SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 37
Download to read offline
Marxism
Prepared by
Smriti
M.Sc (HDCS)
B.Ed ( special
Education
Marxist Anthropology
essentially an economic interpretation of history based on the
works of Karl Marx and Frederich Engels
posits a materialist model of societal change
developed as a critique and alternative to the domination of
Euro-American capitalism and Eurocentric views in the social
sciences.
Change within a society seen as the result of contradictions
arising between the forces of production (technology) and the
relations of production (social organization).
Such contradictions are seen to emerge as a struggle between
distinct social classes
Karl Marx (1818-1883).
The Communist Manifesto (1848)
shows the basic struggle between
classes, and recommends action against
the 'spectre' of capitalism
Capital (1867)
shows how the capitalist system is
exploitative in that it "transfers the
fruit of the work of the majority...to a
minority”
1880 reads Henry Morgan’s Ancient
Society (1877) and became interested in
his evolutionary ideas of society
1883 dies before he can write a book
based on his literary exploration on the
Frederik Engels
1820 - 1895
The Origin of the Family,
Private Property and the
State (1884)
presents the evolution of
humankind from
primitive communism, to
slavery, feudalism,
capitalism, and finally,
industrial communism
Marxist Theory
from Adam Smith
1. social relationships are generated by exchange
2. a person can produce more than he requires for
his own subsistence
3. the power conferred by the ownership of money
is the power to buy other people’s labor
4. while supply and demand may cause the value of
a good to fluctuate, its true or natural value is
determined by the cost of the labour required to
make it.
Marxist Theory
Wrote Capital during the Industrial Revolution in Britain
Much of his analysis is directed at explaining the processes which
give rise to capitalist society
One of the primary concerns with modes of production
Each mode of production has three aspects.
A distinctive principle determining property
A distinctive division of labour
A distinctive principle of exchange
Marx regarded social systems as inherently unstable,
rather than normally existing in a stable condition.
He found the driving force of instability in the
capacity of human beings to produce, by their own
labor more than they needed to subsist on.
He found that the way in which a social system
controlled people’s access to the resources they needed
was equally fundamental.
Marx argued that the market created inequalities
History is marked by the growth of human
productive capacity, and the forms that history
produced for each separate society is a function of
what was needed to maximize productive capacity.
Much of the work of Marx and Engels examined
the conflict generated by the increasing wealth of
the capitalists (Bourgeoisie) at the expense of he
working class (proletariat) who only sunk deeper
into poverty
Marx and Engles viewed history as a sequence of
evolutionary stages, each marked by a unique
mode of production
the history of Europe seen in terms of the
transition from feudalism to capitalism and
eventually to communism
Under the feudal system, which preceded
capitalism, surplus was secured by the legal power
of the feudal lords over the serfs and peasants who
worked in their lands.
Violence and repression could reinforce legal
power if the peasantry resisted handing over the
surplus.
Under capitalism, the extraction of surplus is
managed more subtly through the mechanism of
the wage.
The wage is only equivalent to some of the value of the
worker performed but the labourer;
the remaining ‘surplus value’ is taken by the capitalist in
the form of profits.
Thus, in a capitalist society, the power and wealth of the
dominant class is seen as legitimate, rather than simply
backed by coercion as it was in feudal societies.
What is going on is concealed from the labourers under
the idea of a fair wage for a fair day’s work. – bourgeoise
ideology - class have a vested interest in maintaining their
power and will seek to resist such change
especially through elaboration of mystification in the
ideology, which results in the false consciousness of the
lower class
Marx and Engles viewed social change as an
evolutionary process marked by revolution in which
new levels of social, political and economic development
were achieved through class struggle
A class is defined in terms of the relationship of
people's labour to the means of production
each mode of production produced characteristic class
relationships involving a dominating and a subordinate
class.
These two classes were linked together in a
relationship of exploitation in which the subordinate
class provided the labour and the dominant class then
appropriated the surplus
Capitalism produces a relationship of mutual
dependence between the bourgeoisie and the
proletariat (without labourers the capitalist
cannot make a profit), which is also inherently
antagonistic: the interests of the two main classes
are opposed.
Marx and Engels saw a history of class
relationships in which those who work have been
polarized in opposition to those who control the
means of production
Class in itself vs a class for itself
Marx also maintained that self consciousness
is an attribute of class existence
Consciousness lead to one's group's collective
solidarity, and common interests in relations of
production.
Marx viewed peasants as ambiguous
Marx believed that various tendencies in capitalism
would promote class conflict.
The progressive development of technology would
