SlideShare a Scribd company logo

Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways

Senior Advisor for Microeconomic Studies Division Perry Beider's presentation to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce

1 of 14
Download to read offline
Congressional Budget Office
                                                                                          October 15, 2012




Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways


Presentation to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce


Perry Beider
Senior Advisor, Microeconomic Studies Division

This presentation provides information published in Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways
(March 2011). See www.cbo.gov/publication/22059.
CBO’s Report on Funding Alternatives for Federal
Spending on Highways

 ■ Focuses on fuel and VMT taxes
 ■ Uses facts and estimates from literature
 ■ Provides an economic framework
 ■ Requested by the Chairman of the Senate Budget Committee




                CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Highway Funding Goals


 ■ Efficiency
 ■ Equity
 ■ Privacy




                CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Goal 1: Efficiency


 Maximize benefits of road travel net of total costs, including
    • Costs of building and maintaining roads
    • Costs of using roads
    • Costs of the funding system itself (direct or indirect)




                 CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Comparing Fuel and VMT Taxes: Incentives for
Efficient Road Use

 ■ Prescription for efficiency: Charge people for the marginal cost
   of their use or consumption of a good or service




                 CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
Estimated Mileage- and Fuel-related Costs

                                                              Mileage-Related Costs
 Rural Passenger Vehicles                                     Fuel-Related Costs
                                                              (Converted to cents per mile)




 Urban Passenger Vehicles




             Rural Trucks




            Urban Trucks




                            0       10    20    30    40       50           60           70


                                CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE

Recommended

Accounting for External Costs in Pricing Freight Transport
Accounting for External Costs in Pricing Freight TransportAccounting for External Costs in Pricing Freight Transport
Accounting for External Costs in Pricing Freight TransportCongressional Budget Office
 
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External Costs
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External CostsPricing Freight Transport to Account for External Costs
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External CostsCongressional Budget Office
 
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External Costs
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External CostsPricing Freight Transport to Account for External Costs
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External CostsCongressional Budget Office
 
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External Costs
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External CostsPricing Freight Transport to Account for External Costs
Pricing Freight Transport to Account for External CostsCongressional Budget Office
 
The FAST Act and the Status of the Highway Trust Fund
The FAST Act and the Status of the Highway Trust FundThe FAST Act and the Status of the Highway Trust Fund
The FAST Act and the Status of the Highway Trust FundCongressional Budget Office
 
Alternatives for Making Federal Highway Spending More Productive
Alternatives for Making Federal Highway Spending More ProductiveAlternatives for Making Federal Highway Spending More Productive
Alternatives for Making Federal Highway Spending More ProductiveCongressional Budget Office
 
Public Spending on Transportation and Water Infrastructure, 1956 to 2017
Public Spending on Transportation and Water Infrastructure, 1956 to 2017Public Spending on Transportation and Water Infrastructure, 1956 to 2017
Public Spending on Transportation and Water Infrastructure, 1956 to 2017Congressional Budget Office
 

More Related Content

What's hot

Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290
Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290
Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290ThinkTrade, Inc.
 
Gauteng Transport Authority update
Gauteng Transport Authority updateGauteng Transport Authority update
Gauteng Transport Authority updateTristan Wiggill
 
Charging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing Work
Charging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing WorkCharging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing Work
Charging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing WorkTexxi Global
 
Road Funding in South Africa
Road Funding in South AfricaRoad Funding in South Africa
Road Funding in South AfricaTristan Wiggill
 
Federal Transportation Update
Federal Transportation UpdateFederal Transportation Update
Federal Transportation UpdateRPO America
 
20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida
20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida
20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Floridaguestd509af
 
A kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept study
A kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept studyA kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept study
A kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept studyTristan Wiggill
 
Federal Grants to State and Local Governments for Investment
Federal Grants to State and Local Governments for InvestmentFederal Grants to State and Local Governments for Investment
Federal Grants to State and Local Governments for InvestmentCongressional Budget Office
 
