Writing for grade 10English
Back to ContentsEssay PlannerAn excellent essay planner is availableat:http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/inter...
Back to ContentsAlternative PlansA range of ways to plan essays:-Write a summary of your main argument. This isparticularl...
Back to ContentsCommand WordsCommand words are those words whichindicate to a student what they ought to doin their essay....
Back to ContentsPurposeAn essay without a clear purpose is liable to becomeunfocussed. Coherence may be lost and, if it is...
Back to ContentsStructureStudents think differently. Certain questions invite certain typesof response. Here are a range o...
Back to ContentsIntroductionsIntroductions should be clear and precise. They shouldindicate what the essay is about. They ...
Back to ContentsConclusionsConclusions should summarise what has gone before. They shouldnever contain new material. That ...
Back to ContentsRead AloudReading ones own work out loud is a useful way to test thequality of an essay. Speaking what has...
Back to ContentsSpeed DebatingSpeed Debating is a good activity to do in advance of essaywriting. It works as follows:i) I...
Back to ContentsFormal DebatingFormal Debating is a good activity to do in advance of essay writing. It works asfollows:i)...
Back to ContentsSilent DebateSilent Debate is a good activity to do in advance of essaywriting. It works as follows:i) The...
Back to ContentsFirst SentencesWhat comes first sets the tone. It must.In an essay, the first sentence of a paragraph ough...
Back to ContentsPeer-assessmentPeer assessment affords students two opportunities. First, ofreading someone else’s work. S...
Back to ContentsRedraftingRedrafting is not always the most pleasurable activity. Students oftenfind it hard to write an e...
Back to ContentsModel AnswersA model answer is the ideal; it is the perfect mix of contentand style, evaluation and analys...
Back to ContentsEvidenceA wise man proportions his belief to the evidence(David Hume).A claim is a claim. Only through sup...
Back to ContentsReasonsWe use reasons to persuade others that our claims are true. For example:Children can write essays (...
Back to ContentsExamplesWhen one makes a claim about the world, it is often general orabstract in nature. The addition of ...
Back to ContentsGroup EssaysLike long-distance running, essay writing can be a lonelybusiness. Inspire and motivate studen...
Back to ContentsViewpointsIn a court case two different arguments will be proposed in the face ofa single set of evidence....
Back to ContentsMind MapsMany people use mind maps to plan essays. Amind map has a central topic, out of whichstem key ide...
Back to ContentsDifferent ArgumentsWe all have our own ways of thinking and areas of life towhich we attach particular imp...
Back to ContentsCritiquing ArgumentsArguments are there to be critiqued. Most things can be rebutted.Little is irrefutable...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Essay writing toolkit_master_version

6,436 views

Published on

Published in: Education
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total views
6,436
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
56
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Essay writing toolkit_master_version

  1. 1. Writing for grade 10English
  2. 2. Back to ContentsEssay PlannerAn excellent essay planner is availableat:http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/interactives/essaymap/This resource helps students map outtheir essay in advance. It breaks theprocess down into simple steps andprovides a clear, visual overview.Essay maps can be printed, saved orshared once complete.Blank essay maps can be printed off ifstudents do not have computer access(this feature is available from the firstpage of the link).
