Benamor.belgacemهل الديمقراطية قابلة للتصدير ؟

4..jhtJ4~...l't ~
~ ~j ca1.U 4.lJl....r::: •

~~~~~t.ual
~~t~J~
jadawel ~fJql~

9Jo:!~ ~l ~·~..l.tt JA: '-:'~
.iliA ;j>.!.JJ ~bl:a !)l:a.J) :.r.,~
~_;Jt~J~ :~_,..JI JlJ.Aj
JJI~
~jplJ 4 _r)IJ _,..!.:..ll
JJ11 ~Uall_ ;s_r.ll ~~ _~_,.s::.!l t.;l! _I~I
00961 1 746637 :..,...su- 00961 1 746638 :U.."lA
<J~_..:.>J~-<JI.;_,..!. 13_5558 :~·d"
e-mail: d.jadawel@gmail.com
www.jadawel.net
JJf.Jl~l
2012 ~i;...,.X
ISBN 978-614-418-135-5
~jpi.J ~_;.li.J _r:JJ JJI.,l,; ©a,p J_#-1 ~
~J ~~ Ji J~11 ~ ~ '-?i J ~l::S01 ~ ..~ '-?i J~l Ji ~ j~ ~
Jl.)-_yy4)1 ~l..!lJj J 4 ·W~I ii ~J~)'I ii ~_r._,....dl -.I_,.... JL..._,JI ~
._r!l:JI ~ ~ <Jjl <JJ.:> ~~_;.....IJ ..:.>l..#l..i.i;..J l..III_,.....Ji ~y-!i ~ ~IJ
<Jl.YJ~
Copyright © Jadawel S.A.R.L
Hamra Str. - AI-Baraka Bldg.
P.O.Box: 5558-13 Shouran
Beirut - Lebanon
First Published 2012 Beirut

s
11 ............... ...1...!.1)1 ~)I~~~ ... ~..,..JI_, ~~~..UI
19 ............................... ~..r...L..a::ll ~l.i ~I~..DI J"'
21 .............................................. 0~1
27 .•....•...•...•.........•...•.....•.......•.. 0l:.::...l_, ~
29 .................................................. t..::iA.o
33 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ii...b..::.JI ~ ~'1_,.1.l ~J l>JI L l::-J1_, ~ I~..U I
38 . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . • . . . . . . . ...1.;~1 J~l
41 .................................. }a.:JI ~~_, :r ~~
45 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~~')>.11 ~_,J_,II
47 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~. ~•.); J_,li:-.. ~I~..UI _r...L,a; ~L:i')>.i
48 ............... ~I~..UI ~~~ JL.::; .;JI ~~I ~I J~~
54 ............................. <<("""'11 0ylill_, «J~WI ~lk>Jill
55 .. .. .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. . .. ~I~..UI ~~I :r ...1.;~ t_Y
62 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J~~l)l Jl-::JI :r -,?..b..::.ll_, ii.r""~l .!J~I
65 .. . .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. . .. . .. .. .. _;l:)Y.""-""'_,s:JI ~Kll ~)I
68 .................................................. Wl>-
73 .................................... ~I 4... ··'I .1. •'I• ..>::-:' _,/_r-J
75 ...................... ~_,..UI_, _;..WI ~I LIJ~ (!::"~ ii~~l

6
78 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~.k.11 ~W11 0.::.JWI. .. .) .
78 ........................................... ~W11 :UW
83 ........................................... ~.k.11 :UWI. ..
87 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ ....':>......II•.J •
95 ... ······················ ··············· ······ ..:...~l:::.::.....
103 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .OlA!.l ~Y'
104 ............................................. .OlA!.l J~
107 .......................... ~~JJ o~ 4lA!.ll ~_;:JI
1, __;;;
108 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C:"L..::.lI
114 ............................................ oi.JUl (_.JJ
118 ................... ~1~.1.11 o~ J.,.JI.J ~oi.JUI.J ~C:"L..::.ll
120 ............. ~~~.ill ~Jl>JI ~~~ o~ JlA!.ll J...JI r.Jii
121 ................................. yl y _,AJI.J o~WI y _,.ill
124 .................................. ~~JJ .Jj}o..o.J y_,AJI
126 • -~~. . ••
· · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · · ~r 4-:?Y ~
134 ......... ..:...b~Jl.J ~~ r-_:;; :~Jl>JI ~~~.1.11 ~:rY.J .olA!.ll
134 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . i ~s- r..;;;
136 ............................................... ..:...b~Jl
143 ............. ~o~ ;;Q ;;·.II..::...~ .j ~~~JJI & ~
144 . L$_,.il1 .jlA!.li.J ~lk.ll V"'L..11 ..::...~ :..f.J.J ~;;. ;;·.ll ..::...~-* ~. . .
~
150 ............. ~~ ..:...s.I_;:JI ~1~.1.11 ..::...~~' ~.4; r_?
157 ..... ~..:...s.~ ..:...s.IJ o~ 0-" ~1~.1.11 ..::...~~' ~ r_?
162 . . . . . . . . . . . ~ .r.f- ~.JL::.ll -Y.I_,_ll ~ : ~~JJ ~
166 ........ ..::...lJj11 i!"JJ ~ _r.? ..:...WI_;:.....I.J ~..:...WI_;.....

7
172 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~~ ~~h~ j:j>U ~
177 ................ ~L...::JI ~J ,.j.MJI ~J ,~h..UI
177 .................................................. ~
179 ......................... _;~1 ~I op :_r ?.yo ~..Jt;
182 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~lh..UI ~1J ..;.Jl;jl.;:>.II ~
189 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~L...::JJ '-:?yA_r.JI Jjl.;:>.II
198 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wl>JI
201 ..................................... ..;.J~J ..;.JL...._;.JI
~~ ~t:; ~~ ~ jA ~..bJ ..;.Jl:kh..UI .) ~~' ~41
203 ................................................ ~~
205 ................................ ~~' ~41 ...A:~ .1
206 ......................................... ~~II ~11
206 ................................... ~_,.i!.l ~~II ~_,All
207 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..;.J4~'1 ~y
207 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _)J..U .;yi:JI
..ll_,$ ~ ~G-.11 ~ ~ _).~ :_r ..bJ :~~II ~41 Jl.ut .2
208 ....................................... ~l:.:.ll ..;.J4~'I
209 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~~~~II oJa::-D ~IS ..;.J4~'1
210 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~lh..UI _r.? Z>J)L.ill
211 .................................. _f~l C:__,...JIJ ..;.J4~'1
212 ............................. ~~I ..;.JL:liJIJ "'L:.ll : "'L,a;~
214 ............................. 0~ .r.? Jt ~ ~j>- ~t
215 ........................ ~_r.4.11J .1;_,.l:i>JI : ~~' ~41 .3
216 .................. ~ '"';-'~_rll .r.? Z>J)L.ilJ ~~' ~41

8
219 ...... -,f.L.:;..:;'1 ~~IJ -~'1 .:.oi~LJIJ •.:.o4l.>.:;'1 ~If"
222 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _f')l t!~IJ ~L.:;..:;'1 ~'1
223 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~_,JI ~IJ ~L.:;..:;'1 ~'I
229 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -1-j>JI i lk:JIJ ~ L.>.:;' I ~·' I
233 ................................. W~l Jl.u.'1 ~y .4
234 ............................................. .:.o~L:::.::......'1
237 ............................ ~~ JY.,..::. .,.l.!.jl ~ ~ ~ ~
237 .......................................... ~_,:.....::. .;..~
238 .......................................... .:.o~IJ PI
239 .............................................. :i.::ki~...Lll
240 ................................................ JIJ.::&:.II
241 ................................................ ~~...Lll
242 ............................................... .;..~__;JI
244 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ .....o'1 .:.oL~I........~.-fl. ..
246 ................................................ .:.oGUI
24 7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ;i.J ~ ~ •II .;..I.,.I .>I.. ~ .../•11-
24 7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0~L.....rJI 0_,kl4.11
250 ............................................... .,.L::...i.::....'1
251 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . '-?JY.......Lll .,.1::.'I i.Y' l:i
251 .............................................. :i.::ki~...Lll
252 .......................... ~~I~~ WJ~I ::._r.i)l
253 ................................................ ~~...Lll
253 ...................................... ~ II .:.olsl.a.>-'1.. .Y .. fl.
256 ....................................... .;...;~1 J .k~'1

9
257 ............. ~l~..lli.J ~_,:......lll ~~I~~ 1-7 ~I
259 ................ ~_,:......lll ~~"~'I.J ~l~..lll :2-7 ~I
262 .......... ~~""~'I J dl:JI ~b.J ~l~..lll :3-7 ~I
263 ...................... 4:~1 ~I~ ~.r.AJI :4-7 ~I
264 ............................. ~_,:......lll ~.r-!..lll :5-7 ~I
265 .................................................. Wl>-
269 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~l~..lll .;.J·~ll I'~
273 ............................... ~J:.I~..lll ~~ .J..l.:-; ~
273 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~0y~ ii 0.)~
274 ...................................... -.j:..lll ~)11 ~I
275 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~I.J ~~I 4:*1
275 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ifl...:::::-1 ~ ~1 Qll ~1_,.4.11
276 ....................................... 4:~1 ~~j~'1
278 .......................................... _;.4.11 ...JI_r!.)JI
28o ...................... ~_,.::... ~l,;~..; 4:~1 ~l:-11 cr.
281 ~_,klr.)JI ~ Lo ~..; t~l Qll ~1_,.4.11 ~ ~.4.11 o..,.k:.-11 ~
283 ............. ~_,.::... )~.J ,;;)....::....... ~~~.J ·~ ~~
284 ............................ J:-1~~ ~ I'~ ~'b- ~..)l.i.
285 ....................... 4:~1 ~~ ~ ~ Lo ~ Woa;i
293 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~_r.!jl ~ Lo ~
301 .................................................. Wl>-
305 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . o).~~:~li.J , C:~I.J 41_J.o..lll
307 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . '-="'.rJI.J 41_J.o..lll
310 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~I _d. 41_J.o..lll >~

10
313 ........................ ~..Jl::.ll ..>~ ~ ~_r-JI_, ~_;.o..UI
3 16 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . '-?~ L,.ci 'I ~b1 1_, ~_;.o..UI
319 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~j.; ..>_,la:..o J c;..>~_, ~_;.o..UI
326 .................................................. W.>.
329 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~..!m & ~ ~~~..1.11 _r...J...,a;
334 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~l:..o.W ~LA : .Y.UI ~I
343 ................. ~r5 :~_;:..o11 ~II ~1~..1.11 .;.J~WI
346 ........................ ~~WI y. LA :~1~..1.11 .;.J~WI
346 ................................................. _r..ilil
351 ................................................. ~l:::JI
354 .............................................. .:;.J~.:::.::.....1
357 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wl>JI
357 ............................... ~.r....l..a.ill ~l,; ~1~..1.11 ~
358 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~1~..1.11 _r...J...,a;
361 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . c;_?..AS ~1~..1.11
20 ................................... ~1~..1.11 Jy>- ~ ~1)
364 .............. ~~ .:;.J~_, ~_,..1.11 .;.J~- ~1~..1.11
367 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..).L.J.l ~
371 .................................... ~1~..1.11 .;.J~WI
373 ................................................... ~~
376 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ~ 4.LJ ~ '-?.i.ll LA
380 ...................................... ~~~A;~ ~.i.ll LA.. . ... ..
389 ................................................ ~1__,-JI

11
.l..!,l)l :r>)1~ ~
~ 011 'iJIX ~l$JI _;5i (Y ~I~..UI 0~ 0i ~~ ~
y. ~~ .~ ~ J_rU r-1 ~ ~~Jfl J_rjl Uk.:..o .j 0U JS
:i~·~"U ~~ ~~ ~~.r.J ~~I .;JI ~l:-JI ~I ~ Jlb:-1
~) .~I~..UI r-""'~ ~ .;JI .!lli ~ ~ ~Y}J ~.)J ~~J
~Uk:....JI · c;~ ~ t.:1 ~fl L...::>.II 4......J J.; ~S 4...J ~i-.! . J "t" '-I J ~ . if ~·f
.2011 il>- ~..A.>IJ il>- J
Y' ~~~IJ 4.5')~1 ~~ ~ iJaj (f' ;~~I~~
dl c;f~").11 :.r ~ ~..L.P J~l :.r ~1_,.:...... ~ ~~~ ~I~..UI ~ Lo
~~l>-~1 ·~~~ ~Ji J_rjl ~~I :.r _r.s J ~~l:>-i ~)I
J>.-11 ~ ~i ~yi)IJ ~..UI ~ ~._;L.aJ)JI ~I~~~ 4-::J ~
~)I _r--ll ~f Ji ~~~J ~..;j :.r- ~ -.:..;..J ~f ~J _;.1~..UI
. - •'I !II -'I i c ~IL t. ~: · . . ~i 0i ..uu ~
~ f""' .r? J r . ~ ,.f'~ -.! .
~ ~i ~~J.)l0J.) ~J -:r.~ or-~ Y.~ 6.....15 ~~~..UI J~J
GL:>-iJ ~c;~~ ~~ ~ c;..u.....o ~J ~ ~~~~ JS0 4~ ~
((_;.1~..UI j>Jill :.r- ~wl ~~I 0--" ~I t_W ..UJ .~b
~~ t.._L.,:, dl ,_pj:. .Aj -?J.ll ~Uk:....JI J ~~I JJ..UI ~1.1"'f [.;}..,.5
fJ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0~ 1-4) .oJL:-::>-1 ~41~ ._; c.r'..Lo ~~~ ~J
J~l ~ '-:?'L.i .kr. yo ~~1 ~ ~ 4:JW JL..cil ~
·~ 4ilA>l0}9 ~~~..u1 .;u ~~J ~tz 0J.) :.rJ ·i~ J~.A:jfiJ

12
L ..:....;$ i y,:JI ~_rJI v-1~1 ..;~ J.J>'-A -/' ~I~..Lll iJ'l.J
t.;t.; , ~..u.o ~'J ~I.:.>JI lh o~_,..- ~I ~ ~~'11 _;J.J t.; Lo~
~~I ~~I iJl!JI lh _j I? i~ 0i ~ ~_rJI tsJWI 0i ~i
i")U~.J o~..loo.::.o ~l_r:- ,:r t!WI JJ~ ~i ~~~ ~i.J ·~l ~~
L?i d._.;'1 ~l5 <.:.~~ ~1C.~ '1.J <.:.~~ vP.r:. 0~.:>-i _;.J .:i ; h>....
...l>- - ~ ...l>- - '1 I .I -LA; 1~. ~ ~L a.L.. 1<". '4...].,1 - ..llly .r.::. .y .J ~ i...S""' • I.)"'"". - ~
.~_;;'11 <.:.~'1 .4;.? J ~ l.!.::; ~S iJl.J ' ~
~WI ul~ _j ~_rJI ~yll ~J iJp .}l ~_rj ~I~..Lll
,:r _r..s:.lI ~ , ...r..rJI _;.lA:JI.J L5i)I 4..:.-- L.... ~ ~ ...::....j ~.J , ...r..rJI
- - -
.:i..WI .k.......J.J ~I ~ J~l
~ ~I~..L.!I 0i '11 ~1~1 <.:.~L>.lk ,.,. .. I _;si ,:r ~i t:.J
.,.Lk..!..:J .1>-i ~ ...J.J .~~LA....J ~L...... ,.JJ> U""l:JI J~~ ~~
~ iJ.r.-"')L..)'I -.r-4 w_r _,.l>> , ~u ?..Y ~ ~L- ~ ~')L..)'I
'o~f.. l?.lll ~~I J~ ~ ~1 .~ J I.J~~; W ~l_;....:..lll
~~l ~ ,~ .JjW ~ !((~y-!JI ~ .JJ~ 0i '11 ~ ~
t; · ~L ~<-11 · ')L..')U ~~ L:.>-1 0i ~ · .w~ ~~ ,-- 0-::::-" • • J - • * - .
·J~'11 ~? .) 'LA~ :_r 4-'--.): LS..i.ll .r·'-11 'l:Jb- .
~ 0~ _; ,~~..Lll ~ L~ _;si ~ Crl.UI ,iJy,:JI~I.J
,~'JL iJ .. <.:.~L.>.;;1 I< .. ,:i....,.')L..'-11 <.:.~l11 - ..UI .1.:. WL....o•. . .JJ.F. . t..r ~ • • • ~ fA r .
iJ.J-::'-"")L...)' I JJ...-..a.J..J , ":?"")L...)' I d y>-1I l?i)I c..J ~ ~'JI r-" ~.J
~..r> ~ ~~ ~..J .,.L...:JI.J <.:.~L_:.U'll J~ ~ ~w_r! <.:.~1).)
~I ~.Ji ~l::>JI ~Y.. l:..A> ~.}~~~ ~ ~'JI ~_;~~ ..W ,~
.4;..o Jl-...J ~LiJI ~.rJI.J ~..lll ~lj>-'JI ~ J~i ~
''-!-); ~ OJ""'LA.....ll ~I_;....:..UL; ..t..il_y :.r ~~ lA ~l::>JI lh.J
c_~I.J oJ~I c:' L.,.L;~J_,;..-.1 , ...t':.....:JI J_,.k:JI ~IJ ~i o~l.a.o ~.J
y. Lo.J l?J.J~ y. Lo c:' 'Y-¥1 ~Wi.J .)~I.J Y.L!JI.J ~I.J

13
, ~.JLS'J ~I.J U::: ~.rJI 0J~I ~I ~I~..UI ~.J.r-JI J.»J ·.s"'L;.J
l:?'ts'J .~_,__- ~~ o~ __.>-TJ ,~.ij- ~JLl ~f ~~ ~i c_L U:::
, ~t JAi 4.---.Jlo w- ~ i.r.11 V"'~w ~~.; c.l;:j ~~~..u~.; .;~ ~
~lolA tW L ..J~T ~ L Jl_rJI.; U~J .ij 4--JI -.:....;LS' ~~~
,~ v-::-l ~~~..UI j.Pi :~I .} ~l:?r.r" .)If t_!_r>-1 o.Jl:--JI 0i
Ja..../yl J_,...!JI Uk.J ~l:..o O..,.,J ~ jA :~rl 'l:?~ .} jirl ~
~iJ 4Jl>~l ~fi- .ij -.:....;LS'J 011 ~ I~W ..!.lUS -.:....;LS' l~lJ ~~..lill
U:.._r-JI 0q 4.A..A ~__..;JI ~ ~ , ~~ ~ (.5..l.A ~ I ··iib- 4 ..,i
~J L..J_,.......} 4s-.JjJ ,~WI 0yill :..ro JJrl ....i..a.:JI -} 4..:-!~_,J~I
~I U_r"~ 0i ~J ~..)~ ~l.A.>l ~.) ~ ~iJ ,0b_,....JIJ JI_,..JIJ
.~~~~ ~l::-JI
~~.J~ ~ ,~I~...Lll J.ii· "~~I.:._., ~I ~IJ ~
Ji 4>-~ i~ Ji ..J~ 0i ~ JJ '~l_r..-J ~~l5:.,;l..J~IJ
0i ..J,rU l:J.S .4-! ~y-o-ll u I _Ia uJI 4.;-" ~I !Jb 0r 4il..i>l
~i ~J , ~~ -}LA!.ll !JI.J~)fl :..ro I~ ~ -}W c.l::;l ~1~..1..11
l*"_l.; ul;:-.J~ ..JJ;:;.:.1 ~ V"'L:JI ~W ~Y' ~r ,UU!JI :..ro I~
•
:.r..~ 4-::-! .f1~..UI il.k:JI ~l_r.:.....l i~ ~ ~I 1-4-JJ -~J
~l l5~i l:?l.ll l:?.Jl...a.>JI ~I :y ~ ~L...;~ Jl_r..:>-1 ~ ~ d ~l
UL -} 44,_rJI ~~I ~ ~~ ~ -} 4~__.;JI -} '-!"'"l:--JI .J_,k:JI
~~~~ i-'-~- ; ~J 4~ .,.~~~ 4-::->-1_,..; ~ ..J_rU r-l ~w
y ~ ~__,.;JI ~L..a..ll ~I 01 0)~ ~i ~I oWl -~~~
ul. o:~ J ~)~l ~_,Li ~.J~ ._;.>- '-1-.r-JI 0..1..11 ~I ifi.J)I L"-~1
•4(.,5~1 ~l5:.,;)fl ~.,.I_,..J L..t.IJ~ .} ~I ~ C~ W" -~
_)lr,::-1 c.l::..il ~i .J~I ~ 4'-:f"~)fl 0..Lll illa:JI c:' 4-o~~ -/'J
~ ~I~..UI :f 0y.!I..WI ~.rJI 0~1 .JJ.k J.lii..JI .}J ·-=f.~
~ .ui.JWI :y JS ..,i <.:.~~J ~ ~ ~~ ~p ~I ~l :.r..~
c:' ~~L.a.; l5.Y~ 0~ JW~J 4(.5~ ~JLl JJ~-} ~J 4~1

f(•·f{~lt.(~·~~~~~l~rt.·(~1,··~·~.r-~b·(.(~~~~
~.[.·f:·'l1-~l:~:~.:.tr·c:t·1·1.e-t~~t~t~Lc·-"c·~·.-~.~.~.t·[.[s"£r"S---l,.~--~.~..c--~!;-'[~c_~.t~.f-t:f'tC.t_'--c;;
(•·~·~~~···~~.~~~c~~1:·~·(.J·l··C~.t.t~·.~g;;~·£
·t~'f,.t11.r·~-~~i,.fct[~L(•<t:_~LE""J'-~(·.T.~=.t~.:t.1..-••G-.~·(·G-.·~-"'("'(:·("'l,·c.
tGl--·G-.---"'·G-.t.r:£e:"'··~-~·~·~.r····j..•'"'-'-t·~...f-t',-~C::L.~-v·r(•IP•t:.~,c_.
$~:•L-•~
r-'•~~-·~.~·r'-1(,•-~~-
-c.'tt-~l:1:'-.'t:>«..~{t1:.'-1[&.(;,·oL'-~f:~
1;~t'1.r::---.[!G't,G-.1,-0:F·~.~tt.r.t:.:·(~£.
r'f't_.,..·~·Cr·("'1;"rE·~...v.'"'-~"'·~l_;_•r•'(I-l~..LVr:-(,•t:.V
c·.C."~.l.-t·.·G-.
_~·r:.~:t·r.$'~·-vr-r..r:.t·~F--~~.-·~·~·!;,.-JE
·r~-'1,t_r;:L.t[l-~~~~'t..1~·l---."[."'
~~r•t~,r::-,~-c_~~.{~~{•tt~'~.E1•r.f1-,~If~·~.
..~.r-'".·t.:·.c'.(t.~f.[18·~<~-tr~-~~
.~~ttr-1.::-~[lf!:"•((•'-~rt•t;,('!;,·~·,(f"~•(
E~-.r:-~-G1_.r-rt_~o.:~-1~~~...-~.J-r·1..
·~to:l·fr~·lr"-f·.-:'l'<,!..jl,.i"r.}:·[{t.;c.·.".=-
t
T-~~·t.-~t·~£•t'•G-.l-:·.-L.-C·f:h.'.l•1..-"-•t'l~~.o••'9---.1~'---.1.-
_-~:·re.~,~"':f.{·.~~1.c-~!i'<r,,f·tE.,;.1·1·~
{~.r.~i{l1:.J..--~JC1_·~'--~C{~v·l..·t1s·it-_'tf."'_t_r:..tf"~~_{r._'t_t·"'__"'-~_I~

15
..jJ .~~~ <.:.Jl.Aj')l.;... (.)'" --'L.,., JIA>-)'IJ ~.rJI <.:J~I ~ t.j)l.
~_;.; Jyl>- _j ~I '~J ~1~1 ~ ,o.)WI ~ ~ y::>-~1
~I i .1..; ~..J I~I ~J , 4..;:-lJJ-o-ll ..j ~) ..!.;J , ~lA..lb.; '-""'l.:.lJ
...J'):.>.1 ~~I~~ il.l:i.; ,.)l}i ~ <.:.JL....y ~ i~ ~
.~ ,~ ~Uu ~l .~I.LJ ~~

17
...>:~
..>J.JA u..HJJJ JtJ~ uUlJJ..

