Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

World Quality Day 2011 - Contest Rules & Judging Criteria

3,491 views

Published on

Published in: Technology, Business
  • Be the first to comment

World Quality Day 2011 - Contest Rules & Judging Criteria

  1. 1. Case Study Competitions World Quality Day KaizenBreakthrough Process Improvement Innovation
  2. 2. Assessment Process Define & Define & Evaluators Select agree Final Agree final Evaluators Range & Selection Criteria consensus scoring28-Sept-09 First Continual Improvement Symposium 2009 2
  3. 3. Kaizen Evaluators• Experienced track record in Continuous Improvement• Each evaluator was impartial• 3 evaluators 3
  4. 4. Criteria & Weight• Each Kaizen was scored using the following criteria & the following weight was applied across the boardCriteria WeightCreativity 10%Thoroughness in implementation 20%Benefits 25%Participation 20%Standardization 15%Replicability 10% 4
  5. 5. Range Scoring• Each Kaizen received a score for each criteria on a scale of 1 to 10 where:1 10CreativityVery obvious solution / idea Original and novel, & fool proofing is incorporatedThoroughness in implementationImplementation planned but no details Fully and systematically implementedBenefitsUnclear description; hypothetical Quantified and verified benefits to support strategic objectivesParticipationOne individual Group involves most of the employees from work areasStandardizationNo standardization Official standard issued and communicated to all with trainingReplicabilityNo lesson identified Single point lesson identified, horizontal deployment carried out 5
  6. 6. KAIZEN COMPETITION Contest Rules & Judging Criteria
  7. 7. Contest Rules• Total entries – 30• Preliminary evaluation and scoring• Finalist teams – Team 1 – Dubai Cables – Team 2 – DP World – Team 3 – New Medical Center – Team 4 - SRF – Team 5 – Tawam Hospital• Presentation by each team – 4 minutes• Questions and Answers- 2 minutes• Judges will choose best three for Gold, Silver and Bronze Awards 7
  8. 8. Timing• Green light at 2 minutes• Amber light at 3 minutes• Red light at 4 minutes• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (2 minutes) 8
  9. 9. Kaizen Judging Criteria• Creativity 10%• Thoroughness in implementation 20%• Benefits 25%• Participation 20%• Standardization 15%• Replicability 10% 9
  10. 10. INNOVATION COMPETITION Contest Rules & Judging Criteria 10
  11. 11. Contest Rules• Total entries – 10• Preliminary evaluation and scoring• Finalist teams – Team 1 – DP World – Team 2 – EMAL – Team 3 – Kanoo Travels – Team 4 – Mashreq Bank – Team 5 – Tawam Hospital• Presentation by each team – 8 minutes• Questions and Answers- 3 minutes• Judges will choose best three for Gold, Silver and Bronze Awards 11
  12. 12. Timing• Green light at 5 minutes• Amber light at 7 minutes• Red light at 8 minutes• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (3 minutes) 12
  13. 13. Innovation Judging Criteria• Creativity 10%• Thoroughness in implementation – Implementation planning 10% – Extent of Implementation 10%• Benefits 15%• Participation 20%• Standardization 20%• Learning and Replicability 15% 13
  14. 14. BREAKTHROUGHIMPROVEMENT COMPETITION Contest Rules & Judging Criteria 14
  15. 15. Contest Rules• Total entries – 9• Preliminary evaluation and scoring• Finalist teams – Team 1 – DP World – Team 2 – Ducab – Team 3 – Mashreq Bank – Team 4 – Mashreq Bank – Team 5 – Mashreq Bank• Presentation by each team – 8 minutes• Questions and Answers- 3 minutes• Judges will choose best three for Gold, Silver and Bronze Awards 15
  16. 16. Timing• Green light at 5 minutes• Amber light at 7 minutes• Red light at 8 minutes• Presentation must stop within 30 seconds• Questions by Judges (3 minutes) 16
  17. 17. Breakthrough Process Improvement Judging Criteria• Project Identification & Selection 10%• Chartering 15%• Methodology & Use 40%• Results 20%• Learning’s & Leveraging 5%• General View of the Judge 10% 17
  18. 18. Learn, Share, Grow! Celebrate World Quality Day!!Be a part of the Third CII Symposium!!! Thank You.

×