Targeting Private Equity
By STEPHEN BORNSTEINon DECEMBER 16, 2013

Are 2 & 20just not enough?
Are private equity types any...
A case in point is Caesars Entertainment, the casino company1. Caesarswas taken private
byTPG Capital and Apollo in a $30....
annualized return on their total investments during the same period (comprised of stocks @
5.8%,bonds@ 6.6% and real estat...
BROKERS, INVESTMENT ADVISER, SEC REGISTRATION, CAPITAL GAINS, ORDINARY INCOME,
VALUATION, COLLUSION, CLUB DEALS, CLASS ACT...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Targeting Private Equity

204 views

Published on

Are 2 & 20 just not enough?
Are private equity types any different from hedge funders?

The SEC apparently doesn’t think so and, after excoriating the latter for flagrant securities law violations, the regulators are now training their sights on the former.

http://aroundwallstreet.com/2013/12/targeting-private-equity/

Published in: Economy & Finance, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
204
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Targeting Private Equity

  1. 1. Targeting Private Equity By STEPHEN BORNSTEINon DECEMBER 16, 2013 Are 2 & 20just not enough? Are private equity types any different from hedge funders? The SEC apparently doesn’t think so and, after excoriating the latter for flagrant securities law violations, the regulators are now training their sights on the former. In private equity, it’s not insider trading that’s the rub. What has caught the SEC’s attention are the juicy transaction fees PE fund managers have been charging their portfolio companies for arranging their LBOs, interim restructurings and eventual sales. PE is a $3.3 trillion industry. Leveraged buy-outs can run into the tens of $billions. When the deals close, the PE firms take tens of $millions out of the proceeds for their investment banking services. Some PE firms also charge $millions in ongoing “monitoring fees” for overseeing portfolio company operations. Both transaction and monitoring feesare over and above the 2% annual management fees and 20% carried interests that PE firms typically receive. Theadditional fees also constitute a substantial percentage of PE fund operations.KKR, for example, earned nearly $100 million in transactionfees last year -- more than a sixth of its PE revenues -- anda total of $360 million over the past three years. Blackstone also generated $100 million in transactionfees last year -- an eighth of its PEgross -- and collected over $300 million during the past three years.Overall,PE firms have amassed more than $2 billion intransaction feesover the past 10 years. Conflict of Interest The SEC now wants to know why a PE firm’smanagement fees and carried interestsdon’t cover these investment banking services and to what extent, if any,they are being shared with fund investors. The regulators also want to know whether shareholders of the portfolio companies have been advised of these fees before deals areclosed. PE investors are already on the case and have been pressuring their fund managers to give up more of theirIB fees to their limited partners.
  2. 2. A case in point is Caesars Entertainment, the casino company1. Caesarswas taken private byTPG Capital and Apollo in a $30.7 billion LBO in 2008. At the closing, the two PE firms collected a $200 million transaction fee and, since then, have been chargingaround $30 million a year in monitoring fees. The PE firms have kept a third of those fees and given up the balance to their investors. Earlier this year, two of those investors -- the state pension plans of Rhode Island and Oregon-pressedTPG and Apollo to retroactively give up their transaction and monitoring fees in light of the facts that Caesarsisnow saddled with debt and has been losing more than $1.4 billion a year since the buy-out. According to RI Treasurer Gina Raimondo, the $6 billion in equity that the PE firms put into Caesars is now worth only $2.2 billion.She called the fees retained by the two PE firms "a clear misalignment of interest" in light of the fact that fund investors had seen no profits:"[w]hile I understand investing entails risk and not every investment will work, I expect us to sink or swim together." PE’s Defense PE firmsargue that their transaction fees are negotiated with sophisticated counterparties and no one is being exploited. They also point out that, if they don’t own all of the equity in a portfolio company, their investment banking serviceswould effectively be subsidizing the other investors in the company if they were not paid separate transaction fees. What’s more,most