The violence of organized forgetting


Published on

Author: Henry A. Giroux
Source Truthout

Published in: News & Politics, Spiritual
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

The violence of organized forgetting

  1. 1. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 1 of 30 (Image: Jared Rodriguez / Truthout) The Violence of Organized Forgetting "People who remember court madness through pain, the pain of the perpetually recurring death of their innocence; people who forget court another kind of madness, the madness of the denial of pain and the hatred of innocence." - James Baldwin Learning to Forget America has become amnesiac - a country in which forms of historical, political, and moral forgetting are not only willfully practiced but celebrated. The United States has degenerated into a social order that is awash in public stupidity and views critical thought as both a liability and a threat. Not only is this obvious in the presence of a celebrity culture that em- braces the banal and idiotic, but also in the prevailing discourses and policies of a range of politicians and anti-public intellectuals who believe that the legacy of the Enlightenment needs to be reversed. Politicians such as Michelle Bach- mann, Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich along with talking heads such as Bill O'Reilly, Glenn Beck and Anne Coulter are not the problem, they are sympto- matic of a much more disturbing assault on critical thought, if not rationale thinking itself. Under a neoliberal regime, the language of authority, power and command is divorced from ethics, social responsibility, critical analysis and social costs. Also See: Henry A. Giroux | Hoodie Politics: Trayvon Martin and Racist Violence in Post-Racial America
  2. 2. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 2 of 30 These anti-public intellectuals are part of a disimagination machine that solidi- fies the power of the rich and the structures of the military-industrial-surveil- lance-academic complex by presenting the ideologies, institutions and relations of the powerful as commonsense.[1] For instance, the historical legacies of resis- tance to racism, militarism, privatization and panoptical surveillance have long been forgotten and made invisible in the current assumption that Americans now live in a democratic, post-racial society. The cheerleaders for neoliberalism work hard to normalize dominant institutions and relations of power through a vocabulary and public pedagogy that create market-driven subjects, modes of consciousness, and ways of understanding the world that promote accommoda- tion, quietism and passivity. Social solidarities are torn apart, furthering the re- treat into orbits of the private that undermine those spaces that nurture non- commodified knowledge, values, critical exchange and civic literacy. The peda- gogy of authoritarianism is alive and well in the United States, and its repres- sion of public memory takes place not only through the screen culture and insti- tutional apparatuses of conformity, but is also reproduced through a culture of fear and a carceral state that imprisons more people than any other country in the world.[2] What many commentators have missed in the ongoing attack on Edward Snowden is not that he uncovered information that made clear how corrupt and intrusive the American government has become - how willing it is to engage in vast crimes against the American public. His real "crime" is that he demonstrated how knowledge can be used to empower people, to get them to think as critically engaged citizens rather than assume that knowledge and edu- cation are merely about the learning of skills - a reductive concept that substi- tutes training for education and reinforces the flight from reason and the goose- stepping reflexes of an authoritarian mindset.[3] To read more articles by Henry A. Giroux and other authors in the Public Intel- lectual Project, click here. Since the late1970s, there has been an intensification in the United States, Cana-
  3. 3. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 3 of 30 da and Europe of neoliberal modes of governance, ideology and policies - a his- torical period in which the foundations for democratic public spheres have been dismantled. Schools, public radio, the media and other critical cultural appara- tuses have been under siege, viewed as dangerous to a market-driven society that considers critical thought, dialogue, and civic engagement a threat to its ba- sic values, ideologies, and structures of power. This was the beginning of an historical era in which the discourse of democracy, public values, and the com- mon good came crashing to the ground. Margaret Thatcher in Britain and soon after Ronald Reagan in the United States - both hard-line advocates of market fundamentalism - announced that there was no such thing as society and that government was the problem not the solution. Democracy and the political process were all but sacrificed to the power of corporations and the emerging financial service industries, just as hope was appropriated as an advertisement for a whitewashed world in which the capacity of culture to critique oppressive social practices was greatly diminished. Large social movements fragmented into isolated pockets of resistance mostly organized around a form of identity politics that largely ignored a much-needed conversation about the attack on the social and the broader issues affecting society such as the growing inequali- ty in wealth, power and income. What is particularly new is the way in which young people have been increas- ingly denied a significant place in an already weakened social contract and the degree to which they are absent from how many countries now define the fu- ture. Youth are no longer the place where society reveals its dreams. Instead, youth are becoming the site of society's nightmares. Within neoliberal narra- tives, youth are mostly defined as a consumer market, a drain on the economy, or stand for trouble.[4] Young people increasingly have become subject to an oppressive disciplinary machine that teaches them to define citizenship through the exchange practices of the market and to follow orders and toe the line in the face of oppressive forms of authority. They are caught in a society in which al- most every aspect of their lives is shaped by the dual forces of the market and a
  4. 4. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 4 of 30 growing police state. The message is clear: Buy/ sell/ or be punished. Mostly out of step, young people, especially poor minorities and low-income whites, are increasingly inscribed within a machinery of dead knowledge, social rela- tions and values in which there is an attempt to render them voiceless and in- visible. How young people are represented betrays a great deal about what is increas- ingly new about the economic, social, cultural and political constitution of American society and its growing disinvestment in young people, the social state and democracy itself.[5] The structures of neoliberal violence have put the vocabulary of democracy on life support, and one consequence is that subjectiv- ity and education are no longer the lifelines of critical forms of individual and social agency. The promises of modernity regarding progress, freedom and hope have not been eliminated; they have been reconfigured, stripped of their emancipatory potential and relegated to the logic of a savage market instrumen- tality. Modernity has reneged on its promise to young people to provide social mobility, stability and collective security. Long-term planning and the institu- tional structures that support them are now relegated to the imperatives of pri- vatization, deregulation, flexibility and short-term profits. Social bonds have given way under the collapse of social protections and the attack on the welfare state. Moreover, all solutions to socially produced problems are now relegated to the mantra of individual solutions.[6] Public problems collapse into the limited and depoliticized register of private issues. Individual interests now trump any consideration of the good of society just as all problems are ultimately laid at the door of the solitary individual, whose fate is shaped by forces far beyond his or her capacity for personal re- sponsibility. Under neoliberalism everyone has to negotiate their fate alone, bearing full responsibility for problems that are often not of their own doing. The implications politically, economically and socially for young people are dis- astrous and are contributing to the emergence of a generation of young people
