Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.
   Chapter 8 – Pretrial Procedures, Plea    Bargaining, and the Criminal Trial   Chapter 9 – Punishment & Sentencing    ...
   Check your personal bias (group, religious, lifestyle, status,    etc.) at the door;   No cell phones or texting;   ...
   Understand the pretrial process in criminal cases   Recognize how the bail system operates   Understand the context ...
   At each stage of the pretrial process, key    decisions are made that move some    defendants to the next stage of the...
ADMJ 50
   The court appearance of an accused person in    which the charges are read and the accused,    advised by a lawyer, pl...
   An application to a court requesting that an order    be issued to bring about a specific action   Examples of motion...
   An amount of money, specified by a judge, to be    paid as a condition of pretrial release to ensure    that the accus...
   According to a study of felony defendants in the    nation’s most populous counties, 62 percent were    released befor...
   Bail bondsmen are private businesspeople who are paid fees    by defendants who lack the money to make bail   They ar...
   The prosecutor may stress the seriousness of the crime, the    defendant’s record, and negative personal characteristi...
   Citation   Release on recognizance   Percentage bail   Bail Guidelines   Preventive detention                     ...
   A written order or summons, issued by a law    enforcement officer, directing an alleged offender    to appear in cour...
   Pretrial release granted, on the defendant’s    promise to appear in court, because the judge    believes that the def...
   Defendants may deposit a percentage (usually 10    percent) of the full bail with the court   The full amount of the ...
   To deal with the problem of unequal treatment,    reformers have written guidelines for setting bail.    The guideline...
   Holding a defendant for trial, based on a judge’s    finding that if the defendant were released on    bail, he or she...
   Preventive detention provisions of the Bail Reform Act of    1984 are upheld as a legitimate use of government power  ...
   People who are not released before trial must    remain in jail   Often called the ultimate ghetto, American jails   ...
   Which is the worst case?   A person under suspicion of involvement in a crime    is not detained, and commits a more ...
   Few cases go to trial; instead, a negotiated guilty    plea arrived at through the interactions of    prosecutors, def...
   Plea bargaining has advantages for defendants, prosecutors, defense    attorneys, and judges   Defendants can have th...
   Plea bargaining between defense counsel and    prosecutor is a serious game in which both sides    use various strateg...
   Boykin v. Alabama (1969) Defendants must state that they are    voluntarily making a plea of guilty before a judge may...
   Some argue that plea bargaining is unfair because    defendants give up some of their constitutional    rights, especi...
   Although the right to trial by jury is ingrained in    American ideology fewer than 9 percent of felony    cases go to...
Bench trials -Trials conducted by a judge who acts as fact finder and determines issues of law. No jury participates Jury ...
1. Prevent government oppression by safeguarding citizens against   arbitrary law enforcement2. Determine whether the accu...
(1) selection of the jury(2) opening statements by prosecution and defense(3) presentation of the prosecution’s evidence a...
   Questioning of prospective jurors to screen    out people the attorneys think might be    biased or otherwise incapabl...
ADMJ 50
   Challenge for cause Removal of a prospective juror    by showing that he or she has some bias or some    other legal d...
   Are peremptory challenges a good idea in    jury selection?                                 ADMJ 50
   The defendant, a married, twenty-six-year-    old white male, is charged with sexually    assaulting a single, twenty-...
   Real evidence - Physical evidence—such as a    weapons, records, fingerprints, and stolen property—involved    in the ...
   The defense is not required to answer the case    presented by the prosecution.   As it is the state’s responsibility...
   When the defense’s case is complete, the    prosecution may present witnesses whose    testimony is designed to discre...
   When each side has completed its presentation of    the evidence, the prosecution and defense make    closing argument...
   The standard used by a jury to decide if the    prosecution has provided enough evidence for    conviction            ...
   A request to a higher court that it review actions    taken in a trial court   Appeals are based on questions of proc...
   A writ or judicial order requesting the release of a    person being detained in a jail, prison, or mental    hospital...
