SlideShare a Scribd company logo

Not anti government but irrelevant government

The Canadian socio-economy has been experiencing difficulties since the early 1970s. Neither the New Public Management nor the Program Review experiments of the 1990s succeeded in generating effective repairs. After a long episode in the application of redistribution to assuage those hurt by the governance failures, new forms of organization and mechanisms of coordination are beginning to provide bottom up alternatives to government.

1 of 10
Download to read offline
NOT ANTI-GOVERNMENT BUT
IRRELEVANT GOVERNMENT
Paper by Christopher Wilson & Gilles Paquet
Centre on Governance, University of Ottawa
Presented to the PATheory.net Conference
May 28-31, 2015
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
PATheory.net
A PAPER IN 3 PARTS
 Part One – an analysis of contemporary anti-government phenomena
 Part Two – deals with the dual failure in resolving the coordination problems from the
administrative crises of the 1970s and 1990s in Canada
 The failure of New Public Management to replace Big ‘G’ Government with market
approaches; and
 the subsequent abandonment of efforts to repair the coordination failures in favour of
attempts at redistribution to compensate different groups claiming hurt from those failures
 Part Three – describes how this dual failure has opened the door to new avenues for
small ‘g’ governance that is seen in the emerging interest in alternative methods of
coordination and sharing that are occurring on the margins of the socio-economy
that are designed to make citizens less dependent on government for coordination
purposes, and the government much less indispensable
 See our paper: Government Failure and Antigovernment Phenomena
ANTI-GOVERNMENT ATTITUDES
 Anti-government attitudes are incontrovertibly symptoms of public
discontent at the actions or inactions of government, however
legitimate or defensible those actions may appear to be to
government decision makers
 Anti-government attitudes -- as a reflection of social movements --
may be enlightened, or not, but they are definitely many-
dimensional, ill-defined, a complex of motivations, and only an
obliquely and imprecisely measurable
 Often they are aggregations of Rorschachian, ‘inkblot’,
interpretations of what is really going on. We caution against such
over simplifications that can lead to “a fantasy-land of self
righteousness” (Sibley 2013)
THE ARGUMENT
 Anti-government phenomena are wicked problems involving a spectrum of
government activities – coordination, redistribution, and stabilization as well as
citizen education and ideological aspects (Musgrave 1959)
 Anti-government a la 1970s was a reaction to coordination failures observed in
government, resulting from being too hierarchical and overly coercive, which
manifested in the era of New Public Management in the 80s and 90s
 The inability to make reforms on the coordination front increased the dependency
of government actors on redistribution to retain their legitimacy by compensating
people for the effects those coordination failures had on them
 Redistribution went from being a tool of convenience post WWII to compensate for
declines in private sector activities TO compensating for under spending in areas of public
goods like health & education TO being regarded as valuable in its own right in an era of
egalitarianism where preferences >> needs, needs >> worthy deserts, deserts >> rights and
rights >> absolute rights of entitlement (Kekes 2003)
 Today’s anti-government is paradoxical – i.e. government is too big, too ineffective,
demands too much & is too untrustworthy BUT government is not big enough, not doing
enough to give me what I want or imagine I need & and is the only societal actor I trust to
protect my rights
THE ARGUMENT (CONT’D)
 The failure of government to refurbish itself in the coordination game & to rely
almost exclusively on redistribution has:
 Tarnished the confidence of citizens (down to 9%) in government’s ability to solve
complex problems (Nanos-IRRP poll 2012)
 Generated decreasing concerns to complexity (Tainter 1990)
 Generated public expenditures (eg. Health & education) that are threatening to
bankrupt the state within decades (Levert 2013)
 Given renewed interest to the type of small ‘g’ governance regimes that abound
in uncentralized networks (Cleveland 2002)
 Encouraged development of alternatives to government whether in terms of
social technologies (like P3s or community-based approaches), or the burgeoning
new ICT technologies in so many diverse areas (including garbage collection,
disaster relief, collective decision making, & economic management through the
use of network tools like the blockchain)
 Encouraged the notion that citizens and businesses can “exit” (like emigration of
old) unproductive, unresponsive government institutions into a virtual world where
governments have little influence & value adding innovation is more the norm
CULTURE GOVERNANCE
 As social complexity grows, hierarchies and markets are insufficient to provide
social learning and innovation. According to Farrell & Shalizi (2013), democracy
is the mechanism best suited to bring together different perspectives,
knowledge, and access to resources and power
 Every society is the product of the conversations that take place among its
members (Block 2008) and this collective conversation leads to a continually
evolving culture governance (Bang 2003) that steers society on the basis of
embedded propensities, conventions, paradigms and accepted practices and
mechanisms
 In this light, the incapacity of the anti-government attitudes of the 80s and 90s to
trigger greater transformation of coordination practices was in part due to a
culture governance that resisted arguments around value adding and
increased efficiency and instead welcomed notions of value redistribution. This
was reinforced by failed structural reforms (such as those proposed in Canada’s
Program Review in the late 90s) and a popular, ‘no-fault’ belief that “if you
can’t fix it, then compensate me for it”
 The culture governance of redistribution has become a powerful dampening
force on public sector reform & lies at the root of much of the popular
discontent with government

