SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 102
Download to read offline
ENGAGEMENT


VS


INTERRUPTION"
Why am I doing this?!
Itʼs an important debate, but also a complex one.!

Itʼs a lot easier to go along with jargon and sound-bites than
interrogate the data, the essays and the facts.!

It seems that a lot of people are doing the former.!

And so Iʼve tried to make it a bit more lighthearted and bite-
sized.!

Itʼs not perfect, but hopefully it helps having a proper look at
all this a little bit easier.!
Me!
Iʼve spent half my career in agencies that primarily
deal in “engagement”!

                                      And in making this
                                       thing, Iʼve also
                                         plundered
                                      enormously from
                                      Martin Weigel, Ed
                                       Booty and Bob
                                         Hoffman..!



                                      Iʼve spent half my career in agencies that primarily
                                      deal in “interruption”!



                   Iʼm trying to be fair from the start…!
Both interruption and engagement are confusing
words.!

Couldnʼt both be interruptive?!

Couldnʼt both be engaging?!

Whatʼs the meaningful distinction?!
Socrates said…!
the beginning of
wisdom is the
                          PRETTY
definition of terms
                         SMART



                         FOR A

                      FOOTBALLER
Engagement marketing is a marketing
                                           strategy that directly engages consumers
                                           and invites and encourages consumer to
                                           participate in the evolution of a brand.
Advertising, in its purest form, is just   Rather than looking at consumers as
getting attention !                        passive receivers of messages,
                                           engagement marketers believe that
Alex Bogusky
                              consumers should be actively involved in
                                           the production and co-creation of
                                           marketing programs, developing a
                                           relationship with the brand.





                                           Frederic	
  P	
  Miller,	
  Agnes	
  F	
  Vandome,	
  John	
  McBrewster	
  
                                           h9p://books.google.nl/books?id=__1fYgEACAAJ&hl=nl&sitesec=reviews	
  
The difference!
Interruption: !       Engagement:!

Marketing that        Marketing that
communicates to its   communicates to its
audience via          audience via
projecting a          something that people
message to people.!   participate with.!
The definition!
Interruption: !     Engagement:!

Marketing that is   Marketing that is
fundamentally       fundamentally
one-way!            two-way!
Big brands need to communicate to significant
numbers of people in order to grow.!

This is a comparison of communication.!

Iʼm not talking about improving the product, or
the necessary conversion or service tools like
websites, or shops.!

Iʼm just asking:!
Which is a more effective means for big brands
to market to significant numbers of people?!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference?!

Which is more effective?!

Why?!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference?!

Which is more effective?!

Why?!
Sometimes, the people who believe in two-way marketing
can come across as a bit self-righteous!

“Interruption marketing is doomed as a mass communication tool”!

“Everyone wants a conversation. They want inspiration. Inspire people with your
website. Donʼt just interrupt, but interact. Asking about Return on Investment is the
wrong question today. You should be asking about Return on Involvement”!

“Many people in traditional marketing roles and organizations may not realize
theyʼre operating within a dead paradigm”!

“Interruption Marketing leaves a bad taste in the mouths of your target audience”!

“And spending millions feels good. Seeing your billboard downtown, or your
commercial on television seems like a strategic win. At least youʼre doing
something, right?”!



                                                  Sources are sometimes in the appendix!
But we all have the same end!
Making a business richer.!

Brands are not altruistic champions of the people. !
They are businesses.!
Whether you impact people with a one-way
message, or a two-way idea, itʼs not, primarily, for
the benefit of people.!

Itʼs about creating something that steals into
human attention / action for the benefit a brand*!




              *Thatʼs not necessarily evil, although it often is – but thatʼs for another debate!
Marketing is always about interrupting
people with ideas!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective?!

Why?!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective?!

Why?!
Yes. Itʼs a whipping boy.!


But in terms of a two-way marketing replacing one-way marketing,
PEPSI refresh is a robust example:!



    BIG BRAND!                  +!      $20m SPEND!

2009: Pepsi spend the $20m on one-way Superbowl ads !

2010: Pepsi spend the $20m on a two-way campaign and actually
GAVE THE MONEY AWAY TO GOOD CAUSES. !
It didnʼt work.!   TheW StreetJournal reported that Pepsi-Cola and Diet Pepsi had each
                          a!
                   lost about 5% of their market share in the past year. $

                   For the Pepsi-Cola brand alone this represents a loss of over $350 million. $

                   For both brands, the loss is probably something in the neighborhood of
                   400 million to half-a-billion dollars.$

                   For the first time ever Pepsi-Cola has dropped from its traditional
                   position as the number two soft drink inAmerica to number three
                   (behind Diet Coke.)$

                   In 2010, Pepsi's market share erosion accelerated by 8 times compared to
                   the previous year.$


                               Source: Wall Street Journal andAdcontrarian – see appendix!
80+ million votes registered; almost 3.5 million "likes" on
the Pepsi Facebook page; and almost 60,000 Twitter
followers arenʼt enough.!

These numbers arenʼt that big really…!

3.5 million fans arenʼt so relevant when your competitor
serves Americans 335 million drinks every day.!




                                                   Source: See appendix!
A few killer stats…!

Of 200 brands studied, Ehrenberg-Bass have shown that
on average less than 0.5% of Facebook fans engage with
the brand they are fans of. Only 10% of brands manage to
get over the 1% of fans engaging mark.!

80% of branded apps get less than 1,000 downloads, and
most have barely any active users.!

50% of click-throughs on online ads come from the same
6% of people, who tend to come from low income groups.!



                                              Sources: See appendix!
Sure there have been a few
awards.


But the transformational
effectiveness case studies for
two-way campaigns are
conspicuously lacking.!
There are too many of these instead*!




*This is lazy, and naughty. More on this later."
Time to face facts!

TWO-WAY MARKETING



ANYWHERE NEAR
AS AMAZINGLY AS
IT SAID IT WOULD
It is of course also true that people are also pre-
disposed to reject one-way marketing.!

And indeed, they do. !

Dave Trott tells us that of the £18.3 billion spent on
advertising in the UK last year, 89% is not even
noticed or remembered. 7% is remembered
negatively, leaving 4% to be remembered positively.!

Looking at some of the work, Steve Henryʼs
anecdote that the average return on a UK advertising
pound is 56p seems plausible.!
But the recent success stories are
there for all to, robustly, see!

Hovis – 2010 IPA Grand Prix!
Chrysler – 2012 Grand Effie!
Johnnie Walker – 2008 IPA Grand Prix!

The list goes on… Audi, Old Spice, Bravia,
Compare the Meerkat (Go Compare, even), O2,
Ovaltine…!
250 Case Studies from the last 7 years:

Traditional “one-way” fares pretty well Vs.
“two-way”!




                              Putting the models to the test: IPAdataMINE 2011!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective? One-way. Often.!

Why?!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective? One-way. Often.!

