Ice throw reloaded – studies at Guetsch and St. Brais

Winterwind
WinterwindWinterwind
Ice throw studies
 Gütsch and St. Brais
  February 8, 2012
     René Cattin
Icing in wind energy




                       Ice throw studies | Seite 2 | 2012-02-08
Icing in Switzerland
              Wind map of Switzerland




                          Ice throw studies | Seite 3 | 2012-02-08
Icing in Switzerland
             Icing map of Switzerland




                              Ice throw studies | Seite 4 | 2012-02-08
Gütsch




         2‘300 m asl




                       Ice throw studies | Seite 5 | 2012-02-08
Gütsch


                      Does ice throw occur?
                Enercon E-44
                      - How often?
                      - How far?
                      - How heavy?
                      - Where?
 Enercon E-40


                                       Enercon E-44

                               Ca. 7 days/year meteorological icing
                               Ca. 30 days/year instrumental icing
                               Ca. 150 days/year temperature below 0°C
                               Wind turbines equipped with blade heating


                                   Ice throw studies | Seite 6 | 2012-02-08
Alpine Test Site Gütsch
     COST Action 727: Atmospheric Icing on Structures
     2005 to 2009




                                     Ice throw studies | Seite 7 | 2012-02-08
Method
After each icing event, the area around the wind turbine
is inspected for ice throw.

All found ice fragments are recorded

-  Distance
-  Angle
-  Size
-  Weight
-  Type of ice (rime, glaze, wet snow)
-  Photo of ice fragment



                                Ice throw studies | Seite 8 | 2012-02-08
Method




         Ice throw studies | Seite 9 | 2012-02-08
Method




         Ice throw studies | Seite 10 | 2012-02-08
Methodik
•  Not all events could be captured
•  Inspection partly delayed
•  Exact time of ice throw unknown
•  No distinction between ice throw and
   ice fall


     Inspections during 4 winters (2005 bis 2009)
     à 32 icing events recorded
     à 228 ice fragments documented
     à Also during summer

                               Ice throw studies | Seite 11 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch




   Maximum distance: 92m (2.25 rotor diameter)
           Maximum weight: 1.8 kg


                          Ice throw studies | Seite 12 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch




                   Ice throw studies | Seite 13 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch




                   Ice throw studies | Seite 14 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch




                                                                         Icing




                                                                         Föhn
  à Risky areas seem to be dependant on
     wind statistics under icing consitions
                             Ice throw studies | Seite 15 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch
               Types of ice




   Rime          Glaze                                     Wet snow

                     Ice throw studies | Seite 16 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch
                 Distance to wind turbine

     50%




   Rotor blade
                             Ice throw studies | Seite 17 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch
          Angle relative to wind turbine




                         Ice throw studies | Seite 18 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw study Gütsch
                Resulta
                  te




                    Ice throw studies | Seite 19 | 2012-02-08
Conclusions
•  Ice throw occurs
•  Wind conditions during icing event define risk areas
•  Ice throw when blade is moving downwards?
•  50% of ice fragments found under rotor blade
•  Heavy ice fragments (> 600 g) under rotor blade
•  Ice throw also during summer time

à Übertragbarkeit der Resultate auf grössere WEA??




                               Ice throw studies | Seite 20 | 2012-02-08
Counter measures
•  Routing of winter walkway was changes
•  Warning signs were installed




                                  Ice throw studies | Seite 21 | 2012-02-08
Conclusions
              Further study during winter 2011/12
    2 Enercon E-82
    Hub height 78 m
    Enercon blade heating


St. Brais
1‘100 m asl




              No real icing events so far


                                Ice throw studies | Seite 22 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw model SWIM
•  Simple Wind turbine Icethrow Model




                             Ice throw studies | Seite 23 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw model SWIM
•  Simple Wind turbine Icethrow Model




                             Ice throw studies | Seite 24 | 2012-02-08
Ice throw model SWIM
•  Simple Wind turbine Icethrow Model




                             Ice throw studies | Seite 25 | 2012-02-08
Thank you…




  METEOTEST                            …for your attention
  Fabrikstrasse 14
  CH-3012 Bern
  www.meteotest.ch

