Local Power, Local Control

4,175 views

Published on

A case for distributed renewable energy generation, outlining the economics and political issues and the policies needed to make energy local.

Published in: Technology, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
4,175
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
911
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
31
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Local Power, Local Control

  1. 1. Who  We  Are   Energy Self-Reliant States@  the  Ins)tute  for  Local  Self-­‐Reliance    
  2. 2. Overview  •  Why  renewable  energy?  •  Why  distributed  genera7on?  •  What’s  in  the  way?  •  What  breaks  the  roadblocks?  
  3. 3. Renewable  Energy  is  Widespread   Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  
  4. 4. Renewable  Energy  is  Widespread   Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  
  5. 5. Renewable  Energy  is  Widespread   Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  
  6. 6. Renewable  Energy  is  Cost-­‐Effec7ve  
  7. 7. What  is  distributed  genera7on?  
  8. 8. What  is  distributed  genera7on?   Distribu7on     Any  Size   or  Subtransmission   <  80  MW   Transmission  
  9. 9. Myth  1  •  Distributed  genera7on  does  not  capture   economies  of  scale  
  10. 10. Economies  of  Scale:  Solar  PV   Data  from  70,000  California  solar  PV  installa7ons  Economies  of  Scale  are  Bullshit|  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States-­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/68kaf96  
  11. 11. Economies  of  Scale:  Wind  Economies  of  Scale  are  Bullshit|  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States-­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/68kaf96  
  12. 12. Myth  2  •  Distributed  genera7on  can’t  scale  up  quickly  
  13. 13. Distributed  Genera7on  Scales  Up  
  14. 14. Distributed  Genera7on  Scales  Up   2010:   7,400  MW  of   Solar  PV  
  15. 15. Distributed  Genera7on  Scales  Up  
  16. 16. Distributed  Genera7on  Scales  Up   Total  Capacity:   27,000  MW  
  17. 17. Myth  3  •  Variable  distributed  genera7on  is  expensive  to   integrate  into  the  electric  grid  
  18. 18. Solving  Solar  Variability  with     More  Solar  Solving  Solars  Variability  with  More  Solar  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/65b5nyh  
  19. 19. Solving  Solar  Variability  They  are  seeing  very  li<le  difference  in  the  voltage  levels,  harmonics,  and  overall  power  quality  between  the  different  scenarios.  These  preliminary  results  suggest  that  u)li)es  could  go  to  very  high  levels  of  PV  penetra3on  in  localized  areas  without  causing  problems  for  the  grid.   High  Penetra)on  of  PV  No  Issue  for  Kauian  Grid  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/6a3nnwb  
  20. 20. Opportuni7es  •  Cost  reduc7ons  •  Added  value  •  Economic  benefits  
  21. 21. Opportuni7es  for  Cost  Reduc7ons   German  solar  market  2006  -­‐>  2010  grew  from  2.7  GW  -­‐>  16  GW  
  22. 22. Opportuni7es  for  Cost  Reduc7ons   Solar  PV   <  100  kW   $4.11  per   Wa/!   German  solar  market  2006  -­‐>  2010  grew  from  2.7  GW  -­‐>  16  GW  
  23. 23. Opportuni7es  for  Cost  Reduc7ons   Solar  PV   <  100  kW   $3.70  per   Wa/!   h<p://www.solarwirtscha].de/preisindex  
  24. 24. Opportuni7es  for  Cost  Reduc7ons  
  25. 25. Opportuni7es  for  Cost  Reduc7ons   Solar  PV  Balance  of  System  |  Rocky  Mountain  Ins)tute  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/3dazuo8  
  26. 26. The  Value  of  Distributed  Solar   $5   per  Wa[  Distributed  Solar  Power  Worth  Far  More  Than  Electrons  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/3tqmerh  
  27. 27. The  Value  of  Distributed  Solar  Distributed  Solar  Power  Worth  Far  More  Than  Electrons  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/3tqmerh  
