SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
Background:
 Despite being associated with substantial clinical
and economic burdens, as well as adverse effects
on quality of life, lower extremity amputations
(LEAs) are quite common in the United States
(US).1-2
 Nearly 85% of LEAs are above the foot and/or
ankle.3
 Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD) is responsible for
the majority of these amputations.4 Critical limb
ischemia (CLI) is the most advanced form of PAD
with the average amputation rate among PAD-CLI
patients estimated at 25%.5
 Even with multiple endovascular strategies as
alternative options, many CLI patients receive a
LEA as first-line treatment.6
 Limb salvage programs provide an alternative
treatment care pathway for PAD-CLI patients
aimed at preventing LEAs. Moreover, limb salvage
procedures may reduce costs while improving
patient outcomes.
Objective:
 To estimate the potential lifetime economic
savings to a third party payer from the
implementation of a limb salvage program in
the US.
Methods:
 A simulation model was developed in MS Excel to
estimate the direct healthcare cost of
implementing a limb salvage program in the US
for all CLI patients.
 The model was from a third party payer
perspective.
 It was assumed that all the patients undergoing
amputation will be eligible for the limb salvage
program.
 Clinical endpoints were as follows:
– Number of amputations performed
annually1-2 and
– LEA reduction rate associated with a limb
salvage program.
 Cost parameters included:
– Lifetime direct amputation burden and
– Limb salvage program cost estimates.
 All parameter values were obtained from the
published literature and adjusted to 2016 dollars
using the Medical Care Component of the
Consumer Price Index.
Impact of a Limb Salvage Program on the Economic
Burden of Amputation in the United States
Swetha R. Palli, MS1; Candace Gunnarsson, EdD1; Harry Kotlarz, MBA2; Brad J. Martinsen, PhD2; Ruizhi Zhao PhD Candidate2;
John A. Rizzo, PhD3
[1] CTI Clinical Trial and Consulting Services, Cincinnati, OH; [2] Cardiovascular Systems, Inc., St Paul, MN; [3] Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY
Figure 1: Comprehensive Limb Salvage Program
Conclusion:
 The lifetime economic burden of amputees is
substantial. A national limb salvage program
may reduce this burden by $55.3 ($31.5 to
$79.2) billion.
 Policy efforts aimed at limb sparing treatments
for PAD patients may lead to substantial cost
savings while enhancing patients’ quality of life.
References:
1. Wier LM, Steiner CA, Owens PL. Surgeries in Hospital-Owned Outpatient Facilities,
2012. Health Care Cost and Utilization Project. Statistical Brief. 2015; 188.
2. Centers for Disease Control. National Diabetes Statistics Report, 2014. Accessed on
March 10, 2016 at: http://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/pubs/statsreport14/national-diabetes-
report-web.pdf.
3. Dillingham TR, Pezzin LE, Shore AD. Reamputation, mortality, and health care costs
among persons with dysvascular lower-limb amputations. Arch Phys Med Rehabil.
2005; 86(3):480-6.
4. Ziegler-Graham K, MacKenzie EJ, Ephraim PL, Travison TG, Brookmeyer R.
Estimating the prevalence of limb loss in the United States: 2005 to 2050. Arch Phys
Med Rehabil. 2008; 89(3):422-9.
5. Henry AJ, Hevelone ND, Belkin M, Nguyen LL. Socioeconomic and hospital-related
predictors of amputation for critical limb ischemia. J Vasc Surg. 2011; 53(2):330-9.
6. Jindeel A, Narahara KA, Nontraumatic amputation: incidence and cost analysis. Int J
Low Extrem Wounds. 2012; 11(3):177-9.
7. MacKenzie EJ et al. Health-care costs associated with amputation or reconstruction of
a limb-threatening injury. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007; 89(8):1685-92.
8. Sanders LJ, Robbins JM, Edmonds ME. History of the team approach to amputation
prevention: pioneers and milestones. J Vasc Surg. 2010 Sep;52(3 Suppl):3S-16S.
Please contact the authors for information on additional references.
• Evaluation (e.g., ankle branchial index tests)
• Imaging
• Angiography
• Ultrasound
• Angioplasty w/without stents or atherectomy
• Follow-up evaluation and management
Pre-procedure
Endovascular procedure
Post-procedure
Figure 2: Model Scaffold and Parameters
# of Amputations
Lifetime Amputee
Burden
Total Burden
Comprehensive Limb
Salvage Program
Cost/Patient
Limb Salvage
Rate
Lifetime Cost
Savings
Limb Salvage
Rate
Lifetime Cost
Savings
120,000
$794,027
$95.2 Bil
36%
$31.5 Bil
86%
$79.2 Bil
$23,152
Study Support: This study was supported by Cardiovascular Systems, Inc., CSI
Poster presented at ISPOR 21st Annual International Meeting, May 21-25, 2016, Washington, DC USA
Results:
 Approximately 120,000 (119,700 to 121,667) LEA
procedures are performed annually in the US.1-2
 The estimated lifetime direct healthcare cost for
an amputee patient is $794,027.7
 When aggregated for the total number of LEA
patients annually, the expected lifetime cost is
estimated at roughly $95.2 billion USD.
 In the published literature, comprehensive limb
salvage programs are shown to reduce the rate
of amputations from 36% to 86%.8
 Using the midpoint of this reduction (61%) and
accounting for the estimated cost of a
comprehensive limb salvage program ($23,152)
yields aggregate cost savings of $55.3 billion.
(Additional details about the limb salvage
program can be found in Figure 1).
 The reduction in amputations from a formal limb
salvage program is expected to save CMS from
$31.5 billion assuming a 36% salvage rate to
$79.2 billion assuming an 86% salvage rate (See
Figure 2 for more information on the model
calculation).

