SlideShare a Scribd company logo

From Argument Mapping to Argument Mining, and Back

Talk slides for the 2014 SICSA Workshop on Argument Mining (Dundee, 9-10 July 2014). The talk presents our group's work in the context of argument mining and offers some challenges and applications.

1 of 19
Download to read offline
Brian Plüss
Anna De Liddo
Simon Buckingham Shum
From Argument Mapping to
Argument Mining, and Back
Knowledge Media Institute
The Open University, UK
SICSA Workshop on Argument Mining
University of Dundee, 9-10 July 2014
Tool Support for Argument
Mapping and Visualisation
http://compendiuminstitute.net
From Argument Mapping to Argument Mining, and Back
Tool Support for Argument
Mapping and Visualisation
http://cohere.open.ac.uk
Tool Support for Argument
Mapping and Visualisation
http://evidence-hub.net
Communities of enquiry
Collaborative
Knowledge
Production
Collaborative Web
Annotation and
Knowledge
mapping
Social Network
Analysis and
Visualization
Structured Online
Discussion and
Argumentation
Advanced Analytics for:
Attention mediation &
Deliberation diagnostic
http://catalyst-fp7.eu
Tool Support for Argument
Mapping and Visualisation
Collective intelligence
for social innovation

Recommended

Barberini Analytics - System Architecture
Barberini Analytics - System ArchitectureBarberini Analytics - System Architecture
Barberini Analytics - System ArchitectureChristoph Thiede
 
WSI Stimulus Project: Centre for longitudinal studies of online citizen parti...
WSI Stimulus Project: Centre for longitudinal studies of online citizen parti...WSI Stimulus Project: Centre for longitudinal studies of online citizen parti...
WSI Stimulus Project: Centre for longitudinal studies of online citizen parti...Ramine Tinati
 
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013University of Washington
 
The UX of Automotive
The UX of AutomotiveThe UX of Automotive
The UX of AutomotiveParrish Hanna
 
Robust Expert Finding in Web-Based Community Information Systems
Robust Expert Finding in Web-Based Community Information SystemsRobust Expert Finding in Web-Based Community Information Systems
Robust Expert Finding in Web-Based Community Information SystemsRalf Klamma
 
Mapping for Accessibility: A Case Study of Ethics in Data Science for Social ...
Mapping for Accessibility: A Case Study of Ethics in Data Science for Social ...Mapping for Accessibility: A Case Study of Ethics in Data Science for Social ...
Mapping for Accessibility: A Case Study of Ethics in Data Science for Social ...Data Science Studies UW
 
Teaching AI in data journalism
Teaching AI in data journalismTeaching AI in data journalism
Teaching AI in data journalismPaul Bradshaw
 

More Related Content

What's hot

Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...
Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...
Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...Timo Wandhoefer
 
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turnParthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turnParthenos
 
#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020
#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020
#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020P2Pvalue
 
Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)
Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)
Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)Robert Monné
 
(Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research
(Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research (Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research
(Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research Marieke van Erp
 
Open Digital Science & e-infrastructures
Open Digital Science & e-infrastructuresOpen Digital Science & e-infrastructures
Open Digital Science & e-infrastructuresCarl-Christian Buhr
 
Infrastructures for Open, Digital Science
Infrastructures for Open, Digital ScienceInfrastructures for Open, Digital Science
Infrastructures for Open, Digital ScienceCarl-Christian Buhr
 
Living with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two updateLiving with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two updateMia
 
Social network analysis
Social network analysisSocial network analysis
Social network analysisFEG
 
Smart City R&D Activities in Vienna
Smart City R&D Activities in ViennaSmart City R&D Activities in Vienna
Smart City R&D Activities in ViennaJIC
 
Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30
Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30
Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30tracykteal
 

What's hot (16)

Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...
Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...
Rethinking Governance via Social Networking: The case of direct vs. indirect ...
 