Why?!
Think about it…!
I can remember watching a
football match at University.!

When the ad break came on,
the Cadburyʼs Gorilla advert
started to play. People actually
“shussshed” other people. !

The bar was quieter than at
any other point in the
afternoon. !

People watched with real
anticipation, genuinely
entertained – made happy
even. Some remarked upon
how good it was, and then they
went on with their day. !

That was the moment I
decided I might be ok with
working for brands. !
To be fair, thereʼs also a lot of this!
But there are, undeniably, these!
Iʼve never seen someone (normal) talk
about a two-way idea in the pub!
Whatʼs going on
here?!
1. People donʼt care. 


Especially about brands. 


One-way marketing doesnʼt rely on
them caring much. 

Two-way marketing does.!
Anyone who has ever
contemplated getting a
much-loved picture framed,
or going to a colleague-
that-we-actually-got-on-
well-withʼs leaving drinks
on Tuesday night, knows
this. !

We can barely be bothered
to engage in two-way
behaviour with most things
we like and most people
we know. !
Only 17% of people in the UK are
“intensely” participating with anything online !
Shouldnʼt we consider relationships with brands…!




…as scaled back a thousand times from even this?!
Ehrenberg-Bass have shown, across 145 brands
and 13 categories: !


Just 20% of a brandʼs customers hold about 40%
of the image associations. !


The rest of knowledge about the brand is spread

hazily across the other   80%. !
                           Source: Ehrenberg Bass / Martin Weigel – see appendix!
For that 80%, who make or break a business, brands
largely exist as a low-involvement processing
function, that allow us to make easy, safe choices
without the burden of “engaged” thought or activity. !




They are more likely to function as a well-
remembered red berry on a bush than a good friend. !

A light guarantee of reliability and general
favourability, not a deep or meaningful connection. !
Most of us are polygamously promiscuous with virtually every
brand we ever buy. !

Why?!

Because not caring is a natural, human way of relating to a brand. !
In short, success for most
brands is largely dependent
upon people who would
probably find the thought of
participating in two-way
communication with that
brand quite horrible.!
Which feels pretty instinctively spot on!
Think about all the brands that you interact with,
even buy and use, every day. !

When was the last time you wanted to engage in
any two-way interaction with any of them?*!



*It doesnʼt count if you had to do it for your job.   !
This kind of thing is starting to look a
little bit shaky…!
Are there any exceptions? Maybe…!




                              Thanks, Sell Sell!
Nike have done amazingly well to build up
audiences on things like Facebook, and now
spend less pushing out content through paid
media !
But at its biggest and best, itʼs still light, one-way
style communication in a slightly two-way channel!

                                      *Yes, I know people have
                                      to seek this stuff out, and
                                      they do like it and share it."

                                      But you have to wonder…"

                                      How many people
                                      explored the tunnels,
                                      compared to the tens of
                                      millions that watched the
                                      film?"
Nike are actually quite similar to most brands:

They donʼt benefit to any extraordinary degree from loyal
customers!




        Source: Professor Dawes, UK SPORTSWEAR MARKET 2009, TNS Superpanel Via Martin Weigel – see appendix!
Because not even most                   Back of fag packet
customers of the ultimate high          Nike calculations!
interest brand are all queuing up
to engage at a deep level. !
                                           Sell 200,000,000 shoes alone per
I love football, and running. I have       year!
Nike football boots, and running
                                           Nike + has less than 5,000,000
shoes. !                                   active users.!

I have watched their films on TV            It seems unlikely that deep two-way
                                           communications are driving all of
and online, and enjoyed them.!             their success!!
                                           In fact, it seems unlikely that it is
I have never deeply engaged with           driving the majority of it.!
Nike though. !
                                           *Iʼm not saying current one-way
                                           communication is either – 30 years of
Iʼd argue that the majority of their       great branding, sponsorship,
customers still fall into that camp.!      advertising and distribution and some
                                           two-way marketing are, probably"
Can push two-way a lot
   The real point is that a
                                                              further than brands like
   rare brand like this:!
                                                              this:!




Almost NO brands are like this!   AlmostALLbrands are like this!
As usual,
Sell Sell hit
the nail on
the head… !
After consulting the facts, and consulting our
instincts, does it not appear that most people,
quite reasonably, donʼt care very much at all
about most brands?!

Therefore, does it not appear that most people
could well be largely pre-disposed to reject most
two-way marketing with most brands?!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective? One-way. Often.!

Why? !
1. Most people donʼt want two-way with most brands!
2. Two-way marketing often seems
focused on what some people can
do.


Not what all people actually do do.


Which is doodoo.!
Where the heads of the
 new marketing gurus
        are…!




                    Where the behaviours
                    of actual people are… !




                                              Stolen from Ed Booty!
All of advertising is not all of people!
A lot of one-way related media still has majority reach!

 1981!                                                                                                              2011!
 Average Brit watches 4 hours of TV a day. !                          Average Brit watches 4 hours of TV a day. !

 Favourite British show is a soap. !                                  Favourite British show is a soap. !

 Favourite British news source is The Sun.!                           Favourite British news source is The Sun.!

 Americans get most of the video they watch                           Americans get 98% of the video they watch
 via TV!                                                              via TV!

 Americans with TVs watch almost all of their                         Americans watch almost all of their TV live,
 TV live!                                                             only 7% of total viewing is “timeshifted”!

 Americans sometimes make a sandwich                                  Americans with TiVo skip 11.2% more ads.
 while the ads are on!                                                But thatʼs only 1.2 and 5.6% of total ads*!

 Americans donʼt even know what                                       Americans do 5% of their total purchasing
 Ecommerce is!                                                        online!
                                       *Americans also still eat sandwiches, possibly more – Other less funny footnotes in the appendix"
A lot of two-way related media is still niche!

   Non-majority take-up!                                     Not working for marketing!
                                                        OR
   INTERACTIVE TV!                                           FACEBOOK

   Only 5% in the UK have bought it, and less than           Almost nobody interacts with brands on
   50% of them have bothered to connect it – that            Facebook!
   leaves almost nobody to even collect data from
   regarding interaction with brands!
                                                             APPS!
   SMARTPHONES!                                              Almost nobody downloads branded apps, or
   Even in the US, only 38% of people have the               uses them more than once!
   Android or iOS phones that can offer good two-way
   experiences!
                                                             ONLINE!
   TABLETS !                                                 Click-throughs are dominated by relatively
   11% of people in the UK have them!                        small numbers of generally less affluent
                                                             people. Itʼs rare that large numbers go to
   THE NON-FACEBOOK SIDE OF SOCIAL!                          micro-sites or campaign pages.!
   No other network has close to 50% of people on it!
                                                             QR!
                                                             Do we really need to go there?!
                                                                                           Sources: See appendix!
Success for brands comes from
growing with the many, not with the
few!