  5. 5. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 5 of 30 who will occupy a space of social abandonment and terminal exclusion. Job in- security, debt servitude, poverty, incarceration and a growing network of real and symbolic violence have entrapped too many young people in a future that portends zero opportunities and zero hopes. This is a generation that has be- come the new register for disposability, redundancy, and new levels of surveil- lance and control. The severity and consequences of this shift in modernity under neoliberalism among youth is evident in the fact that this is the first generation in which the "plight of the outcast may stretch to embrace a whole generation."[7] Zygmunt Bauman argues that today's youth have been "cast in a condition of liminal drift, with no way of knowing whether it is transitory or permanent."[8] That is, the generation of youth in the early 21st century has no way of grasping if they will ever "be free from the gnawing sense of the transience, indefiniteness, and provisional nature of any settlement."[9] Neoliberal violence produced in part through a massive shift in wealth to the upper 1%, growing inequality, the reign of the financial service industries, the closing down of educational oppor- tunities, and the stripping of social protections from those marginalized by race and class has produced a generation without jobs, an independent life and even the most minimal social benefits. Youth no longer inhabit the privileged space, however compromised, that was offered to previous generations. They now occupy a neoliberal notion of tem- porality of dead time, zones of abandonment and terminal exclusion marked by a loss of faith in progress and a belief in those apocalyptic narratives in which the future appears indeterminate, bleak and insecure. Progressive visions pale and are smashed next to the normalization of market-driven government poli- cies that wipe out pensions, eliminate quality health care, punish unions, demo- nize public servants, raise college tuition, and produce a harsh world of jobless- ness - all the while giving billions and "huge bonuses, instead of prison sen- tences . . . to those bankers and investment brokers who were responsible for
  6. 6. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 6 of 30 the 2008 meltdown of the economy and the loss of homes for millions of Ameri- cans."[10] Students, in particular, now find themselves in a world in which heightened expectations have been replaced by dashed hopes. The promises of higher education and previously enviable credentials have turned into the swindle of fulfillment as, "For the first time in living memory, the whole class of graduates faces a future of crushing debt, and a high probability, almost the cer- tainty, of ad hoc, temporary, insecure and part-time work and unpaid 'trainee' pseudo-jobs deceitfully rebranded as 'practices' - all considerably below the skills they have acquired and eons below the level of their expectations." [11] What has changed about an entire generation of young people includes not only neoliberal society's disinvestment in youth and the lasting fate of down- ward mobility, but also the fact that youth live in a commercially carpet- bombed and commodified environment that is unlike anything experienced by those of previous generations. Nothing has prepared this generation for the in- hospitable and savage new world of commodification, privatization, jobless- ness, frustrated hopes and stillborn projects. [12] Commercials provide the pri- mary content for their dreams, relations to others, identities and sense of agency. There appears to be no space outside the panoptican of commercial bar- barism and casino capitalism. The present generation has been born into a throwaway society of consumers in which both goods and young people are in- creasingly objectified and disposable. Young people now reside in a world in which there are few public spheres or social spaces autonomous from the reach of the market, warfare state, debtfare, and sprawling tentacles of what is omi- nously called the Department of Homeland Security. The structures of neoliberal modernity do more than disinvest in young people and commodify them, they also transform the protected space of childhood into a zone of disciplinary exclusion and cruelty, especially for those young people further marginalized by race and class who now inhabit a social landscape in which they are increasingly disparaged as flawed consumers or pathologized
  7. 7. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 7 of 30 others. With no adequate role to play as consumers, many youth are now con- sidered disposable, forced to inhabit "zones of social abandonment" extending from homeless shelters and bad schools to bulging detention centers and pris- ons.[13] In the midst of the rise of the punishing state, the circuits of state re- pression, surveillance, and disposability increasingly "link the fate of blacks, Latinos, Native Americans, poor whites, and Asian Americans" who are now caught in a governing-through-crime-youth complex, which increasingly serves as a default solution to major social problems.[14] As Michael Hart and Antonio Negri point out, young people live in a society in which every institution be- comes an "inspection regime" - recording, watching, gathering information and storing data.[15] Complementing these regimes is the shadow of the prison, which is no longer separated from society as an institution of total surveillance. Instead, "total surveillance is increasingly the general condition of society as a whole. 'The prison,' " Michel Foucault notes, "begins well before its doors. It be- gins as soon as you leave your house - and even before."[16] Everyone is Now a Potential Terrorist At the start of the second decade of the 21st century, young people all over the world are demonstrating against a variety of issues ranging from economic in- justice and massive inequality to drastic cuts in education and public services. These demonstrations have and currently are being met with state-sanctioned violence and an almost pathological refusal to hear their demands. More specif- ically, in the United States the state monopoly on the use of violence has intensi- fied since the 1980s, and in the process, has been increasingly directed against young people, low-income whites, poor minorities, immigrants, and women. As the welfare state is hollowed out, a culture of compassion is replaced by a culture of violence, cruelty and disposability. Collective insurance policies and social protections have given way to the forces of economic deregulation, the transformation of the welfare state into punitive workfare programs, the priva- tization of public goods and an appeal to individual accountability as a substi-