   Understand the pretrial process in criminal cases   Recognize how the bail system operates   Understand the context ...
 Punishment   & Sentencing                    ADMJ 50
   Recognize the goals of punishment   Identify the types of sentences judges can impose   Understand what really happe...
   Retribution   Deterrence   Incapacitation   Rehabilitation                     ADMJ 50
   Punishment inflicted on a person who has infringed    on the rights of others and so deserves to be    penalized.   T...
   There are two types of deterrence:   General deterrence - Punishment of criminals that    is intended to be an exampl...
   Depriving an offender of the ability to commit    crimes against society, usually by detaining the    offender in pris...
The goal of restoring a convicted offender to aconstructive place in society through some form of  vocational or education...
   Punishment designed to repair the damage done to    the victim and community by an offender’s criminal    act   A thr...
ADMJ 50
   Incarceration, intermediate    sanctions, probation, and death are the basic ways    that the criminal sanction, or pu...
   Imprisonment is the most visible penalty imposed by U.S.    courts   Although less than 30 percent of people under co...
   A period, set by a judge, that specifies a minimum    and a maximum time to be served in prison.    Sometime after the...
   A sentence that fixes the term of imprisonment at a    specific period   Some determinate-sentencing states have adop...
   A sentence for which the legislature or a    commission sets a minimum and maximum range    of months or years   Judg...
   A sentence determined by statutes and requiring    that a certain penalty be imposed and carried out    for convicted ...
   Common Belief: Long, mandatory sentences will    deter people from committing crimes because they    will stop themsel...
   Potential offenders must think rationally and weigh    the costs and benefits of crimes before committing    criminal ...
   Adopted by 26 states and the federal government   These laws require that judges sentence offenders    with three fel...
ADMJ 50
   Regardless of the prison sentence imposed it may    bear little resemblance to the actual amount of    time served   ...
ADMJ 50
   A reduction of an inmate’s prison sentence, at the discretion    of the prison administrator, for good behavior or par...
   Laws that require offenders to serve a substantial    proportion (usually 85 percent for violent crimes)    of their p...
   Punishments that are less severe and costly than    prison but more restrictive than traditional    probation   Inter...
   Fines   Home confinement   Intensive probation supervision   Restitution to victims   Community service   Boot ca...
   A sentence that the offender is allowed to serve    under supervision in the community   The most frequently applied ...
A sentence in which the offender is releasedafter a short incarceration and re-sentenced toprobation                      ...
   The U.S. Supreme Court decided that capital    punishment does not violate the Eighth    Amendment’s prohibition of cr...
ADMJ 50
   Death differs from other punishments in that it is    final and irreversible   Because life is in the balance, capita...
   Furman v. Georgia (1972) - The death penalty, as    administered, constitutes cruel and unusual    punishment.   Greg...
   Atkins v. Virginia (2002) - Execution of the    mentally retarded is unconstitutional.   Roper v. Simmons (2005) - Ex...
   Execution of the mentally ill   Effective counsel   Death-qualified juries   Appeals   International law          ...
ADMJ 50
   The death penalty deters criminals from    committing violent acts.   The death penalty achieves justice by paying ki...
   No hard evidence proves that the death penalty is a deterrent.   It is wrong for a government to participate in the i...
ADMJ 50
Within the discretion allowed by the code, variouselements influence the decisions of judges:◦   The administrative contex...
   A report, prepared by a probation officer, that    presents a convicted offender’s background and is    used by the ju...
   A mechanism to indicate to judges the expected    sanction for certain offenses, in order to reduce    disparities in ...
   Harsh, unjust punishments can occur    because of sentencing disparities and    wrongful convictions.   Examples of c...
