SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
Veiled Pain A research in NL into the psychological, social and relational consequences of FGM 06 February 2010 Erick Vloeberghs
 
Reasons & Research questions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Introduction ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Psychological consequences :  -  which complaints (psychopathology?) - when & where (incl.scharniermomenten) - level & length of impediments / complaints Social consequences  :  -  immediate surroundings (friends, acquaintances) - in social sphere (at work, school, public area) Relational consequences  :  -  family relations (incl. family in country of origine) - sexual relations (incl. psychosexual consequences) Coping When; in what areas; why? With what means and coping mechanisms (how)? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],= reciprocal relation (conform holistic point of view) = affecting relation Framework
Quantitative  results ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Predictors  After  multiple regressionanalysis: Predictors of PTSS-complaints : The variables memory (good), country of origine (except when from Somalia), coping (misuse of drugs) and type of mutilation (infibulation)    Predicors of anxiety & depression : The variables coping (avoidance and misuse of drugs), country of origine (except when from Somalia), type of mutilation (infibulation) and not having a job. Country of origine. In order from more to less complaints: a.   Ptss: Soedan, Ethiopia, Sierra, Somalia, Eritrea b.   Depression/anxiety: Soedan, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sierra, Somalia
Qualitative results I ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Som 1: A consequence of FGM is that we have many health problems.  Like me for example.  During menstruation, childbirth and when we have sex.  That is emotionally hard. In those periods, I feel temporarily disabled and I can not take care properly for my family. I must leave the care to others. And of course that is not what I want.  On top of that you do not know what it is to enjoy [Ms looks sad.]  Citation
Soe 8: He seemed to push against a wall. That place had been sewn closed my whole life. He never fits in, I thought. I thought I died at first sex, I was so tense and nervous until he was ready ... My husband insisted on having sex with me, while because of my circumcision no matchstick would go in easily. I begged him to go to the doctor to open it up. I went to the doctor - I had made an appointment with him for the operation. My husband finally came along and heard the explanations of the doctor. Once we were out of the room he said that nothing of that was going to happen, no surgery. Citation
Qualitative results  II ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Sie 12: If you're genitally mutilated you have less sex because you do not really enjoy it as much as a woman that did not undergo the ritual.  In my case I know that my misery is caused by circumcision. And it really has a major impact on my life. The stress ... and I also get angry quickly. Because the  m utilation I have no pleasure at all while an uncircumcised woman does not need to bother about that…  Sometimes I respond strongly to my partner. I get angry and quick for nothing. If someone has pain, or if something is bothering you, then that person can sometimes become aggressive. I have that occasionally. My relationship suffers from the fact I’m mutilated. I would be happy if it stops. Citation
Citation When asked to this respondent whether FGM has influence on the relation with her husband, she answers: Eri 8: Yes. I hear many complaints from men about their wives. They say that women do not have sexual feelings or simply don’t want to have sex. And that makes the relationship difficult. There is dissatisfaction; men have sex with other women and ultimately divorce may result.
Qualitative results III ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Sie 6: I just try not to think about what the mutilation and other painfull things because I have many problems, including relationship problems. But when I think about these things, I find the way to God. I listen to even more gospel songs and read the Bible. My faith helps me a lot ... Citation
Conclusions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Theme Riskfactor Question Answer 1) Circumcision Type   Type 1, 2, 3 of 4? Type 2 but especially type 3   Memory of that moment    Can you remember your circumcision good? I remenber my circumcisiom very well 2) Social economic situation and  acculturation Level of education     What is your highest attained level of education? Low education   Age at  migration   How old were you when you migrated to The Netherlands? When I was already somewhat older   Information     Did you receive information about FGM (awareness raising) Yes   Job     Do you have a job or follow a course / study No, I’m not working neither paid nor voluntary   Language capacity   Can you express yourself well in Dutch? No, my knowledge of Dutch is rather bad 3) Coping Seeking support     Do you talk with others about your problems, and does it help you? Sometimes I talk about it with others but it does not help me much.    Avoidance     Do you often feel excluded (receptive) or keep distance to others (actively)? Yes, both; active as well as receptive   Misuse of drugs Do you often use drugs to feel better? Yes, that happens quite often. 4) Relational Partner     In what way your partner deal with the sexual constraints and pain? He has little patience and act egocentric   Stepmother and daughter     Does your partner choose for his mothers’ wish when it comes down to performing the ritual on his own daughter? The wish of his mother is more important for him.
Som 8: I am a religious woman and I do not want the doctor to look at my genitals look. And I also don’t want to explain. I have no need in doing that... I try to go on with my life despite the infections. Simply by working hard. Interviewer: Did you ever had contact with Dutch healthcare? Som 8: No, never. I never go to the doctor if I have an infection. I dont want to show my genitals and tell him what is wrong. Interviewer: Would a female doctor do better? Will she be able to help you? Som: Maybe so. With a female doctor I may dare to speak about my complaints. After all it is a woman and she understands me better, I think.   Citation
Recommendations general ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Recommendations for caregivers ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Themes Panel discussion ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

