Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
When to move to TD-LTE ?              Key Considerations from a 3.5GHz PerspectiveThursday, 24 May 12          © Aequator ...
A brief introduction  My name is Harbir Singh Nat            I am the CEO of Zapp.pt and            The founder of Æqua...
Zapp.pt  Zapp.pt is            a Portuguese company with a 20 year heritage            100% subsidiary of Saudi Oger wh...
Æquator Capital Ltd.  Æquator Capital is a advisory boutique which is focused on   telecommunications, media and technolo...
The peculiar case of 3.5GHz It should be doing very well…… One of the largest continuous spectrum bands from 3.4GHz to 3....
The peculiar case of 3.5GHz ……..but it isn’t Spectrum is not invested in by any large international) MNO, not in a strate...
The peculiar case of 3.5GHz Why ?  No large MNO investor which can deliver demand  Therefore, a Catch-22 situation     ...
The opportunity The hypothesis : The 3.5GHz spectrum will be valuable. The proof       Data consumption by smartphones i...
So what do we do now ?  To build or not to build, that is the question ?  (and another, followup question) If to build w...
Option 1 : Squat on your spectrum  This strategy follows an age old wisdom – when in doubt,   don’t.   Least risk option...
Option 2 : Move to TD-LTE now Advantages  You start building a business today, this has advantages of    Building scale ...
Option 3 : WiMax now, TD-LTE Later Advantages  You start building a business today, this has advantages   building scale ...
Conclusion  Unfortunately, there are no clear answers. (I am also looking   for them)  However, I do not believe WiMax i...
www.aequator.co.ukThursday, 24 May 12      © Aequator Capital Ltd.   14
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Day 2-t10-1530 harbir-singh-20120524

511 views

Published on

LTE World Summit Barcelona May 2012 Day 2

Published in: Business, Economy & Finance
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Day 2-t10-1530 harbir-singh-20120524

  1. 1. When to move to TD-LTE ? Key Considerations from a 3.5GHz PerspectiveThursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 1
  2. 2. A brief introduction  My name is Harbir Singh Nat  I am the CEO of Zapp.pt and  The founder of Æquator Capital Ltd. Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 2
  3. 3. Zapp.pt  Zapp.pt is  a Portuguese company with a 20 year heritage  100% subsidiary of Saudi Oger which through its subsidiary Oger Telecom Ltd. Is a one of the largest telecom operators in the world with over 35 million subscribers  Oger Telecom is the controlling shareholder of Turk Telekom.  Zapp.pt operated CDMA450, TETRA and trunked radio networks throughout Portugal  Zapp.pt has 168MHz of 3.5GHz spectrum in Portugal Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 3
  4. 4. Æquator Capital Ltd.  Æquator Capital is a advisory boutique which is focused on telecommunications, media and technology sectors  We focus on small to medium sized clients  Who need financing solutions which are not delivered by a standard cookie cutter approach  Our website is www.aequator.co.uk Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 4
  5. 5. The peculiar case of 3.5GHz It should be doing very well…… One of the largest continuous spectrum bands from 3.4GHz to 3.8GHz (400 Mhz)  LTE Bands 42, 43  WiMax 2.0 band class 5 Accepted as a mobile band in Europe, with spectrum allocated (in part or whole of the band) throughout the world Nearly 300 deployments throughout the world…… Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 5
  6. 6. The peculiar case of 3.5GHz ……..but it isn’t Spectrum is not invested in by any large international) MNO, not in a strategic way at least (before anyone objects, I would like to point out exceptions prove the rule) Limited device choices  No viable voice handset Absence of multiband or multimode devices No success stories No proven business case Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 6
  7. 7. The peculiar case of 3.5GHz Why ?  No large MNO investor which can deliver demand  Therefore, a Catch-22 situation  Vendors will not develop economical CPEs without assured demand  Operators cannot generate demand without economical CPEs  Most widely used RF filters cut off at 2.7Ghz (co-incidence or physics ?). This prevents multi-band development Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 7
  8. 8. The opportunity The hypothesis : The 3.5GHz spectrum will be valuable. The proof  Data consumption by smartphones is growing at an exponential rate (Softbank experience 200% pa)  Spectrum is limited hence scarce  Therefore with a linear extrapolation - one day 3.5GHz spectrum will be valuable  Q.E.D. But we don’t know when Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 8
  9. 9. So what do we do now ?  To build or not to build, that is the question ?  (and another, followup question) If to build which technology – WiMax or LTE ? We have three options 1. Squat on the spectrum for now. 2. Start TD-LTE Rollout 3. Continue with WiMax and plan to rollout TD-LTE when device eco-system is ready (of course there is a fourth option – continue to rollout WiMax as if nothing happened. But with only 20 minutes per speaker slot, we will skip that one) Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 9
  10. 10. Option 1 : Squat on your spectrum  This strategy follows an age old wisdom – when in doubt, don’t.  Least risk option (by that logic the wisest)  However, this option is  Not available perhaps in a majority of license conditions  Is a strategy to make some money but not to develop a business (in the end you will simple trade the spectrum – that way you never get really, really rich) Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 10
  11. 11. Option 2 : Move to TD-LTE now Advantages  You start building a business today, this has advantages of  Building scale earlier  Lesser migration issues However, problem is  The CPEs you have are single band, expensive dongles and routers  The is no business case for mobility on a standalone 3.5GHz band  And there is no business case for universal coverage  Therefore the business essentially is fixed line substitution, which has low ARPUs and low performance (compared to fixed line) Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 11
  12. 12. Option 3 : WiMax now, TD-LTE Later Advantages  You start building a business today, this has advantages building scale earlier  The WiMax eco-system is here today, now at viable CPE prices  It is still a fixed line substitution business But the problem is that at some point you will need to swap your network and CPEs to TD-LTE. Which could have potential costs. Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 12
  13. 13. Conclusion  Unfortunately, there are no clear answers. (I am also looking for them)  However, I do not believe WiMax is dead or will die anytime soon  Also I do not believe we will see iPAD/iPhone/Galaxy TD-LTE on 3.5 GHz anytime soon, so we better have a strategy which takes this fact into account. Thursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 13
  14. 14. www.aequator.co.ukThursday, 24 May 12 © Aequator Capital Ltd. 14

×