  8. 8. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 8 of 30 tute for social responsibility. Under the notion that unregulated market-driven values and relations should shape every domain of human life, the business model of governance has evis- cerated any viable notion of social responsibility while furthering the criminal- ization of social problems and cutbacks in basic social services, especially for the poor, young people and the elderly.[17] Within the existing neoliberal his- torical conjuncture, there is a merging of violence and governance and the sys- temic disinvestment in and breakdown of institutions and public spheres that have provided the minimal conditions for democracy. This becomes obvious in the emergence of a surveillance state in which the social media not only become new platforms for the invasion of privacy, but further legitimate a culture in which monitoring functions are viewed as benign while the state-sponsored so- ciety of hyper-fear increasingly defines everyone as either a snitch or a terrorist. Everyone, especially minorities of race and ethnicity, now live under a surveil- lance panoptican in which "living under constant surveillance means living as criminals."[18] As young people make diverse claims on the promise of a radical democracy, articulating what a fair and just world might be, they are increasingly met with forms of physical, ideological and structural violence. Abandoned by the exist- ing political system, young people in Oakland, California, New York City, Que- bec and numerous other cities throughout the globe have placed their bodies on the line, protesting peacefully while trying to produce a new language, politics, imagine long-term institutions, and support notions of "community that mani- fest the values of equality and mutual respect that they see missing in a world that is structured by neoliberal principles."[19] In Quebec, in spite of police vio- lence and threats, thousands of students demonstrated for months against a for- mer right-wing government that wanted to raise tuition and cut social protec- tions. These demonstrations are continuing in a variety of countries throughout the globe and embrace an investment in a new understanding of the commons
  9. 9. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 9 of 30 as a shared space of knowledge, debate, exchange and participation. Such movements, however diverse, are not simply about addressing current in- justices and reclaiming space but also about producing new ideas, generating a new conversation and introducing a new political language. Rejecting the no- tion that democracy and markets are the same, young people are calling for an end to the poverty, grotesque levels of economic inequality, the suppression of dissent and the permanent war state. They refuse to be defined exclusively as consumers rather than as workers, and they reject the notion that the only inter- ests that matter are monetary. They also oppose those market-driven values and practices aimed at both creating radically individualized subjects and un- dermining those public spheres that create bonds of solidarity that reinforce a commitment to the common good. And these movements all refuse the notion that financialization defines the only acceptable definition of exchange, one that is based exclusively on the reductionist notion of buying and selling. Resistance and the Politics of the Historical Conjuncture Marginalized youth, workers, artists and others are raising serious questions about the violence of inequality and the social order that legitimates it. They are calling for a redistribution of wealth and power - not within the old system, but in a new one in which democracy becomes more than a slogan or a legitimation for authoritarianism and state violence. As Stanley Aronowitz and Angela Davis, among others, have argued, the fight for education and justice is insepa- rable from the struggle for economic equality, human dignity and security, and the challenge of developing American institutions along genuinely democratic lines.[20] Today, there is a new focus on public values, the need for broad- based movements for solidarity, and alternative conceptions of politics, democ- racy and justice. All of these issues are important, but what must be addressed in the most im-
  10. 10. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 10 of 30 mediate sense is the threat that the emerging police state in the United States poses not to just the young protesters occupying a number of American cities, but also the threat it poses to democracy itself. This threat is being exacerbated as a result of the merging of a war-like mentality and neoliberal mode of disci- pline and education in which it becomes difficult to reclaim the language of obligation, social responsibility and civic engagement.[21] Everywhere we look we see the encroaching shadow of the police state. The government now requi- sitions the publics' telephone records and sifts through its emails. It labels whis- tle-blowers such as Edward Snowden as traitors, even though they have ex- posed the corruption, lawlessness and host of antidemocratic practices engaged in by established governments. Police can take DNA samples of all people ar- rested of a crime, whether they are proven guilty or not. The United States is incarcerating people in record numbers, imprisoning over 2.3 million inmates while "6 million people at any one time [are] under carceral supervision - more than were in Stalin's Gulag."[22] While there has been considerable coverage in the progressive media given to the violence that was waged against the Occupy movement and other protest- ers, I want to build on these analyses by arguing that it is important to situate such violence within a broader set of categories that enables a critical under- standing of not only the underlying social, economic and political forces at work in such assaults, but also allows us to reflect critically on the distinctive- ness of the current historical period in which they are taking place. For exam- ple, it is difficult to address such state-sponsored violence against young people without analyzing the devolution of the social state and the corresponding rise of the warfare and punishing state. Stuart Hall's reworking of Gramsci's notion of conjuncture is important here be- cause it provides both an opening into the forces shaping a particular historical moment while allowing for a merging of theory and strategy.[23] Conjuncture in this case refers to a period in which different elements of society come to-
  11. 11. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 11 of 30 gether to produce a unique fusion of the economic, social, political, ideological and cultural in a relative settlement that becomes hegemonic in defining reality. That ruptural unity is today marked by a neoliberal conjuncture. In this partic- ular historical moment, the notion of conjuncture helps us to address theoreti- cally how youth protests are largely related to a historically specific neoliberal project that promotes vast inequalities in income and wealth, creates the stu- dent-loan-debt bomb, eliminates much-needed social programs, eviscerates the social wage, and privileges profits and commodities over people. Within the United States especially, the often violent response to nonviolent forms of youth protests must also be analyzed within the framework of a mam- moth military-industrial state and its commitment to war and the militarization of the entire society.[24] The merging of the military-industrial complex, sur- veillance state and unbridled corporate power points to the need for strategies that address what is specific about the current warfare and surveillance state and the neoliberal project and how different interests, modes of power, social relations, public pedagogies and economic configurations come together to shape its politics. Such a conjuncture is invaluable politically in that it provides a theoretical opening for making the practices of the warfare state and the ne- oliberal revolution visible in order "to give the resistance to its onward march, content, focus and a cutting edge."[25] It also points to the conceptual power of making clear that history remains an open horizon that cannot be dismissed through appeals to the end of history or end of ideology.[26] It is precisely through the indeterminate nature of history that resistance becomes possible and politics refuses any guarantees and remains open. I want to argue that the current historical moment or what Stuart Hall calls the "long march of the Neoliberal Revolution,"[27] has to be understood in terms of the growing forms of violence that it deploys and reinforces. Such antidemocra- tic pressures and their relationship to the rising protests of young people in the United States and abroad are evident in the crisis that has emerged through the