Anxiety disorder psych
Anxiety disorder  psychAnxiety disorder  psych
Anxiety disorder psychAnxious_Andie1
 
Lgbtqi health care experiences in rural settings
Lgbtqi health care experiences in rural settingsLgbtqi health care experiences in rural settings
Lgbtqi health care experiences in rural settingsAndrea Quintana, PA-C
 
SHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy Schiffman
SHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy SchiffmanSHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy Schiffman
SHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy Schiffmanbkling
 
Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012
Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012
Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012LuiFer Tirado
 
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case StudyAbnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Studyuniprint
 
Naturaltreatmentforadult adhd
Naturaltreatmentforadult adhdNaturaltreatmentforadult adhd
Naturaltreatmentforadult adhdkidneystones
 
Practical aspects of risk assessment in self harm
Practical aspects of risk assessment in self harmPractical aspects of risk assessment in self harm
Practical aspects of risk assessment in self harmYasir Hameed
 

What's hot (19)

Anxiety disorder psych
Anxiety disorder  psychAnxiety disorder  psych
Anxiety disorder psych
 
Sfbt with self harm
Sfbt with self harmSfbt with self harm
Sfbt with self harm
 
Boundaries and relationships
Boundaries and relationshipsBoundaries and relationships
Boundaries and relationships
 
Lgbtqi health care experiences in rural settings
Lgbtqi health care experiences in rural settingsLgbtqi health care experiences in rural settings
Lgbtqi health care experiences in rural settings
 
Families: Courage - Resilience - Transformation
Families: Courage - Resilience - Transformation Families: Courage - Resilience - Transformation
Families: Courage - Resilience - Transformation
 
Creating sustainable family programs
Creating sustainable family programsCreating sustainable family programs
Creating sustainable family programs
 
Finding Joy
Finding JoyFinding Joy
Finding Joy
 
SHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy Schiffman
SHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy SchiffmanSHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy Schiffman
SHARE Presentation: Sexuality and Intimacy after Cancer with Dr. Mindy Schiffman
 
Hw lesson 41b
Hw lesson 41bHw lesson 41b
Hw lesson 41b
 
Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012
Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012
Foster care youth resource sheet may 2012
 
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case StudyAbnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
Abnormal Psychology (Psychiatric history) Case Study
 
State Of U V1
State Of U V1State Of U V1
State Of U V1
 
Exploring Anxiety & Depression in Gen Z
Exploring Anxiety & Depression in Gen ZExploring Anxiety & Depression in Gen Z
Exploring Anxiety & Depression in Gen Z
 
How i met anxiety at age 7
How i met anxiety at age 7How i met anxiety at age 7
How i met anxiety at age 7
 
Naturaltreatmentforadult adhd
Naturaltreatmentforadult adhdNaturaltreatmentforadult adhd
Naturaltreatmentforadult adhd
 
Sexual Counselling/ Role Play
Sexual Counselling/ Role PlaySexual Counselling/ Role Play
Sexual Counselling/ Role Play
 
CIS London
CIS LondonCIS London
CIS London
 
Discovering joy and gratitude
Discovering joy and gratitudeDiscovering joy and gratitude
Discovering joy and gratitude
 
Practical aspects of risk assessment in self harm
Practical aspects of risk assessment in self harmPractical aspects of risk assessment in self harm
Practical aspects of risk assessment in self harm
 

Viewers also liked

Struktur dan fungsi jaringan
Struktur dan fungsi jaringanStruktur dan fungsi jaringan
Struktur dan fungsi jaringanmamadila
 
Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013
Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013
Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013Maureen Scullin
 
2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...
2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...
2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...dlvr.it
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Fake journalism
Fake journalismFake journalism
Fake journalism
 
Struktur dan fungsi jaringan
Struktur dan fungsi jaringanStruktur dan fungsi jaringan
Struktur dan fungsi jaringan
 
Biscuit
BiscuitBiscuit
Biscuit
 
News A 30 2014
News A 30 2014News A 30 2014
News A 30 2014
 
Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013
Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013
Lighten Up 4 Life Press release April 2013
 
2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...
2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...
2 Minutes to Facebook Advertising Success. A Resource for SMBs (Includes Case...
 