   Recognize the goals of punishment   Identify the types of sentences that judges can    impose   Understand what real...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Chapter 8 & 9 powerpoint lecture admj50

1,843 views

Published on

Published in: Economy & Finance, Business
  • Be the first to comment

Chapter 8 & 9 powerpoint lecture admj50

  1. 1.  Chapter 8 – Pretrial Procedures, Plea Bargaining, and the Criminal Trial Chapter 9 – Punishment & Sentencing ADMJ 50
  2. 2.  Check your personal bias (group, religious, lifestyle, status, etc.) at the door; No cell phones or texting; No audio recording or videotaping without prior permission; Wait to be recognized before speaking; Monitor your air-time. Let at least two others speak before you speak again. Listen attentively when others are speaking; Be civil in disagreeing with the views of others: Challenge the idea and not the person; and Be willing to listen to both sides of an issue. ADMJ 50
  3. 3.  Understand the pretrial process in criminal cases Recognize how the bail system operates Understand the context of pretrial detention Recognize how and why plea bargaining occurs Know why cases go to trial and how juries are chosen Identify the stages of a criminal trial Understand the basis for an appeal of a conviction ADMJ 50
  4. 4.  At each stage of the pretrial process, key decisions are made that move some defendants to the next stage of the process and filter others out of the system ADMJ 50
  5. 5. ADMJ 50
  6. 6.  The court appearance of an accused person in which the charges are read and the accused, advised by a lawyer, pleads guilty or not guilty Often arraignment is the first formal meeting between the prosecutor and the defendant’s attorney Arraignment is also an opportunity for a prosecutor to test the strength of the case against the defendant ADMJ 50
  7. 7.  An application to a court requesting that an order be issued to bring about a specific action Examples of motions: ◦ Defense may seek an order for the prosecution to share certain evidence ◦ Defense may seek exclusion of evidence based on the claim that it was obtained through improper questioning of the suspect or an improper search ADMJ 50
  8. 8.  An amount of money, specified by a judge, to be paid as a condition of pretrial release to ensure that the accused will appear in court as required The Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution forbids excessive bail, and state bail laws are usually designed to prevent discrimination in setting bail. They do not guarantee, however, that all defendants will have a realistic chance of being released before trial ADMJ 50
  9. 9.  According to a study of felony defendants in the nation’s most populous counties, 62 percent were released before disposition of their cases 32 percent were unable to make bail 6 percent were detained without bail Among those who gained release, 25 percent had bail set at less than $5,000 ADMJ 50
  10. 10.  Bail bondsmen are private businesspeople who are paid fees by defendants who lack the money to make bail They are licensed by the state and can choose their own clients In exchange for a fee, which may be 5 to 10 percent of the bail amount, the bondsman will put up the money (or property) to gain the defendant’s release Only two countries in the world use commercial bail bond systems, the United States and the Philippines ADMJ 50
  11. 11.  The prosecutor may stress the seriousness of the crime, the defendant’s record, and negative personal characteristics The defense attorney, if one has been hired or appointed at this point in the process, may stress the defendant’s good job, family responsibilities, and place in the community Like other aspects of bail, these factors may favor affluent defendants over the poor, the unemployed, and people with unstable families Yet many of these factors provide no clear information about how dangerous a defendant is or whether he or she will appear in court The amount of bail may also reflect the defendant’s social class or even racial or ethnic discrimination by criminal justice officials ADMJ 50
  12. 12.  Citation Release on recognizance Percentage bail Bail Guidelines Preventive detention ADMJ 50
  13. 13.  A written order or summons, issued by a law enforcement officer, directing an alleged offender to appear in court at a specific time to answer a criminal charge ADMJ 50
  14. 14.  Pretrial release granted, on the defendant’s promise to appear in court, because the judge believes that the defendant’s ties to the community guarantee that he or she will appear ADMJ 50