19
~~L:..ll J__,JJI J ~~~J..ll .JJ~ t_!.J~jl ~~~J..ll J__,JJI 0~~ ~
~_;-.)11 J__,JJI _ 0..WI ~l ~~.Y .j 0.r.--~1 0__,~1 ..l.A::s.l ~~~__,
. ul • J.JI · • · ~- . U.S ~ul . J.JI · · • I,._ I • ~~ ..U.,
-.r. ~ ~..r~ . J . ~ r...ru~~.).
~ :i Q ;;· Q II •.::•..••.~~I
o~ ~~ ~ ,'-:-"WI ci)I -.) .J..l..a: <.S..UI ~l.:5:.11 lh -.). . .
tl:......i (JS- -i..a.; ,tl:......1 I oh (JS- ~~i ~l J...o_,.:ll ~l::--JI .,.~ 4.r"
,0_,.ilrJI ~...J . <<~I~J..ll fl_;..;n-! ...;__,~1 i ~I J__,L:.::; <.S.,>i
4.r" ~~~ '0.r.--l::-J1 0__,~1 ~~ w 0~ 0~ ~~ r+"~~
:i;;_ o.JI ~~~ .1__,_,..;..11 ~i ,(Montesquieu) ~Y ~--' 0_,kJji
.,.~ .:;.JL.....y ..!ll..l.S__, ,(-.~~~ e·~~~.., ,4Q ;;·Qll .:;.J~~ ,d,.;lA!JI)
,~11 t_L1.A..ll cJlplJ ,.:;.J~~'1__, ,~LJJI) ~~__, ~~~..u1
:.r- .,.1) ._; 0yi.Jj--ll .:l.J~ ,..!.LJ~ ~l UWG .(o).~•.::.l__, ,.:;.Jls.lrQ_l__,
.;JI ~__, '~ .)l ~~.::.>..; .;JI .:;.J......l::-JI ~ Lo__, ,~l:JI .:;.J......l::-JI
~~~ .:;.J~IA..ill ~ I~Lo ,~~ _;si ~--' -~ ~~ ~
.,.'Yy. ~ ,<->?i .:;.JI.;t.~__, ·r-l.)-"-" r-l~ J a.yA..oJJI ~ rJJ ~ iL:AJI
.«~f-J...,a.::..ll ~.i ~~~J..ll ~)) : Jl_;..... .:f ~~i .)l j.P_,:..ll 0_,.ilrJI
.:r.'I .:f...J.Jl ·'..J" ..!1;1) !..:?'_? .J~J_.r. (Zoltan Barani): .ji.J4 0l:.l__,j
~..; r.b ~__,J 0j_,...... i~ ~jJ ''..Y'L.S:.; 4.......~ ..; ~~ ilk:J
-~.)_,;~~ ~~ J )y.
~~ J ~~ i..la.; ~Lo .J_,_;J_.r. (Robert Moser): .JjY' .:;.Jf.J.J
·,y'L..S:;

21
~I i Lla:J 0-!':J I 0-'..JJi ....r ..!1;1.) ~...?'_? J,_..;_,.r. :_;I)~ 0 W_,j
~ ..r.b .J:_,J 01j_,...., i~ ~j_, •_;b)l ~IS ~j_, '...r~ w~ ~
~I~..Lll J~ll <Glil_;.... .!.1-l>i ,:y .~J_,..;~~ ~~ ._; _)_y. ~
(Democratic Breakdown and the ((~_,.)1 4....:~1 o_,...4.JI ~1__,...;_,
t;::'Y J:A::.-oll_, ,(2007 ·0~_r.) Decline of the Russian Military)
, (2003 , c~.r."IS) (The Future of NATO Expansion) ( ((_,;l:..ll ~
.(2001 'C~r,IS) (The East European Gypsies) ((4JJJi J__,..!. pn_,
._; ~L.:-JI i_,.L...L1 o~Lo oJ,_..;J.r. (Sheri Berman) :0Laft. ~~
(.5_,....a-iJI ~':Jill ~W_;.... .!.1-l>i ,:y .~_,.J_,s w~ ._; ~JGJ~ ~
(The ((sr.-'J-'':JI -:r-r-.-JI 0.rAJI ~-' ~~':JI ~I~..Lll :4.....~
Primacy of Politics: Social Democracy and the making of Europe's
..:.,.':J~I ,:y -4J...JI ~ w ,(2006 •cr.LS) Twentieth Century)
·Jl-::JI (:>..JL;_, , ~~I ~1_, , ~JJJ':JI ~~I J.J>
4.....l:-JI ._; ..LL,:..;_,..; '-?"".? ~ :(Nancy Bermeo)r.on ~L;
i~ LIJ..U ~J_,..4-.S'i jSr .r-.11 ~ ,~J_,..4-Si ~~ ~ 4_jJl.LJI
(Ugo ~..Jyi ~_,i t:" '+.:S .!.1-l>i ~ ,;..::-1.1~....JI_, iii_,L....-1
(Federalism and ((:i .... u)fl ..:.,.u~':JI_, ~IJ..L.Uill ~ Amoretti)
~ 0...H~~ ...rL.;in_, '(2005 '~,.rA 0~) Territorial Cleavages)
(Ordinary People ((:i.:ki~..UI J~l .) tii_,...JI JJ~ :~~~ _r.? ~ji
in Extraordinary Times: the Role of the Citizenry in the
.(2003 ·0~_r.) Breakdown of Democracy)

22
_.; ..!.JJ.J~...J 0y>:- '-:?'yS J_,_J.J_r. :(John M. Carey) '-?.;I.S ·i 0.r':"
_;W_r.ll ~_,....a-::Jill 0 ..!.JJ>.i 0-" ·).JW).) 4S _.; ~~II i_,..l.JI
.(2009 , ~..r.-".5') (Legislative Voting and Accountability) <<~L~...Q...l.J
,~ •-11 LUI ,._ ,4.....>~11 41a.irl ".........1.11 - 1,. ~ ·<.. -r"""""' .. '-.S""'.J ... .J r.' ~ '-.S""' • r _r..
.Uwi 0-" -:J.......~I.J ~WI ~~i _}yJ.J .~L>...o..li.J ~L;:--JI 4..A...!JI.J
http:jjwww.dartmouth.edu;-jcarey ·.j.J_?J'JI ~yJI ~ iiJ_,.!.:..JI
_J~'u .)}_r.?:-.J ~~ '-?_;S J_,...;.J_r. :(Daniel Chirot) -:JJ~ J.tb
~ 1 I~Wn ~ ~.J .~ __j ~I.J 4......o4- __j ~.J..I.ll -:J.......IJ..ill
(Why Not Kill Them All? <<~.J ~~I '-:?'L;:--JI J:AJI Jk:..o ~~
,(j.J - · 1r.) The Logic and Prevention of Mass Political Murder)
;;L;..k.lln.J ,(Clark McCaulry) J~~ !)J-ys l: !)1__..:.;f~ wi '-?.ill (2006
(Modern Tyrants: The Power<<..;~._) oJL!..::..;I.J _r.JI ;;_,..; : 0_,.:~1
~ ~ W .(1996 ,(.J~_r.) and Prevalence of Evil in Our Age)
. -~..J'u.J ~_rJI ~.JJ.Ji L~.J •_f'JI ~_rz-II.J 'if~II ~I :f
-.} c..Y"fi.J J~b '-?'_;$ J_,...;.Jf. :(Steven E. Finkel)~ ·1 ~
~Jl.!..JI .::J1~ __j c:-"I.J ~ _r.:. ·tJ~ 4......o~ __j ~L:-JI i..,WI
~ L LS_r.-i.J ·.,r.L>...::..;11 !)_,LJI.J , ~~~JJI .....01_,-.JI.J , ~L:-JI
o~l -:J4f_,ll ~..WI ~_r-11 e::l_r. _,.;lJ -:J~I 0-" -4..WI 1997
.-:Jl:kl~..l.ll ~ J u:_;>-T ~~.J
..,t ~L::--JI i_,..L.JI J_,...J.J_.r. : (M. Steven Fish) H ~ ·i
:.r- ~_r--jl ~I~J.Jill ~l::S ~y .~yS_r.J;..; '~J~lS 4...u4-
(Democracy Derailed in <<4..:>-~I Ll;:--ll J~~ : ~.JJ _.; ~J~
,(2005 ''(2 L__$') Russia: The Failure of Open Politics)
~.J_)I cJ_,..!.-11 ~ i...1;_;.ji.J WJL....-JI : "'~' :r" yi~J.Jill.J
(Democracy from Scratch: Opposition and Regime in the((o~~l
~G _.; !)JW w ,(1995 ,(.J~_r.) ,New Russian Revolution)
(The Handbook of <<~l&. e:--" :~}I ~_r.:ll v-1~1 J:J.)n ~l::$'

23
Loll ~(2009 ~~.r.-"LS) National Legislatures: A Global Survey)
(Postcommunism and the Theory of ((~I~J.ll ~~J ~~I ~
.(2001 ~0~_r.) Democracy)
i y. '-:?'yS 1..r--JJ..r. :(Edward D. Mansfield) '1_,; il.o ..) _,.;IJ_,l
~ y J..Lll ~ ~ 0Jl.r. ..A .}~_? jSr .r.,J..,oJ ~ l:-JI i _,L.-Ll :_r.JJJ
-,r"l:-JI _,~'}IJ _)J..Lll .y'1 ~ ~~i ~ jS_r.. -~~ ~~
(Power, Trade and ((~~IJ ~ o1 4--;:JIJ ~oyA.Jill ~l.:S ....4.J_;-. ·.)J..Lll
.j (Jack Snyder) ..>-4..:...... !.~ C:: !.1 L.; W' ~ (1994 ~ 0~_r.) ~War)
~J.r-JI ~l:JI .:..Y.,I~..Lll ~ I~W : Jl:A.ll 1 l:;>lll ~L::S ...A..:JG
~) (Electing to Fight: Why Emerging Democracies Go to War)))
.(2005 ~~~Lo
.'-""'LS0 w~ ~ ~~ illa.; ~11..Ll ~Lo ..>H.r. :Jj~ .:...r.JJ
~~L.:-JI ~I..;>'IJ ~~~'11 4.1:2..;'1 :w~l ~ ~l::Jll ~1.::5 u..ly
(Unexpected Outcome: Electoral Systems, Political ((~JJ d ~IJ
9~>- J.-...J ~(2001 ~tJ~) Parties and Representation fn Russia)
01~ ~L:S .y ~~'11 ~(Ethan Scheiner) ~W 0~1 (::: !.l_r...Z'l~
(Mixed ((~I)IJ ~.1>...11 .:..L::J:.I~..Lll ~~I ~~'11 ~'Ill
Electoral Systems in New and established Democracies).
~_,J ·..> y.- -,r"yS ~ :(Thomas L. Pangle) ~~ .J '-'""Loy
~ ~ ~ d W' ·d~ w~ .; ~I~..Lll .:..L..11..Lll ~
UJ.,_ll 4 o t; · 4
. ; yi~..Lll .:..L....I1..LlJ ~WI (.5~1 .!J~i
~I (.$~ :~I~..Lll ~ll ~L::S .....ilyJ ~~~~.ill ~_,JI
- -(The Ennobling of Democracy: The Challenge of ((~...l>- ~WI
~ C:" !.I~ I Lo-S ~ (1993 ~ ~.J-A _r;y.-) Postmodern Age)
JJ>" : r-"'I ~ 4..ll..uJll ~I.::S U:J~ (Peter Ahrensdorf) ....;..>J..l...:.:yAi
(Justice Among Nations: On the ((i')LJIJ 461 II ~')l>.'1 ...,..........'1
Moral Basis of Power and Peace).

24
i _,.LJJ ..u-L...... J_,....JJ_r. : (Anbal Perez-Lin)~~-~~ J~l
,_,; :i_._,'YJI ~..r.-"'1 ..:..>L..IJ..lll Pr ,_,; ~L..'1 ~~ ~J ~L:-JI
_) _;L....rJI .,.b'IJ ':?'L:-JI Jl_;::....'l/1 ~ ~~i jS_; ·t.J~ w~
':?'l::-JI Jl~'l/1 i.J.s.J ~u)l Wl-Jill -...ily .~..l:>JI .;...Y,I~..lll
(Presidential Impeachment and the New «4_·_1').JI LS~i ~~~I
.(2007 "~:.r.S) Political Instability in Latin America)
..!.I~".>U ~y-ll ~L..; :(Marc F. Plattner)~~ ...J !lJ~
L$~ ;sl_r..J~ .r...;_,.J .~l~..ill .j1}1 u;_,JI ~ ,_j ..:..>L..I.)..UIJ
(Journal of <<~l~..lll ~)) J ;sl_r..J~ .).f-4J .~l~..lll ..:..>L..I.)..lll
<<~:.J..l..:>- ~J:. 4..J-..A yi~J.Jin ~L:.S -..A.Jj-o ~i ~ Democracy).
~J:.ll ~~J (2008 "Jl_.il-_JJ ~~JJ) (Democracy Without Borders?)
"(1979 ";.;~1 ~~.)y(Rousseau's State of Nature) ( <<4..:)::U.JI .J-"J)
-;JI o..r"L-.11 ~l,aAJI if ~l:S 20 (f )S' !l)L!... )~ Ji .)~ ~i W"
.~lh..U~ Jh::;
w~...; 4..;4.Lll .)__,.....JJ_r. :(Adam B. Seligman) ~lv_l_ · -~ i;r
...; ~J.Lll ~JJ-!•.liJ .4..;4.Ll1J .uli!JI ~...; ..!.l~i ..l$-l-oJ •uJa.....y,
«.j..WI ~I ofon ..!1.1~..} ~ "~I (f -4...vJI u.ly ~i W" .w4--l
(The <<U!JI ~''J .(1995 ·~~_r.) (The Idea of Civil Society)
(Modern <<~..L>.JI ~u_)lnJ .(2000 ·~~r.) Problem of Trust)
r---1.,-Jill ~L::.S:J !l)~ ......i..lj-A ~i ~ .(2003 ·~~_r.) Wager)
(Ritual and Its Consequences: An <<uP'):.:..)'1 :.JJ.>. JJ>" ~~ :'+.ilrJ
.(2008 ":..)yi..Si) Essay on the Limits of Sincerity)
~l::-JI i _,l.JI .).,._;Jf. :(Mitchel A. Seligson) ~~ .1 ~
..!.1...~.>-i (f .~G .;...L..I.)..ll ~.)..Gu Pr ~jJ ~.)..Gu w~..}
~I~.Lll : ~_r.JI ~i (John Booth) <<..!..~y, ~.r':" ~)~ ~
(The Legitimacy Puzzle: Democracy and «:i .' _;')UI LS..r.-"1 ,_,; J..:.:l::.liJ
.)~llJ •<t...;.:~ )J a_ .. ·~r.---LS) Support in Latin America)

25
(Development and «~J..lll oiJL-JI i..vJ '-:?'l::--11 ~l..,a.:;.;')'l : ....a>...::.IIJ
Underdevelopment:The Political Economy of Global Inequality)
(John Passe- ~ I.Y'4 0~ ~..>~ c..>_r- .(~1..> ~ ·~1)1 ~I)
Smith).
..,; ~J..lll ..::..L; ')L.JJ A ~...JJ ..::...r.J..> '-:?'.? .)_,.....;J.r. :J-4:....... .!l~
4.......~ -.i ijLJIJ ~__,.,JI ..::..L....I..>..ll 0LA_rJL.... ~J ~l::--11 p.LJI ~
I~W :JL;;;JI ..>~Ill ~LA ~)J~l C: ~)...!....J~ ~ ~ .~_,J_,s
(Electing to Fight: Why Emerging ((~J.rJI ~l:JI ..::...:kl~..lll ~
~~I 0-A))J ,(2005 -~~Lo ~)Democracies Go to War)
(From Voting to Violence: ((':r"_,_AJI t_!~l W:.~~ :. 4 · • ll ~l
_r-::-1.L..hlJ •(2000 •0_,..;..>_,...;) Democratization of National Conflict)
(Myths of Empire: ((_)JJJI C~IJ ~I Ll:-JI : 4........>y1-l..r.-")'1
.(1991 •~..>§) Domestic Politics and International Ambition)

