SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 28
Download to read offline
© OECD
REALITY AND CHALLENGES OF POST COVID (1/3)
- Public procurement review systems in IPA countries
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Wojciech Hartung, Ph. D, Poland
Warsaw, 26 January 2021
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
AGENDA
- EU legal remedies in PP: general requirements
- About the Report: methodology and objectives
- Content of the Report: most important issues
- Conclusions: Poland
- Questions…
1
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
EU legal remedies in Public Procurement:
general requirements
2
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
• Remedies Directives (89/665/EC and 92/13/EC) did not intend to
fully harmonise the remedies systems in the area of public
procurement
• under those directives, the remedies to be provided by Member
States included the powers to:
take, at the earliest opportunity and by way of interlocutory
procedures, interim measures to correct the alleged
infringement
either set aside or ensure the setting aside of decisions
taken unlawfully
award damages to persons harmed by an infringement
3
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
• Directive 2007/66/EC amended the existing Remedies Directives
by introducing:
standstill period of at least 10 days between the decision to
select the best tender and the conclusion of a contract
time limits for pre-contractual remedies of at least 10 days
an automatic suspension of the contract award procedure
where legal proceedings are brought against contracting
authorities’ award decision
ineffectivness of a concluded contract and minimum time
limits for the submission of a motion
alternative penalties
4
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
About the Report: methodology and
objectives
5
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
• The Report Functioning of legal protection measures in EU
countries covers 28 EU Member States; in the case of the UK,
the information only concerns England and Wales
• The Report covers proceedings above EU thresholds covered by
directive 2014/24/EU
• The Report discusses legal protection measures concerning
contract award procedures, does not deal with realisation of a
contract
• The Report was prepared based on analysis of answers given by
law firms from 27 European Union Member States to questions
asked in the questionnaires
• The Report was prepared as at 31 August 2017
• The Report was made by the Polish Public Procurement Law
Association – authors: Anna Szymańska, Piotr Bogdanowicz,
Wojciech Hartung
6
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Content of the Report: most important issues
7
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Protest as a „self-cleaning” mechanism for contracting authority
Is there an obligation to submit an appellate remedy to an awarding
entity before filing an appellate measure to an independent appellate
body of first instance?
8
Protest
YES (7)
NO (21)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Court (civil or administrative) or administrative authority
as a first instance review body
What type of independent authority is appointed to adjudicate remedies
involving correctness of the public procurement procedure in the first
instance?
9
Courts
12 Independent
non-judiciary
authorities
14 Public
administrative
authorities
2
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Number of judges/arbitrators to solve the case
What is the composition of the adjudicating panel of an independent
appellate body?
10
First instance adjudicating panel
One member
(11)
Three
members (11)
Other (6)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Written proceedings or adversary trial
What is the nature of appellate proceedings pending before an
independent body of first instance (written proceedings or adversary
trial)?
11
Hearing
Requirement (10)
Option (13)
None (5)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Time limits to solve a case – first instance
In accordance with binding legal provisions of law, is an independent
appellate body of first instance required to adjudicate a case within
a set timeframe?
12
Time limit to issue a judgment in first
instance
None (12)
Up to 1 month (11)
Over 1 month (6)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Observance of time limits set
Are statutory deadlines met?
13
Observance of time limits
YES (12)
NO (4)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Standstill period for first or also second instance proceedings
Does a suspension period (the period in which the contracting authority
cannot execute a contract with the selected contractor) apply during the
appellate proceedings?
14
Standstill period
Until first instance
ends (17)
Until second
instance ends (4)
Other (7)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Appellate proceedings
Can the rulings of a body of first instance be appealed (be made the
subject of a complaint) to a body of second instance?
15
Right to appeal to second instance
YES (26)
NO (2)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Second instance body – common or administrative courts
What body serves as an appellate body of second instance?
16
Second instance body
Common courts (12)
Administrative courts (14)
None (2)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Time limits to solve a case –
second instance
In accordance with binding legal provisions of law, is a body of second
instance required to adjudicate a case within a set timeframe?
17
Time limit for second instance resolution
None (17)
30-45 days (10)
6 months (1)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Observance of time limits set
Are statutory deadlines met?
18
Observing time limits
YES (5)
NO (5)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Extraordinary appellate measures
Is it possible to challenge adjudications made by a body of second
instance? Do contractors or awarding entities hold this right?
19
Possibility of challenging second instance judgment
YES (19)
NO (9)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Fees and charges
What are the fees and charges associated with the use of legal protection
measures?
20
In these countries
there are no fees
for using legal
protection
measures
4 In this country
there are no fees
for using legal
measures
in first instance
1
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Cancellation of procurement proceedings
Can the appellate body of first or second instance order that the
proceedings be cancelled ex officio (i.e. even when the appealing party
does not request so)?
21
Possibility of invalidating proceedings
ex officio
YES (8)
NO (20)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Separate public procurement authorities
Is there an administrative body appointed to supervise the public
procurement market?
22
Existence of separate public administrative
offices
YES (17)
NO (11)
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Conclusions: Poland
23
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
• Introduction of an obligatory three-member panel in
certain cases;
• Introduction of mechanisms to allow broader use of
experts’ assistance;
• Introduction of the obligation to submit pleadings,
especially replies to appeals, to the parties and participants
of the proceedings within a specified time limit (before the
hearing);
• Allowing the hearings to be recorded (audio or video) by
first instance authorities;
24
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
• Extension of the time limit for filing a complaint to the
second instance court from 7 to 14 days;
• Introduction of the possibility for the parties to the
proceedings to file an extraordinary appeal (kasacja) with
the Supreme Court;
• Reduction of the registration fees and charges for using
legal protection measures;
• Appointment of one court to handle all public
procurement cases in the second instance.
25
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Questions…
26
Functioning of legal protection measures
in EU countries
Contact:
Wojciech Hartung
wojciech.hartung@dzp.pl
tel. +48 660 440 316
27