Recommended

On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...
On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...
On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...TravisDriessen1
 
On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...
On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...
On Hypermodern Regenerative Economics and Hyper-Local Regenerative Food Syste...TravisDriessen1
 
CURRENT ISSUES IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
CURRENT ISSUES IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONCURRENT ISSUES IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
CURRENT ISSUES IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATIONGinandjar Kartasasmita
 
An Interdisciplinary Solution to the Problem of Creation and Development
An Interdisciplinary Solution to the Problem of Creation and DevelopmentAn Interdisciplinary Solution to the Problem of Creation and Development
An Interdisciplinary Solution to the Problem of Creation and DevelopmentMichelle Kirkland Fitch
 

More Related Content

What's hot

Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)Ginandjar Kartasasmita
 
Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012
Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012
Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012Alia Khan
 
I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019
I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019
I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019Ginandjar Kartasasmita
 
Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)Ginandjar Kartasasmita
 
Effects of globalization on public administration
Effects of globalization on public administrationEffects of globalization on public administration
Effects of globalization on public administrationamanlodha5
 
Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)Ginandjar Kartasasmita
 
Retos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito local
Retos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito localRetos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito local
Retos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito localAsociación KyoPol - Symbiotic City
 
'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...
'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...
'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...Dr Igor Calzada, MBA, FeRSA
 
The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012
The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012
The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012Ilaria Boniburini
 
Theory of mass society
Theory of mass society Theory of mass society
Theory of mass society asmamaqsood4
 
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the UniversitySocial sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the UniversityRichard Hall
 
Democratic Values in Planning
Democratic Values in PlanningDemocratic Values in Planning
Democratic Values in PlanningRoberto Rocco
 

What's hot (20)

Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 6 (UNPAS 2012)
 
Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012
Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012
Womens Movements Econ Power Khan Veneklasen 2012
 
DEVELOPMENT AND ADMINISTRATION (II)
DEVELOPMENT AND ADMINISTRATION (II)DEVELOPMENT AND ADMINISTRATION (II)
DEVELOPMENT AND ADMINISTRATION (II)
 
I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019
I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019
I. Challenges to Public Leadership 2019
 
Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 4 (UNPAS 2012)
 
Esfera publica
Esfera publicaEsfera publica
Esfera publica
 
Effects of globalization on public administration
Effects of globalization on public administrationEffects of globalization on public administration
Effects of globalization on public administration
 
Chapter16
Chapter16Chapter16
Chapter16
 
Aartscholteaccountable
AartscholteaccountableAartscholteaccountable
Aartscholteaccountable
 
Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)
Development Administration chapter 5 (UNPAS 2012)
 
03 sfeir younis
03 sfeir younis03 sfeir younis
03 sfeir younis
 
JPAE 17(2) Article --- W. Haynes
JPAE 17(2) Article  --- W. HaynesJPAE 17(2) Article  --- W. Haynes
JPAE 17(2) Article --- W. Haynes
 
Retos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito local
Retos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito localRetos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito local
Retos de la aplicación de las TIC a la participación en el ámbito local
 
'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...
'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...
'Do Digital Social Networks Foster Civilian Participation among Millennials? ...
 