  12. 12. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 12 of 30 merging of governance and violence, the growth of the punishing state, and the persistent development of what has been described by Alex Honneth as "a failed sociality."[28] The United States has become addicted to violence, and this dependency is fu- eled increasingly by its willingness to wage war at home and abroad. War in this instance is not merely the outgrowth of polices designed to protect the se- curity and well-being of the United States. It is also, as C. Wright Mills pointed out, part of a "military metaphysics" - a complex of forces that includes corpora- tions, defense industries, politicians, financial institutions and universities.[29] War provides jobs, profits, political payoffs, research funds, and forms of politi- cal and economic power that reach into every aspect of society. War is also one of the nation's most honored virtues, and its militaristic values now bear down on almost every aspect of American life.[30] As modern society is formed against the backdrop of a permanent war zone, a carceral state and hyper-mili- tarism, the social stature of the military and soldiers has risen. As Michael Hardt and Tony Negri have pointed out, "In the United States, rising esteem for the military in uniform corresponds to the growing militarization of the society as a whole. All of this despite repeated revelations of the illegality and immoral- ity of the military's own incarceration systems, from Guantanamo to Abu Ghraib, whose systematic practices border on if not actually constitute torture."[31] The state of exception in the United States, in particular, has be- come permanent and promises no end. War has become a mode of sovereignty and rule, eroding the distinction between war and peace. Increasingly fed by a moral and political hysteria, warlike values produce and endorse shared fears as the primary register of social relations. The war on terror, rebranded under Obama as the "Overseas Contingency Op- eration," has morphed into war on democracy. Everyone is now considered a potential terrorist, providing a rational for both the government and private corporations to spy on anybody, regardless of whether they have committed a
  13. 13. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 13 of 30 crime. Surveillance is supplemented by a growing domestic army of baton- wielding police forces who are now being supplied with the latest military equipment. Military technologies such as Drones, SWAT vehicles and machine- gun-equipped armored trucks once used exclusively in high-intensity war zones such as Iraq and Afghanistan are now being supplied to police depart- ments across the nation and not surprisingly "the increase in such weapons is matched by training local police in war zone tactics and strategies."[32] The do- mestic war against "terrorists" [code for young protesters] provides new oppor- tunities for major defense contractors and corporations who "are becoming more a part of our domestic lives."[33] As Glenn Greenwald points out, "Arm- ing domestic police forces with paramilitary weaponry will ensure their system- atic use even in the absence of a terrorist attack on US soil; they will simply find other, increasingly permissive uses for those weapons."[34] Of course, the new domestic paramilitary forces will also undermine free speech and dissent with the threat of force while simultaneously threatening core civil liberties, rights and civic responsibilities. Given that "by age 23, almost a third of Americans are arrested for a crime," it becomes clear that in the new militarized state young people, especially poor minorities, are viewed as predators, a threat to corporate governance, and are treated as disposable populations.[35] This siege mentality will be reinforced by the merging of private and corporate intelli- gence and surveillance agencies, and the violence it produces will increase as will the growth of a punishment state that acts with impunity. Too much of this violence is reminiscent of the violence used against civil rights demonstrators by the forces of Jim Crow in the 1950s and 1960s.[36] Yet, there is more at work here than the prevalence of armed knowledge and a militarized discourse, there is also the emergence of a militarized society that now organizes itself "for the production of violence."[37] A society in which "the range of acceptable opinion inevitably shrinks."[38] But the prevailing move in American society to a permanent war status does more than promote a set of unifying symbols that embrace a survival of the fittest ethic, promoting
  14. 14. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 14 of 30 conformity over dissent, the strong over the weak, and fear over responsibility, it also gives rise to what David Graeber has called a "language of command" in which violence becomes the most important element of power and mediating force in shaping social relationships.[39] Permanent War and the Public Pedagogy of Hyper-Violence As a mode of public pedagogy, a state of permanent war needs willing subjects to abide by its values, ideology, and narratives of fear and violence. Such legiti- mation is largely provided through a market-driven culture addicted to the pro- duction of consumerism, militarism and organized violence, largely circulated through various registers of popular culture that extend from high fashion and Hollywood movies to the creation of violent video games and music concerts sponsored by the Pentagon. The market-driven spectacle of war demands a cul- ture of conformity, quiet intellectuals and a largely passive republic of con- sumers. There is also a need for subjects who find intense pleasure in commod- ification of violence and a culture of cruelty. Under neoliberalism, culture ap- pears to have largely abandoned its role as a site of critique. Very little appears to escape the infantilizing and moral vacuity of the market. For instance, the ar- chitecture of war and violence is now matched by a barrage of goods parading as fashion. For instance, in light of the recent NSA and PRISM spying revela- tions in the United States, The New York Times ran a story on a new line of fashion with the byline: "Stealth Wear Aims to Make a Tech Statement."[40] As the pleasure principle is unconstrained by a moral compass based on a re- spect for others, it is increasingly shaped by the need for intense excitement and a never-ending flood of heightened sensations. Marked by a virulent notion of hardness and aggressive masculinity, a culture of violence has become com- monplace in a society in which pain, humiliation and abuse are condensed into digestible spectacles endlessly circulated through extreme sports, reality TV, video games, YouTube postings, and proliferating forms of the new and old
