Changing definitions/ boundaries of sectorRegistered charity sector has doubled in a decade, £24 billion - £52 billionPlus charitable quangos, major cultural institutions which do not report to Charity Commission, but may be major fundraisers, new local trustsNon-registered voluntary associations/ community groupsSocial enterprise sector (eg CCI, IPS, Credit Unions)Tax-exempt entities (universities, Brownies)Housing associationsIndependent SchoolsBig Society?
  4. 4. Tensions - private action, public benefit?Donor preference - ‘impure altruism’ and crowding out theory (eg Andreoni, 1990)Limited evidence of redistributive effects – US research, Clotfelter (1992) and Reich (2005):UK - recent ‘charity deserts’ work (eg Mohan, CGAP)Disadvantaged groups/ causes most dependent on public fundingVoluntary and community organisations in deprived areas most likely to be dependent onpublic fundingVolunteering levels highest in least deprived areasGiving?Can philanthropy fill gaps – social, economic?
  5. 5. Current funding sources – key determinantsPrivateIndividual/ household giving - trends in economic growth, giving cultureMajor giving/ legacies - corporate trends, market values, culture, taxCorporate community investment – static (cash)Charitable trust funds - investment values, legacies, major givingInvestments (markets)Statutory/ earnedStatutory (policy environment)Trading/ enterprise (nature of social markets, non-profit structures)
  6. 6. An example of funding structure £35.5 bn - 63% of registered charities National Trading lottery Corporate subsidiaries 1% giving 3% 6% Legacies Statutory 6% grants and fees Fundraising 36% 6% Voluntary sector 8% Investments 9% Individual fees Individual 9% donations 16% NCVO: Civil Society Almanac 2010
  7. 7. Which Elderly Benevolentfavourite Chest and Heartcauses get Community devt/ Religious (welfare)the biggest regeneration Cancerslice of the Service/ ex-service Health Inf & Research General soc welfarestatutorycake*? Religious (Internl) Arts and culture Hospices/hospitals Envt/ Conservation Children/ youth/ Educn/ professional leisure Disability, deaf, blind, International mental health*Animal welfare and religious missionary causes have disappearedSource: Pharoah, Charity Market Monitor 2011, CaritasData (forthcoming July 2011)
  8. 8. What gets the Community devt/ Benevolent Elderly biggest slice regeneration Youth/ leisure of our giving* Service/ex-service Educn/professional cake? Health Inf/ Research Chest and Heart International Arts and culture General soc welfare Cancer Envt/ Conservation Religious (welfare) Children Animal welfare Disability, deaf, blind, mental health Religious (International) Religious (mission) Hospices/ hospitals*Includes individual, corporate, private trust and legacy giving Pharoah, Charity Market Monitor 2011, CaritasData (forthcoming July 2011)
  9. 9. Current funding trends – the squeezePrivateIndividual/ household giving - contractionMajor giving – poor market information/ market- linked?Legacies – fluctuating in line with marketsCorporate community investment – static (cash)Charitable trust funds – contractionInvestments - contractionStatutory/ earnedStatutory (policy environment) – major public spending cutsTrading/ enterprise – transfers, scale of business operations, fundraising
  10. 10. Cuts, social investment, new marketsStatutory funding cuts - £3 – 4 billion? (over 4 years)Sub-sector diversity - cuts will be highly unevenly experiencedSpecial/ social investment funds - £1 billion (10-year growth,1-2% of sector)Programme Related Investment - £3 million per annum?Current sector borrowing (largely mainstream banks) - £ 3 billion (ish)New markets, opportunity
  11. 11. New (social) finance – some issuesSocial finance space not clearly defined; BSB delaysTransition fund – scale, target?Existing non-profit sector boundaries: private giving and investment voluntary and trading income charitable objectives accounting requirements tax requirements legal requirements legal formsAssessment of capacity - speed, direction, scale of change?
  12. 12. Philanthropy market today (estimated) 1.5 Very wealthy 1.1 Mass affluent* + £1 billion Gift Aid 2.0 Legacies charity tax reclaim 9.9 General public ££ £15.5 billion (ish)*Higher-rate tax-payers onlySources: (McKenzie and Pharoah, Giving 2009 (CAF/NCVO); HMRC Table 10.2, 2009; Legacy Foresight 2009;Sunday Times Rich List, 2008 (what happened to 2009?)
  13. 13. Legacies %43 UK GDP210 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011-1 Charitable legacies-2-3-4-5-6
  14. 14. Philanthropy – some trends, issuesIncreasing dependence on narrower base of donorsIncreasing competition for resourcesLong-term trends?Philanthropic resources – new? redirection of existing?Giving or investing – tensions in culture/ motivationThe new donor – fact or fiction?New technologies/ methods – substitution or new markets?
  15. 15. Innovation, growth – some issuesCharitiesUncertainties and branding challengesLack of market informationInvestment-readiness, speed, feasibilityMarket capacityDistribution - matching the needs and resources of Big SocietyMeasuring impact and returnNew product development – who? where? cost?Who’s shaping the market-place?
  16. 16. Filling funding gaps, shifting direction, reconfiguring?Challenges for existing third sector organisations/ service providersNew entrantsSmall, local and niche providersInfrastructureGrant-makers