                     Ice throw studies | Seite 26 | 2012-02-08
1 of 26

Recommended

A test centre for wind turbines in cold/icy climate by
A test centre for wind turbines in cold/icy climateA test centre for wind turbines in cold/icy climate
A test centre for wind turbines in cold/icy climateWinterwind
621 views10 slides
Icing of wind power: A survey of research efforts and needs by
Icing of wind power: A survey of research efforts and needsIcing of wind power: A survey of research efforts and needs
Icing of wind power: A survey of research efforts and needsWinterwind
820 views27 slides
13 winterwind heating_cattin by
13 winterwind heating_cattin13 winterwind heating_cattin
13 winterwind heating_cattinWinterwind
314 views58 slides
Benefit and expected gains with use of de-icing technologies by
Benefit and expected gains with use of de-icing technologiesBenefit and expected gains with use of de-icing technologies
Benefit and expected gains with use of de-icing technologiesWinterwind
416 views27 slides
Windpower in cold climates – Vindforsk project V-313 by
Windpower in cold climates – Vindforsk project V-313Windpower in cold climates – Vindforsk project V-313
Windpower in cold climates – Vindforsk project V-313Winterwind
351 views36 slides
Drinkwater ice sheet symposium - tu delft climate inst., 17 oct 2013(1) by
Drinkwater  ice sheet symposium - tu delft climate inst., 17 oct 2013(1)Drinkwater  ice sheet symposium - tu delft climate inst., 17 oct 2013(1)
Drinkwater ice sheet symposium - tu delft climate inst., 17 oct 2013(1)TU Delft Climate Institute
1.8K views38 slides

More Related Content

Similar to Ice throw reloaded – studies at Guetsch and St. Brais

Byrkjedal øyvind by
Byrkjedal øyvindByrkjedal øyvind
Byrkjedal øyvindWinterwind
816 views20 slides
Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ... by
Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ...Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ...
Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ...Winterwind
756 views8 slides
Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri... by
Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri...Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri...
Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri...Winterwind
287 views15 slides
State-of-the‐art of ice detection by
State-of-the‐art of ice detectionState-of-the‐art of ice detection
State-of-the‐art of ice detectionWinterwind
443 views11 slides
Reviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude Road by
Reviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude RoadReviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude Road
Reviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude RoadIJERA Editor
294 views5 slides
Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ... by
Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ...Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ...
Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ...Winterwind
751 views20 slides

Similar to Ice throw reloaded – studies at Guetsch and St. Brais(9)

Byrkjedal øyvind by Winterwind
Byrkjedal øyvindByrkjedal øyvind
Byrkjedal øyvind
Winterwind816 views
Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ... by Winterwind
Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ...Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ...
Expert group study on recommended practices for wind energy projects in cold ...
Winterwind756 views
Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri... by Winterwind
Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri...Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri...
Evaluation and experiences from the Vindpilot project at Dragaliden and Gabri...
Winterwind287 views
State-of-the‐art of ice detection by Winterwind
State-of-the‐art of ice detectionState-of-the‐art of ice detection
State-of-the‐art of ice detection
Winterwind443 views
Reviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude Road by IJERA Editor
Reviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude RoadReviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude Road
Reviewing the Technology of Anti-ice in Cold High Altitude Road
IJERA Editor294 views
Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ... by Winterwind
Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ...Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ...
Mapping of icing in Sweden – On the influence from icing on wind energy produ...
Winterwind751 views
Kvt mapping of_icing by Winterwind
Kvt mapping of_icingKvt mapping of_icing
Kvt mapping of_icing
Winterwind895 views
Icing and icing mitigation of wind turbine by Akhthar Edavanna
Icing and icing mitigation of wind turbineIcing and icing mitigation of wind turbine
Icing and icing mitigation of wind turbine
Akhthar Edavanna184 views
Olsson esbjörn by Winterwind
Olsson esbjörnOlsson esbjörn
Olsson esbjörn
Winterwind716 views

More from Winterwind

Ice profile classification - Matthew Wadham-Gagnon by
Ice profile classification - Matthew Wadham-GagnonIce profile classification - Matthew Wadham-Gagnon
Ice profile classification - Matthew Wadham-GagnonWinterwind
1.9K views48 slides
Bergström hans by
Bergström hansBergström hans
Bergström hansWinterwind
786 views23 slides
Bergström fredrik by
Bergström fredrikBergström fredrik
Bergström fredrikWinterwind
855 views14 slides
Campbell iain by
Campbell iainCampbell iain
Campbell iainWinterwind
860 views40 slides
Davis neil by
Davis neilDavis neil
Davis neilWinterwind
722 views14 slides
Delle monache luca by
Delle monache lucaDelle monache luca
Delle monache lucaWinterwind
841 views46 slides

More from Winterwind(20)