bring deskilling of jobs,
creating more homogenised and potentially united
labour force;
the relative gap in wealth between the dominant and
subordinate classes would steadily increase;
processes of capital accumulation and competition
would combine to produce ever more extreme crises of
capitalism,
propelling processes of class conflict towards an
ultimate social revolution.
Evolutionary Marxism
Engles states that socioeconomics develops in a series of stages
from primitive communism, slave society, feudalism, capitalism
and finally communism unilineal evolutionism T
The first stage, primitive communism was an aspect of savagery
characterized by a public control and ownership of the
means of production
 and an absence of exploitation and social class.
The next stage, slave society is related to barbarism.
Property is identified with people, to own people is to
have some control and ownership to the means of
production.
Yet, the notion of private property in relation to land did
not exist at this stage of development
 The third stage, feudalism can be seen in Medieval Europe
There is a class distinction made between aristocrats, those
who own land and serfs the subjects of the aristocrats.
Aristocrats own the land and distribute it among their loyal
serfs. Thus, there is property related to land, and to control
and own this property is related to the control and ownership
to the means of production (i.e. the serfs)
The capitalist stage is the current stage of society. The final
stage (Communism) is yet to come
At this stage there are two classes: the bourgeoisie, the ones who
control and own the means to production;
and the proletariat, those who most sell their labor to the
bourgeoisie..
Evolutionary Marxism
believed that Morgan’s evolutionary stages of human
culture with material achievements and technology
validated their evolutionary theory
Marx and Engels gave currency to the idea of
primitive communism.
argued that the real basis of social and political
inequality was property,
and that since there was no private property in
primitive societies, there was no state and no class or
inequality
19th
century evolutionism discredited in USA in 1930s and
1940s
He retained Marx’s causal paradigm, recognizing three
subsystems of culture: technology, social relations and
ideology.
Technology drives change in the social system
And social life shapes ideology
changed Marx’s emphasis on the control of human labour
and access to productive resources with the idea that the
decisive force driving social evolution was the control of
energy
Leslie White
Peter Worseley
1956 published a Marxist reinterpretation of Meyer Fortes’sanalysis of
the Tallensi (Ghana) society
The Tallensi of are subsistence farmers who traditionally lacked
centralized leadership..
Fortes said that men worked the land of their fathers because ancestors
graves were built on it for religious reasons I.e. functional
He proposed a more practical reason for people’s attachment to the land.
Worsely Showed that Tallensi young men returned to their father’s
homestead when he reached old because of a the desire to inherit the
right to farm some of this land.
Worsely demonstrated how Marx’s axiom that control of the means of
production conferred power, elucidated the economic basis of lineage
organization in small scale societies
STRUCTURAL MARXISM
mid 1960s in France, the Netherlands and Britain,
structuralism was the dominate theory in anthropology
French philosopher Louis Althusser and sociologist
Maurice Godelier merged Structuralism with Marxism
introduced into British anthropology by Jonathan
Friedman in 1974, with his article “Marxism, Structuralism
and Vulgar Materialism
Friedman believed, like Marx, that society is formed by the
conflict (or absence of conflict) between the infrastructure,
the forces of production and the relations of production; and
the superstructure, the juridico-political and the ideological
Thus we have the binary opposition
Neo-Marxists
Neo-Marxists argued that polarized classes analogous to those
detected by Marx and Engels under early capitalism could also be
detected among across virtually the whole range of pre-capitalist
societies.
Thus African societies, presented in harmonious coherence by
earlier functionalist ethnographers were now shown to be riven
with conflict and class struggle.
To the extent that male elders appropriated the surplus labour of
their juniors and of women, they were seen to be exploiting class
(or at least they could qualify as a class)in itself,
This work valuable in exposing the implicit bias of functionalist
accounts
Many contemporary theories have come to rely on Marxists
insights particularly true of cultural ecologists, and neo-
materialists, feminist and postmodern thinkers
Characteristics of Marxist studies
1. A focus on issues of structures of power and exploitation
2. A concern with conflict and change
3. A starting point in the material system of production and
ownership of property
4. An analysis of action as political power struggles between
social groups defined by their control of property
5. Various ways in which class, identity, and local struggles
intersect
Immanuel Wallerstein
The Modern World-System, 1974
looked at how the capitalist
systems penetrated non-
capitalist systems, using a
binary distinction between the
core area and the peripheral
area
argued that world economies
linked by exchange relations
were largely impossible before
about 1500
The capitalist world economy which appeared around 1500
coincided with the expansion of commerce
the states of Northwestern Europe were able to impose a regional
