SlideShare a Scribd company logo

Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU Economies: Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges

SPINTAN
SPINTAN

Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU Economies: Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges

1 of 28
Download to read offline
Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU
Economies:
Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges
C. Jona-Lasinio, (LUISS Lab and ISTAT), Rome
C. Corrado, (The Conference Board), New York
J. Haskel, (Imperial College, CEPR and IZA), London
K. Jaeger, (The Conference Board), Bruxelles
M.Iommi, (LUISS Lab and ISTAT), Rome
WPIA - OECD
12-13 October 2015, Paris
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme for
research, technological development and demonstration under grant agreement No. 612774
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 1 / 28
Outline
• SPINTAN (www.SPINTAN.net): our aim and progresses
• Conceptual issues and main measurement challenges
• Recent trends of public and private intangible investments in the
US and EU economies
• Sources of growth in the total economy
• Policy challenges and next steps
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 2 / 28
The economic view of intangibles
• Taking seriously intangibles drastically changes our view of how
the rise of the knowledge economy impacts on growth and
productivity
• The economic view of intangibles asks for a deep investigation of
the channels through which public and private intangible
investment affect productivity growth.
• Integrating the impact of intangibles on growth in the total
economy is tricky
• Spillovers and complementarities across assets and sectors are difficult to
measure and hard to convey.
• The first step is to generate harmonized measures of intangibles
across sectors and countries
• Corrado, Hulten and Sichel (2005) developed the measurement framework for
intangibles in the market sector.
• Corrado, Haskel and Jona-Lasinio (2014) proposed a framework to measure
intangible investment in the nonmarket sector.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 3 / 28
Knowledge based capital in the total economy
Mapping the CHS assets to the nonmarket sector
and consumer product and food and drug safety (i.e, investments in product reputation). The
correspondence for computer software, purchased investments in organizational capital, and
function-specific worker capital (employer-provided training) is of course far closer.
Table 3: Knowledge Capital in a Total Economy
Market Sector Nonmarket Sector
Computerized Information Information, Scientific, and Cultural Assets
1 Software 1 Software
2 Databases 2 Open data
Innovative Property
3 R&D, broadly defined to 3 R&D, basic and applied science
include all NPD costs
4 Entertainment & artistic originals 4 Cultural and heritage, including
5 Design arch. & eng. design
6 Mineral exploration 5 Mineral exploration
Economic Competencies Societal Competencies
7 Brands 6 Brands
8 Organizational capital 7 Organizational capital
(a) Manager capital (a) Professional and manager capital
(b) Purchased organizational services (b) Purchased organizational services
9 Firm-specific human capital 8 Function-specific human capital
(employer-provided training) (employer-provided training)
Note—NPD=New Product Development, including testing and spending for new financial products
and other services development not included in software or conventional science-based R&D.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 4 / 28
Conceptual framework (Corrado, Haskel, Jona-Lasinio(2014))
Asset typology and SPINTAN topics
4
Types of capital
Knowledge capital
Intangible assets
Physical capital
Tangible assets
Human capital
Human assets
HEALTH and EDUCATION
CULTURE and the ARTS
SCIENCE and the economy
INFORMATION and the economy
Impacts, links, and synergies across
asset types are topic dependent
Topics of interest
The conceptual framework for the measurement of public intangibles is formulated with
the analysis of certain topics in mind: health and education, culture and the arts, science
and the economy, and information and the economy (i.e., not the environment, not mass
transport, etc.).
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 5 / 28
The scope of intangible assets used by the public sector:
industries of interest
laboratories, public parks and museums) in many countries; see table 1 below. The use of “mar-
ket” vs. “nonmarket” groupings of industries is thus not precise because an industry can reflect
activity carried out by a mix of producers, as is evident with NACE Section R and the larger
section of which NACE Section MB is a part.4
Table 1: SPINTAN Industries of Interest
nace nace
section Industry title number
MB Scientific research and development 72
O Public administration and defence; compulsory social security 84
P Education 85
QA Human health activities 86
QB Residential care and social work activities 87-88
R Creative, arts and entertainment activities;
libraries, archives, museums and other cultural activities 90-91
Gambling and betting activities;
sports activities and amusement and recreation activities 92-93
Note—NACE Rev. 2.
Before we leave the subject of NACE-defined industries, it must be said that in some countries
there are industries with significant government or nonmarket production besides those listed
in table 1. These tend to be industries that engage in activities not germane to our topic areas,
Besides Public administration and defence, other industries in the
table contain a mix of market and nonmarket producers.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 6 / 28
Multiple measurement dimensions of Public intangibles
!CHS!intangible!assets!
Nonmarket!sector!4!industries!
!Informa9on,!
Scien9fic!and!
Cultural!assets!
Societal!
Competencies!
NA!intangibles!(So$ware,*
R&D,*Mineral*explora4on)*
Non!NA!intangibles!(Open*
data,*Cultural*and*heritage,*
including*design,*Brands,*
Organiza4onal*capital,*
Func4onBspecific*human*
capital)*
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 7 / 28
Aim
Complete the coverage of intangible investment by industry making
possible analysis of productivity for the total economy based on a
complete accounting of intangible capital inputs.
• Existing measures of intangible investment, INTAN-Invest, cover
a subset of industries: the market sector
• SPINTAN covers the nonmarket sector
New conceptual and measurement challenges
• Identify the asset boundary in the total economy
• Impute a rate of return to public capital formation
• Investigate behavioural link public to private and vice versa (e.g.
role of public sector R&D on private sector)
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 8 / 28
The SPINTAN database
• SPINTAN will deliver (December 2016) estimates of public
intangible investment by industry and institutional sector for 22
European economies plus the US, China, India and Brazil for the
years 1995-2013.
• The data will be cross-country harmonized and consistent with
the National Accounts (NA) principles and with business sector
estimates of intangibles developed by INTAN-Invest
(www.INTAN-Invest.net)
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 9 / 28
Data description
Descriptive analysis will focus on 3 sets of data
• Descriptive analysis (1995-2010)
• CHS type assets for 22 EU countries and the US
• CHS type assets - Non-National Accounts for
10 EU countries and the US
• Sources of growth analysis in the total economy (1995-2009)
• CHS type assets for 5 EU countries
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 10 / 28
New issues to be investigated....
• What is the magnitude of overall intangible investment in the
total economy?
• Does the non-market sector is relatively more or less intangible
intensive than the market sector?