Ice profile classification - Matthew Wadham-Gagnon by Winterwind
Ice profile classification - Matthew Wadham-GagnonIce profile classification - Matthew Wadham-Gagnon
Ice profile classification - Matthew Wadham-Gagnon
Winterwind1.9K views
Bergström hans by Winterwind
Bergström hansBergström hans
Bergström hans
Winterwind786 views
Bergström fredrik by Winterwind
Bergström fredrikBergström fredrik
Bergström fredrik
Winterwind855 views
Campbell iain by Winterwind
Campbell iainCampbell iain
Campbell iain
Winterwind860 views
Delle monache luca by Winterwind
Delle monache lucaDelle monache luca
Delle monache luca
Winterwind841 views
Derrick alan by Winterwind
Derrick alanDerrick alan
Derrick alan
Winterwind893 views
Hietanen jarmo by Winterwind
Hietanen jarmoHietanen jarmo
Hietanen jarmo
Winterwind799 views
Hudecz adriana by Winterwind
Hudecz adrianaHudecz adriana
Hudecz adriana
Winterwind616 views
Huttunen saara by Winterwind
Huttunen saaraHuttunen saara
Huttunen saara
Winterwind667 views
Jeffs justin by Winterwind
Jeffs justinJeffs justin
Jeffs justin
Winterwind607 views
Jordaens pieter jan by Winterwind
Jordaens pieter janJordaens pieter jan
Jordaens pieter jan
Winterwind693 views
Karlsson timo by Winterwind
Karlsson timoKarlsson timo
Karlsson timo
Winterwind532 views
Lehtomäki ville by Winterwind
Lehtomäki villeLehtomäki ville
Lehtomäki ville
Winterwind712 views
Meyer sebastian by Winterwind
Meyer sebastianMeyer sebastian
Meyer sebastian
Winterwind830 views
Ribeiro carla by Winterwind
Ribeiro carlaRibeiro carla
Ribeiro carla
Winterwind754 views
Sell dr. stephan by Winterwind
Sell dr. stephanSell dr. stephan
Sell dr. stephan
Winterwind2.5K views
Sukosd attila by Winterwind
Sukosd attilaSukosd attila
Sukosd attila
Winterwind619 views
Szasz robert by Winterwind
Szasz robertSzasz robert
Szasz robert
Winterwind573 views

Recently uploaded

Lexington Quartzite Countertops Elegance Redefined by
Lexington Quartzite Countertops Elegance RedefinedLexington Quartzite Countertops Elegance Redefined
Lexington Quartzite Countertops Elegance RedefinedGranite Depot of Lexington
7 views6 slides
Concierge Services Business Plan by
Concierge Services Business PlanConcierge Services Business Plan
Concierge Services Business PlanJessica Larson
16 views50 slides
ZARA.pptx by
ZARA.pptxZARA.pptx
ZARA.pptxmerlinjenma529
21 views13 slides
Coomes Consulting Business Profile by
Coomes Consulting Business ProfileCoomes Consulting Business Profile
Coomes Consulting Business ProfileChris Coomes
38 views10 slides
Strategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste Disposal by
Strategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste DisposalStrategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste Disposal
Strategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste DisposalAlfredoRaylan
67 views7 slides
TOP SEO MISTAKES TO AVOID by
TOP SEO MISTAKES TO AVOIDTOP SEO MISTAKES TO AVOID
TOP SEO MISTAKES TO AVOIDnihadudigital
25 views1 slide

Recently uploaded(20)

Concierge Services Business Plan by Jessica Larson
Concierge Services Business PlanConcierge Services Business Plan
Concierge Services Business Plan
Jessica Larson16 views
Coomes Consulting Business Profile by Chris Coomes
Coomes Consulting Business ProfileCoomes Consulting Business Profile
Coomes Consulting Business Profile
Chris Coomes38 views
Strategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste Disposal by AlfredoRaylan
Strategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste DisposalStrategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste Disposal
Strategies for Responsible and Efficient Waste Disposal
AlfredoRaylan67 views
RESIDENTIAL CARPENTRY SERVICES – COLOR RENOVATION INC by colorrenovation
RESIDENTIAL CARPENTRY SERVICES – COLOR RENOVATION INCRESIDENTIAL CARPENTRY SERVICES – COLOR RENOVATION INC
RESIDENTIAL CARPENTRY SERVICES – COLOR RENOVATION INC
colorrenovation18 views
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict by Seta Wicaksana
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict
Group and Teams: Increasing Cooperation and Reducing Conflict
Seta Wicaksana13 views
How to get your business featured on Forbes - Business Show 23 by Quibble
How to get your business featured on Forbes - Business Show 23How to get your business featured on Forbes - Business Show 23
How to get your business featured on Forbes - Business Show 23
Quibble26 views
ERC-BEIS Longitudinal Small Business Survey Dissemination Event Slides by enterpriseresearchcentre
ERC-BEIS Longitudinal Small Business Survey Dissemination Event  Slides ERC-BEIS Longitudinal Small Business Survey Dissemination Event  Slides
ERC-BEIS Longitudinal Small Business Survey Dissemination Event Slides
Amazon Music - Market Analysis by Ana Weathers
Amazon Music - Market AnalysisAmazon Music - Market Analysis
Amazon Music - Market Analysis
Ana Weathers32 views
bookmyshow-1.pptx by 125071035
bookmyshow-1.pptxbookmyshow-1.pptx
bookmyshow-1.pptx
1250710358 views
TNR Gold Shotgun Gold Project Presentation by Kirill Klip
TNR Gold Shotgun Gold Project PresentationTNR Gold Shotgun Gold Project Presentation
TNR Gold Shotgun Gold Project Presentation
Kirill Klip85 views