division of labor and specialization of production - e.g. sugar in the
Caribbean, bullion in the Andes, and cereals in Eastern Europe
and, through increasingly powerful state bureaucracies, to
consolidate the flow of surplus toward the core countries
The world system theory told anthropologists to examine the
history of cultural conflicts to understand the change in any
given cultural area
Political Economy
Critical analysis of economic
and power relationships between
different human populations:
 flow of wealth, labor,
population in the world
 dominance and movement of
capital and commodities
 construction of ideologies and
ritual symbolisms that
support or contest the ‘World
System’ (the international
division of labor)
1950s and early 1960s any association with Marxism was
career threatening
In the 1960s there was a revolt against anthropological
tradition.
It arose along with
the civil rights movement,
the protest against the Vietnam War,
the growth of the women's movement and the other
features of those turbulent times.
Starting in the late 1960s radical social movements
emerged on a vast scale. First was the counter culture
Everything that was part of the existing order was questioned.
The writings of Marx had been largely ignored by anthropologists
but in the late 60s and early 70s they were rediscovered
Radical Critique
The turn toward Marxist analyses coincided with changes
in the empirical base of the discipline - the fieldwork
situation
These changes were underwritten by
(1)the ongoing decolonization of Third World countries,
(2) the reorientation of funding opportunities toward social
problems in the United States,
(3) the politicization of native peoples at home and abroad,
and
(4) the emergence of various indigenous and advocacy
groups including the International Work Group for
Indigenous Affairs (IWGIA) in 1968 and Cultural
Survival in 1972
our society with its world view, its taken for granted
knowledge derived from the capitalist mode of
production, influences the people who practice a
particular science and the further development of that
field
In anthropology the earliest critiques took the form of
denouncing the historical links between anthropology on
the one hand and colonialism and imperialism on the
other.
 passionate commitment to the powerless and to change
"Anthropology since its inception has contained a dual but
contradictory heritage. On the one hand it derives from a
humanistic tradition of concern with people. On the other
hand, anthropology is a discipline developed alongside and
within the growth of the colonial and imperial powers. By
what they have studied (and what they have not studied)
anthropologists have assisted in, or at least acquiesced to, the
goals of imperialist policy. It is becoming increasingly
apparent to many that these two traditions are in
contradiction."
In 1969, the Radical Caucus of the American Anthropological
Association presented a resolution to the Association's annual
meeting which began:
How do we assess the claims of a discipline which
writes accounts of "cultures" abstracted from the
contexts of capitalism and imperialism, racism and
domination, war and revolution?
The reality is that anthropology is the offspring of
colonialism, and reflects a state of affairs in which one
part of humanity treats the other as an object and in
which the anthropologist is her/himself a victim and
her/his power of decision is a fiction, embedded as it is in
the exploitative foundations of our society.
Eric Wolf
Europe and the People without History
(1982)
A Critique of Civilization as a
responses to appeals from indigenous
peoples to seek out the actual nature of
the roots of the exploitative and
oppressive conditions which are forced
on humanity
Wolf emphasized the importance of the
social relations that structured the
organization of production and the
distribution of goods and labor within
and between societies
terms of Marx's concept of the mode of production in order to
delineate] the central processes at work in the interaction of
Europeans with the majority of the world's peoples
In his view, the motor for the rise of international
capitalism was located in the West, and the system
itself was built on exploitation, enslavement, genocide,
and the formation of class structures and states
It also involved ethnogenesis - the creation of peoples
without history both inside and outside Europe
Critique
How important is class and inequality in social life
in many societies, kinship, religion, and ethnicity seem to have
provided stronger connections than has class
Has been criticized on its definition of ideology which puts it forth
as a plot created by the ruling class to mystify the lower class; this is
not likely since the rulers also subscribe to the ideology.
Further, how the ideology spreads is also unclear, as its relation to
other forms of knowledge
Another problem that Marxism has faced is in the evaluation of
societies that do not possess any classes; how and why did 'primitive
communism' change without a conflict of classes?
Marx’s framework cannot deal adequately with other
dimensions of inequality. To conceptualize a society as mode of
production is inevitably to privilege economic relations over other
aspects of inequality. There is more than simply the class struggle
going on in society
Links of kinship religion, ethnicity and nation, have all tended to
seem more powerful than links of classs.
Marx's 11th Thesis on
Feuerbach in mind: that the
philosophers have interpreted the
world, in various ways; the point,
however, is to change it.
Steward
Comaroff
Mintz