More Related Content

What's hot

S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)
S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)
S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)Spyros Panagopoulos
 
Emergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case study
Emergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case studyEmergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case study
Emergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case studyAlbert Sanchez Graells
 
Analysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibility
Analysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibilityAnalysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibility
Analysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibilityAlbert Sanchez Graells
 
Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...
Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...
Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...Albert Sanchez Graells
 
Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)
Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)
Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)Albert Sanchez Graells
 
New points in law on bidding of vietnam
New points in law on bidding of vietnamNew points in law on bidding of vietnam
New points in law on bidding of vietnamiZibook
 
Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...
Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...
Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...Albert Sanchez Graells
 
EU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet Jr
EU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet JrEU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet Jr
EU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet JrLawSWOT
 
2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency
2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency
2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparencyWouter Pors
 
2015-04-23 UPC judges education
2015-04-23 UPC judges education2015-04-23 UPC judges education
2015-04-23 UPC judges educationWouter Pors
 
The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...
The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...
The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...Albert Sanchez Graells
 
Taxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process Clause
Taxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process ClauseTaxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process Clause
Taxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process ClauseUniversity of Ferrara
 
Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?
Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?
Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații
 

What's hot (20)

S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)
S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)
S panagopoulos public_public_partnerships (ippc_bud_161102011)
 
Emergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case study
Emergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case studyEmergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case study
Emergence of trans-EU public law: procurement as case study
 
Analysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibility
Analysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibilityAnalysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibility
Analysis of recent procurement reforms from perspective of flexibility
 
Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...
Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...
Procurement and labour objectives: some thoughts on regulatory substitution a...
 
Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)
Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)
Impact of the ECJ’s jurisprudence in practice (ERA March 2017)
 
New points in law on bidding of vietnam
New points in law on bidding of vietnamNew points in law on bidding of vietnam
New points in law on bidding of vietnam
 
EU and UK private competition litigation
EU and UK private competition litigationEU and UK private competition litigation
EU and UK private competition litigation
 
Brexit & NHS procurement in England
Brexit & NHS procurement in EnglandBrexit & NHS procurement in England
Brexit & NHS procurement in England
 
Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...
Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...
Procurement issues SCF unfair competition from the public sector (glasgow, se...
 
PPT, G Cazan, SIGMA, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6...
PPT, G Cazan, SIGMA, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6...PPT, G Cazan, SIGMA, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6...
PPT, G Cazan, SIGMA, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6...
 
Borut Smrdel, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 J...
Borut Smrdel, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 J...Borut Smrdel, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 J...
Borut Smrdel, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 J...
 