              Source: Charles Graham 2010, TNS Superpanel Via Martin Weigel – see appendix!
Two-way also targets the interested minority who
are likely to buy your product anyway !
Whilst one-way can impact the disinterested
majority who deliver growth !

  SALES!                 Pantene:!
                         Sales split by Customer Frequency!


               Most sales come from the
                most infrequent buyers!




                                                                         FREQUENCY!




                        Source: Professor Dawes, 2009, TNS Superpanel Via Martin Weigel see appendix!
Which explains why two-way communications
didnʼt work for Pepsi Refresh…





It failed to impact the disinterested majority who
make up the majority of Cola sales!
                                         Source: ByronSharp,HowBrandsGrow!
Even great online
products and services that
“engage” people in deep
two-way behaviour every
day are using one-way
marketing to drive growth
via penetration!
If weʼre being harsh…!
One-way!                 Two-way!

Uses mass media!         Uses niche media!

to!                      to!

Give you a shot at       Reward small numbers
growing sales with the   of loyalists for what they
majority!                were already doing!
Social media, the internet and technology has changed things for people.!

But that doesnʼt mean that lots of things havenʼt stayed the same too.!

And that certainly doesnʼt mean that the way brands can market to
significant numbers of people has changed overnight.!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective? One-way. Often.!

Why? !
1. Most people donʼt want two-way with most brands!
2. One-way can reach and impact the majority!
3. One-way communication has
been practicing making realistic
pitches to large numbers of people
who donʼt care about brands for
years!
Maybe two-way marketing is often
struggling because people thought that
it could play by different rules?


It began with a reversal of how weʼd
always thought about marketing.


God knows, weʼve all heard it…!
The world has changed. Everything is dead.
The smart people are engaging consumers
with co-creative content that allows them to
share because people are in control of media
which is always on like them and brands
have to move all the time and never sleep and
your handwash product is not a product it is
a perpetual quantum service that the people
want to participate in via transmedia like
everything else and everything has changed.!
The gurus who still espouse this make
it all sound so easy…!



             "...become social
              thru Pinterest ..."
            all of a sudden you
           become a magnet for
                 whatʼs hot!”"



                           Go to the appendix if you donʼt believe me!
And then all of a sudden youʼve
spunked a load of money on this…!
Or this…!
Or this…!
Or, 

youʼre just
continually
filling the
world with
drivel like
this…!
Surely thinking that people will
ever want to do stuff with brands
will always be a very self-involved,
very unrealistic, very lazy and very
arrogant thing for marketers to
think.!
At its best, one-way marketing understands that it makes a
play for attention-lite from a position of enormous
disadvantage.!

It sets out to throw something out to people that is good
enough to overcome the odds so steeply stacked against
it. !

At its best, it remembers that its primary mission, if it is to
have any chance of making any impact, is to win the
precious and rightfully reluctant attention of people by
offering them something incredibly distinctive, beautiful,
interesting, funny, poignant, or all of these things.!

Without asking for something back. !
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective? One-way. Mostly.!

Why? !
1.  Most people donʼt want two-way with most brands!
2.  One-way can reach and impact the majority!
3.  One-way can often actually feel more generous!
REALISM

Accepts that it begins at a position of very great disadvantage!
Is ridiculously mindful of the human disposition to disregard it !




SCALE

Maps to actual, not potential, human behaviours!
Reaches the majority who make or break a brand!




GENEROSITY!
Rewards and entertains people to the nth degree!
Asks and expects as little back from people as possible!
One-way Vs Two-way!
Is there a moral difference? No.!

Which is more effective? One-way. Often.!

Why? !
1. REALISM!
2. SCALE!
3. GENEROSITY !
What next?!
MAYBE WEʼVE FOUND THE PROBLEM!!
Secrets of successful            Stumbling blocks of bad
one-way communication?!          two-way communication?!

-  It recognises that most       -  It depends upon most
people will never care much      people caring about most
about most brands!               brands – they really donʼt!

-  It works with, not against,   -  Is often too focused on
the likely human behaviour of    possible, not likely, human
most people!                     behaviour of most people!

-  Is extremely generous and     -  Isnʼt often not being
asks very little back from       generous enough, and is
people!                          asking too much back!
The irony is…


That two-way marketing could
probably do better by learning from
the very principles of the
“traditional” one-way marketing*
that it has so often declared to be
dead. !
                           *The amazingly good examples"
Is two-way
success
possible?


Of course.


Thereʼs been
an example
this month… !
REALISM


SCALE – this might change, a bit


GENEROSITY!
REALISM – this wonʼt 


SCALE – this might change, a bit


GENEROSITY – this wonʼt!
If it is to succeed, two-way marketing will have
to seriously raise its game, and seriously
lower its opinion of itself.!




                                  And it will only do so by following the same,
                                  traditional, paths to success as good one-way
                                  marketing…!
REALISM


SCALE


GENEROSITY!
Appendix
       !
Slide 12!
Seth Godin!
Permission Marketing. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1999.!
(I donʼt disagree with everything Seth Godin says. I do disagree with this. I singled
him in the picture because his glasses matched the halo)!

Read more at
http://www.thedrum.co.uk/news/2012/04/25/marketing-dead-says-saatchi-saatchi-
ceo#IVB5r9HUhly5YEqK.99 !
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/bill-lee!
http://www.prdaily.com/Main/Articles/
Advertising_doesnt_work_anymore_for_your_brand_11895.aspx !
http://www.catalystmarketers.com/tag/interruption-marketing/!
http://www.copyblogger.com/advertising-is-dead/!
Slide 19!
http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2011/03/social-
medias-massive-failure.html !
Slide 20!
http://www.businessinsider.com/facts-about-coca-
cola-2011-6?op=1 !
Slide 21!
1. http://martinweigel.org/2012/07/09/lightweight-
 and-generous/ !

2. Deloitte TMT 2012 Predict &
 http://digital-stats.blogspot.nl/2011/07/80-of-
 branded-mobile-apps-have-been.html !

3. http://www.netpaths.net/blog/6-percent-of-
 surfers-generate-50-percent-clicks/ !
Slide 23 (and 61)!
http://wearesocial.net/blog/2012/07/putting-
facebook-fan/ !
Slide 40!
Source: Ehrenberg Bass / Martin Weigel!
http://martinweigel.org/2012/07/09/lightweight-
and-generous/ !
Slide 49!
http://martinweigel.org/2011/09/12/fashionable-
yet-bankrupt/ !
Slide 58!
1.    Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype !
2.    Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype !
3.    Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype !
4.    Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html &
      http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ and
      http://www.scribd.com/doc/92847814/The-Cross-Platform-Report-Q4-2011-Nielsen-May12 !
5.    SEE BELOW FOR THE MATHS: Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html &
      http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ and
      http://www.scribd.com/doc/92847814/The-Cross-Platform-Report-Q4-2011-Nielsen-May12 !
6.    SEE BELOW FOR THE MATHS: Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html &
      http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ !
7.    Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html &
      http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ !

http://www.dukeresearchadvantage.com/laura/2010/05/04/tivo-is-not-kryptonite-for-tv-ads-after-all/#more-1166 !
About 35% of households have DVRs. !
They time-shift 5% of the time. !
Total amount of time-shifted TV is 1.7%!
People skip ads while time shifting 70% of the time.!
Total percent of TV ads being missed in America is 1.2%.!
(Ball Uni study actually has the figure at less than 5% of TOTAL viewing shifted.)!

http://www.scribd.com/doc/92847814/The-Cross-Platform-Report-Q4-2011-Nielsen-May12!
Nielsen report above has TVR shifting at 16%.!
35% of people have TVR.!
They time shift 16% of the time.!
= 5.6% of total viewing is time shifted.!