27
2007 1......i /0l-..:. •• 1 .I.·_. L..5::; wl:>- ~~ 0l:.....Lo l:..i~· -~Y~~ . • •
:~Ji _j ~_,..... ~J~I ~ L,?.lJI
. ..b.....}yl J_r.ll ~L...IJ~ jS_r *
-~r.--IJJJIJ "~·::UJJi J_r.)IJ ~J)I ~L...IJJ.ll jS_r *
. ~I_r.::llI 0_,:..4JI ~ *
·~~16......J..Lo*
.~')l1 ~_;::.4JI ~L...IJ..ill ~} jlj} ~ *
(.r~_r-."J 0-.;~·S ~ :y I~ ~J 0-."+ .,II 0~ ~i W'
(Regina J~~~ ~.J .)l ~~ i.1.i::..j l~iJ -4~J ~ L.
(Curt ;J~ ~Jy.SJ •(Susanne Martin) ~JLA 01j_,......J .Goodnow)
~.UI ~I il1,j r-i ~ ~~I ;J')!.11 oiJp..Lll ~')IJ, .Nichols)
._r1J U,_,.k;-JI oh ~ l..u-l ~ IJ..U.L...

29
~L..!JWI o)..L..o .)1 '-:-'~1 lh 01_,:-s. ~ .rJI UWI ~~~
~11 .,.~ ~I..H -rJI o~l ..:..~_,..-.a-ll~ LP_ra.-> ,~WI
~ .JI.rJI_, 0~wt ~l:..JI ~~I er.J~'l'l ~ ~I~J.JI
~_,..p.JI ~ 9'.r."i_, ~_,~ ~1_, ~I_,.; l!..; , .:r._r...JI 0yill ~ ~
.~ .1k.JI_, ~~~~ ..::..L...._;.. ~Lj)' ~ .;JI J_,J.JI c;~LJ 4.k.!.:..ll
(.r" 0)"'.....::: U""l:..JI t::"J-' ,~1)1 ~)I .j ~ i~ ~I_,:JI cll~ 0i _r:?
..::...:'l')l ~ ~ ii ,~ ~-' Y~J....a;:..lJ ~l; ~I~J.JI ~ :~~
YLA..r.~ J_,L>.; 0i ~I~...Lll 01-li.)l ~ LA.~_, o~l
~ ~ ~ ~L.i ~ JI_;...JI lh :/'~~)'I .j ~I~
~ ~)a.l~ ~I~J.JI ~J..,.,a.j ~ 'l' .Gi ~1)1 ~ . ((~J..,.,a.j>> 4.15
- ~ ~ ~ ,
'l' ,~1)1 .j.J .~'l''l'l? _,1 'u-!~1_,1 ,~I..WI cL-JI ~ JJ..,.,a.j .;JI
~ 0i l>JI . Ul • J.JI · •· . ~I ..::..lo.k.JI .1:.:...;(_J '-1 . ~ _JAoJ ~ '-1 .
~l_r.....'l' I ~)I ~ ' Ja.Aj ~ I~J.JI !!~J..,.,a.j» .)1...J-4-! .Gi 4-kl..!,j
._} ,~l~.ill.;k)l ....0)1 ~ ~~i ~I ~~WI ~I ~1_,.:...-U
. !!~} _,i ~I~...Lll .r.~ ~ 'l'» ~i C..~ ,2007 ~
~I ~~I ...J_;:.....; ·~~J..,.,a.j Jwi .j .:JJL!.; ~i o~ ~.rU
· c · .GI J -~II . ~ · ol · .:1.:..A 0'L til • J.JI · · • II •~ • r-- ~ . 0-" _,... . • ~ .r..ru r...F· ~
~ ,~I~...Lll 0}.9 cll.U_, .ol!.:JI ~ ...:.JLS' 01 J¥ 0i ~~~.ill

30
, l.lJ .0::-"_,.s:.:-JI w ly .)s- i~ ":?'l:-- i ~ :f' oJ l;s- -./' Wl ,~
~ 0i ~ G .Ll.: ~ '. • •1 J-!IJ-:! ~ l~l .Gi ~1__,..11 :y 0~
.~I~.LII ~J~j'l' 4Jl>- ~J+=':" L?i ~ 0i ~ JU , ~~~~
~ LA ~ ..} ~ ~ r-lLA ~1 J_,.il~ cll~ (.7" ~i ~U.l.l ~.J
i..2.; '-?~ J~)'l ~ ~ ')U , ~ c.u...UI_, ~~~...u1 ~hl ~J..,..:;.....,
u-:_r...JI 0__,AJI-.) J~'l' "'~l ~_r.j ~ ~J ·~ 0i ~~~~
Q.j~ J.>. J ~L5 .r.? ~~~~ _;L..._;.o Jlkl .,.~l 0i ~ ~~ ')~b
~I~.LII _:r..j-'U J.r'l..:.A !.J...u..J .)~'l'l (.rA ~I~.LII ~
.4- -,r.J l>JI ~...UI ~ 0i ~ lA ;_,..~..> ,.,.I_,.... ..1.> .)s- , U._,..l4:::..oJ
((_r....L.,a..jll 0i _)s. ~..iS 0_,~.1...!....J u _,.1>....1I oh ~lA;JI :.r _r..5 ..l5~
0i ~~ ~~ w .~w ~ _,t ~ d- :;...t yi~.UI
uiJL,Q..:.JI_, uuU!.ll ~'YU 'lf ~_;. _,i ~JJJi _,i 4.?r.-"i c;p ~~~...UI
.__,>- _,i ~ i.S?~I ~_,.....!JI .)s- W_,}-o wb ~ •Jl::.l~_, •i.S?~I
~ ~ij 4 II~~)) ~l l!..:.; 0i ~~~..ill ~ 'lf ~1 0_,y:.i J_,.A...J
~~ ~ •.)lA.!.1_, i.S~L.,a;.;'l'l_, ..?~ 'lfl ~~ :r ~_,1 ~t>.... o,?. . .
u4'lf_,JI_, ~~.r.-.) ~_,~ ~~...U ulo~ J* ~l i.S~i (.$.lJI. .
((;;;;... 11 .1_,_,...!..1ll .)y ~i _,>-11 ~~ ..LS"~ W ·~.r.:-"~1 c;~
~~L.,a;.;'l'l ~ :r ~ (.$~ L?i - ~~.ill ~~L.,a;.;'l'_, ~~'lfl
.dl~ ~w, lA_, •or.? ~J U:k :r ~ -~1_,
u;W~ .1.z5G ~ ~ ,J_,j~l oh .j :i ;;_;;>JI :.r .,.~ !.I..:...AI
0i _r.? .~~...U Jl~'l'l_, ~~~'lfl ~ ul;_,.::..-.o ~ Lo :i.LL!..ll
~l ~l ·~I~...U .r..~ ~ 'l' ~l JWI L?i)l ~ od :i.K!.... !.~
U;.r-J..o c;~Y. r-lWI .,.L>...;i ~ -i_ ~WI ~__,AJI (.$..lA ~ u ~I
~_,A..JI J')G:. (_~ ~~~...U uJ~ J.Aj ,clJ~ ~l .UW.lJ .~J~J
.~~L.,a.:;'l'l ~I :.r ~ u4~J uuW ul~ 01~ ._; o_r,:->~1
'lfl y.~~ 0i ~~~.ill ~ 'lf ~~ JWI L?i)I ~ ~ ~ , JW~_,
·~ ~~L.a;.;_, ~~J ~.Jl;J 4J~ J-ol_y ~Y':"Y.

t1.fS£:.f:~·~·~~1:§·~.·t"i.1.~~.'t.~I~•E:..-·•~.r""<.,·~tr"(·~~f..r..'
~.~q·~.~·.:-.2~..~·~.c.·.;:_i~F..-·~.tr•.ts~
~<ir-c·1...1...-·~re.1f~·~o•cc,·-1f.v.f.t'
.F~..-[r""·.{1·[··1··~.·..t__[~rr-~.~'t.r·~[1,1t·~-~·~
•••1_~!'c.·~·,La[z.~.~~'t~~•••t'-~.1...t.(•••G.
<£:;~GJf[-t'b~"•Cl~r;:.._L~r··~...(_(•ttC;
·~:·-l'.1...fe.:r;::·~L-C/)~-"-~-
•.~(•~·~.-,t!-~·1S::y.•"V·V~•t::
~.1l.f.ii-~·_-~~-q-~,·~-f1;-:'[r.~·h~·f.·s..f·&:·r.·~
~~.·~c·~·---~·~'t~.~·(·~~c..(·'tE·~.:'1..~1~·~~t:.c(.L.•..·~l.b~·
1
V:I:tt_":[b··G-...·C.J_L
t.•c--:.o•r1,.·!.:.~~~=.;[..f's=·-f.'e.[C;~"~·c.~1...
~.~~--~t·-r~..,.'[t.'t.&.c•~--·vt.c.·tL.f.
--t!b~·~~·c.·r~·~·1;·_s.1-~1:t~~f.·(~r··:-.~:
r.r....~.£~1.f't~·~....-:t-f.2-:(··[t.........~t.v.1c
P
r:Ef....~·~.~·~.
1~·.t·f·r1·[{"{~·1cZ~t"Q·~.~-LE't:
b.r:~fPJ.t~".1-1...~.c.-0.••••t.~.·~.l"C.·.ts-~
t.""'·.L~...::4.th~.(;t.,F:.·r~_tfe'b
:t::,~.F·1r.)!·~_::_·~1~·~··.~·r·~t:~~~.~..~f~~.,.,.(1..t:·t:t.
-rt.~.~nc_rL..'Lc••'t~1bF.r::'~
1·.~~;·~.2,·~s£.-1-..~<(·r-L..i.·~·c·~.2-.~·~~·~'
L1~1:.•r:··'L~·"'~£1~h~_..~[-·""c.·..c;;
-L~...:."'-·~·-t;,.·[.>...:.!,~.·(-£..,-.r:·t;Ll'.rr;.tL.q
l.~;;""r-·c.·E"1;(·.,..·rv.:~-~
·Cli._-(•·~LZ"g""'_c(·.t·.·.~}_~·Vt.·~.c-•
....·c[J.1:~~·-...;0•fL.·tG-.-.-:-••'l~...r:It.r-•.l:••V·,C.~•-."L.•
-·--~--~.~-l't.-1-1~'='.[·-f.

~i •JJ..UI iWI '-:?i_)J i~ t~ ~ ~i ~! •..L>y
..:~~I ~4_ji _r....u.. ~~~.UI ~I
:_r .k.,Ji 0JJ.:.r. .:r..UI ..!.WJi ~ ~ ~ i _r.Ji o~IJ
.~)l..!.ll.ll_r._y; ~J.Z ~ 0! ~! ·~I~.JJI JJJ
32
~I (.r" ._;6 ~I~.UI ~lf'lyS:-)' ~':>UI I.S_.r>-11 ~I L.i
(Ghia Nodia): 4~_,; ~ ~J~ "!""l:-JI
y. ..!ll.Ll ~)I ~t..;..,..1 1 :_r ~~'1_,.-:jl ..!..J..l:>..j I~W
L.~ t....L:-JI f'~ ~ ..!..~~ L. lhJ) olS~I
.( (() l.!.;:,; '11))J ((0__,.A .14ll ..db> J!..o ~ ~ 0,...~
I • :i ~...u..JI ~ lWI . 6.....11 - ill l.,a.;.jl <L'-t-'Y- r -F-~ J ~
~ 0l; .lJ_,JL 1~i ~i _ ~'1 Ji ~ _
~ .Y' 0~ 0i Ji .yl__..jyJ11 J.1; ~ 0l-.;)'1
1M ~ ~ .. <tP "
~_?J ·~ ~J , ~ 1~1 J~ , Y.,l.)yJI
~ ~ r-l~ ~ .((,_y'j _d.» _ri ~!- (.$y>-i oJ~ _
'1 -~~~ (.r" _rsi ~ o)...a.~ ~~J ~IA.UI
.~~.ill((~~))~~ .A 0i J..>.1 ~
~~ - .ill uw1 w ·11 0u •~1.u1 '.- -~L> . t:.·'l · ·- ~ - - ..r-' • - ~ . (/' .)"'"'-'-' ~J
U""l:JI ~ J.:.r. ~ .~WI f'~i ~ ..} U""l:JI ~! ~ l~i ~
,U,ol-Ji ~ oiJl...-JIJ '-:?~~'11 _r:jl ~ p)l .:_,S~11 ~ ~
0iJ •~l.A~ J~ ~ oJJ.A.l~ I~ 0i ~i 0J..i.:.r. • ~W •~~
~
:.r wJ.;.-. ~ ...~IAJ.ll r_~~ 0!» : 4~-.Y J_,.A.J_, .~_,A.> i~
~)JI A 0i Jl ~L> 'lJ ...~1 ~I 4:-lt ~ l.A )~ ~)JI
.;JI ~ ((WI» oh 0! : ((r-lWI ~» ~ ~~k; ((..r"_)» f'ljl ~.Ll~
. ((~ 4SJ~ J.:;J ..:..;..WI -1-)JI .}I~.JJI t_.J~I 4.u_,....... :JJ.;.;
•._;I.UI ~I '-:?i _ ~I..J..>.....LJ o_r.-.JI wl.u11 ~~ ~~ ~J
_ '-:?~L..ci'll J~~j'lJ •0jWI o~~J ·~L::-11 oiJLJIJ -~~.)JI ~.rJIJ

33
':1 o.jj r.f- ,L5.r."i.J ~~f. .j or J}-1 •~.l>..; .;JI ~L....._rjl 4.r ~
"' , ~ t;-
c~WI ~J..! ~ ci.J ~ .._;;::-"1 - ~'1 ...:..l_r-11 ~ ~.J~I ~
- u-*: :_;JI ~ :y ._r.Si ;;~~WI~ .Jl ~;::-"'IJ ~~_r.JI ~1.:-JI
.j 0':11 ~l~..lli.J~ 0i ~l_,.ll j{'J .(Tocqueville) ~YJ ~Y
.JL!.::;I .)l )~ •'-1-,}JI ~.J'I ;;_?]I ~ ~t.jJ d~yA; ~.r. ~J.JJt
lh (YJ .~1 JJ.)JI C: '-:-"~ ~ J.il~ ~~ .;JI ~WI oh
.1~ ~jj G~ ~I~JJI ((~J...,aj)) ~ ·J.lk:......ll
0lt •~ · - · 'I oh 1• *" · *'I .Ul.4JI · 1.:.: L. Lo " • lS• ~ ~ ~ '-:? ..; I.J"""' • .r y .r.;-.J..
4:jj ~ ~i y 'C.JWI .j ~~~..lll j:j-'U .)l ~1)1 )~I ~)
0l5 J..!J .~~~ ~~~~ .)l LA.JJ~ )yU •-.1;::-"'1 (:'...JL::.ll .j I~
.J-4-ll •jj'1 ~ .)J'1 ~WI ~.rJI L ·~I~J...ll ~ t_l9J...ll
.,.L:.;j ~ .!..U.iS ~IJ ,;;~1 ~~':J_,.ll 4)-:>...ll LL::-1-l ~1}1
.JI.rJIJ 0~wi J.? 4.r ~ ,;;).Jl:JI ~.rJIJ ~!.ll ~WI ~.rJI
~~ ~ 0--" ~~~) y!Si ~WI ~ J.u .r..~ -sr.- jj.J
~ o.ji ~')6:.'I ~I ..s.)J . ((~l:-JI ~I_,.llll J.1.k:...o :yJ , ~')6:.t
JS ~ .yl:JI J.>- :y d dl~ , 0Li)'l J_,.A.>J ~I~J...ll JuT t:"'y
.J~I 1··;?- '*! ~WI ~'1 WL,a.,. i~ t:.;i lS .~ 1_,.-:.: 0i 0~
(Y ~~ • L:J ~ ~ J.j ~i J.l> .j i~)'~ ..!.U~J -~l~..lll
~J)j.-11 4..ll>JI oh ~ j.r.'1 ~I .,.~ J..!J .~)L....o ~i 0,.,S:.:. 0i
* . 1 w •* ~~- . • . I. ..k.>. . 4...11 * ..lll ·-*'or-'"' *.) ~ u--- t./ (J"Y. ~) <:_.JY. ~ t./ * ~ j:_;...w
:Jlj ~l -~!.ll
: ...L>IJ <:_~1 .)l r-LJI .y...I.>JI W~ ...:..I...L>.)fl ~)_,;.;
c~ ~ -41? ~ ~ l.;)~ ~ ~.r--11 .,.~ 01
i')Lll .JL:.::;':} ~i ~t 0!J ·'.5?'1 01~1 .j 4.;.rJI
.~WI .,.~t ~ .j ~.rJI .J~I y , Ws. J

'Of"
~
·J·7'"):ij
J
·':?~-J..::~·-
.l-.._".,_~KJ-~'_,1-~}s·.')
·~••.:Jso:rVJ;;t"ds')-•J_jv~
'"l~L·3i·.i1~sJ-·-1J.
sJS.:.J*'"J:l·.~·-
.r~}~~i3•Js~•J0·-
-~S")~.7'~
ls:~s~j:,
d~"'jJ--i
''_,-",J..,~~
sSJ")-,s7'
·-1s~
"'·i'..''-''
11,.~7"·){1
~
Cr•
j'1~s~-~1~.3-;-~~
.')s~r"0:JsJ_;j~.~•--~•:-:;u~sJ-v~:__~•'l
·A.y~J~3.J-")
~·")7'-.:::)~l~js•",.~-·-~:~-~s~J0•<!!,_•'-JJ-JS'j]~s.J")b
~:·.-Jlll-••~·~.•s'-:s-:J·-
~J._,]]J:j_!·J.~•_?.·-1J131·~;~_)'~s•Js~.7'~.1;..)~~J:--j~:0
]-.3~l~s-~s:)~s")~~{~l1J.~i)s~s
-~~s"~-_-a-,..~-J-s);7'~'lsoJ~•'....0.J
~1-.;·~4_3-3-~sjss~jsss·~<"~~;.J
~
~.s~-•J~•",...-s').~s-
j.'l")s-~JS.::3-so~J.:J<>,~:J--....s
.·L..:_:,·.,".s•J),
.~~.;~~sl~~·-~~js4"_-=i~"
<!!,__j·-iJ~s""--·~rsJ..)""~s.J
_js~~-~-t·~J1~'j~~u-s~-]
~s·;~s~~j_'j7J~f·-Js")~s~~·~Js1s~-.,4"''::.,~·-s~.s'-J'ls.J•..:J_::r~..!).-J,-...tsos
:lss)""'js·.')~·J·.0J·-~-s~~.7'
]Js~sr-;-~.·j4~JJ~-t;
1j.~~~~~3·s~.P~}j.,~~s~s
-:->;.J3-=l,:>'~~..'1_~~"'l·..,~l,
~1sJsJ~sr~:7'·.J~~~~~j-;;:
~~~'"..~s-")__:)'_)'
-7'JSss~')
js's.")s~~_J·~jj.]·"l,.<>,~•r-;--I)_:)_·~VJ--
JS•").1-)~OJs•J~_j....'L-'L-