EU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet Jr
EU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet JrEU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet Jr
EU Law Quantitative Restrictions Kindly donated by Robert Gaudet Jr
 
2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency
2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency
2013-09-26 Pharmacovigilance and transparency
 
Matrta Laszuk, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 ...
Matrta Laszuk, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 ...Matrta Laszuk, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 ...
Matrta Laszuk, SIGMA Public procurement review bodies conference, Ohrid 9-10 ...
 
2015-04-23 UPC judges education
2015-04-23 UPC judges education2015-04-23 UPC judges education
2015-04-23 UPC judges education
 
Serbia Presentation, Branislav Cvetkovic, Protection of Rights, 7th Regional ...
Serbia Presentation, Branislav Cvetkovic, Protection of Rights, 7th Regional ...Serbia Presentation, Branislav Cvetkovic, Protection of Rights, 7th Regional ...
Serbia Presentation, Branislav Cvetkovic, Protection of Rights, 7th Regional ...
 
The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...
The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...
The EU’s Joint Procurement Agreement: how does it work, and why did the UK no...
 
Taxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process Clause
Taxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process ClauseTaxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process Clause
Taxpayers' Fundamental Rights and Due Process Clause
 
Restraints of Trade and Dominance in Cyprus
Restraints of Trade and Dominance in CyprusRestraints of Trade and Dominance in Cyprus
Restraints of Trade and Dominance in Cyprus
 
Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?
Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?
Damages for breach of antitrust law. A New Private Enforcement Era?
 

Similar to Presentation by Wojciech Hartung, public procurement reality and challenges post COVID, SIGMA 26 January 2021

Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justiceAccess to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justiceEmanuela Matei
 
S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."
S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."
S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."Larry Catá Backer
 
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis CommunautaireThe Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis CommunautaireBirsemin Jurgens
 
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis CommunautaireThe Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis CommunautaireBirsemin Jurgens
 
intro_wto_disput_settle.ppt
intro_wto_disput_settle.pptintro_wto_disput_settle.ppt
intro_wto_disput_settle.pptshamim308062
 
2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]
2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]
2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]OBFG
 

Similar to Presentation by Wojciech Hartung, public procurement reality and challenges post COVID, SIGMA 26 January 2021 (20)

Presentation on public procurement review system in EU member states
Presentation on public procurement review system in EU member statesPresentation on public procurement review system in EU member states
Presentation on public procurement review system in EU member states
 
Legal protection in public procurement, Erika Bozzay, SIGMA regional conferen...
Legal protection in public procurement, Erika Bozzay, SIGMA regional conferen...Legal protection in public procurement, Erika Bozzay, SIGMA regional conferen...
Legal protection in public procurement, Erika Bozzay, SIGMA regional conferen...
 
PPT - Academies - Topic 1 SIGMA
PPT - Academies - Topic 1 SIGMAPPT - Academies - Topic 1 SIGMA
PPT - Academies - Topic 1 SIGMA
 
State of play on UPC
State of play on UPC State of play on UPC
State of play on UPC
 
UPC State of play (December 2017)
UPC State of play (December 2017)UPC State of play (December 2017)
UPC State of play (December 2017)
 
7 Current Practices in Complaints Review: Examples from the Region and the EU...
7 Current Practices in Complaints Review: Examples from the Region and the EU...7 Current Practices in Complaints Review: Examples from the Region and the EU...
7 Current Practices in Complaints Review: Examples from the Region and the EU...
 
PPT, D Koba 2, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novem...
PPT, D Koba 2, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novem...PPT, D Koba 2, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novem...
PPT, D Koba 2, Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novem...
 
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justiceAccess to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
Access to competition file as a precondition of access to justice
 
6 The Croatian Experience of Building a Remedies System_English
6 The Croatian Experience of Building a Remedies System_English6 The Croatian Experience of Building a Remedies System_English
6 The Croatian Experience of Building a Remedies System_English
 
Public procurement related decisions of the Court of Justice of the EU and th...
Public procurement related decisions of the Court of Justice of the EU and th...Public procurement related decisions of the Court of Justice of the EU and th...
Public procurement related decisions of the Court of Justice of the EU and th...
 
S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."
S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."
S. Beth Farmer: "Resolving Competition Related Disputes Under the AML."
 
Jreu tokyo
Jreu tokyoJreu tokyo
Jreu tokyo
 
PPT, T Pusnar Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novemb...
PPT, T Pusnar Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novemb...PPT, T Pusnar Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novemb...
PPT, T Pusnar Third ENP East public procurement conference, Tbilisi, 6 Novemb...
 