For the 35% of Americans with TiVo:!
Those that do time shift do it 16% of the time, and when they time shift they skip ads 70% of the time.!
So even the TiVo crowd are only skipping 11.2% more ads!!
Slide 59!
1. Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype !
2. ComScore Smartphone Penetration cut by iOS and Android share of market!
3. Ofcom UK study:
   http://media.ofcom.org.uk/2012/07/18/uk-is-now-texting-more-than-talking/ !
4. Sfheat.com !
5. See slide 21!
6. See slide 21!
7. See slide 21!
8. Use your brain! !
Slide 60!
http://martinweigel.org/2011/09/12/fashionable-
yet-bankrupt/ !
Slide 61!
http://martinweigel.org/2011/09/12/fashionable-
yet-bankrupt/ !
Slide 71!
http://nilofermerchant.com/2012/04/04/what-
replaces-marketing/ !

More Related Content

What's hot

HootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdf
HootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdfHootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdf
HootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdfIdzwan Yacob
 
60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.
60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.
60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.Idris Mootee
 
Ogilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaL
Ogilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaLOgilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaL
Ogilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaLChester Lau
 
J Walter Thompson Planning Guide
J Walter Thompson Planning GuideJ Walter Thompson Planning Guide
J Walter Thompson Planning Guidewilliam charnock
 
Strategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insights
Strategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insightsStrategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insights
Strategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insightsKaren Saba
 
Disruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanerva
Disruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanervaDisruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanerva
Disruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanervaio_Works
 
Social Media Strategy For 2023.pdf
Social Media Strategy For 2023.pdfSocial Media Strategy For 2023.pdf
Social Media Strategy For 2023.pdfAmit Singh
 
Brand Strategy Toolkit
Brand Strategy ToolkitBrand Strategy Toolkit
Brand Strategy Toolkitmails2yamini
 
How to define your brand positioning
How to define your brand positioningHow to define your brand positioning
How to define your brand positioningBeloved Brands Inc.
 
Top 10 Planning Departments in Advertising Shortlist
Top 10 Planning Departments in Advertising ShortlistTop 10 Planning Departments in Advertising Shortlist
Top 10 Planning Departments in Advertising ShortlistJulian Cole
 
Social Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdf
Social Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdfSocial Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdf
Social Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdfMarketingTrips
 
How to write a killer agency creative brief
How to write a killer agency creative briefHow to write a killer agency creative brief
How to write a killer agency creative briefDavid Bell
 
The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015
The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015
The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015Michael Goldstein
 
Getting Started with Influencer Marketing
Getting Started with Influencer MarketingGetting Started with Influencer Marketing
Getting Started with Influencer MarketingBrent Csutoras
 
Creative Planning @ Miami Ad School
Creative Planning @ Miami Ad SchoolCreative Planning @ Miami Ad School
Creative Planning @ Miami Ad SchoolThe Planning Lab
 
Account and Media Planning
Account and Media PlanningAccount and Media Planning
Account and Media PlanningEliza Lochner
 

What's hot (20)

Inspiring Creativity
Inspiring CreativityInspiring Creativity
Inspiring Creativity
 
Social media trends 2022
Social media trends 2022Social media trends 2022
Social media trends 2022
 
HootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdf
HootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdfHootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdf
HootsuiteSocialMediaTrends2023_Report_en.pdf
 
60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.
60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.
60 Minute Brand Strategist: Extended and updated hard cover NOW available.
 
Ogilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaL
Ogilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaLOgilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaL
Ogilvy DO Brief - Chester's big ideaL
 
J Walter Thompson Planning Guide
J Walter Thompson Planning GuideJ Walter Thompson Planning Guide
J Walter Thompson Planning Guide
 
Strategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insights
Strategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insightsStrategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insights
Strategic Planning & the Importance of Consumer insights
 
Disruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanerva
Disruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanervaDisruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanerva
Disruption® visma solutions_tbwa_kallekanerva
 
Tbwa speech
Tbwa speechTbwa speech
Tbwa speech
 
Social Media Strategy For 2023.pdf
Social Media Strategy For 2023.pdfSocial Media Strategy For 2023.pdf
Social Media Strategy For 2023.pdf
 
Brand Strategy Toolkit
Brand Strategy ToolkitBrand Strategy Toolkit
Brand Strategy Toolkit
 
How to define your brand positioning
How to define your brand positioningHow to define your brand positioning
How to define your brand positioning
 
Creative Brief Workshop
Creative Brief WorkshopCreative Brief Workshop
Creative Brief Workshop
 
Top 10 Planning Departments in Advertising Shortlist
Top 10 Planning Departments in Advertising ShortlistTop 10 Planning Departments in Advertising Shortlist
Top 10 Planning Departments in Advertising Shortlist
 
Social Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdf
Social Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdfSocial Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdf
Social Media Trends 2023 - MarketingTrips.pdf
 
How to write a killer agency creative brief
How to write a killer agency creative briefHow to write a killer agency creative brief
How to write a killer agency creative brief
 
The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015
The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015
The Cheating Strategist’s guide to Mary Meeker’s Digital Trends 2015
 
Getting Started with Influencer Marketing
Getting Started with Influencer MarketingGetting Started with Influencer Marketing
Getting Started with Influencer Marketing
 
Creative Planning @ Miami Ad School
Creative Planning @ Miami Ad SchoolCreative Planning @ Miami Ad School
Creative Planning @ Miami Ad School
 
Account and Media Planning
Account and Media PlanningAccount and Media Planning
Account and Media Planning
 

Similar to Engagement Vs Interruption

(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook
(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook
(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing HandbookGraham Brown
 
Active Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through Yogurt
Active Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through YogurtActive Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through Yogurt
Active Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through YogurtSteve Gottschling
 
(Your Approach To) Social Sucks
(Your Approach To) Social Sucks(Your Approach To) Social Sucks
(Your Approach To) Social SucksDave Marcello
 
(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook
(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook
(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing HandbookGhani Kunto
 
Social Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct Marketing
Social Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct MarketingSocial Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct Marketing
Social Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct MarketingResource/Ammirati
 
