1. SESSION 3
Future opportunites & initiatives on
Climate Change in healthcare
In conjunction with The NHS Sustainability Day Campaign
#NHSClimateChange
3. Can Behaviour Change Make a Difference?
Health Care’s Climate Footprint
Healthcare Without Harm / Arup 2019
4. We all want to make a difference
To what extent do you agree that individual behaviour to support the
environment, such as improving resource efficiency, reducing carbon emissions
and reducing waste, is important?
5. Most of us don’t think we can
Do you see opportunities within your current role to help the hospital become a
more sustainable organisation?
6. Most of us don’t think we can
What do you consider the most important barriers to improving sustainability in
your area of work?
10. 817 pledges so far this year
Whilst on the subject of plastic reduction, on
Critical Care we have/are in the process of
implementing the following:
• Paper Drinking straws are replacing plastic
• Critical Care branded china mugs have been
purchased to replace plastic cups for staff,
visitors and some patients. (some plastic
will have to stay for certain patients)
• The disposable single use plastic trays are
being replaced by reusable trays that can be
Clinell wiped clean between each patient
(IP approved)
16. Rise of plant-based food
Number of UK vegans quadrupled in 4 years to 2018
Predicted that vegans/vegetarians will make up 25% of UK population by 2025
1 in 3 people have stopped or reduced their meat consumption
17. Climate crisis – scale of emergency
IPCC warned only 12 years to avert catastrophic climate change – last
year
Urgent need to keep global warming under 1.5 C – currently on track for 3
C rise!
Biodiversity crisis – habitats being lost & average wildlife populations
dropped by 60% in 40 years
We need to act now!
18. Vegan diet is the most sustainable diet on all metrics:
• Greenhouse gas emissions
• Amazon rainforest deforestation
• Land usage
• Water usage & eutrophication
2018 Oxford Uni study: “Switching to a vegan diet is the
single biggest way to reduce your impact on the planet.”
Committee on Climate Change: “Public sector should take a strong lead by
offering plant-based food
Climate crisis – plant-based food can help
19. Plant-based diets have many health benefits,
including being less likely to develop:
• Type-2 diabetes
• Heart disease
• Some types of cancer (e.g. prostate)
• High blood pressure
• High cholesterol levels
Public health
British Dietetic Association (BDA) confirm that a well-planned vegan diet is suitable for all ages and life stages,
including pregnant & breastfeeding women
20. Current situation in hospitals
Clear environmental and public health benefits to offering plant-based
food
Hospitals should be able to provide plant-based food on request,
however, in practice this often doesn’t happen
Regular reports from vegans who can’t access suitable food or offered
very poor options like:
• Bowl of chips
• An apple
• Dry baked potato
• Dry toast
21. Veganism is a protected characteristic, qualifying as a non-
religious philosophical belief
Public sector institutions have a duty not to discriminate and this
includes ensuring that patients can access suitable food
Equality Act 2010
22. Seeks to rectify problems vegans experience in public sector
Guaranteed vegan option on every hospital menu
Available to all, not just by special request
Ensure vegans are not indirectly discriminated against, whilst also
building familiarity with healthy, sustainable food among wider population
Catering for Everyone
23. We have already worked with supplier Anglia Crown to develop vegan ready-meal
range
Registered dietitian can offer advice to hospitals or NHS trusts looking to include
plant-based food on their menus
Menu development
Moroccan vegetable tagine Pasta Peperonata Butternut squash curry
24. Conclusion
We need immediate action to tackle climate & public health crises
Plant-based diets have many environmental & health benefits
Public sector should lead by example and offer more plant-based food
Hospitals & NHS Trusts should commit to offering at least 1 vegan option
on all standard menus
The Vegan Society can help
27. Public Perception Before
• The Trust was not doing enough to tackle car use
• Green Travel Plan (2012) developed:
Perception was that it was unambitious and vague
Congestion associated with the Trust identified as main concern.
Limited engagement on travel with the local community, staff and patients.
• Circa 50% of staff identified as living within 5 miles of the site.
• Baseline assessment identified 34.7% using sustainable travel.
