1. Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia
Part 2: Linked Multimedia
Bernhard Haslhofer, Bernhard Schandl, Andreas Langegger,
Wolfgang Halb, Tobias Bürger
1 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
2. Agenda
Multimedia Interlinking: Concept + Vision
Multimedia Annotations
Enriching Personal Media Collections
2 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
3. Multimedia Interlinking
Concept and Vision of a Web of Video Data
Applying the Linked Data principles to multimedia
content
W3C Video on the Web activity
Fragment Identification
Media Annotation
3 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
4. Vision of a Web of Video Data
Aim: Make video an integral part of the Web in which
users can seamlessly consume and create videos
Requirements:
Deep Linking: timed URIs
Metadata: Time-aligned annotations & tags
Search-ability: Searching media using text
Dynamic composition of video mashups
Discoverability: Hyperlinking from inside media to other Web
resources
Share-ability: Integrated handling of metadata with the content
Personalisation: Dynamic composition of media web content
cf. Silvia Pfeiffer “Architecture of a Video Web - Experience with Annodex” W3C Video on the Web workshop, 13.12.2008
4 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
5. Why?
Source: Cisco's Global Consumer Internet Traffic Forecast, Cisco, 2009
5 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
6. Example 1: Where is Danny?
6 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
7. Example 2: Who is Jack?
Region-based annotation in Flickr
Cannot be taken outside of Flickr
Can only be accessed via the Flickr API
7 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
8. Example 3: Complex Query
1. show me photos of actors participating in the
SHINING movie visiting a country in Europe
LinkedMovieDB: list of actors participating in SHINING-: [L-
ACT]
Geonames: list European countries -: [L-EC]
Google: list photos taken in a country of [L-EC] -: [L-ECP]
Google: in [L-ECP] find regions that depict members of [L-
ACT] -: result
2. give me a summary of all scenes from arbitraty
videos where actors talk to a film producer
8 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
9. Linked Data: Current State of
Practice
Linked Data currently mostly applied for textual
resources (cf. LOD cloud)
If any media resources are interlinked then on a
global level (cf. BBC)
Some communities demand for methods to link on a
more fine grained level (cineasts, biologists, etc.)
[Schroeter and Hunter, 2007]
9 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
10. Problems
How to address and retrieve parts of multimedia
content (e.g., a region of an image, sequence of a
video)
How to describe parts of multimedia content in the
Web of Data?
cf. M. Hausenblas, R. Troncy, T. Bürger, and Y. Raimond “How to apply Linked Data principles to multimedia fragments”
Proceedings of LDOW 2009, 2009.
10 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
11. Interlinking Multimedia (iM)
1. Apply linked data principles for fine-grained
identification and description of multimedia
fragments -> W3C Media Fragments WG
2. Describe multimedia content -> W3C Media
Annotations WG
3. Deploy legacy multimedia metadata formats on the
Web of Data -> ramm.x
4. Develop specialized interlinking methods for
multimedia
User-contributed, game-based interlinking
Collaborative interlinking, cf. MetaVidWiki
(Semi-)automatic methods: Multimedia analysis
11 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
12. Media Fragments WG Goal
Provide URI-based mechanisms for
uniquely identifying fragments for
media objects on the Web, such as
video, audio, and images.
Credits: Slides about Media Fragments WG by the Media Fragments WG.
