Successfully reported this slideshow.
We use your LinkedIn profile and activity data to personalize ads and to show you more relevant ads. You can change your ad preferences anytime.

Regulating peer to-peer and alternative finance - sdj


Published on

All the materials for the ACCA Alternative Finance Conference 2013 are to be posted here:

Published in: Economy & Finance

Regulating peer to-peer and alternative finance - sdj

  1. 1. REGULATING PEER-TO-PEER AND ALTERNATIVE FINANCEACCA Alternative Finance Conference 2013 Simon Deane-Johns Keystone Law
  2. 2. Agenda• Peer-to-peer finance – Types – How they work – Common features – Operational risks and controls• Other forms of alternative finance – Supply chain finance – Marketplace finance• Regulatory barriers and options for removal
  3. 3. Types of P2P Finance Crowd- investing Debentures Crowd- Crowd- investing investing Other (e.g. Equities invoices)Crowdfunding P2P Payments (e.g. ForeignDonations/rewards exchange) Crowdfunding P2P lending charities/social Consumers/SMEs Microfinance
  4. 4. How P2P Finance Works Transaction Flow Offer/acceptance => Loan agreementLender Borrower Share/debenture Offer/acceptance => Investment agreement Investor Entrepreneur Platform Operator platform agreement platform agreement Lender/Investor’s Platform Operator’s Borrower/Entrepreneur’s Bank Bank (Seg. Account) Bank
  5. 5. How P2P Finance Works Funds Flow Loan agreement Lender Borrower Share/debenture Investment agreement Transfer request Investor EntrepreneurTransfer request Platform Operator platform agreement platform agreement Funds Transfer Disburse Loan/Investment Funds Transfer Repayment/dividend Lender/Investor’s Platform Operator’s Borrower/Entrepreneur’s Bank Bank (Seg. Account) Bank
  6. 6. Common P2P Features• Platform operator not a party to instrument agreed between participants – Segregates participants’ funds rather than treating them as own assets; – Margin stays with the participants;• Online only –> low cost –> lower fees• Low minimum commitment – Accessible to retail customers (may be subject to questionnaire and/or cap); – Aids diversification of small investment amounts; – Finance from many in small amounts at outset –> no need to securitise;• Centralised data aids risk assessment, performance analysis, enforcement
  7. 7. Standard Operational Risks• Lack of adequate internal controls, governance – Financial mismanagement, operator insolvency; – Internal fraud; – Lack of system integrity/availability; – Lack of business continuity; – Failure to manage/respond appropriately to customer complaints; – Unclear, unfair or misleading promotions/communications.• Basic credit or investment risk• Money laundering, external Fraud
  8. 8. Common P2P Operational Controls• Senior management systems and controls;• Minimum working capital;• Segregation of participants’ funds;• Clear, fair and not misleading service terms/communications/promotions;• Secure and reliable IT systems;• Fair complaints handling;• Orderly administration if platform ceases to operate;• Appropriate risk assessment, AML and anti-fraud measures• Extra measures appropriate to specific instruments
  9. 9. Other Forms of Alternative Finance• Supply chain finance – Funding the early payment of single invoices or batches of invoices – Shifting the credit risk from supplier to buyer – Crowd-funding individual invoices?• Marketplace finance – As part of end-to-end e-commerce marketplace service – Independently of marketplace service – Crowdfunded?
  10. 10. Regulatory Barriers - Overview• Exclusive framework limits types of products, suppliers, intermediaries and activities• Reinforced by guarantee of bank liabilities, Financial Services Compensation Scheme, personal tax rules and savings incentives• Related silos of officials/regulators with powers focused inwardly, and no overriding supervisory powers, responsibility or accountability for how the ‘system’ works as a whole, either internally or in terms of external impactExclusive, rigid, self-reinforcing, officially-endorsed marketing environment creates super-normal profits for incumbents and limits innovation and competition
  11. 11. Barriers for Platforms• Confusion over what is lawful – Slight change in facts has big consequences, EU Directives overlap – Different rules for ‘promoting’ vs ‘offering’ a security; – Unregulated operators may still face rules on public offers and promotions; – Expensive in terms of advice + regulatory creep – Slows time to market• High net worth investor limits – Limits accessible market, liquidity• Incumbent competitors heavily subsidised – State guarantee of bank liabilities, – Financial Services Compensation Scheme – personal tax rules and savings incentives
  12. 12. Barriers for Entrepreneurs• Confusion over what is lawful – Which platform to list on?• High net worth investor limits – Limits accessible market, liquidity• Disincentives for ‘ordinary’ lenders/investors to engage with alternative finance and diversify – Inhibits trend towards customers directly supporting projects – Limits accessible market, liquidity
  13. 13. Barriers for Lenders/Investors• Confusion over what is lawful – Lending or investing in the course of a business? – Easier to give or gamble money away than to receive repayment with interest or a share in the business!• Disincentives to engage with alternative finance – Not available via ISAs – Can’t deduct bad debt before tax, distorting effective tax rate (unlike a bank) – Inhibits diversification beyond cash deposits and some regulated bonds/shares – Deprives consumers of return on savings
  14. 14. Regulatory Options• New regulated activity of “operating a Platform” – Rules similar to Operating Principles of the P2PFA; – ‘hybrid’ businesses and small firms (e.g. Payment Services)• Specific exemptions - clarify meaning of “business” - remove EU overlap - ease rules on promotions, offers to public via Platforms;• Issue permissive guidance where changes can’t easily be made;• ISA-status on instruments available via regulated Platforms;• Remove bad debt tax distortion for instruments available via regulated Platforms.• Ensure framework is joined-up and permeable/responsive
  15. 15. Thank you Twitter: @sdjohns Blog: Pragmatist http://sdj-pragmatist.blogspot.comBlawg: The Fine Printhttp://