Leading from the south, Sangram

Sangram Sanstha
Sangram SansthaSangram Sanstha
Leading from the south, Sangram
SCOPE
OF THE
1. June 2017 – October 2019 with SANGRAM as Lead Partner
2. Consortium Members
a) 14 collectives/ state networks/ federations (supported by 8 NGOs)
a) Uttara Karnataka Mahila Okkutta (5 partners) through Sangama
b) Karnataka Sex Workers Union, through Sangama
c) Vadamalar Federation (Tamil Nadu – 9 partners), through SIAAP
d) Me and My World Network (Andhra – 8 partners), through WINS
e) Me and My World Network (Telengana – 7 partners), through WINS
f) Kerala Network of Sex Workers (8 partners) through Sangram
a) Ganika (Nagpur), through Sangram
b) MJSS (Parbhani), through Adhar Sanstha
c) Samvedna (Bhuj), through KMVS
d) Stree Sanghatan (Chota Udepur), through Vikalp
e) Hardasi Sangh, Amalner through Adhar Bahuudeshiya
f) VAMP Sangli through Sangram
g) Saheli Sangh, Pune (direct funding)
h) Jwala Shakti Samuh through Srijan Foundation
b) Reaches approximately 50,000 sex workers directly/ indirectly
c) 8 states of India
d) 11 partners funded through sub grants, 3 partners administered by Sangram
CONSORTIUM
GRANT
New partner
New partner
New partner
New partner
Background
A. Invisibilisation of Distress migration within India and across the region
• Continued emphasis conflating migration/ trafficking/forced sex work thus
focus on stopping migration rather than creating safer channels of migration
and viable solutions to trafficking
B. Changing forms of labour and exploitative practices by State and non
State actors
• related to working hours/ delayed payments/ low wages /criminalization of
work
C. Prioritisation of criminalisation over welfare
• Denial of recognition of rights as workers rather as victims in need of rescue
for rehabilitation and repatriation.
D. Discourse on nationalism and shrinking space and voices for
populations on the margins
• Suppression of dissent, freedom of speech, expression in the garb of
clamping down on trafficking (pornography, adult content)
India and the Region reeling under global &
regional shifts in policy frameworks
•Expansion from 42 to 61
districts; 8 states.
•Over 1,50,000 members
• Only network to have
female, trans and male sex
workers
• Representation on NNSW
board of these categories
of sex workers
•National Presence –
Coordinators in capital
•Registration process of the
network completed to
75%.
•New 11 member board
taken charge (2 May 2019)
STRATEGIES
Leadership Strengthening, Internal
Discourse around rights
Articulation of Rights in a
collective manner
Other
movement
engagement
APPROACH
Develop
Community
led
initiatives
Let the
Group
reach
readiness
Establish
and
strengthen
collective
response
Emphasis on regular
meetings at the State and
Collective level
Building second line
leadership
NNSW board meetings,
AGM
Training on laws, policies,
research, dispute redress,
Setting up dispute redress
mechanisms
Increased membership
– Collectives, State
networks, National
Network
Increased self
esteem, understanding
of sex work as work
Demand for
decriminalization
emerging from the
ground
Emergence of the sex
worker rights
movement in India, S
Asia
Emergence of sex workers
as Para Legal Volunteers
District legal services
authorities – intervening in
legal cases
Sex workers
intervening
with police/
courts to
release
women from
police
custody,
rescue homes
Community led research
“Raided” – impact of anti
trafficking strategies on
sex workers (4 states –
collectives – tracking sex
workers who have been
raided)
63 news articles at the
national level since March
2018
Rescue home study (Andhra
Pradesh) – next generation
of community research
Helped to shape
the discourse on
criminalisation of
sex work;
Shifted the
public perception
on trafficking
Strengthened
community
voice against
raid and
rescue model
and its
effects on all
communities
Coalition for an
Inclusive approach on
the Trafficking Bill
formed in India –
comprising garment
workers unions, trade
unions, internet
freedom, surrogacy
activists, women’s
health, child rights
groups, LGBTQUI
groups
200 stakeholders
across 8 states sign
Coalition Statement
Interactions, awareness
building around the Trafficking
Bill 2018 with different groups
(lawyers, activists, trade
unions, child rights activists,
health professionals, bonded
labor activists, university
professors,)
8 national meetings –
Hyderabad, Pune, Bangalore,
Ranchi, Mumbai, Delhi,
Lucknow, Chennai
Training workshops for sex
workers on laws (difference
between sex work and
trafficking) and draft bill
Bill translated in 7 languages
for sex workers
Recommendations collated
from sex workers and
presented to different
stakeholders
Breaking silence/
widening
discourse
Shift in
perception around
trafficking bill –
groups whose
rights would be
impacted began to
speak out
Transgender
people
Surrogacy
activists
Freedom of
Expression
Trade Union/
Labor groups
Bonded labor
activists
4000 sex workers
across India sign
demand for
reconsidering
trafficking bill,
decriminalizing work
Signed by stakeholders
across India
Sex workers make
submissions to
Members of Parliament
Media writes about
demands of sex
workers (72)
Minister forced on
defensive – states in
Parliament that Bill not
for consenting sex
workers
Bill lapses in Upper
House
1 of 9