35
, ~.) L,.ci ':J I ..::.o ~_,A..J ~ _,i , ~WI ..::.oI~ l-ll J ')l>. :_r _,i , ~_?:-.J I o_,.ill
..::.o~~~ _,i -~.r-11 Jw11 JJ.>. :..ro _,i -~Lo~..UI .1.~~ _,i
0__,Ajl ..::.o~W .L. , ~-' ...cll~ J1 L.._, , ~WI ~L..~J.l~ _,i , ~Is)I
• l
'-:--'..J...w_, c_y:..WI _)WI r..lll ~J.Z ~-' •o.-4~ obi ~I •.:r._r...JI
.;JI_, , o-4~1 ~~· oli o-4!_, ·CJl>JI J ~~~.ill o..r"'WI ..::.o~~l
~I ..::.ol...u-L-..ll _,i <<~I~..Lll ..::.ol...u-L-..llll ~ l+.J1 J~ Lo QU.
·i~JU ~ t:'..Jl; ,«~l:-)1
0L,j)11 J_,A.> ~ j_,_r. C: 0-!_r...JI 0_,AJI ..::.o~ J ~lWI ~~
•,_f.r.:A1 V""_;..;_,s:JI J ojJ~ ~ J_,A>JI oh ~ ~I.,YI ~ .~_,..UI
oJb1 J1.) ~.r.:A11 ~JL>...ll Ll:-JI.) ~ftr ~~ ~ ~) ~
~) J_r.ill ~1-.::.o..L:.::.....I .;JI •oJ.)l:-oJI oh ci_r>- JJ_, .,;JLS ~
r-L-JI i~i .j ~ LA , 4J J~ 0L.;)Ii J_,A.> ..::.oG~1 · .;!-.;.._~ J_,..UI
.-sy>-11J_,.ill ~IJ.ll 0_,_;..!.11 .j «j>Xll 4,ji ~.)WI
J 0L,j)11 J_,A.> ~.) J.:5G J o-.4~1 ~i_r.JI ~I_; r-1 ·~I.,YI J
.j ..:;..J.:;.JI o_,.k>JI cit ~-' .~l~..lll ~ ~ly ~~ CJWI
.j 0l.;u..J ) ..;.i ..u.; (Ronald Reagan).0l.;u..J ..UG_,J ,_f.r.:A1 ~) ~
.)~ Jl •.j~y:-11 0Wy:-ll .j 1982 .r)y. /01f..? J ~..JI.::.ll "-!Lk>
~ --4~n 0~ o~l ..::.o~':J)I .j 0L;,....L....Ii 0~_;.:-JI 1+. i~ ~I
~I~J.ll ~~ :_r ~WI ~I .j ~~ ~ o~l ..::.o4'1_,.ll i4----1
~1 1983 ~ _r>-l_,i .j ":-'L1..>...ll ..!.U~ -s.)i_, . «011 ~1_,.; ~ .;JI
(National Endowment for «~~ill ~_,JI ......O_,Jill ~ .,.~1
JJ ..:.....i lS_, , V""__..;u_,.s:JI 4J~ ,~~ d- 4L ~_, ,Democracy)
.1984 L ~~ J_,i ~
~ ,«~~.ill ~_,JI .......U_,.lll ~ ~t:J J_,11 ..::.oi_,.:...JI .)
-, -
~Y. ~I~~ ..ill.~ J~ c:PY ~~~J.ll ..::.ol~l-ll op
..::.ol.&.~ ~..Lll ~..u; 0i ..uWI J~l ~ ~~ ~ ~

36
0Jj.-!JI .j J>-..l.:.ll :y lS.y ~ .s..,.>-t 01~ .j ~~~.ill ii_rPWI
~_,s:-JI ~ i .,Z 0t ~ ':1 0L!. ~t ..!.Ll..iS _21J .JJ..UI &:.! ~I..UI
:Y- J~ ~L:.:. ~ ~ i ~ 0t 4..r" ~ ':1 0LS -.H d.~hJ ¢ _,.;u
(..5'""'~ ~? .st J..i.> J..i-; 0t ~_,JI U.S_,JI ~ ~ L.S .~_,s::-11
- - -
.G_,.5'_)-~ ~.UI ~1_;..>11 4..r" 4JI__.kl U-;_,.1 iirAJ ~..Lll ij_; _; Wt
J.4.::;';11 .)s- ii~l-JI .j ~ I~J~ U""'JL..J '"CJL>...ll .) ~~~ ..::..1~1
~~ :y ~)1 ~ ~J .JJuy:-1J ~~1 :y J5 .) ~I~..UI .)1
~:.r::{~I 4..r" '-?_,A-ll ~..LII :_r ~ '"Jw 1J J.--11 ..::.>~.1J ..::..~y-:S
d~l~.ill ._;1)I .....U_,jill ~ (.sJ~IJ .>I~..Lll) ~)I
- - -
.L:.....IJ Jlj Lo lAl;I~J ~ ~I ~}t
~WI UU~I .)1 0l:>-11 ~ .) ~I~..UI j:~ s:-l...uJI J.:.;:......
u:lll ~1)11 :.r ~t '"Lo ~ J1 ~II W)A.~I 0t .r.? -~ly.-.;':11 J1 Jt
(..r") ..,t ~I 4..r" J~ ..W .0L..;':i J_,.A..>- 4......~ ~l_r..ll .i.zt ~
~nJ <<0~':11 Jyi>- ~)) ~ ~WI il-4j':JI lh ~~I ~WI
0~)'1 Jyi>- ~ ~J (~ &,;J ~I_; ~Y.J ~ l.;:._,...a.> •«~I~..UI
~l:..:ll ~ ~L:JI ..:;~l.r-JI J1 ~ s:-?...} trJI lh ~Y'-'.J .~l~..lliJ
lS.r."t J.J>" ~j>-..1I ..::..u'.>>- L.;,_ra.>- '" ii...L:>...::....I ..::..~':1yJI ..,t ..r.j>-..11
0yA.jl ..::.>~W' .i a·· 4 ..,t t;:..s'.r.:-"11 4......~1 }:..s. LA ~J ·~yJI
~I~..LII ~_r.U I_,J~ 0L.;._,.J iiJb! ~y 4..r" ~ 0t W -.:r-~1
._;JlS ii)~l ..} 0L.;)'I J.,A>- ~ ..::..j"J .;JI ~ ~.;k]~
C:: ..r::-;5 J..>. .)1~j>J I ..::.>LoL4.i':1 I ch ~I ..!1.1~ :y ~)I ~
~ .j ~I 4-::J_,.; ~ ·0~ ii)~! ~ .ili .ii~)-~1 ~.r-JI ~~
~fliJ -~Jl>JI ~~ ,;LS"J -.>J..>.! «~I~..UI <:::"yll :y '"1993
ii_,..b.>. ..)J .~~..ill ._;1_,.11 .....U_,.ll ~ ~~~..) ii~ ii~l.._j ii)~)fl
, .. .. ..
..y.t ~I~..UI ).~tJ 0L.;)fl J~ JL,a.;t ~ J~l jJ~ Jl ..::.>~J
~J ·~).>...ll iiJijJ.) ~~)'I 0Jj-.!JIJ 0~)'1 J_,.i> ~ ~
J_,A>-J ~~~.ill ~ .)! '".}Jl.S" ~)I ~ ..) ~t .slJI ~I
- -