• What are the linkages between nonmarket and market intangibles?
• What is the productivity contribution of intangible capital in the
market and nonmarket sectors?
• Market and nonmarket intangibles over the business cycle
• Do Non-NA intangibles are relevant?
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 11 / 28
Public intangibles matter
Public intangible investments (GDP shares)
0.0#
0.2#
0.4#
0.6#
0.8#
1.0#
1.2#
1.4#
1.6#
1.8#
AT# BE# BG# CZ# DE# DK# EL# ES# FI# FR# HU# IE# IT# LU# NL# PL# PT# RO# SE# SI# SK# UK# US#
2000# 1.0# 0.8# 0.3# 0.9# 0.6# 0.4# 0.2# 0.2# 0.6# 0.3# 0.6# 0.9# 0.9# 0.2# 0.8# 0.4# 0.3# 0.1# 0.5# 0.5# 0.9# 0.9# 1.4#
2010# 1.1# 1.0# 0.2# 0.9# 0.9# 0.6# 0.2# 0.4# 1.0# 0.4# 0.6# 0.9# 1.1# 0.2# 1.2# 0.5# 0.3# 0.1# 0.5# 0.6# 0.5# 1.4# 1.7#
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 12 / 28
Nonmarket and market Non-NA intangible shares of GDP
Overall (market and nonmarket) Non-NA intangible investment account for 7% to 3% of
GDP with private and public sectors accounting on average for 5% and 0.6% respectively.
0.0#
1.0#
2.0#
3.0#
4.0#
5.0#
6.0#
at# de# es# be# fi# fr# it# nl# se# uk# us#
NMKT# 0.3# 0.4# 0.2# 0.6# 0.7# 0.4# 0.5# 0.6# 0.6# 1.0# 1.2#
MKT# 3.5# 3.7# 2.5# 4.8# 3.2# 4.1# 2.9# 4.5# 4.1# 5.0# 5.3#
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 13 / 28
Non-Na intangible shares of nonmarket and market value added
Intangible intensity varies considerably across countries with most advanced economies
( US, UK and FI) more intensive in the nonmarket sector. In the remaining countries it is
the opposite (for these assets).
NMKT%
MKT%
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
9.0%
10.0%
es% at% fr% de% nl% se% be% it% fi% us% uk%
NMKT% 1.7% 2.7% 3.3% 4.2% 4.5% 4.7% 4.9% 4.9% 7.2% 9.5% 9.5%
MKT% 3.5% 5.0% 6.9% 5.5% 6.6% 6.8% 7.1% 4.3% 4.8% 7.6% 7.4%
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 14 / 28
Nonmarket and market Non-NA intangible investment (1995-2010)
Nonmarket and market intangible intensities are positively correlated.
AT#
DE#
ES#
BE#
FI#
FR#
IT#
NL#
SE#
UK#
US#
0.00#
0.20#
0.40#
0.60#
0.80#
1.00#
1.20#
1.40#
1.50# 2.00# 2.50# 3.00# 3.50# 4.00# 4.50# 5.00# 5.50# 6.00#
NonMarket#intangible#investments#(%GDP)#
Market#intangible#investment#(%#of#GDP)#
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 15 / 28
Non-NA intangible investment and GDP per capita (1995-2010)
...and public intangible intensity is positively correlated with the level
of economic development
AT#
DE#
ES#
BE#
FI#
FR#
IT# NL#
SE#
UK#
US#
0.0#
5.0#
10.0#
15.0#
20.0#
25.0#
25000# 30000# 35000# 40000# 45000# 50000#
Non#Market/Market#intangible#investments#
GDP#Per#capita#(EKS#US#$#2010)#
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 16 / 28
Non-NA intangible investment and GDP per hours worked (1995-2010)
...also measured as GDP per hours worked
AT#
DE#
ES#
BE#
FI#
FR#
IT#
NL#
SE#
UK#
US#
0.0#
5.0#
10.0#
15.0#
20.0#
25.0#
35.0# 40.0# 45.0# 50.0# 55.0# 60.0#
Non#Market/Market#intangible#investments##
GDP#per#hours#worked#
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 17 / 28
GDP shares of market and nonmarket intangibles
over the business cycle: (1995-2007) vs (2007-2010)
!4.0%
!3.0%
!2.0%
!1.0%
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
at% de% es% be% fi% fr% it% nl% se% uk% us%
GDP%shares%of%market%and%nonmarket%intangible%
investment:%1995!2007%
(%#changes)#
MKT$ NMKT$
!6.0%
!4.0%
!2.0%
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
at% de% es% be% fi% fr% it% nl% se% uk% us%
GDP%shares%of%market%and%nonmarket%intangible%
investment:%2007!2010%
(%#changes)%%
Intangible investment has been marginally impacted by the financial
crisis and nonmarket intangibles even less compared to market
intangibles!
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 18 / 28
What are the main drivers of non-NA intangible investment?
Organizational capital accounts for the largest share of intangible
investment both in the nonmarket (45%) and market (35%) sector.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 19 / 28
Organizational capital: shares in total market and nonmarket
intangible investments
On average purchased OC accounts for a larger share both in
nonmarket and market sectors but shares varies considerably across
countries and sectors.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 20 / 28
Return to nonmarket capital
• Once we have capitalized public intangibles we want to evaluate
their contribution to productivity growth.
• To achieve this goal we need to impute a net return to public
investments.
• A SPINTAN background paper by (Corrado and Jaeger, 2015)
explores using the social rate of time preference (Feldstein, 1964;
OECD 2009) as a relevant alternative for imputing a rate of
return to government capital.
• But at this stage we adopt the national accounts assumption of a
zero nonmarket sector rate of return.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 21 / 28
Sources of growth analysis
• Adding national accounts intangibles (R&D, software, and artistic
and entertainment originals plus mineral exploration) to the
SPINTAN and INTAN-Invest measures of intangibles we are able
to look at a fairly complete picture of intangible inputs to total
production across a sample of advanced countries:
• Finland, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the United Kingdom
• Data sources: SPINTAN, INTAN-Invest and EUKLEMS
• Contributions to labour productivity growth of market and
nonmarket sectors.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 22 / 28
Contributions to Labour Productivity Growth:1995-2009
The performance of advanced economies differs widely according to market versus
nonmarket sector. In Germany, UK and Finland intangible capital is an important source
of growth for the public sector.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 23 / 28
Contributions to Labour Productivity Growth:
1995-2007 vs 2007-2009
At the very beginning of the financial crisis, intangible capital
positively supported labour productivity growth of both market and
non-market sectors in the advanced economies.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 24 / 28
Summing up
• Intangible capital accounts for one-fifth to one-third of labor
productivity growth in the market sector of the US and EU
economies
• ....and for one-third of labor productivity growth in the nonmarket
sector in the EU economies
• Intangibles appear to be counter cyclical particularly in the
nonmarket sector
• Organizational capital is a key asset in this framework
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 25 / 28
Policy challenges
• A primary characteristic of intangible capital, widely supported by
growth accounting exercises and macroeconomic studies, is to be
growth-promoting.
• This is because intangible investments likely generate spillovers to
the economic system being non-rival and possibly non-excludable.
Such spillovers, if they exist, might be within the private sector
and/or between the public and private sector.
• In the light in particular of the claim and counter-claim around
public sector austerity and fiscal policy in Europe, it would be
vital to know which, if any, public sector intangibles had positive
spillovers to the rest of the economy.
• If intangibles is the main story, the focus is long-term, not
short-term requiring bigger policy commitments.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 26 / 28
SPINTAN: Next steps
• Generate real measures of public intangible investments and net
capital stocks.
• Impute a rate of return to nonmarket capital.
• Provide a deep investigation of mechanisms trough which the
synergies between Public and Private sector affect economic
growth.
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 27 / 28
Thank you
C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 28 / 28