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

01 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 2017
01 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 201701 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 2017
01 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 2017Michael Bertocchi
 
(K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.]
(K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.](K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.]
(K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.]9261672891
 
eChallenges 2009, Session 10d
eChallenges 2009, Session 10deChallenges 2009, Session 10d
eChallenges 2009, Session 10dStephan Raimer
 
Anwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und Anwendungen
Anwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und AnwendungenAnwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und Anwendungen
Anwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und AnwendungenNicole Eisele
 
Exactitude Teleradiology Solutions - Canada
Exactitude Teleradiology Solutions - CanadaExactitude Teleradiology Solutions - Canada
Exactitude Teleradiology Solutions - CanadaIsmail Siddiqui
 
Automatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rz
Automatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rzAutomatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rz
Automatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rzinoX-tech GmbH
 
Presentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign Investors
Presentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign InvestorsPresentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign Investors
Presentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign InvestorsCecilia Rivas Schuermann
 
Facebook and Security Settings Report
Facebook and Security Settings ReportFacebook and Security Settings Report
Facebook and Security Settings ReportAbhishek Gupta
 
Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017
Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017
Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017Alexis Von Glasow
 

Viewers also liked (15)

final project
final projectfinal project
final project
 
01 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 2017
01 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 201701 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 2017
01 presentation MkFramework AFUP janv 2017
 
RESUME
RESUMERESUME
RESUME
 
(K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.]
(K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.](K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.]
(K 10619) krishna murari yadav (mel-322) [o.p.c.]
 
eChallenges 2009, Session 10d
eChallenges 2009, Session 10deChallenges 2009, Session 10d
eChallenges 2009, Session 10d
 
Anwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und Anwendungen
Anwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und AnwendungenAnwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und Anwendungen
Anwendungsbeispiele mobile Geräte und Anwendungen
 
Digital Signage
Digital Signage Digital Signage
Digital Signage
 
Exactitude Teleradiology Solutions - Canada
Exactitude Teleradiology Solutions - CanadaExactitude Teleradiology Solutions - Canada
Exactitude Teleradiology Solutions - Canada
 
Blog Talk Radio
Blog Talk RadioBlog Talk Radio
Blog Talk Radio
 
Automatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rz
Automatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rzAutomatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rz
Automatisierte Linux installation 0603_version2012_inoxt_rz
 
Fallo De Conexion
Fallo De ConexionFallo De Conexion
Fallo De Conexion
 
Presentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign Investors
Presentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign InvestorsPresentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign Investors
Presentation - USA Exporters Importers and Foreign Investors
 
Facebook and Security Settings Report
Facebook and Security Settings ReportFacebook and Security Settings Report
Facebook and Security Settings Report
 
E2.9 provincia de castello
E2.9 provincia de castelloE2.9 provincia de castello
E2.9 provincia de castello
 
Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017
Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017
Meetup mini conférences AFUP Paris Deezer Janvier 2017
 

Similar to Impact of a Limb Salvage Program on the Economic

Diabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson Publishers
Diabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson PublishersDiabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson Publishers
Diabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson PublishersCrimsonPublishersOPROJ
 
Decision Support Systems & Health Care
Decision Support Systems & Health CareDecision Support Systems & Health Care
Decision Support Systems & Health Careckrampert
 
PSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et al
PSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et alPSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et al
PSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et alDon Buskirk
 
Bioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent Analysis
Bioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent AnalysisBioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent Analysis
Bioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent AnalysisUniversity of Toronto
 
APDS Lecture 2005-10-18
APDS Lecture 2005-10-18APDS Lecture 2005-10-18
APDS Lecture 2005-10-18largess
 
myeloma.pdf
myeloma.pdfmyeloma.pdf
myeloma.pdfLolaWoo
 
Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017
Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017
Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017RubenMariscal3
 