Data, Indicators and Maps on Homelessness
Data, Indicators and Maps on HomelessnessData, Indicators and Maps on Homelessness
Data, Indicators and Maps on Homelessness
 
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turnParthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
 
#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020
#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020
#P2Pvalue at Share and inspire: Infoday on CAPS in Horizon 2020
 
Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)
Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)
Data Science in Bangladesh Disaster Response - Field Trip (MSc Thesis)
 
(Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research
(Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research (Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research
(Beyond) Combining Text and Tables for qualitative and quantitative research
 
Crowdsourcing: A Geographic Approach to Identifying Policy Opportunities and ...
Crowdsourcing: A Geographic Approach to Identifying Policy Opportunities and ...Crowdsourcing: A Geographic Approach to Identifying Policy Opportunities and ...
Crowdsourcing: A Geographic Approach to Identifying Policy Opportunities and ...
 
Open Digital Science & e-infrastructures
Open Digital Science & e-infrastructuresOpen Digital Science & e-infrastructures
Open Digital Science & e-infrastructures
 
Infrastructures for Open, Digital Science
Infrastructures for Open, Digital ScienceInfrastructures for Open, Digital Science
Infrastructures for Open, Digital Science
 
Irmgard Wetzstein, Peter Leitner: Social media analytics for sustainable migr...
Irmgard Wetzstein, Peter Leitner: Social media analytics for sustainable migr...Irmgard Wetzstein, Peter Leitner: Social media analytics for sustainable migr...
Irmgard Wetzstein, Peter Leitner: Social media analytics for sustainable migr...
 
Oss2016 henttonen
Oss2016 henttonenOss2016 henttonen
Oss2016 henttonen
 
Living with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two updateLiving with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two update
 
Okfn 30.06.2011
Okfn 30.06.2011Okfn 30.06.2011
Okfn 30.06.2011
 
Social network analysis
Social network analysisSocial network analysis
Social network analysis
 
Smart City R&D Activities in Vienna
Smart City R&D Activities in ViennaSmart City R&D Activities in Vienna
Smart City R&D Activities in Vienna
 
Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30
Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30
Carpentries nasa meeting_2018-10-30
 

Similar to From Argument Mapping to Argument Mining, and Back

Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...Anna De Liddo
 
De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012
De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012
De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012Anna De Liddo
 
Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...
Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...
Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...Robert Farrow
 
Discourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social Innovation
Discourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social InnovationDiscourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social Innovation
Discourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social InnovationAnna De Liddo
 
Discussions and decisions on Decidim Barcelona
Discussions and decisions on Decidim BarcelonaDiscussions and decisions on Decidim Barcelona
Discussions and decisions on Decidim BarcelonaPablo Aragón
 
The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...
The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...
The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...Anna De Liddo
 
Media X at Stanford University - Description
Media X at Stanford University - DescriptionMedia X at Stanford University - Description
Media X at Stanford University - DescriptionMartha Russell
 
Horizon_INACAP
Horizon_INACAPHorizon_INACAP
Horizon_INACAPbrettssu
 
Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report
Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report
Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report Ed Chi
 
Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...
Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...
Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...Jean Burgess
 
Tn T Horizons April 28 2008
Tn T Horizons April 28 2008Tn T Horizons April 28 2008
Tn T Horizons April 28 2008brettssu
 
histoGraph: a case study in Digital Humanities
histoGraph: a case study in Digital HumanitieshistoGraph: a case study in Digital Humanities
histoGraph: a case study in Digital HumanitiesCUbRIK Project
 
Catalyst caps concertation presentation
Catalyst caps concertation presentationCatalyst caps concertation presentation
Catalyst caps concertation presentationCAPS2020
 
Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...
Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...
Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...Peter Löwe
 
"It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov...
"It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov..."It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov...
"It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov...CommunitySense
 

Similar to From Argument Mapping to Argument Mining, and Back (20)

Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
Collective Intelligence and Online Deliberation Platforms for Citizen Engagem...
 
De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012
De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012
De liddo & Buckingham Shum jurix2012
 
Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...
Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...
Building and Communicating Evidence of Effectiveness in OER through Collectiv...
 
Discourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social Innovation
Discourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social InnovationDiscourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social Innovation
Discourse Centered Collective Intelligence Platforms for Social Innovation
 
Discussions and decisions on Decidim Barcelona
Discussions and decisions on Decidim BarcelonaDiscussions and decisions on Decidim Barcelona
Discussions and decisions on Decidim Barcelona
 
Research as Hypermedia Narrative
Research as Hypermedia NarrativeResearch as Hypermedia Narrative
Research as Hypermedia Narrative
 
Dh presentation 2018
Dh presentation 2018Dh presentation 2018
Dh presentation 2018
 
The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...
The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...
The Evidence Hub: Harnessing the Collective Intelligence of Communities to Bu...
 
Media X at Stanford University - Description
Media X at Stanford University - DescriptionMedia X at Stanford University - Description
Media X at Stanford University - Description
 
Horizon_INACAP
Horizon_INACAPHorizon_INACAP
Horizon_INACAP
 
Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report
Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report
Ed Chi's CHI2009 Conference Trip Report
 
Cook et al
Cook et alCook et al
Cook et al
 
Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...
Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...
Tracing Publics in the Australian Blogosphere: New Methods for International ...
 
Tn T Horizons April 28 2008
Tn T Horizons April 28 2008Tn T Horizons April 28 2008
Tn T Horizons April 28 2008
 
AHRC CDP Digital Humanities 101
AHRC CDP Digital Humanities 101  AHRC CDP Digital Humanities 101
AHRC CDP Digital Humanities 101
 
histoGraph: a case study in Digital Humanities
histoGraph: a case study in Digital HumanitieshistoGraph: a case study in Digital Humanities
histoGraph: a case study in Digital Humanities
 
Catalyst caps concertation presentation
Catalyst caps concertation presentationCatalyst caps concertation presentation
Catalyst caps concertation presentation
 
Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...
Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...
Data Science: History repeated? – The heritage of the Free and Open Source GI...
 
Learning Layers - Scaling up Technologies for Informal Learning in SME Clusters
Learning Layers - Scaling up Technologies for Informal Learning in SME ClustersLearning Layers - Scaling up Technologies for Informal Learning in SME Clusters
Learning Layers - Scaling up Technologies for Informal Learning in SME Clusters
 
"It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov...
"It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov..."It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov...
"It's the Conversation, Stupid!" - Social media systems design for open innov...
 

More from EDV Project

Detecting Speakers’ Violation of Democratic Entitlements in Political Debates
Detecting Speakers’ Violation of  Democratic Entitlements in Political DebatesDetecting Speakers’ Violation of  Democratic Entitlements in Political Debates
Detecting Speakers’ Violation of Democratic Entitlements in Political DebatesEDV Project
 
TVX 2015 "Madness" Teaser
TVX 2015 "Madness" TeaserTVX 2015 "Madness" Teaser
TVX 2015 "Madness" TeaserEDV Project
 
Election Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG Talk
Election Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG TalkElection Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG Talk
Election Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG TalkEDV Project
 
Collective Intelligence Meets the Political Agenda
Collective Intelligence Meets the Political AgendaCollective Intelligence Meets the Political Agenda
Collective Intelligence Meets the Political AgendaEDV Project
 
Designed visualisation: good design doing good?
Designed visualisation: good design doing good?Designed visualisation: good design doing good?
Designed visualisation: good design doing good?EDV Project
 
The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014
The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014
The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014EDV Project
 

More from EDV Project (6)

Detecting Speakers’ Violation of Democratic Entitlements in Political Debates
Detecting Speakers’ Violation of  Democratic Entitlements in Political DebatesDetecting Speakers’ Violation of  Democratic Entitlements in Political Debates
Detecting Speakers’ Violation of Democratic Entitlements in Political Debates
 
TVX 2015 "Madness" Teaser
TVX 2015 "Madness" TeaserTVX 2015 "Madness" Teaser
TVX 2015 "Madness" Teaser
 
Election Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG Talk
Election Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG TalkElection Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG Talk
Election Debate Visualisation Project - PCRG Talk
 
Collective Intelligence Meets the Political Agenda
Collective Intelligence Meets the Political AgendaCollective Intelligence Meets the Political Agenda
Collective Intelligence Meets the Political Agenda
 
Designed visualisation: good design doing good?
Designed visualisation: good design doing good?Designed visualisation: good design doing good?
Designed visualisation: good design doing good?
 