28. Embracing Green Travel
Green Travel Plan (2014-2030)
Ambitious target (60% by 2030) and detailed actions.
Engagement pathways crucial
Business cases considers all sustainability elements
Budget for cycling facilities - £245k (2014)
Additional £100k realised in 2017 to fund sustainable travel
29. Engagement –
Local authority and Neighbourhood
Quarterly and annual reports
Neighbourhood Forum
Neighbourhood News
Neighbourhood Steering Groups
Internet pages
30. Engagement –
Patients and Staff
Patients
Intranet
Patient leaflet
Sustainable travel and car parking group
Staff
Sustainable Development Committee
Sustainable travel and car parking group
Bicycle User Group and mailing list
Engagement events and campaigns
New start flyer and Corporate induction stall
Intranet pages
31. Cycling - Then
• Cycle to work scheme in place.
• Limited secure cycle parking
• Limited and poorly maintained changing
facilities
• Barriers to cycling were identified:
Changing facilities
Safer cycle lanes
Secure compounds
Information on alternative
Lack of staff engagement with
cyclists.
• No cycling training in place.
32. Site Audit
Site audit conducted in partnership with
TfGM active travel team found;-
• Limited secure cycle parking (40 spaces)
• 147 short stay spaces
• Some cycle spaces poor quality
• Limited shower/changing facilities (6)
• No lockers available for cyclists
33. Cycling - Now
• Free training
• Secure cycle spaces (176)
• Short stay spaces (149)
• Changing facilities (including hair
dryers, mirrors and seating)
• Showers (23)
• Lockers (247)
• Drying areas
• Bicycle maintenance points (3)
• Free monthly maintenance
• Free monthly cyclist breakfast
• Bicycle User Group mailing list
• Free pool bicycles
• Partnership with local cycle shop
37. Walking - Then
• Initially the Trust held ad-hoc seasonal
walks.
• Attendance was low with between 5-10
walkers
• In August 2017 the Trust participated in
‘Walking for Health’ programme.
12-week programme of short
walks
Walk leader training
38. Walking - Now
Walking Wednesday
• Launched in Oct-17.
• Weekly 30 minute walks
around local community.
• Five Ramblers accredited
walk leaders.
• Informal marketing
• Social event.
• ‘Walking Wednesday’ often
attracts around twenty
staff.
39. Public Transport
• Greater Manchester – Improved
infrastructure
• Interest free session ticket loans.
• Discount tickets
• Journey Planning
40. Car Use
• Eligibility testing (i.e. permits issued to those identified as essential motorists)
• Free to staff - park & ride sites (The Christie)
• East Didsbury Park & ride – free parking for Metrolink customers
• Car share scheme
• Electric Charge Points
41. Excellence
• Sustainable travel increased to 42%
• Travel Choices Active Travel Award for excellence
in promoting cycling and walking (2018).
• Recognised the organisation in Greater
Manchester demonstrating the strongest
commitment to active travel.
• In addition the Trust has been awarded:
NHS Sustainability Award – Public Engagement
Green World Gold Award for the Health Sector
TfGM Gold award accreditation for championing sustainable
travel in the workplace 2017 and 2018.
42. Next steps
• Withington Regeneration Group
• Supporting local activities – Fog Lane Park
• Continued partnership with local cycle shop
• The Christie invited to summit a Mayor’s Cycling & Walking Fund (Bee Network)
• GM Walking Voice Steering Group
• NHS Collaborative Network - Sustainable Journeys
43. Public Perception Now
•Neighbourhood forum very supportive
•Local Authority quote The Christie as most
proactive organisation they deal with regarding
promoting sustainable travel
•Transport for Greater Manchester using the Trust
as an exampler
45. The value of an SDMP to an NHS
Organisation
Adam Newman
46. • What is an SDMP?
• What was Leeds’ sustainability agenda before
our SDMP?
• Where are we now?
• How did we develop our SDMP?
• Why should you develop an SDMP?
Introduction
47. • Sustainable Development Management Plan
• Central document defining an NHS
organisation’s sustainability agenda
• Set targets and objectives
• Development of action plan
• Deliver carbon and cost savings
What is an SDMP?
