SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 55
Hull Survey & Preliminary
                                  Assessment




Joseph Lombardi

Marine Surveyor & Consultant
Ocean Technical Services, LLC.
10 Dalton Avenue
Gloucester, Massachusetts 01930
FALLS OF CLYDE
Scottish built, wrought iron hull, fully rigged
ship/barque, part of the Matson Line that traded from
from San Francisco & other West Coast ports to
Honolulu.

Ship rescued from breakers and towed to
Honolulu in the 1960s, restored and then
allowed to languish with minimal care until in
an unsafe condition with falling rigging, rot in
her topmasts/jib boom and deteriorated stand-
ing rig. Hull in poor material condition and in
imminent danger of sinking at Honolulu
Maritime Museum berth downtown.

Ship advertised around world, no takers.

Bishop Museum decides for at-sea disposal of
vessel at 15 mile disposal site in deep water.
The ship was down-rigged by Brian Toss’s
crew in July and August of 2008 with all rig-
ging safely removed and the remaining spars
properly strengthened.

The stem and stern of the ship were strength-
ened with the addition of steel plate, steel rods,
underwater patching, removal of rudder and
the removal of the bow sprit and figurehead.

A disposal site was chosen and approved by
the EPA & USCG and the vessel was rigged for
tow after approval was obtained for the Tow
Plan and Ship Disposal Plan.
Decision Process:

1.) No funding source for restoration,
2.) Vessel in danger of losing part/all of standing rig,
3.) Danger to adjacent commercial berth and Museum
    structure due to possible loss of stability and capsizing,
4.) Extremely poor hull condition with wasted bulkheads,
    framing & decks.
5.) Loss of hull insurance,
6.) No ‘White Knight’ to take vessel away,
7.) Scrapping not an alternative in Hawaii.

Decision made for at-sea disposal of vessel.
THE FOLLOWING
    PHTOGRAPHS DEPICT
    HISTORICAL PHOTOS
    OF FALLS OF CLYDE
    DURING HER SAILING
    DAYS AND BEFORE
    DOWN-RIGGING AND
    PREPARATION OF
   VESSEL FOR DEEP SEA
    DISPOSAL.

   The rig was in poor (and dangerous) condition.
   The bowsprit was failing and in danger of falling at any time.
   Wooden topmasts were rotted and were be removed with associated
    damaged/rotted yards and standing/running rigging.
   Forecastle & Maindeck has serious wooden deck issues and needs replacement
    throughout.
   Interior support scantlings/frames for all spaces are in poor/fair condition and
    require extensive repair/replacement.
   All interior hull transverse and longitudinal bulkheads holed, or are non-existent
    and are non-watertight and require repair/replacement.
   Extensive shell plating is holed and/or suffering > 80% plate loss.
   Many temporary wooden plugs and/or DC plugs were keeping out water.
   Extensive separation of shell plating from structural framing due to corrosion of
    rivet and plate lap seams.
   New coating system failed in Tanks # 4 & 5 with resultant rust/scale. Rust/scale
    and oil waste from tanks was sandblasted and being dumped into lazarette &
    Tanks # 4 & 5.
   No flooding alarm system installed. No standby pumping capability aboard.
   Rudder assembly totally rotted away at waterline and unsupported.
   Side shell framing separated from shell plating as
                    rivets have failed.
   Wooden plugs keeping sea water from
             sinking FOC, aft.
   Transverse bulkhead of swiss cheese. Totally ineffectual structural
                               member.
   The bowsprit is rotten and in danger of falling away.
The top rig (of wood and associated rigging) wass in poor/dangerous
         condition and needs to be taken down immediately.
   Wooden blocks (as depicted above) were in danger of
    carrying away and endangering personnel below.
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008
Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008

More Related Content

Similar to Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008

U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...
U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...
U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...drydockjoe
 
Farhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdf
Farhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdfFarhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdf
Farhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdfDoctor Sadaf Qasim
 
U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009
U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009
U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009drydockjoe
 
Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)
Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)
Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)Ashish sahu
 
Carl Linne, the 106' Holland Jachtbouw
Carl Linne, the 106' Holland JachtbouwCarl Linne, the 106' Holland Jachtbouw
Carl Linne, the 106' Holland JachtbouwnorthropandjohnsoN
 
Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)
Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)
Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)Trimaran Enthusiasts
 
SUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORY
SUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORYSUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORY
SUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORYSVV
 
We Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSE
We Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSEWe Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSE
We Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSERakshnnaNandhakumar
 
Raising the Costa Concordia
Raising the Costa ConcordiaRaising the Costa Concordia
Raising the Costa ConcordiaHayling Island
 
CASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIA
CASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIACASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIA
CASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIAVARUN KESAVAN
 
Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015
Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015
Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015GO-ELS Ltd.
 
Carl Linne yacht available for charter
Carl Linne yacht available for charterCarl Linne yacht available for charter
Carl Linne yacht available for charternorthropandjohnsoN
 
Cliffs and wave cut platforms
Cliffs and wave cut platformsCliffs and wave cut platforms
Cliffs and wave cut platformsPerrymanGeography
 
Coast case studies
Coast case studiesCoast case studies
Coast case studiesMark Ollis
 

Similar to Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008 (20)

U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...
U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...
U.S.S. North Carolina Survey & Repair, Patriots Point Presentation, 19 Oc...
 
Farhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdf
Farhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdfFarhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdf
Farhad Soil Dyn Presentation.pdf
 
U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009
U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009
U.S.S. Laffey & U.S.C.G.C. Ingham Drydock Photos, 2009
 
Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)
Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)
Fish aggrigrating devices(fad)
 
Safety of navigation
Safety of navigationSafety of navigation
Safety of navigation
 
Carl Linne, the 106' Holland Jachtbouw
Carl Linne, the 106' Holland JachtbouwCarl Linne, the 106' Holland Jachtbouw
Carl Linne, the 106' Holland Jachtbouw
 
Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)
Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)
Light Brigade - the NewZealand school of yacht design (author: Gary Baigent)
 
Mesotheliomahelp org navy_shipyards_bethlehem-steel-staten-island
Mesotheliomahelp org navy_shipyards_bethlehem-steel-staten-islandMesotheliomahelp org navy_shipyards_bethlehem-steel-staten-island
Mesotheliomahelp org navy_shipyards_bethlehem-steel-staten-island
 
Offshore_Technology.pptx
Offshore_Technology.pptxOffshore_Technology.pptx
Offshore_Technology.pptx
 
SUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORY
SUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORYSUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORY
SUNKEN SHIPS DOCUMENTORY
 
We Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSE
We Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSEWe Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSE
We Are Not Afraid To Die...... Class 11 CBSE
 
Wally118
Wally118Wally118
Wally118
 
Offshore structures
Offshore structuresOffshore structures
Offshore structures
 
Valentine Tanks
Valentine TanksValentine Tanks
Valentine Tanks
 
Raising the Costa Concordia
Raising the Costa ConcordiaRaising the Costa Concordia
Raising the Costa Concordia
 
CASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIA
CASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIACASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIA
CASE STUDY: SINKING OF COSTA CONCORDIA
 
Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015
Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015
Poster Paper AWEA Offshore 2015
 
Carl Linne yacht available for charter
Carl Linne yacht available for charterCarl Linne yacht available for charter
Carl Linne yacht available for charter
 
Cliffs and wave cut platforms
Cliffs and wave cut platformsCliffs and wave cut platforms
Cliffs and wave cut platforms
 
Coast case studies
Coast case studiesCoast case studies
Coast case studies
 

Falls Of Clyde, Project Management, 2008

  • 1. Hull Survey & Preliminary Assessment Joseph Lombardi Marine Surveyor & Consultant Ocean Technical Services, LLC. 10 Dalton Avenue Gloucester, Massachusetts 01930
  • 2. FALLS OF CLYDE Scottish built, wrought iron hull, fully rigged ship/barque, part of the Matson Line that traded from from San Francisco & other West Coast ports to Honolulu. Ship rescued from breakers and towed to Honolulu in the 1960s, restored and then allowed to languish with minimal care until in an unsafe condition with falling rigging, rot in her topmasts/jib boom and deteriorated stand- ing rig. Hull in poor material condition and in imminent danger of sinking at Honolulu Maritime Museum berth downtown. Ship advertised around world, no takers. Bishop Museum decides for at-sea disposal of vessel at 15 mile disposal site in deep water.
  • 3.
  • 4. The ship was down-rigged by Brian Toss’s crew in July and August of 2008 with all rig- ging safely removed and the remaining spars properly strengthened. The stem and stern of the ship were strength- ened with the addition of steel plate, steel rods, underwater patching, removal of rudder and the removal of the bow sprit and figurehead. A disposal site was chosen and approved by the EPA & USCG and the vessel was rigged for tow after approval was obtained for the Tow Plan and Ship Disposal Plan.
  • 5. Decision Process: 1.) No funding source for restoration, 2.) Vessel in danger of losing part/all of standing rig, 3.) Danger to adjacent commercial berth and Museum structure due to possible loss of stability and capsizing, 4.) Extremely poor hull condition with wasted bulkheads, framing & decks. 5.) Loss of hull insurance, 6.) No ‘White Knight’ to take vessel away, 7.) Scrapping not an alternative in Hawaii. Decision made for at-sea disposal of vessel.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. THE FOLLOWING PHTOGRAPHS DEPICT HISTORICAL PHOTOS OF FALLS OF CLYDE DURING HER SAILING DAYS AND BEFORE DOWN-RIGGING AND PREPARATION OF  VESSEL FOR DEEP SEA DISPOSAL.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24. The rig was in poor (and dangerous) condition.  The bowsprit was failing and in danger of falling at any time.  Wooden topmasts were rotted and were be removed with associated damaged/rotted yards and standing/running rigging.  Forecastle & Maindeck has serious wooden deck issues and needs replacement throughout.  Interior support scantlings/frames for all spaces are in poor/fair condition and require extensive repair/replacement.  All interior hull transverse and longitudinal bulkheads holed, or are non-existent and are non-watertight and require repair/replacement.  Extensive shell plating is holed and/or suffering > 80% plate loss.  Many temporary wooden plugs and/or DC plugs were keeping out water.  Extensive separation of shell plating from structural framing due to corrosion of rivet and plate lap seams.  New coating system failed in Tanks # 4 & 5 with resultant rust/scale. Rust/scale and oil waste from tanks was sandblasted and being dumped into lazarette & Tanks # 4 & 5.  No flooding alarm system installed. No standby pumping capability aboard.  Rudder assembly totally rotted away at waterline and unsupported.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36. Side shell framing separated from shell plating as rivets have failed.
  • 37. Wooden plugs keeping sea water from sinking FOC, aft.
  • 38. Transverse bulkhead of swiss cheese. Totally ineffectual structural member.
  • 39.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42.
  • 43. The bowsprit is rotten and in danger of falling away.
  • 44. The top rig (of wood and associated rigging) wass in poor/dangerous condition and needs to be taken down immediately.
  • 45. Wooden blocks (as depicted above) were in danger of carrying away and endangering personnel below.