SlideShare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. See our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
SlideShare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. See our Privacy Policy and User Agreement for details.
Successfully reported this slideshow.
Activate your 14 day free trial to unlock unlimited reading.
1.
A New Age in Patent Liquidity
New Opportunities for Entrepreneurs
An Inventor/Entrepreneur Perspective
Richard Reisman
Teleshuttle Corporation
rreisman [at] teleshuttle [dot] com
February 15, 2012
1
Copyright 2012, Teleshuttle Corp. All rights reserved. / Patent pending
2.
A Report from the Trenches
(Sell-side – Inventor/Entrepreneur)
One fortunate odyssey
through the Kafkaesque
wonderland of patents…
• From entrepreneurship to “Plan B”
• Getting + developing patents
• Partnering for commercialization
• Sales / Licensing / Litigation
• Lessons?
2
3.
Reisman/Teleshuttle Background
• Diverse Media/IT business roles – over 4 decades
– Manager, consultant, strategist, programmer
• 20 Patents + dozens pending
7 Portfolios – starting 1994
– One litigated 2004-6, sold 2006, controlled by IV
– One sold 2009 to RPX
• Teleshuttle Corp.
– Started: software/services ‘94-96 (a “PE”)
– Now: innovation “studio”
seeking strategic partners and/or IP sales (an “NPE”?)
3
4.
Teleshuttle Corp, Patents, and “Plan B”*
• Valuable new approach to online services
– Smart clients, “push” technology
– Create a new kind of platform business
• Applied for patent before launching company (1994)
– Patent as protection …+ “Plan B” hedge
– “Practicing Entity” 1994-96, limited success
– Shift to Plan B (“NPE”)
• Plan B came through (2006 – 12 years)
[*See blog: “The Six Phases of a Technology Flop” ...Patents, and Plan B]
4
5.
Commercialization Deal – BTG
My “White Knight”
• Need help to license or sell: who/how/deals/$$$
• Evaluated numerous players (1998)
• BTG
– Expertise
– Funding (direct / contingency …vs fund-raising)
– Terms
• Exclusive license to commercialize
• For revenue share (no advance, no costs, +consulting fees)
• (Milestones or reversion – BTG bought extensions, larger share)
• Good results
– Significant added value in continuations ($$$ investment)
– Little control, but good involvement
– Ups and downs, but key people came through
5
6.
…Into Patent Litigation
“The Sport of Kings”
• “Friendly” licensing talks starting 2003
– Microsoft, Apple, 2 others
– Small offers, or just “go away”/“sue me”
• Suits in 2004: Microsoft, Apple
– Discovery
– Markman stage hearings (=“claim construction”)
– Depositions: personal assault
• End 2005 looking strong, but still far apart…
– Ecstasy …maybe? – Huge win down the road?
– Agony …for sure! – More years of trial + appeal
• Grueling work, high stress, …sudden death?
• Very hard on little guy (even with funding)
6
7.
Intellectual Ventures to the Rescue!
My “Fairy Godmother”
• Magical resolution: creative, win-win deal (3/06)
– Structured / brokered by IV
• LLC buys patents – upside: future revenues from others
• IV controls LLC
• Investors in LLC fund purchase (for share in upside)
– We* get $35MM + share of future profits (drop suit)
(*Lawyers, BTG, Teleshuttle)
• Win for IP owner
– Much less than outright win at trial (10x?)
– Reasonable compensation
– Happy, quick end to long ordeal
7
8.
Sale #2 – Search Portfolio
A more “rational” path
• 4 Patents filed 2000, issued 2005-2008
– Begun with BTG (pre-filing)
– Returned by BTG before allowance by PTO
• Evidence of use 2009
• Partners to bring to market
• Sale to RPX 2009
– Very fast (5 months from evidence of use, to closing)
– Friendly, “rational”
– Not the premium price of litigation,
but low risk, no trauma
8
9.
Lessons?
Plan for change, count on nothing
1. Expect changes and reversals:
– People / Priorities / Confidence
– Markets / Outlook
– Hedge your bets
2. Disclose richly + Keep prosecution open!!!*
*File continuation before patent issues or the door closes forever!
3. Partner + Choose partners with great care
Richard Reisman, Teleshuttle Corporation
rreisman [at] teleshuttle [dot] com
9
10.
A New Age in Patent Liquidity
New Opportunities for Entrepreneurs
An Inventor/Entrepreneur Perspective
Richard Reisman
Teleshuttle Corporation
rreisman [at] teleshuttle [dot] com
February 15, 2012
10
Copyright 2012, Teleshuttle Corp. All rights reserved. / Patent pending
0 likes
Be the first to like this
Views
Total views
1,300
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
503
You have now unlocked unlimited access to 20M+ documents!
Unlimited Reading
Learn faster and smarter from top experts
Unlimited Downloading
Download to take your learnings offline and on the go
You also get free access to Scribd!
Instant access to millions of ebooks, audiobooks, magazines, podcasts and more.
Read and listen offline with any device.
Free access to premium services like Tuneln, Mubi and more.