[
~·t·.t-~l.·t.t·
(~.~!=~t.'1
lG.sOSt'-~
-1·.-~.~~(•·~
(·__~.trt:E~~r..(·r-.-·
Vi:<1~·~·OS
~v••l""--,
~1__.E-·-r·.~~
~·f~~,f·I.-~·C:
~(:ff:r1.·~...c-.r.·..t·..
~t..t.~t:.~!:.'"C:..
~·~-;:.(.):··~it-'c-.1s:-C:._v
~•'1,,t::~-.L!_
:::.t0'(•r(•(;,,~
C:..f.Lf::r-y(-
f~:~[.r·r~~t
-1.l...,C~-I_r-o
[-""~·-·_:_
.C:V~l_~·r.tf-·a-,·~
OS1:c:-1.•,•_~
[r't...o:.f·~~
-~.~.r!i'brt...
~··~·~~·~-jt~
·~.·f'l,·~f·L.~~...r·C~~.7-.C·c.·I~.vs-~~.f.'l~·V•E[t!t·LtL•,...L.,.__:'(>t...·V.....-·1"'•
V(__I_-t.!~-c.·-~·C.·r-.~
~r·-·~.8-r.~~1V!_rt."t.[-
.f"I:~£f·E:~r·~·1,_.l--.'i'~·~):
"·{'.(~·r·t;tc::f.~:-~.G.[.-.r.~·
If-T~;;~f-;~·.'E:~[f..f~flr~·c.'-t~t.!t.!c.··~~.t•L~c."C.·
-_·'[!2·8V·~•t-·~'!::~·~~C.·!l
~~_-~f.-.t·-.·c~-'h.-·-.·f.:,c.·~·-~.'t...~~..f"c.·...c...c(
t.-·(•[_['t....fvJ'c.c--·-(;:
=·r-~·c_(i7s;--·s-~·s-~rb~~
~:~[·~.·~.'t~~·f."t.·t0.[Y.~.~~.r~
~~f•(.~f-t;."t::.~··~.S:=t-·G.••.~-t-'t,·
~·...•v.~~:r·~'<i..rC.·L.c.·•
·~'-,Lt·-••'t,~~~(l'oL.(""~
~~~:~.tc_.e'1~··~--L't!:-£t.c-(·'t:r..
~·-~[c..l~.,[t:
-OSs(-(~-~~(,..~f,t'v•
""s...___.....111•-"
,f"'(;I-!:-.~-';t.·.~,,,~!_~.C'1
:!c.·.~~·~11·.~·~~.1:f.(:1·G·t·~~
~~.F~:d:-t~l..~~_:·~·~;:_.[.tt:fr
(.c.·[:_.-(.f.-C't,,.[c-•l',t•-·.---.'C.lr~c.•".·Lc__C:.-
•S-"'OSf'crCL.-e~~·(.·~l.s~-~f.~-'t~(/:)t..·-CL.o:t..E!·-c.·IT~·c.·
,'~">,.L·-".c;.,,,
Ebi<t:g'L~E~~~t)-·~·1:,[£1~·

38
~J •..,r.J.JJ'll ~~':; ~ :;J .4..._:-k~JJ ~~ ~1 ~~ ~_r.
~)'I~~~~ r..hA.! '-:f';J.JJ'l 0JL....:.lJ ~'11 ~J r. ~J.JJi
JJ..UI ~ ~ ~ y'll ~ -Y. r.~I~..U ~j-<U ~ 4..S'.JL!-.I
~ J>-~ lS .I!J_,.:-...,s:JIJ (Organization of American States) ~_r:-4'11
·<~_;)'I o..l>-~1 ~ .~Lw) ~_;)'I ~w:JI :r JS J~l u..~
t=- fill .. -
~ ,.~ :;J~ 0L.....,.;u 01- Q t;. 4 ~J r.(ASEAN) 0~1 4 Q t;. AJ
J ..U t..l>.JJ ~L.JI . I..:.J.j i · ~..l..W 0~ l;.jl5 · 1..1 • ~
J - - '-:!' u '-? :r - - - ..r::-:- ~
~':JLSJJ ~J.JJ'11 ~L>....;':JI i~ r...!Ll~ ~1 UWlJ -~ I Q g ,a_~
'-/'} (Z:".r. ~~ 4.:11~~ }511 4_ )) 0141J ~WI 4l:.!.l1 ~~~LJI
.lL ~ · •II 0ill Ll:JI 0ill . 4...k • .1.11 · · • Jl. • .r.--- .J- . r...l- ~ f..r' •
;;~~ ~Y,I~JJI ,j 0r."~ 0_,.lJ.;..-JIJ 0_,.:1_r-ll 01.5 ..u.l
~..u-L..n ~ J~l ~ r..:r-~1 0__,.ill ~1_-_......; ~ ·~?
~1~1 ~i ~ 4.;...;WI ~.JW ~~ ~lSJ .((~L:-JI ~I
~IJ.>.L-ll ~ t}.B r-lJ .~L ~~ 01J..41 ,j W,~ ,_L,.~p
~LA~~;;~~~"'~ )J ..?>" r.~I~JJ ~~J.>.~I J~ US'
,_;;~~ y~l ~':JLS'_,.ll ~ .;JI ~~ ~i~ LA 0~rJ .~_}JI
.)..u;J -~~ ~ ~~ ~.Uj i;z r.~~.1.11 ~_,.ll ~ ~
-<-I ua.; U., - JJ .-_ u JJ ~ w '11 ~LS' " ~~ 011r-- i J - ~ r...r- - J - - ~ Y
~J.,r.... ~ ~ ~~JJ ~j-<U 0i lS .4_,:....... .):;J~ .Jl::L ~ ?~
(Michael JJLJ !Lo ~Lo J~ ~ ~i ~ ·~J I~ d
·JJ..U ~ ~ ~_,; r.McFaul)
6_jJ11 ,j ~~~JJI ~y.u ~L ~i ..w .dl~ ~~)I~
~ ~l-J1 oh ~ JL.ij)'l 0i ~ ~~ ~ J~ ;;~ ~L or.>-'11
~Ji ~J .4_,; -fy-::-o'll u-"~~1 ~ 4J r-"..U ~J ·41 ~1?.
~b)l ~ ~ LA kg..)Ji .081 0.JJ...,a..A .J J~l .J~ ;;~_y ~1 J_,.ill

39
~11 (.).4 d ..l> .)l lh ._;6_, )-::-ki~...Lll ~l..u-L-JI .,.ljl ccj.-.AJI
~~~~~ ~ ~~J -rJI cc~L.:...:..ll ~~I...L:-::.......11)) Ji ~I~..Lll ~
I~J+ , <•;I_?)J ~J~ ..) cc~_,l.JI ~IJ_,!.ll)) ~~i ..) ,~I~..UI
~ (.).4 ~Y. ~JJJ ~l.!.; ')L_,_? ~ JJ~ ..::...;LS ,-.!JJ~ ~J .~t.hLJ
~I ~~I _r.? ~~I~ ..t_.;i ~~ d'.) ~t-4 ~I JJ...Lll
,!,IJ~ ~ ~ ~~ JJ..UI oh ~J ~~II J.~l 4::At .)s-J
~~ o-4~1 ~_r.AJI oh J.;-;J .~LS_,J ~JJ~J 'd-IS-yo .,sy,~_jJ. .
..) !.~1 ~..~.;11 oh ~Jj .,.t;J .~_;JI ~I ;,..JLA....J ~}I o~l::-1
,~~ _;si ~ ~I~...Lll ~l..u-L-JI .SJ.J..;;- Jy .kL...J11 ~
.lAtil:; .;JI ~~I ~l..,a.o :f ~
~J c..f~ d ~ J..G:JI ~W ~~ _rsIIJ ,_;L!.ll ~I LAi
~~I ~I ~~~ Jl_rJI ~ ~_rJ~ ~I_? ~ ~I~...Lll ~j-<0
J_;.;J~ ~I~...Lll ~j.<U ~'J~ iJ1 ,j.Wu .ri lh ,~L.; ~ .1~
~ -~J·'11 ~~.iSh ..J.J-"J ,~WI~ I~ oJ~L.; ~L5
, _r.Si .i.!.j 0-" .,.?. r..r- iJ.::.......;WlJ Jl.rJI ~ ~J~I ~~I iJl 'y>
~t-4 ~ -/'J ,cct_~_ra.JI .,.4;:,;1 .M.: LA ~I~...Lll .,_~)) Q~j. ~ A
~b ~~1__,...., ~I oh ~ iJI~I ~ ~~ ..ill .jJ~ ~ _,..,..:.;
r-"11 ~~.r. )-~)'1 o~~l ~J~ ~J..Lll ~I ~ ...L9J ,c;~L>
'~~IJ '~~~J <9·:·7 .. 1j_,.....J ,~LA~ -s.r:- L..5 ,c;~l
oh d'~ .)1 d..H..,.;,)'~J -4_dJ ,_;Y"'fiJ ,~_r.JI J~J ,iJ_r.JI.r.-""J
'J .~D y4! :y _;W 4-:-..o I~ iJ~ ,~11 ~J.rJI ..!..IJI_,s:J iJI..ll..:-ll
_,1 ~~ Jwi_, _;..L.JI 0~1_, ..:...l5.rJI Jwi ~A~ ~j.WI <.;.f-11 <•)
~UI ~~~ J_,J..ll5 ':-'jJ.J 4-.:.. 4;_,WI ~L>_, ,J_,J..ll ~ J ~I -=.,l5_rll
~_,l.4.ll .:..>I.;_,.!JI .h _; 0_,.5.;~1 iJ.>.:;.....I...lt_, .~T .k....._,_, ~J.;J1 J__....!._, .k....._, _;
,;.-? o__,.Aj _, ~..l>..,. 0_,J '-?) Cl...!.-' ii..G.;:...I C: ..:...I__,.Al1i.....ll_, ..:...~~')11_, ~I
.~I.?) J 11JlZy:-ll o.;yll _, 11~lZy:-ll o.;_r]lll_, , ~Jft J 11~.;)1 o.;yll 4-.:..J

40
C:J .~ _;U.JI ~I L..JL-..1 1.:is-1J ~r 4-:--o l:?i J~ ~
Jw)fl o~~)f ~J...Lll ~~~ (J" i~ ~ .,.?. ~~~...Lll .,.~ 0~ •.!ll~
~~~W .01-U:JI ch ~ J
~_,....::. 0~ ~ 0~ 0i ~ ..:;.J~l>.::.;~ 0i Y' ~ (J" l~ft- 01
~_r.ll J ~ ~11 ~WI 01 _d- .LP.-Mi J.1. .;JI ~11 ..;:.J~_raJI
~JJJI ..:;.J~ ~ ·JJ...Lll ~ .j ~~~JJ ~ ~ .;JI
~~~~OJ~~ i~j ~~ ~ ..:;.J.l.:;.i .r.JI ~ -s_,.A..IIJ
~ ~~ 01 ~L:....-ll ~ ~ o._ji ~ -~y-.a-JI ~ ~ ..:;.J~w
0i (J" ~) ~J .~~ ~ Jkl:..o J ~I~...Ll..l ~ ~Loi_;JI
j-::-~..Jyl::SJJ C: , ,rPWI 0-")I .j ,~~ Jl_; ~ o~l ..:;.J~~}I
-.?1)1 Ji _ J~ o~l ..:;.J4~_,.11 v-!>J J~ 01 .,._rJ t::"-!. ')1..; 'if-~J~}I
..:;.J4~_,.ll o~ ~.:>. '-f') ~ ~ ~}- ~Y. -f.r./':11 iWI
;;~ r--11 0i 0-" ~) .)s-J .~ _r:? ~ ~j .)1 o~l
0~ 4-i1 ~ 4-i~ -~~~ ~i 4-::9 .,.Wzs.fl JJ...Lll ~ ~~
~ .;JI jS'Lo11 J ~~ ~~~~ ..:;.JL....y L,..,.JJ ,!j_;.; 0i J1 ~i
.t_!y-.aJI ~ Lo ~_rJ o~~ ~Jy.-1 ~
...
0~ 4 c-45' ~L; ..JJ_); J1; .j ~~~~ ..:;.JL....y ~'-~ 01
~~ ,4..J...Lll .,.~ o~~lJ '(J"fJ iJWI ;;~L....::.....I ~ ~1 ,..:;.J~~
.j ~~...Lll ..:;.J~L-11 ..:;.JL:J..k jJ~ .;JI ~)rJIJ ..;:.JJ..u..1 :y ;.Ll$'
. " .~~ ..:;.J~Lo ~..u; _; ~~ o~l 01 LS .)~_?I ..JJ_);
..:;.J~ o.,r.>- o~~ 0~ -~ ~ j.-.; ..:;.JL....y ~ 0.li:..l ~l:-JI
~ J-" ~ L....y JS .,.~ o~~1 .)1 (.l::..>..; ~LAi .j ~ o~J~ .U.,.,
,!j?. ..:;.J~WI ch ~ C: ~....:) .j _)J...Ll ~ ~ 0i w ..,.._,;.
~~I JJJJ ~~ ~1 I~ •U.~J .LAj~1 ~ ~). o.;-::!S l~yi
..:;.J~WI 0-" ~...uJ ~~JJI o~ ~~~ 01 ~I 0-" oGlJ •r-..IWI
. I ~- . II . . ~ ~I
u-:-- -I~ .

~if<1:~:c;::.[~•(•~•.•~:
.~-·~.g·1..F-,.r·~r~~.'C'Lv,[f"l~E't.,."'s.·.•.~~.
!__·-Et.~s;:.l}:.t·..,
~1.••fI~·f"'·~•(•~~~...t_•"'t·'r~~r::.r~I~~_.,•1~~.-:•-:f~~.
fio•V•(}f(1..,•
.~~~~·1:_.~'c....f!:~·t:~
~.~~·-f.-~f.r·
(].£fl:l_,c-•.(•G-~-{.L._•t
I~_..(0
1f.1&c.·'•G-v·C,._,•....:....-c-•r
(..•tv't._•,c._'IP•
-·..~c._.c-
t_~~t[qo•~~1.CEt:~~...~~~t.E.r
J,·.~~·(~:f·r·~1·}·~<tc•fA-,l•~~·-
t·~1.-e[:;~.[..t~1(·
~....~l·,.·(~~~r.J.·~E't
y-::[.-:·c.·.ct.~.F.t~··~.~...f.::t:~[.~
·V'!:=-··t.''L-c._·El~(•
L..c-frf-~·l(.-o•-.-
·~(·~::=-·~=[;;-~·_:_.:::·t'lc._~..s·~
t~S-~:·~.ff}·-c_~>_.:·fr:.'1:_
-).c.l'b.~.·.C1;.Lr-L'b.(t
~:.-G_·t~.[~i:f·[·h1
[·(..r··~.·~·tc.·~rI.~:o.
-o••~-t~'t:,-
r..·~c.·'t~kv
't'C·~:!.E:t~~r
1·~1·v.c(1·.·v1·~
·c.;:;·s1~··~:f{£..
c·r£r:·1·~.~r.·--l.v·~•.~•..t·
~-~~._c;::·~
[
(•c-'C''C't_'b.
.c-.·~:0·L~··.t-~~·-l~•t.-.•c.
y_'L~E~c.··
~-":f_:t~·~.(•
(
"~Lf'>'-
C.••o•1-•~~,_S-
-•1...c-~
ft.~~:~1·1~['t.1...(•c.r.-
.t_:~(t'f:~rtr.~~...~r-·~~...,.
t..c-~;c.·t!-~...~~·f,~
v·c-~~,.''.".r.·..~:
[~·~l'~-1,·L}-
-r.~·~~£·b(;:·~l.
,['t.ft•1:L•1..,""',..(....(•-,....'s-r-••
~:L.·_fs-{,Lf~
·~[1~~t't"ttIf:·

42
r.~ ~')L.:.11 i..r"JJ..UI JJU~ .J i..r"Lop J_,11 J-.a.AJI ~~
: c ~. 1 ; • ~ '-. II ~I 1:. ·II ...::.) ·- ~ ~ t..kl • JJ~~ u:- :.r J~ r'""'""' ~J J • • ~
~lA;J_, -~1 ..:r.~~ ~_,.........~J...ill ..:r.~~ ~~~ ·~L:-
ts~~ ,:.r 4.s.~ ~y ~t ~I lh J~ ~J .~J..>...ll :i_.i WI
.:r,.~ .j 4>-~l ~ .;JI ~~_,JI_, ~pi~ .;JI ~1l.,.:JI ~pi
...::;J~~ ~ ~_,...ajl .jL..J .W~ ~>II 0j: J. ·~I~J..II
.~11 o~ y- ~~;J ~J..>..::..., ~ .;JI ~_,~')>II
:IC.qJ:, •llll · ~JJw.::..JI.t.uJJ -~~~ ~.!W"-::-"-"-::+ J .r-' ~ J • .J ~ ~
j::5;JI ~ ~J .~I~J..I j:~ ~ ~_, ~L:..l ~~~..ill((~
...::.;~ _,i u;_,~ ~l:>-i ~ .;JI ~~L,a::;~_, ~4~I j.oi_,..JI ~ ~
Js- J~l o~ }.; • .!ll~ :y --1~_, .:i...zki~J..II ~ c_4--:J ~~i
JJl:.::.:.J .~)'1_, ,;J.A!.ll_, •0_,L....:..ll_, ~o._:r.J..II_, '"e-"L.::.ll_, .~1 j:..o 4Wz.;
._;WI ~I .j 0~~ ~~J '"u--"L>J ~I .j 0~ i;r :y J5
:y :i...zki~J..I~ ci~_, ~..l>- .Ul..!.::S ~i ~..i..l _;.MJI ~I i~
~1·1 L.:JL. ".M..ll -~:-~11 .U~ . 0~ l.b ~ ~o.t.i..l.::.>... ... ·J. e-" . c.E c-·- -.1 . u- . • . JJ
Jl:-- .j _;.MJI ~ ~ OJJ~ Js- 0~~ ~~ ~ ~oJ").:.>.~1
.oJ_,k; ~ .;JI ~L::-JI ...::;L...j.JI
01...LLJ1 1 • • ol.A!.ll ·t; • · . · · -lt.••....; ,-.:Jl!JI 1 ~~~~ • ~i• (f.:'" -.1 .r.:' ..i-::' ~ c . u-- -.1
~ I. :1• L::....:... 4....11 • JJ ...::;l..-.• ·II 1,•. J;.LA..::..J II~
~ ~J c. . . . ~ _,..,...., r...f'""' l..f·
~ ~ y:-i ~ ~ I~ ~..J •..!ll~ i~ ~ 4S~l-J ~Jl>
oJ...:>. ~ ~~~JJI ~1_,.; -rJI ~~ ~ .)1 ...::.;_,~ J~b
Jj>. ,:.r ~ ~~ ~ (.$.1.4 ~i -.)G .~UJI_, ~)'I ...::;IJ')WI
-~_;.II J~ ily>-1_, e--L::.ll j:~
~1JJ :i .a~ J_,...aj 4....->- :_r <-;-Jl::..<.JI ,:.r ~WI ~~~ 0~
uyu) i..r"~LJI ~ :_r JS J_,b_, -~L:--JI ...::.;~_, uL....rJI
~L..11 ...::.;1;.:-.JI ,y ~ :_r.:jj-:;A ·~1 LS" 0_r.J ~LJI ~1_, ~o 1jy

43
~ ~ '-?.UI lS.WI .)1 .Jjy J~..J .__dl.......Lll_, ~l>.;:j:JI_, ~l:-JI ~
~l::ki~...Lll -j ~~1_, ~l>.;:j':JI ~L:::JI ~.J.4l ~l>.;:j':JI ~I iiJ.>.::......I
~-' ~L.......Lll 4-: ~~i .;JI ul:i--11 ~t; '-,?)S J_,~ 0-?" <} , o-4~1
,~l!JI ~I<} ~j_, .~)~1_, J.>-':>UI ~I~..Lll C~ _j ~
41 ~p ~ ~ :J .;JI ~~I L....y..ll :f- .jiJ~ 0.:J_,j ..!..~~
~~ 4-4 Lo ~lj. .rJI_, ,~..l..>JI u~I~..Lll 4-.16-; .rJI ~~I
~Lo ..) .))_,.)1 cr JS ~..J -~~ .11 -.::;1_,.4.1 - ~s..)_, 4...:ki~...U1
~ L...'I ..::;1,.&..):JI ~ ~I 0-t."' s..)I .J l.z::.>:J C""I.:JI ~I J-4L;.... .!J~_,
~ ~ls::..o1 ~-'- ~I~..Lll ~j.-'U .)! ~1)1 .)~1 ~ _j
~ ~ c;JJj _rsi ~j_, , ~ ~ C" i~ .j u.::-11~..Lll
.oJ~I ~.?.J '-?.)L,.ci:JI J~.)j':JI
,~ ~-' ,0_,.. •_1_ •. ~ ~ ,~WI ~I .j Loi
1~1 Lo ~ .)! 4...:ki~...U1 .).!_;..U ~ J.J>" .r.5.rJI cr 0~-.).!~ J~i_,
~~.).) ~~ ~lr:.....l )11 -i-' ·r'1 ~-.} & ~~~...Lll .).!y.Y 0L5'
tll5 -'L ~WI ~<-II ~i ~I - ..Lll I J I •. I J ~I_}-' . , - .J - ~ ~ .r. y ~ y .J
~L;_r.ll .:,r.-4 0i .)! J-4 ~1_,.11 0i .)! l_,...al>. ,~_,...Lll ~ ~.r."'1
.o~ ulj~l
.;JI J_,...aAjI (f ~rJI , :J*- V""l>JI J...aAJI J..-! ,.)..L,a..1 lh -.}_,
,~l:501 lh ..::;~ ~ ~ _j ~I.).>---: 'is. ~-' -~
r+--·~ .~l~ill W..)k. ~ ~~~ ~ Z?i 0i ~~)I~
~ '-?j .);?. ;J_, ·.J~:JI -.} 4..Lpl~_, o~.).)A ~I~...Lll l_,..r. 0i 0.J-4..r.
(::_, .~I~...U I '-,?j_iA-o J..s- ~ J....- (f ~L.a.:..ll_, ..::; ~_,:.1I "'l.k&.l -.}
~ ~ ~I~..Ll I o.J~ _j oy::-:.5 tS_,s:..:, ("+•..la.u lS..Ll 0i .J..l:-! .!.l.l~
.P ~I ,:_r -4..WI t:) ~ 0~ ,~l>JI '-:?~ ~-' ,:Y.J .~l.ui
<} ~I~..Lll ~t; 0i ~ w ~ t:l~ o~ 0_,i..l;-! (~rJI lh
·)~I l.h. ~ ~ :J ~j (.~1 .}l0~_B ~ ,:Y.J '~