  3. 3. Back to ContentsAlternative PlansA range of ways to plan essays:-Write a summary of your main argument. This isparticularly helpful for clarifying and refining ideas.-Write the first sentence of each paragraph. These shouldanswer the question and form a coherent whole.- Write the conclusion first. Then, work out what you willneed to include in order to reach it.- Bullet point your introduction, main body, andconclusion.- Create a spider diagram with the essay question at thecentre.-Draw out sub-questions from the title. Order the series ofquestions you create and answer each in turn.-Create a table. Put your key points across the top. Evidencefor and evidence against goes along the side (for example -http://www.activehistory.co.uk/Miscellaneous/free_stuff/essay_planner/index.htm)
  4. 4. Back to ContentsCommand WordsCommand words are those words whichindicate to a student what they ought to doin their essay.Here are some examples:CompareContrastDescribeDefineDiscussEvaluateExplainIllustrateJustifyOutlineStudents who know the functions of suchwords are in a better position to answer thequestion.Explanations of command words can be found at:• www.wjec.co.uk/uploads/publications/10055.doc•http://store.aqa.org.uk/resourceZone/pdf/ict/AQA-ICT-W-TRB-CWICT.PDF•http://seis.bris.ac.uk/~hihrp/StudySkills/EssayWriting.pdf•http://owll.massey.ac.nz/academic-writing/command-words.php•http://www.google.co.uk/url?q=http://hbsbusiness.net/commandwords.doc&sa=U&ei=5GnLTpikBseu8QPzqdX-Dw&ved=0CBYQFjAAOAo&usg=AFQjCNFr9Gah16TOSsEki2a_M1Ia6EQzSQ
  5. 5. Back to ContentsPurposeAn essay without a clear purpose is liable to becomeunfocussed. Coherence may be lost and, if it is, logicwill most likely disappear as well.Here are some activities to help ensure studentsretain a clear purpose:i) Provide students with a range of essay titles.Ask them to come up with a single sentencefor each which encapsulates what their answerwould be about.ii) Set an essay for the class. Insist that the firstsentence of each paragraph must answer thequestion. Once the essays are complete, askstudents to read their first sentences to oneanother.iii) Provide students with an essay title. Ask themto come up with a single sentenceencapsulating what their answer would beabout. Collect 3-4 different examples. Askstudents to create an appropriate plan foreach one. They should stick to the differentpurpose each time.
  6. 6. Back to ContentsStructureStudents think differently. Certain questions invite certain typesof response. Here are a range of essay structures for studentsto use:1) Introduction -> Arguments For -> Arguments Against -> Conclusion2) Introduction -> 1st Argument For -> 1st Argument Against -> 2nd Argument For -> 2ndArgument Against -> Conclusion3) Introduction -> Main Body -> Conclusion4) Introduction -> First Key Theme -> Second Key Theme -> Third Key Theme -> Conclusion5) Introduction -> First Point -> Critique of First Point -> Second Point -> Critique of SecondPoint -> Conclusion
  7. 7. Back to ContentsIntroductionsIntroductions should be clear and precise. They shouldindicate what the essay is about. They should answer thequestion. At times it may be appropriate to analysecertain words in the question and reformulate accordingly.An introduction should make it clear to the reader what toexpect. It should be brief, saying only what is necessaryand no more.Activitiesi) Give students a range of essay titles. Ask them towrite introductions for each one.ii) Once students have written an introduction, askthem to rewrite it using fewer words but with thesame meaning.iii) Put students in groups. Everyone has a piece ofpaper. Give an essay title. Everyone writes the firstsentence of the introduction. Papers are then passedon and everyone writes the second line. Continueuntil the introductions are complete. Review anddiscuss.
  8. 8. Back to ContentsConclusionsConclusions should summarise what has gone before. They shouldnever contain new material. That is, anything which has not beendealt with in the preceding text.A good conclusion draws together the threads which the writer haswoven to form a tight, coherent whole.An average essay can be raised by a strong conclusion; a good essaycan be felled by a bad one.Activitiesi) Give students a range of essay titles and ask them to writeconclusions for each. When done, students work in pairs tocompare and contrast.ii) Give students an essay title. Ask them to write theirconclusion and then go back and write the essay.iii) Students are given an essay title. They must write 3-5different conclusions which could fit with the title. Next, theycompare these with a partner before planning out the detailwhich would precede a couple of the conclusions.
  9. 9. Back to ContentsRead AloudReading ones own work out loud is a useful way to test thequality of an essay. Speaking what has been written meansgiving voice to anything which does not make sense, is notclear, or comes across as verbose. There is no where to hidewhen reading aloud.Activitiesi) Students complete an essay and get into groups. Theytake it in turns to read aloud to the rest of the group.Other members offer corrections and alternatives.ii) Students complete an essay. A few students take it inturns to read their essay aloud to the whole class. Theaudience makes notes and gives feedback (alternative:the audience is divided up and they make notes ondifferent areas, for example structure, argument andso on).iii) Students complete an essay for homework. Oncefinished, they read it aloud to themselves (perhapsstanding in front of the mirror). Any issues whichappear in the reading should be corrected.