  15. 15.  Defendants may deposit a percentage (usually 10 percent) of the full bail with the court The full amount of the bail is required if the defendant fails to appear The percentage of bail is returned after disposition of the case, although the court often retains 1 percent for administrative costs ADMJ 50
  16. 16.  To deal with the problem of unequal treatment, reformers have written guidelines for setting bail. The guidelines specify the standards judges should use in setting bail and also list appropriate amounts ADMJ 50
  17. 17.  Holding a defendant for trial, based on a judge’s finding that if the defendant were released on bail, he or she would endanger the safety of any other person and the community or would flee ADMJ 50
  18. 18.  Preventive detention provisions of the Bail Reform Act of 1984 are upheld as a legitimate use of government power designed to prevent people from committing crimes while on bail The justices said that preventive detention was a legitimate use of government power because it was not designed to punish the accused Instead, it deals with the problem of people who commit crimes while on bail ADMJ 50
  19. 19.  People who are not released before trial must remain in jail Often called the ultimate ghetto, American jails hold almost 750,000 people on any one day Thus, a ―presumed innocent‖ pretrial detainee might spend weeks in the same confined space with troubled people or sentenced felons ADMJ 50
  20. 20.  Which is the worst case? A person under suspicion of involvement in a crime is not detained, and commits a more serious violent crime while out on bail. A person who is later found innocent is detained and loses his or her family and job. ADMJ 50
  21. 21.  Few cases go to trial; instead, a negotiated guilty plea arrived at through the interactions of prosecutors, defense lawyers, and judges determines what will happen to most defendants. Prosecutors maintain significant control over the outcomes of plea bargains negotiated guilty pleas became common and was upheld by the Supreme Court in the 1971 case of Santobello v. New York ADMJ 50
  22. 22.  Plea bargaining has advantages for defendants, prosecutors, defense attorneys, and judges Defendants can have their cases completed quickly The defendant is likely to receive less than the maximum punishment that might have been imposed after a trial Prosecutors may gain an easy conviction Private defense attorneys also save the time needed to prepare for a trial and earn their fee quickly Plea bargaining helps public defenders cope with large caseloads Judges avoid time-consuming trials Plea bargaining benefits all involved ADMJ 50
  23. 23.  Plea bargaining between defense counsel and prosecutor is a serious game in which both sides use various strategies and tactics A tactic that many prosecutors bring to plea- bargaining sessions is the multiple-offense indictment Defense attorneys may threaten to ask for a jury trial if concessions are not made ADMJ 50
  24. 24.  Boykin v. Alabama (1969) Defendants must state that they are voluntarily making a plea of guilty before a judge may accept the plea. North Carolina v. Alford (1970) A plea of guilty by a defendant who maintains his or her innocence may be accepted for the purpose of a lesser sentence. Ricketts v. Adamson (1987) Defendants must uphold the plea agreement or suffer the consequences. Bordenkircher v. Hayes (1978) A defendant’s rights were not violated by a prosecutor who warned that refusing to enter a guilty plea would result in a harsher sentence. ADMJ 50
  25. 25.  Some argue that plea bargaining is unfair because defendants give up some of their constitutional rights, especially the right to trial by jury A second argument stresses sentencing policy and points out that plea bargaining reduces society’s interest in appropriate punishments for crimes ADMJ 50
  26. 26.  Although the right to trial by jury is ingrained in American ideology fewer than 9 percent of felony cases go to trial Of these, only about half are jury trials, the rest are bench trials, presided over by a judge without a jury In 2004, trials produced only 3 percent of felony convictions in the nation’s 75 most populous counties ADMJ 50
  27. 27. Bench trials -Trials conducted by a judge who acts as fact finder and determines issues of law. No jury participates Jury - A panel of citizens selected according to law and sworn to determine matters of fact in a criminal case and to deliver a verdict of guilty or not guilty. ADMJ 50
  28. 28. 1. Prevent government oppression by safeguarding citizens against arbitrary law enforcement2. Determine whether the accused is guilty on the basis of the evidence presented3. Represent diverse community interests so that no one set of values or biases dominates decision making4. Serve as a buffer between the accused and the accuser5. Promote knowledge about the criminal justice system by learning about it through the jury duty process6. Symbolize the rule of law and the community foundation that supports the criminal justice system ADMJ 50