Treatment of legally privileged information in competition proceedings – WILS...
Treatment of legally privileged information in competition proceedings – WILS...Treatment of legally privileged information in competition proceedings – WILS...
Treatment of legally privileged information in competition proceedings – WILS...
 
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis CommunautaireThe Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
 
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis CommunautaireThe Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
The Eu Dimension In Intellectual Capital – Treaties And The Acquis Communautaire
 
intro_wto_disput_settle.ppt
intro_wto_disput_settle.pptintro_wto_disput_settle.ppt
intro_wto_disput_settle.ppt
 
ADR mechanisms 3
ADR mechanisms 3ADR mechanisms 3
ADR mechanisms 3
 
2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]
2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]
2011 05 roadmap_legislative_proposal_on_antitrust_damages_actions_en[1]
 
Judicial action
Judicial actionJudicial action
Judicial action
 

More from Support for Improvement in Governance and Management SIGMA

More from Support for Improvement in Governance and Management SIGMA (20)

PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Ukraine roadmap.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Ukraine roadmap.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Ukraine roadmap.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Ukraine roadmap.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Moldova roadmap.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Moldova roadmap.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Moldova roadmap.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Moldova roadmap.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -CAF Armenia roadmap.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -CAF Armenia roadmap.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -CAF Armenia roadmap.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -CAF Armenia roadmap.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - Financial support tu PAR in Montenegro....
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - Financial support tu PAR in Montenegro....PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - Financial support tu PAR in Montenegro....
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - Financial support tu PAR in Montenegro....
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdf
 
Photo gallery - SIGMA-GIZ Academies on QM - Stage 1.pdf
Photo gallery - SIGMA-GIZ Academies on QM - Stage 1.pdfPhoto gallery - SIGMA-GIZ Academies on QM - Stage 1.pdf
Photo gallery - SIGMA-GIZ Academies on QM - Stage 1.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - prezentacija gsb podgorica.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - prezentacija gsb podgorica.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - prezentacija gsb podgorica.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - prezentacija gsb podgorica.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF-MONTENEGRO-29-FEB.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF-MONTENEGRO-29-FEB.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF-MONTENEGRO-29-FEB.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF-MONTENEGRO-29-FEB.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Georgia.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Georgia.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Georgia.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF Georgia.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - QM Roadmapping Day 2 and 3.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - QM Roadmapping Day 2  and 3.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - QM Roadmapping Day 2  and 3.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - QM Roadmapping Day 2 and 3.pdf
 
Academies-QM_Stage1_Ministry of Higher Education CAF.pdf
Academies-QM_Stage1_Ministry of Higher Education CAF.pdfAcademies-QM_Stage1_Ministry of Higher Education CAF.pdf
Academies-QM_Stage1_Ministry of Higher Education CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - ReSPA and CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - ReSPA and CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - ReSPA and CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - ReSPA and CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Bosnia Herzegovina CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Bosnia Herzegovina CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Bosnia Herzegovina CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Bosnia Herzegovina CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Montenegro CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - North Macedonia CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - CAF in Ukraine.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 -Serbia CAF.pdf
 
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdfPPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdf
PPT - SIGMA-GIZ Academies - Stage 1 - SIGMA opening.pdf
 
Omnichannel management, by Willem Pieterson - SIGMA Webinars on service desig...
Omnichannel management, by Willem Pieterson - SIGMA Webinars on service desig...Omnichannel management, by Willem Pieterson - SIGMA Webinars on service desig...
Omnichannel management, by Willem Pieterson - SIGMA Webinars on service desig...
 
eZdravlje, by Vladimir Raickovic - SIGMA Webinars on service design and deliv...
eZdravlje, by Vladimir Raickovic - SIGMA Webinars on service design and deliv...eZdravlje, by Vladimir Raickovic - SIGMA Webinars on service design and deliv...
eZdravlje, by Vladimir Raickovic - SIGMA Webinars on service design and deliv...
 

