1.
SOLIDMARTIJN DASHORST
topicus

2.
AGENDA
INTRODUCTIE
SOLID
CONCLUSIE & DISCUSSIE

3.
INTRO

4.
Acroniemen
TCP
IP XP
SOLID
JAVA EE
JSP JPA
SOAP
SMTP
SNMP
OSI
HTTP
HATEOAS
POM
PINO
JAREAR
EJB
C#
JAX-B JAX-P
JAX-WS
JAX-RS
SAAJ
k8sl10n
i18n
GRASPKISS
STAVAZA
MOSCOW
YAGNI

5.
SOLID
Robert C. Martin
"Uncle Bob"

6.
SOLID
Robert C. Martin Copyright (c) 2000 by Robert C. Martin. All Rights Reserved.
www.objectmentor.com
1
Design Principles and
Design Patterns
Robert C. Martinwww.objectmentor.com
What is software architecture? The answer is multitiered. At the highest level, there
are the architecture patterns that define the overall shape and structure of software
applications1
. Down a level is the architecture that is specifically related to the pur-
pose of the software application. Yet another level down resides the architecture of
the modules and their interconnections. This is the domain of design patterns2
, pack-
akges, components, and classes. It is this level that we will concern ourselves with in
this chapter.
Our scope in this chapter is quite limitted. There is much more to be said about the
principles and patterns that are exposed here. Interested readers are referred to
[Martin99].
Architecture and DependenciesWhat goes wrong with software? The design of many software applications begins as
a vital image in the minds of its designers. At this stage it is clean, elegant, and com-
pelling. It has a simple beauty that makes the designers and implementers itch to see it
working. Some of these applications manage to maintain this purity of design through
the initial development and into the first release.But then something begins to happen. The software starts to rot. At first it isn’t so
bad. An ugly wart here, a clumsy hack there, but the beauty of the design still shows
through. Yet, over time as the rotting continues, the ugly festering sores and boils
accumulate until they dominate the design of the application. The program becomes a
festering mass of code that the developers find increasingly hard to maintain. Eventu-1. [Shaw96]
2. [GOF96]

7.
SOLID
Single Responsibility Principle
Open Closed Principle
Lishkov Substitution Principle
Interface Segregation Principle
Dependency Inversion Principle

8.
SOLID

9.
SOLID

10.
A class should only have a single
responsibility, that is, only changes to one
part of the software's specification should
be able to affect the specification of the
class.
wikipedia.org

11.
Één verantwoordelijkheid per klasse:
één reden om te wijzigen.

12.
public static void main(String[] args) {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je voornaam? "));
user.setAchternaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je achternaam? "));
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

13.
public static void main(String[] args) {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je voornaam? "));
user.setAchternaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je achternaam? "));
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

14.
public static void main(String[] args) {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je voornaam? "));
user.setAchternaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je achternaam? "));
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

15.
public static void main(String[] args) {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je voornaam? "));
user.setAchternaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je achternaam? "));
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

16.
public static void main(String[] args) {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je voornaam? "));
user.setAchternaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je achternaam? "));
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

17.
public class PersonDataCapture {
public Person getUserData() {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je voornaam? "));
user.setAchternaam(System.console().readLine("Wat is je achternaam? "));
return user;
}
}

18.
public static void main(String[] args) {
PersonDataCapture input = new PersonDataCapture();
Person user = input.getUserData();
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

19.
public static void main(String[] args) {
PersonDataCapture input = new PersonDataCapture();
Person user = input.getUserData();
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

20.
public class PersonValidator {
public boolean isValidUser(Person user) {
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegeven");
return false;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().isBlank()) {
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgegeven");
return false;
}
return true;
}
}

21.
public static void main(String[] args) {
PersonDataCapture input = new PersonDataCapture();
Person user = input.getUserData();
PersonValidator validator = new PersonValidator();
if (!validator.isValidUser(user)) {
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

22.
public static void main(String[] args) {
PersonDataCapture input = new PersonDataCapture();
Person user = input.getUserData();
PersonValidator validator = new PersonValidator();
if (!validator.isValidUser(user)) {
return;
}
console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam());
}

23.
public class AccountGenerator {
public String generateAccountFor(Person user) {
return user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getAchternaam();
}
}

24.
public static void main(String[] args) {
PersonDataCapture input = new PersonDataCapture();
Person user = input.getUserData();
PersonValidator validator = new PersonValidator();
if (!validator.isValidUser(user)) {
return;
}
AccountGenerator generator = new AccountGenerator();
String accountnaam = generator.generateAccountFor(user);
System.console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn", accountnaam);
}

