SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 24
The Duty to Preserve and Spoliation Presented by: Anthony M. Rainone, Esq. October 26, 2011
The Duty to Preserve: What is it? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Triggering the Duty to Preserve ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Triggering the Duty to Preserve ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Limits on the Duty to Preserve ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Spoliation: a refresher ,[object Object],[object Object]
Forms of Spoliation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Counsel’s Obligation ,[object Object],[object Object]
Counsel’s Obligation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Spoliation Sanctions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Purpose of the Sanctions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Authority for Sanctions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Dismissal and Suppression ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Dismissal and Suppression ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Spoliation Adverse Inference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Spoliation Adverse Inference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Spoliation Adverse Inference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Spoliation Adverse Inference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Defenses to Spoliation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(2)(B) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Litigation Hold Letter ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Preservation of ESI ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Anthony M. Rainone, Esq. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
DISCLAIMER ,[object Object]

More Related Content

What's hot

Family Law Injunctions - AMSM
Family Law Injunctions - AMSMFamily Law Injunctions - AMSM
Family Law Injunctions - AMSMAzan Marwah
 
Procedural Issues in Bad Faith Litigation
Procedural Issues in Bad Faith LitigationProcedural Issues in Bad Faith Litigation
Procedural Issues in Bad Faith LitigationRachel Hamilton
 
Law-Exchange.co.uk Powerpoint
Law-Exchange.co.uk PowerpointLaw-Exchange.co.uk Powerpoint
Law-Exchange.co.uk Powerpointlawexchange.co.uk
 
Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013
Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013
Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013Patton Boggs LLP
 
16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar
16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar
16th Annual Professional Responsibility SeminarKegler Brown Hill + Ritter
 
NY Disclaimers and Late Notice
NY Disclaimers and Late NoticeNY Disclaimers and Late Notice
NY Disclaimers and Late NoticeDano0403
 
ACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' Fees
ACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' FeesACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' Fees
ACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' FeesBoyarMiller
 
Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009
Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009
Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009morsemh
 
Stephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 march
Stephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 marchStephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 march
Stephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 marchStephen Ware
 
John gellene talk lou jones breakfast materials
John gellene talk lou jones breakfast materialsJohn gellene talk lou jones breakfast materials
John gellene talk lou jones breakfast materialsLaser Haas
 
Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z
Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z
Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z Bailey and Wyant PLLC
 
The state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 cover
The state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 coverThe state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 cover
The state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 coverAdam Leitman Bailey, P.C.
 
Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...
Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...
Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...Financial Poise
 
2012 presentation dpw liens
2012 presentation dpw liens2012 presentation dpw liens
2012 presentation dpw liensJoe Chapman
 
Premise liability memo
Premise liability memoPremise liability memo
Premise liability memoMichael Currie
 

What's hot (20)

Family Law Injunctions - AMSM
Family Law Injunctions - AMSMFamily Law Injunctions - AMSM
Family Law Injunctions - AMSM
 
Reicon14 session 3 final ppt
Reicon14 session 3 final pptReicon14 session 3 final ppt
Reicon14 session 3 final ppt
 
Procedural Issues in Bad Faith Litigation
Procedural Issues in Bad Faith LitigationProcedural Issues in Bad Faith Litigation
Procedural Issues in Bad Faith Litigation
 
R2R Meeting 19 pdf
R2R Meeting 19 pdfR2R Meeting 19 pdf
R2R Meeting 19 pdf
 
Law-Exchange.co.uk Powerpoint
Law-Exchange.co.uk PowerpointLaw-Exchange.co.uk Powerpoint
Law-Exchange.co.uk Powerpoint
 
Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013
Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013
Reinsurance Newsletter ~ June 2013
 
16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar
16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar
16th Annual Professional Responsibility Seminar
 
NY Disclaimers and Late Notice
NY Disclaimers and Late NoticeNY Disclaimers and Late Notice
NY Disclaimers and Late Notice
 
ACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' Fees
ACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' FeesACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' Fees
ACC 2013 - Spoliation Claims & Maximizing Attorneys' Fees
 
Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009
Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009
Morse IPO Slides Joint Defense Of Ip Litigation November 2009
 
Stephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 march
Stephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 marchStephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 march
Stephen ware arbitration agreements in bankruptcy 2018 march
 
John gellene talk lou jones breakfast materials
John gellene talk lou jones breakfast materialsJohn gellene talk lou jones breakfast materials
John gellene talk lou jones breakfast materials
 
Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z
Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z
Seminar Handout for Construction Defect Litigation: from A to Z
 
The state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 cover
The state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 coverThe state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 cover
The state of foreclosures in 2012 & 2013 cover
 
Bad Faith Nov2013 covenant judgments
Bad Faith Nov2013 covenant judgments Bad Faith Nov2013 covenant judgments
Bad Faith Nov2013 covenant judgments
 
The state of foreclosure law in 2012 final
The state of foreclosure law in 2012 finalThe state of foreclosure law in 2012 final
The state of foreclosure law in 2012 final
 
Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...
Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...
Valuing Real Estate Assets (Series: Ethical Issues in Real Estate-Based Bankr...
 