Advertisement And Vice Product
Advertisement And Vice ProductAdvertisement And Vice Product
Advertisement And Vice ProductSheila Guy
 
Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)
Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)
Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)Jan Rezab
 
9 principles of_brandingdxdd
9 principles of_brandingdxdd9 principles of_brandingdxdd
9 principles of_brandingdxddzishu1234
 
"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London
"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London
"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum LondonPolle de Maagt
 
The Incite Summit 2013 eBook
The Incite Summit 2013 eBookThe Incite Summit 2013 eBook
The Incite Summit 2013 eBookNick Johnson
 
Brandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copyBrandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copyJim Cuene
 
Brandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copyBrandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copyjimbler
 
What Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" Parody
What Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" ParodyWhat Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" Parody
What Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" Parodyjimbler
 
So, What is Brand Enlightenment?
So, What is Brand Enlightenment?So, What is Brand Enlightenment?
So, What is Brand Enlightenment?oe:gen
 

Similar to Engagement Vs Interruption (20)

(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook
(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook
(mobileYouth) The Youth Marketing Handbook
 
Active Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through Yogurt
Active Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through YogurtActive Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through Yogurt
Active Cultures: Linking Value and Digital Marketing as Told Through Yogurt
 
(Your Approach To) Social Sucks
(Your Approach To) Social Sucks(Your Approach To) Social Sucks
(Your Approach To) Social Sucks
 
(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook
(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook
(GhaniKunto.me) Download - Youth Marketing Handbook
 
Advertisement Analysis Essay
Advertisement Analysis EssayAdvertisement Analysis Essay
Advertisement Analysis Essay
 
Social Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct Marketing
Social Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct MarketingSocial Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct Marketing
Social Marketing Delivers on the Promise of Direct Marketing
 
Content & conversation
Content & conversationContent & conversation
Content & conversation
 
Got socialmedia3
Got socialmedia3Got socialmedia3
Got socialmedia3
 
Advertisement And Vice Product
Advertisement And Vice ProductAdvertisement And Vice Product
Advertisement And Vice Product
 
Persuasive Techniques In Grant Writing
Persuasive Techniques In Grant WritingPersuasive Techniques In Grant Writing
Persuasive Techniques In Grant Writing
 
Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)
Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)
Multiparty Mobile Prague Mark Linder Final (Nx Power Lite)
 
9 principles of_brandingdxdd
9 principles of_brandingdxdd9 principles of_brandingdxdd
9 principles of_brandingdxdd
 
Advertisement As A Social Phenomenon
Advertisement As A Social PhenomenonAdvertisement As A Social Phenomenon
Advertisement As A Social Phenomenon
 
"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London
"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London
"A presentation about common sense." for Opera Forum London
 
The Incite Summit 2013 eBook
The Incite Summit 2013 eBookThe Incite Summit 2013 eBook
The Incite Summit 2013 eBook
 
The Incite Summit 2013 eBook
The Incite Summit 2013 eBookThe Incite Summit 2013 eBook
The Incite Summit 2013 eBook
 
Brandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copyBrandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copy
 
Brandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copyBrandbuilding goldiblox copy
Brandbuilding goldiblox copy
 
What Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" Parody
What Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" ParodyWhat Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" Parody
What Marketers Can Learn From the GoldiBlox "Girls" Parody
 
So, What is Brand Enlightenment?
So, What is Brand Enlightenment?So, What is Brand Enlightenment?
So, What is Brand Enlightenment?
 

Recently uploaded

A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.mcshagufta46
 
To Create Your Own Wig Online To Create Your Own Wig Online
To Create Your Own Wig Online  To Create Your Own Wig OnlineTo Create Your Own Wig Online  To Create Your Own Wig Online
To Create Your Own Wig Online To Create Your Own Wig Onlinelng ths
 
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for BusinessQ2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for BusinessAPCO
 
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023Steve Rader
 
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHelene Heckrotte
 
Project Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture ReportProject Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture Reportamberjiles31
 
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsUpgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsIntellect Design Arena Ltd
 
7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.uk7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.ukaroemirsr
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access
 
מיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלי
מיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלימיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלי
מיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגליBen Shushan & Co. C.P.A (Isr.)
 
MC Heights construction company in Jhang
MC Heights construction company in JhangMC Heights construction company in Jhang
MC Heights construction company in Jhangmcgroupjeya
 
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfChicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfSourav Sikder
 
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdfCompany Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdfRobertPhillips265023
 
AMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdf
AMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdfAMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdf
AMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdfJohnCarloValencia4
 
The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...
The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...
The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...Brian Solis
 
Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...
Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...
Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...IMARC Group
 
Transform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in Launceston
Transform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in LauncestonTransform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in Launceston
Transform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in Launcestondjhbuildersau
 
NewBase 25 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase  25 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...NewBase  25 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase 25 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...Khaled Al Awadi
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Sixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDF
Sixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDFSixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDF
Sixth Sense Media Portfolio (Eng Ver) PDF
 
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
 
To Create Your Own Wig Online To Create Your Own Wig Online
To Create Your Own Wig Online  To Create Your Own Wig OnlineTo Create Your Own Wig Online  To Create Your Own Wig Online
To Create Your Own Wig Online To Create Your Own Wig Online
 
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for BusinessQ2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
Q2 2024 APCO Geopolitical Radar - The Global Operating Environment for Business
 
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
 
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
 
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV IndustriesInvestment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
 
Project Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture ReportProject Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture Report
 
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsUpgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
 
7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.uk7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.uk
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
 
מיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלי
מיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלימיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלי
מיסוי רילוקיישן לפורטוגל- היבטי מיסוי ישראלי ופורטוגלי
 
MC Heights construction company in Jhang
MC Heights construction company in JhangMC Heights construction company in Jhang
MC Heights construction company in Jhang
 
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfChicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
 
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdfCompany Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
Company Profile and SWOT Analysis Product List.pdf
 
AMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdf
AMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdfAMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdf
AMAZON SELLER VIRTUAL ASSISTANT PRODUCT RESEARCH .pdf
 
The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...
The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...
The End of Business as Usual: Rewire the Way You Work to Succeed in the Consu...
 
Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...
Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...
Boat Trailers Market PPT: Growth, Outlook, Demand, Keyplayer Analysis and Opp...
 
Transform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in Launceston
Transform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in LauncestonTransform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in Launceston
Transform Your Kitchen Essential Tips for Renovations in Launceston
 
NewBase 25 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase  25 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...NewBase  25 March  2024  Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
NewBase 25 March 2024 Energy News issue - 1710 by Khaled Al Awadi_compress...
 