Recommended

National Campaign on Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR) by
National Campaign on Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR)National Campaign on Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR)
National Campaign on Dalit Human Rights (NCDHR)Dasra
780 views2 slides
Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI) by
Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI)Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI)
Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI)Dasra
365 views2 slides
Wesat0503 by
Wesat0503Wesat0503
Wesat0503Mohamed Rafique
229 views7 slides
SMP Gender Equality Forum-Gender Matters in Leadership by
SMP Gender Equality Forum-Gender Matters in LeadershipSMP Gender Equality Forum-Gender Matters in Leadership
SMP Gender Equality Forum-Gender Matters in LeadershipScotland Malawi Partnership
1.1K views27 slides
Praja Foundation by
Praja FoundationPraja Foundation
Praja FoundationDasra
823 views2 slides
Engaging effectively with aboriginal people in primary health networks by
Engaging effectively with aboriginal people in primary health networksEngaging effectively with aboriginal people in primary health networks
Engaging effectively with aboriginal people in primary health networksUniversity of Newcastle
760 views15 slides

More Related Content

What's hot

Local Democracy by
Local DemocracyLocal Democracy
Local DemocracyJamaity
2.2K views18 slides
Radhika fox april_6_2011 by
Radhika fox april_6_2011Radhika fox april_6_2011
Radhika fox april_6_2011ktedlin
336 views23 slides
DEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signed by
DEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signedDEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signed
DEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signedPaddy Onyango
145 views6 slides
Advocacy and Lobbying fo Social Change by
Advocacy and Lobbying fo Social ChangeAdvocacy and Lobbying fo Social Change
Advocacy and Lobbying fo Social ChangeNicol Cave
3.2K views19 slides
The State of Democracy and Economy in Malaysia by
The State of Democracy and Economy in MalaysiaThe State of Democracy and Economy in Malaysia
The State of Democracy and Economy in MalaysiaBienvenido "Nonoy" Oplas, Jr.
2.3K views13 slides
How to support womens land rights in mozambique by
How to support womens land rights in mozambiqueHow to support womens land rights in mozambique
How to support womens land rights in mozambiqueFIAN Norge
775 views50 slides

What's hot(18)

