Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

решение вс

1,508 views

Published on

Решение Верховного суда

Published in: Law
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

решение вс

  1. 1. BE3>xoBI}L1171 cyzi POCCI/ II/ ICKOI/ I IIJEJIEPAIII/ II/ I Ileno N2 AKTII/ I15-679 P E III E H II E HMEHEM rocclmcxon oE1u-IPAIIMM r. Mocxna 13 anrycra 201 S r. Bepxonuuii Cyn Poccniicxoii Qenepaunn 3 cocrase cynm Bepxoauoro Cyna Poccnficxofi tbenepamm I/ Iaancmco 10.1‘. vp npu cexpempe Honaraenoii K. A. c yIIac'meM npoxypopa Crenanonoii J1.E. , npencmnwnenefi zaanmenefi Ilannoaa PI. IO. , Cmupuoaa E. E._. Cyxnx ILI-1., npencraameneii aarmrepecoaanuono Jmna Enm-1oi«'1 H. B., Crpyqxosofi E. A.. IO B , Bomcoaa 10.11., Tepeuuconuqa C. B., 1 ~ ~ ' u cyne6aoM aacenamm anmmmcrpamnuoe neno no N ' llleunca Bnauumupoama o npuauannu Heneiicrayromxm ‘A 1 Yxasa Hpesmzexrra Poccuiicicofi tbeztepawvm 273 «O Bueceaun nsuenemm 3 nepcqem. caenennfi, mioii rafine, y-rsepxaxénnmfi Yxaaom l'Ipe3w1eH'ra 30 Hoafips 1995 1'. N2 1203», no aasmnenmo Ba6qem<o Boponona Bnazmmnpa Bnammnposuqa, Ilaaunoaoii . , Kauunma Hanna 10psemma, Kapnyxa Pycnaua _ Tmaypa Bnammnponuua, Ilaanona I/ Ina: -la 10pLenmia, H : = Illnocfiepra Hana Mapxonma o npnsnaaaa . --n : cnenennii, omecénnux x rocynapcrsenaofi 1 Ilpesnneirm Poccuiicxoii cbenepauun -2 or 30 30:61»: 1995 r. N2 1203, . -.1: aaxononarenscrna Poccnficxofi <Poccnficxoi! raaere», y-raepxnea . .;_= v i wanna (nanee - Hepeqenn).
  2. 2. "V yi<a30.1 flpc3n,1em'a Poccuiicxofi tliencpalum or lb‘ Man 2013 1; _x, -._, 3-, } (’, l;, _1¢¢ — : ,.':13 N9 273)‘ on},6_, mKOBaH, .u, ._,1 28 Man 2015 :1 na <<. Od)u11nzunm<m 1mTCpllC1‘-f10pTa. ’l€ npaaoaofi nmliopmaumi >> WP3 ‘ ~' W'l. pru 0.1._10' . m, l mom: 2015 r. 3 Coépamm aaxonogiarenbcraa Poccimcxofi (I>cJ¢P311iin. N. » 2:_ CT. 3206. B nCpC‘l€Hb BHBCCHH H3.l€H€HH$1. flonnyninow l nymcra l Yxaza . -V9 373 nym<T l0 Tlepetmn M3.'lO)l’CH 3 Hogofi p€. Tl2lKLIHH. corstacno Koropofi K roc_v:1apcTBcHHoi”1 Taiine omeccmn CBC, '1C1lilH. pacicpmaaroiune norepn . 'lH'-lH0l‘0 cocraaa B Boeimoe sperms, B MHpHOc BpC. /[$1 3 nepuozi nP0B€£1eHmi cneuna.1i. m,ix onepannfi. n0.'1H0.l0‘lH5lMH no pacnopmnemno TaKIiMH caeziemumn Ha, r1eneno Mmmcrcpcrao o6opom. i Pocciificxoii <De;1epauim. Bocrpmcoa fl. B. 06p£1THI1C5l B Bepxoanbifi Cyn Poccm”xci<on (DCll€p3lll‘lH ac 3aHBJ1CilH€M o npmuamm Hcneiicrsyioumm ilonnynma I nyuma l Yxaza N2 27-. xoropblfi. no em MHCHIHO. imeer npaaosyio Heonpeaenénnocrb H uapyu1aeT npana n CBOGOIILI qenoaexca. rapaimiposanmnc CT8Tb5l. lH l. 33. 