44
:.r" JS ~ ~.UI ~I ~ ~..!.LJ~ :.r" ~I ~ ~J
~i ~l,r.J ~1~.1.1 ~l.r. 0i ~~ 0L.::-:J-~r.!J ~~J ~0.r •)_.....
. < ~~ •i I .I 0l5 LJ JJ 4.-.:.ill W ~ 4Jl5 .1 4-.ul::J .<:.._1'-!' .r.::-- '-:!"- . •• .r '+" • J • • .r.:-" .r- . r--
~ 0i lS .~ly:-11 oh 4::-t J.:.b.; .jll 01.ll:JI ..) ~~~.ill iWI iJ.A::J
~ly:-11 ~ ~ :y ~L::... ~i ~li~ ~ ~l J~i ~JJI ~1>-~1
..; ~.)~ ~ vJ~ ..l..i ko ~i ~~ :J_,;i 0i ~JtJ ~~~
, . -~ ~ ~I o~~1 Jlyo ~I ~l::-S ~1 IJa;J .~~JJI ~;N t_J..,..!..o
~1~1 i~':JI y- i.,a_; ~~WI yl-ji ~ .j ~1~.1.11 ~J.$-L-.l
~".>'JI ~':JJL>-!1 :y 7.S ~ ~ !.l:.~ 0~ ~J~I lh .j ~WJ
JJ~I ~~_;.; ':J Ji ~~_;.; .A.i .;-11 - ~~~.1.11 ~~ ~'.r. ~w IJ"'Yl
~ ~J~ lSi ~J .0Li-.:J-~~J ~ ~J ~0_,_;._1_ •• ~~J~ .w.JJ (..).UI. . -
~J.$-l-J ~l,r. )i ~ Jy> ~ ~ 1.:-:-. ~ J.li:JI 0i ..>Sr-JI
.;JI L:""J~I ~~J ~')>.~I jSl...-.JI Jy> ~J ~.h..O ~1~.1.11
.J.J..J} -.)1 ~l::S:1 lh ._;~..J .~i ~~JJ _r.:J ;JJ~ ~~ u..r.;
.~WI ..$ .j ~ J>~ y.).11

47
.~.L ~lk.. t.~I..L l..:..:j'1 II U:.l" ..Lll ~ t.: L.; 01• ~ • J t..S'· • ~ • u.- ~ ~ .
011 i~ ,uJ.) (.r.._r..s.J ~ ~ ~Y l:?.u1 '-F-JJJ'l1 .)W'u
,
4-)~ ~ ~~ </'J •el}l J,rJI ~~ ~ ~~~..UI ~ J;b.J~
JLU ~c)~ ~LS ~ U""J~ ~~ ~~ L:...;~j :..ro 4i>- .;
~i ~ .Gi c?l Cr->JJ~I ,:.r.:·::·UJJ11 ~ 0lSJ -~~~ 4.:Jl::JL;_,:JI
...1....0 .~I~..Lll ~.)l>..;l J~l 0J.) ~JJJ11 olA!.liJ .)J-l>JI J~
.j .J ~ ~.b. ..) (Ralf Dahrendorf) ...JJJJ.:...Jb ........iJIJ .)Jylll cfll
' -~ t........._,.::..l c~ ~ 0i ['-F-JJJ11] .)L>..;'1 ~ 0i •&_r.-4
~ ~~ _ lrlj~J c;J_,..;t;..;...... ~ .}. ,Ja.o ~lyS)J y__.,j ~
J~ ~.l>.,j ~J .~1 ...L>i J,h. LS -~~y:-11 4.:J_,.kl.r.")'l ~
~ :.r ~ -~~ ~L,., jJ~ ~.) YJ •(Pierre Manet) ~Lo
..::,.,~')1 L.iJ . (
1
<~I~..Lll ~.J_,.kl.r.A)'Ill oL......... L. j~~ ~JJJ•'1
J .J~_; ~ qj__,.!JI -.} r..fr.-'Jt J.l...!...:Ji C::" __,;..;l.:.::.: '-:f',J.JJ'Jt J~l .JlS I~! (1)
:2006 ,~L..) !!<.J-::'...Jl..;:,. L~ .f->J t_O~ C:.~ -;JI !!"-::bi~..Lll "-u~lr.)/lll
(58_ 57 ~1 __.1;1 n5

0~r~·C.·~
•1/.
fr.tL..::
:·~.f·&:
~rf~)·t..C.·c..
~1.-
.t~·'t-(.'<'e.!
lr:.'L1
·~·&:f·~
~~.·~..r-.t.c-•C.
f;~"-~
¥~··~,t-•
·~·~~~·~
lfT,~~~..c.r~.-c.·-·
-·{'~.'r,
tt.f
~~.£·~.t-:~·E·~·t:r~r·~~·(·1-~t~~<t~~
1.t~·~~..vc..e.f.·c~·rJ·[1:.<;~-__~r-
.-·~~E.f(·~-~·-~.t·(.:--~~·~t.."f=
~.~f~.~.~£.~-~~.·~·r·~~--t·~.v-.·~
t<1~~·!Gc.~~·~~et~·t·"~~~l_f··t:-t·..1-·~-•b.r.,l'-~.•vt~-·'/-r.~
1
-
l:...[~:-•.-.y.'-'L...
~..:__~:oo~-·~.~·'·~."'.f"1,[__:.~[~~.1•
~.~~.~~-:tc·r.·r_~<::::-r..c·f--c...e-:c.
~L~r·~-~·~~-f.._r-'f~o•1.r<=s;-
·~(c't..V.tv(·..!_.-~'t....
.~~.1;..:".~",.t·.-.~·.f~·V·.....~
~=.r~·t.L.t~l.~.-<r[·~ro•~.f'~~~.
·~.r··V-·(·~.r.~E.~·.-c~·.~tc~~·'L
~t.f~~-r:~f·&:-·(•-q..-~-
t·~.~~0.•.t·;~J-·~~F·C:~.~~t't-~·[;"'r'.t.~-..t•t•'/-·~&r,~·~-,.t•lSOS$r[,~·C;•..:t•
~-::~~·.!:~tt~t_<>~~~·!0'~~~L,~:
l
..,·r·'t?~:~(•~·~.-er-:Itf,.·&:f)Co[,_rff.1·.·L.~£~~·.-r-f'1-..c.~ltt:·
•r~~,...~··-.rt•-::•L....t:..~~...r.-1·~-."-_:_.'(G•
-t.-'vc.·.l$uv..
1-··~.y;l~.~"[.:·-·5'·vE~E:lt0f·E.~$s~·t.s-t•.s~_,
Qf..it~t~f.'f-.[.c.·~1-·:t'~~~~'~t~~.r,
1~-·~·~f'--~·t't---t·t··e.
r,:;;;Q(•~~(··:t·.t'v·t..c-t'f·~~(•r;::~.f:.f
[}::f-~FEl.~·[~~s:·:f[~.._.1~I~

49
...L.,a.i ~ ..ti.ll cq · l::JI J~l · L; IC' •. ~I ~I
_r.. ~ ~ ~..) '-!' i u-"'! .J
c..;.J ~ ;;_,AJ~ L:..;i ~~i ..u.; -~~~ L:..;i Jl!.A ~.J : ~~~...Lll
~ ~~~.) OJY.J ~~~.) ~ :r _;si -~ -.::...lUL> .Ji 4 ( ; ~
_r.....L.,a.i 4......~ ~yK1 J~l lh 0i ~ ..k....~l h11 ~I~~
~I_;:-.. ~I ,}l5J LSJ..>.l ~I ,_} -.:....;L5 4......~ :Y' ~ ~~~...Lll
• . (1)4LL!JI UL ~I. .r..
.) .Ji U:WI .) ~1_,..... ,a,~ ~.)1~1 ~:.::fl'l ~~.r.A)'I J.; ~
~-4~y ~y1;-)'1 tJ_;..-11 eul.; ~~ _; ~ ~~ .0y-o aoII
~ 0i ~ w 0.J~ lyl5 L:..;i (""""'~~~I 0i (Thucydides)
¢?. ~ -rJI ~I ~i :r ~~:1o><..l _j');;.11 ~ c_u...Ll~ ~.rJI
~l> -.:....;L5 -rJI ~_,...._!JI :r -4..WI ._)s. ~WI ~~I~...Lll ~~
«~)) ~ •J ly>11 ~i _; •.;-./l' I t::y--::JI ~ ~ W .t..:..;1
OJ~~ c_y-PY. I_,...;.JJ .:r-.)~1 u-.:fl'l ~I~...Lll 01 ._;');;.11
U:.)-~--1 o-.4_J..j ~LS LS..UI «J.)WI ~~ll ~1J.)j~ ~.J~ L.. ,L.h.;..;
~I.J ,:.r ,«J.)WI ~L.k>Jll 1-4-J W_,; .0~1 ~l>..:.J • 4JI~.J
;s::;) ~I)I lh 0i Jl.i...J .~ ~ J~l il_r.>-1 J.J...Lll - 0-LJI
~1 ~.ill ~WI l....p JS ~ly ~ -rJI) ~~I :r (.r.?y ~
~i 0yW ~.1 ~Y. .1-45 ~I.J ~ 0i lo~ .(~ ~~ ~i
JS ~~~~eLl~_,- ~l>JI 4>J~ ~~I~_,.) J$0 -~~ ~
~-'.) ~ ~ _,i .~1_, ~I 4Jj~l ~Lb.J.) t...;,_,....a..> .~_,.)
4))>JI t.WI ~I :r ~f>:S ~I LS.LJI ~~~ ~I e:Jl....a..oJI
.J.)~ r-".) t.?~ ~1; .) ~ .;JI OJ.J~I J_,J..ll ~
, 14.1 .u~i .J~~>> ,[<<~..lill ~.JLA::J_,11>> ~ ~~ ~ L. L;;LS] .J_,j_,;..._j ~I (1)
d26-120 d01-100 ,95 ,73-72 ,56-54 d969 :.Jj,LS 11.3 d8-16.1
:y-1_,...!. 15 ~ d994 :~ 220 ,209-208 d972 :~ 347
.323-310 d995

l
r·
<;:
(•
.f
1c..
1VJ
-.J
L.-.J
-·~~
.-.J
'-0
<;:-
·~f
-~t•oL-
.c-{
t~
·~l
~.b
-~-·f
~~.
~
-'--'
--c..·_c..·r·1.~·1:.&~·r-(·~·1~~(____1·r-t~.;..~
a1~r.L..~..--~__.""t;.E't.c..r-tJ.r.~--~'"'·~f1-:(;..K:.[--•.r::
~~~.~l.'"'[t~~~·~·)...~..~bl-.f1.-~".··E..c1-.c"'tK:t:c..·l~·.{;;
[1---"t"''tc_f::t'--(Ifc..&.:
~~.f,c-j-'t.'.l/.t-·:r.f1:(•r..t:t'~f·~.ir~
<1;~l~V.fc..·"'.-·~t'L.."''-'L'L-.t•
~~'t__'L...~c..·-~.1--~-.·[.'c.
.r'f.,,-·.l-'>''1..r~-::;-..[•I;_·G.-l-c_1{~1f·~~E:~l11-·~.t:'Ef~1qt~
1..~.L-:tf't~1:rt.-~-·s.r·c..c.·t.1-·L"'-~~
~~·_,l-.-~._:.~.t-.r~~-~S.lr.·~~.·~
~c;.f"''tt:.~l'L-1~•C-~{1,~-
·~-~-}Ef='J.~1;.t··~-·tt...lr.~··(.•-~(·;.._"."'·~
~•-~(..•,)oo[:_1-::·..o•[••~
~•-~.,t.o•-{_'•-
1:[.':~1:::i<t.':.~~•f;.,~.t[ty.{~1.
E'L1:.)~~-t't.G~-~[:.~~"'-·(;;~··[};
---l---}~·,(.C..v••t}'-•,{''t·(____'ioC.·
•=YC...·c..·-·.."...,LT-sct'-lsY>-.c.b
2rt:.L~~:}•·~t·fr_~.t·[.-,~:~"'"'••-E::-~(;..'1:,c_.~C~
(;,tt1~-~-~v·'b.v."·.r·fv~1-1F~·__.r.~t.t·~.';t.l--.Lr-11>•..,.•r:.f.V~~~•V't__o•·
'i•f::~'-•~~"....t:.I-•'.C~·)~[-'1.-'•(;..
.r-·::i=r~f·~-;..t·[ic·~.~T~·[~.~z.t.t1:!l:.1:.(·'l-r.t::r-~·(;...!:-!:-l-v.c-·
:__!.·t·.:..._:..__}·._:1-£~~·_F·c..-·.r~~"'·(·-rlc..·[:·"'.
'-r-~t!.
~-,c..,11·..'t•0~.
~-:£:__~~'t.b·~~f1~·C1;f[ts..1V'o
0

51
<<l:?,;~l "-!lk.>-JJ .j (Pericles) ~..r.! ~ • .US dl~ .)1 oWl
0J~ (.;A ~ ~ ~ ((~~~ -,?'lz.... i~)) ~ ol-.. Lo l}.d u-.:f'1 0i
~L.:...J •JaA.; t..J_,.l.lr.)'I ~ ~_rj ..:..>l)J_;.......oJ o~ ..:..> 4...l-.jJ ~)y
,Wtl J.::--i :r ~ 'Y <~..it «~I~JJIJJ ~ L:...o~ 0p) : .J~ ~..r.!
~}I .j <~..il (t;.JW. ~~) ~J .«._r>l>.....!.'1 :y ~~ y;Si J.::--i :y ~J
Lo....A..; .«....; •11 ~<--11.. ",_. Lo · 4.......JL:.; LL:>..:;.;I L...l < • ~• r-' J ~-- . ~ t_/ • J •. . .rYJ.r:"
I~ ~1~1 J~ll 0~ ·~I LJW ~~~ ~·'YI ~_?:; l:?_r..;
·~..r.! J~ L.S •«Ll.:-11 ~ ~I JY''1 .j L?i)l ~1-41 .j Cf.r"L.;
~t ~ •4~ ~IAJJI o.h 0i ~ ~..r.! ~~ dl~ .)1 oW.!J
u.J.; • ~ LJ,..i .!) ..l,j I. :f .<"I • ~ <--ll L w uw ~ ~~~ •<i ~ t.:.!. y . . . J '"t" <..Y'"'J ,-- J • r-- r-' ~
l.h .jJ ..k.i; d....J_,.l.lr.)'l ~_,.; ~ IQ+·I.~ 0:illl ....;_rJIJ y_rjl
~ L:.;iJ •....;1__,.....1 0J~ :r J~l ~ L:.;i ~i ...AJJJ ~.;::: ~ ~J...,a.ll
Uli!JI ~y Js:5' ~..WI 01 Jl..a..::..>~ J.,_;i ....~_r.J 0J~ 0-'" ~I
.(2.41-2.37 ~ J..L.a.JI) «~..f-)'1
•JlWI ~~ ~tl ~IAJ..ll 0i o_r.>-'1 ..;...IJl:--JI o.h ...j>y
JJJJI dl~ ..) ~ •4;:.o..r. J!..f-)'1 ~~ WL,., ~.Jyblr."l OJJ~ ..) ~lS
o4J ~.J .4-::Jl ~IAJ..ll ~i ..;...J,L ~IJ • 4J ~L> ...:...;lS ~I
cll~J • _;l.,_j)'l JLA~j'YI ~ l:?l.ll Lo ~J ~¥1 l:?~ 0i JJJJI
..t:...S'1 U:-1 • ..UI . •• • JJI 'l-.i'YI o.AA~... ~ '-I~L? J.. .
0i ,c~jl~ ~~ .~l>JI ..:..>l:bi~..UI o..i.A 1-.; 0i ~ 'Yi ~J ·~
~ 0y5J~ .:r-l.ll 0.,.:.11~1 L?i> j~)'ll~ 0~ .:r-..UI ~ wtl
ply~ 0:.lJI ~~ ~tl t_W>-1 ~ dJ ,(~tl ~IAJ..ll
~_r:...iw.. 'Y ~i ~ly-)1 ~ ~~~IJ ~_r>-i ;;)....,:2.-4 ..:..>L:-bl~~
1•. 1<" •. I.~~~ :L:.-.4.; ~ ~ 1.~7 0i c l...a-JI..;...Lkl • ...Lll..u-~~.._..._._'"1!-' . • • r-- J • ~ .
.(j_,51.r.-' JL> 0lS W' •o.}U ..:..>4~ ~ Lo) 4· ...+~1 ~IAJ..ll
'-:-'~1 ~ r-=: .jll ,«c;)~Pl ~ 0i -4'Y 0lS .~..WI..:..>'YWI ,j ~J
.wWI ~tl e:JL..a....ll ~ ~~Y. .~l;JI..;...l:bi~JJI iK>

52
01 46J? oL.Iy ~~1 ~l>JI .;.,~l~..lll JJ~ ~1 4~J
~LS _rs-1 j~1 ~ -i ~ J_r-jl ~L.}~I ~..4----~ 4 WJ ~ ~
~1 4J"YJ:,)'I ~ r '1 I~ ~~ .,ry. ~ ~u-: ...+..11 u-.:)'1 4-o~
~ ~ll 0~JI ~ 4((~1 ~ ~ ~ .. -i ~in~ ~1
~J 4.;.;1.> ~>W; .>" ~ ..!11.> 0J ~ 4~>IJ..1....<'J1 ~ t;.jJ :0:-4..WI
.(2.40.4 ~ J.l..,a.....]l) ((J..a>.: ~ L:.;J
.;JI ~WI .;.,~l~..illl:?~~l ~_,JI .r..r.J ~~ JJ~ ~
• t •.•
"----' ~ ~ ~· . • . l..:...JI I ·~L.!..,jl
• • . • UJ jS' OJ~ ~J 0~ ~ * .. "T'
~WI ,]pi -i I~ JJ1)'1 ~ ~~ 0J Jot:; ~J .~11 ((~Ill
~~~ .J-::'.J 4((J~WI ~lk>Jill J ~>LO~I .jl~ J~ e::.r:JI ~)I ~
~l: ~ .;·ll ~J 4oykl>.....JI ~ L_?.l.ll ~I i~l 01 _;kWI
~l~..lll ~....A '-:?".....1 ~>?. y. 4(..)y>-1 ~ .>" 44Jy_r.JI ~I..S:..JJ
·~~ ~ LS 4((~~1n o__,+!. ~ ~'1
~.>~ t: J~l r ~ o~l y")l>.Ji ~I oh ~l:..::J
l;~ ~1 ~J ,..;>.;_,~I~.)~ 01 .r.f- .<•.15:;~1 ~l~..lll
(Hannah ..G} 4J ~l~..lll ~I._) ~_,....;J _rs1 ~ -dWI
er-::JJJJ ..G} .r" JS·(..)y::-i (Sheldon W~lin). er-::JJJ 0J~J A;endt)
~ yZ ~1 Ji 4~ ~)1 ~ 4~~1 ~~~..UI 01 (0Jy:>-TJ)
0i 4~I y::>-11 ~IJa.:,:. -i .;.,~JJ ..;JI ~~ .;.,IJl:s ~ 4~4:JI
~1 ~1 ~I ~l.!..::.ll lh ~ ~ 4((~~~~~4 ~ ~.J_,kl_r.-41
• (1)~.....- •
. ~~)~
·fo..r.! Jl ~ <•)
d958 ..1..;) }a; :~l:-]1 o~ JI.WI ~ olj.;J ~.r.! ~ ,.,lj) Jl ~~ (1)
'-::-14r.--)'l ,y .:r.lJJ ClJ~ ~ .,lj) )aj ~J ~J .28J 27 ~ L;._,......,:.
~.5:.. ~ .:r.AJj...JI ..::.>~ ~i )ajl ~78-77 L;._,......,:. ,90-63 : 1996) ~~
~ ~ '-:?.lJI) .JL...r-'_j .:.~i ..:;.,~ ~ ,~1 ~J Jl!...JJ .(8-7 •.:r.JJJ

~~.r't''1-~~r·t;~J''f~..1-!;;l..!;-,rD~
L't•-c.·f,.f?~"
-l:c.·1G~·t...-.n·~
...,.f·(.'1~·;;.?(•~&.~@~;
·~-L.~'-~~.t._3'-
.'t..~~·r~~·!-;.~g·r:
c.·~.f,e.·C~~----:e'f2.~·~.tf1'"""E··1_.~·
'r·~'":}~--··=....'e.::r•_!.l(..•I_oI
~'t..~'[·~~1,l~fnc_r1_
1.t.1.C.·1_C.·t'1.~·5C_
cGf~.._--·r
~•••(E.'-C.•~f1:-~,;r
:_~.~§f.·=z.·'·1.~~r£Ar:~Eb.1~..-y.·~.·t
v~'-r...r1{r,-._'-''.t:!00t.
~t:r•fr'•'~·'-t.;lt-'t."G.~'-(•
rE'.~•E!~~[•).~-(;;
~·..•Ci..~z.~·[:;~.t·cl.~·
·~.r.~1r•t'v•'-"l~·
~1:..~v,",..·~.-
rt~·_~·i[t'!=;~iG
[.c::l-~....0•tIt,'L-(...••),_
·-·~1:l·~·c.~f&.~..-·•
~~r.·~·'~r'•i-•-,;-~·~.•Q•
c'-~.J-·Lf.·V0bo•~
.·~'1;,~'tr.~t.:'b:~;L
~.1·~1rtt.~.~'-c.
~,.C.•--~.r~~.~r'r
wer'f_'1..c;:t-.ol.t..
~e;c;~-t~·~.£·G..j':'~~
-·I~.(',.[~.·t:'"7-~·~~.t·I~,~..."~~·~r-~
~~;t...."[-·•(..•~."!::.
c._-~[{;."~.-.tt•.~~.
~~G-~---~·-tL.~
y.)·v(••Q<i'r·{'·~r·~.[·-,1-
l..(1·&=f.g·.[t:-·tf
tL.11-...~.---·y·~~~-tt'--f-
ct'=.-:t<f:.r:;f•(..);-r.·cc
r~t;·~~-GJ.~·r·G-.-£~
~·C·(1~.,..~t::-•
G-·v.c:1.·r-•'t~L...{G--...~
~.f~.c-r.~·~~[~·:t.1rJ:.,..
o•C·G-t1~',,,[_-•c._-Cf.~b'f.,)-9_t",..,-;-c._~'I
~r_:.·(.c·'c.~(•'-t;t'r·-·~•(;.
-·t'~c·~-!L·(;:i-L...J·.l·
:r·~·~r.<C.~.t·(;.·.~~·t;·t.•·~~
•~"1..•-~)1J"".c-I-•~
t~.[.~(~·.lt··E:'1·.~.~:~·~r:
.'t't.c._~c._'-~~:v-.1-~~'"".--.·~·~
~~·v-~.~1·~.~~<i'T.y.~·~~<i't-~..[1/"l·-·C.t.1S-·S-·Jl,.-
0c·~-·'tI.!:.r=99"'L.~
bS~OS·~OS-
'(,Cy~~£.I•~t~l~0
~~•&-:'f_,~t.~r~E1~"it:.-c_...~c·-·....__:..~.·~-r.l~<f·_f'b.·V~·C:
~Lt·t."'-(i=.t-·'
L.{;:l·~f.·~.~·~r·<..·c.<i't