Recently uploaded

2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 142024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14JSchaus & Associates
 
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.SUNWayResearchandInn
 
CeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agenda
CeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agendaCeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agenda
CeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agendaEnergy for One World
 
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomFlagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomSUNWayResearchandInn
 
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomFlagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomSUNWayResearchandInn
 
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................SUNWayResearchandInn
 
PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)
PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)
PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)ahcitycouncil
 
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSESTHEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSESLouis Malaybalay
 
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish CouncillorsUnderstanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish CouncillorsScribe
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 15
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 152024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 15
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 15JSchaus & Associates
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdfCanadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdfAndrew Griffith
 
Hadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 EditionHadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 EditionHadleyWood Association
 
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and WildlifeLivewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and WildlifeRandy Myers
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...JSchaus & Associates
 
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptxNSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptxDheerajKL1
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...
SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...
SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...JSchaus & Associates
 
Let’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docx
Let’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docxLet’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docx
Let’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docxSERUDS INDIA
 
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 EditionHadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 EditionHadleyWood Association
 

Recently uploaded (20)

2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 142024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisiton Regulations - Part 14
 
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
The AMAMPEMBE Royal Kingdom of South Africa.
 
CeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agenda
CeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agendaCeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agenda
CeraWeek 2024 - Executive conference agenda
 
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomFlagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
 
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal KingdomFlagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
Flagship Projects Mpempe Continental Royal Kingdom
 
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
About Amampembe Royal Kingdom........................
 
No Elevators Day - Action Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairs
No Elevators Day - Action Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairsNo Elevators Day - Action Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairs
No Elevators Day - Action Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairs
 
PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)
PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)
PPT Item # 8 - 4821 Broadway Notice of Intent (NOI)
 
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSESTHEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
THEOLOGY SOCIAL JUSTICE - TYPHOON ULYSSES
 
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish CouncillorsUnderstanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
Understanding Year End for Town & Parish Councillors
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 15
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 152024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 15
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations - Part 15
 
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdfCanadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
Canadian Immigration Tracker - January 2024.pdf
 
No Elevators Day - Communications Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairs
No Elevators Day - Communications Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairsNo Elevators Day - Communications Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairs
No Elevators Day - Communications Guide 2024 - #UseTheStairs
 
Hadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 EditionHadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - December 2023 Edition
 
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and WildlifeLivewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
Livewell Oxygen System Tested by Texas Parks and Wildlife
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
SPONSORED CONTENT - AGILE ATS - Recruiting Strategies Systems & Tactics For G...
 
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptxNSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
NSFW QUhhvliyvyv;iyv;v;yifyfo7otudb75IZ.pptx
 
SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...
SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...
SPONSORED CONTENT - DV Solutions - Building Relationships With The Federal Fo...
 
Let’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docx
Let’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docxLet’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docx
Let’s feed hungry people in kurnool.docx
 
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 EditionHadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
Hadley Wood Newsletter - February 2024 Edition
 

Presentation by Wojciech Hartung, public procurement reality and challenges post COVID, SIGMA 26 January 2021