Guidelines for DVT Prophylaxis
Guidelines for DVT ProphylaxisGuidelines for DVT Prophylaxis
Guidelines for DVT ProphylaxisArun Shanbhag
 
Grand Rounds: Univ of Chicago Cardiology
Grand Rounds: Univ of Chicago CardiologyGrand Rounds: Univ of Chicago Cardiology
Grand Rounds: Univ of Chicago CardiologyRobert Poston
 
Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...
Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...
Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...komalicarol
 
Integrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary Syndrome
Integrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary SyndromeIntegrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary Syndrome
Integrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary SyndromeIgnacio Basagoiti
 
Executive Roundtable
Executive RoundtableExecutive Roundtable
Executive RoundtableTodd Tabel
 
Wearable Sensors for Cardiac Rehabilitation
Wearable Sensors for Cardiac RehabilitationWearable Sensors for Cardiac Rehabilitation
Wearable Sensors for Cardiac RehabilitationAshot Melik-Martirosian
 
Building a translational team for impacting public policy Pre-Congress Worksh...
Building a translational team for impacting public policyPre-Congress Worksh...Building a translational team for impacting public policyPre-Congress Worksh...
Building a translational team for impacting public policy Pre-Congress Worksh...OARSI
 

Similar to Impact of a Limb Salvage Program on the Economic (20)

Diabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson Publishers
Diabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson PublishersDiabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson Publishers
Diabetic Foot Ulcers: Where Do We Currently Stand-Crimson Publishers
 
Decision Support Systems & Health Care
Decision Support Systems & Health CareDecision Support Systems & Health Care
Decision Support Systems & Health Care
 
PSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et al
PSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et alPSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et al
PSC_spasticity J of Stroke & Cerebrovascular Dx Oct 2013 Philp et al
 
Hassan nawazish
Hassan nawazishHassan nawazish
Hassan nawazish
 
Pvd abstract
Pvd abstractPvd abstract
Pvd abstract
 
CLEVER Final Manuscript_JACC_17Mar2015
CLEVER Final Manuscript_JACC_17Mar2015CLEVER Final Manuscript_JACC_17Mar2015
CLEVER Final Manuscript_JACC_17Mar2015
 
Bioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent Analysis
Bioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent AnalysisBioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent Analysis
Bioabsorbable Drug-Eluting Cardiac Stent Analysis
 
Waist circumference
Waist circumferenceWaist circumference
Waist circumference
 
APDS Lecture 2005-10-18
APDS Lecture 2005-10-18APDS Lecture 2005-10-18
APDS Lecture 2005-10-18
 
myeloma.pdf
myeloma.pdfmyeloma.pdf
myeloma.pdf
 
Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017
Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017
Guideline for the Prevention of Surgical Site Infection, 2017
 
Guidelines for DVT Prophylaxis
Guidelines for DVT ProphylaxisGuidelines for DVT Prophylaxis
Guidelines for DVT Prophylaxis
 
Grand Rounds: Univ of Chicago Cardiology
Grand Rounds: Univ of Chicago CardiologyGrand Rounds: Univ of Chicago Cardiology
Grand Rounds: Univ of Chicago Cardiology
 
Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...
Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...
Structure and development of a clinical decision support system: application ...
 
Integrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary Syndrome
Integrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary SyndromeIntegrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary Syndrome
Integrative Telerehabilitation Strategy after Acute Coronary Syndrome
 
Wesat2203
Wesat2203Wesat2203
Wesat2203
 
JCO study_Wang_Nov 2011
JCO study_Wang_Nov 2011JCO study_Wang_Nov 2011
JCO study_Wang_Nov 2011
 
Executive Roundtable
Executive RoundtableExecutive Roundtable
Executive Roundtable
 
Wearable Sensors for Cardiac Rehabilitation
Wearable Sensors for Cardiac RehabilitationWearable Sensors for Cardiac Rehabilitation
Wearable Sensors for Cardiac Rehabilitation
 
Building a translational team for impacting public policy Pre-Congress Worksh...
Building a translational team for impacting public policyPre-Congress Worksh...Building a translational team for impacting public policyPre-Congress Worksh...
Building a translational team for impacting public policy Pre-Congress Worksh...
 