The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012
The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012
The right to the city_Boniburini_ 2012
 
Theory of mass society
Theory of mass society Theory of mass society
Theory of mass society
 
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the UniversitySocial sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
Social sustainability, mass intellectuality and the idea of the University
 
Concepts and Definitions
Concepts and DefinitionsConcepts and Definitions
Concepts and Definitions
 
Development And Administration (I)
Development And Administration (I)Development And Administration (I)
Development And Administration (I)
 
Democratic Values in Planning
Democratic Values in PlanningDemocratic Values in Planning
Democratic Values in Planning
 

Viewers also liked

Parallel Computing in R
Parallel Computing in RParallel Computing in R
Parallel Computing in Rmickey24
 
Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015
Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015
Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015abdullah al-Thani
 
Cuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicología
Cuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicologíaCuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicología
Cuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicologíareinamontilla0601
 
TOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions team
TOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions teamTOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions team
TOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions teamDonald Hume
 
Global Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORS
Global Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORSGlobal Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORS
Global Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORSGlobal Medical Cures™
 
17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect
17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect
17.05.11_Game for visual field deffectEri Shiroyama
 
Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...
Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...
Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...Joris Faure
 
Disorders of consciousness
Disorders of consciousnessDisorders of consciousness
Disorders of consciousnessHena Jawaid
 
Sarah Varian resume 2
Sarah Varian resume 2Sarah Varian resume 2
Sarah Varian resume 2Sarah Varian
 
Origin of India (India Renaissance)
Origin of India (India Renaissance)Origin of India (India Renaissance)
Origin of India (India Renaissance)Trinity Dwarka
 
Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)
Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)
Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)Hassan WAHSISS
 
110627 soutenance memoire
110627 soutenance memoire110627 soutenance memoire
110627 soutenance memoireJeenuuke
 
Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...
Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...
Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...Hassan WAHSISS
 
ESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIA
ESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIAESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIA
ESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIAmdcarvajalm
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Parallel Computing in R
Parallel Computing in RParallel Computing in R
Parallel Computing in R
 
Efruzhu anti̇cancer drug hu north cyprus 29
Efruzhu  anti̇cancer  drug  hu  north  cyprus  29Efruzhu  anti̇cancer  drug  hu  north  cyprus  29
Efruzhu anti̇cancer drug hu north cyprus 29
 
Le 18/20 de l'APACOM
Le 18/20 de l'APACOMLe 18/20 de l'APACOM
Le 18/20 de l'APACOM
 
Tecnología educativa
Tecnología educativaTecnología educativa
Tecnología educativa
 
Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015
Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015
Cis017 6 revision-parallel_2015
 
Cuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicología
Cuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicologíaCuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicología
Cuadro comparativo modelos y teorías de la psicología
 
TOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions team
TOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions teamTOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions team
TOI Integrated Business Intelligence Review 06-02 solutions team
 
Global Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORS
Global Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORSGlobal Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORS
Global Medical Cures™ | DIABETES RISK FACTORS
 
17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect
17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect
17.05.11_Game for visual field deffect
 
Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...
Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...
Présentation de la protection des données dans SharePoint - Global Conférence...
 
Marka epilepsy
Marka epilepsyMarka epilepsy
Marka epilepsy
 
Disorders of consciousness
Disorders of consciousnessDisorders of consciousness
Disorders of consciousness
 
Sarah Varian resume 2
Sarah Varian resume 2Sarah Varian resume 2
Sarah Varian resume 2
 
Origin of India (India Renaissance)
Origin of India (India Renaissance)Origin of India (India Renaissance)
Origin of India (India Renaissance)
 
Adenekan Adewunmi Isaac CV
Adenekan Adewunmi Isaac CVAdenekan Adewunmi Isaac CV
Adenekan Adewunmi Isaac CV
 
Ubuntu 15.04
Ubuntu 15.04Ubuntu 15.04
Ubuntu 15.04
 
Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)
Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)
Module rh de l'ERP Odoo (ex OpenERP)
 
110627 soutenance memoire
110627 soutenance memoire110627 soutenance memoire
110627 soutenance memoire
 
Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...
Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...
Rapport sur quelques fonctionnalités du module de gestion des ressources huma...
 
ESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIA
ESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIAESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIA
ESTUDIO DE LA BIODIVERSIDAD EN COLOMBIA
 

Similar to Not anti government but irrelevant government

Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...
Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...
Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...zsbattfiacatnueve
 
Microsoft word 20 big ideas for 2012.doc
Microsoft word   20 big ideas for 2012.docMicrosoft word   20 big ideas for 2012.doc
Microsoft word 20 big ideas for 2012.docjafercar
 
Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...
Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...
Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...Future Agenda
 
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTUSantosConleyha
 
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTUBenitoSumpter862
 
BIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETY
BIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETYBIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETY
BIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETYTwittercrisis
 
The Third Era (highlight booklet)
The Third Era (highlight booklet)The Third Era (highlight booklet)
The Third Era (highlight booklet)Richard Lum
 
Rao 3e issues and institutions in governance
Rao 3e   issues and institutions in governanceRao 3e   issues and institutions in governance
Rao 3e issues and institutions in governanceSizwan Ahammed
 
2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx
2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx
2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docxrhetttrevannion
 
The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...
The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...
The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...Abel Diale
 
RETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptx
RETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptxRETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptx
RETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptxUnarineNdou
 
Law, governance and the challenges for development
Law, governance and the challenges for developmentLaw, governance and the challenges for development
Law, governance and the challenges for developmentAlexander Decker
 
Transforming Governance
Transforming GovernanceTransforming Governance
Transforming GovernanceNicole Cabral
 
Governance and Comparative Politics
Governance and Comparative PoliticsGovernance and Comparative Politics
Governance and Comparative PoliticsTri Widodo W. UTOMO
 
Lesser Developed Countries
Lesser Developed CountriesLesser Developed Countries
Lesser Developed CountriesSheila Guy
 
Development Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining factors
Development Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining  factorsDevelopment Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining  factors
Development Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining factorsPrazwal Pradhan
 
Classical Public Theory
Classical Public TheoryClassical Public Theory
Classical Public Theorywenhsing yang
 

Similar to Not anti government but irrelevant government (20)

Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...
Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...
Public Administration in the twentieth-first CenturyTheory and Practice Repor...
 
Microsoft word 20 big ideas for 2012.doc
Microsoft word   20 big ideas for 2012.docMicrosoft word   20 big ideas for 2012.doc
Microsoft word 20 big ideas for 2012.doc
 
Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...
Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...
Future of government - An initial perspective - Cheryl Chung, Lead Strategist...
 
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTU
 
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY  March 2000Peters, Pierre  MUTU
10ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY March 2000Peters, Pierre MUTU
 
BIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETY
BIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETYBIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETY
BIG SOCIETY, BIG DATA. THE RADICALISATION OF THE NETWORK SOCIETY
 
The Third Era (highlight booklet)
The Third Era (highlight booklet)The Third Era (highlight booklet)
The Third Era (highlight booklet)
 
Rao 3e issues and institutions in governance
Rao 3e   issues and institutions in governanceRao 3e   issues and institutions in governance
Rao 3e issues and institutions in governance
 
2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx
2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx
2Running Head THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR.docx
 
The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...
The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...
The Importance of State-Business Relations in Advancing Developmental Goals i...
 
RETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptx
RETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptxRETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptx
RETHINKING THE IDENTITY OF ADMINISTRATION CPUC 032 (2).pptx
 
poli 480.pdf
poli 480.pdfpoli 480.pdf
poli 480.pdf
 
Law, governance and the challenges for development
Law, governance and the challenges for developmentLaw, governance and the challenges for development
Law, governance and the challenges for development
 
Transforming Governance
Transforming GovernanceTransforming Governance
Transforming Governance
 
5th wave social impact evaluation
5th wave social impact evaluation5th wave social impact evaluation
5th wave social impact evaluation
 
Governance and Comparative Politics
Governance and Comparative PoliticsGovernance and Comparative Politics
Governance and Comparative Politics
 
Lesser Developed Countries
Lesser Developed CountriesLesser Developed Countries
Lesser Developed Countries
 
Sociology
SociologySociology
Sociology
 
Development Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining factors
Development Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining  factorsDevelopment Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining  factors
Development Management and Bureaucracy restraining and constraining factors
 
Classical Public Theory
Classical Public TheoryClassical Public Theory
Classical Public Theory
 

More from Christopher Wilson

Time for a new paradigm of government
Time for a new paradigm of governmentTime for a new paradigm of government
Time for a new paradigm of governmentChristopher Wilson
 
Intelligent Governance: An Alternative Paradigm
Intelligent Governance: An Alternative ParadigmIntelligent Governance: An Alternative Paradigm
Intelligent Governance: An Alternative ParadigmChristopher Wilson
 
The Internet Will Make Governments Unrecognizable
The Internet Will Make Governments UnrecognizableThe Internet Will Make Governments Unrecognizable
The Internet Will Make Governments UnrecognizableChristopher Wilson
 
From leadership to stewardship
From leadership to stewardshipFrom leadership to stewardship
From leadership to stewardshipChristopher Wilson
 
Mechanisms of Collaboration and Engagement
Mechanisms of Collaboration and EngagementMechanisms of Collaboration and Engagement
Mechanisms of Collaboration and EngagementChristopher Wilson
 
Developmental evaluation learning as you go
Developmental evaluation learning as you goDevelopmental evaluation learning as you go
Developmental evaluation learning as you goChristopher Wilson
 
Setting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in Mind
Setting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in MindSetting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in Mind
Setting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in MindChristopher Wilson
 
Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships
Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships
Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships Christopher Wilson
 
Complexity, risk and collaboration
Complexity, risk and collaborationComplexity, risk and collaboration
Complexity, risk and collaborationChristopher Wilson
 
PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010
PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010
PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010Christopher Wilson
 

More from Christopher Wilson (13)

Time for a new paradigm of government
Time for a new paradigm of governmentTime for a new paradigm of government
Time for a new paradigm of government
 
Reimagining Global Governance
Reimagining  Global GovernanceReimagining  Global Governance
Reimagining Global Governance
 
Intelligent Governance: An Alternative Paradigm
Intelligent Governance: An Alternative ParadigmIntelligent Governance: An Alternative Paradigm
Intelligent Governance: An Alternative Paradigm
 
Re-imagining Government
Re-imagining GovernmentRe-imagining Government
Re-imagining Government
 
The Internet Will Make Governments Unrecognizable
The Internet Will Make Governments UnrecognizableThe Internet Will Make Governments Unrecognizable
The Internet Will Make Governments Unrecognizable
 
From leadership to stewardship
From leadership to stewardshipFrom leadership to stewardship
From leadership to stewardship
 
Mechanisms of Collaboration and Engagement
Mechanisms of Collaboration and EngagementMechanisms of Collaboration and Engagement
Mechanisms of Collaboration and Engagement
 
Developmental evaluation learning as you go
Developmental evaluation learning as you goDevelopmental evaluation learning as you go
Developmental evaluation learning as you go
 
Setting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in Mind
Setting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in MindSetting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in Mind
Setting Up for Collaboration: Top Four Things to Keep in Mind
 
Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships
Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships
Metaphors, biases & learning partnerships
 
Complexity, risk and collaboration
Complexity, risk and collaborationComplexity, risk and collaboration
Complexity, risk and collaboration
 
PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010
PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010
PHAC Knowledge Exchange Forum Nov 2010
 
The Community We Want
The Community We WantThe Community We Want
The Community We Want
 

Recently uploaded

UN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome Document
UN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome DocumentUN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome Document
UN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome DocumentEnergy for One World
 