  28. 28. The  Value  of  Distributed  Solar  Distributed  Solar  Power  Worth  Far  More  Than  Electrons  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/3tqmerh  
  29. 29. Value  of  DG  Solar  PV  –  Palo  Alto   CLEAN  Coali)on  Calcula)on  
  30. 30. Jobs  from  Renewable  Energy  Pudng  Renewables  to  Work:  How  Many  Jobs  Can  the  Clean  Energy  Industry  Create?  (UC  Berkeley)  
  31. 31. Absentee  =  lost  opportunity  •  Out  of  two  coun;es   in  Minnesota  we   export  about  $80   million  dollars  a  year   to  France,  Florida,   Italy,  Portugal,  Spain.            -­‐Dan  Juhl,  community   wind  developer  
  32. 32. Value  of  Local  Ownership  NREL: Economic Development Impacts of Community Wind Projects: A Review and Empirical Evaluation
  33. 33. Value  of  Local  Ownership  NREL: Economic Development Impacts of Community Wind Projects: A Review and Empirical Evaluation
  34. 34. Value  of  Local  Ownership  
  35. 35. Value  of  Local  Ownership   Economic  Impact  data  taken  from  Shining  Bright:  Growing  Solar  Jobs  in  Iowa
  36. 36. Distributed  Genera7on  is  Democra7c  
  37. 37. Roadblocks  
  38. 38. FERC’s  High-­‐Voltage  Gravy  Train  
  39. 39. FERC’s  High-­‐Voltage  Gravy  Train  
  40. 40. FERC’s  High-­‐Voltage  Tunnel  Vision   FERCs  High  Voltage  Gravy  Train  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/647brlu  
  41. 41. Policy  Ma[ers  
  42. 42. Policy  Ma[ers  
  43. 43. Policy  Ma[ers  Monthly  cost  of  German  renewable  energy  program  
  44. 44. Policy  Ma[ers  Monthly  cost  of  U.S.  renewable  energy  program  
  45. 45. Policy  Ma[ers   Germany   2009   Germany   2011  From  page  19  of  the  brilliant  report,    Tracking  the  Sun  III:  The  Installed  Cost  of  Photovoltaics  in  the  U.S.  from  1998-­‐2009  (large  pdf).  
  46. 46. Policy  Ma[ers  Ontarios  Buy  Local  Renewable  Energy  Policy:  An  Update  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/3o4th8d  
  47. 47. Policy  Ma[ers:  State  Laws   RPS Policies with Solar/DG ProvisionsWA: double credit for DG www.dsireusa.org / April 2011 NH: 0.3% solar- electric x 2014 OR: 20 MW solar PV x 2020; MI: triple credit for solar- double credit for PV MA: 400 MW PV x 2020 electric NY: 0.4788% customer- sited x 2015 OH: 0.5% solar-NV: 1.5% solar x 2025; CO: 3.0% DG x 2020 electric x 2025 NJ: 5,316 GWh solar-2.4 - 2.45 multiplier for PV 1.5% customer-sited x 2020 electric x 2026 IL: 1.5% PV x 2025 WV: various PA: 0.5% PV x 2021 UT: 2.4 multiplier multipliers for solar-electric DC   DE: 3.5% PV x 2026; MO: 0.3% solar- triple credit for PV AZ: 4.5% DG x 2025 electric x 2021 NC: 0.2% solar MD: 2% PV x 2022 x 2018 NM: 4% solar-electric x 2020 DC: 0.4% solar x 2020 0.6% DG x 2020 TX: double credit for non-wind (non-wind goal: 500 MW) 16 states + Renewable portfolio standard with solar / distributed generation (DG) provision DC have an RPS with solar/DG Renewable portfolio goal with solar / distributed generation provision provisions Solar water heating counts toward solar provision
  48. 48. Policy  Ma[ers:  State  Laws  
  49. 49. A  Small  but  Growing  Market   Photo  credit:  CERTs  
  50. 50. Policy  Ma[ers:  Local  Rules   Poor  Solar  Permidng  Rules  Increase  Residen)al  Solar  Prices     by  Up  To  20  Percent  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/5ts5b2k  
  51. 51. Policy  Ma[ers:  Local  Rules   Poor  Solar  Permidng  Rules  Increase  Residen)al  Solar  Prices     by  Up  To  20  Percent  |  Energy  Self-­‐Reliant  States  -­‐  h<p://)nyurl.com/5ts5b2k  
  52. 52. It’s  Happening  Here   •  80  kilowa[s  PV   •  20  owners   •  Shares:  $3.15  /  Wa[   •  13-­‐year  payback   •  Carbondale,  CO  
  53. 53. Thank  you!  John  Farrell  •  energyselfreliantstates.org  •  jfarrell@ilsr.org  •  h[p://twi[er.com/johnffarrell  

×