  29. 29. (1) selection of the jury(2) opening statements by prosecution and defense(3) presentation of the prosecution’s evidence and witnesses(4) presentation of the defense’s evidence and witnesses(5) presentation of rebuttal witnesses(6) closing arguments by each side(7) instruction of the jury by the judge(8) decision by the jury ADMJ 50
  30. 30.  Questioning of prospective jurors to screen out people the attorneys think might be biased or otherwise incapable of delivering a fair verdict. ADMJ 50
  31. 31. ADMJ 50
  32. 32.  Challenge for cause Removal of a prospective juror by showing that he or she has some bias or some other legal disability. The number of such challenges available to attorneys is unlimited Peremptory challenge Removal of a prospective juror without giving any reason. Attorneys are allowed a limited number of such challenges ADMJ 50
  33. 33.  Are peremptory challenges a good idea in jury selection? ADMJ 50
  34. 34.  The defendant, a married, twenty-six-year- old white male, is charged with sexually assaulting a single, twenty-one-year-old white female co-worker in his car when giving her a ride home from an office party at which both of them drank several beers. ADMJ 50
  35. 35.  Real evidence - Physical evidence—such as a weapons, records, fingerprints, and stolen property—involved in the crime. Demonstrative evidence - Evidence that is not based on witness testimony but that demonstrates information relevant to the crime, such as maps, X-rays, and photographs; includes real evidence involved in the crime. Testimony - Oral evidence provided by a legally competent witness. Direct evidence - Eyewitness accounts. Circumstantial evidence - Evidence provided by a witness from which a jury must infer a fact ADMJ 50
  36. 36.  The defense is not required to answer the case presented by the prosecution. As it is the state’s responsibility to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt (1) contrary evidence is introduced to rebut or cast doubt on the state’s case (2) an alibi is offered (3) an affirmative defense is presented ADMJ 50
  37. 37.  When the defense’s case is complete, the prosecution may present witnesses whose testimony is designed to discredit or counteract testimony presented on behalf of the defendant If the prosecution brings rebuttal witnesses, the defense has the opportunity to question them and to present new witnesses in rebuttal. ADMJ 50
  38. 38.  When each side has completed its presentation of the evidence, the prosecution and defense make closing arguments to the jury The attorneys review the evidence of the case for the jury, presenting interpretations of the evidence that favor their own side Each side may remind the jury of its duty to evaluate the evidence impartially and not to be swayed by emotion ADMJ 50
  39. 39.  The standard used by a jury to decide if the prosecution has provided enough evidence for conviction ADMJ 50
  40. 40.  A request to a higher court that it review actions taken in a trial court Appeals are based on questions of procedure, not on issues of the defendant’s guilt or innocence The appellate court will not normally second-guess a jury Instead it will check to make sure that the trial followed proper procedures ADMJ 50
  41. 41.  A writ or judicial order requesting the release of a person being detained in a jail, prison, or mental hospital. If a judge finds the person is being held improperly, the writ may be granted and the person released ADMJ 50
  42. 42.  Understand the pretrial process in criminal cases Recognize how the bail system operates Understand the context of pretrial detention Recognize how and why plea bargaining occurs Know why cases go to trial and how juries are chosen Identify the stages of a criminal trial Understand the basis for an appeal of a conviction ADMJ 50
  43. 43.  Punishment & Sentencing ADMJ 50
  44. 44.  Recognize the goals of punishment Identify the types of sentences judges can impose Understand what really happens in sentencing Analyze whether the system treats wrongdoers equally ADMJ 50
  45. 45.  Retribution Deterrence Incapacitation Rehabilitation ADMJ 50
  46. 46.  Punishment inflicted on a person who has infringed on the rights of others and so deserves to be penalized. This approach rests on the philosophical view that punishment is a moral response to harm inflicted on society ADMJ 50