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvencyartba
 
A Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in Florida
A Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in FloridaA Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in Florida
A Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in Floridaguestd509af
 
2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP Highlights2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP HighlightsCHCRPA
 
Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...
Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...
Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...New York Public Transit Association
 
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quitoshrdcinfo
 

What's hot (20)

Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290
Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290
Heavy Vehicle Use Tax Form 2290
 
Federal Highway Spending and Revenues
Federal Highway Spending and RevenuesFederal Highway Spending and Revenues
Federal Highway Spending and Revenues
 
Gauteng Transport Authority update
Gauteng Transport Authority updateGauteng Transport Authority update
Gauteng Transport Authority update
 
5 8
5 85 8
5 8
 
Charging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing Work
Charging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing WorkCharging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing Work
Charging Ahead | Making Road User Pricing Work
 
Road Funding in South Africa
Road Funding in South AfricaRoad Funding in South Africa
Road Funding in South Africa
 
Federal Transportation Update
Federal Transportation UpdateFederal Transportation Update
Federal Transportation Update
 
20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida
20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida
20-year Transportation Funding Shortfall in Florida
 
A kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept study
A kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept studyA kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept study
A kilometre based road user charge system proof of concept study
 
ATU Fairfax County Bus Takeover Release
ATU Fairfax County Bus Takeover ReleaseATU Fairfax County Bus Takeover Release
ATU Fairfax County Bus Takeover Release
 
Federal Grants to State and Local Governments for Investment
Federal Grants to State and Local Governments for InvestmentFederal Grants to State and Local Governments for Investment
Federal Grants to State and Local Governments for Investment
 
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
04/24/13: State of the Highway Trust Fund: Long-Term Solutions for Solvency
 
A Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in Florida
A Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in FloridaA Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in Florida
A Review of MPO Long Range Transportation Plans in Florida
 
2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP Highlights2040 RTP Highlights
2040 RTP Highlights
 
Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...
Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...
Challenges and Opportunities: A National Perspective on the Public Transit In...
 
Extra! Extra!: New Circulars and Guidance
Extra! Extra!: New Circulars and GuidanceExtra! Extra!: New Circulars and Guidance
Extra! Extra!: New Circulars and Guidance
 
UNECE Sedov
UNECE SedovUNECE Sedov
UNECE Sedov
 
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito
[Urban transportation policy program] action plan quito
 
Federal Transportation Funding Update
Federal Transportation Funding UpdateFederal Transportation Funding Update
Federal Transportation Funding Update
 
Surface Transportation - Finance Context & Issues
Surface Transportation - Finance Context & IssuesSurface Transportation - Finance Context & Issues
Surface Transportation - Finance Context & Issues
 

Viewers also liked

Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual MeetingCindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual MeetingJames Barnes
 
Responding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio Forward
Responding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio ForwardResponding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio Forward
Responding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio ForwardGreenCityBlueLake Institute
 
Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...
Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...
Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...Congress for the New Urbanism
 
Congestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s plan
Congestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s planCongestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s plan
Congestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s planstreetsblog
 
Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...
Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...
Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...Congress for the New Urbanism
 
Influence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissions
Influence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissionsInfluence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissions
Influence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissionsInstitute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 
Next Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and Parking
Next Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and ParkingNext Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and Parking
Next Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and ParkingMarcus Bowman
 
14 15 vmt_sb375-1
14 15 vmt_sb375-114 15 vmt_sb375-1
14 15 vmt_sb375-1Mei Chi Lo
 
VMT Validity and Alternative Measures of Motorization
VMT Validity and Alternative Measures of MotorizationVMT Validity and Alternative Measures of Motorization
VMT Validity and Alternative Measures of MotorizationAmy Tzu-Yu Chen
 
Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...
Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...
Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...Institute for Transport Studies (ITS)
 

Viewers also liked (12)

Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual MeetingCindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
 
Responding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio Forward
Responding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio ForwardResponding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio Forward
Responding to Climate Change - Driving Ohio Forward
 
Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...
Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...
Driving and the Environment: The Effects of Compact Development on Motorized ...
 
Congestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s plan
Congestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s planCongestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s plan
Congestion Mitigation Strategies: Alternatives to the City’s plan
 
Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...
Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...
Reducing CO2 Emissions through Parking and Transportation Demand Management- ...
 
Influence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissions
Influence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissionsInfluence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissions
Influence of tradable credits on travel demand and vehicle emissions
 
Next Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and Parking
Next Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and ParkingNext Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and Parking
Next Generation Vehicles: Electric Cars, Emissions, Commuting, and Parking
 
Metro High Capacity Transit System Plan
Metro High Capacity Transit System PlanMetro High Capacity Transit System Plan
Metro High Capacity Transit System Plan
 
14 15 vmt_sb375-1
14 15 vmt_sb375-114 15 vmt_sb375-1
14 15 vmt_sb375-1
 
VMT Validity and Alternative Measures of Motorization
VMT Validity and Alternative Measures of MotorizationVMT Validity and Alternative Measures of Motorization
VMT Validity and Alternative Measures of Motorization
 
Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...
Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...
Freight transport models with logistics in data-rich and not so rich environ...
 
Transport systems and climate change in developing countries
Transport systems and climate change in developing countriesTransport systems and climate change in developing countries
Transport systems and climate change in developing countries
 

Similar to Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways

Reforming surface transportation funding and financing
Reforming surface transportation funding and financingReforming surface transportation funding and financing
Reforming surface transportation funding and financingmarcscribner
 
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...LTC @ CSUSB
 
Mileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQ
Mileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQMileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQ
Mileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQPorts-To-Plains Blog
 
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...Mercatus Center
 
Transportation Electrification in Vermont
Transportation Electrification in VermontTransportation Electrification in Vermont
Transportation Electrification in VermontEAN-VT
 
Ppp for solving public transport woes in india
Ppp for solving public transport woes in indiaPpp for solving public transport woes in india
Ppp for solving public transport woes in indiaAmit Jain
 
Presentation on Closed Toll & Toll Systems
Presentation on Closed Toll & Toll SystemsPresentation on Closed Toll & Toll Systems
Presentation on Closed Toll & Toll Systemsshanmuga sundaram
 
Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?
Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?
Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?Ujjwal Rao
 
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual MeetingCindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual MeetingJames Barnes
 
DP_Road_pricing_in_Australia
DP_Road_pricing_in_AustraliaDP_Road_pricing_in_Australia
DP_Road_pricing_in_AustraliaAndrew Mote
 
Why new road user tax
Why new road user taxWhy new road user tax
Why new road user taxM S Siddiqui
 
EV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPC
EV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPCEV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPC
EV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPCShiva Prashanth Kasina
 
Feedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary Experiment
Feedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary ExperimentFeedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary Experiment
Feedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary ExperimentTristan Wiggill
 
Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...
Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...
Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...WSP
 
Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...
Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...
Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...IEA-ETSAP
 
The Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provision
The Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provisionThe Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provision
The Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provisionUniversity of Canberra
 

Similar to Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways (20)

Reforming surface transportation funding and financing
Reforming surface transportation funding and financingReforming surface transportation funding and financing
Reforming surface transportation funding and financing
 
Transportasi kota malang
Transportasi kota malangTransportasi kota malang
Transportasi kota malang
 
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
 
illuminati
illuminatiilluminati
illuminati
 
Mileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQ
Mileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQMileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQ
Mileage Based User Fee Alliance FAQ
 
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
Sustaining Surface Transportation: Overview of the Highway Trust Fund and Ide...
 
Comprehensive RUC Presentation
Comprehensive RUC PresentationComprehensive RUC Presentation
Comprehensive RUC Presentation
 
Transportation Electrification in Vermont
Transportation Electrification in VermontTransportation Electrification in Vermont
Transportation Electrification in Vermont
 
Ppp for solving public transport woes in india
Ppp for solving public transport woes in indiaPpp for solving public transport woes in india
Ppp for solving public transport woes in india
 
Presentation on Closed Toll & Toll Systems
Presentation on Closed Toll & Toll SystemsPresentation on Closed Toll & Toll Systems
Presentation on Closed Toll & Toll Systems
 
Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?
Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?
Electric Vehicle Is it a threat to CNG?
 