More Related Content

What's hot

Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemony
Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemonyGramsci's theory of cultural hegemony
Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemonyTara_S
 
Marxism by Rameez Ahmed
Marxism by Rameez AhmedMarxism by Rameez Ahmed
Marxism by Rameez AhmedRameez Ahmed
 
Socialism
SocialismSocialism
Socialismjrwv
 
Marxist feminist theory
Marxist feminist theoryMarxist feminist theory
Marxist feminist theoryCarl Niblock
 
Antonio Gramsci
Antonio GramsciAntonio Gramsci
Antonio Gramscibrianbelen
 
Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)
Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)
Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)Saman Ijaz
 
Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt
Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt
Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt Sikandar Jan
 
Marxism & capitalism
Marxism & capitalismMarxism & capitalism
Marxism & capitalismemclem
 
Gramsci and hegemony
Gramsci and hegemonyGramsci and hegemony
Gramsci and hegemonyNWsociology
 
Karl Marx and conflict theory
Karl Marx and conflict theoryKarl Marx and conflict theory
Karl Marx and conflict theorySajjad Mehdi
 
Critical Theory - Frankfurt School
Critical Theory - Frankfurt SchoolCritical Theory - Frankfurt School
Critical Theory - Frankfurt SchoolAsif Sultan Razu
 
Dialectical materialism by Man Bahadur Shahi
Dialectical materialism by Man Bahadur ShahiDialectical materialism by Man Bahadur Shahi
Dialectical materialism by Man Bahadur ShahiMBSHAHI
 
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISMPOLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISMGeorge Dumitrache
 

What's hot (20)

Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemony
Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemonyGramsci's theory of cultural hegemony
Gramsci's theory of cultural hegemony
 
Marxism by Rameez Ahmed
Marxism by Rameez AhmedMarxism by Rameez Ahmed
Marxism by Rameez Ahmed
 
Socialism
SocialismSocialism
Socialism
 
Feminism
FeminismFeminism
Feminism
 
Marxist feminist theory
Marxist feminist theoryMarxist feminist theory
Marxist feminist theory
 
Antonio Gramsci
Antonio GramsciAntonio Gramsci
Antonio Gramsci
 
Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)
Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)
Post Structuralism (Derrida, Foucault, Jean)
 
Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt
Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt
Class struggle By Karl Marx ppt
 
Marxism & capitalism
Marxism & capitalismMarxism & capitalism
Marxism & capitalism
 
Gramsci and hegemony
Gramsci and hegemonyGramsci and hegemony
Gramsci and hegemony
 
Feminism Theory
Feminism TheoryFeminism Theory
Feminism Theory
 
Karl Marx and conflict theory
Karl Marx and conflict theoryKarl Marx and conflict theory
Karl Marx and conflict theory
 
Marxism
MarxismMarxism
Marxism
 
who is karl marx
who is karl marxwho is karl marx
who is karl marx
 
Theory of class conflict
Theory of class conflictTheory of class conflict
Theory of class conflict
 
Michel foucault
Michel foucault Michel foucault
Michel foucault
 
Critical Theory - Frankfurt School
Critical Theory - Frankfurt SchoolCritical Theory - Frankfurt School
Critical Theory - Frankfurt School
 
Marxism
Marxism Marxism
Marxism
 
Dialectical materialism by Man Bahadur Shahi
Dialectical materialism by Man Bahadur ShahiDialectical materialism by Man Bahadur Shahi
Dialectical materialism by Man Bahadur Shahi
 
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISMPOLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISM
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES - MARXISM
 

Similar to Marxism

Similar to Marxism (10)