25.
public static void main(String[] args) {
PersonDataCapture input = new PersonDataCapture();
Person user = input.getUserData();
PersonValidator validator = new PersonValidator();
if (!validator.isValidUser(user)) {
return;
}
AccountGenerator generator = new AccountGenerator();
String accountnaam = generator.generateAccountFor(user);
System.console().printf("Je accountnaam is: %snn",
accountnaam);
}
public class AccountGenerator {
public String generateAccountFor(Person user) {
return user.getVoornaam().substring(0, 1) + user.getA
}
}
public class PersonValidator {
public boolean isValidUser(Person user) {
if (user.getVoornaam() == null || user.getVoornaam().isBlan
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige voornaam opgegev
return false;
}
if (user.getAchternaam() == null || user.getAchternaam().is
console().printf("Je hebt geen geldige achternaam opgeg
return false;
}
return true;
}
}
public class PersonDataCapture {
public Person getUserData() {
Person user = new Person();
user.setVoornaam(console().readLine("Wat is je voorna
user.setAchternaam(console().readLine("Wat is je acht
return user;
}
}

26.
SOLID

27.
open for extension
closed for modification

28.
class Rectangle {
int width;
int height;
}

29.
class AreaCalculator {
public double area(Rectangle... rectangles) {
double area = 0;
for (var r : rectangles) {
area += r.height * r.width;
}
return area;
}
}
Rectangle r1 = new Rectangle();
r1.width = 2;
r1.height = 3;
var calc = new AreaCalculator();
System.out.println(calc.area(r1));

30.
class Rectangle {
int width;
int height;
}
class Circle {
int radius;
}

31.
class AreaCalculator {
public double area(Object... shapes) {
double area = 0;
for (var s : shapes) {
if (s instanceof Rectangle) {
var r = (Rectangle) s;
area += r.height * r.width;
} else if (s instanceof Circle) {
var c = (Circle) s;
area += c.radius * c.radius * Math.PI;
}
}
return area;
}
}

32.
var rect = new Rectangle();
rect.width = 2;
rect.height = 3;
var circle = new Circle();
circle.radius = 2;
System.out.println(new AreaCalculator().area(rect, circle));

33.
abstract class Shape {
public abstract double area();
}
class Rectangle extends Shape {
int height, width;
public double area() {
return width * height;
}
}
class Circle extends Shape {
int radius;
public double area() {
return radius * radius * Math.PI;
}
}

34.
class AreaCalculator {
public double area(Shape... shapes) {
double area = 0;
for (var s : shapes) {
area += s.area();
}
return area;
}
}

35.
SOLID

36.
...in a computer program, if S is a
subtype of T, then objects of type T
may be replaced with objects of
type S without altering any of the
desirable properties of the program
(correctness, task performed, etc.)
wikipedia.org
Liskov substitution principle

37.
Objecten moeten zich netjes
gedragen...
TLDR; principe

38.
Waar een A verwacht
wordt, moet een B zich
gelijksoortig gedragen B
A

39.
interface Sender {
void send(String s);
}
class SmtpSender implements Sender {
@Override
public void send(String s) {
}
}
class FtpSender implements Sender {
@Override
public void send(String s) {
}
}

40.
interface Sender {
void send(String s);
}
class SmtpSender implements Sender {
@Override
public void send(String s) {
if (s.startsWith("banaan"))
throw new IllegalStateException();
}
}
class FtpSender implements Sender {
@Override
public void send(String s) {
}
}

41.
interface Sender {
void send(String s);
}
class SmtpSender implements Sender {
@Override
public boolean send(String s) {
}
}
class FtpSender implements Sender {
@Override
public void send(Integer s) {
}
}

42.
class Filer {
public boolean file(String x) throws FileAlreadyExistsException {
return false;
}
}

43.
class Filer {
public boolean file(String x) throws FileAlreadyExistsException {
return false;
}
}
class NetworkFiler extends Filer {
public boolean file(String x)
throws FileAlreadyExistsException, SocketException {
return false;
}
}

44.
class Rectangle {
private int width, height;
public void setHeight(int h) {}
public void setWidth(int w) {}
public int getHeight() {}
public int getWidth() {}
}
static void fillRect(Rectangle r) {
r.setHeight(50);
r.setWidth(150);
assert (r.getHeight() == 50);
assert (r.getWidth() == 150);
}
Rectangle r = new Rectangle();
fillRect(r);