Engagement Vs Interruption

  • 2. Why am I doing this?! Itʼs an important debate, but also a complex one.! Itʼs a lot easier to go along with jargon and sound-bites than interrogate the data, the essays and the facts.! It seems that a lot of people are doing the former.! And so Iʼve tried to make it a bit more lighthearted and bite- sized.! Itʼs not perfect, but hopefully it helps having a proper look at all this a little bit easier.!
  • 3. Me! Iʼve spent half my career in agencies that primarily deal in “engagement”! And in making this thing, Iʼve also plundered enormously from Martin Weigel, Ed Booty and Bob Hoffman..! Iʼve spent half my career in agencies that primarily deal in “interruption”! Iʼm trying to be fair from the start…!
  • 4. Both interruption and engagement are confusing words.! Couldnʼt both be interruptive?! Couldnʼt both be engaging?! Whatʼs the meaningful distinction?!
  • 5. Socrates said…! the beginning of wisdom is the PRETTY definition of terms SMART FOR A FOOTBALLER
  • 6. Engagement marketing is a marketing strategy that directly engages consumers and invites and encourages consumer to participate in the evolution of a brand. Advertising, in its purest form, is just Rather than looking at consumers as getting attention ! passive receivers of messages, engagement marketers believe that Alex Bogusky
 consumers should be actively involved in the production and co-creation of marketing programs, developing a relationship with the brand.
 Frederic  P  Miller,  Agnes  F  Vandome,  John  McBrewster   h9p://books.google.nl/books?id=__1fYgEACAAJ&hl=nl&sitesec=reviews  
  • 7. The difference! Interruption: ! Engagement:! Marketing that Marketing that communicates to its communicates to its audience via audience via projecting a something that people message to people.! participate with.!
  • 8. The definition! Interruption: ! Engagement:! Marketing that is Marketing that is fundamentally fundamentally one-way! two-way!
  • 9. Big brands need to communicate to significant numbers of people in order to grow.! This is a comparison of communication.! Iʼm not talking about improving the product, or the necessary conversion or service tools like websites, or shops.! Iʼm just asking:! Which is a more effective means for big brands to market to significant numbers of people?!
  • 10. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference?! Which is more effective?! Why?!
  • 11. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference?! Which is more effective?! Why?!
  • 12. Sometimes, the people who believe in two-way marketing can come across as a bit self-righteous! “Interruption marketing is doomed as a mass communication tool”! “Everyone wants a conversation. They want inspiration. Inspire people with your website. Donʼt just interrupt, but interact. Asking about Return on Investment is the wrong question today. You should be asking about Return on Involvement”! “Many people in traditional marketing roles and organizations may not realize theyʼre operating within a dead paradigm”! “Interruption Marketing leaves a bad taste in the mouths of your target audience”! “And spending millions feels good. Seeing your billboard downtown, or your commercial on television seems like a strategic win. At least youʼre doing something, right?”! Sources are sometimes in the appendix!
  • 13. But we all have the same end! Making a business richer.! Brands are not altruistic champions of the people. ! They are businesses.!
  • 14. Whether you impact people with a one-way message, or a two-way idea, itʼs not, primarily, for the benefit of people.! Itʼs about creating something that steals into human attention / action for the benefit a brand*! *Thatʼs not necessarily evil, although it often is – but thatʼs for another debate!
  • 15. Marketing is always about interrupting people with ideas!
  • 16. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective?! Why?!
  • 17. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective?! Why?!
  • 18. Yes. Itʼs a whipping boy.! But in terms of a two-way marketing replacing one-way marketing, PEPSI refresh is a robust example:! BIG BRAND! +! $20m SPEND! 2009: Pepsi spend the $20m on one-way Superbowl ads ! 2010: Pepsi spend the $20m on a two-way campaign and actually GAVE THE MONEY AWAY TO GOOD CAUSES. !
  • 19. It didnʼt work.! TheW StreetJournal reported that Pepsi-Cola and Diet Pepsi had each a! lost about 5% of their market share in the past year. $ For the Pepsi-Cola brand alone this represents a loss of over $350 million. $ For both brands, the loss is probably something in the neighborhood of 400 million to half-a-billion dollars.$ For the first time ever Pepsi-Cola has dropped from its traditional position as the number two soft drink inAmerica to number three (behind Diet Coke.)$ In 2010, Pepsi's market share erosion accelerated by 8 times compared to the previous year.$ Source: Wall Street Journal andAdcontrarian – see appendix!
  • 20. 80+ million votes registered; almost 3.5 million "likes" on the Pepsi Facebook page; and almost 60,000 Twitter followers arenʼt enough.! These numbers arenʼt that big really…! 3.5 million fans arenʼt so relevant when your competitor serves Americans 335 million drinks every day.! Source: See appendix!
  • 21. A few killer stats…! Of 200 brands studied, Ehrenberg-Bass have shown that on average less than 0.5% of Facebook fans engage with the brand they are fans of. Only 10% of brands manage to get over the 1% of fans engaging mark.! 80% of branded apps get less than 1,000 downloads, and most have barely any active users.! 50% of click-throughs on online ads come from the same 6% of people, who tend to come from low income groups.! Sources: See appendix!
  • 22. Sure there have been a few awards.
 But the transformational effectiveness case studies for two-way campaigns are conspicuously lacking.!
  • 23. There are too many of these instead*! *This is lazy, and naughty. More on this later."
  • 24. Time to face facts! TWO-WAY MARKETING ANYWHERE NEAR AS AMAZINGLY AS IT SAID IT WOULD
  • 25. It is of course also true that people are also pre- disposed to reject one-way marketing.! And indeed, they do. ! Dave Trott tells us that of the £18.3 billion spent on advertising in the UK last year, 89% is not even noticed or remembered. 7% is remembered negatively, leaving 4% to be remembered positively.! Looking at some of the work, Steve Henryʼs anecdote that the average return on a UK advertising pound is 56p seems plausible.!
  • 26. But the recent success stories are there for all to, robustly, see! Hovis – 2010 IPA Grand Prix! Chrysler – 2012 Grand Effie! Johnnie Walker – 2008 IPA Grand Prix! The list goes on… Audi, Old Spice, Bravia, Compare the Meerkat (Go Compare, even), O2, Ovaltine…!
  • 27. 250 Case Studies from the last 7 years:
 Traditional “one-way” fares pretty well Vs. “two-way”! Putting the models to the test: IPAdataMINE 2011!
  • 28. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective? One-way. Often.! Why?!
  • 29. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective? One-way. Often.! Why?!
  • 31. I can remember watching a football match at University.! When the ad break came on, the Cadburyʼs Gorilla advert started to play. People actually “shussshed” other people. ! The bar was quieter than at any other point in the afternoon. ! People watched with real anticipation, genuinely entertained – made happy even. Some remarked upon how good it was, and then they went on with their day. ! That was the moment I decided I might be ok with working for brands. !
  • 32. To be fair, thereʼs also a lot of this!