  15. 15. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 15 of 30 media. But the ideology of hardness, and the economy of pleasure it justifies are also present in the material relations of power that have intensified since the Reagan presidency, when a shift in government policies first took place and set the stage for the emergence of unchecked torture and state violence under the Bush-Cheney regime. Conservative and liberal politicians alike now spend mil- lions waging wars around the globe, funding the largest military state in the world, providing huge tax benefits to the ultrarich and major corporations, and all the while draining public coffers, increasing the scale of human poverty and misery, and eliminating all viable public spheres - whether they be the social state, public schools, public transportation or any other aspect of a formative culture that addresses the needs of the common good. State violence, particularly the use of torture, abductions, and targeted assassi- nations are now justified as part of a state of exception in which a "political cul- ture of hyper-punitiveness"[41] has become normalized. Revealing itself in a blatant display of unbridled arrogance and power, it is unchecked by any sense of either conscience or morality. How else to explain the right-wing billionaire, Charles Koch, insisting that the best way to help the poor is to get rid of the minimum wage. In response, journalist Rod Bastanmehr points out that "Koch didn't acknowledge the growing gap between the haves and the have-nots, but he did make sure to show off his fun new roll of $100-bill toilet paper, which was a real treat for folks everywhere."[42] It gets worse. Ray Canterbury, a Re- publican member of the West Virginia House of Delegates insisted that "stu- dents could be forced into labor in exchange for food."[43] In other words, stu- dents could clean toilets, do janitorial work or other menial chores in order to pay for their free school breakfast and lunch programs. In Maine, Rep. Bruce Bickford (R) has argued that the state should do away with child labor laws. His rationale speaks for itself. He writes: ""Kids have parents. Let the parents be responsible for the kids. It's not up to the government to regulate everybody's life and lifestyle. Take the government away. Let the parents take care of their kids."[44] This is a version of social Darwinism on steroids, a tribute to Ayn
  16. 16. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 16 of 30 Rand that would make even her blush. Public values are not only under attack in the United States and elsewhere but appear to have become irrelevant just as those spaces that enable an experience of the common good are now the object of disdain by right-wing and liberal politicians, anti-public intellectuals and an army of media pundits. State vio- lence operating under the guise of personal safety and security, while parading as a bulwark of democracy, actually does the opposite and cancels out democ- racy "as the incommensurable sharing of existence that makes the political pos- sible."[45] Symptoms of ethical, political and economic impoverishment are all around us. One recent example can be found in the farm bill passed by Republicans, which provides $195 billion in subsidies for agribusiness, while slashing roughly $4 billion from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). SNAP provides food stamps for the poor. Not only are millions of food stamp benefi- ciaries at risk, but it is estimated that benefits would be eliminated for nearly two millions Americans, many of them children. Katrina vanden Huevel writes in the Washington Post that it is hard to believe that any party would want to publicize such cruel practices. She writes: "In this time of mass unemployment, 47 million Americans rely on food stamps. Nearly one-half are children under 18; nearly 10 percent are impoverished seniors. The recipients are largely white, female and young. The Republican caucus has decided to drop them from the bill as "extraneous," without having separate legislation to sustain them. Who would want to advertise these cruel values? Neoliberal policies have produced proliferating zones of precarity and exclusion embracing more and more individuals and groups who lack jobs, need social assistance, lack health care or are homeless. Accord-
  17. 17. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 17 of 30 ing to the apostles of casino capitalism, providing "nutritional aid to millions of pregnant mothers, infants and children . . . feeding poor children and giving them adequate health care" is a bad expenditure because it creates "a culture of dependency - and that culture of depen- dency, not runaway bankers, somehow caused our economic crisis." [46] But there is more to the culture of cruelty than simply ethically challenged poli- cies that benefit the rich and punish the poor, particularly children, there is also the emergence of a punishing state, a governing through crime youth complex, and the emergence of the school-to-prison pipeline as the new face of Jim Crow.[47] A symptomatic example of the way in which violence has saturated everyday life can be seen in the increased acceptance of criminalizing the behavior of young people in public schools. Behaviors that were normally handled by teachers, guidance counselors and school administrators are now dealt with by the police and the criminal justice system. The consequences have been disas- trous for many young people. Increasingly, poor minority and white youth are being "funneled directly from schools into prison. Instead of schools being a pipeline to opportunity, schools are feeding our prisons. Justified by the war on drugs, the United States is in the midst of a prison binge made obvious by the fact that "Since 1970, the number of people behind bars . . . has increased 600 percent."[48] Moreover, it is estimated that in some cities such as Washington, DC, that 75 percent of young black men can expect to serve time in prison. Michelle Alexander has pointed out that "One in three young African American men is currently under the control of the criminal justice system in prison, in jail, on probation, or on parole - yet mass incarceration tends to be categorized as a criminal justice issue as opposed to a racial justice or civil rights issue (or crisis)."[49]
  18. 18. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 18 of 30 Young black men in American have an identity ascribed to them that is a direct legacy of slavery. They are considered dangerous, expendable, threatening and part of a culture of criminality. They are guilty of criminal behavior not because of the alleged crimes they might commit but because they are the product of a collective imagination paralyzed by the racism of a white supremacist culture they can only view them as a dangerous nightmare, But the real nightmare re- sides in a society that hides behind the mutually informing and poisonous no- tions of colorblindness and a post-racial society, a convenient rhetorical obfus- cation that allows white Americans to ignore the institutional and individual racist ideologies, practices and policies that cripple any viable notion of justice and democracy. As the Trayvon Martin case and verdict made clear, young black men are not only being arrested and channeled into the criminal justice system in record numbers, they are also being targeted by the police, harassed by security forces, and in some instances killed because they are black and as- sumed to be dangerous.[50] Under such circumstances, not only do schools resemble the culture of prisons, but young children are being arrested and subjected to court appearances for behaviors that can only be termed as trivial. How else to explain the case of a diabetic student who, because she fell asleep in study hall, was arrested and beaten by the police or the arrest of a 7-year-old boy, who because of a fight he got into with another boy in the schoolyard, was put in handcuffs and held in custody for 10 hours in a Bronx police station. In Texas, students who miss school are not sent to the principal's office or assigned to detention. Instead, they are fined, and in too many cases, actually jailed. It is hard to imagine, but in a Maryland school, a 13- year old girl was arrested for refusing to say the pledge of allegiance. There is more at work than stupidity and a flight from re- sponsibility on the part of educators, parents and politicians who maintain these laws, there is also the growing sentiment that young people constitute a threat to adults and that the only way to deal with them is to subject them to mind-crushing punishment.
