Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Web service        Central Database     Innovative Court TechnologyClaimant PC               Print/mail system            ...
Introduction•   Dory Reiling•   Judge, 1st instance court in Amsterdam•   Dutch judiciary information manager•   Senior ju...
Innovative Court Technology•   Evidence: technology in courts in Europe•   Court innovation•   Innovation with technology ...
CCJE survey         1 Practical court workJudges• write increasingly on computers• About half use models, templates• Some ...
CCJE survey       2 E-access to courts• Some E-filing in half the member  countries• E-filing legislation in more than hal...
CCJE survey         3 Reality checkState of IT innovation in courts in Europe• Files are still paper• E-filing practice is...
IT and Court Innovation• Hard to discuss between judges and  management• Individual cases• Looking back• A model that works
Cases are Different...               -       Outcome unpredictable?     +           -                    1 title        4 ...
...But they have things in common                -       Outcome unpredictable?     +            -                     1 t...
Distribution across case load                    -          Outcome unpredictable?           +              -             ...
Interventions                    -            Outcome unpredictable?         +               -                            ...
Interventions for each group               -           Outcome unpredictable?              +           - Case filing      ...
Most popular among judges:        legal information on lineTraditional              Innovative• National legislation   • L...
Traditional legal information marketProducers   Legislator     Judiciary   Scholars                          PublishersCon...
Legal information market Innovation                     Legislator         Scholars                 Education    Legal pra...
Web servicesIncreasing interactivity1. Information service2. Downloadable forms3. Form e-filing4. Transaction5. Automation...
My Favorite Innovation                  Web service        Central DatabaseClaimant PC                                    ...
Money Claim OnlineTransactionInformation serviceFastAccess for new groups
Resources• Int. Journal for Court Administration  Vol. 3 no. 2 January 2011  Vol. 4 no. 2 June 2012• www.coe.int/ccje• www...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Innovative Court Technology Reiling June 2012

868 views

Published on

Published in: Education, Technology
  • Be the first to comment

Innovative Court Technology Reiling June 2012

  1. 1. Web service Central Database Innovative Court TechnologyClaimant PC Print/mail system XML transfer (Online defences Court Helpdesk from 9.12.02) Admit/offer Defend or or pay Dr. Dory Reiling mag. iur. further help Printed claims Netherlands Defendant responds Served by post
  2. 2. Introduction• Dory Reiling• Judge, 1st instance court in Amsterdam• Dutch judiciary information manager• Senior judicial reform expert World Bank• PhD on Tech support for judicial reform• Chair, knowledge systems user group• www.doryreiling.com• www.doryreiling.blogspot.com• @doryontour
  3. 3. Innovative Court Technology• Evidence: technology in courts in Europe• Court innovation• Innovation with technology in courts• My favorite innovation
  4. 4. CCJE survey 1 Practical court workJudges• write increasingly on computers• About half use models, templates• Some use voice recognitionMajority of courts• monitor length• keep statistics on individual judges
  5. 5. CCJE survey 2 E-access to courts• Some E-filing in half the member countries• E-filing legislation in more than half• Requirements vary• Practice is low• Except in Austria
  6. 6. CCJE survey 3 Reality checkState of IT innovation in courts in Europe• Files are still paper• E-filing practice is low - except in Austria• Electronic files are mostly still experimental• And so are electronic signatures• IT in oral hearings is low• Web services are the next frontier
  7. 7. IT and Court Innovation• Hard to discuss between judges and management• Individual cases• Looking back• A model that works
  8. 8. Cases are Different... - Outcome unpredictable? + - 1 title 4 judgment Partyrelation 2 notarial 3 settlement +
  9. 9. ...But they have things in common - Outcome unpredictable? + - 1 title 4 judgment Party relation 2 notarial 3 settlement +
  10. 10. Distribution across case load - Outcome unpredictable? + - 35 % 8% 1 title 4 judgment Party relation 2 notarial 3 settlement 30 % 9% +Source: NL Judicial Council statistics 2002-2007
  11. 11. Interventions - Outcome unpredictable? + - 35 % 8% 1 title 4 judgment Party relation 2 notarial 3 settlement 30 % 9% +Source: NL Judicial Council statistics
  12. 12. Interventions for each group - Outcome unpredictable? + - Case filing Case filing Automated case Electronic files processing Knowledge management 1 title 4 judgment Partyrelation 2 notarial 3 settlement Case filing Case filing Automated case Web guidance processing Negotiation software + Web guidance
  13. 13. Most popular among judges: legal information on lineTraditional Innovative• National legislation • LII’s• European legislation • Court decision e-• National case law archive• International case • Wiki Juridica law • Integration with• Law review articles education • European Case Law Identifier (ECLI)
  14. 14. Traditional legal information marketProducers Legislator Judiciary Scholars PublishersConsumers Legal practice Judiciary Education
  15. 15. Legal information market Innovation Legislator Scholars Education Legal practice Publishers JudiciaryProducersAndConsumers
  16. 16. Web servicesIncreasing interactivity1. Information service2. Downloadable forms3. Form e-filing4. Transaction5. AutomationSource: EU Benchmark for e-government
  17. 17. My Favorite Innovation Web service Central DatabaseClaimant PC Print/mail system XML transfer (Online defences Court Helpdesk from 9.12.02) Admit/offer Defend or or pay further help Printed claims Defendant responds Served by post
  18. 18. Money Claim OnlineTransactionInformation serviceFastAccess for new groups
  19. 19. Resources• Int. Journal for Court Administration Vol. 3 no. 2 January 2011 Vol. 4 no. 2 June 2012• www.coe.int/ccje• www.coe.int/cepej• www.moneyclaim.gov.uk• www.doryreiling.com

×