48. • Largely unorganised
• Lack of clarity over objectives and
targets
• Lack of senior level buy-in
• Difficult to report and track progress
What was Leeds’ sustainability agenda before our SDMP?
49. • Strong existing sustainability agenda:
Sustainable Development Management Plan
(SDMP)
Strategic Sustainability Management Group
(SSGM)
Environmental Management System (EMS)
• Sustainability interventions well underway
• Identified reductions of 16,000tCO2e/annum
by 2025
• Genuine senior level buy in
Where are we now?
51. • NHS Standard Contract 2019/20 Service Conditions-
18.2
• Centralise sustainability strategy
• Set objectives and targets
• Track progress against objectives and targets
Why should you develop an SDMP?
52. Adam Newman- Interim Sustainability Manager
adam.newman@nhs.net
adam.newman@wrm-ltd.co.uk
Thanks for your attention
53. WelLPRES
Smita Shetty, Healthier Lancashire & South Cumbria Integrated Care System (ICS)
Zan Virtnik, Parsek
Managing Care Pathways
Effectively and Efficiently
55. Healthier Lancashire and South Cumbria ICS and their partners - Parsek
and others who have shared core values and principles i.e.
Developing and implementing sustainable and scalable digital
solutions in healthcare
Reducing carbon footprint, waste, duplication, variation across our
organisations
Increasing efficiency and productivity
PARTNERSHIP
56. Aligning with NHS Long Term Plan, Sustainable Development
Strategy and other national objectives
Patient centric solution - WelLPRES
Co-designed with our citizens, clinicians and other stakeholders
First Use Case - Breast Cancer Follow-up Pathway - 23 Oct
2019
Project Management Style
WELLPRES
57. Some of the benefits of implementing WelLPRES are:
Reducing travel for both clinicians and citizens
Reducing the need to print documents including patient
information leaflets, appointment letters, as these will be
available digitally
Offering 'Personalised Care' and support self-care/self-
management
Improving patient engagement and communication
BENEFITS OF WELLPRES
58. Vitaly Managed CareVitaly Patient
Patient access
Professional access
WELLPRES
WelLPRES consists of two products from Vitaly’s solution pack:
59. WelLPRES
Smita Shetty, Healthier Lancashire & South Cumbria Integrated Care System (ICS)
Zan Virtnik, Parsek
Managing Care Pathways
Effectively and Efficiently
61. 90 percent of all spreadsheets have
errors that affect their results
Source: 2017, Cornell University, Ghada AlTarawneh, Simon Thorne, arXiv:1703.09785v1
62. Vitaly Managed CareVitaly Patient
Patient access
Professional access
WelLPRES
A comprehensive
ecosystem of collaborative
solutions on top of the
interoperable platform.
63. Continuity of care for patients.
Providing access to documents.
Better control of current health condition.
Better patient experience & satisfaction.
OVERALL BENEFITS
Reducing travel and carbon footprintCO2
77. Through an intuitive interface, Vitaly
eHealth Platform enables patients
and healthcare professionals a
secure access to relevant data
when and where it is needed.
USER-CENTERED CARE
78. Vitaly collects relevant clinical
data from various healthcare
information systems in a
standardised form. ATNA
XDS XUAFHIR
PIX
INTEROPERABILITY AND ARCHITECTURE
Our platform is fully healthcare IT
compliant. Core of the platform is
FHIR (Fast Healthcare Interoperability
Resources)
HL7
79. Using responsive design, Vitaly
offers the same user experience on
all devices – smartphones, tablets
and PCs.
When designing user interaction we
always test the experience.
OPTIMAL USER EXPERIENCE
82. WCAG
“WCAG is a set of guidelines for making content accessible for all
users, including those with disabilities.”