  19. 19. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 19 of 30 This medieval type of punishment inflicts pain on the psyche and the body of young people as part of a public spectacle. Even more disturbing is how the legacy of slavery informs this practice given that "Arrests and police interac- tions . . . disproportionately affect low-income schools with large African- American and Latino populations"[41] Poor minorities live in a new age of Jim Crow, one in which the ravages of segregation, racism, poverty and dashed hopes are amplified by the forces of "privatization, financialization, militariza- tion and criminalization," fashioning a new architecture of punishment, mas- sive human suffering and authoritarianism.[42] Students being miseducated, criminalized and arrested through a form of penal pedagogy in prison-type schools provide a grim reminder of the degree to which the ethos of contain- ment and punishment now creeps into spheres of everyday life that were large- ly immune in the past from this type of state violence. This is not merely bar- barism parading as reform - it is also a blatant indicator of the degree to which sadism and the infatuation with violence have become normalized in a society that seems to take delight in dehumanizing itself. Widespread violence now functions as part of an anti-immune system that turns the economy of genuine pleasure into a mode of sadism that creates the foundation for sapping democracy of any political substance and moral vitality. The predominance of the disimagination machine in American society, along with its machinery of social death and historical amnesia, seeps into in all as- pects of life, suggesting that young people and others marginalized by class, race and ethnicity have been abandoned. But historical and public memory is not merely on the side of domination. As the anthropologist, David Price, points out, historical memory is a potent weapon in fighting against the "desert of organized forgetting" and implies a rethinking of the role that artists, intellectuals, educators, youth and other con- cerned citizens can play in fostering a "reawakening of America's battered pub- lic memories."[53] Against the tyranny of forgetting, educators, young people,
  20. 20. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 20 of 30 social activists, public intellectuals, workers and others can work to make visi- ble and oppose the long legacy and current reality of state violence and the rise of the punishing state. Such a struggle suggests not only reclaiming, for in- stance, education as a public good but also reforming the criminal justice sys- tem and removing the police from schools. In addition, there is a need to em- ploy public memory, critical theory, and other intellectual archives and re- sources to expose the crimes of those market-driven criminogenc regimes of power that now run the commanding institutions of society, with particular em- phasis on how they have transformed the welfare state into a warfare state. The rise of casino capitalism and the punishing state with their vast apparatus- es of real and symbolic violence must be also addressed as part of a broader his- torical and political attack on public values, civic literacy and economic justice. Crucial here is the need to engage how such an attack is aided and abetted by the emergence of a poisonous neoliberal public pedagogy that depoliticizes as much as it entertains and corrupts. State violence cannot be defined simply as a political issue but also as a pedagogical issue that wages violence against the minds, desires, bodies and identities of young people as part of the reconfigura- tion of the social state into the punishing state. At the heart of this transforma- tion is the emergence of a new form of corporate sovereignty, a more intense form of state violence, a ruthless survival-of-the-fittest ethic used to legitimate the concentrated power of the rich, and a concerted effort to punish young peo- ple who are out of step with neoliberal ideology, values and modes of gover- nance. The value of making young people stupid, subject to an educational deficit has enormous currency in a society in which existing relations of power are normal- ized. Under such conditions, those who hold power accountable are reviewed as treasonous while critically engaged young people are denounced as un- American.[54] In any totalitarian society, dissent is viewed as a threat, civic lit- eracy is denounced, and those public spheres that produce engage citizens are
  21. 21. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 21 of 30 dismantled or impoverished through the substitution of training for education. It is important to note that Edward Snowden was labeled as a spy not a whis- tle-blower - even though he exposed the reach of the spy services into the lives of most Americans. More importantly, he was denounced as being part of a generation that unfortunately combined being educated with a distrust of au- thority. Of course, these antidemocratic tendencies represent more than a threat to young people, they also put in peril all of those individuals, groups, public spheres and institutions now considered disposable because that are at odds with a world run by bankers, the financial elite and the rich. Only a well-orga- nized movement of young people, educators, workers, parents, religious groups and other concerned citizens will be capable of changing the power rela- tions and vast economic inequalities that have generated what has become a country in which it is almost impossible to recognize the ideals of a real democ- racy. Conclusion: The rise of the punishing state and the governing-through-crime youth complex throughout American society suggests the need for a politics that not only negates the established order but imagines a new one, one informed by a radi- cal vision in which the future does not imitate the present.[55] In this discourse, critique merges with a sense of realistic hope or what I call educated hope, and individual struggles merge into larger social movements. The challenges that young people are mobilizing against oppressive societies all over the globe are being met with a state-sponsored violence that is about more than police brutal- ity. This is especially clear in the United States, given its transformation from a social state to a warfare state, from a state that once embraced a semblance of the social contract to one that no longer has a language for justice, community and solidarity - a state in which the bonds of fear and commodification have re-