Ice throw reloaded – studies at Guetsch and St. Brais

  • 1. Ice throw studies Gütsch and St. Brais February 8, 2012 René Cattin
  • 2. Icing in wind energy Ice throw studies | Seite 2 | 2012-02-08
  • 3. Icing in Switzerland Wind map of Switzerland Ice throw studies | Seite 3 | 2012-02-08
  • 4. Icing in Switzerland Icing map of Switzerland Ice throw studies | Seite 4 | 2012-02-08
  • 5. Gütsch 2‘300 m asl Ice throw studies | Seite 5 | 2012-02-08
  • 6. Gütsch Does ice throw occur? Enercon E-44 - How often? - How far? - How heavy? - Where? Enercon E-40 Enercon E-44 Ca. 7 days/year meteorological icing Ca. 30 days/year instrumental icing Ca. 150 days/year temperature below 0°C Wind turbines equipped with blade heating Ice throw studies | Seite 6 | 2012-02-08
  • 7. Alpine Test Site Gütsch COST Action 727: Atmospheric Icing on Structures 2005 to 2009 Ice throw studies | Seite 7 | 2012-02-08
  • 8. Method After each icing event, the area around the wind turbine is inspected for ice throw. All found ice fragments are recorded -  Distance -  Angle -  Size -  Weight -  Type of ice (rime, glaze, wet snow) -  Photo of ice fragment Ice throw studies | Seite 8 | 2012-02-08
  • 9. Method Ice throw studies | Seite 9 | 2012-02-08
  • 10. Method Ice throw studies | Seite 10 | 2012-02-08
  • 11. Methodik •  Not all events could be captured •  Inspection partly delayed •  Exact time of ice throw unknown •  No distinction between ice throw and ice fall Inspections during 4 winters (2005 bis 2009) à 32 icing events recorded à 228 ice fragments documented à Also during summer Ice throw studies | Seite 11 | 2012-02-08
  • 12. Ice throw study Gütsch Maximum distance: 92m (2.25 rotor diameter) Maximum weight: 1.8 kg Ice throw studies | Seite 12 | 2012-02-08
  • 13. Ice throw study Gütsch Ice throw studies | Seite 13 | 2012-02-08
  • 14. Ice throw study Gütsch Ice throw studies | Seite 14 | 2012-02-08
  • 15. Ice throw study Gütsch Icing Föhn à Risky areas seem to be dependant on wind statistics under icing consitions Ice throw studies | Seite 15 | 2012-02-08
  • 16. Ice throw study Gütsch Types of ice Rime Glaze Wet snow Ice throw studies | Seite 16 | 2012-02-08
  • 17. Ice throw study Gütsch Distance to wind turbine 50% Rotor blade Ice throw studies | Seite 17 | 2012-02-08
  • 18. Ice throw study Gütsch Angle relative to wind turbine Ice throw studies | Seite 18 | 2012-02-08
  • 19. Ice throw study Gütsch Resulta te Ice throw studies | Seite 19 | 2012-02-08
  • 20. Conclusions •  Ice throw occurs •  Wind conditions during icing event define risk areas •  Ice throw when blade is moving downwards? •  50% of ice fragments found under rotor blade •  Heavy ice fragments (> 600 g) under rotor blade •  Ice throw also during summer time à Übertragbarkeit der Resultate auf grössere WEA?? Ice throw studies | Seite 20 | 2012-02-08
  • 21. Counter measures •  Routing of winter walkway was changes •  Warning signs were installed Ice throw studies | Seite 21 | 2012-02-08
  • 22. Conclusions Further study during winter 2011/12 2 Enercon E-82 Hub height 78 m Enercon blade heating St. Brais 1‘100 m asl No real icing events so far Ice throw studies | Seite 22 | 2012-02-08
  • 23. Ice throw model SWIM •  Simple Wind turbine Icethrow Model Ice throw studies | Seite 23 | 2012-02-08
  • 24. Ice throw model SWIM •  Simple Wind turbine Icethrow Model Ice throw studies | Seite 24 | 2012-02-08
  • 25. Ice throw model SWIM •  Simple Wind turbine Icethrow Model Ice throw studies | Seite 25 | 2012-02-08
  • 26. Thank you… METEOTEST …for your attention Fabrikstrasse 14 CH-3012 Bern www.meteotest.ch Ice throw studies | Seite 26 | 2012-02-08