  10. 10. Back to ContentsSpeed DebatingSpeed Debating is a good activity to do in advance of essaywriting. It works as follows:i) Introduce a proposition. For example, ‘Conservatism isnot relevant to modern politics’.ii) Divide the class in half.iii) Indicate which half of the class will be arguing FOR andwhich half will be arguing AGAINST.iv) Give students time to construct their arguments.v) Ask the students who are FOR to stand up. They mustfind a student who is AGAINST and sit opposite them.vi) Students take it in turns to speak (2-3 minutes foreach) before 1-2 minutes of free-for-all.vii) Students who are FOR stand up and find a newpartner. Repeat step VI and so on.
  11. 11. Back to ContentsFormal DebatingFormal Debating is a good activity to do in advance of essay writing. It works asfollows:i) Introduce a motion. For example, ‘This house believes that humanbehaviour is biologically determined’.ii) Divide the class in half. One half will be FOR. One half will be Against.iii) Each group must nominate three speakers. These will be the Proposer,the Seconder, and the Summariser.iv) The groups prepare their arguments in detail.v) The Proposers, Seconders, and Summarisers are called forward. They sitat the front, with a judge in between.vi) The Proposer FOR the motion speaks first for an allotted period of time.The Proposer AGAINST then speaks and so on.vii) The rest of the class act as an audience. They must come up withquestions to ask the speakers at the end of the debate.viii) Finally, a judgement is given as to who has won the debate.Resources available at - http://www.ltscotland.org.uk/debatinginschools/index.asp
  12. 12. Back to ContentsSilent DebateSilent Debate is a good activity to do in advance of essaywriting. It works as follows:i) The teacher writes questions and/or statements in thecentre of 3-5 large pieces of paper. These are then spreadaround the room.ii) Students enter and are told they are not allowed to talk.They must take out a pen and move around theroom, reading the questions/statements.iii) Students must write their responses to eachquestion/statement on the paper.iv) When they have answered each one, they continue tomove around, except they now comment on otherpeople’s comments.v) Once sufficient time has elapsed, end the activity and usethe sheets as a basis for discussion. From this, it will beeasy for students to dive straight into their essays.
  13. 13. Back to ContentsFirst SentencesWhat comes first sets the tone. It must.In an essay, the first sentence of a paragraph ought to indicatewhat that paragraph is about. If it does not, there is a high risk oflogical confusion developing. This makes the writing less clear.The purpose of an essay is to communicate understanding,argument and judgement. Therefore, one should always strive forclarity and sense. From the first sentence, to the last.Activitiesi) Give students an essay title. Ask them to imagine how theywould go about answering it. Then, they must write the firstsentence of each paragraph. When finished, develop intopaired or group discussion.ii) Students are in groups. Give them an essay title. Ask themto write the series of first sentences which would suffice forthe essay. When finished, each group reads their sentencesout and takes feedback.iii) Students are given an essay title. They come up with twoalternate plans then write the first sentences for each.Students then self-assess, deciding which would be thebetter essay and why.
  14. 14. Back to ContentsPeer-assessmentPeer assessment affords students two opportunities. First, ofreading someone else’s work. Second, of analysing and applyingthe mark scheme they themselves will be assessed against.Activitiesi) Students are given a title and write their essays. Oncompletion, they pair up and swap work. The teacherprovides a mark scheme. Students mark each others workand set a target. Discussion ensues.ii) Students write their essays. The teacher collects andshuffles them. The essays are handed out at random, alongwith a mark scheme. Students mark the essay they get andset a target. They then seek out the author and explaintheir decisions.iii) Students write their essays anonymously. The teachercollects them in, shuffles them and redistributesthem, along with a mark scheme. Students mark the essaythey receive. Finally, authors reclaim their essays anddiscuss their results with the marker.
  15. 15. Back to ContentsRedraftingRedrafting is not always the most pleasurable activity. Students oftenfind it hard to write an essay and baulk at the prospect of redoing it.Nonetheless, redrafting is an effective medicine if one can get past thebitter taste. The following activities might make the process a littleeasier.Activitiesi) Take in and mark your students’ essays. Set them a clear targetwhich relates directly to what they have done in that essay. Givethem one example of how they might alter their work. Return theessays and ask for a redraft based on the target, the identificationof areas requiring improvement, and the example of what thatimprovement might look like.ii) Students write their essays and make a note at the bottom ofwhat they would like an editor to focus on (for example,argument, grammar, key words and so on). Students swap essaysand edit each others work paying special attention to what hasbeen requested. The essays are returned and students use theediting to help them redraft their original piece.iii) Students receive a target, either from the teacher or via peer-assessment. They choose 2-3 paragraphs to redraft in line withthe target. The original marker then looks at the new paragraphsand provides feedback.