Powerpoint
PowerpointPowerpoint
Powerpoint
 
Ayesha Ghafoor Presentation#1.pptx
Ayesha Ghafoor Presentation#1.pptxAyesha Ghafoor Presentation#1.pptx
Ayesha Ghafoor Presentation#1.pptx
 
Indian and western sociologists
Indian and western sociologistsIndian and western sociologists
Indian and western sociologists
 
Karl Marx Theories and Ideas
Karl Marx Theories and IdeasKarl Marx Theories and Ideas
Karl Marx Theories and Ideas
 
Marxism and its application
Marxism and its applicationMarxism and its application
Marxism and its application
 
Communism
CommunismCommunism
Communism
 
Marxism and its ideology
Marxism and its ideologyMarxism and its ideology
Marxism and its ideology
 
Marxist
MarxistMarxist
Marxist
 
Karl marx
Karl marxKarl marx
Karl marx
 
Essay On Marxism
Essay On MarxismEssay On Marxism
Essay On Marxism
 

More from Smriti Singh

Mental illness and mental retardation ppt
Mental illness and mental retardation pptMental illness and mental retardation ppt
Mental illness and mental retardation pptSmriti Singh
 
Red ribbon hiv aids in adolescents
Red ribbon   hiv aids in adolescentsRed ribbon   hiv aids in adolescents
Red ribbon hiv aids in adolescentsSmriti Singh
 
Teenage pregnancy....
Teenage pregnancy....Teenage pregnancy....
Teenage pregnancy....Smriti Singh
 
Prenatal development ppt (2) final
Prenatal development ppt (2) finalPrenatal development ppt (2) final
Prenatal development ppt (2) finalSmriti Singh
 
Universal design-for-learning
Universal design-for-learningUniversal design-for-learning
Universal design-for-learningSmriti Singh
 

More from Smriti Singh (7)

Mental illness and mental retardation ppt
Mental illness and mental retardation pptMental illness and mental retardation ppt
Mental illness and mental retardation ppt
 
Red ribbon hiv aids in adolescents
Red ribbon   hiv aids in adolescentsRed ribbon   hiv aids in adolescents
Red ribbon hiv aids in adolescents
 
Teenage pregnancy....
Teenage pregnancy....Teenage pregnancy....
Teenage pregnancy....
 
Prenatal development ppt (2) final
Prenatal development ppt (2) finalPrenatal development ppt (2) final
Prenatal development ppt (2) final
 
Apgar score
Apgar scoreApgar score
Apgar score
 
Time out aba
Time out  abaTime out  aba
Time out aba
 
Universal design-for-learning
Universal design-for-learningUniversal design-for-learning
Universal design-for-learning
 

Recently uploaded

SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..
SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..
SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..InnaLaurie
 
Choosing the Right Control Panel for Pump Systems
Choosing the Right Control Panel for Pump SystemsChoosing the Right Control Panel for Pump Systems
Choosing the Right Control Panel for Pump Systemsindiailios6
 
Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...
Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...
Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...Patagonia4
 
LIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTH
LIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTHLIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTH
LIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTHYouthLab
 
Owen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdf
Owen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdfOwen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdf
Owen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdfBlog Halt
 
wearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearables
wearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearableswearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearables
wearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearablesbusinessenquiryn2023
 
The forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forest
The forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forestThe forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forest
The forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forestdigitalnehasharma09
 
Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!
Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!
Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!mohit635000
 

Recently uploaded (8)

SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..
SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..
SnapSEX - best online dating site 2024..
 
Choosing the Right Control Panel for Pump Systems
Choosing the Right Control Panel for Pump SystemsChoosing the Right Control Panel for Pump Systems
Choosing the Right Control Panel for Pump Systems
 
Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...
Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...
Pro Stroke Bold Black Liquid Eyeliner,...
 
LIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTH
LIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTHLIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTH
LIFE BALANCE: A DIVE INTO EMERGING ASPIRATIONS ACROSS INDONESIA'S YOUTH
 
Owen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdf
Owen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdfOwen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdf
Owen Wilson's Crooked Nose – An Endearing Quirk of a Hollywood Icon.pdf
 
wearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearables
wearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearableswearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearables
wearables best workout clothes/Nauticon wearables
 
The forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forest
The forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forestThe forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forest
The forest holds memories she found herself in a sunny forest
 
Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!
Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!
Sit Back and Relax: Elevate Your Events with Our Plastic Chair Collection!
 

