Successfully reported this slideshow.

Lokpal

1,001 views

Published on

Published in: Education, Technology, Business
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Lokpal

  1. 1. LOKPAL BILL Vs. JAN LOKPAL BILL: COMBATING CORRUPTION & MAL-ADMINISTRATION & FILLING A VACUUM<br />Presented By <br />Avishek Raj<br />LL.M. (H.R.)<br />IIIrd Semester<br />Seminar Paper –IV<br />Group – A<br />Date – 15.09.11 <br />
  2. 2. CONCEPT OF OMBUDSMAN (LOKPAL)<br />Meaning<br />Origin & Development<br /> Sweden - 1809<br /> Denmark – 1953<br /> New Zealand – 1962<br /> Norway – 1963<br /> England – 1966<br /> Australia – 1976<br />iii) Essential Features of Ombudsman<br />
  3. 3. INDIAN PANORAMA<br />The ARC initiative of Lokpal<br />Different & Chronological Versions of Lokpal Bill<br /> I The Lokpal Bill 1968<br /> II The Lokpal Bill 1971<br /> III The Lokpal Bill 1977<br /> IV The Lokpal Bill 1985<br /> V The Lokpal Bill 1989<br /> VI The Lokpal Bill 1996<br /> VII The Lokpal Bill 1998<br /> VIII The Lokpal Bill 2001<br />
  4. 4. CAMPAIGN FOR THE JAN LOKPAL BILL<br />
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7. DRAFT LOKPAL BILL, 2011 Vs. THE JAN LOKPAL BILL, 2011<br />[A] DRAFT LOKPAL BILL, 2011 :-<br />i) What is Lokpal Bill<br /> ii) Scheme of the Bill<br /> iii) Salient Features of the Bill<br />[B] JAN LOKPAL BILL, 2011 :-<br />i) What is Jan Lokpal Bill<br /> ii) Scheme of the Bill<br /> iii) Salient Features of the Bill<br />
  8. 8. GOVT.’S LOKPAL BILL Vs. JAN LOKPAL BILL: A COMPARATIVE CHART<br />Prime Minister<br />Judiciary <br />Conduct of MPs<br />Lower Bureaucracy<br />CBI<br />Whistleblower Protection <br />NGOs<br />Removal of Lokpal Member & Chair <br />Investigatory Power<br />
  9. 9. SUPPORT & CRITICISM OF THE JAN LOKPAL BILL<br /><ul><li>CRITICISM :-</li></ul> Naïve approach<br /> Extra Constitutional<br /> Criticism from NCPRI & Arundhati Roy<br /><ul><li> SUPPORT :-</li></li></ul><li>CONCLUSION & SUGGESTIONS<br />Single Institution as opposed to Multiple Agencies<br />Inclusion of The Prime Minister<br />Judiciary <br />Inclusion of CBI<br />The Principles of Federal Polity enshrined in the Constitution should not be affected by the Lokpal Bill<br />Bill should be consistent with Art. 105 <br />Bugging of telephones should not be there<br />
  10. 10. THANK YOU<br />

×