  16. 16. Back to ContentsModel AnswersA model answer is the ideal; it is the perfect mix of contentand style, evaluation and analysis, argument and evidence.Some exam boards provide model answers as exemplars. Youcan create your own library by photocopying the very bestwork your own students produce.Activitiesi) Following the writing and marking of an essay, providestudents with a copy of the mark scheme. Place them ingroups and ask them to create a model answer, takingaccount of the detailed information in the mark scheme.ii) Hand out copies of the model answers you havecollected (without any grades visible). Give students theappropriate mark scheme. In pairs, they work throughthe model answer, identifying why it received such highmarks. Follow up with discussion.iii) Students work in groups of 4-6. They should alreadyhave completed an essay. Using the same essay title,their marked essays and a mark scheme, they create amodel answer on large sugar paper, splitting the workup between them. Students present to each other withexplanations.
  17. 17. Back to ContentsEvidenceA wise man proportions his belief to the evidence(David Hume).A claim is a claim. Only through support does it become an argument. Evidence isone of the most crucial means of support. It picks out something in the world andsays ‘hey, look: this proves what I am saying to be true’. Whether it actually provesit or not is another matter, one most often left to the reader to decide. Theseactivities will help students think carefully about evidence:Activitiesi) Give students an essay title and ask them to write a brief plan. Next, ask themto go through and identify what evidence they would use to support eachpoint. They should make a list of this evidence and provide a rationale for eachpiece. Students swap their plans and lists of evidence with a partner. Theyread through and comment on the strength of the evidence. Finally, adiscussion ensues.ii) Introduce students to the credibility criteria: Bias; Corroboration; Consistency;Reputation; Ability to Perceive; Vested Interest; Expertise; Neutrality (BCCRAVEN). Provide them with a range of evidence to assess using these criteria.More information at http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/A-level_Critical_Thinkingiii) Students work in pairs. They are given a topic to discuss. Person A starts. Theymust support every point they make with evidence. Person B stops them ifthey fail to do this at any point and the roles are reversed.
  18. 18. Back to ContentsReasonsWe use reasons to persuade others that our claims are true. For example:Children can write essays (claim/conclusion)1) I have seen many children write essays.2) I myself was once a child and wrote many essays at that time.3) Cognitive psychology shows intelligence is not innate and that everyone hasthe capacity to learn.Each of these is a reason supporting the claim (or conclusion). We could insertthe word ‘because’ between them to further prove the case. Here are someactivities to get students thinking about reasons:Activitiesi) Give students a newspaper article or politician’s speech and ask them toidentify the claims made along with the reasons used to support them.ii) Give students a claim (this could be subject-related or completely random).Ask them to come up with as many reasons as possible which couldsupport it.iii) Give students an essay title. Ask them to come up with a brief plan. Foreach key point identified in the plan, they must find three reasons whichcould be used to support it. Students then work in pairs, explaining theirreasons to one another and critiquing them.
  19. 19. Back to ContentsExamplesWhen one makes a claim about the world, it is often general orabstract in nature. The addition of an example helps to contextualisethe statement in the mind of the audience (whether reader, viewer orlistener). This strengthens the case, adding a reference point which canbe taken a hold of, considered, checked and reflected upon.For example:Churchill provided effective leadership during the war. For example, hespoke eloquently to the British people, thus galvanising their spirits ata time of great difficulty.Activitiesi) Students work in pairs. One person speaks, the other listens. Thespeaker must back up everything they say with an example. Ifthey fail to do so, the listener points this out and the roles arereversed.ii) Hand students their essays back. Ask them to go through andhighlight every example they have given. Then, they shouldidentify where else they could have used examples and whatthese could have been.iii) Give students an essay title. Ask them to plan the essay. Next,students identify an appropriate example for each paragraph inthe main body.