12 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
13. Media Fragments: Use Case
and Requirements
Document:
http://www.w3.org/2008/WebVideo/Fragments/wiki/
Use_Cases_&_Requirements_Draft
Link to, Display, Bookmark, Annotate, Search, etc. media
fragments
Type of fragments: four dimensions considered
time ([point?] interval), space ([point?] rectangle), track and id
(named fragment)
Protocols covered: HTTP(S), RTSP
13 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
14. Technological Survey
Media Fragments URI already present on the Web ... but with
very different syntax and behaviour
Google Video: (#50m16s)
YouTube: (#t=1m45s)
Archive.org powered by TemporalURI: (?t=74.5 )
Videosurf: (?t=140&e=184)
Microsoft IIS 7.0: (Fragments(video=20000000))
Other time-clipping and spatial clipping methods:
MPEG-21: time, space, track, id (mp(/CD/track/~time(%27npt
%27,%270%27,%2760%27))
SVG: space (svgView(14.64,15.73,146.98,147.48))
SMIL: time (clipBegin, clipEnd), space (panZoom, area), media markers
MPEG-7: time, space, modality
14 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
15. Media Fragments 1.0
Syntax
http://www.example.com/movie.mov#t=12.33,21.16
http://www.example.com/
movie.mov#t=smpte-25:00:12:33:06,00:21:16:00
http://www.example.com/movie.mov#xywh=20,20,40,40
http://www.example.com/movie.mov#xywh=pixel:20,20,40,40
http://www.example.com/movie.mov#track='audio1'
http://www.example.com/movie.mov#id='the%20kiss%20scene'
http://www.example.com/
movie.mov#track='audio2'&t=12.33,21.16
15 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
16. Media Annotation WG: Purpose
16 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
17. Media Annotations WG: Core
Ontology
Goal: to develop a simple lingua franca
17 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
18. Bringing Legacy Metadata to
the Web of Data: ramm.x
Problem: How to make existing multimedia metadata in legacy formats (e.g.,
MPEG-7) available on the Semantic Web?
Aim: To deploy existing legacy metadata in HTML documents and by that
integrate external descriptions in a RICO by reference.
Ramm.X uses RDFa, formalisations of metadata standards, and the
Ramm.X vocabulary to deploy multimedia metadata.
18 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
19. Interlinking Methods
1. Automatic Interlinking
2. Emergent Interlinking
x
3. User Contributed Interlinking UCI
4. Game based Interlinking GBI
x
Quality
AI
EI x
x
# Annotations
Time
19 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
20. References
Michael Hausenblas, Raphael Troncy, Tobias Bürger, and Yves
Raimond "Interlinking Multimedia: How to Apply Linked Data
Principles to Multimedia Fragments" In: Proceedings of Linked Data
on the Web (LDOW2009), co-located with the 18th International
World Wide Web Conference (WWW2009), Madrid, Spain, 2009
WonSuk Lee, Tobias Bürger, Felix Sasaki, Véronique Malaisé,
Florian Stegmaier, and Joakim Söderberg (eds.) "Ontology for
Media Resource 1.0" W3C Media Annotation Working Group, W3C
Working Draft 18 June 2009, 2009.
Raphaël Troncy, Erik Mannens, Michael Hausenblas, Jack Jansen,
Yves Lafon, Silvia Pfeiffer, and Davy van Deursen "Media
Fragments URI 1.0" W3C Working Draft 18 November 2009, 2009.
Silvia Pfeiffer “Architecture of a Video Web - Experience with
Annodex” W3C Video on the Web workshop, 13.12.2008, 2008.
20 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
21. What’ll come next
Multimedia annotations: The LEMO framework
Enriching personal media collections
21 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
22. Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia
Part 1: Linked Open Data: Vision, Concepts and Technologies
Bernhard Haslhofer, Bernhard Schandl, Andreas Langegger,
Wolfgang Halb, Tobias Bürger
22 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
23. Agenda
Introduction Multimedia Interlinking
Producing Linked Data Multimedia Annotations
Existing Data Sets Enriching Personal
Media Collections
Linking Data
Consuming Linked Data
23 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
24. Many interpretations
An annotation is…
… a remark, explanation, or interpretation added to the original
document
… a means to make implicit structures explicit
… a datum created by a third party that can take the form of a
written note, a symbol, a drawing, or a multimedia clip
...