54
<<r-"~1 ~_,ili))J ((J,)WI ~Ua>..H))
C~ ~ 0i ~ -?.lJI ~'1 i~l y ((J~WI '-:"'l..k>.Jill 01
~.J -?.lJI ''-:"'Lk.>.JI lh.J .~_r>-'1 '-:"'_,...._!JI ~ J_,....i::.JI ~ '-:"'_,...._!JI
0.Jj--!..11 ..r.-4 -?.JL-.. ~..lj ~~Y. 0~)f~ ~ J""L....i ~ Y' ·0~1
1;_r.-o ~ 0~)11 lh 0i -r.-4~_,; Jl!.o c!'Y..J ....Jlb..JI ~~ J 4.J.J...UI
0i.J -~~.:..o lylS ~J~)fl 0i ~ ~ 4 ..lit.~,; ~.r.-"1 ~h 0-"
- -Lol)~ J_,.k....-.; ~ L:...;i d •0y.J~fl 0~'1 ~ 0---·_1~1
~JyiJI t.;i J1_;;1 ~(~I ,.W:.) ~I ._;.;'1 _ra.:jl 0i -r.-4~_,;,
- -
.!1..:-...i.h ~LS:JI oF-~~ J~ ._rjl ~JLS:JI ~.J ·~I ~Jls:JI -.)1
~~ ~jji.J .G..JL-.. ~~I ~J~;'J ~ ~ J~ (Delphic)
-?jjl (__,>-~~oF-_r.-i -./'.J) 0_y.1JI 0-" ly~ r-l ~i ~ ~-4..l..::--~
Jl-r.-4~_,;A dl~.J ·4..4#1 ~? J~ ~J~ OJ~ ~i 4:-..o ..::....;l&.
·.,t"f1url -~~.J i~ .Ji -~~.J 0~ '-:?"'L..'1 Jlj-11 ~ J..l...UI
':f"""l::-JI ~I ~l:....: Jlj-JI ..:Ll~ ~I 01 J~l ~
~l::--11 ~yl~l -.; A ~L'1 Jlj-JI .La. 0i r.? .~')50
~..L..LJ J""L..'1 }Y.. 4~_,; ¢w~ ~~~ -~~~ ~ LA ~~
_d- ~.411 lh ~ JJJ .(ius gentium) ~'1 0_,.;W ~ ~
•J.J...UI !J_,..LU ~L..'1 ~~ }Y.. ~jji.J 4 9.J~ ~ ...J~ "":"'~
- -
.~1)1 G~ ~1 '-:"'.}JI ~ ~.r. ~.J...Lll ~yWI ~ J""Li r:-->"
.~I~...JI ..r.~ ~ l.A-J lh ~~-~..w.l il~l ~i 0lS.J
?- :.rl.!.ll 0_,.ill ~~ .} •(Edmund Burke) !JJY. ..ljY'~1 il~l y.
lS ((~...JI '-:"'_r.lll - 4.J.J...UI ~I '-:"'.J.rJI ~ Jl ~I .JJ_y~ J
~hll ~ ~I~J..ll ui....J~I J~l ~ ~i 0-" _ ~ J.lki
:_r t_IJ...UI 0-" ~)I ~ .(1)~}JI oJ_;ll il12.:..1 -?J.fll .kl.!..:..li.J J"..WI
J..r-- i')U ._,...J_;J» (403-398 : 1839) !!..!.1.4.l J::.A... i-y.___, J..r-- .)/,TI tlL....)ll (1)
(66-65 ~ J~) !!1972 ~y /_;WI :.;r..r.; .,i t_W}>'J .)WI ~_,.11

55
~ (.;-" l~i ~r. l,.L OJ~l: ,JJb'l'l J':>L> (.;-" ~ 'ill2..;JI
.)1 (Vitoria) ~J~ ~~~ ~~I tbWI ~_,..-jl ..;:_,~~ ~~i
:r t.l;..lll ~ ~? ly~ r-l ~'l'JA .;_,~)a.:.ll ~~i 0i 'l'l ,.!JJY.
r-li~W Jlj-JI ~...J .lAJL!.:.;I Jl Ji .~I~..UI Jl ~:JY.. ~..UI _&1
----.JI 0l5 J.A.l ~ill - ..lll ~L 11 ..WlA:J ~ -II 0 'WI --...>-
.. - ~ J • ~ - ~ y . f.
J_,>.jl Ji .~l~..ill Jl.WI ~.Jl::JI ~I y. ,clJjj oJ_,.k>- ft11
~~I t:..;i _j -01~ jr... r-l ~.ill - <<.;.;11 ~rJI)) ~ ..::....i1.1i ~
i.1i:JI _j) ~I r-5~1 ~~ ~ .AJJ t..J~ _j u-S0J ·~J
.~_;JI ;;J_,!.ll ..; ~ 0-"J •<J.a· Qu c.r-bS .;Y~ ~l ~.:J ~.ill
,rs11 .;_,L.J~I ~.JL; (._;GJ ljJ.r. fl11 U!...11 oh ~ ...LiJ
t: 'l'l ~J L!.;.;l:J ~I~..Ul: ~I ~.WI ~.r.. r-1J .':1..l:s-l
~I~..UI ~-s.:J~I ..; OJY J_,...a..> ~J •?- C:""WI 0yiJI .;_,~U.~
..kA; lf:....J~ ~J ~L...11
~-s:JL:-1-l -.>J_,.!..lI J _,..-:JI ..!.>J~ «~.r.:-"rI ~l::JI)) ~ ..Li.l
- -
0~.:J~ ~ cr. L..5J ·JJ..UI c..r-JI ..; ~I~..UI t....Jk.JIJ
WLA.::......L: (Alexander Hamilton) 0~LA J..l:-....50iJ (James Madison)
~ ~.i.ll ...J-4-JI 0i (Federalist Papers) «~IJ..lAJI JIJJ11)) ~~..;
~ I~..UI t..J~I :_r oo4~ t_Y ~L!..;l y. ..fr.:"'rI J.fW>..Ul i.Y"L....rI
lh JJ~ ~ ..;:_jlSJ .~~~~~I ~I~ t,;.J~ .._.;1-%;
-114 d03-102 :~ J...L..a.....ll) <<~.) ..r'~ ~Li..WI Ll:--- J_,.,.. .;_,~II
-1958) 1792 ~~ 1•--:,T 18 •__k~..,.S. ~J_,..lll ~Jl>JI .r.JJ .)! .UL..J (118
I :L; .ULA... I~ ...;L4.J..,u,!.) .;_,L.,l..;:j')l..l....A...J •LA..:Ji 1.:.~1 .(177-176 :1978(,}'::' ...r- . .., JY. . - 1..)"" ~
•4:~_,.11 Wll J (141-132 :1839 J ~(Law of Nations) ( <<r--'')11 0y.tll
.(137 d33-131 d28-127 ,85-84 :1995

56
~ ~1 OJJ~ (.$.:1l (.$lJI ~ ~ ~~ _; (,$)~ J~1. . .
~ (.r ~L.;)fl 4.:_,-ll ~.:1_r. OJ~~ • ~ .,.L..i::.>-II__, •_;.k:y:-11 J__,.:......UI
.~_y__, (Locke) .=J) :_yo JS'
~ •c~WI 4....J~I ~__.kll..; ·~l;-JI c~l .uu ~
.:1~)' ~ ((L?}UJ J,:.<J)) :f' ~ ~)~~ ~J5 ..;..l=..lla ao~
._j L__,ju ~ ~J.A rJ ~_,;- ~ ._j ~JL!..JI JJ>. :_yo W.)1
o).~ .G~ ~ _;..WI ~~ 0i •.!.D~ ~ 0 _y •..w LPJ__, .~1
4-)JG:. (_yO~ •fil ~--' ,;;.·k aol 4.:..UlA::J ~..d :_yo~~~
L;W ..;..~ ~.,....;_,...iJI ~):UJI ~l>. ~ "-:-1~·11 0__,.1;;- .,1 .:~1_)11
':?'LJ ~ -4~ J_,k..JI lh ..j ((~.r.)Jin ~ !__, .cy..WI ~.:~~
~~ ~--' ·.:r._r>-11 J.>..A.j :.r 0~11 ~--' ·~I~ ~JL!.....JI
_ 4_,.,l:>JI w~ ~~ :_yo ~ 0l .:~} ~ ~ .;JI ~L-..iJI ..r'L....1~
.(.$-:~l...ci11 ~.., ~ __, ~L>J1 ~~ wly •.,.~ JS' ~--' :J__,i
- -
0.J-'"!.:~LA ~ LA :_r- ~ ~ ;;~~ ~~~..U ~&1 ~)
:r 0~ .:~...Ls-i :r 0~ L="-~_A ~ ~~ .rJ' ~ ~~~JJ))
0.J-'"!.:~LA cA LS) ((~ ~.,.WI 0__,..r.J..J...J 0~ ~lJI ~I_,...JI
~ ~ .J~1 lS.r;- ~ 01 .(«Tenth Federalist» .rZWI JIJ.Lt..ll ..;
:.r ~..u...~' ~~ L?jJ' ((~))__, ((e_,...J)) L:"-~_..J, 0.)-'-!.:~LA ~ J1k.!
.((~ ~~r. ..;.;__,~ ~ ~ ~~)) .:I~Y. ,Ljl:.:....J (("-;-'_;,..>1))
~ ~I 0~ -((~__, ...:Jl!JI ._)IJJ..illl .) 0~-:~LA (.~ LS__,
.) ~~..WI 6..:S.r."11 ..::.>LA~__,ll ~')S:JI ..;..L.J~ ((~))
(.r ((~JL!.....JI ~ ;;JJj (.$l (.r ~~ ~ "-:- ·: U ~I .,.L.,a.;)'l
- -
oi_,...JI c~ ~ .l:UW ..;..~~lu .~1 ..; ;;~L:-JI ~Jl!...JI
(0.J-'"!.:~LA ~ ~) ~I .) ~ ~J~ ~--' ·~I c~WI
•0*~) 0-'.Jl::>.....J ~ (.r ~ 0~ ~~ J")l>. (.r ((~;))
.(329 .49 - 42 :2011 ·0.)-':!.:~LA ·-.?~

57
t...J~ j-.4 -4~1 c_PI 1-4-J ~JWI L~l ul~ 01
~ .~11 W4 (John Adams) y..obT 0y.- U.~ W) ((~l_r.;ljll
~L:.::JI <-;-JL::S11 ~ r a·~l_, ~ ..+· .. li -~~ ...u.:..:: 0i ~~~
~~I '-:?"Lz..-lI C.~ I :f , ~ l>...lI ~~ L,a.;:j1 I Ua.L..l1_, y U_rLl
o~ 4i C:..J~ <) 4_j~ :_r- ~ L,?J.ll __.kl>.....J~ J _,A->....JI_, ~I
~J ,((~11 ~_,....Jill~~ :_r ~ 1 -s_r>-i uJ~ .~4r."l _,i
'-:?~l,a_:;l c.~ '-:?i 'jji ~~ c.~ ~ '~i i~ JJG:. :.r ~
~i ~_,_r.... o).~::J~ ~~~~ JL;...:.,jl _j~ 0i ~~~ ~ .~
lh 0A ~ J_, ...!ll.lS ~l:r.l Jii_, •<-;-J_r-JI ~L> 0A Jii 0~ ~~~
~_,..UI Jt_,....::JI_, a).~..-J ~ J~~ ~ !.SJ~ ~~! u4~_,i
y-c:. GL>JJ ~~ L'y..JI ~'WI 0l5 ~ -~.JA ..lSi w:J ·~J
l..t.J.-4.;_, i..l!.)' ~J.ll u~Jl>')JI o.J..>. 0A ~ ~~ -~~ ~L..;l
~l.::S <) u..a.JI '-:?~ ~) ~ <) ~.JA C.~ ..l!_, .4_j~ ~~
.(2.20) (L'espirit des Lois) ((~_,All C.-'Jll
L...!:> o~,jj il.&. 0y.; o~,jlJ .o;..WI _;LA.,QJI oJ~I ~Wll
, I • I • , • • "•d _. '1 ,
u~J ~J •cJ~ u~J -~ (J.J..>. u~J
~1_,.; 01 J_,.A..ll ~--' ...~ JJG:.i u~J •o).~~;
o).~~u .cl~ ~ L..t._;..G_, ,JJG:.11 ~ o)-~1
, 0_,..k')Ui ~ r.L; ..!.Ul.J_, :~I J')l>fI ~
..!ll~ -.>) W" d-6.:Ay_, ~.r.~I J Jl>.fI ~ aJ ~ ..9
• ((iY- JS" ,j
:(25.12) ~ ~ ,j ~ ~.JA ~J
~L.....11 j-.4 ii_,_r.JI ~i_, o~l c}-J 0l->)'I ~
~_, , ~ ~_r-ll yS"-.4 ~ u-)_, ,..:r.J.lI 4 4-<>-J o..ISj-<>JI
0_,~~ J"'L:JI ~ ~ ~J •o~ ~.rJI ~ ~
~~~ .~Ll....>jji~~~J •G..:..A

-r-Y- .;JI dl.;J ~IJ) J )y .;JI ~_r=-11 .....iklyJI
. ((cr.JJI ~
58
~ ~ ;;_;:; J ~JJJi ..;.J~ .;JI .~jr-31 ~JJI '":-'J.rJI ~ .u.l
~ Ji ~L:--- l:?i :.r 0JJ~ -~..l-.11 ~..)~~ ~Y c')...,.,)'1
~L...;JI ~ dl~ ~J ..;,; ~')W -r-J ~y .)1 ~ .,...,~
~ ,.L!..;l Jl ~ ..::....;ts .;JIJ •((('"'"'1 0_,.;.in 0~ ~~ ~I
0J_;.!JI Jl J>~ ~I ~.L..II 0i ?I .ill ·('"'"II :..r- -,?'l:z..... JJ~
dl~J .~r- yUI ~_,..8~ _ro~ ~jl:..; ..;.JI,.L...~IJ ~~ ~J..Lll
~.A::..il '":-'J? .)1 J~l ~~ ._; ~~i ~..u1 J~~~ J>..L:ll -~wi
- -
d~ e::_ra-11 )yi)'IJ J~~l L"WI t: ill lh ~b-1 .Lr-
l:?..UI i')LlJ ~I U""L'1 4-ii 0':J I ..uu .;JI ~.:.:.II ~_,.II ~~l.,a.::;11
·('"'"11 ~ ~_,.411 ii.J->~ ~ 0jlj ~ J;b.J~ ~
~l_r.:lll ~..J~I 0i y. ~~ r.WI ~ dl~ 0-" ~)1 J>-
~l:.r.-")'1 4>-J.r. Gl::>-iJ ,;;_~...JI 4>-J.r. ~1~1 L ~I ~~I
~Wiy:-11 ~l_dJI - ~~I o~l '-r" ~Ji .;..;J .u--JI t!lk.ll ..;.JI~
;;_,.__,y Jl l:?~y •~_,_!. ;si ((~_r._,:.; 4.5?)) .,!..J~ ~i Ji .Js.J c...~.;~I
~_,.411 :..r-11 e:JL,a.. ~i .;..;J .JI.dJI JlA~j'IJ i')Lll ~WI J~l
~J .4.........._,.:jl ch ~_;...=J ~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~lr.:lJI ~_,..aJ ~~~
l .. . "' <II "' "'
~~ -~1~1 ~ ·~~~'-!""_,.ill 0-"~1 0-" ~_;51 rl !J~ 0lS
.~JG:.'1 ~WI ~Li)'~ ~i ~ .1.> Jl o...l;~l ~l_dJI ~~
J ~..I.>J ts~~ ~ c.> .;JI ~L)1 J LA~ !J_,.l 0y;;- 0i r.?
J_r-.ili ~I..Ll '":""'J.r-JIJ ..;.JJ_,!JI '":""'_,..:..; .Jl ~b , ~")ls:JI ~
i~ Jy-- ~l!.l ~L)1) ...l;...b..::.ll ~J ~ ~rJI 6.....J}:>Ir.)'1 _j _~_,.II
- 192 d76 ckl..A......JI •«Second Treatise of Government» -~1
.dl~ 0-" ~i ~_r.-.o11 ~~ ~ ~~ ..,ljJ .(232 - 221 d96
~_r.;.o11 ':?"L..~..U .(Benjamin Franklin)~~~~~ r i ..u.;

59
oJ_,.!JI ~ ~~~~ ~ W~l J:,_,~ <L>-1_2~ ,J_,"~JI ~I
.k_,rJI ~ 0i ~(William Pitt)~ il:J-' ~..U dl~_,) "~_r.-4rl
· ·1 :q 4...J....IA::.ll ;__; ~~~ · ·1 ~tL J~ 0L ";__,; :q IJ.:S . L.la:JI ••'-.r.:' r . . . r '-.r.:' r . . . - r '-I i ..r:.!'-'
~)) :~L::.ll ..:..IJ~~ <L>I_?I ~ r__r!._, .~1~1 ~lk:_r.ll ..:..L....~I_,
· · '1 · ,1.1"4....;L,j'}l _•:0i.._,j;.·L:..;L!,UI tq~L:.;i
~-' r-: ~-' '-t-'-' • • u-- . .7 • • .r.::""' •
•dl~ :r ,;si ojJ~ c;_,k.> _;_, .(l)ns_r.-4i-.} ~~ _; ~~~ u-"Li
•j,r.11 ~_r.-4rl o.>?l ((~)y.-4ill .(Thomas Paine)~ u-"l.oY ~LA>
~ W' "~~~.ill LA>.r.~J ~.)..11 0_)?1 ..L,.:. .!lJY. ~_,..~l ..:..~
~ ~ .~_r.-41 I o->fi ~WI ~")l.:..'':J I ..:..'1 'l.ill .!lJY. ~ ~.>-" :y
:w~ · · w- 11 o ·11 0.! "..:........•.• ~ • _r.4 ).)-' •
i ..1;_; ~-' "~')>. 1 I ~)a:JI ~ u-""'G~ i ..1;_;))
~WI~ ~)~I 0L,.j)'l J_,A.> ~-' ·~~ iJL.
LS_,.;i ~ J.rJI dl '":-'.;JI :r 0'11 J~ .~w;u
~l ·'":-'}JI ~l J,r.JI :y ..::.J~ .;JI ~I~~ :y
~ ~i ~-' •-4.b...:..ll ~-' ~ ~l_;i i~l ~ '1
. (2
)(('-:?~1 ~ o-.4~ ~ J...u__, "~.AZ
~..>~1 LS_,.ill ~ ~ :JWLS ..:..j,r. -;JI ~11 ~LS ..W
..:..l:'1)1_, ~lk:.r. -4J.>..::.l~ ~ "_r..s, ~L::.ll 0yill .; - LSPI ~1~1
~ ~ ~i :r ~Jl>JI -.} ~i? _,i ~~ JL; 0i - o~l
~~l~"l'l ~ ~ "l' :I..L:S") 499.21 ~~ .}a;l 560.21 :-1959 ,~} (1)
,382 ,367 .21J ( .!!.J~ ')' Jt l)_,.>i ~ .:,~ .:,i ~ .~l:~J 0-" '-:?i ...L..P
J~l) 1774 ~ /J_,.L:i 6 -i ~1; _)! cr..J~Y. ~ ~~.....) ..!..LIJSJ ,522
(283.21 :o_4;
..:.,~ ~~ )2.;1 .4........i....JI •.;l.!..ll .~1 ,(The rights of Man) «.JL..;)'i J_,.A.>» (2)
:-1959) 1777 ._,....)... /)~T 12 •"-;_r-11 ..:.,)L..I_,..JI 4-) .)! dl...J ~ ~1__,..;
.(7-6 :24 :o_4; J~l) 1777 y,L. /)~11 J J'.§ Jyl..> J!J ,(473.23

60
i* ..!1J-.4J 4~Y.i oJ~ 4~.r.-"l ~ !)i !)y:. 0-" 4~ JA.:..-o ..;1~
~..!ll~ i~ ~t;;i ..) ~~~ ..~.....A; ~)J 4J..,a.ill
(John Stuart ~ ~)~ !)y:-;- ~ y:JU.. .}Lh:_r. <.>~ ~J _rsi !)l
- -(Few words on Non- ((j.>J.::JI i...~,s. JJ>" ~ ~l..J.S>> dlA...o .j Mill)
d 24 - 111 .21 :[1859 4..:-L.•,'f ~I] 1981 _ 1965 Intervention)
U:WI .jJ 4J>- :_r c;~ J.:-.o c:'l--4 ~L; ~ .024-118 LP~
.((~r._r.lI)) '":'"'_,.....!J~ ~ Lo ~ ~ J )::;>.I <.>_r.5JI ~I_r.:llI <.>_,A.lI 4~ J
..? t+>IJ) r>> !)i o-45 ~_,klr."l 0-" e_,:..JI ~ 4o,;IJ~ ~J
4~ ~ 4~ !)~ ..!l.l-.4J - ((~ 0-" 4..ll>- ..) ~..J.Aj ly~
,((u-"4'1 ~ 0-" ~~ ~)~)) ~ ~..J ((~ ~)) ~)~ i.>..:-:
- .<•)~,)JI Jl.r.JIJ ~~~ ~ --./' Jzo ~ ~ .;JI 6.1!...11 0-"J
~l ~ ~ ~J Lo ._;.-. ~i ~ ~ 4<-Sy>-i ~..; 0-" ~J
.;_;, ~~ ~~~~ OJY JW~ i~ ~ly:-:lJI ~~ ~II <.>~
4Q,j..),s.~ ~~ c;...~,s.lAS '-:-'l_ra-11 0-" !)~ J)) ~ ~ 44:-::>J 4~~
.oh j>-..dl i...~,s. ~l;-J ~ Jzo i..U.-' . (('-?i)~J '-?y.....JI r..ll~ 'l
~_rJI Jl J_y.ll 0-" ~ Lo ~ <.>..ll ~ ~ l~iJ> Jzo J~ 4'~l)
~ ~r-JI !)~ 4~1 ~,; 0-" ~l_r.jl .)s- ~~~,; ~ !)~ ~J..ll
!)l ~l .((Wb Ji ~ ~? !)~ J 4~~~1 ~ .:r._r:-T '-?~~i ~
~i y ((~ ~L....._;..-ll -)L,._;... ~i ~ !)_,s:.l ...~..:>-} )~'))
~ d~U .((~? ~ ~i 0-" )J.,..>.1J '":'"'l.......aJI ~1_,.... .j ~.r.))
~ ~ 4--v ~~ ~)~ ~l ~ ~'-:?" Lo ~ !)~ Lo~)) 4~
J~ !)i ~_rJI ~ j;IA>JJ ~J~ ~J f~ ~ ~ ' ~~
~L:Ji .j ~J f~ oh J_,.k:::J ~1 t._.,__.AJI !)~ d.~~ ~lAb 0-"
.((~w1 o~~ ~r-- J::l JL!..ll cl.45:ll

61
. . • I· :i I. ~: < .WI t i:i • ~ ~ ...;i .....i.....aJ I • L,
~~ ~ --e--' Sr.-' • .r.: y . . . . t.r-'" U u
~I}IJ J>.-1~ ~ ~ 44.JI.r.J .rJ- (..J;.ji ..W. ~I :/' ~li~ ~?
J.>- ~ ~ ~i LS 4~fl oh.) ~l_r.:lJI ~.)_,!.)1 c:' UJ~
.~1 iJW .krs ~.j OJ; il::-9 Jt illa.:JI ..; ~ ..!.JJ.J..>. .k~
4~t _n. ..w. ~~ ~ ~ 4JL>..; 4~1 :~ J_,A: dl~ di oW.iJ
4d I_r.:lll .r.)- ~f I j.;:>..lll J l;;,; i:i.J.s.l..--.1 ~I~I ~_,.A-)I j>-...G 0~
~.J . (( t,;J~ ~J 4t,;J~ y')>.tJ 4t,;J~ ~)) 4~ •.::..JJ~ ~
4~y>-t ~y-:5 ~l_r.::-1 c;_,; Jt 4~~r. dl ~Y' ~~ cy-~ d~ ~
j>-...G '-:?t ~JL=-..1 ~1~1 ~ d~~» ~~~I~~ ~_r.l
~ ~ J.l.k.: ~ i.Jl-P ~t .:r ct.)~J 4~~~~ OJY ~i.) ~i. . .
0~ ~lAJI ~ ~ ~.rJI c.) ~~ ._;JI '-:"'~I j5:.l ~J_,A.ll J~~l». . .
. ((~ J;lb..JI .)s- i:iJ~I,;
J..L:......5Ji O~JJt ..w ~~ ~I~IJ ')li...; _,!5fl ~.r."11 ~)I ~tJ
~ ..W. ~~~ 4(Pacificus Papers) ((4J~4JI JIJJfi» ~ ~...L:.s- 0*~
CJ_,!..LJ ~I d- (Thomas Jefferson) (JJ-""'.H.- U""LA_,.; ~G o~l
.Gt ~I ~ 0~~ C):> ...L!J .~l~..ill ~k.JI ~_r.J....a.j'J ~_;.11
:(60.15 :1987 - 1961) _f- LS rJ-JI _;_r.:-4fl ......UrJI
~ ~ '-:?.lJI y:::jl .y ~ 0i ~ ~t i?U ~~
~_r=-i ~~ ~~~J ljr." (j~ ~- ~~? J.S_;; ZJiJ
J__,.k ,._i ~ ~I cJ.,H-WI ~·~1 d! o.J.s.L...-...ll i..u; 0i
o_y~ i..u.; 0i ~i '-:?·~ ~ ~ ~J 4 y....._..w r..~
.((oJ.f.liJ ~~~ ull ~
~ 4~~~ (.J)~ 4(Abraham Lincoln) .)~ il.Air.i ~J iJLSJ
o...ls-L-JI yU. lS_r.:-4i .)1 4(Lajos Kossuh) ..!Jr--~ U""..H~ J_,...,.,J
4.:....... ,._i ~.J~I oJ_,!.lJ L-:JI e-iJ w~ ~J)I J.>...L::..ll ..W. ~.r."11
~JJ 4(116 - 115 .2 :1955 - 1953) u-J~ ~ ..LU .1848

62
'":"'~~~ :_r- ~I :ro ~)I~ .~i ~I ..::..I)__,.AJI :r" ~~
..;j~~)) J.H ~ ..;.111 w w_, Q.ji -~_, ~J-"_,s:J ~~ --.?~~
~ ~~ '} 0i b~ ~1_, j-4 0~ •j>-J.:..II i.LJ o~y.JI ~..r;:-4tl
'":"'.r:--')) <J.H JW.i) :ro ~)1 ~ _ <<~.u-L...o _,i o~ ..::..IJ} iY
.«1? ~ e'5:; ~ ~ -U:JI lh ~w ~..IZ
Jy> ~1~1 L ..::.>__,.; .;JI o~l :J~~ J.A....::.j_, ~.r. oJ_,...aJI ~
~I ~_;:JI J.Sj1 ~I ~yi.ll- ~l_r.:-Lll ~L....U ~)I ~yi.ll
~ ~~ '1 l_?lJI 0_,:-YlA J~i ~J ..!ll~ C:-' -~.J~I ~.J~
oh o~ •cr.~L-..11 ~~1_, OJ~ 4-: (..:u .;JI ~.ill ~I Q,jJI~
..::..L.JJ+Q~_u c;_r...-JI ~~)) •«JIJ..WI>> ~L:S ~ Ju LS .0t ~yi.ll
~r..J .«J~)I J")l>.i ~_,.:; ~~ ~ oJWI C.-'J>> 0t_, ,«~
:(23 :2001) 0*l.,.
4.kUI 6.Ak~ ~ ~?.-' o~ 6.Ak~ o_,_;ll ~ ~~))
.~.J~ ~~_,~ ~ o-4.u- '":"'-'? ~.1:-j r-li ~~~ _,i
~~I lS , ~t I ~ JJLJI i L2.:..11 y. ..!ll~ ~~ ..lAj
r-li ~0lk.LJI t........._,; _,i ~IJt~ ~I ~ ~ j-4
o-4~ _)IJ>" tl!...t I :..r" -4..uJI ~ •o)..~...:..1 t.-'J i..>.A.J
.«~~!.11_, J_,tl ~
~ J-:..11 lh ~ _;si_, ..l.!.i ..::..~ (Rousseau) J-"JJ i-1.9 J...il
~I ~Jl..!..::..ll ~JS:JI ~~~JJI .,.~J.::.....,I .r-"JJ ~~~ ..W .~WI
0bi .1.9_, •~ -4x.::..ll_, ~.;JI ~l_r.;lll ..:;..I.....)~I ~ ~ J~
j-4 4i ~ ~ 0.S cr..WI cr.-4..L!...ll .JI.UI '-:-'1?'11_, o_,._AJI J-"JJ
~ l_r.:-LlI _ t..J 4--:JI ~b_rill ~I ~_,.J~1_, ~~'}I ~.::.:JI
~~I_; ~ ~ l_?.lll ..,r_,)1 ~_,..!-:11 lh 0i J-"JJ ~j ..lAj .~..WI

63
.Jl~.?~~ -~'11 ~)I o~L:-J~ ~l>JI ~..WI ~l:-JI ~.)a.:.ll C::'
oh 0i ~ w .t.-.J 0J~ :.r ~~r~1 _r.si YJ...u1 JJL>'1 ~
~ o • l.t - - ~ - •<i ~L -L..::.~ :W ...lll ~ l-::.11 ~Lii')UI. J.r '+'.r-> !..J.r ..r-' • c- .J u. - •
..Lo...LJI l> .t .·C-It o..LJ..>...ll ~~ "J.11 ~ ~ 0 c. · d~ 6...;• ..y~ • . ~ • . . . ~J U ·
Jii ~ r-1 ~...I.>JI ~J~I JJ...lll 0~ ~~~)'~ cll~ 0-'" ~i ~JJ ~~J
~L.,.J~I :.r" or..l.4 4-LU "-:"'_r- ~ • ~ _r.si ~LS ~ • ~
.(l)~J.AJI ~J~I
0-!.JJI ~_;JI Jl_,!.1 ~ 0-" ~~~I)I J~l ~JJ fo ~i J.AJ
- 350 .237-26 .10: 1967 (Robespierre) _r••• :.JJ o~~ l.,_.:..h.i
..r-JI ((o_,..>'1l) ~~~~ :yl.r.-:-1 d- u.;~ ~~~~ o~)'J :_r (367
.o~ <<'-:"'~A)) L~ J~ ,y ~J ·4...;~~ ((;l_ ..:.z,;ll)) 4-~
~~ oh ~l5 ...l.O • -WI w~i 1;'fl 'I I q .•tL ;_,; u...- 0-: - r..r '-!"' ~ tr-' . J J
l:.AJ ·-.r'l>JI ~J~ WJ ~WI ..}._,-; .Jl ~ ~~J~ _rs-i o-4~1
. .. ~ .. l
l...u. ~ (.$-M (.$1 .)~ . <<._r;'1 ~rJI)) J ~~I ~ 0.:...JI J.lkl
- -
~~~~ _ ~y,:-o'11 (.J)~ ~ ~lj LA ~.JJ -.f._,A...JI -f1~...lll C._,.Ja.ll
Jlj Lo (.$..!...4 l.?i .)G ~~i <<~...Lij)) _r.si ~J~ ~J ~J • .!U ':>l:
-1959-} lici.,L..')lll J_,..... Jy '-:"'.k.:.ll 1.4 (Social Contract) 11if~~l ..IA..JI» (1)
903.3 : ...__.;_; J~~ .,? .~~~)~ )~::. u_r....)) !179.3-178.3 :1995
1 ..L.,a.....)l _) , II~..L:.lr.JI ~_,.s;:-JI JJ>" ,;..>!).~Ill 848.4 : ~ J..L.,a.....)l _) : IIJ.:..-1»
_) ,11J~ ~J.ill '-:"'~ ~l..lll i')L)I U_r....l..r' ..;_,.A.la.:.i.ll 1014.3 -1013.3 :~
_) II~I..Lll i')UI JJ>" ':?1 11 588-587 ,584 ,574-568 ,564.3 :...__,;,; 1..L.,a.....ll
11~~~1 4..WI .y ..Ll_y '-:"'.rJI 4..l>ll W....l ~I 595.3-593.3 :~ 1..L,a...JI
612.3-601.3 :~ 1~1 _) ,(11'-:"'_rJI 4..l>»-! c::.s. ...J__,...; .o1 _,...!.:... _r.? ;;1 .1...!,)
'-:"'.rJill !614.3 :~ 1 ..L.,a.....ll _; .3 ~)I ·C~ ~) 11'-:"'__.,.JI JJ>" ..:;.,l1.l..!.ll
cJL!.)fl ~ .1904.3-1899.3 :~ 1~1.) ,;;1~ _r.? ;;1.1...!,) 11'-:"'.rJI ~1.>-J
~ ~I:JI ~I J~ .)1 ~I .lj[cd ...J.,LN <f ~ ~_,.. 0 .)[..:!J.l5
.17.13 ,«~I_,A.ll (.J)l :~JJJ11 ~~I ~JJJtl r-"11

