Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
Why?
Cognitive Architectures and Deep Thinking
ISSIP Conference Call
21 January, 2016
Jack Park
My Purpose
• Is Not
– To advance our understandings by making claims,
broad or otherwise.
• Is
– To explore avenues which ...
Situation A
• Niel deGrasse Tyson asked Sir Richard Branson
if Sir Richard could grant free rides to space
for politicians...
Situation B
• A person’s parent succumbs to the end game
of a Leukemia.
– The person is told by the parent’s physician tha...
Situation C
• CO2 in the upper atmosphere is claimed to
contribute to climate change
• Why?
• CO2 is defined as a greenhou...
Why Indeed! Aristotle’s 4 Causes*
• Material Cause
– Change related to the material composition
(components)
• Formal Caus...
Final Cause
• Final Cause as:
– Purpose
– Emergent state based on a final binding of the
history
– Anticipation*: a predic...
A Non-living Example
What How Why
A Living Example
Tighter Focus
Why Microbiome?
Anticipatory
Systems:
Closed To Efficient
Cause
Robert Rosen *
(1991): Life Itself
* https://en.wikipedia....
Why Ask Why?
• To Study Complex Systems
– Anticipatory Systems
• Living systems are anticipatory
– Deep Thinking:
• Relati...
Thanks to the
organizers at IBM:
Jim Spohrer
Dianne Fodell
Thanks to reviewers:
Randy Goebel
Mark Szpakowski
Nefer Doane
W...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Why? A Discussion about Cognitive Architectures and Deep Thinking

1,044 views

Published on

A Discussion about Cognitive Architectures and Deep Thinking by Jack Park from TopicQuests Foundation presented at the Cognitive Systems Institute Speaker Series.

Published in: Technology
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Why? A Discussion about Cognitive Architectures and Deep Thinking

  1. 1. Why? Cognitive Architectures and Deep Thinking ISSIP Conference Call 21 January, 2016 Jack Park
  2. 2. My Purpose • Is Not – To advance our understandings by making claims, broad or otherwise. • Is – To explore avenues which can lead to advanced understandings by way of illustrations , with a touch of theoretical considerations – To start a larger conversation…
  3. 3. Situation A • Niel deGrasse Tyson asked Sir Richard Branson if Sir Richard could grant free rides to space for politicians and world leaders* • Why? • Tyson had stated that every astronaut he interviewed could not imagine lifting arms against another human after experiencing Earth from space. • Why? * http://www.techinsider.stfi.re/neil-degrasse-tyson-meets-pepper-the-robot-at-clinton-globale-initiative-2015-9?sf=aaeoxy after minute 46 in the video
  4. 4. Situation B • A person’s parent succumbs to the end game of a Leukemia. – The person is told by the parent’s physician that Leukemias are not familial; nothing to worry about. – Several years later, that person is diagnosed with the same Leukemia. • Why?
  5. 5. Situation C • CO2 in the upper atmosphere is claimed to contribute to climate change • Why? • CO2 is defined as a greenhouse gas. Greenhouse gases contribute to climate change. • Why?
  6. 6. Why Indeed! Aristotle’s 4 Causes* • Material Cause – Change related to the material composition (components) • Formal Cause – Change related to the arrangement, shape, structure (design) • Efficient Cause – Change related to agency (carpenters) • Final Cause – Change related to the target to which change directs (purpose) * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_causes
  7. 7. Final Cause • Final Cause as: – Purpose – Emergent state based on a final binding of the history – Anticipation*: a predictive model *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anticipation_(artificial_intelligence) Robert Rosen (1985): Anticipatory Systems
  8. 8. A Non-living Example What How Why
  9. 9. A Living Example
  10. 10. Tighter Focus
  11. 11. Why Microbiome? Anticipatory Systems: Closed To Efficient Cause Robert Rosen * (1991): Life Itself * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Rosen_(theoretical_biologist)
  12. 12. Why Ask Why? • To Study Complex Systems – Anticipatory Systems • Living systems are anticipatory – Deep Thinking: • Relational Models of complex systems entail examination of all aspects of causality A system containing a predictive model of itself and/or its environment, which allows it to change state at an instant in accord with the model's predictions pertaining to a later instant. (Rosen)* *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anticipation_(artificial_intelligence) Robert Rosen (1985): Anticipatory Systems
  13. 13. Thanks to the organizers at IBM: Jim Spohrer Dianne Fodell Thanks to reviewers: Randy Goebel Mark Szpakowski Nefer Doane Why Not? Cognitive Systems Institute talks are archived at http://cognitive-science.info/community/weekly-update/ jackpark@topicquests.org

×