Item # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC Minutes
Item # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC MinutesItem # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC Minutes
Item # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC Minutesahcitycouncil
 
Presentation of the European Youth Foundation
Presentation of the European Youth FoundationPresentation of the European Youth Foundation
Presentation of the European Youth FoundationEuropeanYouthFoundation
 
IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024
IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024
IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024Energy for One World
 
How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...
How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...
How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...Centre of Policy and Legal Reform
 
MPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptx
MPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptxMPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptx
MPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptxJo Balucanag - Bitonio
 
Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24
Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24
Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24nissamant
 
PM International Conference 24 Poster Template
PM International Conference 24 Poster TemplatePM International Conference 24 Poster Template
PM International Conference 24 Poster Templatenissamant
 
Trading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standards
Trading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standardsTrading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standards
Trading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standardsResolutionFoundation
 
Monroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 Presentation
Monroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 PresentationMonroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 Presentation
Monroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 Presentationabbystainfield
 
PMAI PM24 International Conference Program Schedule
PMAI PM24 International Conference Program SchedulePMAI PM24 International Conference Program Schedule
PMAI PM24 International Conference Program Schedulenissamant
 
Central Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs Agreement
Central Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs AgreementCentral Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs Agreement
Central Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs AgreementVictoriaColangelo
 
PMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster Presentation
PMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster PresentationPMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster Presentation
PMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster Presentationnissamant
 
Lecture Presentation on Project Proposal
Lecture Presentation on Project ProposalLecture Presentation on Project Proposal
Lecture Presentation on Project ProposalJo Balucanag - Bitonio
 
Observance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdf
Observance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdfObservance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdf
Observance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdfChristina Parmionova
 
Item # 4 - Community Improvement Grant Awards
Item # 4 - Community Improvement Grant AwardsItem # 4 - Community Improvement Grant Awards
Item # 4 - Community Improvement Grant Awardsahcitycouncil
 
2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation
2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation
2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study PresentationVictoriaColangelo
 
Vertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptx
Vertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptxVertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptx
Vertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptxNAP Global Network
 

Recently uploaded (20)

UN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome Document
UN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome DocumentUN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome Document
UN Summit of the Future: Draft Outcome Document
 
Rahil Foundation
Rahil Foundation Rahil Foundation
Rahil Foundation
 
Revised Investigative Report on City Officials
Revised Investigative Report on City OfficialsRevised Investigative Report on City Officials
Revised Investigative Report on City Officials
 
Item # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC Minutes
Item # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC MinutesItem # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC Minutes
Item # 1a - February 12, 2024 CC Minutes
 
Presentation of the European Youth Foundation
Presentation of the European Youth FoundationPresentation of the European Youth Foundation
Presentation of the European Youth Foundation
 
IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024
IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024
IEF Energy Outlooks Comparison Report-2024
 
How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...
How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...
How to upgrade EU benchmarking in Fundamentals: the case of judicial reform i...
 
MPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptx
MPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptxMPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptx
MPA Lecture on Stakeholder Analysis.pptx
 
Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24
Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24
Manuscript Template Name of the Author PM24
 
PM International Conference 24 Poster Template
PM International Conference 24 Poster TemplatePM International Conference 24 Poster Template
PM International Conference 24 Poster Template
 
Trading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standards
Trading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standardsTrading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standards
Trading standards: How exposure to global trade shapes our living standards
 
Monroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 Presentation
Monroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 PresentationMonroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 Presentation
Monroe Downtown Master Plan Public Meeting 2 Presentation
 
PMAI PM24 International Conference Program Schedule
PMAI PM24 International Conference Program SchedulePMAI PM24 International Conference Program Schedule
PMAI PM24 International Conference Program Schedule
 
Central Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs Agreement
Central Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs AgreementCentral Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs Agreement
Central Winds Park Pickleball Instructional Programs Agreement
 
PMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster Presentation
PMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster PresentationPMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster Presentation
PMAI PM24: Guidelines for the Poster Presentation
 
