Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Study Guide: "Invoking Justice"


Published on

Study Guide for use in conjunction with Deepa Dhanraj's film, "Invoking Justice." Created for Foreign, Comparative, and International Legal Research seminar at the Louisiana State University Law Center.

Published in: Law
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Study Guide: "Invoking Justice"

  1. 1. RESEARCH SEMINAR IN FOREIGN, COMPARATIVE, AND INTERNATIONAL LAW Spring 2014 Susan Gualtier Foreign, Comparative, and International Law Librarian 225-578-4028 Room L104 Study Guide: Invoking Justice Film Synopsis: Invoking Justice A film by Deepa Dhanraj India, 2011, 85 minutes, Color, DVD, Tamil, Subtitled In Southern India, family disputes are settled by Jamaats—all male bodies which apply Islamic Sharia law to cases without allowing women to be present, even to defend themselves. Recognizing this fundamental inequity, a group of women in 2004 established a women’s Jamaat, which soon became a network of 12,000 members spread over 12 districts. Despite enormous resistance, they have been able to settle more than 8,000 cases to date, ranging from divorce to wife beating to brutal murders and more. Award-winning filmmaker Deepa Dhanraj (SOMETHING LIKE A WAR) follows several cases, shining a light on how the women’s Jamaat has acquired power through both communal education and the leaders’ persistent, tenacious and compassionate investigation of the crimes. In astonishing scenes we watch the Jamaat meetings, where women often shout over each other about the most difficult facets of their personal lives. Above all, the women’s Jamaat exists to hold their male counterparts and local police to account, and to reform a profoundly corrupt system which allows men to take refuge in the most extreme interpretation of the Qur’an to justify violence towards women. AWARDS, FESTIVALS, & SCREENINGS  Film Southasia, QFX Jury Award  Int’l Doc FF Amsterdam (IDFA), International Premiere  One World International Human Rights Documentary Film Festival, Prague  Helsinki Documentary Film Festival  Asian American International Film Festival  San Francisco International Asian American Film Festival  Hawaii International Film Festival
  2. 2. Discussion Points: 1) Why was the women’s Jamaat created? 2) How is it that the women were simply able to set up their own Jamaat? Where do the Jamaats get their authority? 3) Do you think that the women’s Jamaat is respected as much as the men’s Jamaats? Or at all? 4) What do you think of the police role in bringing male litigants before the women’s Jamaat? 5) Do you agree that the women’s Jamaat is acting as a Jamaat in its full capacity? Or are they acting in one or more slightly different capacity (i.e. as “lawyers” representing “clients,” as family law mediators, as a women’s rights advocacy group, etc.?) Is it possible to know whether the women’s Jamaat is acting in its full capacity based solely on the information provided in this film? 6) Did you hear anyone cite any law? How do you think these cases are being decided (i.e. application of “black letter” Sharia law, custom, equity, etc.?) Do you think that the method of adjudication differs between the women’s and men’s Jamaat’s? Is it possible to know? 7) Did you hear anyone refer to any other type of legal system? What are your thoughts on what was said? 8) Would you consider the women’s Jamaat to be “progressive”? Do you think that it is inherently restricted by “complicating factors” (i.e. cultural norms, custom, the poverty of its clientele, the substance of the law, how the law has been applied in the community in the past, etc.?)
  3. 3. 9) How easy do you think it would be to research a case decided in this region? What would some of the obstacles be? How easy do you think it would be to research and sufficiently understand how the Jamaat courts work and what role they serve in the community? What would some of the obstacles be? 10) Regardless of whether you enjoyed the film, do you think it tells the full story of the women’s Jamaat? Is it biased? Did it give you a complete picture of how this region’s legal system works? Did it leave you with any questions regarding how the Jamaats work? What more would you want to know about the region’s legal system or about the women’s Jamaat?