  47. 47.  There are two types of deterrence: General deterrence - Punishment of criminals that is intended to be an example to the general public and to discourage the commission of offenses. Specific deterrence - Punishment inflicted on criminals to discourage them from committing future crimes. ADMJ 50
  48. 48.  Depriving an offender of the ability to commit crimes against society, usually by detaining the offender in prison. Selective Incapacitation - Making the best use of expensive and limited prison space by targeting for incarceration those individuals whose incapacity will do the most to reduce crime in society. ADMJ 50
  49. 49. The goal of restoring a convicted offender to aconstructive place in society through some form of vocational or educational training or therapy. ADMJ 50
  50. 50.  Punishment designed to repair the damage done to the victim and community by an offender’s criminal act A three-way approach that involves the offender, the victim, and the community This approach may include mediation in which the three actors devise ways that all agree are fair and just for the offender to repair the harm done to victim and community ADMJ 50
  51. 51. ADMJ 50
  52. 52.  Incarceration, intermediate sanctions, probation, and death are the basic ways that the criminal sanction, or punishment, is applied The United States does not have a single, uniform set of sentencing laws The criminal codes of each of the states and of the federal government specify the punishments Judges often receive wide discretion in determining the appropriate sentence ADMJ 50
  53. 53.  Imprisonment is the most visible penalty imposed by U.S. courts Although less than 30 percent of people under correctional supervision are in prisons and jails, incarceration remains the standard for punishing those who commit serious crimes Three basic sentencing structures are used: ◦ Indeterminate sentences (36 states) ◦ Determinate sentences (14 states) ◦ Mandatory sentences (all states) ADMJ 50
  54. 54.  A period, set by a judge, that specifies a minimum and a maximum time to be served in prison. Sometime after the minimum, the offender may be eligible for parole. Because it is based on the idea that the time necessary for treatment cannot be set, the indeterminate sentence is closely associated with rehabilitation. ADMJ 50
  55. 55.  A sentence that fixes the term of imprisonment at a specific period Some determinate-sentencing states have adopted penal codes that stipulate a specific term for each crime category Others allow the judge to choose a range of time to be served ADMJ 50
  56. 56.  A sentence for which the legislature or a commission sets a minimum and maximum range of months or years Judges are to fix the length of the sentence within that range, allowing for special circumstances Only in special circumstances should judges deviate from the presumptive sentence ADMJ 50
  57. 57.  A sentence determined by statutes and requiring that a certain penalty be imposed and carried out for convicted offenders who meet certain criteria The judge may not consider the circumstances of the offense or the background of the offender The judge may not impose non-incarcerative sentences ADMJ 50
  58. 58.  Common Belief: Long, mandatory sentences will deter people from committing crimes because they will stop themselves from causing harm to society out of fear of the severe punishments that await them. ADMJ 50
  59. 59.  Potential offenders must think rationally and weigh the costs and benefits of crimes before committing criminal acts; and Potential offenders must fear that possibility that they will be caught. In fact, many offenders do not think rationally ADMJ 50
  60. 60.  Adopted by 26 states and the federal government These laws require that judges sentence offenders with three felony convictions (in some states two or four convictions) to long prison terms, sometimes to life without parole In some states, these laws have inadvertently clogged the courts, lowered the rates of plea bargaining, and caused desperate offenders to violently resist arrest ADMJ 50
  61. 61. ADMJ 50
  62. 62.  Regardless of the prison sentence imposed it may bear little resemblance to the actual amount of time served In reality, parole boards in indeterminate- sentencing states have broad discretion in release decisions once the offender has served a minimum portion of the sentence Offenders can have their prison sentence reduced by earning ―good time‖ for good behavior, at the discretion of the prison administrator. ADMJ 50
  63. 63. ADMJ 50
  64. 64.  A reduction of an inmate’s prison sentence, at the discretion of the prison administrator, for good behavior or participation in vocational, educational, or treatment programs. Prosecutors and defense attorneys take good time into consideration during plea bargaining by calculating the actual amount of time a particular offender will likely serve The amount of good time one can earn varies among the states, usually from 5 to 10 days a month ADMJ 50