WCAG 2.1 for ICT (info. comm. tech)
MB Campaigns Manager at TVS
TVS oldest vegan org, campaigning & ed charity
Share benefits of veganism
Here today to talk about how what we eat can help to save the world
You may have noticed recently that PB food becoming more popular
Increase in number of UK vegans and this is expected to continue to rise in coming years, prediction that vegans/vegetarians will make up 25% of UK population by 2025
Big increase in people reducing meat/animal product consumption also, 1 in 3 report some level of meat reduction
The increasingly popular Veganuary campaign highlights the increase in number of vegans, participants doubled in 2019 from previous year
UN IPCC informed us last year that we had just 12 years to avert catastrophic runaway climate change
Need to limit global warming to max 1.5C – on track for over 3C rise
Also have a biodiversity crisis - Average wildlife populations have dropped by 60% in 40 years
We need to act now!
Vegan food is most sustainable on all metrics
Vegan diet has 50% less GHG emissions than standard western diet
Animal ag responsible for 91% of Amazon deforestation
Vegan diets require 50% less land than meat-eating diets
Also benefits from less water usage & less eutrophication/water pollution
2018 Oxford Uni study found switching to a vegan diet is the ‘single biggest way’ to reduce an individual’s impact on planet
CCC: public sector should take a strong lead by offering plant-based food
UK currently also facing many diet-related public health crises – cost to NHS is more than smoking, alcohol abuse or lack of physical activity
PB diets have many health benefits found in population studies
Less risk of: Type-2 diabetes, heart disease, some types of cancer, high blood pressure, high cholesterol levels
BDA confirm well planned vegan diet suitable for all, inc pregnant & breastfeeding
Despite clear benefits to the environment & public health, you would think that plant-based food would be widely available in the public sector, especially in hospitals, however, this is not the case.
Although in theory all hospitals should be able to provide PB food to patients on request, in practice this often doesn’t happen
Regularly receive reports from vegans in hospital who can’t access any vegan food or are offered very poor options.
Some options we have heard from patients: bowl of chips, an apple, a dry baked potato, dry toast – not a proper nutritionally balanced meal.
Veganism is protected characteristic under Equality Act, qualifying as a non-religious philosophical belief
Public sector institutions have a duty not to discriminate against patients and this includes ensuring that all patients can access suitable food
By not providing vegans with suitable food, hospitals & NHS Trusts are breaking the law
C4E campaign seeks to rectify the problems that vegans experience in hospitals & other public sector settings
Calls for a guaranteed vegan option on every hospital menu
Available to all, not just by special request
Would enable growing number of vegans & flexitarians to be properly catered for (avoiding indirect discrimination), whilst building familiarity with healthy, sustainable food among wider population
TVS have already worked with supplier Anglia Crown to develop a range of vegan ready meals which are supplied to over 100 hospitals nationally. These include the pictured items, Moroccan vegetable tagine, pasta peperonata and butternut squash curry
We have a registered dietitian on staff who can offer advice to hospitals or NHS Trusts looking to include vegan options on their menus
To conclude:
Clear that we need immediate action to tackle climate & public health crises
Plant-based diets have many environmental & health benefits
Public sector should lead by example and offer more plant-based food
Hospitals & NHS Trusts should commit to offering at least 1 vegan option on all their standard menus
TVS can help with menu development
That concludes my presentation today, hope you found it useful.
Happy to answer any questions you might have
Do you know what is this icon?
(Go silent for 3 seconds)
And this is the same tool how which is in use for managing low risk patients in Breast Cancer Follow Up Programme
According to researchers from Cornell University
The implementation consists of a combination of two key elements of Parsek's Vitaly health care solution set:
- A Patient portal for facilitating patient engagement and allowing them to access their electronic health record.
- A Managed Care system, which enables personalised and remote coordinated healthcare for clinical teams.
This first phase will digitise the 5-year supported self-managed follow up programme, and in the future phases will add 2 additional cancer recovery programmes (Colorectal and Prostate supported self-managed follow up).
The solution is designed to support patients with stable disease to self-manage their follow up care. Following treatment of breast cancer, the clinical teams assess the patient’s eligibility to enter a supported self-managed follow up pathway by following risk stratification protocols.
The overall benefits of Patient portal
Better guidance and patient support which can minimize unnecessary examinations, unnecessary doctor’s office visits and avoid losing patients to follow up.
Better patient experience & satisfaction.
Providing access to documents
Better control of current health condition.