Marxism

  • 2. Marxist Anthropology essentially an economic interpretation of history based on the works of Karl Marx and Frederich Engels posits a materialist model of societal change developed as a critique and alternative to the domination of Euro-American capitalism and Eurocentric views in the social sciences. Change within a society seen as the result of contradictions arising between the forces of production (technology) and the relations of production (social organization). Such contradictions are seen to emerge as a struggle between distinct social classes
  • 3. Karl Marx (1818-1883). The Communist Manifesto (1848) shows the basic struggle between classes, and recommends action against the 'spectre' of capitalism Capital (1867) shows how the capitalist system is exploitative in that it "transfers the fruit of the work of the majority...to a minority” 1880 reads Henry Morgan’s Ancient Society (1877) and became interested in his evolutionary ideas of society 1883 dies before he can write a book based on his literary exploration on the
  • 4. Frederik Engels 1820 - 1895 The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (1884) presents the evolution of humankind from primitive communism, to slavery, feudalism, capitalism, and finally, industrial communism
  • 5. Marxist Theory from Adam Smith 1. social relationships are generated by exchange 2. a person can produce more than he requires for his own subsistence 3. the power conferred by the ownership of money is the power to buy other people’s labor 4. while supply and demand may cause the value of a good to fluctuate, its true or natural value is determined by the cost of the labour required to make it.
  • 6. Marxist Theory Wrote Capital during the Industrial Revolution in Britain Much of his analysis is directed at explaining the processes which give rise to capitalist society One of the primary concerns with modes of production Each mode of production has three aspects. A distinctive principle determining property A distinctive division of labour A distinctive principle of exchange
  • 7. Marx regarded social systems as inherently unstable, rather than normally existing in a stable condition. He found the driving force of instability in the capacity of human beings to produce, by their own labor more than they needed to subsist on. He found that the way in which a social system controlled people’s access to the resources they needed was equally fundamental. Marx argued that the market created inequalities
  • 8. History is marked by the growth of human productive capacity, and the forms that history produced for each separate society is a function of what was needed to maximize productive capacity. Much of the work of Marx and Engels examined the conflict generated by the increasing wealth of the capitalists (Bourgeoisie) at the expense of he working class (proletariat) who only sunk deeper into poverty Marx and Engles viewed history as a sequence of evolutionary stages, each marked by a unique mode of production
  • 9. the history of Europe seen in terms of the transition from feudalism to capitalism and eventually to communism Under the feudal system, which preceded capitalism, surplus was secured by the legal power of the feudal lords over the serfs and peasants who worked in their lands. Violence and repression could reinforce legal power if the peasantry resisted handing over the surplus. Under capitalism, the extraction of surplus is managed more subtly through the mechanism of the wage.
  • 10. The wage is only equivalent to some of the value of the worker performed but the labourer; the remaining ‘surplus value’ is taken by the capitalist in the form of profits. Thus, in a capitalist society, the power and wealth of the dominant class is seen as legitimate, rather than simply backed by coercion as it was in feudal societies. What is going on is concealed from the labourers under the idea of a fair wage for a fair day’s work. – bourgeoise ideology - class have a vested interest in maintaining their power and will seek to resist such change especially through elaboration of mystification in the ideology, which results in the false consciousness of the lower class
  • 11. Marx and Engles viewed social change as an evolutionary process marked by revolution in which new levels of social, political and economic development were achieved through class struggle A class is defined in terms of the relationship of people's labour to the means of production each mode of production produced characteristic class relationships involving a dominating and a subordinate class. These two classes were linked together in a relationship of exploitation in which the subordinate class provided the labour and the dominant class then appropriated the surplus
  • 12. Capitalism produces a relationship of mutual dependence between the bourgeoisie and the proletariat (without labourers the capitalist cannot make a profit), which is also inherently antagonistic: the interests of the two main classes are opposed. Marx and Engels saw a history of class relationships in which those who work have been polarized in opposition to those who control the means of production
  • 13. Class in itself vs a class for itself Marx also maintained that self consciousness is an attribute of class existence Consciousness lead to one's group's collective solidarity, and common interests in relations of production. Marx viewed peasants as ambiguous