45.
class Rectangle {
private int width, height;
public void setHeight(int h) {}
public void setWidth(int w) {}
public int getHeight() {}
public int getWidth() {}
}
class Square extends Rectangle {
public void setHeight(int h) {
super.setHeight(h);
super.setWidth(h);
}
public void setWidth(int w) {
super.setWidth(w);
super.setHeight(w);
}
}
static void fillRect(Rectangle r) {
r.setHeight(50);
r.setWidth(150);
assert (r.getHeight() == 50);
assert (r.getWidth() == 150);
}
Square s = new Square();
s.setHeight(100);
fillRect(s);

46.
SOLID

47.
No client should be forced to depend on
methods it does not use
wikipedia.org
Interface Segregation Principle

48.
interface Shape {
public double getArea();
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
void draw();
}

49.
interface Shape {
public double getArea();
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
void draw();
}
class Rectangle implements Shape {
private int width, height;
public double getArea() {
return width * height;
}
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape othe
public void draw() {}
}

50.
interface Shape {
public double getArea();
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
void draw();
}
class Rectangle implements Shape {
private int width, height;
public double getArea() {
return width * height;
}
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape othe
public void draw() {}
}
class Circle implements Shape {
private int radius;
public double getArea() {
return radius * radius * Math.PI;
}
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other)
public void draw() {}
}

51.
interface Shape {
public double getArea();
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
void draw();
}
class Rectangle implements Shape {
private int width, height;
public double getArea() {
return width * height;
}
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape othe
public void draw() {}
}
class Circle implements Shape {
private int radius;
public double getArea() {
return radius * radius * Math.PI;
}
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other)
public void draw() {}
}
class Point implements Shape {
private int x, y;
public void draw() {}
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other)
}

52.
interface Drawable {
void draw();
}
interface Shape {
boolean congruentWith(Shape other);
}
interface Area extends Shape {
double area();
}

53.
interface Drawable {
void draw();
}
interface Shape {
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
}
interface Area extends Shape {
double area();
}
class Rectangle implements Drawable,
Area, Shape {
private int height, width;
public void draw() {
}
public boolean isCongruentWith(Shape
}
public double area() {
}
}

54.
interface Drawable {
void draw();
}
interface Shape {
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
}
interface Area extends Shape {
double area();
}
class Circle implements Drawable,
Area, Shape {
private int radius;
public void draw() {
}
public boolean congruentWith(Shape ot
}
public double area() {
}
}

55.
interface Drawable {
void draw();
}
interface Shape {
boolean isCongruentWith(Shape other);
}
interface Area extends Shape {
double area();
}
class Point implements Drawable, Shape {
private int x, y;
public void draw() {
}
public boolean congruentWith(Shape ot
}
}

56.
• Java Collections
• Java IO streams

57.
SOLID

58.
Depend upon abstractions,
not concretions
Dependency Inversion Principle

59.
1. High-level modules should not depend
on low-level modules. Both should
depend on abstractions.
2. Abstractions should not depend on
details. Details should depend on
abstractions.
1. High-level modules should not depend
on low-level modules. Both should
depend on abstractions.
2. Abstractions should not depend on
details. Details should depend on
abstractions.

60.
LeerlingDAO RapportService

61.
LeerlingDAOImpl RapportService
LeerlingDAO

62.
Wanneer je het Open/Closed Principle
toepast, volgt "automatisch"
Dependency Inversion
iemand op internet

63.
CONC
LUSIE

64.
SOLID
Single Responsibility Principle
Open Closed Principle
Lishkov Substitution Principle
Interface Segregation Principle
Dependency Inversion Principle

65.
SOLID
Single Responsibility Principle
Open Closed Principle
Lishkov Substitution Principle
Interface Segregation Principle
Dependency Inversion Principle
GRASP
General
Responsibility
Assignment
Software
Patterns

66.
SOLID GRASP
Het *wat* Het *hoe* en waarom

67.
Refactoring
Code Ownership
Continuous Delivery

68.
SOLID
DRY
YAGNI
GRASP
PATTERNS
REFACTORING

69.
Meer lezen/zien?
• GRASP
(wikipedia)
• Refactoring (2nd Edition)
Martin Fowler (boek)
• Clean Code
Robert C. Martin (boek)
• Readable code - and the long
lost secret of how to achieve it
Christin Gorman (video, 10min)

70.
Discussie