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual MeetingCindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
Cindy Burbank's Presentation to the 2009 Highway Users Annual Meeting
 
DP_Road_pricing_in_Australia
DP_Road_pricing_in_AustraliaDP_Road_pricing_in_Australia
DP_Road_pricing_in_Australia
 
Why new road user tax
Why new road user taxWhy new road user tax
Why new road user tax
 
EV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPC
EV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPCEV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPC
EV Charging - Business Opportunity for NTPC
 
Feedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary Experiment
Feedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary ExperimentFeedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary Experiment
Feedback on DRiVE: Distance-based Road user charge Voluntary Experiment
 
Funding Opportunities for Premium Transit Corridors Presenation
Funding Opportunities for Premium Transit Corridors PresenationFunding Opportunities for Premium Transit Corridors Presenation
Funding Opportunities for Premium Transit Corridors Presenation
 
Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...
Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...
Mobility Pricing: How to Harness Mobility Pricing to Reduce Congestion, Promo...
 
Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...
Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...
Exploration of cross-sector emissions benefits of medium- and heavy-duty vehi...
 
The Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provision
The Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provisionThe Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provision
The Politics of Road Reform: The challenges ahead for road pricing and provision
 

More from Congressional Budget Office

The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing SlidesThe Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing SlidesCongressional Budget Office
 
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 SlidesThe Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 SlidesCongressional Budget Office
 
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of TaxpayersUsing Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of TaxpayersCongressional Budget Office
 
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding PlanPerspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding PlanCongressional Budget Office
 
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher CostsThe 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher CostsCongressional Budget Office
 
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the BudgetExploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the BudgetCongressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCongressional Budget Office
 
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
 Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of UnemploymentCongressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary OutlookCBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary OutlookCongressional Budget Office
 
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...Congressional Budget Office
 
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the CongressCBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the CongressCongressional Budget Office
 
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020Congressional Budget Office
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeCongressional Budget Office
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeCongressional Budget Office
 

More from Congressional Budget Office (20)

The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing SlidesThe Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
The Budget and Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034: Press Briefing Slides
 
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 SlidesThe Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
The Economic Outlook for 2024 to 2034 in 19 Slides
 
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of TaxpayersUsing Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
Using Multiple Data Sources to Learn About the Race and Ethnicity of Taxpayers
 
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding PlanPerspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
Perspectives on the Navy’s 2024 Shipbuilding Plan
 
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher CostsThe 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
The 2024 Outlook for Navy Shipbuilding: Familiar Plans and Higher Costs
 
CBO’s Use of GitHub
CBO’s Use of GitHubCBO’s Use of GitHub
CBO’s Use of GitHub
 
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the BudgetExploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
Exploring the Effects of Medicaid During Childhood on the Economy and the Budget
 
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s Role and Most Recent Long-Term Budget Projections
 
Atlas of Military Compensation
Atlas of Military CompensationAtlas of Military Compensation
Atlas of Military Compensation
 
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
 Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
Approaches to Estimating the Noncyclical Rate of Unemployment
 
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary OutlookCBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
CBO’s Analysis of the Long-Term Budgetary Outlook
 
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
Projecting the Effects of U.S. Federal Policies on Electric Vehicle Demand an...
 
