Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Performance Bonds - 11 December 2009


Published on

A presentation given on 11 December 2009 on performance bonds on international construction projects.

  • Be the first to comment

Performance Bonds - 11 December 2009

  1. 1. Session 4 WORKSHOP I: Performance Bonds Francis Ho, Senior Associate Energy & Infrastructure Project Development: e-mail: Legal and Commercial Issues for Major Projects Phone: +971 2 652 3426 London, UK Mobile: +971 50 557 0446 11 December 2009
  2. 2. Performance Bonds - Introduction  What is their purpose?  Parties involved: (1) Contractor (Principal) (2) Employer (Beneficiary) (3) Issuer (Surety)  Two main types: (1) Default bonds (2) On demand bonds
  3. 3. (1) Default Bonds - Background  Originated in early 19th Century  Guarantee rather than “true” bond  Requirement to establish Contractor default  Primarily protect against Contractor insolvency  Commonly used on projects in the UK  Mostly issued by insurance and surety companies
  4. 4. Default Bonds – When can Employer draw?  What are circumstances under which Employer entitled to payment?  Employer must usually establish:  Contractor’s liability under Contract  Employer has suffered loss  May require litigation before can claim  Primarily protection against insolvency
  5. 5. (2) On demand Bonds - background  International - originated in 1970s  Means of overcoming legal and language difficulties  Payable on demand so good for employers and risky for contractors (especially as there will be counter-indemnity to Issuer)  Commonly used on international projects and some UK power and oil projects  Usually issued by banks
  6. 6. On demand Bonds – When can Employer draw?  What are circumstances under which Employer entitled to payment?  Payable on first demand  No requirement to establish Contractor default or Employer loss
  7. 7. Default Bonds - How can a call be prevented?  Issuer can put Employer to proof  Issuer’s obligations same as Contractor’s, therefore Issuer’s liability may be released for:  Forbearance given by Employer to Contractor  Material alteration of Contract without Issuer’s consent  Consider including “indulgence” clause to prevent this  Expiry event/date occurs
  8. 8. On demand Bonds - How can a call be prevented?  Very difficult, even if Contractor disputes allegation of non-performance  Fraud  Illegal under governing law in the country of enforcement to allow the call (consider governing law)  Lack of good faith (“unconscionability”) - Singapore  Court order or injunction to restrain Employer from call or Issuer from making payment on receipt  Courts generally reluctant to interfere in contract relations between commercial parties
  9. 9. Drafting and Commercial Considerations (1) For Employers:  If bond to be on demand, make this clear in drafting  Can bond be used to claim liquidated damages?  Does Issuer have satisfactory financial covenant?  Is Issuer based in Employer’s home country? Will help avoid possible legal uncertainties
  10. 10. Drafting and Commercial Considerations (2) For Contractors:  What is cost? Has bond been “priced for”?  If Employer’s main concern is Contractor’s insolvency, will default bond suffice?  Unfair calling insurance and Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees  Clause in Contract to allow Contractor to recover for overpayment under Bond?  Is there longstop date?  Risk of “pay or extend”
  11. 11. Drafting and Commercial Considerations (3) For Issuers:  Is there longstop date?  Counter-indemnity with Contractor  Have they investigated Contractor’s financial position and ability to perform its Contract obligations?