Impact of a Limb Salvage Program on the Economic

  • 1. Background:  Despite being associated with substantial clinical and economic burdens, as well as adverse effects on quality of life, lower extremity amputations (LEAs) are quite common in the United States (US).1-2  Nearly 85% of LEAs are above the foot and/or ankle.3  Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD) is responsible for the majority of these amputations.4 Critical limb ischemia (CLI) is the most advanced form of PAD with the average amputation rate among PAD-CLI patients estimated at 25%.5  Even with multiple endovascular strategies as alternative options, many CLI patients receive a LEA as first-line treatment.6  Limb salvage programs provide an alternative treatment care pathway for PAD-CLI patients aimed at preventing LEAs. Moreover, limb salvage procedures may reduce costs while improving patient outcomes. Objective:  To estimate the potential lifetime economic savings to a third party payer from the implementation of a limb salvage program in the US. Methods:  A simulation model was developed in MS Excel to estimate the direct healthcare cost of implementing a limb salvage program in the US for all CLI patients.  The model was from a third party payer perspective.  It was assumed that all the patients undergoing amputation will be eligible for the limb salvage program.  Clinical endpoints were as follows: – Number of amputations performed annually1-2 and – LEA reduction rate associated with a limb salvage program.  Cost parameters included: – Lifetime direct amputation burden and – Limb salvage program cost estimates.  All parameter values were obtained from the published literature and adjusted to 2016 dollars using the Medical Care Component of the Consumer Price Index. Impact of a Limb Salvage Program on the Economic Burden of Amputation in the United States Swetha R. Palli, MS1; Candace Gunnarsson, EdD1; Harry Kotlarz, MBA2; Brad J. Martinsen, PhD2; Ruizhi Zhao PhD Candidate2; John A. Rizzo, PhD3 [1] CTI Clinical Trial and Consulting Services, Cincinnati, OH; [2] Cardiovascular Systems, Inc., St Paul, MN; [3] Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY Figure 1: Comprehensive Limb Salvage Program Conclusion:  The lifetime economic burden of amputees is substantial. A national limb salvage program may reduce this burden by $55.3 ($31.5 to $79.2) billion.  Policy efforts aimed at limb sparing treatments for PAD patients may lead to substantial cost savings while enhancing patients’ quality of life. References: 1. Wier LM, Steiner CA, Owens PL. Surgeries in Hospital-Owned Outpatient Facilities, 2012. Health Care Cost and Utilization Project. Statistical Brief. 2015; 188. 2. Centers for Disease Control. National Diabetes Statistics Report, 2014. Accessed on March 10, 2016 at: http://www.cdc.gov/diabetes/pubs/statsreport14/national-diabetes- report-web.pdf. 3. Dillingham TR, Pezzin LE, Shore AD. Reamputation, mortality, and health care costs among persons with dysvascular lower-limb amputations. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2005; 86(3):480-6. 4. Ziegler-Graham K, MacKenzie EJ, Ephraim PL, Travison TG, Brookmeyer R. Estimating the prevalence of limb loss in the United States: 2005 to 2050. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2008; 89(3):422-9. 5. Henry AJ, Hevelone ND, Belkin M, Nguyen LL. Socioeconomic and hospital-related predictors of amputation for critical limb ischemia. J Vasc Surg. 2011; 53(2):330-9. 6. Jindeel A, Narahara KA, Nontraumatic amputation: incidence and cost analysis. Int J Low Extrem Wounds. 2012; 11(3):177-9. 7. MacKenzie EJ et al. Health-care costs associated with amputation or reconstruction of a limb-threatening injury. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007; 89(8):1685-92. 8. Sanders LJ, Robbins JM, Edmonds ME. History of the team approach to amputation prevention: pioneers and milestones. J Vasc Surg. 2010 Sep;52(3 Suppl):3S-16S. Please contact the authors for information on additional references. • Evaluation (e.g., ankle branchial index tests) • Imaging • Angiography • Ultrasound • Angioplasty w/without stents or atherectomy • Follow-up evaluation and management Pre-procedure Endovascular procedure Post-procedure Figure 2: Model Scaffold and Parameters # of Amputations Lifetime Amputee Burden Total Burden Comprehensive Limb Salvage Program Cost/Patient Limb Salvage Rate Lifetime Cost Savings Limb Salvage Rate Lifetime Cost Savings 120,000 $794,027 $95.2 Bil 36% $31.5 Bil 86% $79.2 Bil $23,152 Study Support: This study was supported by Cardiovascular Systems, Inc., CSI Poster presented at ISPOR 21st Annual International Meeting, May 21-25, 2016, Washington, DC USA Results:  Approximately 120,000 (119,700 to 121,667) LEA procedures are performed annually in the US.1-2  The estimated lifetime direct healthcare cost for an amputee patient is $794,027.7  When aggregated for the total number of LEA patients annually, the expected lifetime cost is estimated at roughly $95.2 billion USD.  In the published literature, comprehensive limb salvage programs are shown to reduce the rate of amputations from 36% to 86%.8  Using the midpoint of this reduction (61%) and accounting for the estimated cost of a comprehensive limb salvage program ($23,152) yields aggregate cost savings of $55.3 billion. (Additional details about the limb salvage program can be found in Figure 1).  The reduction in amputations from a formal limb salvage program is expected to save CMS from $31.5 billion assuming a 36% salvage rate to $79.2 billion assuming an 86% salvage rate (See Figure 2 for more information on the model calculation).