  20. 20. Back to ContentsGroup EssaysLike long-distance running, essay writing can be a lonelybusiness. Inspire and motivate students by having themwork in groups. Here are some possible activities:i) Put students in groups of three. Provide an essaytitle. Working together, the students must write theessay. One could do the introduction and first keypoint, one most of the main body, and the third theremainder including the conclusion.ii) Students work in pairs. They agree a centralargument for the essay. They then agree the mainpoints in favour of this argument. One studentwrites the paragraphs explaining these. The otherstudent writes rebuttal paragraphs evaluating eachpoint.iii) Students work in groups of three or four. They aregiven an essay title and a large sheet of sugarpaper. They must produce a detailed plan on thesugar paper which they will subsequently presentto the class. The audience quizzes the group ontheir decisions.
  21. 21. Back to ContentsViewpointsIn a court case two different arguments will be proposed in the face ofa single set of evidence. Instances are frequent where both cases arepersuasive and plausible. It can take much careful reasoning to cometo a decision as to the verdict which ought to be given.Students, eager to put forward their own viewpoints, sometimes missthe nuances inherent in many topics. These activities seek to draw outsome of the gradations.Activitiesi) Give students a key piece of content (for example, a study, anhistorical event, a philosophical argument). Follow this up with arange of perspectives relevant to your subject. Ask students toanalyse the content from each position in turn. They can thencompare and contrast the results.ii) Students work in pairs. They receive an essay title. Each mustsketch a plan which has a clear, coherent perspective. Studentsswap plans and write each other’s essays.iii) Place an essay title on the board. Hand out, at random, a seriesof cards with different positions/perspectives written on each.Students must sketch a brief plan of the essay they would writefrom that perspective/position. They then stand up and find apartner (with a different perspective/position). Fevered debateshould ensue, with the plan as a point of reference.
  22. 22. Back to ContentsMind MapsMany people use mind maps to plan essays. Amind map has a central topic, out of whichstem key ideas. From these key ideas, furtherbranches develop, containing sub-points.Mind maps help one to order informationvisually. They are also useful for ticking offinformation as it has been dealt with. In thisway they act as an aide memoire, as well as anorganisational tool.Information on mind mapping can be found at:http://freemind.sourceforge.net/wiki/index.php/Main_Pagehttp://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newISS_01.htmhttp://www.thinkbuzan.com/uk/
  23. 23. Back to ContentsDifferent ArgumentsWe all have our own ways of thinking and areas of life towhich we attach particular importance. For students, acorollary of this is that they can get stuck in a certain groovewhen writing their essays. The activities below may work as acorrective:Activitiesi) Give students an essay title. Ask them to compile asmany different arguments as possible which could beadvanced in response.ii) Students get into groups and are provided with a rangeof essay titles. They choose one and create a large spiderdiagram (say, on sugar paper) covering as many answersas possible.iii) The teacher writes different perspectives, viewpoints orpositions on a series of cards (for example, in sociologythis could beMarxist, feminist, pluralist, functionalist, postmodernist,and social-constructivist). The cards are handed out atrandom along with an essay question. Students mustdevelop their arguments from the perspective, positionor viewpoint indicated on their card.
  24. 24. Back to ContentsCritiquing ArgumentsArguments are there to be critiqued. Most things can be rebutted.Little is irrefutable. An essay is more persuasive when taking account ofthis reality. Dogmatic browbeating wins few followers; it makes theproponent appear naive and simplistic. The following activities centreon critique of arguments:Activitiesi) Students write an essay. The teacher takes the work in andredistributes it. Students go through the essay they have beengiven with the express intention of challenging each argumentthey find. Challenges are noted with coloured pen. Students thenget together and discuss their critiques.ii) Take a newspaper article, a comment piece, or an MPs speech.Give out to students. Ask them to work through the text andidentify as many challenges to the argument as they can. This caninclude issues such as reliability, credibility, logic, accuracy,validity, the evidence called upon, the relationship betweenreasons and conclusion, and so on.iii) Use the issues noted above as lenses. Write them on separatepieces of card and hand them out at random. Students must lookat an argument, piece of evidence or essay and produce a critiquethrough their lens. These are then shared and used as a basis fordiscussion.

×