of such fees nowadays are being offset against management fees. According to Preqin, a PE data tracker, LBO funds launched in 2012 and 2013 rebate an average of 87% of transaction fees to their investors and about 63% of PE funds now rebate all of their transaction fees to investors. Rebates were at 51% in 2010 and 2011. Monitoring fees are encountering the same resistance. PE fund managers have historically justified these fees by claiming that they relieve portfolio companies from having to pay management consultants for the same services. Nevertheless, according to Pitchbook Data, such fees have fallen precipitously across the entire PE industry since the fourth quarter of last year, thanks largely to the efforts of activist limited partners. Apollo, for example, recently offered 100% rebates on monitoring fees in its newest PE fund. The PE industry also stands by its returns to investors."Private equity is the highest returning asset class for investors—net of fees—over long time horizons," according to a recent study by the Private Equity Growth Capital Council, a PE trade group. The study shows that PE delivered a 10% median annualized return to 146 public pension plans managing more than $1 billion over the last 10 years. By comparison, the surveyed pension plans earned only a 6.5%median 1 Another good example is TXU, a Texas utility, which, in 2007, was taken private in the largest LBO ever ($48 billion) by KKR, TPG and Goldman Sachs which collectively pocketed almost $300 million in transactionfees at the closing. TXU (renamed Energy Future Holdings) is now overloaded with debt and facing bankruptcy.
  3. 3. annualized return on their total investments during the same period (comprised of stocks @ 5.8%,bonds@ 6.6% and real estate@ 6.7%). Broker Registration? The SEC also thinks that PE transaction fees are transaction-based compensation that may require PE fund managers to register as securities brokers(http://aroundwallstreet.com/2013/04/691/). PE firms are currently regulated by the SEC only as investment advisers2 andbroker registration–which is a far more onerousregulatory regime than IA registration -- would undoubtedly be anathema to PE firms. Under US law, a securities broker is any person engaged in the business of effecting transactions in securities for the account of others. One earmark of being a broker isreceivingfees in connection with a securities transaction that are either conditioned on its success or calculated in proportion to its size.According to David Glass, a senior SEC attorney, the receipt of any such fees causes an adviser “to take on a salesman’s stake” which, according to Glass, could be avoidedin PE by offsettingsuchadvisory fees against fund management fees. Other SEC Concerns PE transaction fees are not the only SEC target. The industry is facing scrutiny from Congress over why itscarried interests (http://aroundwallstreet.com/2012/11/curtains-for-carried-interest/) in portfolio companies should be taxed at capital gains rates rather than as ordinary income.Also, regulators areconcerned about inconsistencies in the valuation of illiquid PE assets and the offloading of regular PE management company expenses onto investors through the outsourcing of administrative and other services to independent vendors. Lastly, a number of the most prominent PE firms have been confronted with a class action from erstwhile shareholders in their portfolio companies alleging collusion in club deals designed to depress acquisition prices. All in all, the PE industry offers a potentially rich vein of enforcement opportunity for a revitalized regulator like the SEC which is determined to root out any financial chicanery that, once again, puts even sophisticated investorsat the mercy of Wall Street. TAGS: PRIVATE EQUITY, 2&20, HEDGE FUNDS, SEC, INSIDER TRADING, PE, TRANSACTION FEES, PORTFOLIO COMPANIES, LEVERAGED BUY-OUTS, LBO, MONITORING FEES, MANAGEMENT FEES, CARRIED INTERESTS, KKR, BLACKSTONE, CAESARS ENTERTAINMENT, TXU, TPG CAPITAL, GOLDMAN SACHS, APOLLO, RHODE ISLAND, OREGON, PREQIN, PITCHBOOK DATA, PRIVATE EQUITY GROWTH CAPITAL COUNCIL, TRANSACTION-BASED COMPENSATION, SECURITIES 2 Ironically, the House of Representatives just passed a bill actually exempting PE fund managers from SEC registrationin an effort to facilitate the flow of capital to new and growing businesses. The bill, however, is not expected to survive in the Senate or, even if it did, an Obama veto.
  4. 4. BROKERS, INVESTMENT ADVISER, SEC REGISTRATION, CAPITAL GAINS, ORDINARY INCOME, VALUATION, COLLUSION, CLUB DEALS, CLASS ACTION, OUTSOURCING, WALL STREET

×