  • 1. © OECD REALITY AND CHALLENGES OF POST COVID (1/3) - Public procurement review systems in IPA countries Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Wojciech Hartung, Ph. D, Poland Warsaw, 26 January 2021
  • 2. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries AGENDA - EU legal remedies in PP: general requirements - About the Report: methodology and objectives - Content of the Report: most important issues - Conclusions: Poland - Questions… 1
  • 3. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries EU legal remedies in Public Procurement: general requirements 2
  • 4. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries • Remedies Directives (89/665/EC and 92/13/EC) did not intend to fully harmonise the remedies systems in the area of public procurement • under those directives, the remedies to be provided by Member States included the powers to: take, at the earliest opportunity and by way of interlocutory procedures, interim measures to correct the alleged infringement either set aside or ensure the setting aside of decisions taken unlawfully award damages to persons harmed by an infringement 3
  • 5. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries • Directive 2007/66/EC amended the existing Remedies Directives by introducing: standstill period of at least 10 days between the decision to select the best tender and the conclusion of a contract time limits for pre-contractual remedies of at least 10 days an automatic suspension of the contract award procedure where legal proceedings are brought against contracting authorities’ award decision ineffectivness of a concluded contract and minimum time limits for the submission of a motion alternative penalties 4
  • 6. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries About the Report: methodology and objectives 5
  • 7. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries • The Report Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries covers 28 EU Member States; in the case of the UK, the information only concerns England and Wales • The Report covers proceedings above EU thresholds covered by directive 2014/24/EU • The Report discusses legal protection measures concerning contract award procedures, does not deal with realisation of a contract • The Report was prepared based on analysis of answers given by law firms from 27 European Union Member States to questions asked in the questionnaires • The Report was prepared as at 31 August 2017 • The Report was made by the Polish Public Procurement Law Association – authors: Anna Szymańska, Piotr Bogdanowicz, Wojciech Hartung 6
  • 8. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Content of the Report: most important issues 7
  • 9. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Protest as a „self-cleaning” mechanism for contracting authority Is there an obligation to submit an appellate remedy to an awarding entity before filing an appellate measure to an independent appellate body of first instance? 8 Protest YES (7) NO (21)
  • 10. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Court (civil or administrative) or administrative authority as a first instance review body What type of independent authority is appointed to adjudicate remedies involving correctness of the public procurement procedure in the first instance? 9 Courts 12 Independent non-judiciary authorities 14 Public administrative authorities 2
  • 11. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Number of judges/arbitrators to solve the case What is the composition of the adjudicating panel of an independent appellate body? 10 First instance adjudicating panel One member (11) Three members (11) Other (6)
  • 12. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Written proceedings or adversary trial What is the nature of appellate proceedings pending before an independent body of first instance (written proceedings or adversary trial)? 11 Hearing Requirement (10) Option (13) None (5)
  • 13. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Time limits to solve a case – first instance In accordance with binding legal provisions of law, is an independent appellate body of first instance required to adjudicate a case within a set timeframe? 12 Time limit to issue a judgment in first instance None (12) Up to 1 month (11) Over 1 month (6)
  • 14. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Observance of time limits set Are statutory deadlines met? 13 Observance of time limits YES (12) NO (4)
  • 15. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Standstill period for first or also second instance proceedings Does a suspension period (the period in which the contracting authority cannot execute a contract with the selected contractor) apply during the appellate proceedings? 14 Standstill period Until first instance ends (17) Until second instance ends (4) Other (7)
  • 16. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Appellate proceedings Can the rulings of a body of first instance be appealed (be made the subject of a complaint) to a body of second instance? 15 Right to appeal to second instance YES (26) NO (2)
  • 17. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Second instance body – common or administrative courts What body serves as an appellate body of second instance? 16 Second instance body Common courts (12) Administrative courts (14) None (2)
  • 18. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Time limits to solve a case – second instance In accordance with binding legal provisions of law, is a body of second instance required to adjudicate a case within a set timeframe? 17 Time limit for second instance resolution None (17) 30-45 days (10) 6 months (1)
  • 19. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Observance of time limits set Are statutory deadlines met? 18 Observing time limits YES (5) NO (5)
  • 20. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Extraordinary appellate measures Is it possible to challenge adjudications made by a body of second instance? Do contractors or awarding entities hold this right? 19 Possibility of challenging second instance judgment YES (19) NO (9)
  • 21. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Fees and charges What are the fees and charges associated with the use of legal protection measures? 20 In these countries there are no fees for using legal protection measures 4 In this country there are no fees for using legal measures in first instance 1
  • 22. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Cancellation of procurement proceedings Can the appellate body of first or second instance order that the proceedings be cancelled ex officio (i.e. even when the appealing party does not request so)? 21 Possibility of invalidating proceedings ex officio YES (8) NO (20)
  • 23. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Separate public procurement authorities Is there an administrative body appointed to supervise the public procurement market? 22 Existence of separate public administrative offices YES (17) NO (11)
  • 24. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Conclusions: Poland 23
  • 25. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries • Introduction of an obligatory three-member panel in certain cases; • Introduction of mechanisms to allow broader use of experts’ assistance; • Introduction of the obligation to submit pleadings, especially replies to appeals, to the parties and participants of the proceedings within a specified time limit (before the hearing); • Allowing the hearings to be recorded (audio or video) by first instance authorities; 24
  • 26. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries • Extension of the time limit for filing a complaint to the second instance court from 7 to 14 days; • Introduction of the possibility for the parties to the proceedings to file an extraordinary appeal (kasacja) with the Supreme Court; • Reduction of the registration fees and charges for using legal protection measures; • Appointment of one court to handle all public procurement cases in the second instance. 25
  • 27. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Questions… 26
  • 28. Functioning of legal protection measures in EU countries Contact: Wojciech Hartung wojciech.hartung@dzp.pl tel. +48 660 440 316 27