The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014
The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014
The Election Debate Visualisation Project - KMi Internal Seminar - 19 June 2014
 

Recently uploaded

itc limited word file.pdf...............
itc limited word file.pdf...............itc limited word file.pdf...............
itc limited word file.pdf...............mahetamanav24
 
IIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdf
IIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdfIIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdf
IIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdfAustraliaChapterIIBA
 
AWS Identity and access management for users
AWS Identity and access management for usersAWS Identity and access management for users
AWS Identity and access management for usersStephenEfange3
 
Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...
Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...
Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...ThinkInnovation
 
Lies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix Enigma
Lies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix EnigmaLies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix Enigma
Lies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix EnigmaAdrian Sanabria
 
ppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptx
ppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptxppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptx
ppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptxHizkiaJastis
 
Tips to Align with Your Salesforce Data Goals
Tips to Align with Your Salesforce Data GoalsTips to Align with Your Salesforce Data Goals
Tips to Align with Your Salesforce Data GoalsDataArchiva
 
Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...
Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...
Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...Thibaud Le Douarin
 
Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023
Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023
Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023stephizcoolio
 
Industry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptx
Industry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptxIndustry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptx
Industry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptxMdRafiqulIslam403212
 
fundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptx
fundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptxfundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptx
fundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptxPoonamRijal
 
Business Analytics _ Confidence Interval
Business Analytics _ Confidence IntervalBusiness Analytics _ Confidence Interval
Business Analytics _ Confidence IntervalRavindra Nath Shukla
 
Operations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample Screens
Operations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample ScreensOperations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample Screens
Operations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample ScreensKondapi V Siva Rama Brahmam
 
A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)
A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)
A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)UNCResearchHub
 

Recently uploaded (15)

itc limited word file.pdf...............
itc limited word file.pdf...............itc limited word file.pdf...............
itc limited word file.pdf...............
 
IIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdf
IIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdfIIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdf
IIBA Adl - Being Effective on Day 1 - Slide Deck.pdf
 
AWS Identity and access management for users
AWS Identity and access management for usersAWS Identity and access management for users
AWS Identity and access management for users
 
Electricity Year 2023_updated_22022024.pptx
Electricity Year 2023_updated_22022024.pptxElectricity Year 2023_updated_22022024.pptx
Electricity Year 2023_updated_22022024.pptx
 
Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...
Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...
Unlocking New Insights Into the World of European Soccer Through the European...
 
Lies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix Enigma
Lies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix EnigmaLies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix Enigma
Lies and Myths in InfoSec - 2023 Usenix Enigma
 
ppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptx
ppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptxppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptx
ppt penjualan berbasis online omset.pptx
 
Tips to Align with Your Salesforce Data Goals
Tips to Align with Your Salesforce Data GoalsTips to Align with Your Salesforce Data Goals
Tips to Align with Your Salesforce Data Goals
 
Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...
Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...
Generative AI Rennes Meetup with OVHcloud - WAICF highlights & how to deploy ...
 
Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023
Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023
Soil Health Policy Map Years 2020 to 2023
 
Industry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptx
Industry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptxIndustry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptx
Industry 4.0 in IoT Transforming the Future.pptx
 
fundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptx
fundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptxfundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptx
fundamentals of digital imaging - POONAM.pptx
 
Business Analytics _ Confidence Interval
Business Analytics _ Confidence IntervalBusiness Analytics _ Confidence Interval
Business Analytics _ Confidence Interval
 
Operations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample Screens
Operations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample ScreensOperations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample Screens
Operations Data On Mobile - inSis Mobile App - Sample Screens
 
A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)
A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)
A Gentle Introduction to Text Analysis :)
 