There are different interpretation of the term
Annotation in different domains
24 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
25. 25 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
26. Many solutions
26 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
27. Many solutions
27 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
28. What is LEMO?
A Web-based, multimedia annotation framework
Consisting of
A semantic backend-end storage
Front-ends for image, audio, and video annotations
Online Demo at:
http://dme.arcs.ac.at/annotation/econnect-
annotation-showcase.html
28 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
29. Driving requirements
Objects to be annotated are multimedia
Need a uniform data model, no content-type specific solution
Annotations often address specific content parts
(fragements)
Need a uniform fragment identification approach
Shift towards the Web
Do no lock annotation data in closed data stores but…
Expose annotation data as Linked Data on the Web (following the
Linked Data Principles)
29 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
30. Driving Requirements
Reuse of existing standards
(Semantic) Web Standards
URI, HTTP, RDF, RDF/S, OWL
RESTful Web Service Design
Annotea data model & protocol
Xpointer, MPEG21, SVG, etc. for fragment
identification
30 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
31. Why not use Annotea as it is?
Annotea is for the annotation of Web pages; LEMO
should also support annotation of embedded content
items
Annotea doesn’t assign datatypes to its properties;
LEMO uses OWL’s (data)typing features
Annotea doesn’t support multimedia fragment
identification; LEMO uses MPEG-21 (multimedia)
fragment identification
31 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
32. A Uniform Annotation Model
annotation profiles; cf. application profiles for
metadata interoperability
an Annotea-based core model
with content- and annotation-type specific model
extensions
implemented as light-weight software components
(add-ons)
32 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
33. A Uniform Annotation Model
33 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
34. A Uniform Annotation Model
34 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
35. Uniform Fragment Identification
introduce a fragment element with URI range
follow MPEG-21 media pointer scheme
an annotation can define multiple fragments
URI-encoding of fragments
minimal consensus
content-type specific extensions
35 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
38. Annotations as Web Resources
38 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
39. Annotations as Web Resources
39 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
40. References
The LEMO Annotation Framework (paper)
http://www.cs.univie.ac.at/upload//550/papers/
lemo_framework_final.pdf
The LEMO Annotation Framework (code)
http://europeanalabs.eu
Open Annotation Collaboration
http://www.openannotation.org/
40 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
41. Agenda
Introduction Multimedia Interlinking
Producing Linked Data Multimedia Annotations
Existing Data Sets Enriching Personal
Media Collections
Linking Data
Consuming Linked Data
41 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
42. Enriching Personal
Media Collections
42 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
43. Goal
to raise problem awareness for personal
semantic multimedia
to introduce the basic concepts of semantic
personal information management
to introduce recent research and tools from
the semantic desktop community
to indicate overlaps and potential for cross-
fertilization
43 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
44. The Web
The World Wide Web is designed for
humans, not machines.
Automatic information processing is hard.
But at least, there is a common technology
infrastructure (URIs, HTTP, HTML,
browsers, etc.).
This is a solid basis to build upon: the
Semantic Web and Linked Data reuse and
extend the human-centric Web.
44 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
45. The Desktop
On your desktop, this problem is even
worse:
No unified identification of data items.
No standardized, simple communication
protocol.
No agreed, open representation format for
data.
No means to store and retrieve semantic
annotations.
45 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
46. How does your desktop look like?
files
emails
documents
contacts
media
...
at most: fulltext search ... which doesn’t
work well for multimedia data
46 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
47. … organize
Invitation E-Mail
meeting in
Belfast …
Time Schedule
Attendee Dirk Belfast Weather Meeting Agenda
47 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
48. How are data organized?
Hierarchical structures (aka data silos) for
files, emails, bookmarks, applications, ...
Separate organization metaphors for
contacts, calendars, communication, ...
Multimedia data: media-dependent
metadata (look at your music player or your
photo manager), locked away in files or in
application-specific data bases.
The walled personal information garden ...
48 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
49. 49 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
50. Personal Multimedia
For the organization of multimedia data,
metadata is key.
How to manage your personal metadata?
50 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
51. The Semantic Desktop
The vision of the Semantic Desktop is to
create an infrastructure for the
management of meaningful metadata about
resources that covers the entire personal
sphere of information.
In fact, the Semantic Desktop is your
personal Semantic Web.
51 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
52. How?
assign globally unique, immutable URIs to
all resources.
collect / store / index resource descriptions
and relations between resources.
provide uniform access to these
descriptions.
integrate these descriptions into
applications and make use of them.
social semantic desktop: share and
communicate personal resources.
52 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
53. Why?
The Semantic Desktop reflects the user’s
Personal Information Model — i.e., the
user’s view on their data.
This allows tools to deliver information
when it is actually needed.
53 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
54. Topic Project
… organize
Invitation E-Mail
meeting in Management CID
Belfast …
Time Schedule
Attendee Dirk Belfast Weather Meeting Agenda
54 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
55. What can the Semantic Desktop deliver?
Contextualized, semantic search
find information more efficiently
Similarity metrics and recommendations
show the user what they already have in their
data space
Data analysis and information extractions
understand and interpret what is there
55 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
56. What can the Semantic Desktop deliver?
Semantic Tagging
relate things and concepts
Semantic Personal Wikis
useful notetaking and semistructured resource
description
User Interfaces
faceted search, drag+drop annotations, etc.
56 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
57. Recent Research Projects
NEPOMUK (EU FP6) [Gro07]
has (amongst others) defined a reference
architecture and ontologies for the
representation of personal information
reference implementation (desktop
service), based on Java/Eclipse
goal: infrastructure for existing OS
integration in KDE 4
raised significant public awareness (2
times slashdotted)
57 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
58. Commercial Break
Results from NEPOMUK and other
projects are commercialized, have a
look at www.gnowsis.com
58 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
59. Recent Research Projects
Haystack [Kar07]
has presented a new metaphor for
interacting with data
dynamically assembled user
interfaces
dynamically assembled workflows
and data conversions
basically an OS modeled in RDF
59 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
60. Many more
DeepaMehta
DBin
Chandler
Semex
iMeMex
IRIS
X-COSIM
...
60 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
61. Semantic Desktop Infrastructure
SemDAV [Sch09]
combines aspects from the Semantic Web and
file systems into a unified data model
provides storage and query mechanism for
semantic files
provides virtual file system access for file-based
applications
provides an API for “semantic” applications
provides file browser-like user interaction
metaphors
61 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
62. 62 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
63. Semantic Desktop Infrastructure
TripFS [Sch09a]
exposes a file system as Linked Data
assigns immutable URIs to files and
traces file system modifications
extracts metadata from files and exposes
them as RDF
provides a SPARQL endpoint over the file
system
links files to external data sources (e.g.,
MusicBrainz, ACM, ...)
63 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
64. 64 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
65. Semantic Desktop Infrastructure
Aperture [Sau06]
a generic framework for extraction of
metadata from digital resources
provides extractors, crawlers, monitors, ...
for different kinds of data sources (e.g.,
file system, email, web pages, web
services, ...)
can be extended and customized
open-source
65 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
66. Semantic Desktop Infrastructure
Nepomuk-KDE
core components from NEPOMUK
(resource identification, triple store,
ontologies) have been integrated in KDE 4
and are now part of the standard
distribution.
first implemented application: tags,
comments and ratings for files
much more to follow (e.g., Gwenview
image viewer, Bangarang media player,...)
66 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
67. 67 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
68. 68 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
69. 69 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
70. 70 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
71. 71 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
72. 72 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
73. Summary
The Semantic Desktop is highly relevant for
the management of personal media
collections — metadata is key!
It is there! – just use it.
Questions? bernhard.schandl@univie.ac.at
73 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
74. References & Credits
[Gro07] Tudor Groza et al., The NEPOMUK Project –
On the Way to the Social Semantic Desktop. Proc. I-
Semantics 2007
[Kar07] David Karger, Haystack: Per-User
Information Environments Based on Semistructured
Data, in: Beyond the Desktop Metaphor, MIT Press,
2007.
[Sch09] Bernhard Schandl et al., The Sile Model — A
Semantic File System Infrastructure for the Desktop.
Proc. ESWC 2009
74 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009
75. References & Credits
[Sch09] Bernhard Schandl, TripFS: Exposing File
Systems as Linked Data. Triplification Challenge
2009.
[Sau06] Leo Sauermann et al., Semantic Desktop
2.0: The Gnowsis Experience. Proc. ISWC 2006
75 SAMT 2009 – Tutorial Web of Data in the Context of Multimedia (WoDMM) Graz, Austria - 2 Dec 2009