It is also
Enable continuity of care by providing information about patient conditions between defined healthcare episodes
Increased therapy compliance
Optimize healthcare service by in-time reaction to patient condition changes
Patient Responsibilities:
- Attend annual planned mammography screenings. This test consists of digital x-ray imaging of breasts. Images are then reviewed by a radiologist who prepares a report.
- Fill out the questionnaire to highlight any red flag symptoms or patient concerns (which is subsequently reviewed by a health professional).
A decision is made by the health professional on the outcome of the mammogram and Questionnaire results (if everything is OK or further examination is needed).
Let’s have a look from a functional perspective point of view as a patient
Patient can access all different medical information
Patient Portal will also be integration with new citizen identity service, NHS Login so non-professional users will be able to use NHS Login as part of the verification and authentication process
all tasks are created in Managed care by Cancer care coordinator
Such as: Questionnaires, annual mammography appointment, regular appointments, progress tracking,
digital questionnaires,
engage patients to contribute information where and suits them best,
reduce unnecessary administration overhead,
effective information management
Cancer care coordinastor will based on clinical guidelines thresholds receive a notifiation to detect and react to potential issues sooner
Patients will also be able to access all the documents residing in LPRES backbone and all manually uploaded documents to MC (HCP facing solution).
In future phases there is plan to include also structured data (such as immunizations, medications, allergies and conditions)
better communication between health professionals and patients
patients are not left alone after the procedure,
easily share information and get in contact with the hospital and/or the doctor.
Health journal involves patients in the process of care and gives them ability to track self observations or add different patient-generated measurements (such as body temperature, blood pressure, oxygen saturation etc) health journal will also guide to be complient to digital care plan
And now have a look on Managed Care which is HCP facing solution
The solution used on HCP side is Vitaly Managed Care, which is used for implementing, managing and carrying out of the patient‘s careplan.
The careplan is based on a disease-specific template, which includes the appointments and other tasks.
In case of breast cancer follow up programme, the template is done according to NHS guidelines, but has enough flexibility to cover the differences in individual institution‘s workflows.
It includes the yearly mammographies, questionnaires and clinical reviews, as well as a number of one-time appointments, such as educational appointments.
The result is well organised data that replaces excell spreadsheets and similar solutions that were used for managing the follow up programme untill now.
The data is
All in one place
Automatically organised and
Updated in real time with input from the pateint and HCP‘s side
This mean less time lost looking for the required information, as well as
Less chance of mistakes
Along with allowing remote interventions, this anables more optimised workflows and consequently lower healthcare costs, as well as better health outcomes.
In July we start work on implementing well-press into other follow up programmes being carried out on these institutions, namely colorectal cancer follow-up and prostate cancer follow up.
The implementations will be similar in purpose and basic functionality, but will differ in appointments and tasks, specifics to the follow up-programme. They will again be done according to NHS guidelines, but will allow for institution specific workflows.
All of these follow-up programmes are just for monitoring patients when active treatment is finished and are relatively lightweight, with just a few appointments and tasks every year. But the solution being implemented here is designed in such a way that in future it can be easily be applied to active outpatient treatment of various diseases.
Actually, the more tasks the patient must regularly do, such as measurements, questionnaires, therapy applications, etc, the more benefits can be expected by using telemedicine functionalities.
We have a platform which is fully healthcare IT standard compliant and providing HL7 v2 and v3 (core of the platform is FHIR, entitiy/domain model is HL7 FHIR and all internal communication is implemented using HL7/FHIR)
We have healthcare IT standard access control, we have Open ID and SAML tokens (the same as NHS Login)
The connector layer (which is capable of communication with healthcare IT standard (HL7 v2, v3 and IHE) with external services and sources.
Our platform is highly secured Internet/DMZ.
Web Content Accessibility Guidelines
Well to put it simply, it’s a set of guidelines that prevent situations like this but on the web
To conclude, implementation of well-press results in better informed and empowered patient and HCPs, which enables better health outcomes and lower cost of healthcare. In future, the solution can easily be modified to cover any sort of out-patient disease management, bringing the same benefits there.