64
~l:..i:....':J ~~.:J ~l;.r.")'IJ 4(1
)~~.ill dJ..u.JI ~.L,a::.lJ ~lAJ':JI
ts~~4 ~~ d ..~.::.i~J ;;JyJI J..oi :r ~~ ..:.;,;~':1J 4~1
.} - ~~liJ ~JJ :y JS ~.5' !.5-M ~i _)LJ ~.i.)lr,::ill ~~JJI
Jl~11 i_,.....i.} _Ji 4(~_J 4v-5')•A_J 4~ p ~) Jl~11 ~i
~ _)tA::.;I _)ly:-:-1 y~ -si ~ ~J.1~ - <J:-45YJ ~*lA p ~)... .. .. ..
~ ,j ~ ~II o.i.A ~ ..::...ilS ~;;.r"'UI ~~~...UI ~_r-..11 ;;~
JL.a..ii ~ ?- ~l!..ll ~y-i1 ..:;I_-_._; ..) S_r.4i ..) )~ -s..UI _}Li:..ll
~.J 0(2
)~~..ill lAr..~J oJ_,!.l4 -~IJ..LJI ~~~;J ~_,.....~
~ ':J o~~ ~~J ~j tl!.....1 oh ..::...i.5' 1~1 L. ,j ~ ~i y~
oJ_rjl il:AJ _,.;_,.:.)4 -s".>WI ..:.;~ ~ y~ oJ~ ..!il~J 4~
:y ~~ ~~ lAJ~ W 4_;');>.11 lA~ Ji ~~~J ~yAJI
~~~ 0-s__.>-i ~li :y 4JI~i :yJ 4~li :y ~j..L.oiJ 4J ~~I
.;JIJ .1792 ~_;, /_;I!JI :.r..P 19J 15 ,j ..1..4A:...JI ~_,A.ll r-'~1 .;.;I)}~~ (1)
;...)11 .J1 ~Lis ..:..:..~s-1 .jliJ '~? ~ ,j ~.r.. 0 ~ ~~~ o..!.&-L....ll ..:..:..ls-1
¥J iiiJ...-11 J1 ~rJI if .J~ J1 .J~.r.. ..r"l>...!.1'-:?1 «J..l.&-11 .S J-L..::.... ~_,A.ll
.«r-+""" .J_,.il.;..;;; :.r.,.lll ~J1 ~ Jt- ~ljl:;:..oiJ ~.r."11 ~wi ~ w~l ,_;
0(61.15-59015 : 1987-1961) .J_A-4-l ~L:.ll «~.)4-1111 JIJJJI J ...?.i'J .)JJ W'
L..P~ ,(1794) ((CJL::.:S'.r."J11 .J_,:.l.:..~ ~ ):2.;1 ,~l..,.;UJI •-4- )r ...?r ~1 :y (2)
,(1795 _r.ly. /j~ «CamilluS)) ( ..;':j..4.. :_r ~JJI .r.:J~IJ ,JJJI ~I~~~
-1961 - (1793 _r.J~ /j_rJ) _;l!.ll (~.)4-1 JIJJ11 «PacificUS)) ( ~ :r ")..;...;
-493 ,489018-479018 19016-12016 678-669 ,61.15-5501~ :1987
: 1984) .r..l.::! /.ji!JI 0ylS 3 "->-J~I .;.;Jr- il,:JJ _)j.J_,_..H.- ~L...r. .J).i o501
.JlS l;?JJI t___.....JI ~II :~~~ ~ ~l.r-11 ~ J~ ~ ,(1006-1003
r+""' .hi...J ,wb...JI JIS:...!, :y ~ '-:?1 CJJ.) :y ~.WI :y -4..WI ...SY' d~.JJ..,......
J..il ooo.,r>T ~ '-:?1 ~ .J1 ~ L.S -4...:..:;,.l .......!.1 ..:.U~ .)J.j1 t..;1J 0~4r.JI ~
~ ._;J} ~L. ':1 ~J ,~1 •-4- ~1-4-!JI ~ .k~ l:?..U .)}1 _r-1..!... .;:..;);;
0..5:.1 ':.r..? L;lSJ ·~I_,.,..J i.) ~ JS ~ ~ yli -~ L.,..l) ':1 .Ji ~ ,/J11
0 ((ir.JI ~ y. ~ J..a-!1 ~WI

65 ~ u - · ; .t:.·. U:.l • JJI .l.,.aj ..::..W')t>i.,--- ~...) .J,r- . ~ .)'!. •
'~JWI ~IJ ~~~~~ ~W4 I~Jr.J -~~~ oJ.fJI ~ :_r
OJJ_rA-)1 ~J _ ((~.l.>.JI ~I~..Uill J t$y-tt>~l ~I~
d~_r>'lll.J ·~1~1 ~ ~ o~ t_jl:..::..LI ~L.; _ ((LA_r...L..a.1ll
.~)JI oJ_,!JI t: ..l:St; j5:: lh ~ ~J ,((~_rS:llllJ
1:.-;G _;s'1 4JJ~I (Immanuel Kant) .k;LS j:y~l p ._; ~
4.u~4 ~_rL .k;LS 0LS ..W ·~..l:-o ~y ~ dJ~J , t_!;JI lh j>J
·~)JI oJ_;.LJ ~} ~~~ 0LS '-?..UI .k;LS u>JJ .4.u_,::.....JJI Ji ~I~JJI
~I dJ..UJ .4.A.;LJI ~lr,::ll r--.JJ ~~4 ~W 1:,;6 Q.jl~ ..::.J_,JI ._; 0LS
.~~J ~~~JJI ~~~ w...!.;:5"1 o~~)f .k;LS
~WI wl II LS:..;)U •1 "JL>i ·- o~~l .k.;lS · ..uJ- _r:-:;-'-' J e:: J -.r ~ . ~
.~_rjl ~J ,~JL>bUI ~J .4..:>-~1 ~~__..ill ~~IJ oi.J~~
~ .k_rs l..A.r.~.J ~~ L..A.L:...u 01~ oi.Jl-JIJ ~~~~ ~rJLj
·J~'1 .jJA.JI _;UJI ~_r:JI -.} ¢s" 0fo .;JI ~L.;)fl ~~~
0 .<:'. 0i ...w ".>U , - - t<' • · ~ "LUI •-11 lh 0 <' -Y"'- . ~ ~ '-:?' Cj.r--' Y"'- ~J
t: ~ J-91__,.:.; ~1~1 4JJ...UI 0~ ,4.J).i~J ·~JWI ol,?)fl :,r ~~~
, ~i o)..o..,JJJ .~')6:.'1 ..::..~_r:JI ~ ~i LA ~ ~·~ , ~~'1
C:_r.;.JLS • ~')l>.JU -4..l.!JI 4-ol_r>-1 ~ :,r ,~ly:-:-l.JI 4..lJ...UI ~ ~i
t$J.JrP y. W ~_,.;WI ~1,?)11 ~L...~ :,r o-4..W. 4.J~ ~ 0i •._;I..UI
~ ~J ·("-"")-~~ji.J ~1_,.....11 :,ri (./' ~ -~~~ ~JWI ~_rJI ~~
-~_,A..JI ~IJ 4,;l4!JI .?~-.}~I J~'1 i..l.i::JI .:;..J ~~ 0i
.~1 __;~·~I .l>JI-.} .,_Ji:.j .;JI 4.)1_r.:lJI 4.JJJJI ~J o..lly '-?..UIJ
..::..L....J~I 0~ ~ 0i '-:- l6·1 _;JL>'1 i..u:JI lh 0i ~
~~i -JI..UI ~_r:.ll 0~ ~ •4.)J.;-J4 .jl::.:J.r.--_,5 J~ 4.)1~1
~ i~ 0i -4 ~J ·~~ ..::...~ :r ~ J~ 0i J -4 ~ -~

r
·~
t-
.!:-
·((..
ff..
1:
1....
~
=0
cr"
cr"(1)
~
~-
1.
~
f,....,
*.....,
.._:·c.....c:·~Lc..e.:cf'fe.:c.·.((.,e'to·t·k-..-~·k.!;",fc.··--=>
1Psh.",..t1.1...~.t~1...(/v•1...lr.'11[-1...~
~
t:·:~•~~r..~..((.,tt:.;.(/~.~-t.1·,t
~.r,.L-.~trc.""-~-s-~·~""f::t::t''-l~-t;_ttL.'(>'l't_·(;L'..
t_•(;;_r'~~1=~:~...·.2:r..·c1~-.-;'c:•1·-~.[~~·~·-.t.[_l·t.~·!;1...-·tf'c.r..,t•~t:
·(·~._:--:·~[~c£l.Et:·::~.[·~·r·~-:·&:
~[.t~·}l[~·f·-1:~~1_1[;;·~,t•{'bF:~l:.~~e:-·(l..~··~...,~...rc....:.-r.·[r.."'~~c_
·~-~__,.f~·~'1.~.,.e~...·t··~..t-'ilr
[;;-f.~::Vf·_:_i1~y~~.·~.·(·C:!_•.(.~-:~tL'-.1..,~~•(/..!lh•-tc;7(.!/f.';l.,.'t_,[1r--
.c..."L.~'C•'I·L~l.e:-:-1_·(/...P).s:-.~.c:·,.1.!.•.LE·r.:ir;f·ft~(;::l.,,..",.t---~t;!-•~
~.~[~·~.:-..·c[:.~c·~¥.L~~~~·~-:.{...e·~.c.·.:e:··.
~•••1-l'f.-~v~e.'ln:~-··!_.•1f.:!.-'¢·(t~
•0•rc.·.-~·r-1t._:_:rf.~:t.[_l:•t:'1[~~·~·_[~~hOSt•-'~•~'i.~(_•~cr-S-1_.,(_•S
-~~__,._:.~~E1~!lr-·-·t.'!:::~:.r·c·'l1..:
~'r.~·o•~~.f·~-·~i'~~-~~.c'.~··~··[1~·~~·t
F.
~.F·~·+.~.F,.~t~~,...--·~.~,..~~~~~-..~~,..t...L'L..ec
.r..~)•·t:c¥~~t-~1~t-~[1:1~bf;t:
o•b"I...s(/..1...f::..'r_~.'foLSG~·V'-..,~·L1...L~
f~.'k:~-~~-1·.{~tc·1f.1_c·~~-:·,..L[
~'L.-[~Lt•f...-~-1.t-t•c.·r,C.·-o~.e.:_•(o•1...•t.•t'~,(.~·"''•-""1...~1.;·~~
f."~f·~~t"[l~si~.¥~£J·_.i·~'[1~~I~

67
c~'1 1.:u. ~~ ~~u_, ;;t;;.·..JI r--"11 J.P_,.;..; WL-.9 011_,
~ oyk.AJI ~-ll>- ~ ~-' .. 9').>..i ~r. J_,..UI ~_,JI ;;-~ '':?J~
~Y- '_, d ..A>~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ':?i ~ ' •~ J_,..UI ~l.a..AJI
..(tb~ ~? ...r- ~y> J5 01,.9 •~l4JI ~ _,i) ~-.b~ ~ ~y> ~
Lo •~L!...;)' iw _rs1I J_,..UI J-1-.6..;.; ~ cll.l$' ~yc-:, ' J WI ~_,
~ WL>- Q.j~ (6 ..349 : 1902) ..k.;LS' J_,A..__, .. ((~11 ~)) ,..k.;LS' ~
~1_,......) ~ ~ ~ 4....oi ':?i o~IJ!)) 01,.9 , -.,r'.u.:..ll !Ji~l I~ t_.J.r-Ji
!J4;..;tSll _ ((oJ~ ~ :r- ~_rUl) ~i ~-' •(((j...UJI _,i J_,..il~
((J~~ .;:? ~~~)) 0_,s:.; ~~ •!Ji_rJI lh .Y.)o J .._U; _ ((~~ ..:;...i.AAL.u
...W. ...~..>_,::Ji ~1_,_, ~ ~ ~...lQ;:JI J_,..Lll 0~ ~ 4f-' ..J_,..Lll ~
).JI l ~<"i ~ li o -:.lL., 1 --~ •• 0i 11 ·-'" 1~1 ,i.e:- ~• ~ ..r- i I..S'· _,...,... • 'T" f.:!U r ~ u ~ -'
~LWI ~ ~J11 ~ ~ -?.u1 r G.J~ ~1r.-;:-1 ~Jaj 01 ~1
.;JI_, ·~I il.oi 4-J_,_;...-..JI ~): .. -11 ~~I Loi_, .. LAl,a·;;.,! J...-ou__,
~~ ~ •lS~WI JlA~j11_, :y11_, ~I ~_rJ~ ~Lok::AI ~.. ..
•..k.;LS' Cjl::: clL~_, -~ o)a.>- ~r- .)1 ~I ..!...LE y:- ~ oJ~.j .;:?
dJ~I ..:;_,~WI~ o~ ~~'~ -~WI ~l_r.:lll .U')Li ~
' •..!..Ll~ ..k.;LS' i~ •.u')l...i (f ~ ~ -~_, -~~~ ~~
J 0~~_,...Ji ~~~ ~ Q.jf ~-' •~~~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~ Q.jf
:.r ~_,~ ~Y.j ~ iY y.J ~ Jl-..A ~ e::P.Y ~1_, .~.J~I
...!..Ll.l$' ~L..id.r! o~ ~_, J ~rI J~
~_,i ~ 0i oJ~I ((r-"11 ~ll ~ 0i Ja.jLS _r.....u.. I~
Lo- ((~~ ;J_,~ j5J _j..l.JI J_,:......Lll 0~ 0i)) :Jl::.ll ((~~~ lA~Iyll
c: ~~ ':?J_,:......~ 0yw ~ ~ ~:..; ~~ ,..k.;LS" c~ LS -~
.)1 ~_;;i .k.;LS LAJ~ .;JI ((~11 ~)) 01,.9 cll~_, ...:;...LkL.U ~
~ o~l ~11 .)~~~WI (yLll) ~--U/)11 JW ~ ;__.._L
~ 0i ~y:-_, 0i ~ cll.ls' Ja.jl5 ~ .~~ C"-' ._)WI -=....;_,JI
J_,:....~ J c;_,AJ~ J>-..l.:.llll ,((~..Lll r-LJ~ ~l>JI ~..li. ~_,...)) _,i -~1

68
((J~Ls. d- ~~~)) ~_,..Lll ..!11.; ~ r-1 ~ - ((~y->-i ~J~ ~ il.la..; _,i
j>-J.:JI 0i _,;. ,.:.ll.U Jaj LS ~ -,?.UI ".?'L...'1 I ~1_, .J_,..UI ~
o_)a..JI ~~ ~1 , ~i ~~ J ')l:.:. 0-" •o~_,....JI __..k>.J ..?r-'- ~I
_(1)~· -II I.·:Lil')l... ~ . ~~~
J r-- ~ • . .J""Pr
~ i~ d14..b4JI ~~ ;;_; ;511 -,?)a:JI ...,...L..11 JaiLS i..Li...J
t..J~I ~.......JI .!ll~ ._; U..W_; •J_,..lll 0ylill ~ ~lr.:z-l ~_,~
~I JLA11 -.::...jLS 01 _,;.~I Jlj-11 ~J .~W1 d1..J~_, ~lr.:lJI
~ ':1 - ~ ~~~ ~~ ~Is. ~~ :_r .A c_rJ - JaiLS tAL>_,i
~ .!ll~_, -~1_, _rs11 JJ-"11 (f ~_,..lll ~) t..JJ ~ _r.S;- ~
JLi t•i .w").:;.i t•11 · II 111 JaiLS ..J~f 01 • •<11 ~~u-'. u ,__r,;::'~ Yr-- t::J
·~y>-i ~'U :..r ~-' _;;!;;- .. II ~_,A.U ~L; .f5i 0jl_,; ~ ~~
,~").:;.i J.9i_, Jloi j-9rl ~WI _)lr.:lJI ~ .:.ll.U ~ Jlj-11 0k!
-,?":}.5 -,?JJ' ~~11 4..1_,.1.11 ~J cL....... W J~l c.U1 Q.j~~ 0LS 01 _,;.
~~ ~ .j LS~i ~JJ--o y- ~~ 0LS -,?.UI •(Henry Clay)
.( 2. 524 : 1961) ((~,?~~or>>~ -~"YJI LS~i .j ~l_r.:ljl
.J.5 ..:ll~ (f ~J d76n ,351-349 ,8 .347- 8.343 :1902 J <<~..U i'")Ll11 (1)
(Metaphysical Principles of Right) <<J.>..ll ~_r.j~l tso:~~ll !386 .381 .368
..L....o...4Jl: ~WI ~_)l:Jll !355-354 .351-350 ,6.344 :~ J~ ~
-8.310 :~ J~ J ((~J ~)i:.ll !~l!lJ ~L.II ~_;.11 <<.jl:::JY.r--_,s::ll
.92-91 ,7.86- 7.85 ;--..ij J~ _j <<.;~~~...WI ~II !8.313

c_C.·..·(/..·l~·.c.cC·"~·Ic.·~·~..t·(•.cc...tI0
&·~.c...c.:r.·~·;:~:Z:<l.'(p,((..-:·r:'f-.t;·t.v·Ct::te:0
.[~'L~·..~·'t.x-.tr.f...~·~E~ft-~·£.Lr.
t....-~"'t:~·.t:E·C-~~~.f.<1,·~t·-·t't...
E.L·C.·-'t:v--~.L""[I-"c;·"---.~
r~r~tF.·t::~.~~-·~.·_T~·~··~I.~[1-£.l~"'.'·C:
l.~rvftt•~c..c-'f"~~-~.ri1:·t
i
~f:~·~.~ttb·~_:....'LIt:·(/..IEF·
b
•,c·Vf•C.·~'.C-"-L.•1:___:!.,.~,_'.C-t....
-'"'-•~"'-1I'L;-•f---
c...r·(/..(..;:-·c...r-·_~.t·[r~~·~~·~·(•(•cc
-EL.C:.:t:;t_[~c.tl.::(:'L-t:'•
·~..f'E~.c:-".~~.pc~·t:.1f---:.[t'.~~~·~<.'t
~~·E'-""'··rc-'·1.El·~f't:.c-rr..~..,..br.~t'f...·~:t,~-l".,::.•t'-.!·~t~---:t~~·~:lJbb·t~"-'t,t·.l-~•~-L-f,t-lt:_t•'&l:se_:o....,....t-1
·t2r..c=·(/..<trcT....c·r:t~.f.·~:~t..l_}·'-:.(;''-·.~·s.-·-~.r.c.:)z~t.~.·)_C·t·~C··~~~·bJ.t·..c:·~·f.rl-~t.~L"ce.:h.-c;:~r~"'l.L"p,nc-••~.r.
·t:f.~·s;-c:t".·~·~·[-~·l~·~:t'[.~·~0'f.~.·~-[:".
•.t-'-•,~1-'q"-.L.
r-['r-.1.r1lt:_['<'~·~r;:f.<-·'-'L.""'!;;~f.t
;.·~.~:r;··~)c.·.~·.f:~.f._:_;t_-vc.:r~··"'-·l~·tt~·~·(·~
'lA~"..r,.~~..t-E"':~t·~~-:·brG.<tf-~~t.--:)·
E::~~·-~"..~r-r:.~{ltry.[..~•1::.:v~c_-,......ss;t~;~,~$tsG"--
g•"---.~.~•tl•f[,_'I•~I.,.-~~II~{~~.~f·.t~•..f.~.~~
~l~.:0,"~,;_·~~~f·~L:C11·~_:...<t~.c-t·~'"-.~e:---:[
f
,.l~:v~~[.v~·~~.~·s~.r.c.-~~i·);{?l··tf1·~.·~i·t
~.f'<~"'-·tLv~L~r-'t:.L'!::r::.·t.t'f.·~••~L·~;1~-CVt:."-r•,----t'~-b-~.

70
~ .).>- ~.r.. '-?~ ~L.,a.... J I~ ~~ :..r" d.l.lS l:J. ~ ~J
~ ~ ~J~ & ~ }a>JI 0i ~_,i if.J.: ~~1 Jl~,; .J:J..ill ~
~~I ~ ,.. •• d .;JI W _,:.jl ~W~I ol;A.JI 0i , t:;;~_, ,~ ~L::.ll
~~ Z .}_,; d.lJ..:_, .d..L.::.=--.~I ~ L.;~ I JJl_rJI ,W5:::S , -:...j U t_?~I
t!'_,JI ~ 0LS tll>. oh :.;y->-i •.::..1J~ : ~ ~_;,..; .!.J_,...l>....l ~
:r ~ ~1_,.; lSJ~ uP~i J.! :r ~ _;.lA.:.ll ~lj ~~ d"j..>.11. .
~ -rJI ~")..>.11 ts~~l ~ J_,.:> J>lA.:...ll ~ ~J .~4JI ')IS
.~1_, .r.f- ofii_, _ ~ ~I f; t_?.UI J:Llll ~ JJ> JJ_, ,~
~ ~JJ _ ~_rJI J~~ Lo~ _r:-T I~ Jl_rll JJ> J>lA:.ll 1>.4
<<
1
, ;;·.,II ~}Jill ~..::5' ...j (Jurgan Habermas) V""Lor.~ ,y.JY. ..;..')lot;
_,.;L:JI ~ .!.J...L:>- t_?.UI iLA..i~l ~ ~ 01 _ (Divided West) (2006)
:y ~~ ~.Jl; ...::..>~ :y ~ t_?.UI :Jl_rJI ~r-J I~ ~~ W
4....J~I ~11 ~ ~b c:--'_,.:;J ~ls:JI t_J~ ~_r> ~ 0_,~
o..tSi ~ y!Si 4.5~ yJL>.i ...::..>~ ~b 0l Jyill ~_,r_, .~1~1
dl~ ~i) ~i_, V"" Li ~b d~_, - V"" ~.r.U. J!.A ...::..> 4~ ~L>.....,.,i
~~ ..L;:S'G ~-' .J3 f I ili}I :y r f I ~ _,~ ..- _r.S'i w t_..A...aJI
~_,JI ,_j c~ , Jl_rJI ,_j ~_r-JI J_,.:> J>li:..ll ~~ :.r ~l:JI _,_,~
~II JW ....A..~.>- ...j J..a.>- t_?.UI t_..L.aJI ~ t_?.UI ~ ~~)1_,
.~1 .;.WI J>- (_,;l:..ll)
0i ~ .;JI ~l_,..lll JJ> ..l:5G ~ •o~ 0~ ~l:,JI 0i _d-
. ::: ,
..;...I_,.....,":JI ~ -~~ .:rJ .1~ ._i....~l iLA..i~l dl~ J~ i'YU
:.y..~ ~y><-lI ...j ._;.;!5 Iyo.1Z .:y..UI ~~yz-liJ ~.;z4f I ~ o}_;...JI
Jl •o~l t""11 c~IJl 0~..J J_,..lll 0yWI if 0yJIJ.: ~i ~i
dl _,.-.11 ...j 4JL.i>-~- L.;_} 4...,ol>_, ,;....J..ill ~JJJi ~ i_,.lJI t!'-'
~11 JW ~ o~ 0i ~ t_?.UI C~l wJJ J"j..>.11 iy.JI
:.y..~ ,1~ .:y..UI 0y.JWI 0~JJJfl ~~ •-s__.>-i ~lj if'-' .(_,;l:..ll)
·~ 0_,~ :_r r-L-JI_, 'J~I_, J..-.11 Jl..~..:s-~1 0~ ~i r ~ ,;;i

~.'f·({;t·'_·1,~·t:~~·.qc-~·1:~.~~~~t'I~
:tf:~~~rlt:~~1
·V~1
~.~.~'L1:~~~'t
•("(•~~~~T~'~-:{r:E1:lr(•~i::f.g'1I'11_:_
v.G1:::.f~.I-~1.~~,t•-(•Et.-~~CL
E.'v-·L.~·{1t~.(.r:-~~~~~··C:.:J':;,~~·-
-1...cv-~[1...'Ll.'1.·~t-•I-t~•<h
(•{'r~1..•,-'--•~~!__~~~.~~I'f:1==''t..
1
~:~~
.f.r~..~.~~·rt-:t1t.r~·1~1:::.~•~·t~·1=
~-f.·C:.t~f:·t'-.ct'~.V':'-,r:;",.r.~"-f~1·t:
t;·~...r.~·-:~~~~·~·~-·~.:r~r.·t:·-.~-:'t__['[~.
·C'-:·,totfr,~•'L;tt----..~~~:·~.r.:.1•£)_•t,•-II-b
(.r~Le:r,r-t..r(r•t•'t..~C1...(•LiLo•P•'t-I
~~:10~·1·~~~~c-.r.~•t~~.t•~~·~~·r.~_:_~~'}•
~.f.~rc.~..•t;~~c~c""~··f·t:)~~~c_~-~·vt:.L~~··t:·{,.~'..ct..-..·t.""Lyr+
·E··~~-;;[l·~f..1;~1:~·~.f.'(,-'i:t;.f-·~:,.c,;!.~-·C~
tlt·!;;·'f-t~C:fi.!'i:~~~t~~·"..,::<~t."--~~·~
~~·cco-<.-;~•v"'ll-c~··.·f..f.·~(•f---..~~~r)·'LItS1I~~~IIE~~
~-E·f-~~rr·.~~~~"ft~f.~~~l;-0.~.~.s~"
I.f.b.rc-""~~•rrC{;;Oc;;r'l·,c.~tc_~·t.~·<hf;~·:~h•c.·s;-·~~·tc..·t;,.~.c.:...t;·~!=-h~·:~·~.~~c.'
.f:.i·(~;~...'·-~:t.r.t:·rrr·-·t:--r1t('i~...·[~-~·C:
I~1•(f·~I1...r..,.'1.,•I1);·[~..c';t.-"._-toe_sss't·•1...••-1...1...1...1...---I-ItI--1....L-

12
._;L;:J_,_JI ~W~I 0-" -sy>-i ~1~iJ "~I__..S) J!-o j-S'loi ~ c.4--:JI
~l..!...il _}l J>-..dl l.h oJ ..:..o~i ...l..iJ .4--A-i ~JJ ..!.U~ ,_} l....: "~U
~ oJ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~_,.>:>JI r.? ..:..o~ ..J.A ~~ ~
..:..ou");j _j t,.,WI ~.MJI ..:..o~~I r J "Jl~l _j.MJI ~
o~~ ~_,.ill -l::-ll J~~l CJJ~ :y C.')l.,.,)'l ~i :y .k.;._,a.; • ..:..o~J
).JI~ ..:..olo~
~ ~ ~i "oJ~L; ..:..o~l>- _j "~l.r.;-Lll ..:..olo_,.>:>JI J~ •(~-i
~i .).A ~i <-;J? ..j ~~ )? ~ 0~~ ~ ~y ~JJ
" ~ o~~J oJ~~ jjNJ o~L.JI oh ~ ~- .;k_,.ll J~
oGL-.ll J ~~ ~ Jk>l CJJ~ :_ro "4-:Js- ~ Ji ~l...; CJi ~J
-~r.:JI
Jl '-1'; ~I.::.:>JI ._;J.oG CJi ~ -sy>i o.r ~..l.!..:J~ 4.ll.WI oh ~i
f.. ~ ~ ~
.~Wl ..:..ol..!.lZJ ..:..oJ.ol_j o)!::......l Jl '-I'; ~I LS ·i_r.; 01 ~ "c.fo 01
CJi ~ -s.i.ll ~4...Lll ~I ~ y J ~L:>-l yo -s~ ._)..J..Jt> CJl.. .. .. .. ..
• I LiS J o...l>- I,.. 6..Jl...> I<' I Uli:J l:. ·'I L..11 .~ ro . . ..? ~ u- ~..r--' ...r r Y-
l:.:::r- ~L!.)' ~ ~ ~ .;JI ~~ ~ _j ~~ ..:..o4J.>..:ll
G~ .wi ~ i.::>~1 _j ~...~..!.:;.. ~JiJ -~ t_u...LlJ ~lr.;:lJI ~I~...Lll
l.h o~L.....::......I CJiJ ,!J~ ~")l>.'1 ..:.......L..i ~ -s.UI y ~
- - -
~ ~~ ~ .~ ~ r.:--:S ~ ~ CJi ~ ._rL..'1
(J~ .;__...Pl.>- ~li..!. 4..").>. :y ~ -s.i.ll !J~I ._rL....'1 ,~'1
- -
.~iJ JJ lS "~J) ~l-.4; (f ~ "y:k>JIJ

75
~.wJt ~~~..Jt ~tj.l ~.l ;.l~1
a.lj..lltj
J>-b ~L. ~~_,.... '_rP WI ~_,JI ,..; '_;..WI C::Q -"!"'-~I ~
}J ,~.!.ll ~WI ~.rJI -.::...t .;JI ~_;..JI ~ -~J.>.J ~I ~rJI
-~~~ u~_r.JI_, -~~L...:ci'l'l ~I~ J/YI ik..ll -.i 0~~1
Lo c.rJ ~_,~ ._j dl~_, ·~)JI L>.M.ll ~ ~.Jl:JI &1 uiJLoJ
._; , ~-' .o~..l>...4 01~ ._; o~~y _r.? _,i o~~y 4...:11~..lll ~LS 1~1
(
1
)...Jl.!.::SI LA· · - ~I ~..lll Ll .J... 0 ··-.·'I ~~i •u' · • .-11 4....1.J....r..ruJ - .F-.. J . ~ - - - .
~.>.:.WI~ 0i ~r-LJ ~ Q.ji ~~)I~-' ._;.411 ~I ~i
u~l ~ ~~ ~ eJ6.12Ql ~ ._;.411 C::Q-~~1 u~~l
. (
2
)ww1 s~ J.,; Lo u>J_, ,t~_,JJI L>_,;..-. ~ Lo o~~~~ ~.Jl:dl
:.~ ,~l:-JI i_,.LJI.} ..:..>'Y~I ~.} JWI y. W' ,..,;) «.._jl..!..::51 o:.~pl ..::..1; (1)
J.:.:...- ~ ):..;1 .~LJI ~I 4--..G.::...I .rJI FIJ J~'ll 0-" r.s .)! W..:l lh
1941 iJ_,j 1980 ~~L. 1942 .JL.~ 1973 ..G) 1959 _,.....J~J_,s JWI
.1964 _,::JIJ 1963 »
..:..>~1 •-4-J .JlS I~!L. J_» ~ J_,A: 'Y ~ ?..Lz.... --4l-o Jl::l4 y ~~I lh (2)

76
~~~ ~_,k.JIJ 4..>-_,:.WI :i_ .. _t;·-11 ;;~I ~~ y. _;..WI c"·~lll 0i 'l
ijLJ ,(.I..,JJI if ~~~J •.jl~ ~>LO~ jjJI ~ 9?. ~.J ·~_r.1
.(221 :1999 J..j~b) <<ts'~~ J_,......,'1 :_ro ~J-• ~ ..,i 0_,.;W~
~u':>WI ~ 4..........1.., ~~ _;w1 c...:'!"<-~1 J--=..: •(..$y->i ~~Jl:--o-:J
&J~I ~..l.ji :_r -~~L4::..ll.., -~~IJ ·~)I .r,?.J ~)I ~~II
~~~ _r:? ~~~ ~ o~>l~l ~Lil> (.r.J .~1 ~~~~ ~
.<1
)(2001 _;4~J j~JJ~l ·J.} ~24 :2003 0_,;)S:.il ~2000 ~_r.:)
~L..t.~11 .)l ._;J.....JI ~~ ~~1 i~11 lh ~ ~~.J
:y ~~ ~ JUi .~WI :i.!.AJI ~ .~1 ~WI .!.>1-l>i.J ~I
<<~I~JJI c~l)) ~L:S' L;,_,...a.:>-.., ._;..WI~~ J_,:>- ;;~1)1 JwJI
•(1993) (Robert Putnam) il;;Y. ~yU) (Making Democracy Work)
)_r-::.....~ 0Y'-!. -:r..Lll ~~II ?~IJ ~>l...LJI (.;-" 6...-~ il...:;_.,;l
j.J_r. ~lj .~ ..::...;_,JI .j.J .oJ..:~I e::_~WI.., ~~ ~ t_")lk':>U
~W.l ·~_r..!..1 ~4-.i ~J"' J _;..WI ~ ~L.....j.AJ _;..WI ~l_r--11
~i 0-" •L:?r~' ~~.., -4~1 Jl_r.:lll ~ ~~~ il...;_.,.1 .)l
~WI ~>~i ~ J ~L:..lJ Ll;:--)1 t_~ Jl ~~ _;..WI ~I
.(2000 •j).JJS.J l:?I.Jy.Ji ~ 1999 •j).JJ.5)
c"·'?"~' ~ "vP_ra.>J' ~.., ~ ~ ~j.r-JI .)l ~~ Loi
~ ~J ·~ ilkl--' ·~l~..ill ~L...i L];~J 1~_}.4 _;..WI
JL..t.) <<~1~':>J ~ _;w1 c·-'?""-~' ~ 0.S ...w)) .1>1..,...... ..l> ~
~l.:JI "-:ki~..Ll4 41-:J h C>l lh C>U :r C>i ~ 'l ..L.:.!.ll ~ JI.J..Ai
~~4 ~r:JI lh ~ J_,L;... ~I ,J _}ll:..A> oJL!.'il J~J ... J.>. Jl 1)..!.>-
."-::JI.dJI_, "-:kl~..ill ~~t........ ~ ..::..~Y. ~ ~I ..::..~1_, ..::..l.....1.:......1 ~
lh ~ , IJ..!..> ._;..WI ~ o~l JU~I Jy-- ~I e:!'-' .)1 UW'i4J
.~_,...:.~ ~~? oyAU; y. L. .j ._;Ill -?1)1 :.r 1~ lj..U ~~~
.~l:SJI lh .j 0~ ~ -?lll ~~ if ~~1 ~ ~~ ~ (1)

Benamor.belgacemهل الديمقراطية قابلة للتصدير ؟

Benamor.belgacemهل الديمقراطية قابلة للتصدير ؟

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (20)

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (20)

More from benamor belgacem

More from benamor belgacem (20)

Benamor.belgacemهل الديمقراطية قابلة للتصدير ؟