47 33I’0H3 P°°°‘“‘C*‘°“ (Denepaunn or 27 : [eKa6p$l I991 r. .l’2 3124-l «O cpencraax Maccoaofi nH¢>op. 1auHn». nporuaopcrnn CTaTbR. l 5. 6. 7 3a1<oHa Pocciificxofi (De.1epauIm or 31 moan I993 r. N9 5485-] «O rocyzxapcmennoii Taiinc». crarbsm 30 H 56 KOHCTHT_"LIHH Pocciificxofi (Dcncpauim. B o6ocHoBaHne caocro Tpe6oBaHm1 3asmmem. yi<a3zu. tno zaxonom npe;1_vcMorpeH 3ai<pz. m.n“x nepeqem, cec,1eHm-"1. cocranrmioumx l‘OC_'£1apC1‘B€HH)'"lO fanny. B HEM orcyrcmyior caenemm 0 I10'l‘L3p$lX nwmoro cocraaa B Mnpnoe spew: B nepnon nposenenim Cfleuliallbllblx onepaiiim. BROHCHKO A. A.. Boponoa B. B.. flaasuloaa C. B.. Kamnrmi H. lO. . Kapnyi-c P. .lI. . Oneacxnfi T. B.. Harmon I/ I.IO. . Flacbxo l‘. M.. UJJIOCGCPI‘ fl. ;l. ofiparunucb 3 Bepxoanbifi Cyxi Poccimcxofi <De11epauim c 38SlB. 'I€HHC. 1 o npmnaimn neneficmyiomnm nymrra 10 Hepeqim B penaxuun Yxaza N9 273. cimmx. um on uapymaer nx npano Ha cao6o;1Hi.1Fi noncx. I10.-'1y‘{cH1l€ H pacnpocrpaneime nnq)opMaulrm, He cooraercmyer -{acm l cmrbn 8. ‘IZICTSIM l n 2 CTaTbH 9. qacm 1 cm-H, " [0 cpenepansnoro 3ai<oHa or 27 mom: 3006 r. N9 l~l9-(D3 «O6 ; m(popMaum, _ umpopmaunounblx T6XHO. l'l0l‘H51X H o 3au1HTe HH<bop. :iaunn». ‘laCT$l. ‘l I n 2 CTaTbH 5. nymcry l crarbu 8 (DCIICPEUWBHOFO zaxoua or 3 dieapami 2009 r. N9 g_q)3 «O6 o6eCneqemm flocryna K nmpopmaumi o Il€5l'1"6.T1bI{0CTH roc}= ;1apc1‘gcHHw. ; Mecmoro camoynpaanemm». '~{aCTH 3 CTaTbH -l. c'raTz. sm S. 0, 7_ o raHo3HOPT3“°3 , P 21 moan 1993 r, No 54354 9 3aKoHa Poccniicxofi <D€l1€Pa11H" 0T " e , crane 47 33x0 2 . ~ «O rocYl13Pm-Beflflofi NTa: i|H7‘ll «O cpencraax Macs: Foccmicmn (henepauun o , _ _ - OT 27 11eKa6pg 1991 r. - 19 txacm 4 CTaTbl[ia(w‘I19"H¢)OpMamm»‘ 3 mm‘-6 ~ -' . Hacm 3 CTBTLH is txacm I c'ra'n. n np0THB°P°"'m « 0;; (benepauflfl. I'Io MHCHIHO aasns “ KoHc. m,-yuan PoCCH"°" “T051611. ocnapiiaaembiii Mansuoii on KT Hapymaer npnnuun (bop pe;1e.1eHnocTn H CO31.1aé1“ V “Y” yronoanoii OTBCTCTBCHHOCTH aaimy OTC
  3. 3. Onpc,1c.1L’I_IH€M Bepxormoro Cyzla PoccniicKoii me‘ _ , _: _~ monn 30!) r. 3.'I. lllHHCTp£lTHBHblC nena no LIBHHHM ’5a}1B. 'lCHH$llVl oaL; .]. :pMA“" W, nposizaoncrao 11.151 coauccmoro paccM0'rpcuHH H pa3p4.'ulcHmL I mum" MnHncrePC'1‘B0 OOOPOHH Poccni’1cKoi"i tbcaepaumi lMHHO60p0HbI Po¢c, ,,, ) Hm-ligoxioqeiiiioc flpC£1CTaB. 'U1’I'b nmepecm l1pe3n,1cma PoccniicKoi”1 <penem, mH '_ : ;., .””~[cpCCOBaHH0l'0 Jnua no qcny. 3 nncbuennux Bo3pa>KeHmax Ha '; a;1H.1cHHn '-}(33£l. 'lO. Hm ll_'Hl(T l0 flepcqna a pc;1aKuHH Yxaza N9 2'73 ll3,'1aH r. '1aBoi'1 r'0'~‘)'¥l“P°TB“ B ”P°11°~"?1«‘< HpenocTaBneHHi, ix euy no: iHoMoLim"i. '3aK()H0.Z1aTe.1bC1B Poccimcxofi Cbezlepaunn He npornsopcnm. npaaa H c13o6onbi 3asn3mc:1ei"1 “3p}'1llaCT. Ba6*ieHKo A. A.. Boponoa B. B., KaHblI'HH fl. lO. . n3Beu1'éHH1.ic o Bpe. lL: HH n were cy:1e6Horo pa36npzrrem, cTsa Ha: i.ae>Kau1H. i ofipaaou. B cy;1e6Hoe 3aCe.1aHHc HC snannncb. npxmuu Hexmm He coo6u1imH. BblCJIyHJaB 06'b$lCIl¢Hll5l 3amm1‘e: iefi Bocrpuxoaa 1.1.B. . Ilasbinoaofi CB. Kapnyxa P. .H. . Oncacxoro T. B.. Haanoiaa I/1.10.. llacbxo F. M.. LU:1oc6cpra I1.M. l1PL’»'lCTaBHTe. '1Cfi 3asu3HTenei“i flamioaa 11.10.. C! IHpHOBa E. E. H Cyxnx 11.H. . 3o3pa>KeHHa npe11cTaHi»m: .*1ci”x zamncpccoaanuoro miua F.1HH07i “B-- C'rp_vHKoBoi"i E. A.. Bcpeaima lO. B.. Bonxosa lO. l1.. Tepc111Koawia C. B.. npoiaepim ocnapmaaemoe Hopmammioe nono>KeHne Ha coonaercraue HOp. laTHBHbl. I npasosbm aK1‘au. imeioumm 6onb1n_wo iopnmmecxyio cnny. 3ac.1_vu1aB 3aK_1ioucHne npoicypopa FeHepa. n1.Hoi"x npoxyparypbx Poccm”icKoi“1 Cbcnepauim CrcnaHoaoi"i J1.E. . nonaralauleii I{CO6X0,'IH. lbL( B _V:1OB. T1CTB0p8HHM zasmnennux Tpefionai-nn”1 O'l’K3”£3Tl>. Bepxoamaiii Cyn Poccm“icKoii Ibenepauuu He Haxozun ocHoBamn‘i .132 ynoanersopeuwl aasianenmi. F 0C)’11apCTBCHHa51 normmxa 3 o6.1acTH o6ecne-«emu: 6e3onacHocm $1B. '1}1CTC5l qacrmo BHy'rpeHHe1“4 H BHeumci“x nommncn Poccm"acKm”i (bezlcpgiunn n r1p€, '1L‘TZlB. 'I}1Q'1‘ co6oii COBOKy! II{OCTb cxoopnuunpoaannmx H O61z€£1HH€§HHbIX c;1iuu, i.a 3a. 1b1c.10.1 nonmnqecxnx, Op[‘aHM3al1HOHHblX. C01IHa. 'IbHO-3KOHO. lH'~iCCKHX. aocnubix. npaaoablx, HH([)0pMa11HoHHb1x. CFICIIHELTLHBIX H immx Hep (cTaTb2 -l <Dc,1cpa_1i. noro 3aKoHa or 28 neKa6pa 2010 r. .‘. "2 390—(l>3 «O 6c3onacHocTH>> (.1a.1cc <I)c:1epanbm. xi“1 3aKoH N2 390-(D3). O'momeHH5I, Boaimxaioume B camn c omcccniicm cacnennii K mcygapcraeflflofi Taiifle. HX 3aCeKpC‘{MBaHHCM unit pzicceKpeHm3aHHeM H zauurrofi B pnfrepecax o6ecneqeHHs1 6e'30I1aCHOCTH Pocc:1iicKoi1 tbenepauim. pCFyJlllp)'lOTC; { 3aKoHoM Poccniicxofi ‘DGIICPKIIHH 0T ~l_ Hiorm 1993 r. N. » 5-185-l «O mcynapc-meguqofi raiiue» (nanee —;3aKoH N2 3483-1). 3 cuny a63aua aroporo cTan. n . -. H£13BaHH0l‘0 3aKoHa l‘0Cy11apc1'BeuH; m Tmvma - 310 3aII1Mu1aeMme FOCYIIBPCTBOM 03*‘-"1€HHvfi B 06nac1u ero aoenHoi“i. 3KoHoMwaecKon, pazaenbirsarenmioii. oi’: 3"e"men°n"T"qeCK ' one anmn “ 0- o . , Komppaanenbiaarensuofi R P ‘p _3bIcKHon n<. aTc: n.HocTH. Koropblx M0>KeT H3399“ . ‘/llltpo Gcaonacnocru Poccm‘icKoi”i pacnpocTP3”°“"° ‘De11epau""' r M n HKTa l - Cornacno aosauy cenwo y y cTzm. n 3 3aKoHa N9 5485-1 rocy118P°T 3°" « Kym Tangy cocraamuor csezlemuz B aocuuofi ofisiacm o m, c_10Kau““
  4. 4. N ‘ . . 4 ’ memmux Hanuenonaumrx, o6 opraHH3am4oHHofi crpyicrype, 0 goopymenuu > ficfli 11¢ -mcnenuocffl Boficx H coc-nosmnn nx 6oeaoro ofiecneqenmi. a Tal0I(e o Boeuno. nonnmwecflofi “ (WW1) Ofiepamaaofi o6c1'aH0BKe- Cneneunn, paclcpunaionme norrepn mmnoro cocrana 3 soennoe spew, ,, L I Wpfloe spew: B nepnon npoaenemm cneuuanbnmx onepaunn omocsnca x ‘ _' omeqernloii Kareropnn caenennfi 3 soeimofi o6nac'ru, cocrannsuoumx mcy}1apC'l'BeHHylO rain-ry. _ 0TH€¢eHH€ amx csenemm K rocynap c051“°11°*"“'1 TPe50BaHI-Hi crarefi 6 H 9 3aKoHa N9 5485 RX °TP3°"°3°P'1a Benomcrsennoii mm nporpaMMHo-uene ' flP"H““"°-M" 3aK°HH0c'm, o6ocHo3aHHocm H cnoeBpeMeHHoc'm. Ta"“M °5P3'-’-OM. no cnoemy conep)Ka. HIuo lTyRK'l' 10 n¢P€‘*H" 3 P9113-KW“ Yxaaa N2 273 Hanpannen Ha peannaaumo 1‘pe6o3aHHfi aaxononarenbcma Poccnficxofi Cbenepaunu 0 mcynapc-mennoii ranne, z1e*ranH3npye'r npnnenénnyio 3511115 HOPMY 3aKoHa H my He npomnopevnn. Ocnapnnaemoe HOpMaT‘HB! -loe nono>KeHHe 6u. no yrBep7K11eH0 nP°3“11°“T°M sanuswm 3aKoHa Ha ocnoaaunn POCCKVICKOVI ‘Denepamm a coorsercranu c 1'pe6o epamm or 21 Max 2015 r. I1p€l1C‘l‘aBnemm Hpanmenbcrna Poccnficxofi (Den . N§ 3095n-1'14, Ko1~opoMy npenmecrnoaamx axcnepman oneHKa npoencra yKa3a no emenueu Meaxsenomcraennoii nannomy H H! -[HM Bonpocam, eno ono6peHHc p Komrccvm no sanurre rocynapcraenuoii Tafinu or craeunoifi mime ocynxecnmeno npu -1, To con. 8 COOTBCTCTBHH c son npnHaJ1ne>KHocn. xo H onanu Ha c'ra'n. e 8 Qenepaimnoro 3aKoHa M 390-d>3, ‘ KT8 2 crwrsn 4 3aKoHa N2 5485-I, ycranannnnmomnx, ‘no u tbenepanau pemaer n cootaercrann c aaxoaonarenscrsom nv. - aonpocu, cnxaannue c 06¢Cfle‘lel-{HEM 3aunm. | napcrsennofi Tafinn, y'raep>K11ae'r nepeqeus caenenufi, ennofi raiine. .8 He npornnopetmw a63anaM Bropomy n nsrromy 7 3aKona N2 5485-1. cornacno KOT0pblM He nonneaxa-r '2, -. . : anon mine 11 aacexpermnamvno cnenegug 0 A‘ W" ' " '5 """’°‘P°‘l"”‘» Y1‘P°7K3l0IIu»Ix 6e3onacHoc'm H ’ ~ nocnencmnxx, o cmxnmmx éencranxx ux 1- A GICTBFIFIX. 0 dzanax Hapymemui up“ 14 (£060 “ “ '‘°’“‘‘‘Y "9 coneplxanne He cansano n
  5. 5. nopsuuca. zaxounocm. npun u as ' r 000' 3aHHOCTH. so . . . ., - »‘ O09 3“3r3'3MbIe Ha mm. nccyulm ran_uo en)--, K., ), "Dim-. ;x; m_ H600-‘<0Il| ’lMOCTb Bblnonuemm mm HOCT _ _ "pi‘. '1Il(); I;xI um aBIICHHbl) 38113‘! B ; 'HO()bIX )'L‘.1()m1H_ I I ‘‘~ “ TU pezla ‘, z<u3}m mm 3,r1op0BbK) npu npoxovmcmm C:1y‘, +;6., ,_ Cor:1acHo nymcry I c1~an, n 10. crane II n n_vm<Ty I «. ~mn, u. 1: daeacpanbnoro 3ax<oHa 01 31 Mas] 1996 , —_ N9 (,1-<p3 «O6 060pOHc» B00py; +<L‘um.1u Cum»! POCCHHCKOE tbegepauun — rocy;1apcTBeHHa$! BOCHHEM 0pfaHH’suum«. _ cocrannsuomax ocflogy ofiopoflb, poccmqcxofi (De;1epaIIHH. oxm c0c1’0>n m ueurpanbnmx oprauoa BOBHHOFO ynpaarxemm. 051>€»'1“H€“"“. C0t‘£1“HUHHi"s. ‘ somxcxux = xacTeL"1 H opraumauufi. xoropme axonm B BHIIH H P013 BUNCH Boopyxcénnblx Cm] Poccxmcxofi Cbenepauxm n 3 noficxa. He BX0I15UuHe P BH';1b1Vn pona Boiicx Boopymémlmx Cm Poccnfacxofi <Dc.1cP3””"- ’1’“”“°'” “’”““ Boopyxcéunmx CW1 Poccflficxofi (I)e;1epauHH Bxclioqaer BO€HHOC. 'l); !8lllH. H . mu rpayxnancxoro nepconana (q)e;1cpa_rIbHbL rocy. uapcvmenm. m l‘p3/l, 'la|1LlH. cnywxaluxix u pafiormncos) Boopy‘Ac'c'mn.1x C Mn Poccnncxou <Dc;1€p3l1HH- 0 mm . . v I ‘ ‘ . . 3aceiq3emn3a1me caenemuu. pacxpbmaloumx nmcp" -“”“°'° ;3:”O - . ”-”. HHecB. c omocurcx K ooecncueumo 3au1xm. r rocynapcmcnnon l8"““ Hapyuxennem npaa zasmmencn B n3:xo>xcmuv.1x mm acne11._ax. Cm Hmwom Jloaonm zasuzmenefi o npaaoaou HCOHpC; '1€. .-ICHHOCTII Ho izuumfl Hopuamauoro nonoyxenma BBHJI)’ ucnonbzoaamm B H€. IV: ‘1]C: I‘l5:'! Tj: ’1:1“j“L; :;EE“fi£K‘m V , . . - , - 'oHc, .' c. % ‘ c — Onepal-"‘“”* “”°T"'pw" onpgkmflm mfopbn B 3a: .m, x ‘6C; II1‘I‘r. "lbHb! 1H OHH v DH - ' ' ' (benepaumi OTCYTCTBVOT. He M01"-W 0ibl: )bHEII1(‘))(: )X0,1l(Ibl-' cnocofiwx nparsonoro ocuoaaflbl Ha HX -T1H“1H°-“ "I"-4CmB'"‘”m ‘ ‘ L ~ j 1‘TI C'w0ro perynnposaflna '-ITO He O3H8‘lZ1CT HC38KOHHOCTb H IlCOOOLHOBC1HH((. x . . 3 . ., . u bl E1‘/ K‘HHOC n aaoaoc co, '1cp, m1Hm n m npennflcaflufl, "Memmero “CH0 8 PIKO: -1311115! P o H€0}1H03Ha'~lHOP0 To. . _ Jlonyckalotllero egaflue «cncuflaflbflafl Oncpaupm» ;1Bm! s.‘I‘C$l o6u1c'11oTpcu. 'mcm. m. we - - CHOBOCO 3aKoHo11aTcm, c"rBc Poccm‘icxm”x (Dc:1cpuxum (rI)‘IH<1 *0-1*‘ "cn0‘m’3yeMHM B - - I '11 -1;} [095 r V“ -H)-(D3 ne aofi CTaTbH I 3 q)e, m:pzus. noro aakoua or . .1 pg. » - . . - qacrn p or! cny. ’K6e 6c30“a(_‘H0(_“[‘fl. >)_ ML“AC. 'X_'Hl1p01,lllO! HPJJBL‘ H «O (penepaflw alcrax 3 TOM qncuc pctucnmax Eaponciicxoro Cv;1a no npaxmw . p [X a ' _ P ' Mewlyflapomw omegue or l9;1cxa6pa 2013 r. no may ulloopncsa H . '1pyI‘Hc qenosexa (noflafl P i'c1<os"1 (Dene alum») (Dobriyeva and Others) "P°T"3 °°°”‘ P ‘ 171 one alum omocmcs H KOH1‘pTcppOpIICTHHCCKLUI K tmcny cneuHa. m.Ho H P ’ . . _ ‘ ‘ __ W“ enenne Koropon H nopsmon cc npomrxgmm amen a npan0m. x_ onepaumhonpenmu ocnoaamn npumenemm Boopv>KL‘mn, Ix C 11.1 Poccuiicxoix . bl ‘ Opmflmaufloflfl 60 56c c Teppopmmom co; xep>xa1cn 13 (l>c. ~'1cpa.1bno, 1 'szn<0Hc ¢°’1cpa"'"", ,0%6 r Kr“ 35_(p3 «O npomso, r1ciicTam1 Teppopsmiy». °T6MapTa-mqm; ,M. o6pa3oM cncnycr 0THOC}1TbC$l H K 1o: n<oBaumo C3088 Ammo no e6mIcMoro B OTHOIIICHHH nwmoro cocmaa. xmopoc B «noTcpml)b Iyle gas 3 ocnapuaaemofi pexlaxusm HCll0Jlb’i)’CTCfl 3 cm o6bmH0.I "y*"‘T° P M azmwmoro Tonxonamm. onycxasoulv P nonumaxum. H511
  6. 6. 6 cocTaua CB$I3aHhl c ucaoxmonmocn, ‘$8.131! K0 . *0 £122: Hxpunmm . rmuo. 1 (: mua, ,,, non -— . . U yqemm flseqba um: maoro cocmam m'k’m““< o’}‘‘[1e”“’‘- 1“ “*"°P0m. -.« 9"‘"°‘""e""" C-”. V'>Kc6m. Ix uacr_vn. r1eHvm cuep-m ¢)aKl‘H‘i€CKOI‘0 . !€CTOI-{ax Takax mubo pMaI-IP13 B 33 Bucnmocm or eé K0}! Kpemoro c0,1cp‘A<aHHx a armsan. 3 TP H pacxpmgarb ,0., ,m cacnemxx o mcnoxauuu. r ~ “ v » . JCHCTBH1€. '1bHl. Ix ounou crpwcrxpe. o Boopm»: eHMH qucm. ' ' ' - ‘ Mom" v o6ccneqeHusI. a Taxxv 0 so - 2 . (mm) onepamsnon o6cTanom<e xompme comaamm » emm no. mm= «.~cxm-, H - T rocyga on ‘m1 = ~ . nPe11)’C-IaTpm3an Komnnexcnmi Mexanmvl o6ecneue: mu :0c)'T0TaH“)' Tafiflbl‘ B TOM ‘mcne co . ,V, ~1apq—; ;cuuoi‘a or 1 . - (benepauflfl ¢eflepanbHbm Bercmyxoume noxmomolmsx FIpc,3H, lema Pocclmcx-toil eé 3 (1) qmnnsnofi 3a aaxxouonarem. wen u 06yC. 'IOBJICHHblC mooxo; umocn, ,Q UIHTBI orpanmemm 11:12 . uoc1yna K nmbopmauxm. TM. 8 cooraercnsxm c wacruo I cranu 3 <De,1epa.1bHoro '3a}(()}{a OT 9 ¢¢BPa-VIE 3009 r. N2 8—(D3 «O6 o6ecneqeHHH nocryna K HH¢)opMaum1 o «''1e’‘T°5”>"0CT" 1” 0C)’I18pCTBt‘. HHblX opranoa H oprauoa Mecmoro czmoynpamcmm-v (Ila-"C3 '* ‘D€£lepa.1bHmii 3axoH N2 8418) nocryn K mxqmpmauxm 0 . '1€flTC.1bHOCTH P0C)’J1apcTBeHHb1x oprauon H opranoa MCCTHOFO czmoynpamemm orpammmsacrcn B cnyliaxx, ecmi _vI<a3aHHasI mltbopmauml omecena B ycranomennou rbe:1epa.1bm. m I 3aK°H0M UOPSUIKG K cBe,1cHmm. cocranxlmoxuum rocynapcmcnuyxo mu I-! H)'|0 oxpanxewyio zaxonom Tafmy. ‘lacrmxm 1-2 crzmm 9 (l)e,1epa.1bHoro zaxona 01 37 mom 2006 r. N2 149-(D3 «O6 nHq)op: uamm. untpopxuatxuonnblx TC. ‘(HOJ10l‘lUlX n o mnurrc : mq)op. sauun» (nanee -— (benepansnmfi 3a1<on N2 I49-CD3) npen)~’c. 1o'rpeHo. tno OI‘p'¢1HH‘1€HH€ nocryna K nuqnopmaumx ycrauasnmaaercx q)c;1cpem, n1.1,u1 3:u<oHa. m B uczmx 3aI11Id'I‘bl ocnon xcoacrmyuuounoro cmosa. upascmcnnocm. uoposbsx. npzus n zaxomnarx mnepecon npyrux nuu. oéecneqcumx o6opoum crpanbu n éesonacnocm rocynapcrsa. O55l3aTcJIbHbl. ! ammerca co6.1Io;1cnuc KOH(bH,1CHuH£mbHOC’l‘H uud)op_, {aupm, nocryn K Kompofi orpammeu <. ’pc;1cpa.1bH1.Lm 3aKoHa. m. I'IpasaM H O5$I3aHHOC'l‘XM >x<ypHa. rmcTa. onpc:1c.1L‘11:xm1 B rnanc " 3axoHa Poccuficgofi (De;1epaI_1}/ m o1 27 ,1eKa6px 1991 r. N2 2124-! «O cpcncmax Maccoaofi ; «mq)opMa[[}{; {)) (nanee — 3aKoH N2 2124-I). B TOM mxcnc npany ‘a<ypHa.1ucTa HCK8’I’b. aanpamunarb. nonyqan. H pacnpocrpamm. nmbopmaumo (nyum I qacm nepaoii CTMW 47), Koppecnommpyer 06111112“: npmnum nczxonycmmocm 3.1oynoTpc6.1cmm cao6oz1oii Maccoaoii mId)0PMa11""- _ I/ IM 3 qflcjle IIPOWCTO H6 Il0n)’CK3CTC$i HCl10J'lb3OBaHHC CPCIICTB ‘NHJCCOBOH m, ¢opMamm 3 uenxx cosepmemm yronosuo naxa3ye. u.1x ,1c; mm"L £1.15! " Tannmomux rocynapcnaennyio mu Imyro CI1CuH£UlbH0 ifmy (qacrb nepaaa cranm 4 3a1<oua N2 2124-I). C yqé'r0M roro, ‘no OTHBCCHHC x rocmapcraerauofi Tafmc cacrxcmmv. CO11ep)Kall1HXC$l B nymcre I0 Flepetmx, npomaezieno npC3HL1CHTOM Poccmicxou meflepauw 30 ncnonneuue 'rpe6o3aHHu tbencpammmx zaxonos. npcnycMa. rp"Ba]. Ou1}{x, 3 qacmocm. H He06§0IlH. :blc orpammemm nocrynva K mubopmmmu mm 3a[_1mTbI rocynapcmeuuou Tamm. noaonm 3am3me: xeu 0 oxpanxemyro 3aKOHOM T3
  7. 7. ‘F-r’l“JC'g': .. '. , -. ‘[lv_i. Iu| fi9.'- VIVI1-, "(3_~"u'; : . . ,0}: . , . V 5 . f:hV'_(g); (., _.. V‘ at . “.'10-: .m "+; ‘= " z‘ "'3"-’. ' 9!. ~'3‘l*. ‘N53€l€(6’I‘Hu-, -Saint’-qu‘. ‘}. _‘. l, -'I'I1.'. . ! u]r‘v, .,‘ " " ' §£I'. ¢m: (.', .., .. ‘M’-. '.Ir-ta; ;, ,,, .,m. . : . . H,, ,;. .. .. ‘.,2,¢, ,N ' 2 fn'ml! x:a. :mf. "H. I. _|g, .‘ , -Magi; .2 = “'*= ¢'~'i-’*i~= <"—a: I:(-'5-ais: 2:22.522 'W. “It: -mm: m:N 7 ‘ "'. "’. ?"l}I-, ; . “ i>lIl, '—lu', y o: I'3ll(€-:01!-. ‘:{‘-I: l:(I . ;., ,U, m_. ”. os: tu. nl!1'= °"~!9nI: (aa: m;. "gg: m.; p: 4u: —i(Iou; g;. ~-; Han‘! !‘. "|'-4,-i; v:~‘ mm: un"o ’o(Ns‘1"r: |:}: | (.'. ]‘I)$[UL. oyn1o‘1:1;; u-. ,;. “: _1 WI‘ , ='Il‘ ’. '.‘ : . ' : v- . “, l(‘—§. l1I5l~’; '., ’h I” "WLHW1 ""m"'". "" 9mv‘: u:l‘o: m,; . . gun Wxtafizxax-‘a zm. '. .. _ , V ' 7-7* 3 ’ :1; ‘: g;«_. _;. _o; a. ' Is, o:a; .~. |.A, ,«, A Y u, ~.m-. m:u_m: ._ : ~ ‘I.0)III):1:l.1[. = : «). '(~. ;:(. ‘r. 5(t, ‘.‘(i}| I: :3: IlIJ1l0?<¢"¥3'5“ N! l:I: I:h'o H """“'v""‘1”"”‘-"‘, ""*‘ l 7"*"‘¢Is"-I:1:t~; -. — | .|ll‘ . ~, 2'? ’ . ‘A . _ 5 » AmT; II: o)usc: I:m. ~. . -.. (, '”f'. ‘ ". '“"‘_-"""—". "" "‘-. ‘h| =l! !.<. -If, " t-mums. uh}. ('0)-mw. -r r K '“ ‘‘‘’‘“’‘‘. '1'. P.= .'I'-. 'I| ;>. °1I=9=- 1:- '! ¥')| I~‘. l'- : mw. I»: '4u: m:'um'~‘ ' - «"1: H;9>: m: v . " . -; , . ‘3 "! ’i’“‘. »?u. t,/ .. . mra3)mI: m:r. I:m: '. ' : q:1~. ,m-c: n:s: x,; .;g: o, ; ;- . r.v; >,‘u. .;,4-4,. 0 ‘mm. MI ". "l5,’Vi-“V” H *#¥7'UI. ;‘o I, n(. ‘1.: . l(u: u,m;1= ; ,,. ..; ,.-. -_, ’. -2 , , _ , aul H-1: suit .03" ‘! l,I10II5l‘= 'A. I), o:“—'. '.I’. Ir . ll| V“! _lV(_| )S~'('vl€ : .v, :m~‘u-, ~. . ‘1I= V»; i:~ J-9; snmu 2! ~n‘: ‘ua: 1' . -muu.1;. » J. " u°! =l°~h¢~- ‘mm ’~w~HP. m.<u. ’ 0»-int‘-Lmlm 2. : r— umm->: :+: r :1-: n': ¢_an: <a =1a: o). '( : ""V| §" N‘, .'m. ;p, ''; ~''"’'7‘'u; - ‘. .- . v 7 . '”"”‘ “"“"‘ ”"—‘W"""’- 'W'N'fiI| .-1-2.‘ = , min‘ ‘! .'! .‘-'~. ‘7-Jzmzlzu: I(U! |lW= l£': r= <+: o>2u1s'A: o;w. """‘”“ ""i"“"’7 ‘1*’*= ‘"= »5 "'t'—m‘-I, mIn: s:uxn‘o» : (n: mu'wumn: n:m= ’i : ~'= I.m: »: : l:a, U$t ”P'. .'v": r~''l{‘T’' «-7 {ln): Im: u1;, '1I, mo): I'u). -. ‘H.310 "'02*H'. l'. 'l*l‘. U|'C --. m:u: : u-2»: "~u': m'. ~ : ‘:. ll3(| ‘1,U$l‘~'l| l'. l’:1 ‘A. 'mv. ~!'. I': '(-t: (-i’. "I-M-i‘->: II_Im . :m: u. . - '§gz-‘«: m:(:4:uv: ‘ v'! oV‘: >v. ’~; u‘: ’(~a: u): :'. — 0:‘-. __n(-—go'= :nw. r. _n~: u;A—4:‘n~+: : 21 «-: :w. - . ’ '1:(* :2 -nmu: u:um ~, .,'-mg "u1i: v4'. _I«’lyi: (I)'; ' Hr-mvi-. *=IIH= s -m» : um, -1:¢a)'. " manna: 1 v 2-r: v:: ~s: t:v: m:<m'o In-i, ~IIx, «~i~s'r: vI-mmi -; .‘_. «_ anr<. ,m‘. ,_n: umI_s >5'I, u -mm: n.; .( tug (ion»: iom: ::: +s. u:wn: :u; _n. -.u: ‘u'. I:mu'. ' :1’. uum. um: u)p: u:u: ut 991-M‘-l9r= |II: :(I). '.§' : v=’I: m=' WU II. -2"-‘NV iH: w,m, ,,_. A,‘. A H-‘. _._A ; .‘-_(—. ;;. ;um_~, i‘, f_mu4.'nu; -m (| )VIl'.5:l'-"~l-(| :‘. .‘q‘J1I ~: '.-'-y. ‘ ,1; ”. ‘;, r;-;4{-_ ; . 5,. (.); m;‘;2:u)o: s!: |%I1 fitllivflztv‘-silt! Iiifliilllliim '*S5ZI3'Il-l3|'J'. , 1. : "_: ”;y: M“, ‘ngyj, ,ng; _o‘ ‘; f‘_'j‘ ‘_. _»; »;, m_; u:| sq; q;o)nn uo: o’iu'-. v.aw: -n. '»: uIn V, ,_‘. l_’. ,,; ,,, ,,, _v :1~‘. ,g; (u: a:| n|é'~ gyx . ;'ow. w.Is’w: m’. |Ii+meg_o»: II|1u: | i'—]’IIl5. I' =1” , ,,, .;m‘; ‘g: l(:4:I: (o+: 7.1;mmI. '.I: mo): HI'I: u n-n<o: m:m'. .4 ‘ : .*; ‘v. Kf. _ ; .nu'.1’, M('vl: .4y: "i, L's; ;|‘, L§I. (O)§ (A :1:1*-: w.' ml: :>: !.~, r-«1:I‘-a: I:I£ : II‘«f°‘~"*'*3'*‘ HI‘ _Hl_: |:", ,'» 2.”; -"l. _. V’ . ;¢qVo>: ‘.'»: l4;': L_‘“ _. -;; »:m-, 1| : m:u‘)_o)= . :u: I'. 9‘ - ‘ pmw 354:»-v. I'm'. In: 5ht: !tIH. 'r|5|""‘”""; ' , .. mm: - I " 2 ‘ ‘:9.’ Pr 1 . ‘.'—I a_'"; hunt: : ‘| J.‘f-§5N"~}'-‘n . ‘.v‘| :.'Zl. I- ‘ "' ‘ "‘. ’ 34"1,r"“‘u; ";”; g5|-p: , ERIN 9: H.3--D. Hme: .-n: g.I; <u: v.v'. t= ' . ,.A A}; znzuvrz '“1““'~i"““"" ; ;. ggf; ._ ; .;. ;|; m.; :|: o:. : '.; |o)l! _'1if1‘
  8. 8. ,. ns~. 'a: o:a: m'. ;. _m_, ,w ‘ -"= !‘A: u.. ,. , — -w" = P”'>"" ‘2‘vm: m:' "" n—: _-'-*'. n:t: ‘*°"1"""""“ u. r.2uL: -m: III'. I'. :4‘ 13 '7 ': r.'¢m. '. IN‘-<""“'”“': "-m ou: :+; m:, u.. ; ).'1'. y~_ . ',§. qn, M): I:ln 1 ‘It: ' ¢': fi:: v.nm: y;n: u : '¢| |"’~”'”'""" "mi-4'. I". 'u.5~“)r "2 . . . 2 ‘ ' V’ ' I : 61:01.! 9. ‘mm. ‘ . n(vhHII'. I'. 2 . .. « v, -. u-stilt: "~' L , ._, :”_‘: m,f . .:. :.m'. x~ .1 11'-ié)I‘13): l:li). 1 -"At: szncn-««: m:' 0:-. m‘. ,-. _»; .,, ,,. ' ", :,,2.(-'A: I:I: -01 'l‘; I-j"3i'4"4(. ‘:‘. "'V

×