Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Cryptocurrencies - playing the cards right

99 views

Published on

Simon Lelieveldt, a regulatory consultant in payments and banking, contributed to the April 2014 Bitcoin meetup in Amsterdam with a presentation on the relevant legal underpinnings of any payment system (Frijda, 1914). He showed how even playing cards have become payment instruments in the past.

Simon compared the bitcoin emergence to e-money discussions of the 1990s and stressed the relevance of good governance to wrap up with the statement that the idea(l) of no regulation for bitcoin would be a useless myth.

Published in: Economy & Finance
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

Cryptocurrencies - playing the cards right

  1. 1. Cryptocurrencies Playing the cards right Simon Lelieveldt @finhstamsterdam
  2. 2. • Postbank – ING • Dutch central bank / supervisor (DNB) • SL Consultancy • Dutch Bankers Association (NVB) • Independent Regulatory Consultant • Retail Payments • Supervision of e-money: Chipper/Chipknip • Development of e-money & Payment Services Directives • Financial supervision and compliance • Financial History (of Amsterdam)
  3. 3. The Amsterdam Exchange Bank (1609)
  4. 4. Money in Quebec (1685) • Redeemed: 1717, Paris
  5. 5. US Coinage Act of 1873
  6. 6. Theory of money (1914) • Discussion on the nature of bank notes • State-proclaimed is the essence ? • Convertability into valuable commodity ? • Acceptance with the public ?
  7. 7. Theory of money (1914) • Discussion on the nature of bank notes • State-proclaimed is the essence ? • Convertability into valuable commodity ? • Acceptance with the public ?
  8. 8. Some lessons learnt, over time 1. Any type of token will work: acceptance by the public is key 2. State and legal systems should not be flawed (property-justice) 3. Value of coins/money in circulation must match their economic use 4. Private sector organisations can also instill trust and stability 5. Anonymous (value) exchange systems will always take off quickly
  9. 9. This time it’s different ? E- money • Regulators jump to impose supervision • Some sectors avoided the supervisory regime • Private schemes with broad and solid governance rules • Anonymous systems subject to investigation / liquidation • No value effect due to 1:1 conversion with fiat currency Crypto-currencies • Some regulators regulate as far as financial service is the result • Companies seek to be included in the supervisory regime • Insufficient governance built into crowd-based design • Silk Road / Increasing trend to identify customers • Monetary side effects due to design choices on circulation size
  10. 10. Three main topics Regulation • FINCEN • ECB • Many central banks • NYC State regulator MSB • Germany Compliance • Western Union • Dwolla • Rabobank • Swedbank • Apple • USAA Bank • Wolfsberg group Cryptocurrency Market Governance
  11. 11. The landscape
  12. 12. Regulation - compliance • Now: the money transmitter route (betaaldienstverlener) • Combined with future legislation: access to bank accounts • Future question: digital contracts, tradeability – markets • Money transmitters vs regulated markets (exchange) regulation?
  13. 13. Playing the cards right …. • A weak governance model is also some form of governance • The ‘no regulation’ idea is a useless myth • Steering clear from regulation might leave one empty-handed

×