Local Democracy by Jamaity
Local DemocracyLocal Democracy
Local Democracy
Jamaity2.2K views
Radhika fox april_6_2011 by ktedlin
Radhika fox april_6_2011Radhika fox april_6_2011
Radhika fox april_6_2011
ktedlin336 views
DEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signed by Paddy Onyango
DEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signedDEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signed
DEVOLUTION AND WOMEN CONFERENCE SUMMARY-signed
Paddy Onyango145 views
Advocacy and Lobbying fo Social Change by Nicol Cave
Advocacy and Lobbying fo Social ChangeAdvocacy and Lobbying fo Social Change
Advocacy and Lobbying fo Social Change
Nicol Cave3.2K views
How to support womens land rights in mozambique by FIAN Norge
How to support womens land rights in mozambiqueHow to support womens land rights in mozambique
How to support womens land rights in mozambique
FIAN Norge775 views
Ms Maria Jose Novoa : Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e... by cooperatives
Ms Maria Jose Novoa	: Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...Ms Maria Jose Novoa	: Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
Ms Maria Jose Novoa : Empowering the co-operative movement through advocacy e...
cooperatives3.1K views
Civil service NGO sector on Participation by Valred Olsim
Civil service NGO sector on ParticipationCivil service NGO sector on Participation
Civil service NGO sector on Participation
Valred Olsim260 views
Idasa and Governance in Africa by guest64b6d0
Idasa and Governance in AfricaIdasa and Governance in Africa
Idasa and Governance in Africa
guest64b6d0185 views
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip... by IFPRI-PIM
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
Getting a seat at the table: Strengthening women’s tenure rights and particip...
IFPRI-PIM12 views
Bond briefing on lobbying bill summary final 09 sept 2013 by arosebond
Bond briefing on lobbying bill   summary final 09 sept 2013Bond briefing on lobbying bill   summary final 09 sept 2013
Bond briefing on lobbying bill summary final 09 sept 2013
arosebond156 views
Swaniti by Dasra
SwanitiSwaniti
Swaniti
Dasra 330 views
National Integrity Strategy of Bangladesh by Shimanta Easin
National Integrity Strategy of BangladeshNational Integrity Strategy of Bangladesh
National Integrity Strategy of Bangladesh
Shimanta Easin3.8K views

Similar to Leading from the south, Sangram

PVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian society by
PVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian societyPVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian society
PVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian societyLenin Raghuvanshi
518 views11 slides
Unifem icoe for nacp iv by
Unifem icoe for nacp ivUnifem icoe for nacp iv
Unifem icoe for nacp ivMohamed Rafique
371 views20 slides
Presentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4P by
Presentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4PPresentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4P
Presentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4Pgoodmencampaign
408 views12 slides
Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ) by
Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ)Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ)
Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ)Dasra
271 views2 slides
Foundation for Democratic Reforms in India by
Foundation for Democratic Reforms in IndiaFoundation for Democratic Reforms in India
Foundation for Democratic Reforms in Indiaindianelections2009
746 views47 slides
WomenPowerConnect by
WomenPowerConnectWomenPowerConnect
WomenPowerConnectRachna Shanbog
436 views23 slides

Similar to Leading from the south, Sangram (20)

PVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian society by Lenin Raghuvanshi
PVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian societyPVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian society
PVCHR works to ensure basic rights for marginalized groups in the Indian society
Lenin Raghuvanshi518 views
Presentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4P by goodmencampaign
Presentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4PPresentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4P
Presentation by Khamsavath Chan Thavysouk, P4P
goodmencampaign408 views
Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ) by Dasra
Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ)Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ)
Centre for Health and Social Justice (CHSJ)
Dasra 271 views
Coercion Verses Empowerment by HRLNIndia
Coercion Verses EmpowermentCoercion Verses Empowerment
Coercion Verses Empowerment
HRLNIndia1.9K views
[IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar] Gender and Collective Lands: Good practices an... by IFPRI Gender
[IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar] Gender and Collective Lands: Good practices an...[IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar] Gender and Collective Lands: Good practices an...
[IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar] Gender and Collective Lands: Good practices an...
IFPRI Gender1.2K views
Pria by Dasra
PriaPria
Pria
Dasra 257 views
Human rights in the Global Fund new funding model by clac.cab
Human rights in the Global Fund new funding model�Human rights in the Global Fund new funding model�
Human rights in the Global Fund new funding model
clac.cab783 views
Good governance by jans jans
Good governanceGood governance
Good governance
jans jans182 views
Training Manual on Human Rights and Local Governance by Shankor Paul
Training Manual on Human Rights and Local GovernanceTraining Manual on Human Rights and Local Governance
Training Manual on Human Rights and Local Governance
Shankor Paul3.3K views
Annual Report 2012 by WOREC Nepal
Annual Report 2012Annual Report 2012
Annual Report 2012
WOREC Nepal1.3K views
Panel 2.Jane Schaller Civil Society Engagement Gavi Alliance, Pmnch, Prof &... by ihp
Panel 2.Jane Schaller Civil Society Engagement   Gavi Alliance, Pmnch, Prof &...Panel 2.Jane Schaller Civil Society Engagement   Gavi Alliance, Pmnch, Prof &...
Panel 2.Jane Schaller Civil Society Engagement Gavi Alliance, Pmnch, Prof &...
ihp265 views