  22. 22. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 22 of 30 placed the bonds of civic responsibility and democratic vision. Until educators, individuals, artists, intellectuals and various social movements address how the metaphysics of casino capitalism, war and violence have taken hold on Ameri- can society (and in other parts of the world) along with the savage social costs they have enacted, the forms of social, political, and economic violence that young people are protesting against, as well as the violence waged in response to their protests, will become impossible to recognize and act on. If the ongoing struggles waged by young people are to matter, demonstrations and protests must give way to more sustainable organizations that develop al- ternative communities, autonomous forms of worker control, collective forms of health care, models of direct democracy and emancipatory modes of educa- tion. Education must become central to any viable notion of politics willing to imagine a life and future outside of casino capitalism. There is a need for edu- cators, young people, artists and other cultural workers to develop an educative politics in which people can address the historical, structural and ideological conditions at the core of the violence being waged by the corporate and repres- sive state and to make clear that government under the dictatorship of market sovereignty and power is no longer responsive to the most basic needs of young people - or most people for that matter. The issue of who gets to define the future, own the nation's wealth, shape the parameters of the social state, control the globe's resources, and create a forma- tive culture for producing engaged and socially responsible citizens is no longer a rhetorical issue, but offers up new categories for defining how matters of rep- resentations, education, economic justice, and politics are to be defined and fought over. At stake here is the need for both a language of critique and possi- bility. A discourse for broad-based political change is crucial for developing a politics that speaks to a future that can provide sustainable jobs, decent health care, quality education and communities of solidarity and support for young people. Such a vision is crucial and relies on ongoing educational and political
  23. 23. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 23 of 30 struggles to awaken the inhabitants of neoliberal societies to their current reali- ty and what it means to be educated not only to think outside of neoliberal com- monsense but also to struggle for those values, hopes, modes of solidarity, pow- er relations and institutions that infuse democracy with a spirit of egalitarian- ism and economic and social justice and make the promise of democracy a goal worth fighting for. For this reason, any collective struggle that matters has to embrace education as the center of politics and the source of an embryonic vi- sion of the good life outside of the imperatives of predatory capitalism. Too many progressives and people on the left are stuck in the discourse of foreclo- sure and cynicism and need to develop what Stuart Hall calls a "sense of poli- tics being educative, of politics changing the way people see things."[56] This is a difficult task, but what we are seeing in cities such as Chicago, Athens and other dead zones of capitalism throughout the world is the beginning of a long struggle for the institutions, values and infrastructures that make critical educa- tion and community the center of a robust, radical democracy. This is a chal- lenge for young people and all those invested in the promise of a democracy that extends not only the meaning of politics, but also a commitment to eco- nomic justice and democratic social change. I take up this issue in Henry A. Giroux, Universities in Chains: Challenging the Military-Industrial-Academic Complex (Boulder: Paradigm, 2007). Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Color- blindness (New York: The New Press, 2010). This issue is taken up brilliantly in Kenneth J. Saltman, The Failure of Corporate School Reform (Boulder: Paradigm, 2013). These themes are taken up in Lawrence Grossberg, Caught In the Crossfire: Kids,
  24. 24. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 24 of 30 Politics, and America's Future, (Boulder: Paradigm Publishers, 2005); Henry A. Giroux, Youth in a Suspect Society (New York: Routledge, 2009). See, for example, Jean and John Comaroff, "Reflections of Youth, from the Past to the Postcolony," Frontiers of Capital: Ethnographic Reflections on The New Econo- my, ed. Melissa S. Fisher and Greg Downey, (Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2006) pp. 267-281. Zygmunt Bauman, Liquid Times: Living in an Age of Uncertainty (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2007), p. 14. Zygmunt Bauman, "Downward mobility is now a reality," The Guardian (May 31, 2012). Bauman develops this theme in detail in both Zygmunt Bauman, On Education, (Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 2012) and Zygmunt Bauman, This Is Not A Diary, (Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 2012). Zygmunt Bauman, Wasted Lives (London: Polity, 2004), p. 76. Rabbi Michael Lerner, "Trayvon Martin: A Jewish Response," Tikkun (July 14, 2013). Zygmunt Bauman, On Education (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2012), p. 47. Ibid., Bauman, On Education, p. 47. I have borrowed the term "zones of social abandonment" from Joäo Biehl, Vita: Life in a Zone of Social Abandonment (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2005); see also Henry A. Giroux, Disposable Youth (New York: Routledge, 2012) and Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow (New York: The Free Press, 2012). [14] Angela Y. Davis, "State of Emergency," in Manning Marable, Keesha Middle-
  25. 25. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 25 of 30 mass, and Ian Steinberg, Eds. Racializing Justice, Disenfranchising Lives (New York: Palgrave, 2007), p. 324. Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Declaration (Argo Navis Author Services, 2012), p. 20. [16] Ibid., Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Declaration, p. 20. [17] See Loic Wacquant, Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecu- rity (Durham,NC: Duke University Press, 2009). [18] John Steppling, "Control & Punish,", (June 22, 2013). [19] Kyle Bella, "Bodies in Alliance: Gender Theorist Judith Butler on the Occupy and SlutWalk Movements," TruthOut (December 15, 2011). Stanley Aronowitz, "The Winter of Our Discontent," Situations IV, no.2 (Spring 2012), pp. 37-76. I take this up in Henry A. Giroux, Education and the Crisis of Public Values (New York: Peter Lang, 2011). [22] Adam Gopnik, "The Caging of America," The New Yorker, (January 30, 2012).