2012 presentation dpw liens
2012 presentation dpw liens2012 presentation dpw liens
2012 presentation dpw liens
 
Settlements
SettlementsSettlements
Settlements
 
Premise liability memo
Premise liability memoPremise liability memo
Premise liability memo
 

Similar to The Duty to Preserve and Spoliation

Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First CenturyWoodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Centuryjohn Kelly
 
Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel (S Cohen 04 14 11)
Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel   (S  Cohen 04 14 11)Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel   (S  Cohen 04 14 11)
Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel (S Cohen 04 14 11)scohen69
 
BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...
BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...
BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...BoyarMiller
 
Waiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During Discovery
Waiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During DiscoveryWaiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During Discovery
Waiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During DiscoveryAndrew N. Plasz
 
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search WarrantsResponding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search WarrantsNexsen Pruet
 
Chapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdf
Chapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdfChapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdf
Chapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdfstudywriters
 
Admissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges the i
Admissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges  the iAdmissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges  the i
Admissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges the imalar17
 
SAVE-VAWA-Restraining-Orders
SAVE-VAWA-Restraining-OrdersSAVE-VAWA-Restraining-Orders
SAVE-VAWA-Restraining-OrdersL. Gabriel Womack
 
cle Rules of Evidence CRI037
cle Rules of Evidence CRI037cle Rules of Evidence CRI037
cle Rules of Evidence CRI037Missy Cruz
 
Litigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slides
Litigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slidesLitigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slides
Litigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slidesDowney Law Group LLC
 
Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court
Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court
Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court David Butts Law Firm
 
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Brendan Kenny
 
Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...
Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...
Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...Terrell Patillo
 
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New RulesEnsuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rulesrlhicksjr
 
Date and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docx
Date and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docxDate and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docx
Date and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docxedwardmarivel
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizurerlhicksjr
 

Similar to The Duty to Preserve and Spoliation (20)

Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First CenturyWoodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
Woodshedding in theTwenty-First Century
 
Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel (S Cohen 04 14 11)
Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel   (S  Cohen 04 14 11)Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel   (S  Cohen 04 14 11)
Negotiation Ethics For In House Counsel (S Cohen 04 14 11)
 
BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...
BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...
BoyarMiller – Navigating Your Company through Spoliation Claims and Strategie...
 
Waiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During Discovery
Waiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During DiscoveryWaiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During Discovery
Waiver of Privilege for Documents Inadvertently Disclosed During Discovery
 
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search WarrantsResponding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
Responding to Grand Jury: Subpoenas & Search Warrants
 
LAWN666 Family Law.docx
LAWN666 Family Law.docxLAWN666 Family Law.docx
LAWN666 Family Law.docx
 
Chapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdf
Chapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdfChapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdf
Chapter 5 Changes In The Culture Of Divorce Divorce.pdf
 
Ethics For Florida Probate Lawyers
Ethics For Florida Probate LawyersEthics For Florida Probate Lawyers
Ethics For Florida Probate Lawyers
 
Daniel day
Daniel dayDaniel day
Daniel day
 
Admissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges the i
Admissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges  the iAdmissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges  the i
Admissibility of fruits of breached evidentiary privileges the i
 
SAVE-VAWA-Restraining-Orders
SAVE-VAWA-Restraining-OrdersSAVE-VAWA-Restraining-Orders
SAVE-VAWA-Restraining-Orders
 
cle Rules of Evidence CRI037
cle Rules of Evidence CRI037cle Rules of Evidence CRI037
cle Rules of Evidence CRI037
 
Legal Transcription - Difficult Words and Terms
Legal Transcription - Difficult Words and TermsLegal Transcription - Difficult Words and Terms
Legal Transcription - Difficult Words and Terms
 
Litigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slides
Litigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slidesLitigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slides
Litigation ethics 5-29-2018 - slides
 
Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court
Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court
Short v. Short Case - Mississippi Supreme Court
 
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
Mastering E-Discovery Presentation (partial)
 
Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...
Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...
Trinity Kings World Leadership discovers how (former attorney) Milton Raiford...
 
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New RulesEnsuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
Ensuring Your E-Discovery Procedures Comply With The New Rules
 
Date and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docx
Date and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docxDate and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docx
Date and Time Wednesday, February 27, 2019 53200 PM ESTJob .docx
 
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And SeizureLaws Governing E Data And Seizure
Laws Governing E Data And Seizure
 

The Duty to Preserve and Spoliation

  • 1. The Duty to Preserve and Spoliation Presented by: Anthony M. Rainone, Esq. October 26, 2011
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.