  • 14. Marx believed that various tendencies in capitalism would promote class conflict. The progressive development of technology would bring deskilling of jobs, creating more homogenised and potentially united labour force; the relative gap in wealth between the dominant and subordinate classes would steadily increase; processes of capital accumulation and competition would combine to produce ever more extreme crises of capitalism, propelling processes of class conflict towards an ultimate social revolution.
  • 15. Evolutionary Marxism Engles states that socioeconomics develops in a series of stages from primitive communism, slave society, feudalism, capitalism and finally communism unilineal evolutionism T The first stage, primitive communism was an aspect of savagery characterized by a public control and ownership of the means of production  and an absence of exploitation and social class. The next stage, slave society is related to barbarism. Property is identified with people, to own people is to have some control and ownership to the means of production. Yet, the notion of private property in relation to land did not exist at this stage of development
  • 16.  The third stage, feudalism can be seen in Medieval Europe There is a class distinction made between aristocrats, those who own land and serfs the subjects of the aristocrats. Aristocrats own the land and distribute it among their loyal serfs. Thus, there is property related to land, and to control and own this property is related to the control and ownership to the means of production (i.e. the serfs) The capitalist stage is the current stage of society. The final stage (Communism) is yet to come At this stage there are two classes: the bourgeoisie, the ones who control and own the means to production; and the proletariat, those who most sell their labor to the bourgeoisie.. Evolutionary Marxism
  • 17. believed that Morgan’s evolutionary stages of human culture with material achievements and technology validated their evolutionary theory Marx and Engels gave currency to the idea of primitive communism. argued that the real basis of social and political inequality was property, and that since there was no private property in primitive societies, there was no state and no class or inequality
  • 18. 19th century evolutionism discredited in USA in 1930s and 1940s He retained Marx’s causal paradigm, recognizing three subsystems of culture: technology, social relations and ideology. Technology drives change in the social system And social life shapes ideology changed Marx’s emphasis on the control of human labour and access to productive resources with the idea that the decisive force driving social evolution was the control of energy Leslie White
  • 19. Peter Worseley 1956 published a Marxist reinterpretation of Meyer Fortes’sanalysis of the Tallensi (Ghana) society The Tallensi of are subsistence farmers who traditionally lacked centralized leadership.. Fortes said that men worked the land of their fathers because ancestors graves were built on it for religious reasons I.e. functional He proposed a more practical reason for people’s attachment to the land. Worsely Showed that Tallensi young men returned to their father’s homestead when he reached old because of a the desire to inherit the right to farm some of this land. Worsely demonstrated how Marx’s axiom that control of the means of production conferred power, elucidated the economic basis of lineage organization in small scale societies
  • 20. STRUCTURAL MARXISM mid 1960s in France, the Netherlands and Britain, structuralism was the dominate theory in anthropology French philosopher Louis Althusser and sociologist Maurice Godelier merged Structuralism with Marxism introduced into British anthropology by Jonathan Friedman in 1974, with his article “Marxism, Structuralism and Vulgar Materialism Friedman believed, like Marx, that society is formed by the conflict (or absence of conflict) between the infrastructure, the forces of production and the relations of production; and the superstructure, the juridico-political and the ideological Thus we have the binary opposition
  • 21. Neo-Marxists Neo-Marxists argued that polarized classes analogous to those detected by Marx and Engels under early capitalism could also be detected among across virtually the whole range of pre-capitalist societies. Thus African societies, presented in harmonious coherence by earlier functionalist ethnographers were now shown to be riven with conflict and class struggle. To the extent that male elders appropriated the surplus labour of their juniors and of women, they were seen to be exploiting class (or at least they could qualify as a class)in itself, This work valuable in exposing the implicit bias of functionalist accounts
  • 22. Many contemporary theories have come to rely on Marxists insights particularly true of cultural ecologists, and neo- materialists, feminist and postmodern thinkers Characteristics of Marxist studies 1. A focus on issues of structures of power and exploitation 2. A concern with conflict and change 3. A starting point in the material system of production and ownership of property 4. An analysis of action as political power struggles between social groups defined by their control of property 5. Various ways in which class, identity, and local struggles intersect
  • 23. Immanuel Wallerstein The Modern World-System, 1974 looked at how the capitalist systems penetrated non- capitalist systems, using a binary distinction between the core area and the peripheral area argued that world economies linked by exchange relations were largely impossible before about 1500 The capitalist world economy which appeared around 1500 coincided with the expansion of commerce the states of Northwestern Europe were able to impose a regional division of labor and specialization of production - e.g. sugar in the Caribbean, bullion in the Andes, and cereals in Eastern Europe