Recently uploaded

Support Girl students with Education by
Support Girl students with EducationSupport Girl students with Education
Support Girl students with EducationSERUDS INDIA
6 views6 slides
Dr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx by
Dr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptxDr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx
Dr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptxAKADEMIYA2063
7 views34 slides
How to Find Contractors and Architects for Your Historic Home Renovation by
How to Find Contractors and Architects for Your Historic Home RenovationHow to Find Contractors and Architects for Your Historic Home Renovation
How to Find Contractors and Architects for Your Historic Home RenovationNational Trust for Historic Preservation
100 views8 slides
Taking care of the elders by
Taking care of the eldersTaking care of the elders
Taking care of the eldersSERUDS INDIA
7 views6 slides
ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑ by
ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑ
ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑssuser9e6212
170 views18 slides
AABS project overview by
AABS project overviewAABS project overview
AABS project overviewWorldFish
23 views17 slides

Recently uploaded(20)

Support Girl students with Education by SERUDS INDIA
Support Girl students with EducationSupport Girl students with Education
Support Girl students with Education
SERUDS INDIA6 views
Dr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx by AKADEMIYA2063
Dr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptxDr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx
Dr. Ousmane Badiane - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx
AKADEMIYA20637 views
ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑ by ssuser9e6212
ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑ
ΕΚΘΕΣΗ ΚΟΜΙΣΙΟΝ ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΡΚΙΑ
ssuser9e6212170 views
AABS project overview by WorldFish
AABS project overviewAABS project overview
AABS project overview
WorldFish23 views
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey? by OECD CFE
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
How can the social and solidarity economy help refugees along their journey?
OECD CFE104 views
Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ... by India Water Portal
Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ...Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ...
Managing drinking water infrastructure in West Bengal Gram Panchayats_Sujata ...
Arrow Adoption Training for Kinship Families by ArrowMarketing
Arrow Adoption Training for Kinship FamiliesArrow Adoption Training for Kinship Families
Arrow Adoption Training for Kinship Families
ArrowMarketing40 views
A terrorist threat originating from Qatar. by fasurijobaf
A terrorist threat originating from Qatar.A terrorist threat originating from Qatar.
A terrorist threat originating from Qatar.
fasurijobaf7 views
Dr Jean Paul Latyr FAYE - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx by AKADEMIYA2063
Dr Jean Paul Latyr FAYE - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptxDr Jean Paul Latyr FAYE - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx
Dr Jean Paul Latyr FAYE - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference.pptx
AKADEMIYA20638 views
UNiTE- Invest to Prevent Violence against Women & Girls! by Christina Parmionova
UNiTE- Invest to Prevent Violence against Women & Girls!UNiTE- Invest to Prevent Violence against Women & Girls!
UNiTE- Invest to Prevent Violence against Women & Girls!
Mrs. Tsitsi Makombe - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference by AKADEMIYA2063
Mrs. Tsitsi Makombe - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference Mrs. Tsitsi Makombe - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference
Mrs. Tsitsi Makombe - 2023 ReSAKSS Conference
AKADEMIYA20635 views
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS... by India Water Portal
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...
Mukhya Mantri Gramin Peyjal Nishchay Yojana (MGPNY) – Bihar_Pankaj Kumar_AKRS...
2023 First Tee - Greater Richmond Holiday Gift Guide by bill151498
2023 First Tee - Greater Richmond Holiday Gift Guide2023 First Tee - Greater Richmond Holiday Gift Guide
2023 First Tee - Greater Richmond Holiday Gift Guide
bill15149880 views
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ... by India Water Portal
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...
Social behavioural change to drive community ownership_ Divyang Waghela_Tata ...