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the CongressCBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
CBO’s Recent Appeals for New Research to Enhance Its Work for the Congress
 
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
Trends in the Distribution of Household Income From 1979 to 2020
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
 
Health Care and the Federal Budget
Health Care and the Federal Budget Health Care and the Federal Budget
Health Care and the Federal Budget
 
How CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax Revenues
How CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax RevenuesHow CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax Revenues
How CBO Projects Corporate Income Tax Revenues
 
CBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget ProjectionsCBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget Projections
CBO’s 2023 Long-Term Budget Projections
 
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget OfficeThe Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget Process and the Role of the Congressional Budget Office
 
The U.S. Economic Outlook
The U.S. Economic OutlookThe U.S. Economic Outlook
The U.S. Economic Outlook
 

Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways

  • 1. Congressional Budget Office October 15, 2012 Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways Presentation to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Perry Beider Senior Advisor, Microeconomic Studies Division This presentation provides information published in Alternative Approaches to Funding Highways (March 2011). See www.cbo.gov/publication/22059.
  • 2. CBO’s Report on Funding Alternatives for Federal Spending on Highways ■ Focuses on fuel and VMT taxes ■ Uses facts and estimates from literature ■ Provides an economic framework ■ Requested by the Chairman of the Senate Budget Committee CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 3. Highway Funding Goals ■ Efficiency ■ Equity ■ Privacy CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 4. Goal 1: Efficiency Maximize benefits of road travel net of total costs, including • Costs of building and maintaining roads • Costs of using roads • Costs of the funding system itself (direct or indirect) CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 5. Comparing Fuel and VMT Taxes: Incentives for Efficient Road Use ■ Prescription for efficiency: Charge people for the marginal cost of their use or consumption of a good or service CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 6. Estimated Mileage- and Fuel-related Costs Mileage-Related Costs Rural Passenger Vehicles Fuel-Related Costs (Converted to cents per mile) Urban Passenger Vehicles Rural Trucks Urban Trucks 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 7. Charges That Maximize Efficiency of Road Use ■ Charge for both VMT and fuel use ■ Total charges 3 to 8 times higher than today ■ Full marginal-cost pricing on entire road network would yield ~ $500 billion per year, 3 times the current total construction and O&M spending (~ $160 billion per year) ■ Efficient VMT charge: uniform “base” component + (potentially much larger) “congestion” component that varies by time and place ■ Congestion charges could save ~$40 billion per year in construction, $20 to $50 billion per year in time and fuel CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 8. Would Implementation Costs Outweigh the Benefits of VMT Taxes? ■ Costs of a nationwide system very uncertain; available evidence is limited ■ Estimated benefits of $60 to 90 billion per year from congestion pricing leave a lot of room for implementation costs ■ What about less comprehensive VMT taxes? CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 9. Goal 2: Equity Fair treatment for • Different groups of users? • General taxpayers? • People with low incomes? • Rural residents? • “Donor” states? • All of the above? CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 10. Equity Implications ■ Both fuel and VMT taxes satisfy “user pays” criterion ■ Both fuel taxes and VMT taxes other than congestion charges impose larger relative burdens on • Households that drive more (e.g., rural) • Lower-income households ■ Fuel taxes also impose larger relative burdens on households using lower-MPG vehicles (sports cars, SUVs, pickup trucks, old cars) ■ Congestion charges shift tax burden toward (mostly urban) households that drive in congested conditions CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 11. Goal 3: Privacy ■ Implications for efficiency and equity ■ But core issue is respecting individuals’ rights CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 12. Options for Addressing Privacy Concerns 1. Limit the information used 2. Use detailed information but do all charge calculations in- vehicle • Store info internally for specified time or • Deduct charges in real time from prepaid debit card 3. Use detailed info; calculate charges externally but • Anonymously or • Using a private company 4. Ease into VMT system; let private firms bundle other services 5. Allow “safety valve” opt-out alternative(s) for those most concerned about privacy CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 13. Summary Comparisons Compared to fuel taxes, VMT taxes • Provide better incentives for efficient road use • Are no worse on some interpretations of equity and better on others • Have higher (and more uncertain) implementation costs • Raise privacy concerns (for congestion charges) CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE
  • 14. Two Key Questions for a System of VMT Charges ■ What should the system do? • Just raise revenue? • Reduce pavement damage? • Reduce specific congestion problems? • Maximize efficiency of road use? ■ Who should lead the system’s introduction? • The federal government? • The states? • The private sector? CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE