CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects

1,663 views

Published on

Presentation at the 2nd eScience Network Conference. Juni 12, 2013 at Max Planck Institute for the Physics of Complex Systems, Dresden. See also the Poster: http://de.slideshare.net/anjalorenz/plakat-escience-celepro

Published in: Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
1,663
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
659
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
4
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects

  1. 1. Anja LorenzClusterE-LearningeScience Network ConferenceDresden, 12.06.2013CELeProCollaboration in E-Learning Projects
  2. 2. Science todayProject based, mobile, time-flexible
  3. 3. Collaboration in TeachingWith whom have you worked together in context of teaching?With…of your ownprofessor-shipof your owninstitutionof otherhigher educ.institutionsOutside ofhighereducationnocollabo-ration(visiting)professor55.0%(138)48.2%(121)31.1%(78)19.1%(48)13.1%(33)researchassociate64.9%(163)52.2%(131)24.7%(62)19.5%(49)7.6%(19)undergraduateassistants43.8%(110)27.9%(70)5.6%(14)1.6%(4)25.9%(65)otherpersons8.0%(20)6.8%(17)2.4%(6)22.7 %(57)31.1%(78)No collaboration with any of the given groups:6 persons (2.4%, N=253)16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 3 | 19
  4. 4. Enabled by Tools and ConceptsSocial Software Tools, E-Learning 2.0, SocialLearning, Communities of Practice, …
  5. 5. Objective of CELePro16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 6 | 19
  6. 6. Method: Online SurveyClicks to Survey: 824Started: 543 (65.9%)Compled: 253 (30.7% resp. 48.1%)16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 7 | 19
  7. 7. 16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 8 | 19
  8. 8. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationThe typical lecturer at a higher education institution in Saxony
  9. 9. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationDemographics (N=253)• Male (71.1%) Female 26.5%, No answer 2.4%• 37 years old median (average: 38.55), range: 25–76• University (70.8%)• Diploma (37.5%)• Engineer (42.1%)n= 252• Research Associate with regular teachingtasks (36.8%)University of Applied Sciences 25.3%,School of arts 3.6%, Other 0.4%PhD 31.2%, Habilitation 14.6%,Master 4.3%, Bachelor 1.6% …Chair 27.7%, Research Associate withsporadic teaching tasks 17.8% …16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 10 | 19
  10. 10. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationCollaboration in Teaching: Information Management ActivitiesActivity % nSharing documents 64.0 162Creating and editing text 53.8 138Sharing links & sources 39.1 99Managing metadata 24.5 6216.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 11 | 19
  11. 11. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationCollaboration in Teaching: Communication ActivitiesActivity % nChatting (1:1) 52.2 132Group notification (1:m) 44.7 113Group communication (n:m) 34.8 88Automatic notification 29.2 74Giving feedback 19.4 4916.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 12 | 19
  12. 12. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationCollaboration in Teaching: Relationship Management ActivitiesActivity % nManaging his own user profile 34.4 87Managing contacts 34.0 8616.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 13 | 19
  13. 13. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationUsage of Social Software Tools for Teaching (N=253)ToolPerma-nently oftenSome-timesveryseldom neverdo notknowthat toolSocialNetworks2.8% 4.3% 6.3% 9.9% 75.5% 1.2%Wikis 4.7% 10.7% 16.2% 19.8% 44.3% 4.3%Weblogs 1.2% 2.0% 6.7% 8.7% 76.3% 5.1%Micro-blogging0.4% 1.2% 2.4% 6.7% 84.6% 4.7%MediaSharing0.4% 6.3% 14.6% 17.8% 58.9% 2.0%SocialBookmarking0.0% 1.2% 2.4% 5.1% 72.3% 19.0%16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 14 | 19
  14. 14. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationUsage of Social Software Tools for Teaching (N=253)Never!(44.3% Wikis – 84.6% Microblogging)From comments:eMail, OPAL, telephone, personal contact16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 15 | 19
  15. 15. Some further resultsPoster• What social softwaretools are used bycollaborativeactivity?• Which collaborativeactivities areperformed withinteaching tasks?Data Report (in July)16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 16 | 19
  16. 16. ConclusionsCollaboration inteaching takes place… but not by means ofSocial Software Tools!
  17. 17. Further research?Case Study ≈ Show Case:Periodic repetition of the survey?
  18. 18. Thank you!Remarks? Questions?“It might also bequestioned whethercooperation andsocial media isperhaps attributed ahigher potentialthan they actuallyhave… “(GMW 13 Reviewer,11.06.2013)16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 19 | 19
  19. 19. ReferencesDIN EN ISO/IEC 19796-1 (2009). Informationstechnik – Lernen, Ausbilden undWeiterbilden – Qualitätsmanagement, -sicherung und -metriken – Teil 1:Allgemeiner Ansatz (ISO/IEC 19796-1:2005); Deutsche Fassung EN ISO/IEC 19796-1:2009. Deutsches Institut für Normung e. V. Berlin: Beuth.DIN PAS 1032-1 (2004). Aus- und Weiterbildung unter besondererBerücksichtigung von e-Learning – Teil 1: Referenzmodell fürQualitätsmanagement und Qualitätssicherung – Planung, Entwicklung,Durchführung und Evaluation von Bildungsprozessen undBildungsangeboten. Deutsches Institut für Normung e. V. Berlin: Beuth.Ebner, M. & Lorenz, A. (2011). Web 2.0 als Basistechnologien für CSCL-Umgebungen. In Haake, J., Schwabe, G. & Wessner, M. (Hrsg.): CSCL-Kompendium 2.0 (in Vorbereitung). Frankfurt: Oldenbourg.Freistaat Sachsen. (2011). Personal an den Hochschulen im Freistaat Sachsen 2010.Kamenz. URL: http://www.statistik.sachsen.de/download/100_Berichte-B/B_III_4_j10-Korrektur.pdf16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 20 | 19
  20. 20. Image SourcesResearch – IMG_1367 by Nicola since 1972 (CC-BY).http://www.flickr.com/photos/15216811@N06/6067028560/The US Brig Niagara arrives at Renaissance Pier by Official U.S. Navy Page (CC-BY)http://www.flickr.com/photos/usnavy/7943246262/Gerber pocket tool by Pedro Vera (CC-BY) http://www.flickr.com/photos/pvera/24938735/state of the art by Anthony Easton (CC-BY)http://www.flickr.com/photos/pinkmoose/2130792847/Evaluation Scale by Bill Sodeman (CC-BY-SA)http://www.flickr.com/photos/billsophoto/4175299981/Blogpost from 15th May 2012 by Sven K. http://blog.svenk.de/4555.html48/365 by Jiuck (CC-BY-NC-SA) http://www.flickr.com/photos/jiuck/4365662437/United by Nina Matthews (CC-BY)http://www.flickr.com/photos/21560098@N06/4961187879/Professor X and Robot by Simon Abrams (CC-BY-ND-SA).http://www.flickr.com/photos/flysi/7350023/16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 21 | 19
  21. 21. The CELePro Project• Online Survey• Autumn 2013• Target Group: Teaching Staff in Saxony• Spreading by– mailing lists– additional individual eMails to staff of universitiesof applied sciences• Clicks to Survey: 824• Response Rate: 65.9%• Completion Rate: 48.1% (253)16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 22 | 19
  22. 22. Representativity?• Male 71.1%, Female 26.5%, No answer 2.4%• 37 years old median (average 38.55), range: 25–76• University 70.8%,University of Applied Sciences 25.3%,School of arts 3.6%,Other 0.4%Compared to Freistaat Sachsen (2011)35.0%Most 40–50, but only information on non-time-limited staff80.2%12.0%4.5%16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 23 | 19
  23. 23. Representativity?• Diploma (37.5%), PhD 31.2%, Habilitation 14.6%,Master 4.3%, Bachelor 1.6% …• Engineer (42.1%) n= 252• Chair 27.7%,Lecturer 4.7%,Teaching Staff for special tasks 4.3%Research Associate with regular teaching tasks 36.8% +Research Associate with sporadic teaching tasks 17.8%=54.6Compared to Freistaat Sachsen (2011)No information16.8%1.3%3.2%78.7%24.2%, predominant discipline,lack of medicine staff16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 24 | 19
  24. 24. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationComputer Supported TeachingThe software used for teaching• … was chosen by himself• … is hosted by central institutions• … is exclusively used professionally• … is backuped automatically or regularelyHe feels largely safe concerning legal aspects.16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 25 | 19
  25. 25. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationTeaching Experiences• 10 Semesters of teaching experiences 0–78, median• No additional training in teaching (64.4%)Self assessment:• (Much) experiences in teaching• Tends more to established teaching methodsthan to experimenting• May arrange his teaching independently16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 26 | 19
  26. 26. Introducing Mr. Ed UcationUsage of Social Software Tools for Teaching (N=253, average)Social Software Tool Average*Social Networks 4.55Wikis 4.01Weblog 4.72Microblogging 4.88Media Sharing 4.34Social Bookmarking 5.06* Scale:1: permanently, 2: often, 3: sometimes,4: very seldom, 5: never, 6: do not know that tool16.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 27 | 19
  27. 27. Social Software ToolsClassification by Ebner & Lorenz 201116.06.2013 Anja Lorenz – CELePro: Collaboration in E-Learning Projects 28 | 19
  28. 28. RequirementsAnalysisConditions Production Implementation Realization EvaluationGiven byinstitutionalregulationsChosing contents:• Total amount• GranularityDidactics/Methodology incl.Consequentorganizationalconcepts oflearningscenariosPlanning of usedtools and mediaincl. maintenanceand careConception oftests & examsAnalysis ofContext andResources:• external• organisational/institutional• personell• Targetgroup• EquipmentSchedule/BudgetingRealization ofcontentImplementation ofdesign and mediaTechnicalrealization incl.maintenance andcare• Test,• adapt and• publishLearningresourcesOrganizeoperation and useTechnicalinfrastructure Execution• Administration• Activities• Checkcompetencelevel• Plan,• execute and• verifyEvaluationOptimizationConceptThe E-LearningProcess ModelDIN EN ISO/IEC 19796-1 (2009)DIN PAS 1032-1 (2004).

×