Recommended

Private and Public Intangible Capital: Productivity Growth and New Policy Cha...
Private and Public Intangible Capital: Productivity Growth and New Policy Cha...Private and Public Intangible Capital: Productivity Growth and New Policy Cha...
Private and Public Intangible Capital: Productivity Growth and New Policy Cha...SPINTAN
 
Sources of country-sector productivity growth: total factor productivity and ...
Sources of country-sector productivity growth: total factor productivity and ...Sources of country-sector productivity growth: total factor productivity and ...
Sources of country-sector productivity growth: total factor productivity and ...SPINTAN
 
A Methodolgy for Disentangling Public Funded R&D (GBARD) by Industries
A Methodolgy for Disentangling Public Funded R&D (GBARD) by IndustriesA Methodolgy for Disentangling Public Funded R&D (GBARD) by Industries
A Methodolgy for Disentangling Public Funded R&D (GBARD) by IndustriesSPINTAN
 
Intangible capital
Intangible capitalIntangible capital
Intangible capitalSPINTAN
 
Private and Public Intangible Capital Productivity Growth and New Policy Chal...
Private and Public Intangible Capital Productivity Growth and New Policy Chal...Private and Public Intangible Capital Productivity Growth and New Policy Chal...
Private and Public Intangible Capital Productivity Growth and New Policy Chal...SPINTAN
 
Modeling market and nonmarket Intangible investments in a macro-econometric f...
Modeling market and nonmarket Intangible investments in a macro-econometric f...Modeling market and nonmarket Intangible investments in a macro-econometric f...
Modeling market and nonmarket Intangible investments in a macro-econometric f...SPINTAN
 
Presentation of SPINTAN project
Presentation of SPINTAN projectPresentation of SPINTAN project
Presentation of SPINTAN projectSPINTAN
 
ICT, R&D and Non-R&D intangible capital: complementary relations and industry...
ICT, R&D and Non-R&D intangible capital: complementary relations and industry...ICT, R&D and Non-R&D intangible capital: complementary relations and industry...
ICT, R&D and Non-R&D intangible capital: complementary relations and industry...SPINTAN
 

More Related Content

What's hot

Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...
Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...
Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...Istituto nazionale di statistica
 
Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)
Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)
Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)SPINTAN
 
Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...
Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...
Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...SPINTAN
 
WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016
WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016
WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016SPINTAN
 
The intangible economy in Spain
The intangible economy in SpainThe intangible economy in Spain
The intangible economy in SpainIvie
 
Intangible Assets and Spanish Economic Growth
Intangible Assets and Spanish Economic GrowthIntangible Assets and Spanish Economic Growth
Intangible Assets and Spanish Economic GrowthSPINTAN
 
Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...
Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...
Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...Peter Zhen Ye
 
155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...
155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...
155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...innovationoecd
 
Intangibles and Cultural and Creative Industries
Intangibles and Cultural and Creative IndustriesIntangibles and Cultural and Creative Industries
Intangibles and Cultural and Creative IndustriesIvie
 
Global Innovation Index 2021
Global Innovation Index 2021Global Innovation Index 2021
Global Innovation Index 2021Wiziin Inc.
 
Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?
Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?
Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?Structuralpolicyanalysis
 
A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative Industries
A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative IndustriesA Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative Industries
A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative IndustriesThink Ethnic
 
Dr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the Economy
Dr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the EconomyDr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the Economy
Dr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the EconomyDr Dev Kambhampati
 
Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016
Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016
Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016Dirk Pilat
 
ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...
ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...
ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...SPINTAN
 
Multiple to return_on_r&d
Multiple to return_on_r&dMultiple to return_on_r&d
Multiple to return_on_r&dDino, llc
 
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economiesIntangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economiesABACO
 
[1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise]
[1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise][1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise]
[1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise]Dino, llc
 

What's hot (20)

Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...
Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...
Cecilia Susanna Jona-Lasinio, La misurazione dei beni intangibili oltre gli a...
 
Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)
Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)
Working Party on Industry Analysis (WPIA)
 
Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...
Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...
Intangibles: medición y contribución al crecimiento. Seminario de inauguració...
 
WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016
WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016
WPIA Meeting - OECD. Paris Oct2016
 
The intangible economy in Spain
The intangible economy in SpainThe intangible economy in Spain
The intangible economy in Spain
 
Intangible Assets and Spanish Economic Growth
Intangible Assets and Spanish Economic GrowthIntangible Assets and Spanish Economic Growth
Intangible Assets and Spanish Economic Growth
 
Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...
Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...
Comparative Advantage and Intellectual Property Rights: Some Evidences from C...
 
155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...
155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...
155-holguin Baseline for indicators for R&D and innovation in ICT a tool for ...
 
Intangibles and Cultural and Creative Industries
Intangibles and Cultural and Creative IndustriesIntangibles and Cultural and Creative Industries
Intangibles and Cultural and Creative Industries
 
Global Innovation Index 2021
Global Innovation Index 2021Global Innovation Index 2021
Global Innovation Index 2021
 
Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?
Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?
Productivity Slowdowns and Inequality Speedups: What is the Role of Intangibles?
 
A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative Industries
A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative IndustriesA Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative Industries
A Creative Block? The Future of the UK Creative Industries
 
Dr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the Economy
Dr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the EconomyDr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the Economy
Dr Dev Kambhampati | Artificial Intelligence, Automation & the Economy
 
Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016
Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016
Pilat eu spri new avenues innovation policy 9 june 2016
 
ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...
ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...
ICT and Intangible Capital: Complementary Relations and Industry Productivity...
 
Multiple to return_on_r&d
Multiple to return_on_r&dMultiple to return_on_r&d
Multiple to return_on_r&d
 
Wp10
Wp10Wp10
Wp10
 
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economiesIntangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
 
[1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise]
[1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise][1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise]
[1999][r&d][eee extended engineeringenterprise]
 
Cloud_Computing_Top_Markets_Report-2
Cloud_Computing_Top_Markets_Report-2Cloud_Computing_Top_Markets_Report-2
Cloud_Computing_Top_Markets_Report-2
 

Viewers also liked

Prabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.com
Prabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.comPrabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.com
Prabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.comBangalore Property
 
Ancient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDR
Ancient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDRAncient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDR
Ancient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDRFreyk John Geeris
 
Des Safety Excellence award
Des Safety Excellence awardDes Safety Excellence award
Des Safety Excellence awardahdes88
 
Bllom's taxonomy for i pads
Bllom's taxonomy for i padsBllom's taxonomy for i pads
Bllom's taxonomy for i padsmrslrc
 
binary number system
 binary number system binary number system
binary number systemvishal gupta
 
Electrolysis in industries
Electrolysis in industriesElectrolysis in industries
Electrolysis in industrieskaiying
 

Viewers also liked (10)

Teste
TesteTeste
Teste
 
Prabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.com
Prabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.comPrabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.com
Prabhavathi Lotus Grand - bangalore5.com
 
Наадам фестиваль
Наадам фестивальНаадам фестиваль
Наадам фестиваль
 
Ancient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDR
Ancient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDRAncient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDR
Ancient Ruins around Curiosity - 3 D HDR
 
Des Safety Excellence award
Des Safety Excellence awardDes Safety Excellence award
Des Safety Excellence award
 
Bllom's taxonomy for i pads
Bllom's taxonomy for i padsBllom's taxonomy for i pads
Bllom's taxonomy for i pads
 
Induction talk 2016
Induction talk 2016Induction talk 2016
Induction talk 2016
 
binary number system
 binary number system binary number system
binary number system
 
verb
 verb verb
verb
 
Electrolysis in industries
Electrolysis in industriesElectrolysis in industries
Electrolysis in industries
 

Similar to Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU Economies: Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges

Spillovers from public intangibles
Spillovers from public intangiblesSpillovers from public intangibles
Spillovers from public intangiblesSPINTAN
 
Haskel - Spillovers from public intangibles
Haskel - Spillovers from public intangiblesHaskel - Spillovers from public intangibles
Haskel - Spillovers from public intangiblesinnovationoecd
 
OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016
OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016
OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016SPINTAN
 
Public Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN Project
Public Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN ProjectPublic Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN Project
Public Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN ProjectSPINTAN
 
PUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement Issues
PUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement IssuesPUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement Issues
PUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement IssuesSPINTAN
 
Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...
Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...
Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...innovationoecd
 
Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)
Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)
Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)Marcos CAVALCANTI
 
HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...
HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...
HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...StatsCommunications
 
A Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative Industries
A Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative IndustriesA Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative Industries
A Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative IndustriesAllison Thompson
 
Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...
Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...
Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...scirexcenter
 
Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014
Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014
Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014- Irv -
 
What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...
What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...
What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...STIEAS
 
The informal economy, innovation and intellectual property
The informal economy, innovation and intellectual propertyThe informal economy, innovation and intellectual property
The informal economy, innovation and intellectual propertyDr Lendy Spires
 
Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...
Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...
Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...MarketResearch.com
 
Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?
Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?
Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?Economic Research Forum
 