Lecture Presentation on Project Proposal
Lecture Presentation on Project ProposalLecture Presentation on Project Proposal
Lecture Presentation on Project Proposal
 
Observance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdf
Observance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdfObservance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdf
Observance of the International Mother Language Day (IMLD) 2024.pdf
 
Item # 4 - Community Improvement Grant Awards
Item # 4 - Community Improvement Grant AwardsItem # 4 - Community Improvement Grant Awards
Item # 4 - Community Improvement Grant Awards
 
2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation
2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation
2023 Winter Springs Water and Wastewater Rate Study Presentation
 
Vertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptx
Vertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptxVertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptx
Vertical Integration Webinar Presentation-Regions4.pptx
 

Not anti government but irrelevant government

  • 1. NOT ANTI-GOVERNMENT BUT IRRELEVANT GOVERNMENT Paper by Christopher Wilson & Gilles Paquet Centre on Governance, University of Ottawa Presented to the PATheory.net Conference May 28-31, 2015 Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada PATheory.net
  • 2. A PAPER IN 3 PARTS  Part One – an analysis of contemporary anti-government phenomena  Part Two – deals with the dual failure in resolving the coordination problems from the administrative crises of the 1970s and 1990s in Canada  The failure of New Public Management to replace Big ‘G’ Government with market approaches; and  the subsequent abandonment of efforts to repair the coordination failures in favour of attempts at redistribution to compensate different groups claiming hurt from those failures  Part Three – describes how this dual failure has opened the door to new avenues for small ‘g’ governance that is seen in the emerging interest in alternative methods of coordination and sharing that are occurring on the margins of the socio-economy that are designed to make citizens less dependent on government for coordination purposes, and the government much less indispensable  See our paper: Government Failure and Antigovernment Phenomena
  • 3. ANTI-GOVERNMENT ATTITUDES  Anti-government attitudes are incontrovertibly symptoms of public discontent at the actions or inactions of government, however legitimate or defensible those actions may appear to be to government decision makers  Anti-government attitudes -- as a reflection of social movements -- may be enlightened, or not, but they are definitely many- dimensional, ill-defined, a complex of motivations, and only an obliquely and imprecisely measurable  Often they are aggregations of Rorschachian, ‘inkblot’, interpretations of what is really going on. We caution against such over simplifications that can lead to “a fantasy-land of self righteousness” (Sibley 2013)
  • 4. THE ARGUMENT  Anti-government phenomena are wicked problems involving a spectrum of government activities – coordination, redistribution, and stabilization as well as citizen education and ideological aspects (Musgrave 1959)  Anti-government a la 1970s was a reaction to coordination failures observed in government, resulting from being too hierarchical and overly coercive, which manifested in the era of New Public Management in the 80s and 90s  The inability to make reforms on the coordination front increased the dependency of government actors on redistribution to retain their legitimacy by compensating people for the effects those coordination failures had on them  Redistribution went from being a tool of convenience post WWII to compensate for declines in private sector activities TO compensating for under spending in areas of public goods like health & education TO being regarded as valuable in its own right in an era of egalitarianism where preferences >> needs, needs >> worthy deserts, deserts >> rights and rights >> absolute rights of entitlement (Kekes 2003)  Today’s anti-government is paradoxical – i.e. government is too big, too ineffective, demands too much & is too untrustworthy BUT government is not big enough, not doing enough to give me what I want or imagine I need & and is the only societal actor I trust to protect my rights
  • 5. THE ARGUMENT (CONT’D)  The failure of government to refurbish itself in the coordination game & to rely almost exclusively on redistribution has:  Tarnished the confidence of citizens (down to 9%) in government’s ability to solve complex problems (Nanos-IRRP poll 2012)  Generated decreasing concerns to complexity (Tainter 1990)  Generated public expenditures (eg. Health & education) that are threatening to bankrupt the state within decades (Levert 2013)  Given renewed interest to the type of small ‘g’ governance regimes that abound in uncentralized networks (Cleveland 2002)  Encouraged development of alternatives to government whether in terms of social technologies (like P3s or community-based approaches), or the burgeoning new ICT technologies in so many diverse areas (including garbage collection, disaster relief, collective decision making, & economic management through the use of network tools like the blockchain)  Encouraged the notion that citizens and businesses can “exit” (like emigration of old) unproductive, unresponsive government institutions into a virtual world where governments have little influence & value adding innovation is more the norm