Leading from the south, Sangram

  • 2. SCOPE OF THE 1. June 2017 – October 2019 with SANGRAM as Lead Partner 2. Consortium Members a) 14 collectives/ state networks/ federations (supported by 8 NGOs) a) Uttara Karnataka Mahila Okkutta (5 partners) through Sangama b) Karnataka Sex Workers Union, through Sangama c) Vadamalar Federation (Tamil Nadu – 9 partners), through SIAAP d) Me and My World Network (Andhra – 8 partners), through WINS e) Me and My World Network (Telengana – 7 partners), through WINS f) Kerala Network of Sex Workers (8 partners) through Sangram a) Ganika (Nagpur), through Sangram b) MJSS (Parbhani), through Adhar Sanstha c) Samvedna (Bhuj), through KMVS d) Stree Sanghatan (Chota Udepur), through Vikalp e) Hardasi Sangh, Amalner through Adhar Bahuudeshiya f) VAMP Sangli through Sangram g) Saheli Sangh, Pune (direct funding) h) Jwala Shakti Samuh through Srijan Foundation b) Reaches approximately 50,000 sex workers directly/ indirectly c) 8 states of India d) 11 partners funded through sub grants, 3 partners administered by Sangram CONSORTIUM GRANT New partner New partner New partner New partner
  • 3. Background A. Invisibilisation of Distress migration within India and across the region • Continued emphasis conflating migration/ trafficking/forced sex work thus focus on stopping migration rather than creating safer channels of migration and viable solutions to trafficking B. Changing forms of labour and exploitative practices by State and non State actors • related to working hours/ delayed payments/ low wages /criminalization of work C. Prioritisation of criminalisation over welfare • Denial of recognition of rights as workers rather as victims in need of rescue for rehabilitation and repatriation. D. Discourse on nationalism and shrinking space and voices for populations on the margins • Suppression of dissent, freedom of speech, expression in the garb of clamping down on trafficking (pornography, adult content) India and the Region reeling under global & regional shifts in policy frameworks
  • 4. •Expansion from 42 to 61 districts; 8 states. •Over 1,50,000 members • Only network to have female, trans and male sex workers • Representation on NNSW board of these categories of sex workers •National Presence – Coordinators in capital •Registration process of the network completed to 75%. •New 11 member board taken charge (2 May 2019)
  • 6. Leadership Strengthening, Internal Discourse around rights Articulation of Rights in a collective manner Other movement engagement APPROACH Develop Community led initiatives Let the Group reach readiness Establish and strengthen collective response
  • 7. Emphasis on regular meetings at the State and Collective level Building second line leadership NNSW board meetings, AGM Training on laws, policies, research, dispute redress, Setting up dispute redress mechanisms Increased membership – Collectives, State networks, National Network Increased self esteem, understanding of sex work as work Demand for decriminalization emerging from the ground Emergence of the sex worker rights movement in India, S Asia Emergence of sex workers as Para Legal Volunteers District legal services authorities – intervening in legal cases Sex workers intervening with police/ courts to release women from police custody, rescue homes
  • 8. Community led research “Raided” – impact of anti trafficking strategies on sex workers (4 states – collectives – tracking sex workers who have been raided) 63 news articles at the national level since March 2018 Rescue home study (Andhra Pradesh) – next generation of community research Helped to shape the discourse on criminalisation of sex work; Shifted the public perception on trafficking Strengthened community voice against raid and rescue model and its effects on all communities
  • 9. Coalition for an Inclusive approach on the Trafficking Bill formed in India – comprising garment workers unions, trade unions, internet freedom, surrogacy activists, women’s health, child rights groups, LGBTQUI groups 200 stakeholders across 8 states sign Coalition Statement Interactions, awareness building around the Trafficking Bill 2018 with different groups (lawyers, activists, trade unions, child rights activists, health professionals, bonded labor activists, university professors,) 8 national meetings – Hyderabad, Pune, Bangalore, Ranchi, Mumbai, Delhi, Lucknow, Chennai Training workshops for sex workers on laws (difference between sex work and trafficking) and draft bill Bill translated in 7 languages for sex workers Recommendations collated from sex workers and presented to different stakeholders Breaking silence/ widening discourse Shift in perception around trafficking bill – groups whose rights would be impacted began to speak out Transgender people Surrogacy activists Freedom of Expression Trade Union/ Labor groups Bonded labor activists 4000 sex workers across India sign demand for reconsidering trafficking bill, decriminalizing work Signed by stakeholders across India Sex workers make submissions to Members of Parliament Media writes about demands of sex workers (72) Minister forced on defensive – states in Parliament that Bill not for consenting sex workers Bill lapses in Upper House