1.
Forking Successfully
Colin Charles, Chief Evangelist, Percona Inc.
colin.charles@percona.com / byte@bytebot.net
http://bytebot.net/blog/ | @bytebot on Twitter
OSCON London, United Kingdom
17 October 2016

2.
whoami
• Chief Evangelist (in the CTO office), Percona Inc
• Founding team of MariaDB Server (2009-2016),
previously at Monty Program Ab, merged with SkySQL
Ab, now MariaDB Corporation
• Formerly MySQL AB (exit: Sun Microsystems)
• Past lives include Fedora Project (FESCO),
OpenOffice.org
• MySQL Community Contributor of the Year Award winner
2014

3.
Agenda
• Forks
• GitHub generation
• GNU Emacs and XEmacs
• MySQL, MariaDB Server, and Percona Server
• Drizzle?
• Other forks

4.
To fork, or not to fork,
that is the question

5.
Fork
In software engineering, a project fork happens
when developers take a copy of source code from
one software package and start independent
development on it, creating a distinct and separate
piece of software.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fork_(software_development)

6.
GitHub generation
• Watch: Notifications for active participants
• Star: Bookmarking + “light” appreciation
• Fork: a copy of a repository; make your changes
• Pull request: encouraging to merge your
changes with the upstream project

7.
First open source fork…
• POSTGRES?
• 1986, when Michael Stonebraker wanted the
‘after Ingres’ database
• Today this has given you PostgreSQL

8.
GNU Emacs and
XEmacs
1991

9.
Copyright Assignment
(and Contributor License Agreements)

10.
Last stable release of
XEmacs
January 2009

11.
Feature Parity
(or the death of a fork)

12.
MySQL
World’s most popular open source database

13.
GPL MySQL
2000

14.
October 2005: Oracle
acquires Innobase Oy
(“InnoDB Friday”)

15.
October 2005 - late 2005
• October 2005: 5.0 becomes GA*
• Late 2005: Maria project starts

16.
MySQL fast-forward
• January 2008: acquired by Sun Microsystems
• June 2008: Drizzle — fork of MySQL 6.0 — modular, fast,
microkernel architecture, UTF8, etc.
• November 2008: Percona Server (patchset ~July)
• April 2009: Oracle proposes acquisition of Sun Microsystems
(and MySQL)
• January 2010: Oracle completes acquisition of Sun
Microsystems
• October 2009: MariaDB 5.1 Beta release

17.
MariaDB
• Developed at Monty Program Ab
• February 2010: MariaDB 5.1 GA release
• November 2010: MariaDB 5.2 GA release
• February 2012: MariaDB 5.3 GA (GIS, replication
improvements, optimiser)
• April 2012: MariaDB 5.5 GA
• November 2012: Announcement of MariaDB Foundation

18.
Community Developed.
Feature Enhanced.
Backward Compatible.

19.
Community Developed
• MariaDB: takes external contributors/committers,
Google Summer of Code
• MySQL: contributions welcome, commits not
• MySQL Community Contributor Award
Program
• Percona: bug reports/feature requests welcome,
commits not (pull requests accepted)

20.
Distribution matters
• Being available matters
• Linux distributions, clouds, containers, etc.
• Security matters - fix those CVEs quickly, and
say what got fixed

21.
Branch or Fork?
• MySQL 5.5 — Percona Server 5.5 — MariaDB
Server 5.5 - drop-in compatible
• MySQL 5.6 — Percona Server 5.6 - drop-in
compatible
• MySQL 5.7 — Percona Server 5.7 - drop-in
compatible

22.
Drizzle
• Drizzle: 2008 - 2012 (R.I.P.)
• Aggressive about standards — utf8 was first
class, FRM files were gone, no MEDIUMINTs,
etc.
• Drizzle - single company open source project
(Rackspace). Most went on to work at
OpenStack

23.
LibreOffice/OpenOffice.org
• LibreOffice started as ooo-build for the large
codebase
• Document Foundation backed (28 Sep 2010)
• March 2015 LWN.net - “LibreOffice has won the
battle for developer participation”
• Apache Foundation got OpenOffice.org -> Apache
OpenOffice
• Lack of active developers and code contributions

24.
There are others!

25.
Nagios and Icinga

26.
OpenSSL and
LibreSSL

27.
node.js and io.js

28.
Hudson and Jenkins

29.
OwnCloud and
NextCloud

30.
SugarCRM and
SuiteCRM

31.
OpenBSD and
NetBSD

32.
Oracle Enterprise Linux
and CentOS and Red Hat
Enterprise Linux

33.
To watch
• Docker
• MariaDB MaxScale

34.
Bitcoin
And the hard fork

35.
Android

36.
Those who cannot
remember the past are
condemned to repeat it.
George Santayana

37.
Why are you forking?

38.
Naming
• Pick a good one that focuses on values
• Beware of trademarks

39.
Takeaways
• Community matters
• Developers matter
• Limit end-user friction
• Sustainable development methodology
• Fork as a last resort
• Clear fork focus

40.
As a user what should you
use?
• Think about innovation today
• Beware vendor lock-in - freedom from vendor
independence is crucial
• Ensure you are well supported

41.
Thank you!
Colin Charles
colin.charles@percona.com / byte@bytebot.net
http://bytebot.net/blog | @bytebot on twitter
slides: slideshare.net/bytebot