  • 6. CULTURE GOVERNANCE  As social complexity grows, hierarchies and markets are insufficient to provide social learning and innovation. According to Farrell & Shalizi (2013), democracy is the mechanism best suited to bring together different perspectives, knowledge, and access to resources and power  Every society is the product of the conversations that take place among its members (Block 2008) and this collective conversation leads to a continually evolving culture governance (Bang 2003) that steers society on the basis of embedded propensities, conventions, paradigms and accepted practices and mechanisms  In this light, the incapacity of the anti-government attitudes of the 80s and 90s to trigger greater transformation of coordination practices was in part due to a culture governance that resisted arguments around value adding and increased efficiency and instead welcomed notions of value redistribution. This was reinforced by failed structural reforms (such as those proposed in Canada’s Program Review in the late 90s) and a popular, ‘no-fault’ belief that “if you can’t fix it, then compensate me for it”  The culture governance of redistribution has become a powerful dampening force on public sector reform & lies at the root of much of the popular discontent with government
  • 7. COMPLEX SOCIETIES AS DISSIPATIVE SYSTEMS  System change in non-equilibrium structures like living systems and governments is the result of fluctuations from the status quo. Small changes are dampened but fluctuations that are far from equilibrium can combine to increase the efficiency of the system as a whole and move it to a more stable state. This is the basis of self-organizing, self emergent structures.  Implication for Gov’t: The coordination reforms aspired to 20 years ago were incremental and subject to dampening influences from a culture governance dominated by redistribution.  Today, even though redistribution has become gospel, anti-government attitudes are being fuelled by the presence of alternatives from coordination experiments and tools happening far from the centre of government at society’s margins. Structure FluctuationFunction Fig. 11 - Criteria for Self-Organization
  • 8. ILLUSTRATIONS FROM THE MARGINS  Belgium’s lack of government for 589 days 2010-2011 (+ 150 days in 2014)  Bitcoin and, more importantly, the blockchain (no need for centralized economic management)  The most creative public policy (eg. Food-Secure Canada, Homeless Hub, Indigenous Child Well Being Research network) is being co-produced, not with government, but by alliances of citizens & academics (Jackson 2015)  “Forget Government: Hire a Business Leader” (business deals with homelessness in Calgary)  Uber & collaborative consumption (better resource allocation)  Ushahidi-Haiti (civic organizing to coordinate disaster relief)  OpenParliament (citizens – not government – providing access to democratic information  DemocracyOS (platform for public debate)  Loomino (tool for collective decision making)  Anti-SOPA (largest public rally against an elected government in history)  The virtual secession of Silicon Valley ( citizens opting out)
  • 9. QUO VADIS – WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?  As in the 80s, dissatisfaction w/ the status quo is generating anti-government attitudes, but today, in addition to the coordination concerns there are serious sustainability concerns wrt to redistribution; plus a drift in culture governance towards notions of cooperation, self sufficiency, innovation and value creation; plus a growing number of serious alternatives to government. We have options.  It is unlikely that the state has the capacity, the skills, or the motivation to bring back coordination and collaboration to the centre of the governance stage. The current anti-government rhetoric that is submerged in the paradoxical attitudes around redistribution make that almost impossible.  Will the state become a shadow of its current and former self? Probably.  Will / can the private sector and markets assume the role of primary facilitator of social cooperation and collaboration? Unlikely, given the way information flows in them through hierarchies and markets.  Will coordination emerge bottom up, chaotically, unpredictably from a civil society that fosters public dialogue and conversations, partnerships and working together? Maybe.  We are at an inflection point, as Andy Grove once described (1996), and only time, practised judgement and paying attention to the things happening on the margins will help to guide us forward
  • 10. THANK YOU Contact Info: Christopher Wilson cwilson@uottawa.ca