  • 33. But there are, undeniably, these!
  • 34. Iʼve never seen someone (normal) talk about a two-way idea in the pub!
  • 36. 1. People donʼt care. 
 Especially about brands. 
 One-way marketing doesnʼt rely on them caring much. 
 Two-way marketing does.!
  • 37. Anyone who has ever contemplated getting a much-loved picture framed, or going to a colleague- that-we-actually-got-on- well-withʼs leaving drinks on Tuesday night, knows this. ! We can barely be bothered to engage in two-way behaviour with most things we like and most people we know. !
  • 38. Only 17% of people in the UK are “intensely” participating with anything online !
  • 39. Shouldnʼt we consider relationships with brands…! …as scaled back a thousand times from even this?!
  • 40. Ehrenberg-Bass have shown, across 145 brands and 13 categories: ! Just 20% of a brandʼs customers hold about 40% of the image associations. ! The rest of knowledge about the brand is spread hazily across the other 80%. ! Source: Ehrenberg Bass / Martin Weigel – see appendix!
  • 41. For that 80%, who make or break a business, brands largely exist as a low-involvement processing function, that allow us to make easy, safe choices without the burden of “engaged” thought or activity. ! They are more likely to function as a well- remembered red berry on a bush than a good friend. ! A light guarantee of reliability and general favourability, not a deep or meaningful connection. !
  • 42. Most of us are polygamously promiscuous with virtually every brand we ever buy. ! Why?! Because not caring is a natural, human way of relating to a brand. !
  • 43. In short, success for most brands is largely dependent upon people who would probably find the thought of participating in two-way communication with that brand quite horrible.!
  • 44. Which feels pretty instinctively spot on! Think about all the brands that you interact with, even buy and use, every day. ! When was the last time you wanted to engage in any two-way interaction with any of them?*! *It doesnʼt count if you had to do it for your job. !
  • 45. This kind of thing is starting to look a little bit shaky…!
  • 46. Are there any exceptions? Maybe…! Thanks, Sell Sell!
  • 47. Nike have done amazingly well to build up audiences on things like Facebook, and now spend less pushing out content through paid media !
  • 48. But at its biggest and best, itʼs still light, one-way style communication in a slightly two-way channel! *Yes, I know people have to seek this stuff out, and they do like it and share it." But you have to wonder…" How many people explored the tunnels, compared to the tens of millions that watched the film?"
  • 49. Nike are actually quite similar to most brands:
 They donʼt benefit to any extraordinary degree from loyal customers! Source: Professor Dawes, UK SPORTSWEAR MARKET 2009, TNS Superpanel Via Martin Weigel – see appendix!
  • 50. Because not even most Back of fag packet customers of the ultimate high Nike calculations! interest brand are all queuing up to engage at a deep level. ! Sell 200,000,000 shoes alone per I love football, and running. I have year! Nike football boots, and running Nike + has less than 5,000,000 shoes. ! active users.! I have watched their films on TV It seems unlikely that deep two-way communications are driving all of and online, and enjoyed them.! their success!! In fact, it seems unlikely that it is I have never deeply engaged with driving the majority of it.! Nike though. ! *Iʼm not saying current one-way communication is either – 30 years of Iʼd argue that the majority of their great branding, sponsorship, customers still fall into that camp.! advertising and distribution and some two-way marketing are, probably"
  • 51. Can push two-way a lot The real point is that a further than brands like rare brand like this:! this:! Almost NO brands are like this! AlmostALLbrands are like this!
  • 52. As usual, Sell Sell hit the nail on the head… !
  • 53. After consulting the facts, and consulting our instincts, does it not appear that most people, quite reasonably, donʼt care very much at all about most brands?! Therefore, does it not appear that most people could well be largely pre-disposed to reject most two-way marketing with most brands?!
  • 54. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective? One-way. Often.! Why? ! 1. Most people donʼt want two-way with most brands!
  • 55. 2. Two-way marketing often seems focused on what some people can do.
 Not what all people actually do do.
 Which is doodoo.!
  • 56. Where the heads of the new marketing gurus are…! Where the behaviours of actual people are… ! Stolen from Ed Booty!
  • 57. All of advertising is not all of people!
  • 58. A lot of one-way related media still has majority reach! 1981! 2011! Average Brit watches 4 hours of TV a day. ! Average Brit watches 4 hours of TV a day. ! Favourite British show is a soap. ! Favourite British show is a soap. ! Favourite British news source is The Sun.! Favourite British news source is The Sun.! Americans get most of the video they watch Americans get 98% of the video they watch via TV! via TV! Americans with TVs watch almost all of their Americans watch almost all of their TV live, TV live! only 7% of total viewing is “timeshifted”! Americans sometimes make a sandwich Americans with TiVo skip 11.2% more ads. while the ads are on! But thatʼs only 1.2 and 5.6% of total ads*! Americans donʼt even know what Americans do 5% of their total purchasing Ecommerce is! online! *Americans also still eat sandwiches, possibly more – Other less funny footnotes in the appendix"
  • 59. A lot of two-way related media is still niche! Non-majority take-up! Not working for marketing! OR INTERACTIVE TV! FACEBOOK
 Only 5% in the UK have bought it, and less than Almost nobody interacts with brands on 50% of them have bothered to connect it – that Facebook! leaves almost nobody to even collect data from regarding interaction with brands! APPS! SMARTPHONES! Almost nobody downloads branded apps, or Even in the US, only 38% of people have the uses them more than once! Android or iOS phones that can offer good two-way experiences! ONLINE! TABLETS ! Click-throughs are dominated by relatively 11% of people in the UK have them! small numbers of generally less affluent people. Itʼs rare that large numbers go to THE NON-FACEBOOK SIDE OF SOCIAL! micro-sites or campaign pages.! No other network has close to 50% of people on it! QR! Do we really need to go there?! Sources: See appendix!
  • 60. Success for brands comes from growing with the many, not with the few! Source: Charles Graham 2010, TNS Superpanel Via Martin Weigel – see appendix!
  • 61. Two-way also targets the interested minority who are likely to buy your product anyway !
  • 62. Whilst one-way can impact the disinterested majority who deliver growth ! SALES! Pantene:! Sales split by Customer Frequency! Most sales come from the most infrequent buyers! FREQUENCY! Source: Professor Dawes, 2009, TNS Superpanel Via Martin Weigel see appendix!
  • 63. Which explains why two-way communications didnʼt work for Pepsi Refresh…
 It failed to impact the disinterested majority who make up the majority of Cola sales! Source: ByronSharp,HowBrandsGrow!
  • 64. Even great online products and services that “engage” people in deep two-way behaviour every day are using one-way marketing to drive growth via penetration!
  • 65. If weʼre being harsh…! One-way! Two-way! Uses mass media! Uses niche media! to! to! Give you a shot at Reward small numbers growing sales with the of loyalists for what they majority! were already doing!
  • 66. Social media, the internet and technology has changed things for people.! But that doesnʼt mean that lots of things havenʼt stayed the same too.! And that certainly doesnʼt mean that the way brands can market to significant numbers of people has changed overnight.!
  • 67. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective? One-way. Often.! Why? ! 1. Most people donʼt want two-way with most brands! 2. One-way can reach and impact the majority!
  • 68. 3. One-way communication has been practicing making realistic pitches to large numbers of people who donʼt care about brands for years!
  • 69. Maybe two-way marketing is often struggling because people thought that it could play by different rules?
 It began with a reversal of how weʼd always thought about marketing.
 God knows, weʼve all heard it…!
  • 70. The world has changed. Everything is dead. The smart people are engaging consumers with co-creative content that allows them to share because people are in control of media which is always on like them and brands have to move all the time and never sleep and your handwash product is not a product it is a perpetual quantum service that the people want to participate in via transmedia like everything else and everything has changed.!
  • 71. The gurus who still espouse this make it all sound so easy…! "...become social thru Pinterest ..." all of a sudden you become a magnet for whatʼs hot!”" Go to the appendix if you donʼt believe me!
  • 72. And then all of a sudden youʼve spunked a load of money on this…!
  • 75. Or, 
 youʼre just continually filling the world with drivel like this…!
  • 76. Surely thinking that people will ever want to do stuff with brands will always be a very self-involved, very unrealistic, very lazy and very arrogant thing for marketers to think.!
  • 77. At its best, one-way marketing understands that it makes a play for attention-lite from a position of enormous disadvantage.! It sets out to throw something out to people that is good enough to overcome the odds so steeply stacked against it. ! At its best, it remembers that its primary mission, if it is to have any chance of making any impact, is to win the precious and rightfully reluctant attention of people by offering them something incredibly distinctive, beautiful, interesting, funny, poignant, or all of these things.! Without asking for something back. !
  • 78. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective? One-way. Mostly.! Why? ! 1.  Most people donʼt want two-way with most brands! 2.  One-way can reach and impact the majority! 3.  One-way can often actually feel more generous!
  • 79. REALISM
 Accepts that it begins at a position of very great disadvantage! Is ridiculously mindful of the human disposition to disregard it ! SCALE
 Maps to actual, not potential, human behaviours! Reaches the majority who make or break a brand! GENEROSITY! Rewards and entertains people to the nth degree! Asks and expects as little back from people as possible!
  • 80. One-way Vs Two-way! Is there a moral difference? No.! Which is more effective? One-way. Often.! Why? ! 1. REALISM! 2. SCALE! 3. GENEROSITY !
  • 82. MAYBE WEʼVE FOUND THE PROBLEM!!
  • 83. Secrets of successful Stumbling blocks of bad one-way communication?! two-way communication?! -  It recognises that most -  It depends upon most people will never care much people caring about most about most brands! brands – they really donʼt! -  It works with, not against, -  Is often too focused on the likely human behaviour of possible, not likely, human most people! behaviour of most people! -  Is extremely generous and -  Isnʼt often not being asks very little back from generous enough, and is people! asking too much back!
  • 84. The irony is…
 That two-way marketing could probably do better by learning from the very principles of the “traditional” one-way marketing* that it has so often declared to be dead. ! *The amazingly good examples"
  • 86. REALISM
 SCALE – this might change, a bit
 GENEROSITY!
  • 87. REALISM – this wonʼt 
 SCALE – this might change, a bit
 GENEROSITY – this wonʼt!
  • 88. If it is to succeed, two-way marketing will have to seriously raise its game, and seriously lower its opinion of itself.! And it will only do so by following the same, traditional, paths to success as good one-way marketing…!
  • 90. Appendix !
  • 91. Slide 12! Seth Godin! Permission Marketing. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1999.! (I donʼt disagree with everything Seth Godin says. I do disagree with this. I singled him in the picture because his glasses matched the halo)! Read more at http://www.thedrum.co.uk/news/2012/04/25/marketing-dead-says-saatchi-saatchi- ceo#IVB5r9HUhly5YEqK.99 ! http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/bill-lee! http://www.prdaily.com/Main/Articles/ Advertising_doesnt_work_anymore_for_your_brand_11895.aspx ! http://www.catalystmarketers.com/tag/interruption-marketing/! http://www.copyblogger.com/advertising-is-dead/!
  • 94. Slide 21! 1. http://martinweigel.org/2012/07/09/lightweight- and-generous/ ! 2. Deloitte TMT 2012 Predict & http://digital-stats.blogspot.nl/2011/07/80-of- branded-mobile-apps-have-been.html ! 3. http://www.netpaths.net/blog/6-percent-of- surfers-generate-50-percent-clicks/ !
  • 95. Slide 23 (and 61)! http://wearesocial.net/blog/2012/07/putting- facebook-fan/ !
  • 96. Slide 40! Source: Ehrenberg Bass / Martin Weigel! http://martinweigel.org/2012/07/09/lightweight- and-generous/ !
  • 98. Slide 58! 1.  Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype ! 2.  Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype ! 3.  Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype ! 4.  Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html & http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ and http://www.scribd.com/doc/92847814/The-Cross-Platform-Report-Q4-2011-Nielsen-May12 ! 5.  SEE BELOW FOR THE MATHS: Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html & http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ and http://www.scribd.com/doc/92847814/The-Cross-Platform-Report-Q4-2011-Nielsen-May12 ! 6.  SEE BELOW FOR THE MATHS: Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html & http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ ! 7.  Adcontrian - http://adcontrarian.blogspot.nl/2010/09/amazing-invisible-tivo-effect.html & http://www.admavericks.com/2012/05/14/lessons-from-the-ad-contrarian/ ! http://www.dukeresearchadvantage.com/laura/2010/05/04/tivo-is-not-kryptonite-for-tv-ads-after-all/#more-1166 ! About 35% of households have DVRs. ! They time-shift 5% of the time. ! Total amount of time-shifted TV is 1.7%! People skip ads while time shifting 70% of the time.! Total percent of TV ads being missed in America is 1.2%.! (Ball Uni study actually has the figure at less than 5% of TOTAL viewing shifted.)! http://www.scribd.com/doc/92847814/The-Cross-Platform-Report-Q4-2011-Nielsen-May12! Nielsen report above has TVR shifting at 16%.! 35% of people have TVR.! They time shift 16% of the time.! = 5.6% of total viewing is time shifted.! For the 35% of Americans with TiVo:! Those that do time shift do it 16% of the time, and when they time shift they skip ads 70% of the time.! So even the TiVo crowd are only skipping 11.2% more ads!!
  • 99. Slide 59! 1. Ed Booty - http://bbh-labs.com/majority-report-looking-through-the-digital-hype ! 2. ComScore Smartphone Penetration cut by iOS and Android share of market! 3. Ofcom UK study: http://media.ofcom.org.uk/2012/07/18/uk-is-now-texting-more-than-talking/ ! 4. Sfheat.com ! 5. See slide 21! 6. See slide 21! 7. See slide 21! 8. Use your brain! !