Similar to Veiled Pain

Ptsd in the inner city
Ptsd in the inner cityPtsd in the inner city
Ptsd in the inner cityM Stevens
 
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are sayingCBRC
 
Question #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docx
Question #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docxQuestion #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docx
Question #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docxsimonlbentley59018
 
Relationships Part 2
Relationships Part 2Relationships Part 2
Relationships Part 2macca60
 
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docx
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docxDepartment of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docx
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docxsalmonpybus
 
Tragedy and Coping
Tragedy and CopingTragedy and Coping
Tragedy and Copingeph-hr
 
I NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docx
I NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docxI NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docx
I NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docxflorriezhamphrey3065
 
Professional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal Experience
Professional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal ExperienceProfessional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal Experience
Professional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal Experiencerahulkelowna
 
Ipc lesson plan 11 sex
Ipc lesson plan 11   sexIpc lesson plan 11   sex
Ipc lesson plan 11 sexrich136
 
P I A S C Y G R O U P D I S C U S S I O N A B O U T A B S T A I N A N C E...
P I A S C Y  G R O U P  D I S C U S S I O N  A B O U T  A B S T A I N A N C E...P I A S C Y  G R O U P  D I S C U S S I O N  A B O U T  A B S T A I N A N C E...
P I A S C Y G R O U P D I S C U S S I O N A B O U T A B S T A I N A N C E...Mukalele Rogers
 
Piascy group discussion about abstainance
Piascy group discussion about abstainancePiascy group discussion about abstainance
Piascy group discussion about abstainanceMukalele Rogers
 
Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...
Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...
Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...LIDC
 
Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19
Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19
Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19sojan47
 
Module 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptx
Module 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptxModule 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptx
Module 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptxShashankPrabalclass1
 

Similar to Veiled Pain (16)

11a bolte san antoniofinal2010bolte
11a bolte san antoniofinal2010bolte11a bolte san antoniofinal2010bolte
11a bolte san antoniofinal2010bolte
 
Ptsd in the inner city
Ptsd in the inner cityPtsd in the inner city
Ptsd in the inner city
 
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
1045 1 what new sero-converters in toronto are saying
 
Question #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docx
Question #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docxQuestion #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docx
Question #1 Please choose ONE of the following to make an origi.docx
 
Relationships Part 2
Relationships Part 2Relationships Part 2
Relationships Part 2
 
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docx
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docxDepartment of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docx
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral SciencesUniversity o.docx
 
3.5.2 Toni Delany
3.5.2 Toni Delany3.5.2 Toni Delany
3.5.2 Toni Delany
 
Tragedy and Coping
Tragedy and CopingTragedy and Coping
Tragedy and Coping
 
I NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docx
I NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docxI NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docx
I NEED THIS DONE TODAY!!!!Please no plagiarism and make sure you.docx
 
Professional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal Experience
Professional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal ExperienceProfessional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal Experience
Professional and Personal Attributes. Worldviews and Personal Experience
 
Ipc lesson plan 11 sex
Ipc lesson plan 11   sexIpc lesson plan 11   sex
Ipc lesson plan 11 sex
 
P I A S C Y G R O U P D I S C U S S I O N A B O U T A B S T A I N A N C E...
P I A S C Y  G R O U P  D I S C U S S I O N  A B O U T  A B S T A I N A N C E...P I A S C Y  G R O U P  D I S C U S S I O N  A B O U T  A B S T A I N A N C E...
P I A S C Y G R O U P D I S C U S S I O N A B O U T A B S T A I N A N C E...
 
Piascy group discussion about abstainance
Piascy group discussion about abstainancePiascy group discussion about abstainance
Piascy group discussion about abstainance
 
Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...
Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...
Engendering Migrant Health: An Embodied Approach, Dr Denise Spitzer, Universi...
 
Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19
Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19
Dealing with post traumatic experience during covid 19
 
Module 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptx
Module 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptxModule 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptx
Module 10-Injuries and Violence for.pptx
 

Veiled Pain

  • 1. Veiled Pain A research in NL into the psychological, social and relational consequences of FGM 06 February 2010 Erick Vloeberghs
  • 2.  
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.  
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Predictors After multiple regressionanalysis: Predictors of PTSS-complaints : The variables memory (good), country of origine (except when from Somalia), coping (misuse of drugs) and type of mutilation (infibulation)   Predicors of anxiety & depression : The variables coping (avoidance and misuse of drugs), country of origine (except when from Somalia), type of mutilation (infibulation) and not having a job. Country of origine. In order from more to less complaints: a.   Ptss: Soedan, Ethiopia, Sierra, Somalia, Eritrea b.   Depression/anxiety: Soedan, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Sierra, Somalia
  • 9.
  • 10. Som 1: A consequence of FGM is that we have many health problems. Like me for example. During menstruation, childbirth and when we have sex. That is emotionally hard. In those periods, I feel temporarily disabled and I can not take care properly for my family. I must leave the care to others. And of course that is not what I want. On top of that you do not know what it is to enjoy [Ms looks sad.] Citation
  • 11. Soe 8: He seemed to push against a wall. That place had been sewn closed my whole life. He never fits in, I thought. I thought I died at first sex, I was so tense and nervous until he was ready ... My husband insisted on having sex with me, while because of my circumcision no matchstick would go in easily. I begged him to go to the doctor to open it up. I went to the doctor - I had made an appointment with him for the operation. My husband finally came along and heard the explanations of the doctor. Once we were out of the room he said that nothing of that was going to happen, no surgery. Citation
  • 12.
  • 13. Sie 12: If you're genitally mutilated you have less sex because you do not really enjoy it as much as a woman that did not undergo the ritual. In my case I know that my misery is caused by circumcision. And it really has a major impact on my life. The stress ... and I also get angry quickly. Because the m utilation I have no pleasure at all while an uncircumcised woman does not need to bother about that… Sometimes I respond strongly to my partner. I get angry and quick for nothing. If someone has pain, or if something is bothering you, then that person can sometimes become aggressive. I have that occasionally. My relationship suffers from the fact I’m mutilated. I would be happy if it stops. Citation
  • 14. Citation When asked to this respondent whether FGM has influence on the relation with her husband, she answers: Eri 8: Yes. I hear many complaints from men about their wives. They say that women do not have sexual feelings or simply don’t want to have sex. And that makes the relationship difficult. There is dissatisfaction; men have sex with other women and ultimately divorce may result.
  • 15.
  • 16. Sie 6: I just try not to think about what the mutilation and other painfull things because I have many problems, including relationship problems. But when I think about these things, I find the way to God. I listen to even more gospel songs and read the Bible. My faith helps me a lot ... Citation
  • 17.
  • 18. Theme Riskfactor Question Answer 1) Circumcision Type   Type 1, 2, 3 of 4? Type 2 but especially type 3   Memory of that moment   Can you remember your circumcision good? I remenber my circumcisiom very well 2) Social economic situation and acculturation Level of education     What is your highest attained level of education? Low education   Age at migration   How old were you when you migrated to The Netherlands? When I was already somewhat older   Information     Did you receive information about FGM (awareness raising) Yes   Job     Do you have a job or follow a course / study No, I’m not working neither paid nor voluntary   Language capacity   Can you express yourself well in Dutch? No, my knowledge of Dutch is rather bad 3) Coping Seeking support     Do you talk with others about your problems, and does it help you? Sometimes I talk about it with others but it does not help me much.   Avoidance     Do you often feel excluded (receptive) or keep distance to others (actively)? Yes, both; active as well as receptive   Misuse of drugs Do you often use drugs to feel better? Yes, that happens quite often. 4) Relational Partner     In what way your partner deal with the sexual constraints and pain? He has little patience and act egocentric   Stepmother and daughter     Does your partner choose for his mothers’ wish when it comes down to performing the ritual on his own daughter? The wish of his mother is more important for him.
  • 19. Som 8: I am a religious woman and I do not want the doctor to look at my genitals look. And I also don’t want to explain. I have no need in doing that... I try to go on with my life despite the infections. Simply by working hard. Interviewer: Did you ever had contact with Dutch healthcare? Som 8: No, never. I never go to the doctor if I have an infection. I dont want to show my genitals and tell him what is wrong. Interviewer: Would a female doctor do better? Will she be able to help you? Som: Maybe so. With a female doctor I may dare to speak about my complaints. After all it is a woman and she understands me better, I think. Citation
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.