From Argument Mapping to Argument Mining, and Back

  • 1. Brian Plüss Anna De Liddo Simon Buckingham Shum From Argument Mapping to Argument Mining, and Back Knowledge Media Institute The Open University, UK SICSA Workshop on Argument Mining University of Dundee, 9-10 July 2014
  • 2. Tool Support for Argument Mapping and Visualisation http://compendiuminstitute.net
  • 4. Tool Support for Argument Mapping and Visualisation http://cohere.open.ac.uk
  • 5. Tool Support for Argument Mapping and Visualisation http://evidence-hub.net Communities of enquiry
  • 6. Collaborative Knowledge Production Collaborative Web Annotation and Knowledge mapping Social Network Analysis and Visualization Structured Online Discussion and Argumentation Advanced Analytics for: Attention mediation & Deliberation diagnostic http://catalyst-fp7.eu Tool Support for Argument Mapping and Visualisation Collective intelligence for social innovation
  • 7. Human–Machine Annotation for Collective Sensemaking + XIP Collaboration with Ágnes Sándor
  • 8. Human–Machine Annotation for Collective Sensemaking + XIP Collaboration with Ágnes Sándor
  • 9. Rhetorical functions of metadiscourse identified by the Xerox Incremental Parser (XIP) BACKGROUND KNOWLEDGE: Recent studies indicate … … the previously proposed … … is universally accepted ... NOVELTY: ... new insights provide direct evidence ... ... we suggest a new ... approach ... ... results define a novel role ... OPEN QUESTION: … little is known … … role … has been elusive Current data is insufficient … GENERALIZING: ... emerging as a promising approach Our understanding ... has grown exponentially ... ... growing recognition of the importance ... CONTRASTING IDEAS: … unorthodox view resolves … paradoxes … In contrast with previous hypotheses ... ... inconsistent with past findings ... SIGNIFICANCE: studies ... have provided important advances Knowledge ... is crucial for ... understanding valuable information ... from studies SURPRISE: We have recently observed ... surprisingly We have identified ... unusual The recent discovery ... suggests intriguing roles SUMMARIZING: The goal of this study ... Here, we show ... Altogether, our results ... indicate
  • 10. Human–Machine Annotation for Collective Sensemaking + XIP Collaboration with Ágnes Sándor • Case study on project report dataset • XIP + Cohere versus Humans + Cohere • Promising overlaps between the two • XIP’s output could be integrated with human annotation for visualization • Applications on Learning Analytics for academic writing
  • 11. Citizen Engagement in Televised Election Debates http://edv-project.net
  • 12. Citizen Engagement in Televised Election Debates http://edv-project.net
  • 14. Focus groups motivate a set of ‘democratic entitlements’ • Ability to scrutinise the communicational strategies adopted by the speakers, e.g. to detect intentional confusion & manipulation • Understand the meaning, background and historical record of political claims • Connect disparate arguments and claims with a view to understanding their ramifications, esp. negative • …
  • 15. Mapping the UK election TV debates http://people.kmi.open.ac.uk/sbs/2010/04/real-time-mapping-election-tv-debates Seeing Nick Clegg’s moves
  • 16. Rhetoric and Rules of the Game (Non-Cooperation in Dialogue)
  • 17. Rhetoric and Rules of the Game (Non-Cooperation in Dialogue) • Manual annotation + automatic analysis • Is further automation possible?
  • 18. Social Media Mining for Critical Engagement in Political Debates • Aim: develop online tools for assisting citizens in making sense of dynamics around more general political agendas • E.g.: a citizen interested in a particular idea, debate or controversy can retrieve the political actors that align with the different positions • Challenge 1: extracting arguments from social and online media and presenting them in ways that are tailored to a citizen’s interests and needs • Challenge 2: extracting arguments from published media, such as newspapers, blog posts or party policy documents and automatically link social media contributions to these arguments http://sense4us.eu
  • 19. Thanks! Brian Plüss Anna De Liddo Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute The Open University, UK