  • 24. and, through increasingly powerful state bureaucracies, to consolidate the flow of surplus toward the core countries The world system theory told anthropologists to examine the history of cultural conflicts to understand the change in any given cultural area
  • 25. Political Economy Critical analysis of economic and power relationships between different human populations:  flow of wealth, labor, population in the world  dominance and movement of capital and commodities  construction of ideologies and ritual symbolisms that support or contest the ‘World System’ (the international division of labor)
  • 26.
  • 27. 1950s and early 1960s any association with Marxism was career threatening In the 1960s there was a revolt against anthropological tradition. It arose along with the civil rights movement, the protest against the Vietnam War, the growth of the women's movement and the other features of those turbulent times. Starting in the late 1960s radical social movements emerged on a vast scale. First was the counter culture Everything that was part of the existing order was questioned. The writings of Marx had been largely ignored by anthropologists but in the late 60s and early 70s they were rediscovered Radical Critique
  • 28. The turn toward Marxist analyses coincided with changes in the empirical base of the discipline - the fieldwork situation These changes were underwritten by (1)the ongoing decolonization of Third World countries, (2) the reorientation of funding opportunities toward social problems in the United States, (3) the politicization of native peoples at home and abroad, and (4) the emergence of various indigenous and advocacy groups including the International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs (IWGIA) in 1968 and Cultural Survival in 1972
  • 29. our society with its world view, its taken for granted knowledge derived from the capitalist mode of production, influences the people who practice a particular science and the further development of that field In anthropology the earliest critiques took the form of denouncing the historical links between anthropology on the one hand and colonialism and imperialism on the other.  passionate commitment to the powerless and to change
  • 30. "Anthropology since its inception has contained a dual but contradictory heritage. On the one hand it derives from a humanistic tradition of concern with people. On the other hand, anthropology is a discipline developed alongside and within the growth of the colonial and imperial powers. By what they have studied (and what they have not studied) anthropologists have assisted in, or at least acquiesced to, the goals of imperialist policy. It is becoming increasingly apparent to many that these two traditions are in contradiction." In 1969, the Radical Caucus of the American Anthropological Association presented a resolution to the Association's annual meeting which began:
  • 31. How do we assess the claims of a discipline which writes accounts of "cultures" abstracted from the contexts of capitalism and imperialism, racism and domination, war and revolution? The reality is that anthropology is the offspring of colonialism, and reflects a state of affairs in which one part of humanity treats the other as an object and in which the anthropologist is her/himself a victim and her/his power of decision is a fiction, embedded as it is in the exploitative foundations of our society.
  • 32. Eric Wolf Europe and the People without History (1982) A Critique of Civilization as a responses to appeals from indigenous peoples to seek out the actual nature of the roots of the exploitative and oppressive conditions which are forced on humanity Wolf emphasized the importance of the social relations that structured the organization of production and the distribution of goods and labor within and between societies terms of Marx's concept of the mode of production in order to delineate] the central processes at work in the interaction of Europeans with the majority of the world's peoples
  • 33. In his view, the motor for the rise of international capitalism was located in the West, and the system itself was built on exploitation, enslavement, genocide, and the formation of class structures and states It also involved ethnogenesis - the creation of peoples without history both inside and outside Europe
  • 34. Critique How important is class and inequality in social life in many societies, kinship, religion, and ethnicity seem to have provided stronger connections than has class Has been criticized on its definition of ideology which puts it forth as a plot created by the ruling class to mystify the lower class; this is not likely since the rulers also subscribe to the ideology. Further, how the ideology spreads is also unclear, as its relation to other forms of knowledge Another problem that Marxism has faced is in the evaluation of societies that do not possess any classes; how and why did 'primitive communism' change without a conflict of classes?
  • 35. Marx’s framework cannot deal adequately with other dimensions of inequality. To conceptualize a society as mode of production is inevitably to privilege economic relations over other aspects of inequality. There is more than simply the class struggle going on in society Links of kinship religion, ethnicity and nation, have all tended to seem more powerful than links of classs.
  • 36. Marx's 11th Thesis on Feuerbach in mind: that the philosophers have interpreted the world, in various ways; the point, however, is to change it.