Well-Being as Business Purpose?, Wilson
Well-Being as Business Purpose?, WilsonWell-Being as Business Purpose?, Wilson
Well-Being as Business Purpose?, WilsonStatsCommunications
 
U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020IndexBox Marketing
 
12 may 2015 les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...
12 may 2015   les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...12 may 2015   les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...
12 may 2015 les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...Mohamed Larbi BEN YOUNES
 

Similar to Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU Economies: Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges (20)

Spillovers from public intangibles
Spillovers from public intangiblesSpillovers from public intangibles
Spillovers from public intangibles
 
Haskel - Spillovers from public intangibles
Haskel - Spillovers from public intangiblesHaskel - Spillovers from public intangibles
Haskel - Spillovers from public intangibles
 
OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016
OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016
OECD Blue Skies Conference. Sept 2016
 
Public Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN Project
Public Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN ProjectPublic Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN Project
Public Sector Intangibles: The SPINTAN Project
 
PUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement Issues
PUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement IssuesPUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement Issues
PUBLIC CAPITAL. Measurement Issues
 
Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...
Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...
Groningen Growth and Development Centre (GGDC) 25th anniversary | 28-30 June ...
 
212205
212205212205
212205
 
Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)
Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)
Intangibles: the new sources of growth (OECD project)
 
HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...
HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...
HLEG thematic workshop on measuring economic, social and environmental resili...
 
Innovation and r&d
Innovation and r&dInnovation and r&d
Innovation and r&d
 
A Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative Industries
A Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative IndustriesA Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative Industries
A Dynamic Mapping Of The UK S Creative Industries
 
Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...
Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...
Experiment of the Assessment of Societal and Economic Impacts by Policy Simul...
 
Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014
Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014
Creative industries economic_estimates_-_january_2014
 
What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...
What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...
What are the user interests behind requests for data and indicators on PPI? C...
 
The informal economy, innovation and intellectual property
The informal economy, innovation and intellectual propertyThe informal economy, innovation and intellectual property
The informal economy, innovation and intellectual property
 
Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...
Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...
Printed Electronics Markets in China By Asia Market Information & Development...
 
Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?
Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?
Rediscovering Industrial Policy for the 21st Century: Where to Start?
 
Well-Being as Business Purpose?, Wilson
Well-Being as Business Purpose?, WilsonWell-Being as Business Purpose?, Wilson
Well-Being as Business Purpose?, Wilson
 
U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Polish And Other Sanitation Goods Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
 
12 may 2015 les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...
12 may 2015   les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...12 may 2015   les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...
12 may 2015 les politiques de recherche et d’innovation dans les pays de l’...
 

More from SPINTAN

Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016
Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016
Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016SPINTAN
 
14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)
14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)
14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)SPINTAN
 
Investment Agenda for Europe
Investment Agenda for EuropeInvestment Agenda for Europe
Investment Agenda for EuropeSPINTAN
 
Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016
Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016
Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016SPINTAN
 
Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15
Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15
Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15SPINTAN
 
I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15
I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15
I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15SPINTAN
 
SPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde Mas
SPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde MasSPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde Mas
SPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde MasSPINTAN
 
Estimating Public Intangibles in Real Time
Estimating Public Intangibles in Real TimeEstimating Public Intangibles in Real Time
Estimating Public Intangibles in Real TimeSPINTAN
 
The EU Productivity Gap - Open Session
The EU Productivity Gap - Open SessionThe EU Productivity Gap - Open Session
The EU Productivity Gap - Open SessionSPINTAN
 
Human Capital: Extending the measures
Human Capital: Extending the measuresHuman Capital: Extending the measures
Human Capital: Extending the measuresSPINTAN
 
The Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector -A Preliminary Study in Japan
The Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector-A Preliminary Study in JapanThe Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector-A Preliminary Study in Japan
The Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector -A Preliminary Study in JapanSPINTAN
 

More from SPINTAN (11)

Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016
Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016
Franco-German Conference. Paris. July 2016
 
14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)
14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)
14th European Workshop on Efficiency and Productivity Analysis (EWEPA)
 
Investment Agenda for Europe
Investment Agenda for EuropeInvestment Agenda for Europe
Investment Agenda for Europe
 
Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016
Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016
Conference of the Global Forum on Productivity 2016
 
Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15
Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15
Matilde Mas Ivars - I Workshop KIIS. Valencia Nov15
 
I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15
I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15
I Workshop KIIS Valencia Nov15
 
SPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde Mas
SPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde MasSPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde Mas
SPINTAN project Final Conference Latest SPINTAN Developments. Matilde Mas
 
Estimating Public Intangibles in Real Time
Estimating Public Intangibles in Real TimeEstimating Public Intangibles in Real Time
Estimating Public Intangibles in Real Time
 
The EU Productivity Gap - Open Session
The EU Productivity Gap - Open SessionThe EU Productivity Gap - Open Session
The EU Productivity Gap - Open Session
 
Human Capital: Extending the measures
Human Capital: Extending the measuresHuman Capital: Extending the measures
Human Capital: Extending the measures
 
The Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector -A Preliminary Study in Japan
The Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector-A Preliminary Study in JapanThe Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector-A Preliminary Study in Japan
The Role of Intangibles in the Public Sector -A Preliminary Study in Japan
 

Recently uploaded

FT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdf
FT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdfFT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdf
FT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdfSaiPawan21
 
FINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptx
FINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptxFINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptx
FINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptxRaymondJohnson71
 
INT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural Artifacts
INT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural ArtifactsINT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural Artifacts
INT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural ArtifactsS Meyer
 
20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation
20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation
20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor PresentationAdnet Communications
 
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdfStock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdfMichael Silva
 
BASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS
BASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMSBASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS
BASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMSkamikazekujoh
 
Breaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising Moves
Breaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising MovesBreaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising Moves
Breaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising Movesmaker Money
 
Bandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptx
Bandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptxBandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptx
Bandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptxKavinKumar386911
 
Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and Real Digital...
Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and  Real Digital...Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and  Real Digital...
Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and Real Digital...Christian Kameir
 
GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224
GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224 GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224
GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224 hnaour
 
DSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdf
DSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdfDSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdf
DSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdfDSPMutualFund
 
DSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdf
DSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdfDSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdf
DSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdfDSPMutualFund
 
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdfStock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdfMichael Silva
 
04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson. .pptx
04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson.          .pptx04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson.          .pptx
04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson. .pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Abhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in India
Abhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in IndiaAbhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in India
Abhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in IndiaVighnesh Shashtri
 
DSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdf
DSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdfDSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdf
DSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdfDSPMutualFund
 
Advice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdf
Advice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdfAdvice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdf
Advice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdfHenry Tapper
 
GCF - T&L M&A trends
GCF - T&L M&A trends GCF - T&L M&A trends
GCF - T&L M&A trends hnaour
 

Recently uploaded (20)

FT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdf
FT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdfFT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdf
FT Partners Research - FinTech in India.pdf
 
FINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptx
FINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptxFINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptx
FINAL_PRESENTATION_WEEK4 _GLOBAL ECONOMICS.pptx
 
INT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural Artifacts
INT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural ArtifactsINT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural Artifacts
INT-450 Cultural Anthropology Topic 4c Cultural Artifacts
 
20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation
20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation
20240222 Calibre February 2024 Investor Presentation
 
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdfStock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2/29 yt vid.pdf
 
AI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy Forum
AI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy ForumAI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy Forum
AI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy Forum
 
BASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS
BASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMSBASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS
BASIS OF COST ACCOUNTING - COMPUTERISED ACCOUNTING SYSTEMS
 
Breaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising Moves
Breaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising MovesBreaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising Moves
Breaking Cryptocurrency News: Shiba Inu Token Makes Surprising Moves
 
Bandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptx
Bandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptxBandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptx
Bandhan Bank,Bandhan Bank Products, source, cost and revenue.pptx
 
Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and Real Digital...
Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and  Real Digital...Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and  Real Digital...
Cybersecurity and Finance - Paradigm shift towards a Global and Real Digital...
 
GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224
GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224 GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224
GCF - Our Added Value in Mobility & Environment Sector 0224
 
DSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdf
DSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdfDSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdf
DSP Value Fund Presentation April2023.pdf
 
DSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdf
DSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdfDSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdf
DSP Focus Fund Presentation December 2022.pdf
 
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdfStock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 2:27 yt vid.pdf
 
04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson. .pptx
04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson.          .pptx04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson.          .pptx
04_Gambit_Laurent Bodson. .pptx
 
Abhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in India
Abhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in IndiaAbhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in India
Abhay Bhutada to Rajeev Jain - Finance Leaders Behind The Top NBFCs in India
 
DSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdf
DSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdfDSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdf
DSP Short Term Fund Presentation Nov22.pdf
 
Advice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdf
Advice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdfAdvice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdf
Advice Guidance Boundary Review Evidence Final Feb 24.pdf
 
GCF - T&L M&A trends
GCF - T&L M&A trends GCF - T&L M&A trends
GCF - T&L M&A trends
 
AI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy Forum
AI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy ForumAI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy Forum
AI: Our Choices Matter 2024 US Monetary Policy Forum
 

Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU Economies: Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges

  • 1. Private and Public Intangible Capital in the US and EU Economies: Recent Trends and New Policy Challenges C. Jona-Lasinio, (LUISS Lab and ISTAT), Rome C. Corrado, (The Conference Board), New York J. Haskel, (Imperial College, CEPR and IZA), London K. Jaeger, (The Conference Board), Bruxelles M.Iommi, (LUISS Lab and ISTAT), Rome WPIA - OECD 12-13 October 2015, Paris This project has received funding from the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme for research, technological development and demonstration under grant agreement No. 612774 C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 1 / 28
  • 2. Outline • SPINTAN (www.SPINTAN.net): our aim and progresses • Conceptual issues and main measurement challenges • Recent trends of public and private intangible investments in the US and EU economies • Sources of growth in the total economy • Policy challenges and next steps C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 2 / 28
  • 3. The economic view of intangibles • Taking seriously intangibles drastically changes our view of how the rise of the knowledge economy impacts on growth and productivity • The economic view of intangibles asks for a deep investigation of the channels through which public and private intangible investment affect productivity growth. • Integrating the impact of intangibles on growth in the total economy is tricky • Spillovers and complementarities across assets and sectors are difficult to measure and hard to convey. • The first step is to generate harmonized measures of intangibles across sectors and countries • Corrado, Hulten and Sichel (2005) developed the measurement framework for intangibles in the market sector. • Corrado, Haskel and Jona-Lasinio (2014) proposed a framework to measure intangible investment in the nonmarket sector. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 3 / 28
  • 4. Knowledge based capital in the total economy Mapping the CHS assets to the nonmarket sector and consumer product and food and drug safety (i.e, investments in product reputation). The correspondence for computer software, purchased investments in organizational capital, and function-specific worker capital (employer-provided training) is of course far closer. Table 3: Knowledge Capital in a Total Economy Market Sector Nonmarket Sector Computerized Information Information, Scientific, and Cultural Assets 1 Software 1 Software 2 Databases 2 Open data Innovative Property 3 R&D, broadly defined to 3 R&D, basic and applied science include all NPD costs 4 Entertainment & artistic originals 4 Cultural and heritage, including 5 Design arch. & eng. design 6 Mineral exploration 5 Mineral exploration Economic Competencies Societal Competencies 7 Brands 6 Brands 8 Organizational capital 7 Organizational capital (a) Manager capital (a) Professional and manager capital (b) Purchased organizational services (b) Purchased organizational services 9 Firm-specific human capital 8 Function-specific human capital (employer-provided training) (employer-provided training) Note—NPD=New Product Development, including testing and spending for new financial products and other services development not included in software or conventional science-based R&D. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 4 / 28
  • 5. Conceptual framework (Corrado, Haskel, Jona-Lasinio(2014)) Asset typology and SPINTAN topics 4 Types of capital Knowledge capital Intangible assets Physical capital Tangible assets Human capital Human assets HEALTH and EDUCATION CULTURE and the ARTS SCIENCE and the economy INFORMATION and the economy Impacts, links, and synergies across asset types are topic dependent Topics of interest The conceptual framework for the measurement of public intangibles is formulated with the analysis of certain topics in mind: health and education, culture and the arts, science and the economy, and information and the economy (i.e., not the environment, not mass transport, etc.). C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 5 / 28
  • 6. The scope of intangible assets used by the public sector: industries of interest laboratories, public parks and museums) in many countries; see table 1 below. The use of “mar- ket” vs. “nonmarket” groupings of industries is thus not precise because an industry can reflect activity carried out by a mix of producers, as is evident with NACE Section R and the larger section of which NACE Section MB is a part.4 Table 1: SPINTAN Industries of Interest nace nace section Industry title number MB Scientific research and development 72 O Public administration and defence; compulsory social security 84 P Education 85 QA Human health activities 86 QB Residential care and social work activities 87-88 R Creative, arts and entertainment activities; libraries, archives, museums and other cultural activities 90-91 Gambling and betting activities; sports activities and amusement and recreation activities 92-93 Note—NACE Rev. 2. Before we leave the subject of NACE-defined industries, it must be said that in some countries there are industries with significant government or nonmarket production besides those listed in table 1. These tend to be industries that engage in activities not germane to our topic areas, Besides Public administration and defence, other industries in the table contain a mix of market and nonmarket producers. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 6 / 28
  • 7. Multiple measurement dimensions of Public intangibles !CHS!intangible!assets! Nonmarket!sector!4!industries! !Informa9on,! Scien9fic!and! Cultural!assets! Societal! Competencies! NA!intangibles!(So$ware,* R&D,*Mineral*explora4on)* Non!NA!intangibles!(Open* data,*Cultural*and*heritage,* including*design,*Brands,* Organiza4onal*capital,* Func4onBspecific*human* capital)* C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 7 / 28
  • 8. Aim Complete the coverage of intangible investment by industry making possible analysis of productivity for the total economy based on a complete accounting of intangible capital inputs. • Existing measures of intangible investment, INTAN-Invest, cover a subset of industries: the market sector • SPINTAN covers the nonmarket sector New conceptual and measurement challenges • Identify the asset boundary in the total economy • Impute a rate of return to public capital formation • Investigate behavioural link public to private and vice versa (e.g. role of public sector R&D on private sector) C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 8 / 28
  • 9. The SPINTAN database • SPINTAN will deliver (December 2016) estimates of public intangible investment by industry and institutional sector for 22 European economies plus the US, China, India and Brazil for the years 1995-2013. • The data will be cross-country harmonized and consistent with the National Accounts (NA) principles and with business sector estimates of intangibles developed by INTAN-Invest (www.INTAN-Invest.net) C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 9 / 28
  • 10. Data description Descriptive analysis will focus on 3 sets of data • Descriptive analysis (1995-2010) • CHS type assets for 22 EU countries and the US • CHS type assets - Non-National Accounts for 10 EU countries and the US • Sources of growth analysis in the total economy (1995-2009) • CHS type assets for 5 EU countries C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 10 / 28
  • 11. New issues to be investigated.... • What is the magnitude of overall intangible investment in the total economy? • Does the non-market sector is relatively more or less intangible intensive than the market sector? • What are the linkages between nonmarket and market intangibles? • What is the productivity contribution of intangible capital in the market and nonmarket sectors? • Market and nonmarket intangibles over the business cycle • Do Non-NA intangibles are relevant? C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 11 / 28