  65. 65.  Laws that require offenders to serve a substantial proportion (usually 85 percent for violent crimes) of their prison sentence before being released on parole Has become such a politically attractive idea that the federal government has allocated almost $10 billion for prison construction to those states adopting truth-in-sentencing Critics maintain that truth-in-sentencing will increase prison populations at a tremendous cost ADMJ 50
  66. 66.  Punishments that are less severe and costly than prison but more restrictive than traditional probation Intermediate sanctions provide a variety of restrictions on freedom ADMJ 50
  67. 67.  Fines Home confinement Intensive probation supervision Restitution to victims Community service Boot camp Forfeiture of possessions or stolen property ADMJ 50
  68. 68.  A sentence that the offender is allowed to serve under supervision in the community The most frequently applied criminal sanction Nearly 60 percent of adults under correctional supervision are on probation Conditions are imposed specifying how an offender will behave through the length of the sentence Probation is not extended as a right to the offender ADMJ 50
  69. 69. A sentence in which the offender is releasedafter a short incarceration and re-sentenced toprobation ADMJ 50
  70. 70.  The U.S. Supreme Court decided that capital punishment does not violate the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition of cruel and unusual punishments The numbers of people facing the death penalty has increased dramatically Although about 200 people are sent to death row each year, since 1977 the annual number of executions has never exceeded 98 ADMJ 50
  71. 71. ADMJ 50
  72. 72.  Death differs from other punishments in that it is final and irreversible Because life is in the balance, capital cases must be conducted according to higher standards of fairness and more-careful procedures than are other kinds of cases Several important Supreme Court cases illustrate this concern ADMJ 50
  73. 73.  Furman v. Georgia (1972) - The death penalty, as administered, constitutes cruel and unusual punishment. Gregg v. Georgia (1976) - Judge and jury must consider certain mitigating and aggravating circumstances and proceedings must also be divided into a trial phase and a punishment phase. McCleskey v. Kemp (1987) - The Supreme Court rejects a challenge of Georgia’s death penalty on grounds of racial discrimination. ADMJ 50
  74. 74.  Atkins v. Virginia (2002) - Execution of the mentally retarded is unconstitutional. Roper v. Simmons (2005) - Execution of offenders for crimes committed while under the age of 18 is unconstitutional. ADMJ 50
  75. 75.  Execution of the mentally ill Effective counsel Death-qualified juries Appeals International law ADMJ 50
  76. 76. ADMJ 50
  77. 77.  The death penalty deters criminals from committing violent acts. The death penalty achieves justice by paying killers back for their horrible crimes. The death penalty prevents criminals from doing further harm while on parole. The death penalty is less expensive than holding murderers in prison for life. ADMJ 50
  78. 78.  No hard evidence proves that the death penalty is a deterrent. It is wrong for a government to participate in the intentional killing of citizens. The death penalty is applied in a discriminatory fashion. Innocent people have been sentenced to death. Some methods of execution are inhumane, causing painful, lingering deaths. ADMJ 50
  79. 79. ADMJ 50
  80. 80. Within the discretion allowed by the code, variouselements influence the decisions of judges:◦ The administrative context of the courts◦ The attitudes and values of judges◦ The presentence report◦ Sentencing guidelines ADMJ 50
  81. 81.  A report, prepared by a probation officer, that presents a convicted offender’s background and is used by the judge in selecting an appropriate sentence ADMJ 50
  82. 82.  A mechanism to indicate to judges the expected sanction for certain offenses, in order to reduce disparities in sentencing. Although guidelines make sentences more uniform, many judges object to having their discretion limited in this manner ADMJ 50
  83. 83.  Harsh, unjust punishments can occur because of sentencing disparities and wrongful convictions. Examples of contemporary issues: ◦ Racial disparities ◦ Wrongful convictions ADMJ 50
  84. 84.  Recognize the goals of punishment Identify the types of sentences that judges can impose Understand what really happens in sentencing Analyze whether the system treats wrongdoers equally ADMJ 50

×