  26. 26. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 26 of 30 Stuart Hall interviewed by James Hay, "Interview with Stuart Hall," Communi- cation and Critical/Cultural Studies 10:1 (2013): 10-33. There are many sources that address this issue, see, in particular, Melvin A. Goodman, National Insecurity: The Cost of American Militarism (San Francisco: City Lights, 2013). [25] Stuart Hall, "The Neo-Liberal Revolution," Cultural Studies, Vol. 25, No. 6, (No- vember 2011), p. 706. [26] Daniel Bell, The End of Ideology: On the Exhaustion of Political Ideas in the Fifties (New York: Free Press, 1966) and the more recent Francis Fukuyama, The End of History and the Last Man (New York: Free Press, 2006) . [27] Stuart Hall, "The March of the Neoliberals," The Guardian, (September 12, 2011) [28] Alex Honneth, Pathologies of Reason (New York: Columbia University Press, 2009), p. 188. C. Wright Mills, The Power Elite (New York: Oxford University Press, 2000), p. 222. See Gore Vidal, Imperial America: Reflections on the United States of Amnesia (New York: Nation Books, 2004); Gore Vidal, Perpetual War for Perpetual Peace (New York: Nation Books, 2002); Chris Hedges, War is a Force that Gives Us Meaning
  27. 27. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 27 of 30 (New York: Anchor Books, 2003); Chalmers Johnson, The Sorrows of Empire: Mil- itarism, Secrecy, and the End of the Republic (New York: Metropolitan Books, 2004); Andrew Bacevich, The New American Militarism (New York: Oxford Uni- versity Press, 2005); Chalmers Johnson, Nemesis: The Last Days of the Republic (New York: Metropolitan Books, Andrew J. Bacevich, Washington Rules: Ameri- ca's Path To Permanent War, (New York, N.Y.: Metropolitan Books, Henry Hold and Company, 2010); Nick Turse, The Complex: How the Military Invades Our Everyday Lives (New York: Metropolitan Books, 2008). Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Declaration (Argo Navis Author Services, 2012), p. 22 [32] Andrew Becker and G.W. Schulz, "Cops Ready for War," RSN, (December 21, 2011). [33] Ibid., Becker and Schulz, "Cops Ready for War." [34] Glenn Greenwald, "The Roots of The UC-Davis Pepper-Spraying," Salon (Nov. 20, 2011). [35] Erica Goode, "Many in U.S. Are Arrested by Age 23, Study Finds," The New York Times, (December 19, 2011) p. A15. [36]
  28. 28. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 28 of 30 Phil Rockstroh, "The Police State Makes Its Move: Retaining One's Humanity in the Face of Tyranny," CommonDreams, (November 15, 2011). [37] Michael Geyer, "The Militarization of Europe, 1914–1945," in The Militarization of the Western World, ed. John R. Gillis (New York: Rutgers University Press, 1989), p. 79. [38] Tony Judt, "The New World Order," The New York Review of Books 11:2 (July 14, 2005), p.17. [39] David Graeber, "Dead Zones of the Imagination," HAU: Journal of Ethnograph- ic Theory 2 (2012), p. 115. Jenna Wortham, "Stealth Wear Aims to Make a Tech Statement," The New York Times (June 29, 2013). [41] Steve Herbert and Elizabeth Brown, "Conceptions of Space and Crime in the Punitive Neoliberal City," Antipode (2006), p. 757. Rod Bastanmehr, "Absurd: Billionaire Koch Brother Claims Eliminating Mini- mum Wage Would help the Poor," AlterNet (July 11, 2013). Hannah Groch-Begley, "Fox Asks if Children Should Work for School Meals," Media Matters (April 25, 2013. Online: [44]
  29. 29. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 29 of 30 Amanda Terkel, "Maine GOP Legislators Looking To Loosen Child Labor Laws," Huffington Post, (March 30, 2011). [45] Pascale-Anne Brault and Michael Naas, "Translators Note," in Jean-Luc Nancy, The Truth of Democracy, (New York, NY: Fordham University Press, 2010), pp. ix. Paul Krugman, "From the Mouths of Babes," The New York Times (May 30, 2013), Online: Ibid., Michelle Alexander. Jody Sokolower, "Schools and the New Jim Crow: An Interview With Michelle Alexander," Truthout, (June 4, 2013). Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Color- blindness (New York: The New Press, 2010), p. 9. For a particularly egregious and offensive defense of this racist stereotype, see Richard Cohen, "Racism versus Reality," Washington Post (July 16, 2013). Online: [51] Smartypants, "A Failure of Imagination," Smartypants Blog Spot (March 3, 2010). Online: Don Hazen, "The 4 Plagues: Getting a Handle on the Coming Apocalypse," Al- ternet, (June 4, 2013). David Price, "Memory's Half-life: A Social History of Wiretaps," Counterpunch
  30. 30. 7/23/13 10:50 PMThe Violence of Organized Forgetting Page 30 of 30 20:6 (June 2013), p. 14. I take up this issue in detail in Henry A. Giroux, The Educational Deficit and the War on Youth (New York: Monthly Review Press, 2013). [55] John Van Houdt, "The Crisis of Negation: An Interview with Alain Badiou," Continent, 1.4 (2011): 234-238. [56] Zoe Williams, "The Saturday Interview: Stuart Hall," The Guardian (February 11, 2012).