  • 12. Public intangibles matter Public intangible investments (GDP shares) 0.0# 0.2# 0.4# 0.6# 0.8# 1.0# 1.2# 1.4# 1.6# 1.8# AT# BE# BG# CZ# DE# DK# EL# ES# FI# FR# HU# IE# IT# LU# NL# PL# PT# RO# SE# SI# SK# UK# US# 2000# 1.0# 0.8# 0.3# 0.9# 0.6# 0.4# 0.2# 0.2# 0.6# 0.3# 0.6# 0.9# 0.9# 0.2# 0.8# 0.4# 0.3# 0.1# 0.5# 0.5# 0.9# 0.9# 1.4# 2010# 1.1# 1.0# 0.2# 0.9# 0.9# 0.6# 0.2# 0.4# 1.0# 0.4# 0.6# 0.9# 1.1# 0.2# 1.2# 0.5# 0.3# 0.1# 0.5# 0.6# 0.5# 1.4# 1.7# C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 12 / 28
  • 13. Nonmarket and market Non-NA intangible shares of GDP Overall (market and nonmarket) Non-NA intangible investment account for 7% to 3% of GDP with private and public sectors accounting on average for 5% and 0.6% respectively. 0.0# 1.0# 2.0# 3.0# 4.0# 5.0# 6.0# at# de# es# be# fi# fr# it# nl# se# uk# us# NMKT# 0.3# 0.4# 0.2# 0.6# 0.7# 0.4# 0.5# 0.6# 0.6# 1.0# 1.2# MKT# 3.5# 3.7# 2.5# 4.8# 3.2# 4.1# 2.9# 4.5# 4.1# 5.0# 5.3# C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 13 / 28
  • 14. Non-Na intangible shares of nonmarket and market value added Intangible intensity varies considerably across countries with most advanced economies ( US, UK and FI) more intensive in the nonmarket sector. In the remaining countries it is the opposite (for these assets). NMKT% MKT% 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 3.0% 4.0% 5.0% 6.0% 7.0% 8.0% 9.0% 10.0% es% at% fr% de% nl% se% be% it% fi% us% uk% NMKT% 1.7% 2.7% 3.3% 4.2% 4.5% 4.7% 4.9% 4.9% 7.2% 9.5% 9.5% MKT% 3.5% 5.0% 6.9% 5.5% 6.6% 6.8% 7.1% 4.3% 4.8% 7.6% 7.4% C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 14 / 28
  • 15. Nonmarket and market Non-NA intangible investment (1995-2010) Nonmarket and market intangible intensities are positively correlated. AT# DE# ES# BE# FI# FR# IT# NL# SE# UK# US# 0.00# 0.20# 0.40# 0.60# 0.80# 1.00# 1.20# 1.40# 1.50# 2.00# 2.50# 3.00# 3.50# 4.00# 4.50# 5.00# 5.50# 6.00# NonMarket#intangible#investments#(%GDP)# Market#intangible#investment#(%#of#GDP)# C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 15 / 28
  • 16. Non-NA intangible investment and GDP per capita (1995-2010) ...and public intangible intensity is positively correlated with the level of economic development AT# DE# ES# BE# FI# FR# IT# NL# SE# UK# US# 0.0# 5.0# 10.0# 15.0# 20.0# 25.0# 25000# 30000# 35000# 40000# 45000# 50000# Non#Market/Market#intangible#investments# GDP#Per#capita#(EKS#US#$#2010)# C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 16 / 28
  • 17. Non-NA intangible investment and GDP per hours worked (1995-2010) ...also measured as GDP per hours worked AT# DE# ES# BE# FI# FR# IT# NL# SE# UK# US# 0.0# 5.0# 10.0# 15.0# 20.0# 25.0# 35.0# 40.0# 45.0# 50.0# 55.0# 60.0# Non#Market/Market#intangible#investments## GDP#per#hours#worked# C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 17 / 28
  • 18. GDP shares of market and nonmarket intangibles over the business cycle: (1995-2007) vs (2007-2010) !4.0% !3.0% !2.0% !1.0% 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 3.0% 4.0% 5.0% 6.0% at% de% es% be% fi% fr% it% nl% se% uk% us% GDP%shares%of%market%and%nonmarket%intangible% investment:%1995!2007% (%#changes)# MKT$ NMKT$ !6.0% !4.0% !2.0% 0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% at% de% es% be% fi% fr% it% nl% se% uk% us% GDP%shares%of%market%and%nonmarket%intangible% investment:%2007!2010% (%#changes)%% Intangible investment has been marginally impacted by the financial crisis and nonmarket intangibles even less compared to market intangibles! C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 18 / 28
  • 19. What are the main drivers of non-NA intangible investment? Organizational capital accounts for the largest share of intangible investment both in the nonmarket (45%) and market (35%) sector. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 19 / 28
  • 20. Organizational capital: shares in total market and nonmarket intangible investments On average purchased OC accounts for a larger share both in nonmarket and market sectors but shares varies considerably across countries and sectors. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 20 / 28
  • 21. Return to nonmarket capital • Once we have capitalized public intangibles we want to evaluate their contribution to productivity growth. • To achieve this goal we need to impute a net return to public investments. • A SPINTAN background paper by (Corrado and Jaeger, 2015) explores using the social rate of time preference (Feldstein, 1964; OECD 2009) as a relevant alternative for imputing a rate of return to government capital. • But at this stage we adopt the national accounts assumption of a zero nonmarket sector rate of return. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 21 / 28
  • 22. Sources of growth analysis • Adding national accounts intangibles (R&D, software, and artistic and entertainment originals plus mineral exploration) to the SPINTAN and INTAN-Invest measures of intangibles we are able to look at a fairly complete picture of intangible inputs to total production across a sample of advanced countries: • Finland, Germany, Italy, Spain, and the United Kingdom • Data sources: SPINTAN, INTAN-Invest and EUKLEMS • Contributions to labour productivity growth of market and nonmarket sectors. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 22 / 28
  • 23. Contributions to Labour Productivity Growth:1995-2009 The performance of advanced economies differs widely according to market versus nonmarket sector. In Germany, UK and Finland intangible capital is an important source of growth for the public sector. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 23 / 28
  • 24. Contributions to Labour Productivity Growth: 1995-2007 vs 2007-2009 At the very beginning of the financial crisis, intangible capital positively supported labour productivity growth of both market and non-market sectors in the advanced economies. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 24 / 28
  • 25. Summing up • Intangible capital accounts for one-fifth to one-third of labor productivity growth in the market sector of the US and EU economies • ....and for one-third of labor productivity growth in the nonmarket sector in the EU economies • Intangibles appear to be counter cyclical particularly in the nonmarket sector • Organizational capital is a key asset in this framework C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 25 / 28
  • 26. Policy challenges • A primary characteristic of intangible capital, widely supported by growth accounting exercises and macroeconomic studies, is to be growth-promoting. • This is because intangible investments likely generate spillovers to the economic system being non-rival and possibly non-excludable. Such spillovers, if they exist, might be within the private sector and/or between the public and private sector. • In the light in particular of the claim and counter-claim around public sector austerity and fiscal policy in Europe, it would be vital to know which, if any, public sector intangibles had positive spillovers to the rest of the economy. • If intangibles is the main story, the focus is long-term, not short-term requiring bigger policy commitments. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 26 / 28
  • 27. SPINTAN: Next steps • Generate real measures of public intangible investments and net capital stocks. • Impute a rate of return to nonmarket capital. • Provide a deep investigation of mechanisms trough which the synergies between Public and Private sector affect economic growth. C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 27 / 28
  • 28. Thank you C. Jona-Lasinio SPINTAN 28 / 28